Wingspan Pocket Review: Tiny Wingspan?? That's Un-Flocking-Believable
Transcript
Hi everyone, I'm Tally. This is Fowl Play, with Board Game Geek, and today we're reviewing Wingspan Pocket, which is for one to five players.
So, this is a new small box re-implementation of Wingspan. Uh supposedly to be more portable and lighter and quicker. So, it has the core of Wingspan you love, but with a few minor changes to make it more streamlined, basically. So, we're going to get into how to play, and then what we think, but please know that this was a review copy from the publisher.
You bring me down for all to see.
Unsurprisingly, Wingspan Pocket plays very similar to Wingspan, but there are a few key differences. So, here you have a big deck, and uh the cards are double-sided. So, one side will represent the food resources, and the other side will represent the birds that you're going to be playing. So, you'll have a marketplace like you see here, where there'll be four birds on display, and you'll have four types of food to pick from. Uh and essentially to start the game, you're going to receive six cards, and you can pick two of them to keep as birds, and the other four will be your starting food resources. And birds might also require eggs to play, which you'll start uh with one. So, you have your nest here, and on your turn, you'll take one of three actions. So, you can play a bird by paying its cost, and then you'll put it into your row. You can draw any two cards, so you can take one bird and one food, or two food, or however you want to split it.
Or you can lay up to three eggs, but they have to be on different birds or the nest. And the trick here is that actually every time you take one of these actions, you're then going to be activating every brown power bird that you have in your tableau. So, you begin to chain a lot more quickly and more frequently than you do in normal Wingspan. And uh as a kind of optional element, you can play with some scoring. So, if you want an easier game, you can leave out this kind of condition-based scoring such as the usual stuff. If you know Wingspan, it will be you know, for every bird uh that has a fish in its cost, then you'll score at the end. The difference here is that you're going to score per egg on that bird. So, you you want to have eggs on those birds for them to count for the objective, which is a little bit tricky.
So, yeah, you're basically going to be playing birds and activating your brown powers and laying eggs just like you usually would, but here the game's going to end when one player gets six birds in their tableau. And then you're going to score up for the kind of points the birds are worth, the end-game scoring if you'd included that, and for eggs on your birds. So, that is how you play Wingspan Pocket. Wingspan Pocket occupies a little bit of a weird space because at the core, it is just Wingspan with some of the edges trimmed off. But it it's it's just a little bit weird because it's it's obviously more focused on maybe a lighter crowd, and it probably the other benefit is that theoretically is more portable. So, then it can be a pub game, you know, so you can introduce it to anyone, and then maybe ramp up to the core Wingspan. But obviously the core Wingspan was already in many ways a gateway game to people.
Mhm. So, it's a little bit weird that it's been reduced even further uh at least to me. And I think the other thing is that uh I would say one of the main appeals of Wingspan Pocket is that it would be portable.
Mhm.
And it actually tends to take up a lot of table space, like more than you'd think, because the fact is that you're going to have your birds in front of you, and you're going to have your food resources in the front of you. In an ideal world, you're first of all you need to have your row of bird cards that you're playing, and you might have up to six. And then you want to see all the food you have, and okay, you could kind of keep a hand, but then you have to kind of continuously check and look as opposed to just having them out on the table. And weirdly uh I mean, I like the duality that the cards kind of are both the birds and the food, but it actually would have taken up less space if they just had the food tokens. So, if that makes sense.
I agree on that.
because then you just have a little pile rather than spreading them all out over the place. As you can see in some of our photos, it just it just takes up a lot of room unless you're making life more difficult for yourself by just holding them all in like one hand.
Mhm.
So, I find that a little bit weird, basically. Um yeah, what what what do you What is your opinion of Wingspan Pocket?
I I liked it enough. It was fun to play. I think what stands out to me is where you say the edges are trimmed off, it's more limiting maybe where it didn't need to be. So, for example, for me, so the game ends when you have one person has six birds in the row.
But the joy of Wingspan is spinning things out
Yeah.
typically. So, yeah, I find it maybe a little bit too limited and then the joy of the original game is not there when I don't think that's necessarily necessary to cut those things away. You could still make it smaller and more portable and lighter in different ways than cutting off the bits that make Wingspan so great. Just for example with the end game goals, it always caught me out that you needed to have eggs on the birds to score for those end game conditions. When again the kind of joy of Wingspan is you don't necessarily have to have eggs on birds at the end of the game. It's just another way to score but here you do. It's kind of sucking [snorts] in
And off the off the back of that as well like there's some things that if you played a lot of Wingspan they're a little bit difficult to get to grips with like that for example, but also basically every you have one of three actions and every time you do that you trigger all of your brown powered birds and it can be very weird if you're an experienced Wingspan player to play a bird and then activate all the powers in a row. And like you kept getting caught out by that I think and it just yeah it's a little bit of a weird thing in some of the way they they changed the powers I think or the way it works. So yeah it just again like you said there's there's nothing wrong with it. I think I just it's such a weird place because would you get this and then go on to like full Wingspan or is it supposed to be just a travel version or cuz if I think the bottom line is we have basically everything Wingspan.
And I think I would never play this unless we're going on holiday.
No no for sure.
never play it at home cuz I'll just play Wingspan.
Yeah.
And I don't think it's like yeah compact enough and dynamic enough to want to take to the pub either
No.
With some like friends.
I agree.
So, if you want Wingspan and you have big table wherever you are, then uh I think it works. But otherwise, yeah, I I just I would just recommend normal Wingspan, basically.
Yeah. I mean, some of the
Asia if you're two players.
Like things that we know and love about Wingspan, like the birds and the different powers, that's all there.
Yeah.
It's just that for me, to make it smaller and more lean, I think it could have been done in different ways where you're not cutting out the cool parts of the game. That's what I feel like it's done a little bit.
It's a good way to put it. And I I don't know if you felt this, but I also felt sometimes it was a little restricted um because basically the way it is now, you have to pick a bird from the marketplace and you have to pick a resource from the marketplace. Um and a lot of times the birds, it feels more limited because you can't draw blindly.
Mm. Yeah.
And so sometimes you're like, "I don't want any of these birds because they don't meet the conditions."
Yeah.
So then it's like, "I don't really want them." And then like vice versa, sometimes the food, because you're not like rolling for it and you can't because like obviously you can build up in Wingspan that you can take more food. Sometimes here you're like, "Well, I really need fish to activate my brown powers." And then there's no fish for three rounds.
Yeah.
I found it more limiting in that way as well. And like like I got more annoyed that things weren't there and I had no way to
Yeah, there's no way of spinning the things out. In the normal game, you can be like, "Okay, well, I'll save that for later or I'll do something else with it." But here it's just so limited that again, that like engine building for me was not really so there.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So yeah, so I think all in all, it's yeah, I mean it does what it sets out to do.
Yeah.
It's not bad. It's just that I yeah, we don't know why you would want this over Wingspan unless it was specifically that you're addicted and you want to play it when traveling, basically. I'll be interesting to actually see what people think of this if some people are this is really great cuz one of the things is that okay, it does play very quickly.
Yes.
So that is like again what makes it maybe more of a pub game. Um and maybe people like that that is like a kind of you get Wingspan but it's a filler game at the end of the night or something. We'll just be really interested to see what people think of it when it's out and where it sits for them.
Mhm. Yeah.
Yeah, please ask us any questions you might have about Wingspan Pocket. Please consider subscribing and thank you for watching. See you.
Bye.