Phantom Society Board Game Review
Transcript
today Yura file reviews is looking at the Phantom society by frederick columbia and herve Molly winsome due tre and Nyad I hope I pronounced that correctly it's a beautiful production and it's a deduction game based around ghost hunting intended for four players but with variants for two and three players essentially this is ghostbusters the board game just by another name and that's even hinted at in the manual with the hotel that we're playing in being called sir philip of Venkman marlem be a manor hotel which is clearly a not to Peter Venkman from ghostbusters the hotel is also called the ground Palace Hotel apparently according to the Box in one slight diversion from the rules I do wonder whether this subtitle might suggest that there are plans for alternate sets to come out in the future but I have no basis for that suggestion apart from the fact that it's got this subtitle on the box this board represents the hotel the Scottish hotel in which the ghosts are hiding and trashing rooms two of the players in the the four player standard version of the game two of the players will be controlling ghosts so we have these ghost tokens here a blue ghost a white
ghost a green ghost and a red ghost and two of these will be controlled by each of the ghost players the other two players will be playing the ghost hunters now the blue ghosts can only hide under blue rooms the red ghosts only under red rooms the green ghosts and the green rooms and the white goes under white rooms and when they hide the way that it works is that the the piece comes off the board here and the token is placed inside there like this and then the piece is placed back on so at the start of the game and first the players will place these tiles over the board and then after that the players will wear the ghost hunter players will cover their eyes and the ghost players will hide their ghosts around this board from there on the the rules basically are based around destroying various rooms in this hotel on both sides the ghosts want to destroy the rooms just to make mischief and the hunters are destroying the rooms while searching for the ghosts the first thing that happens in the game is that the ghosts will destroy a room now they can destroy any room that is adjacent to where the ghost is hiding so for example we know that there is a ghost hiding
under this room but the ghost hunters don't know this so this ghost has the opportunity to destroy any one of these adjacent rooms so he might for example choose to destroy this one it's taken off the board has flipped over and we've got a slimed version of the room on the back there okay so this room is taken to one side and it's worth one point for the ghosts now the ghosts are aiming to destroy 45 points worth of room so one point isn't particularly helpful but with the hunters destroying rooms as well those points are all going to be added to the ghosts total now one important strategy point is that this ghost now considers this room adjacent so in any number of empty spaces in a straight line does not block adjacency so now this one is adjacent all of these are adjacent but also this one however now it's one of the ghost hunters turns and the ghost hunter needs to choose a room which he thinks that ghost might be in now as the ghost hunter I know that that ghost is going to be in one of these rooms so I've got to choose essentially one of those rooms to destroy or I could I could destroy anywhere on the board to see if I pick out one of the other three ghosts but it's more like I'm going to try and destroy one of these so as the ghost
hunter I want to limit the amount of damage that's done so I'm unlikely to destroy this number six and so I might go for this number one up here and there's nothing there the green ones have a sort of a littered library sort of image on the back of them now we keep on doing this and the total amount of destroyed rooms keeps adding up until eventually 45 points are reached or until all the ghosts are revealed so the ghosts win if 45 points have been being destroyed and the hunters win if all four ghosts have been revealed now it is worth bearing in mind that the ghost hunters do not know which color ghosts each player is controlling and that does make a significant difference because if I knew that let's put one of these one of these tiles back here if I knew that the the player whose turn it is was the blue ghost and then this room disappeared well I would know instantly then it must be under this tile and take that off so that's an important rules point has been missed in one of the other videos which is why I mention it now we haven't yet looked at the very first stage of the game which is about setting up the board now the first time that you play this this will feel like
it's entirely arbitrary that basically it doesn't matter where you put the tiles that you could just put them anywhere and it would make very little difference that isn't the case and as you play the game a few times you'll very quickly start to see that there's quite a lot of strategy in this first step of the game and I'll talk through some of those strategies briefly now to give you an idea of the sort of decisions that you're going to be making one thing that might occur to you if you're a ghost player is that it is not much use to you if there are sixes or high-value rooms six is the maximum in the corner of the board the reason for this is that if we have other rooms around here and you are hiding under here need to be a green goes to hide under the green room so if I was hiding under here and I wanted to destroy this 6 i'm gonna very quickly give myself away because if I destroy this 6 as a ghost then the player is going to know that I'm one of these three so it's very easy for the ghost hunters to find me eventually so the ghosts are going to want to avoid the high value cards going into the corners of the board now equally the hunters are going to want that situation so they're going to want to put sixes and fives and fours into the corner of the board where it's much harder for the
ghosts to destroy them without giving themselves away clearly that also means that the ghosts are going to be trying to put the higher value rooms more towards the center of the board so they're going to want these sixes and fives up towards the middle here and commonly what you'll see at the beginning of the game is a situation like this so you'll end up with the two ghosts going here and you might end up with the two ghost hunters going here and then the board starts to build out from that but it can become quite a tactical sort of strategic exercise this building up of the board the the other thing that seems to be quite helpful for the ghost hunters is to try and keep all of one color roughly in the same region of the board and if I can sort of pull all my green tiles all around here and I know that the green ghost is going to be confined to one area if I eliminate some of the other ghosts it's going to be easier to home in on that particular area so there is strategy in this in this part of the game even if it initially and doesn't seem apparent when you've played the game a couple of times in a sitting and it tends to take about 10 minutes 15 minutes to play through a game of this you'll quickly start to hear players saying oh it's too easy for the ghosts or it's too easy for
the hunters you know that there's a lack of balance in there well the game offers us a system whereby we can set ourselves objectives and it's quite a clever system and it does add to the strategy in the game and although it's quite hard to get your head around essentially each team of two players has a set of cards like this and they're all beautifully illustrated as you can see and they've all got values on them which correspond to the values on the room so for example this is it worth four points essentially in terms of the rooms and then these ones here so that they're lovely images and they've got these names on them which are entirely irrelevant they never come up at any other point in the game so I'm not quite sure what the thinking was with that but but they're lovely images and they do add to the theme now the way that this works is at the beginning of the game the players think about whether they want to be the ghosts or the hunters if they want to be the ghosts they're going to have to bid a higher total than their opponents so if I was going to be the ghosts I might want to bid 54,000 something like that so there we are 54,000 now that is my bid for how many rooms I think I could destroy if I was the ghosts sohrab airing in minded than the basic game 45
is the total that you'd be looking for here I've bid 54 I'm going to wipe out 54 points worth of rooms now my opponents they also have a deck of these cards but they only have odd numbers so that there can never be a draw so they might think well yeah I want to be the ghosts so i'm going to bid quite high as well bearing in mind that the highest value is the team that that gets to be the ghosts so he's going to bid let's say we're going to go quite high we think so we're going to go 47,000 so this team these have been unseen by the other teams and these are currently faced down 47,000 they bid and then we reveal both 47,000 and 54,000 now this team has been higher so they are going to be the ghosts but their target is not going to be 54,000 their target is going to be 47,000 so by bidding a little bit lower this team has made it easier for the ghosts now there's a lot of strategy in this point then and it's really hard to think it all through it at the start you know if you bid too low what impact is that going to have if they'd bid 32 for example think you know I really don't want to be the ghosts I want to be the hunters soul a bit 32 suddenly we have a
situation where their opponents are the ghosts but they only have to achieve 32 points which is really easy so there's there's a whole lot of back and forth you know having a chat with you your team member working out what your strategy is going to be and it becomes quite a sociable sort of game it's quite nice to play a few sittings in one session staying as the same team so you can build up a little bit of that sort of you know we're going to get them next time sort of attitude towards the game these add a lot to the game and but I did find it slightly odd the amount of theme that has been put into this game when essentially the mechanics are very simple and and and these names and they kind of suggests that these cards should be doing something more than just being bidding cards but they are lovely lovely artwork and you know I can't fault it from that perspective at all I bought plant in society really on a bit of a win you know I saw the beautiful artwork I love the artwork by this artist you also did tokaido and seasons and the whole load of other games with a sucker for games with beautiful beautiful artwork and this really is one ghost busting theme I like deduction games so it really was quite an easy sell for me and and I must say when I first play that I was disappointed because it only took 10 minutes it was so so brief which before their game is really short 10 minutes and they didn't
seem to be that much to it it seemed very arbitrary which tokens I picked up and you know I often out have a selection of maybe seven or eight different rooms that the ghost could be in and I have to pick one of them and I might be right or I might be wrong time so I'm going to be wrong and but but but there are moments like that in the game we're really it does become a bit of a luck driven thing now now that's not the case once you've played it a few times and and actually it grows on you extremely quickly only after sort of three or four games do you start to really see I'm on a minute there's something I can do here which is going to really change events and the strategy starts to creep in those bidding cards really help I haven't played it with two players or with three players and in fact in the rules that's described as a variant as opposed to being and you know the standard way to play it but I can imagine losing that camaraderie of the sort of teamwork the partnerships would lose a lot from the game there are other reasons which I'll go on to which I think there might be a slight problem with loneliness with two or with three although I don't think is terminal I think you could still do it but I think there may be slight issues with that but the game has a lot of strategy actually once you get going and although it's only 10 minutes or 15 minutes if you play a few games in a row then the
excitement sort of builds and and rivalry starts to build up between the teams and it really feels like a game that you should play a few times in one sitting there are some oddities with it in terms of production and that sort of thing and these tiles you know fantastic you know the artwork on them is great and I particularly love the sort of destroyed rooms on the back but they don't feature these destroyed rooms never really come into play it feels like they should be placed on the board you know that that way up and then when the room is destroyed you know you flip it over and leave it on the board the trouble is the born then looks very cluttered and it's not very easy to read the situation on this you can't really do that so you know that it feels slightly odd that we don't have a sort of much clearer more delineated sort of picture on the back showing that this room has been destroyed that we can leave on the board and that's a minor minor point a slightly more significant point is that these not these tiles so much but the ghost tiles they fit so tightly into the holes that you could damage the the edges around them and in fact if you put them in one way they won't really fit at all and you'd have to force them but in the other way they kind of sorting quite nicely but you can't get them back out again that's what popping them through and that's a slight slightly irritating part about it there's no reason that they needed to be quite so tight and but it's not hugely
significant probably the most significant problem I've had with it so far is that the ghost players forget where they put the ghosts and that happens quite a lot and it's quite easy and I do it it's quite easy to forget you're looking at this grid and I've even played games where a ghost player this destroyed room and they've revealed a ghost because they've forgotten where the ghosts are I would have thought the game would have been incorporated some sort of component or something which rectified that made it easier to remember where you are there is a grid reference on the board but it's tiny really tiny and I didn't even spot it for a few games but i guess the players could write down which grid reference their ghosts are in and fold a paper you know keep it one side and that could help and but that is an oddity in the game that it does really behind having quite a good memory for where you put something in terms of what other games this is like well we're in the same sort of genre as mr. Jack and as Scotland Yard these sort of deduction games hidden movement type games it's not the same as these games if you've got these games then the Phantom society is a very different experience but it is that genre and there are lots of other games in the genre letters from Whitechapel fury of dracula escape from the aliens in outer space you know and
and and they're all work having a look at but the phantom society is a unique experience it is its own thing I love the theme I love the Ghostbusters sort of concept and it really works well with that with the the film you know this this destroying of hotel rooms in order to grab the ghosts and the ghosts also destroyed in a room snap that all fits in really nicely and it does feel like it could have been a film ty anything if they'd be able to afford the rights or something like that although the artwork and the you know that the setting this this Scottish mansion all that it's it's lovely as it is you don't need that but it does help to to sell it to new players and setups you want to play this game is sort of like ghostbusters you know and that really works for it I think this games got a lot going for it and I think if you like the look of it then then you know pick it up the the components are fantastic the artworks fantastic and the game bills you're going to play a few times before you really get to grips with it and so so so you know give it a few goes one slightly odd thing about it which i haven't mentioned is I'm not sure what families are going to make of it it kind of feels like it's theirs it's too much thinking is too so the way you brain has to work around those bidding cards that's it's quite convoluted sort of system I think
it's a good system but I'm not sure family is it going to go for it they're going to get confused and I think a lot of gay is it going to play this once and think it's too simple and not realize that with a few plays that's going to build you know and I think a few gamers might say actually one game though that's that's probably enough this there's nothing much to this and I think they'd be wrong so I think there's going to be some trouble marketing it from that point of view and but who knows it's a new game and I hope it does very well right phantom society