My Top 10 Favorite Game Designer Debuts
Transcript
Hey, I'm Jamie with Stommyer Games, and today I'm going to talk about my top 10 favorite debut games. So, these are games for these are the first published games for 10 different designers. Games that I really, really love. There are games that I left off this list that I also love. There are um games that I'm probably not aware of were a were a designer's first game. It's a little hard to search for, but um and really for many designers, I found this to be somewhat true. I talked about this in the video a little bit more, but I I found that what I perceived to be a designer's first game oftentimes turned out not to be their first game. If you go to Board Game Geek, you can you can look up designers like think of your favorite designer, think of what you think is their first game, and you might find like 10 other games before that or a couple other games before that that didn't make a splash at all, but this game, but uh but every now and then, a designer's very first published game makes a big splash. So, I'm going to talk about these games and why I think some just some general thoughts about how to make a splash with your debut design. Um, yeah, let's jump right in, I guess, and go to the honorable mentions. I have Neurosima Hex by McCall or Orox. I'm going to mispronounce some of these names. Villagers by Hakan Gardner, Hive by John Yani, Cascadia by Randy Flynn, Scoanteer by Morton Monrod Peterson. Um, and I'll put Vidaulture on there. That was my debut published design by me,
Jamie Stigmar. Vidiculture. Uh, yeah. Let's jump over to the top 10 list here and start to look at them. So many of these games are heavier games surprisingly. So they're they're kind of impressively impressively heavy for a a debut design, but it is sometimes just as difficult to design a really streamlined game like Hanamikoji. Hanami Koji is by Kota Nakayyama. It was Cody Nakayyama's first published game and it is a very streamlined two-player tugof-war game where you're trying to influence seven different geisha using cards and a very limited action system that is really really nice. It's a you get four different tiles over the course of the round. you must use all of those tiles.
And several of the tiles do things like uh they say you get to choose one card to play and um and the other player you get to play three cards and the other player chooses one and you get the other two and those cards will are are the cards that exert influence over the uh the geisha. Um I think it's uh it's a very restrained game. It it it does exactly what it needs to be and nothing more than that. And I think that's rather difficult to do with a debut design. I think it's oftentimes a great thing to do for a design that you don't almost that you don't end up publishing. Like I think it's good to design games before you actually seek publishing for your first uh game that you want to publish. Um so that's why this list is about games that um that it's the it's a designer's first published game, but it is almost certainly not these designers first games. they ever designed. Uh going through that process of designing a game from scratch multiple times before you decide, oh, this is the one that I'm actually going to pursue publishing with, I think, will result in a much stronger product and probably a much stronger and much more marketable product as well because you'll you'll probably have done a lot more research then and played other games and understand what other games are already out there. But anyway, that's Hanamikoji at number 10. At number nine, I have Lost Ruins of Arnac, which is the co-design between Min and Elwin. It is their debut design. Made a huge splash.
Many of these games are in the top 100, top 200 on boarding geek. This is definitely one of them. This is an a deck building exploration game. And I really I really like a lot about the game. But one thing I wanted to highlight is that uh it's clear to me by playing this game that Min and Elwin had played or had heavily researched a lot of other deck building worker placement games. It combines deck building and worker placement in some unique ways. And they didn't just try to do the same thing that other deck builders were doing. In fact, they poked at deck building and they said, "Why when you gain a card in a deck building game, why does it always go to your discard pile? Why couldn't it go someplace else? Why couldn't you use the benefit right away? Why couldn't it go on the top? I I'm forgetting right now if it goes on the top or the bottom of your deck. It's one of the two. Uh in Lost Runes of Varn, that's where it goes. It doesn't go to your discard pile. Um and I think that's really really clever that they they took their knowledge of this pretty vast field of of games, deck building games, and they poked at it. They found something that they wanted to do better or do differently at least in their game. And I think that's a huge sign of a really strong debut game when you know the other games in the market. You know uh you know the genre well that you're designing in and you decide to do something different and innovative and arguably better uh when you debut your own game. And I believe that Lost Runes of Arnack did that really well in multiple areas but that's one of them.
So that's Arnack at number nine. At number eight we have Everdell uh James A. Wilson's debut design. I very recently played Farshore and so it's neat to play Farshore which is the sequel to Everddale while thinking about Everddale as as James' debut design. It's a very very good I I believe it's a very very good debut design. It's my number eight favorite. Um Farsore I think is even better. Like it's it's neat to see what uh James ended up thinking about after after having Everddale out there out out there for many years. But Everdell itself I think is uh is a really really clever design. um where one of the key things I think that makes the game special is that it comes across as a game with very few actions that you can take before you need to pass out of the round. I think you only get two to three workers. Um you have limited resources and you usually get those resources by playing workers, but the game gives you ways to ek out one more turn, try to get one more turn and then one more turn. It has this optimization that you can learn from the more that you play Everddale and that is really satisfying. I think James also does something really clever with the game which is he expands each player's hand by creating a display of eight face up cards that are essentially in your hand.
So whenever you want to build something or add a new card to your village, you aren't limited to your personal hand. You also have this public hand of cards that uh that you might choose from and that you really might choose from over your own hand of cards because someone else might take that card that you want. So you aren't just reserving that card, putting it in your hand, but oftentimes you are immediately putting it into play. Thought that was a really clever mechanism for increasing a player's agency over what they might be able to build. Um and uh yeah, I think James did that really well in Everddale. My number eight pick. At number seven, I have a couple games from Stonemire Games here. Uh, I think we have more games than this from debut designers, and I I like them all, but I I think that maybe the strongest two game debuts that we have at Stonemire Games are Apiary and the next game that I'll show you in a moment. This is from Connie Vulgman.
This is Conniey's um first design. I get to work quite a bit with Connie on this design. And one of my favorite moments of this design process was uh when when Connie shared this game with us at Stamar Games and she said um that she was open to Smar Games publishing the game. I was curious about it. I heard I it was at our design day event and I heard great things about it and I wanted to learn more about it. Um but I asked Connie how she would feel. So at the time the game was bee themed. It was always be themed but it wasn't science fiction be themed. And I asked Connie what she would think about adding a science fiction theme to it. And I think part of this was influenced by a recent book that I had read called um Children of Time by Adrien Chchaikowski. Um which isn't about bees. It's more about spiders. But uh but it is it has a similar field to apiary. And Connie uh Connie I think is great overall at at hearing feedback. Not always accepting the feedback but at least hearing it, listening to it, bouncing back and forth about it. And Connie said to this particular note, she said, "Yes, I actually think that would solve some problems in the game because by adding a science fiction layer to a strongly nature themed game, it gave her a little bit of flexibility to solve some design problems that were hampered by her being limited to a non-ci-fi theme." Um, that's a long way of saying that. I I I really like how Connie was open to a publisher publishers feedback to I believe strengthen a uh strengthen her
first published game Apiary. Um I think Connie does a lot of things right in this game. A lot of really clever elements of positive player interaction. There's a ton of player interaction in Apiary. Uh for a game that isn't negative at all. You're not doing negative player interactions against other players. are actively helping them throughout the game and helping yourself uh by placing workers on actions that already have workers there. Um but yeah, I think Apiary is a really really strong design from uh Connie Bulgman and it's a strong debut design. At number six, we have the other Stommyer game on the list. This is Wingspan from Elizabeth Hargrave. Uh similar to Connie, I had the pleasure of working with Elizabeth on this game for a long time before we decided to publish it. very early on when I when I first saw Wingspan. It had a different name and it was a game about playing I believe it was eight birds. Maybe it was 10 birds, but the whole game was about playing eight birds. And once you played eight birds, the game ended. There might have been some points on the birds. It might have just been a game about, you know, a race to try to play eight birds, but it was just about play. Every turn you try to play a bird. There wasn't a sense of progression. There wasn't a sense of engine building to it. But I saw at the time that Elizabeth was really, really good at pairing um what made birds unique and what made specific birds unique with the abilities that she was putting on those birds. Designing cards is not easy, especially designing cards theme first that feel where the mechanisms connect to the theme. I think that is very difficult to do. And out of the gate, Elizabeth had like a hundred different bird cards that did this. So, I was really impressed by that and uh
was excited to work with Elizabeth to to add these engine building elements to add a strong action system and add the engine building that you end up seeing in the final game with these uh the player mats that that are that are in the final game where you every time you play a bird or or don't play a bird, maybe you just activate a row of cards, you were doing something more powerful than the previous turn. Um, but overall I wanted to highlight Elizabeth's ability to design these thematically unique cards, thematically and and uh and mechanically unique cards. I I think there are over 400 cards in Wingspan now. And it's just a really impressive feat for a first-time designer to be able to do that. Even now, I've designed and published I don't know around eight games, maybe 10. Um, it is still my biggest struggle to design that many cards for a game and make them feel unique and special. um related to the mechanisms and themes. So yeah, Wingspan, my number six favorite debut design from Elizabeth Hargrave.
Number five, one of my favorite designers, uh Paul Denin designed this game, Clank that I really, really love. Uh Paul's gone on designed to also design Dune Imperium, which is another one of my favorite games. But Paul, we talked about deck building earlier with Lost of Arnac. Paul took deck building and he connected it with a dungeon crawl essentially. um where you are you are running through a dungeon and using movement on cards as a resource so that you can move through the dungeon. And in the original Clank and I actually still prefer the original Clank, I love that you get to see the entire board from the beginning. You get to see all these paths that you could take and right away you're choosing some paths and not choosing other paths and they're leading you deeper deeper into the into the dungeon. and you have this choice as to when you want to turn around, when you've grabbed an artifact, when you're ready to turn around and run back out of this dungeon with the artifact. Uh, if it doesn't, in fact, the case with all these games is that to me, they don't feel like first designs. And again, it's probably because these are not the actual first games that these people designed. Although, I think Wingspan may have been Elizabeth's first design. But for the most part, I'm guessing that most of these designers designed other games or or worked on other games before going allin on these remarkable debut games. And that that for me that has to be thea case with Clang. It's too refined of a design in my opinion and too clever of a design for it to be truly Paul's first attempt at ever designing a game. Um yeah, Clank number five on my list. Delightful game. Number
four is again one of the slightly more uh restrained games on the list, but one that has a ton of replay-ability. This is Cgraphers. This is a rolling right game that well, it's actually a flip and right game that uh that scales up to any number of players that you have pencils for. Um where you are creating a map using a series of cards that are flipped flipped face up to show you a polyomino shape and a type of terrain that needs to go on that shape on your map. Uh, this is designed, I'm sorry, by Jord Jordi Adon. And, uh, one of the things I I love that Jordy does on this is that he uses an existing goal system that I think is actually somewhat underused in games because it's a really clever way of adding a lot of replay replay-ability to a game, especially a round based game. Uh, that I first saw it in Isle of Sky. It's it also in Cgraphers where there are four total goals in the game.
These are spatial goals that you're trying to accomplish in cartgraphers. And in any given round, you're trying to you will score two of those different goals, a different pairing of two different goals. So over the course of uh either a four or five round game, I think it's four round game, you're scoring four different pairs of of these goals. So you're also scoring each goal twice in ctographers. I think it's a really clever system. Again, I haven't seen it used all that often, but I'm really glad that Jordy used it for this game. I think it was uh he he probably saw it in Isle of Sky and decided to bring it into cartgraphers, but I'm glad he did. It's a really clever system. I'm glad it's used here. And uh yeah, I just I I love playing this game. I've played it many many times. Carttographers by Jordi Adon. At number three is an interesting case here. This is Time Stories. The person on the box is Manuel uh Rosie Rossoi. Um sorry Manuel, I'm mispronouncing that name. But on Boing Geek, also credited here is Peggy Shassanet or Shassane. And uh it is peg it is not Manuel's first design, but it is Peggy's first design.
And I'm going to infer something a little bit here, but I think that sometimes for your debut design, it's really nice to work with someone else. Min and Owen work together. That was another one that I mentioned for Los Varak. I think this is the only other one on the list where two people work together on one person's debut design. But I think that's a great opportunity uh to pair with someone else who maybe is a little bit more comfortable with game design, has some some experience with it, and to work with them to bring a game to life is a great way to make a debut. And I think Peggy made an amazing debut with uh a game that heavily inspired my game Vantage. This is time stories where you are looking at the world from a first-person perspective and using that information that first-person information to um to to to solve the greater mystery of the scenario of time stories that you are playing. Uh really beautiful game, beautiful illustrated game. Uh but also I I I really like the time loop element of it. And I really like the idea that you walk into a room, you split up, you each look at something different and you come back together and say, "Hey, this is what I saw." and what you saw might be different than some what someone else may have seen or what you perceived what you read there. Uh really clever system and a lot of creativity from both Peggy and Manuel. Great debut design from Peggy Shassinet.
And number two, back to restrained designs. So Clover from Franqua Roma. An incredible first game debut from someone uh in in a genre that is very difficult, I think, to design a breakout game. This is the cooperative um cooperative uh uh word association genre. Uh we we have code names. We have just one and and now we have so Clover. Really difficult to design something that feels fresh and new where all where players feel clever in multiple ways. You feel clever in So Clover when you are writing down your clue words and uh you're you're taking this pair of words and then you get to write down a single word clue to get people to guess what that pair is. And then you also get to feel clever when you were trying to decipher what uh what cards go in what places on the clovers when you're trying to to solve what what another player wrote down. Clever in two ways. Uh nearly infinitely replayable, I think, due to the combinations of cards and how they can come out on your clover. Just an exceptionally clever game from Frank Roma. Um I yeah I I I'm so impressed when a designer I'm impressed when a designer designs a really complex game that is uh that is their debut design. But I I think I'm even more impressed by a designer designing a uh a a refined restrained game like So Clover that that takes off in the way that um that it did for for Frank and for Repos Productions. That is my number two pick. So Clover, but to go back the other way I am going to pick Ark Nova as my number one. This is an
incredible debut design from Matias uh Wiggy or Wig. Uh and it's it incorporates elements that are in other games for sure. Like it includes the the the dual track from Rajas of the Ganges. Um it includes uh you know a a card a nature themed card building mechanism uh that we that we see in other games. you're you're building stuff on a player mat a little bit similar to Castles of Burgundy with these text shaped tiles that you're putting out, but it combines all of these things together in a way that always makes sense thematically. It truly seems like a theme first game in my opinion. Um, and I I I think Matias did design this from a theme first from the ground up. And the thing that I am continually amazed by in Arch Nova when I play it is uh is how well the cards are designed. Like the cards incorporate all of my favorite things about a card- driven game where cards have uh they have a cost on them, but and that cost sometimes has a threshold that you need to have met to be able to play the card.
Like you need to have certain tags to play certain cards and then when you play the card uh often has a comes into play ability. It might have an endgame ability or endgame points. It um it might have an income ability. And almost every card that you play in ArchNova has uh an kind of like Splender, it has an ongoing it has a tag that you can play to to meet those thresholds for other cards. So there's this wonderful order of operations of which card do I play first? Do I do I play this card first and or or do I wait until I can make it a little bit cheaper by having this other tag that I've gained in the game that I I have this tag now so I can play these cards cheaper? uh just a wonderfully designed cards and again similar to Elizabeth and and Wingspan Batias designed hundreds of cards out of the gate all of which are are seem to be theme first designs um yeah really an incredible accomplishment in Arc Nova the number three game on board game right now Matias Wiggy's uh or Wig's first game first debut design very very impressive now I do have another video about uh uh tips for designing your first game and do stress in this video, I'll link to it. You can see it at the end at the end tag here that uh this video is about designing your first game for the purpose of going through the design process, not uh for making a splash with your first published game.
Because I really do think it's helpful to go through that process, design a few games without the intent of publishing, just to go through the process to learn what it really takes to design a game from the ground up. Uh it isn't just an idea. It's also about going through the play test and iteration process. Um, feel free to check out that video if you're interested in designing your first game. If you're interested in if you're ready to design the game that you want to be published for the first time, I think today's list is is uh at least hopefully an inspiring way to look at what some people's debut designs are. But also keep in mind, like I mentioned at the beginning of the video, if you look at most designers and you look at what their first games are, um, you probably haven't even heard of the first games that they designed. Maybe even the first 10 games they designed didn't really make a splash until they took off and had a had a big hit. They kept trying. They kept trying to make a splash. I would say though in the modern era of game design and game publishing with so many games being published, I would love to see um I would love to see people trying to make a splash with their first game. Uh and and uh because there are just so many games being published out there. So that's kind of my challenge to designers to design multiple games, but wait until you have that one that one that is really really special and innovative and that you think has a a great chance of bringing joy to a lot of people. um and focus on that one for publishing rather than the ones that were not less special but uh but that that were more you more about you learning
the ropes for design. Um and I I do this for myself as well. I I try to be restrained in in terms of which designs I design just to learn from the process of designing the game versus the ones that I actually decide to publish at Stonewire Games. Um yeah, there's my thoughts on on this on debut designs. I am sure I am 100% sure that I missed some incredible debut designs. So, please mention them in the comments. I'd love to hear about your favorite debut design. Maybe double check on Morgan Geek to make sure that it was a designer's first published game. Um, again, you might be surprised to find some other games on the list published before it, but uh but yeah, let me know your favorite picks in the comments below. I'd love to hear them. Thanks.