Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 121: Jason Morningstar on Night Witches

Transcript 1:03:11

thank you it's ad break time first welcome to season 7 of the Beyond Solitaire podcast I've got some great things planned for us this season and I'm very excited second I'm happy to say that Beyond Solitaire is still sponsored by Central Michigan universities Center for Learning through games and simulations they've got great things ahead themselves but for now I want to mention that their new game 500 year old vampire will be on backer kit through August 16th so make sure to check it out if you haven't already and third if you love Beyond Solitaire and want to support the show please consider supporting me on patreon at patreon.com Beyond Solitaire for now though let's get out with the show hey Gamers this is David something Beyond Solitaire and I have two very special guests on the podcast this week uh I have gots David Thompson who's my co-designer on night which is boring boring I have very exciting Jason Morning Star who is the designer of the RPG night wishes that came out in 2014 is that correct yep that's right fantastic so we have joined Jason over this time uh in the club of people who love the night witches and thought it would be fun for us all to get together and talk uh so Jason um wanna this is mostly a board gaming podcast and you've made an RPG so why don't you give us kind of like the basics of your RPG system and how that plays out in night witches so people can get a sense of your game yeah so uh thanks for having me by the way and um which is my version of night wishes is a tabletop role-playing game so you play it with um three or four of

your friends sitting around the table uh in the same way that you play any other role-playing game and you're telling the story of women in the 588th uh Knight bomber regimen so it uses a system that was adapted from Vincent Baker's apocalypse world so it's all powered by the apocalypse game you know so if you're familiar with games like Monster hearts or apocalypse world it is uh it's going to be similar to that but it's Unique uh and it's bespoke it's designed specifically to tell of this story so where uh other games do other things in in night witches you're very specifically playing the women in this regiment and your time is divided between the day when you're sort of recovering and preparing for your next mission and the night when you're actually flying your rickety 1920s pipelines and attacking the Germans so there's two very distinct phases in the game and they're both important but the the really important one is the day phase when you're recovering and trying to uh prepare for the the Relentless grind of the war you're constantly uh uh flying they would fly many missions each night that's kind of abstracted in in the game but um uh it presents a really interesting point of view for a tabletop role-playing game and I hope provides empathy uh for what these women did what they achieved and also

um sort of opened uh opens a window on a really interesting piece of lived history so you get to portray these women you get to see the the dangers that they faced um it's I often talk about it as being at the intersection of uh endemic sexism and genocidal Warfare so you also get to see like the these women had enemies within the Red Army too that there were many people who didn't want them to be there and so there's hostility from the people who should have been supporting them as well as of course their their enemies in war so that's sort of what the game's about uh you play these women you flying missions having uh you know experiences in the air but also on the ground as you prepare to do it all over again the next night that's awesome so I think it's so fun that your game is focused on the day because David's in my game is very much focused on the night yeah yeah for sure and that was a that was a design choice and I think we can talk about that one of the things you've mentioned as we were sort of getting ready was that uh people had said what can you combined these and um I I think not actually uh and we can talk more about that but like I I deliberately de-emphasized the the actual missions you you can if you do everything right your missions are going to be resolved with just a couple of die rolls and and that's the way I wanted it um if you start having to engage with the system more or something has gone very badly wrong and somebody's not coming home uh which which is a a very

considerate choice on my part because I want that tension and pressure to be there and I want you to to fight really hard for your missions to be note perfect and uneventful uh so like it's it's a it's a very different uh uh approach to the same topic and I think there's a lot to say about that yeah so just a brief everybody who might not know um our Missions at night are quite eventful uh David do you want to give just like the quick rundown of that gaming experience I I do but can he I either want to put a pin in this question and come back to it or maybe answer it quickly um so one obvious super obvious thing in a role-playing game you always take the role of a character but in a board game that's not true right in a board game sometimes you what the player is can be much more abstract or it can be broader than just a single person and then the game that you know Liz you and I are designing you're either as a player you're either playing by yourself and you control two Crews which is a total of four people or you're playing two players and you're controlling you know one plane of two people and um I just that made me think about so that's where that's what you know your avatar if you will or what you're controlling and what agency you have and so obviously that's a huge difference between the games but it made me think Jason I know that the night phase in your game is abstracted largely minimalized for the day phase what is the sort of how do you evoke the relationship between the pilot and the Navigator during the night phase and how

does that carry over into the day phase if you don't mind me asking yeah that's a great question uh David um so uh you're in the game and you're playing a combat section so you're going to have three planes in the air and what that means is that there's going to be some non-player characters in the mix as well and that player characters uh because they're part of your section you you build up an affinity for them you care about them you want them to succeed just like your own the Avatar the character that you're playing is going to succeed or fail and the the game is brutal at night if things don't go right they go way wrong and you're making choices like who dies you know uh and so so um the the those decisions become really important if the person's sitting in your back seat uh is somebody that you genuinely care about uh and if if um if you have to sort of do the math and and figure out how this mission is going to go wrong who's going to suffer and how are they going to suffer um are you going to make choices that endanger the mission or that endanger the Personnel uh are you going to try to get a plane back to the base because you need the planes to be functional even if that means someone's going to bleed out you know these are the kind of hard choices you're making at night if you haven't prepared and been very lucky uh so so those relationships become Amplified and intensified uh as the game goes on and one of the things that I

that I'm very proud of as a designer is that uh I I feel like Nightwish is when it's played in a campaign mode where you're actually following these women from their training to the you know the edge of Berlin uh is that uh as the war goes on lives become more precious you don't want to be the last pilot to die fighting the Nazis um and so in in that situation by the end of the game people are extraordinarily cautious and of course they've learned the system a little bit and so they're they're working things as best they can to to improve the odds in their favor at night which means that they're cutting Corners during the day which is fascinating um and so you get characters that begin the war being very uh you know sort of obedient to the system and they might be uh you know really good Soviet citizens the model a Soviet women and by the end of the war man all the matters of the people in the seat in front or behind you and that's such a beautiful transition and it seems to Echo lived experience and War a lot and I really like that I don't know if that answered your question but uh no that's great that's awesome that's fantastic yeah yeah so um okay so Liz you had asked you know just kind of a brief overview of our game right so the people who have listened to you and I we've we've done we've done kind of two podcasts before right we did one with where we talked with Reina Rayna Pennington and then where you and I chatted about the game is that right yeah remembering that Serena Pennington is our historical

consultant for those of you who have not heard her name before she's she's great and so it's amazing bibliography that's so great okay yeah no she's she's been fantastic and so um I apologize for people who listened to that already I'll quickly recap but one thing that you know Liz you and I decided to do extremely early on before we we designed the first bit of the game was we did our reading and then we met with Reina and we said where is the game meaning like the board game where is the game going to be because there were so many different possible things it could have been a game it was a resource management where we're we are the mechanics getting the planes into the sky or it could have been you know the logistics redeploying the Airfield every night or whatever um but what we decided we wanted the game to be was a low complexity quit playing Super tense game that evokes the flying part right that's really what happens now there's a very short easy to adjudicate bit about the recovery between sorties right but but independent of that you spend the vast majority of your time conducting the actual missions and so um I mean it's you know just from this few minutes we've already been talking it I think it's really cool that we're talking about the exact same topic we both have a very much like a razor focus on the women right because you and I have talked about this a lot Liz like trying to stay alive is Paramount right in in the in the game that is the key and you're going to develop a

um you know a fondness for those characters that you're playing and we want that human part of the of the game to come through but we've done it in a very different way yeah um so you know everyone uh but uh we are we are planning to basically have character cards that depict a pilot and Navigator together bonding working the plane you know people that you you know their faces and so when you lose that crew and have to discard them that is not gonna feel good we don't want it to feel good we want you to have to risk it and then we want it to feel terrible and so what is the risk of death in your game in order so it's very high and the idea is that it's gonna happen to somebody oh absolutely yeah it's uh I think it would be unprecedented for a group of players playing the full campaign uh to end the game with all the characters they started with I've never had that experience people are going to die um people that you care about uh your characters are gonna die um you're gonna you're gonna churn through people within the regiment within the section um and it's going to be reconstituted over time so like that's it that's what's on the tin uh you know you're gonna avoid the warranty if you if you fight against that the game will push back pretty hard um and and that's uh that that's important thing for tabletop role players because it it kind of flips the script a little bit on a lot of role-playing which is kind of power fantasy where you you know

you're controlling a character that's going to grow and succeed and become better at what they do that happens in night witches a little bit uh your characters can become more competent uh they can earn medals you know they can uh there's all kinds of things that can happen that will make them a little bit more effective but it's it's not a lot uh and they're going to need every Advantage they can get as the game progresses just because the law of averages is very much against them yeah I actually love that you said that because we also have like a little bit of a campaign upgrade system where you get cards that indicate you're getting better at your job but we cut all the ones that made things too good yeah no I think that's that's a really good design Instinct for this particular story right because there's a there's a wall there like you're handicapped by the equipment that you have access to and it's never going to get any better uh if anything is going to get worse because your enemies are going to learn how to how to lead your planes and how to you know how to Spotlight them and yeah absolutely so um the other thing I think is interesting and I I did want to spend some time with it is that I feel like we both wanted to make these games because we really cared about depicting these women in history who did something super interesting and to do it in a way that's very respectful and empowering and like giving Agency for them so how did you decide to Express that in the context of your game yeah thanks that's a really good question and I want to ask you the same thing because I'm really curious about

how you approach that so for me the first piece of that is that I when I started this I said this is living history there are people for whom this has grown truth and I could meet them so I felt the need to approach it respectfully as a topic with the expectation that I might have to justify myself to someone who lived it and I've done that before I have another game that's also about World War II and it has the same kind of thing where you know I I could meet a survivor of these things and I need to keep Center that in in my design work uh I felt that was important so uh so what I so so I wanted it to reflect some form of ground truth but I also wanted it to be a playable and engaging game and I didn't want it to be something that people were going to bounce off of or that they were going to just not not approach because the topic was difficult or uh or dangerous in some way for them in terms of social capital or engagement or whatever so uh so I was very thoughtful about those things as I was building the game and I knew that that it was kind of special because there there's a real pitch that you can give for their story which is these people are badasses who you know they bomb the Nazis every night for you know years and when they didn't have bombs to drop railroad ties and it's an amazing

story and if you can get someone in this in the seat with that pitch then you can say and they were all women uh and that that really changes the dynamic uh in a very positive way and so um for me it's always very satisfying at conventions to to get a group of people maybe some people who identify as male who would never dream of playing a female character in a tabletop role-playing game uh to to have that experience uh and then walk away from it with maybe some empathy for those particular women or the the difficulties that they encountered that their male counterparts maybe didn't uh so that was that was very much on my mind as well that there was a a a way into that story that was going to be beneficial uh more broadly uh so uh so those are the things I was thinking about I think as I as I approached it I wanted to make sure that I was making a game that was playable and fun but also a game that respected the history uh in a thoughtful way you know what's really funny is that I think David and I could give a version of the same answer David do you want to go first and then I'll fill in or the other way around no you go ahead you go ahead so yeah um I I particularly uh felt you're like oh like let's talk about how badass this is right and then they were all women as kind of like I feel like we both kind of started from that point like both projects so

for me one thing we actually worried about whether we should call the game night which is because it's clear that the Pilots did not necessarily want to be called that um you know they're very much like we're Pilots we're here to fight for a country we're here to do our job and we are damn good at our job and so I think that especially for you know for me as a as a woman who does a lot of work and I don't want to be the best woman something I just want to be the best at what I do flat um I really felt that a lot as I was reading through like interviews with these women and so and you know we're also trying to make sure this game goes to more traditional War gaming settings as well as like hobby board gamers and so the game if you took away all of the art that we're planning and the flavor text really plays pretty straight it's a hex encounter it's it wasn't it's a hex game where you're pulling from a bag which you know is you know bag building is an established board game thing and um you're having these sort of dramatic things that appear on the ground as you fly over and really you know the core Loop of the game is about being the most competent pilot possible it's into art and in the flavor where the identity of these Pilots is becoming more clear and for us that was a deliberate choice because we wanted to Showcase these women's competence and growing skill and you know boldness and going out there and doing this again and again and again after your plane's been shot at after things have started to go

wrong when you're running out of time in the night and um you know so for us uh and I think this is especially true for me um you know I wanted to really treat these women respectfully as professionals because that's what would have meant something to me if somebody had remembered my my stuff in a war and I think it's really cool that our game went that direction and that yours is very much about their personal needs and their daytime lives because those dovetail in such an interesting way David what do you have anything to add really quick um no I mean I just I think that there's I think that and we had a little bit I think of this conversation with Reina um there's a little bit of a possibility that when people view a game like this they view it from Modern sensibilities about issues of sexism right and gender bias and things like that and so certainly these women were having these problems that is these challenges right these internal challenges within the Soviet military but for them according to the interviews they've given at the time and ever since then um to include how they talked to Arena they were not that was not their primary concern right their primary concern was defending their country and so it's it's kind of like what you were saying Liz um what we want to tell I think is the story of these extremely brave people who were given um an almost impossible task with extremely poor equipment and their

ability to overcome the odds and become a guards unit and be the best at who they were independent of being women uh oh and they just happen to be women right um so yeah it's it's really it's a really powerful story and I'm hopeful and we'll see I'm hopeful that it transcends the typical Niche hot like in the hobby Niche where you would see that sort of um interest in a topic like this because of of who they were right and to the war game Space where historically you might not see such a welcoming uh you know Community for that it sounds like you've you've laid the groundwork though because even stripped of flavor uh those people will be able to engage with the game and it'll be solid yeah and we definitely made sure that it would be stressful that like you don't have guns you don't have right like you have these crappy little bombs and you have the ability to turn really tightly good luck have fun um so what initially Drew you uh Jason to the topic of the night witches and what kind of research did you do leading up to your game yeah I think um uh uh the the inspiration came from Casimir cottam's monograph one of her books I think it was Sylvia woman in combat um that I just read you know because I was interested and didn't know anything about it uh and that got me really

excited uh and I thought well I'm a game designer there's a game here this is awesome this was in 2007 when I when I read that um and I got really excited I made a game that was really terrible it just wasn't any fun I wasn't it didn't do justice to the story I didn't do justice to the history um and so I just put it away for a while and then when I played apocalypse world for the first time I realized that the the way that that game was structured uh was the answer to the question that I had um it was the thing that I didn't know how to do suddenly I just I knew how to do it um that that was the technology I needed and so that was 2012 or 2013 and the game kind of flowed out of me at that point um but yeah it had a long sort of percolating period where I I had identified it as something that was exciting to me and interesting I was doing some research on it um in a very informal way because I wasn't sure that I had the tools I needed to make a game out of it and then I got the tools yeah so that's that's the the progression oh that's awesome David how did we get interested in night witches you mentioned it to me and I was like that sounds really cool we should do that but where did you get interested I have no idea oh yeah you know what so well as you know I'm a military history fan right like I so I'm always reading some crazy something from military history and um and of course I have a little

special place in my heart for women in World War II right so I have like a long list of topics of of women in World War II um and that was just always at the top but it was never I was never able to carve out the time to work on it right so you I think you know we had discussed something I was interested in it and I think you just kind of you were like we're gonna do this so so obviously so it moved from the top of my list of things I can't work on to okay we're doing this now so that's awesome so Jason I wanted to ask us to focus on these women as as human beings who are forming these intense personal relationships with each other um of various teachers and uh one thing that is a major aspect of your game um is queer relationships so um I say for us we asked for our character art to be I guess ambiguous like you could read the women as friends or you could ship them depending on your own personal interpretation um but uh what made you decide to uh add that component of the women's relationships to your game and then how did you make sure that that was gonna happen in a way that was like respectful and natural and like really gonna work in that kind of vulnerable role-playing setting yeah this is a great question and uh first of all I think that the women themselves were pretty pretty clear that that um that wasn't part of it that they were they were not there for romantic relationships they were all

professionals um and that that kind of stuff didn't go on uh I I don't I don't know one way or the other I I mean maybe maybe it didn't but I felt that uh given the topic I needed to make that a possibility I needed to to let people explore that if if that was their inclination or if that's just sort of where the fiction LED them uh so there's nothing in the game uh that that makes that happen uh but I wanted to make sure that uh that I recognized that um a military unit full of women uh might be a military unit that had some lesbian relationships in it and I didn't want to shy away from that uh I had a um and I'm a straight white guy I don't I don't know anything about anything but I wanted to be sensitive to that and so I created a a little coven of of my career friends who were willing to sort of just double check my language and my approach to the topic uh and then you know I kind of backed it up with with uh as much documentary evidence as I could so I talk about the implications of being homosexual at the time uh and you know make sure that as a a player or a facilitator in the game that you have these resources to to like present as potential dangerous to your players if that's where they're going to go there's a cause and effect relationship there that it's a it's a dangerous thing to

express yourself in those ways or to follow those those instincts in a you know in a wartime setting a stalinist wartime setting uh so so that that's that was sort of my position uh I wanted to to really be clear about that and give people the opportunity to explore if I wanted to most people do but that if you don't the game it's not there's nothing mandated in it there are no no mechanics in the game surrounding the queerness so this actually leads me to a question which is okay I think this board game designers David and I have some similar struggles but it's going to come out differently how do you balance between making sure your players have the freedom to have a good time in your game with the fact that you're using a historical setting and that you're trying to at least keep things like somewhat informative about history I mean I feel like that would actually be even harder in an RPG than it is a game like uh like a board game and so how do you manage that in terms of your presentation and rules that you add in or do you just have to let it go yeah that's a great question and it is a it's a constant uh source of tension for me so I I'm very much interested in history and using history as inspiration for for games and when I find something I'm really excited about the first question I have to ask is is this going to be better to be focused on in a in a very direct way or should I abstract

this in some way so for example I have a game that's about the Lebanese Civil War and the decision I made pretty early in that process was that I needed to abstract that that just because of the moving pieces and the complexity of it there were there were some some rough edges I was going to need to to file off to make it intelligible to people playing playing the game and that to do it justice to to uh to create the experience that I wanted that you could then talk about you could then you know talk about the history it needed to be abstracted so in that particular case it's taking place in space Lebanon uh and all the the all the factions have been relabeled and they're but their motivations are the same and they're uh you know the the balance of power is the same but but I had to abstract it quite a bit to just kind of make it work in that case and I'm happy with that decision with this game again like that I I it's living history there are people who experience this that are still alive and so I didn't feel like I I well obviously that's true with Lebanese Civil War II but in this case I I really felt like if I met somebody who went through these things I needed to be able to say I uh I told your story in a way that was respectful as best I could and um uh hopefully you'll you'll feel the same way and that and that guided me to make it as accurate as I could in that way but of course it's out of my hands once once

I've you know sold it to somebody who who plays it at their table and and if they mess it up or make it weird there's nothing I can do to other than say please don't mess it up and make it weird um and provide resources to to like the game itself has mechanisms that if you follow them you're going to tell the story that Echoes the second world war um it's not it's not going to be substantially different uh the way that the unit progresses across uh the Ukraine and Belarus is not going to be in Poland isn't going to be very different from what happened in real life um the individual moments and light motifs might be different but you're still cueing to history in a way that I I think is is good enough but it's absolutely an issue and for somebody who's a subject matter expert it can be very painful to play a tabletop role-playing about a historical topic um my other sort of intense heavy history game is gray ranks which is about the um like youth resistance during the Warsaw uprising uh and you play Teenagers you know that are that are fighting in Warsaw and and you're doomed like it's not going to go well the game doesn't end with a Polish Victory it just doesn't that's just that's not the way it goes um and people will fight back against that and then they want success and they want things to go well and uh it's sometimes it's hard to see if people

push too hard in that direction or if they just do things that are very historical which happens all the time and uh in my opinion for a role-playing game you just kind of have to let that go you know people are gonna make mistakes they're gonna change things a little bit and it's much much better to just be like yep rather than being like well actually actually the name of that plane was changed in 1943 to the U2 from the po2 so we've got it like that's just not that's not helpful it's demoralizing it's it's not gonna make things better so yes authority issue let's say it that way yeah we go through it too actually David I want you to take this one um you know I know that you have done games with much greater granularity than our night which is um but do you want to talk about some of the the historical aspects we decided to keep and what we decided to play fast and loose with just for comparison yeah yeah for sure I mean I think one thing it's an important decision to make early on what your goal is in terms of historicity and authenticity and all of those efforts right so um like you said there are some board games that I've designed where and this usually has to do with scale right these are about very small scale things about about actual individual people and once in my this is a personal thing for me but I think you know you and I share this as we're designing night witches if you're going to make a game about real people and those real people are going to be in the game then you need to do

everything you can to make sure that the game is an accurate representation of those people right and their contributions and who they were when you take a step back from that and you have a more zoomed out view of a situation like night witches or some of the other games that I've worked on that are like historical but not nearly as historically accurate quote unquote um I think you buy yourself the opportunity to abstract a lot more and accept a lot more um like simplifications of the model that you're using right and that's certainly what we where we've gone with night witches right so you know we had a very early on we had a decision we were going to make this a low complexity game because we want to make it accessible for people because we want people like me to be able to play with my 12 year old daughter right like that's an important thing for the two of us and so um we've intentionally said I mean we let's just you know we met with Reina a couple of days ago and we said hey here's our game we walked her through all of our missions and we said this is the focus of the mission and what we were really doing with with reyno is saying how historically representative is this type of mission and she for the most part gave us thumbs up and she's like yeah that seems reasonable and every once in a while she'd like raise an eyebrow and she's like that might be just one step too far and so we'll do we'll we we will do what we can to sort of like meet find that happy middle ground of it's accessible so low complexity um it's historically like inspired slash

representative but it also needs to be at the end of the day like it has to be fun to play too right we can't it can't be Yep this is historically accurate and it'll bore you senseless and you'll never play it again so this game very much is is we're trying to find that that sweet spot between those different factors I think so you uh handled the the knights that kind of long grind of multiple sorties by reducing it and making the day more important we had to come up with increasingly interesting missions and only represent parts of the night to prevent people from doing what represent like hours and hours and hours of repetitive bomb drops yeah and for me that's one of those areas where I zoomed way out I'm like we're gonna there's a night phase in the game you're going to do an attack which represents maybe eight or ten sorties um and the you know the overall result is what we care about and if something goes wrong that's interesting but if nothing goes wrong then you did 10 and it's Dawn is sort of the attitude I took from that piece of it I very much telescope that so uh so Jason I have a question for you um so next year uh Knight witches RPG is going to turn 10 and that is awesome especially because it's still so clearly beloved uh by the community so how how have how have your feelings about in responses to the game kind of evolved over the last 10 years and kind of where do you see it in terms of your other work

thanks that's a good question uh well I love it uh I think it's a it's a solid game I enjoy it every time I play it or facilitate it um I think that it does cool things and that it can provide a a really satisfying play experience on a variety of levels I don't think any of that's changed um I don't know about you but for for me like 10 years is enough time that I've grown and changed as a designer and I look back at it and there are specific things that I think I would change in in the game that I would uh smooth out or or clarify or make more interesting or whatever you know that that feeling but it's a it's a piece of work that I'm proud of and uh that's that's a that's a good place to be for it one of the things that's happened that that took me by surprise but that I really love is that there's been a trend somewhat dented by the pandemic but uh definitely a trend of playing multiple combat sections at once at game conventions so uh imagine four tables with four facilitators each running you know a section with three airplanes and then this this group is all in one big room and you've got a you've got a mission board on the wall like a dry erase board which shows how each section is doing in relation to the others it adds this element of competition a little bit people can switch between sections the the last time we did it somebody got married and we like stop

the game and sort of role played a wedding in the middle of it's just like it's it really changes the dynamic in a very satisfying way to have 16 people playing simultaneously what is really a four-person uh role-playing game so little surprises like that are really Pleasant to see as well and also to see the design threads that it introduced uh influencing other people so I see bits and pieces of night which is in other games as well and that's that always makes me proud to see if you can ask a quick question of Jason so um I mean I think I so I've got the book I bought it many years ago long before Liz and I started talking about um because I I come from an RPG background on mostly tabletop game or a board gamer now but if I remember correctly does a game kind of assume that the players are pilots and Navigators or are it does it provide for like if I wanted to be ground crew right does it provide that flexibility it doesn't I want you to be in the planes I want you to be going on okay uh so you're probably curious about the the sort of like Real World Air Force analogy of you know the campground crew sort of has the pilot Navigators lives in their hand every time they send them up and it's a whole different stress right I was just wondering if that was if that was in the game okay it can certainly happen you've got a rich cast of NPCs that that are non-player characters that are there doing that stuff and uh you know the you're following the fiction in the game so occasionally you will get a a pilot

or a navigator who can't fly for whatever reason because they're injured most usually uh but for other reasons too if they're being punished or something some other circumstance so it does happen in play but the the intention of the game and the way that the characters are structured is that you're you're flying you're navigating you're in a cockpit you're going on missions yeah that's awesome it's funny because Liz and I when we first started uh we because you know they had this this unusual advancement within the unit where a grounds crew person could potentially become a navigator you know and and so there was was a point very early on where we actually were trying to factor in the role of the individual grounds crew and we kind of sort of came to a kind of a similar uh realization that this is really about the key the game is about the planes in our case and we had to abstract that out but it was an interesting um interesting experience for us to get there I think and there's there's a whole other game about the logistics of keeping these things running that would be fascinating you know it's just it's a fertile ground there's plenty plenty of games in the night which is for sure so I'm going to take this opportunity this is my podcast hobby horse always so I'm a huge believer that games are able to communicate and depict and teach about history uh in ways of other kinds of media just cannot quite do so you do a lot of historical RPGs uh would you be willing to talk about you've mentioned some but would you be

willing to talk about kind of the historical work you're doing when you're creating RPGs and what kinds of experiences do you think you can offer players Beyond reading a book or watching documentary yeah um and maybe the best way to do that is to talk about a particular game and and sort of where it came from and what my intention was for it so let's talk about a game called Carolina death crawl uh Carolina death crawl again it just came out of a historical reading I was reading about the American Civil War I live in North Carolina so naturally that's kind of an interest of mine is to to see sort of what happened around me and I found out about Potter's raid on Rocky Mount in uh in 63 I think it was uh and I read about this and it was a you know it was a union raid from the coast which had controlled deep into the North Carolina to wreck some railroads and then get back out and uh they they got in and they did their thing and then it was sort of every man for himself to get back to the coast uh and that interested me because they didn't all make it back and I was like well that that's a cool story you know your your Union soldiers who just get abandoned or you get separated from your unit way Behind Enemy Lines like 100 or more miles Behind Enemy Lines with swamps and you know an indigenous population who really want to kill you between you and there that's cool that's a game I want to make that and uh so as soon as I read that I was excited about making the game about

it I did lots more reading um uh sort of assembling of the accounts I made a big map the children ever been with I drove it I went you know because it's it's regional history for me I can if they talk about a battle at the bridge a little content near Creek I can go there and kind of get a feel for it so so that maybe my text will have a little more authenticity to it having sort of stood in the swamp uh so uh so I I knew I wanted to make it I did a bunch of research I figured out sort of the the core Loop in that game which was going to be one of uh this unit slowly decreasing like like everybody but one person is going to die on the way back to Wilmington or Newbern on the way back to New Bern you're gonna die one person's gonna survive that's the way the game works uh and so the fun of the game is how's it going to happen who's going to get me and then and what happens next and so uh so all of that stuff is uh all the history is right on but then there's this sort of spooky overlay on top of it where um it's it's not really a supernatural game but like you you know that your predestinence to fail and there's a question about who it's it's going to survive it's lightly competitive in that way uh and at every stop along the way you're getting injected with new bits of History uh of real things that were happening in the time and place and so

after playing the game uh in a way that you wouldn't get by just reading about Potter's raid you kind of get a feel for what eastern North Carolina was like in 1863 uh and what it was like maybe to be in those situations uh and some of the things that they encountered that were horrifying so uh so and and in the end you have this product that that delivers that experience pretty consistently uh that's engaging in fun it's horrible uh it's scary uh and it maybe teaches you something so I I call that a win I was very happy with the way that all came together in Carolina death crawl's case that sounds really I want to go play Carolina death crawl now I'll see you guys later right I mean there you go one of the one of the design decisions that I had to make that was really important was that um what happens to you as a player as a participant after you die uh your character you know has a moment and then they're written out of the story when it can happen quite early because there's only four of you maybe so so somebody's got to go first and the the answer that I came up with is that you uh and this is a little larpy it's a little live action role-playing uh you uh what when your character's dead you become the the voice of the world and your job is to just whisper in people's ears encouraging them to make bad decisions

uh and uh and telling them the bad things that are about to happen to them so uh you don't get to sit down anymore after you die you become a swamp ghost and you have to sort of uh tell tell the other people like what's what's about to happen and and improve their game make their game scarier and weirder yes you should play it I I encourage you to so this also leads me to a question so one of the Hot Topics in historical board gaming right now is how can board games kind of create emotional connection and pain and compassion like with games uh and then I think kind of twin to that is what are we asking players to do and how callously are we asking them to do it like probably the most old hat topic is like oh what if you're playing the Nazis in a board game um so are those kinds of conversations live in RPG world and then what kinds of things do you feel comfortable asking your players to do versus not in the context of a role-playing game oh man this is so dear to my heart this is such a great great topic because absolutely and more so right because at least with the it seems like with the board game you have much more control over the parameters of the experience right or is it the role-playing game there's there's a lot of places someone's creativity can go and finding ways to bound that and to frame the experience in a way that allows someone to consent to what

they're about to experience is so important uh and uh I try really hard to to do that I I want my games especially now uh like this has increased gradually over time and I look back at some of my early work where I just was like well you're probably just like me and if you're just like me you you understand these boundaries and that's cool oh and I did not feel that way anymore and my games now uh are gonna tell you what they're about right up front uh they're going to tell you what you're going to be doing what the expectations are what the topics I think are likely to be problematic that are in the game are how I expect you to interact with each other as people how I expect you to interact with each other as characters all in a way to try to make it a safer experience for everybody and then uh how do you uh how do you nope out of that if it's not working right all of that stuff is front loaded now for me in these games um I uh I recently wrote a game that was a run at uh portal 11 which is a a convention that rotates around Eastern Europe and it's a game called bloody Autumn it's about the end of the second world war in Serbia in the Balkans and you play people in a village that are deciding what to do as the Red Army is approaching and you've got croats and serbs and uh there's a German family and there's just like it's just it's the

mess you think it's going to be of conflicting interests and conflicting desires and lots of grudges and people who've been hurt and traumatized and you have to make these very important decisions with very little input and under short time span and it's an intense game right it's really intense and I had to put content warnings on the game and I also had to put a Content warning knowing that some of the people who were going to be playing it particularly in Eastern Europe would have family histories around this topic and one of the things I had to say was that um some of the people in this game have relationships with fascism that you need to repudiate and I understand that maybe part of your family's history uh you know interacts with that you as a player are responsible for being very clear-eyed about that your past is not who you are but you need to understand what that means what the implications are and how you're going to interact with other actual human beings at the table uh in engaging with this material so I I feel that as a designer you kind of need to front load of that stuff you just need to be very clear about it so that somebody can look at that and be like well actually no I don't want to I don't want to go there I don't want to play that I don't feel like I can do it safely or responsibly um uh I just don't like it I don't like your attitude or approach to this topic and all of those things are fine please the door is open go play something else

you know uh I I think a clear-eyed presentation of that is very healthy for everybody I'm just like pausing politely to make sure that David doesn't have a question no question but it just makes me think of how much more mature I would say the RPG space is on this topic than the board game space and so what I mean by that is um I was recently like I said I don't play a lot of RPGs but recently I did played in one uh with some co-workers and the very first thing we did first session at least we sat down and we talked about and the game provided structure for this we had a conversation about you know what was what was the sort of normal bounds that we were all going to agree to right and then how would we how would players um flag if something came up that we had not anticipated right where somebody was uncomfortable and then I just look at board games and there's just not an equivalent you buy a game I was playing uh Stonewall Uprising recently which is an absolutely magnificent game but somebody has to play the man and basically the the idea is in board gaming once you bought the game there's an expectation that somebody's taking that role the game doesn't provide for any sort of outs um and it's just it's a very interesting different space that the two the two worlds live in yeah that's uh that's a hard place to be because that's

um potentially an emotionally difficult role and you kind of need to process that or maybe debrief from that and you need your friends to be like hey man you played the man and it was awful and we love you you know there needs to be space for that right yeah I mean I think there's I don't want to tangent too much on this but there's basically two approaches right well there's three approaches one is a horrific approach that we won't discuss um but I think otherwise there's two ways to sort of play it one is as you're playing it you understand you you actually feel the man and you you learn from that um and the other is try to have the main player just try to try to detach himself from the emotional impact and play it purely as a game um and I and honestly I don't know where I Fall In Those because it is that's a that's something I am not comfortable with doing right and so sure um well it's I think that's a designable surface though too right and it's gonna depend on the project a little bit right where you where you fall on that Spectrum there's a beautiful game that's explicitly about colonialism called Dog Eat Dog and and this is an example of how you can design to get people thinking about these topics um I don't know the dog eat dog does safety super well but it does do one thing really well which is that somebody needs to play the colonizer in the game and the way that you decide that is by comparing your income as players and the person who makes the most money plays the colonizer so like and that is such a fraught

conversation like for Americans in particular to talk about money at all is very uncomfortable and then to be comparing with other people at the table it sets the tone perfectly from what follows uh and it also allows that person who is in a position of economic privilege at the table uh to sort of ruminate on that as they play that role I just think it's a brilliant piece of design that's amazing that's brilliant yep that's awesome so just kind of pull it back around at night witches um so I mean you played this game many times right and you've watched a lot of people play it what what range of emotional responses to that game you get and do you have any key moments that have just really stuck with you from playing with others or watching others play good or bad yeah no uh well so I can give you some bad too but I think in terms of positive ones the game builds builds out from individuals and you're you have a connection to a community that's somewhere far away uh and so like they're every character is going to have the family or you know a mentor or somebody that they that they care about that is impacted by the war but is not with them you can write letters to or you can visit or whatever uh so like you're not you're never you don't even begin the game isolated it's impossible uh you're part of the community and then of course

you're part of the regiment and as play continues you really care about the fate of the 588 right um that becomes important and then your section becomes even more important than the people in it the other pilots and Navigators the support staff uh there they become very real and kind of lived in uh individuals uh that uh that are really Central to your experience so most of the really positive moments I I can remember are relating to the maybe ironically The Arc of those characters not the ones that we've created for ourselves but the ones that serve our surrounding us um when a you know in the navigator in your plane dies and you're bringing back their body to the to the air base or the Airfield uh you know those moments are just super intense the little little victories you know when you're when your mechanic becomes a navigator you know after after they've tried for so long to achieve that um and maybe that's the same person right usually that's the gut punch right they get what they want and then they lose it all uh so like moments like that I think are the ones that are really uh the most heartwarming for me to see I really love that the example of the wedding uh you know there was a character who was boasting about their fiance who of course was in the 586 there's something one of the mixed units that we're flying better planes uh and uh this was a will they won't they it lasted for the most of the session and then the end uh they just had time

to have this spontaneous wedding before they had to fly again and so everyone was scrambling to make this very special for them even though the Clock Was ticking and then they had a bad Mission because of it which is just like chef's kiss perfect you're making me so happy so those are those are great um I think the kind of the negative experiences relate to people who look at the game and immediately want to change it I had a guy who this was some conversation in the Forum who was like hey your game is really cool uh I want to use it to play a U-Boat crew and I was like okay I can't stop you I can tell you not to but uh you know there's nothing I can do to prevent you from Rolling dice with your friends and doing whatever you want so good luck but that kind of thing is pretty demoralizing because it's clear that the game has a message and the message is just not not getting through in that case uh this this is the the the easy out of this interview but I do want to ask so I'm I'm hoping that people who are listening to this want to play your RPG of night witches uh and hopefully the board game night which is too but yeah if somebody's never done an RPG before what do you recommend for getting started oh wow oh well there are a lot of ways to answer that but I think the the thing to do is to find some friends who maybe haven't played either but are excited

about it because your enthusiasm will solve all the problems that you're imagining um they're not complicated even the most complicated role-playing game is not that complicated if you are a board gamer you absolutely can Master any role-playing game that you're excited about night witches is an easy game to play you need two six-sided dice there's a very very simple probability curve interesting things will happen when you roll the dice the game tells you how to do it I I wrote it assuming uh new players or people that were not familiar with role-playing games so the one of the very first things in the game is hey if you if you've played games before skip to this if you haven't played this kind of game here's some some texts to read that will Orient you and then the game will walk you through it so don't be afraid if you're a board gamer and this sounds cool to you absolutely grab some of your friends make sure everybody's on board and just give it a try and in the case of night witches in particular I'm happy to talk to you about it as well if you if you bounce off it and it feels confusing I've had that conversation many times I love it I'm happy to support you so don't be don't be shy about that uh there are many great games if night wishes is not the game for you I totally understand there are lots of lovely role-playing games find one that you think is cool uh and give it a try again actually a really good Gateway game specifically for board gamers is a game that was designed to uh Echo some of the affordances of board games which is my other game Fiasco Fiasco comes in

a box it's got cards it's structured in a way that I think will be very familiar to your audience but it's still a tabletop role-playing game and it's very fun about dumb people getting in trouble what's not to like uh and then my usual soft eat the end of things uh what have y'all both been playing for fun what have you gonna play David so so I mentioned it before um so like so I only get together to play with my friends about once a month right because this is this is the life of a game designer you don't actually play games you just design games and then um I I do get to play with my kids right but usually I have I have my game group once a month and it's usually two guys and we usually so we almost always play three player games but this this past week I had a buddy of mine come over so we actually got some two-player games in which I haven't done in many many months maybe close to a year and at the top of my to playlist was Stonewall Uprising I'm embarrassed that it took me this long to get it and it was everything I was hoping would be and more so we played a bunch of games it's the only game we played twice um at the end of the night we had a little bit of time and we're like what are you gonna do now and we just both wanted to play that game again so that's that's definitely been the top of my list and I should say it's from Taylor schust is the designer and uh catastrophe games as a publisher uh and for me it's all play testing all the time I'm not playing other people's games as much right now as I would like so I have a weekly group that meets and we're almost always playing something

that I'm working on that's in various states of completion that's I don't know how much more detail you want than that but that's that's where I'm at that's awesome uh and then um so for people who want to reach out uh where can y'all be found online Jason you first yeah sure so my company is Bully public games uh and ended up only public games there are links to our products including nightwishes uh we have a patreon where I'm doing all the behind the scenes stuff that might be interesting to people as well uh and uh there's there are links to contact me directly from bully puppy games David uh for me for me probably Board Game Geek people can look me up there and they can just reach out to me versus via message I typically say Twitter and I guess that's technically still true that's that's a good way to get a hold of me though um I'm like the rest of the world I'm actively looking for some Alternatives so I don't know how much longer I'll be there but those are the two probably the easiest way to get a hold of me what are you playing so um I normally am a solo gamer but I've been playing with other people a lot because I have time and so I've got this huge game of Europa universalis going the price of power uh I'm England I'm getting my butt kicked but I'm really having a good time I've played several games of oath and that's been really fun I've really enjoyed it uh I finally got to play Pax Renaissance recently that was great

um you know I know that Phil eklin has his issues but damn he made a good game uh and I'm in the middle of a tutorial series for Cuba Libre right now and I've just done like so many kubilee videos that's awesome uh so yeah I've been having a really good time and I can be found anywhere online it's beyond Solitaire and I'm terminally online so I am not hard to track down um so before we close out uh does anybody have any final thoughts about night witches any last things we want to say I'm so happy that you're making your game I can't wait to play it uh it looks really cool and this has been nice it's been nice talking to you yeah yeah the only thing I'll say is hopefully at some point the three of us that are in the same location and Jason you could run us through a game of night witches because that would be amazing yeah same same let's we can just have a night wishes day and we'll we'll swap games love it let's do it yeah all right night witch Con coming to someone's house back in and Jason I'm so glad you came on I I really really enjoyed getting to talk to you about our shared love of these people and their history and then also clearly we have a lot of shared love for history and gaming in general and that always warms my heart so thank you so much my pleasure David you're cool too so uh thanks so much for watching everybody or listening please like

subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming

Progress saved