Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Secrets of Warden Keene Review: A Grave Mystery

Transcript 11:03

Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassel

and I'm Wendy Ye.

Today we're taking a look at the secrets of Warden Keen, which sounds like a guy who runs a prison, but no, his name

That's what I thought too.

His name is Warden. In this game, the game takes place in I believe 1925. You your group this game says one to four players. Although it doesn't it could be it it could be six. I suppose there's no

it would be hard to see with six. I think Yeah,

but I'm saying there's no real physical reason it couldn't be more.

Right. Right.

You are collectively the new caretaker of a cemetery.

The new warden.

Yeah. Well, no, the new the new caretaker. The other guy's name was Warden. You're not warden. Was that actually his name?

Yes, his name is Warden Keane. You're Joe or something.

Okay. I thought that was his title and his name was Keen. Okay.

So then you he left you he was bored sitting at the cemetery. So he would look at all the stones and learn about these people and he makes puzzles for you then to solve. There are 11 named puzzles in this box. And uh let me show you how it works. In this game, you have a bunch of gravestones, and each of them has a letter number A1, and it shows that it goes on the A1 plot. So, you can take these off if you want to, or if you just want to pull them up and more closely look at what's on it. There's all sorts of messages and maybe letters and other things, sometimes pictures that might matter in this. There's also a gate up here which may or may not matter as to what's on this. You have some crows over here and these crows are just used for you if you want to put them down just to remember some people that are involved with it. And then the rest comes with a the journal. So at the beginning it gives you a letter which tells you why you're doing what you're doing along with a picture of the cemetery along with a list of the different mysteries that you're solving. And then each mystery has some stuff that's written here and then has a question. Put the candle in the grave grave of James McKay's murderer. So I need to look down here using these figure out who James McCrae's murderer is. There might be some hints that are written here and or hints maybe that come earlier. Probably

not though. Most of it is going to be out here on the board. And when you figure it out, you say, "Who killed James McCrae?" Maybe it was this person. And I'm just putting a random candle down. And then you can open a book. It will give you some hints you can look at first and that might help you. You might change your answer and then it will give you the actual answer. And then you go on to the next case. That's pretty much it. I can't really tell you more without spoiling it, but I will mention that some of these, you can see they're kind of 3D. They have different pieces that are on them with pictures. There's Ivy. Sometimes part of the information is covered up. Uh there are a few extra things, some letters and a lunar calendar that may or may not be part of some of the mysteries, but that's how you play it.

All right, we're gonna be careful not to give spoilers here. Um but I I do want to point out a couple things. First of all, this game is very much replayable. I know this because it's been played probably by eight different groups since we've gotten.

There's no like permanent cutting things off or crossing things out. Um, take notes on the side. Don't put big X's on stuff.

Yeah. And and the board is a is a piece of paper, which I wondered about. Um, but it's really the stones. You don't need that piece of paper, I don't think. Um, and the stones are kind of the fact that they're not on it is nice because you can pick them up and look at them like this and put them back. Yeah, that's that's fair. I didn't think about that, but that's really useful.

The the game is essentially in the escape room genre,

but I would cross it with um it's

reminds me of micro macro a little bit.

Yes. And or Chronicles of Crime because the theme is so strong in this. you are saying, "Oh, this person, I bet they had an affair with that person and this person,

are they cousins?" You know, and you you you you're talking thising like, "Oh, I bet that person's a murderer."

And because of that, I mean, the theme really does it has to be about theme.

There there's, don't get me wrong, there's cryptologology and other ways that you solve, and there's a few that I think you might need a piece of paper for. Maybe I did them all in my head, but it was some effort to do that. But a lot of them, I mean, the first one

Yeah.

is so simple. You're like, that can't be the answer.

They're just getting you into it.

Well, so initially, like this doesn't come with a separate thing of rules. Like you just start reading the book, right?

Yes.

And so um initially when I pulled this out, I was like, where are the rules? Do am I allowed to open up this book? So, I open up the book. I started reading and um there's a point where you it like is giving you the answer basically and you're like, "Wait, it's pointing out who's going where and what tombstones you're looking at." Um but instead, it's kind of like a tutorial. Like it explains to you what it's doing in that first tutorial. And they're like, "Did you figure it out?" I'm like, "Oh, I understand now." So then I started doing the second scenario and I was like, "Oh, it's is this a second tutorial? It's giving me a lot of information, but I appreciate that it walks you through the first few ones and kind of like gives you training wheels before it just lets you go, you know, and I appreciated that. However, I wish there was a little bit more information. It was so thematically written the instructions that I wish there was a little like card or something that said, "Okay, this is how you're going to play. Now play."

I didn't think about that, but I mean, I guess I played so many of these games. I got to the red writing and I was like, "Well, we're let's figure it out now.

Let's go."

I I don't I'm very critical of these escape room games often. I don't think they cheated at all in this at all, like or that there was a puzzle I thought was too difficult. There were they definitely ramps up in difficulty, but I don't think any of them were too hard. And definitely sometimes we couldn't figure it out. We'd flip it and be like, "All right." Other times there were things that I did very quickly and then because I taught this game to a lot of people. I'd sit there and be like,

"Why are you not using the mirror on? There's no mirror. I'm just giving an example." Like, "Why are you not using the mirror on that? It's so obvious." You know, things like that. And some things that are obvious to some people won't be to others, which is why you can play this solo, but I think it's best in a group

that for that discussion. Yeah, we definitely I think in my the group that I played with, we all had different moments where we saw things that were important. And so, could you play by yourself? Sure, you might get stuck.

And it's also, but I mean, if you do get stuck, you just say, "All right, let's see. Let's go to

let's read the next bit." and and it you learn about this whole town and some of the things that happen in the town and there's different clues, sometimes visual, sometimes extra stuff and it I I feel like it comes to life a little bit and sometimes future mysteries will refer to past ones so you should do them in order. I don't know that you have to but it at least thematically it helps. Yeah, I I really appreciated how they felt so connected because um I've played games that are like solve this puzzle and now solve this puzzle and now solve this puzzle, but this um each puzzle felt interconnected to the other puzzles because you were in the same graveyard and thematically this guy's been wandering around the graveyard figuring out these puzzles himself. So, it's not like the information changes or the people in the in the graves have changed. And so, I just appreciate how all those puzzles are interconnected.

Yeah. And there were definitely times where I saw something like, I wonder if that's a future puzzle. And then maybe it was or, you know, like, oh yeah, I remember this this this is the guy who who murdered the cat. No one murders a cat. Um, but you know, you have these back and forth things. I think the theme of it is really strong and and there was at least one the times I was playing, we were playing in low light and I was like, this is really thematic. You know, we're sitting there like, how do you see this?

Some candles.

Um, so what would you give it?

Um, I'm going to come in at an eight for this. I really enjoyed what was going on. I think that um it had some cool puzzles. I definitely need a group personally because I was not going to catch everything. Um I also appreciate that because you could pick up the tiles and the pieces that people could sit opposite from each other and still see what was going on and read what was going on because playing some other games that have the big sheet um it's hard when you're like the third person sitting on the opposite side. And so yeah, this one was a lot of fun. I very much enjoyed it. Eight. And I'll jump on that in a sense of like I like the fact that since so much of it is through the theme, it's you're talking it through. Do you think these two people were married? Do you think this guy had three wives and these are all three of them or whatever it might be? That talking things through means again you could be sitting anywhere at the table and it actually drew people in. I played this with a lot of different people.

Um I'm giving it a nine. It's one of my favorite escape room games that I've played in a while

because the theme is so strong. Like I've got to the point now where puzzles are I don't it sounds a eotistical say they're boring but you know when you get a new thing I'm like maybe the insert matters maybe it's in the UPC on the back maybe it's uh

maybe it's in the instructions you know you're so been trained to figure out all these puzzles here the theme was more important I think some people are going to say it's this is too easy

I don't care though because I had so much fun doing it and now that I'm finished with it I can easily pass it to someone else and they can play it too and or We we're going to put in Dice to our library where people can continually play it. So,

well, there you go. Seal of excellence.

Also a great theme. That whole cemetery theme is Oh, yeah.

It's a little spooky. Not really. It's not It's not really about ghosts and goblins, but it also gives you a sense of mortality and there's like that that theming in there. And the 20s is a good setting.

Yeah.

So, that's Secrets of War and Keen. I'm Tom.

I'm Wendy.

See you next time in the graveyard. Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved