Joan of Arc: Orléans Draw & Write | Review
Transcript
thank you hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and today I'm going to be reviewing Joan of Arc the Orlean drawn right all right so here is Joan of Arc the Orlean drawn right all laid out and uh it's on the solo side of the of the writing sheet so basically this game can be played by more than one player but obviously I did this for solo and I've played it once at two players but if you want to play with more than that this one does go up to five and there is an entire other side where the multiplayer game happens so on this side of the sheet it's a multiplayer game and then over here we have solo so I'll be working in these areas and this is where Joan of Arc is working and she's the opponent so basically this game has some of the same elements of Orlean but it's also been turned into a drafting game and we will draw five tokens from the bag so I'm the first first player so I will get to pick first and then Joan will draft and I'll draft back and forth until these are gone so so I'll get an additional action on this round then we'll draw five tokens from the back again for the next round and Joan will get to go first and she'll get an additional action each of these tokens represents something that you can do as a basic action and then you can pick up buildings to give you extra oomph to the tokens uh but basically Farmers let you collect goods and filling up rows or Columns of goods has various rewards nights allow you to travel so you can fill in land travel routes along this
map and then of course fill in corresponding Goods that you pick up along the way Craftsmen let you either get money or build locations so if you travel to a location and Joan hasn't sniped from you yet you could build there and that's a major major component of scoring down here Scholars allow you to progress along the progress track also very key the sailors let you either get money or travel along a water route and then you've got these Merchants who can either give you money or let you build one of these locations if you've got the money to burn so rather than take money tokens you fill in this grid for money so just as there's a grid for goods there's also a grid for money and you have to fill it from left to right but for every column of money you spend you get bonuses and then for every row you fill you get bonuses so you have to make some choices about which bonuses are more important to you and how you want to build out your uh cash of cash this Shield track is filled up by these bonuses and it's also sort of overflow so you know if you've filled up all of your goods but then you get another good you can put it in the shield track and the main thing to note is at the end of the game the primary scoring is going to come from locations you've built plus citizens you've earned times progress on the scholar track so locations are built over here on the map citizens are earned in sort of a race to some of these spots on the sheet there's a couple on the progress track as well and then you multiply that by the progress that you've made so that's a lot of points your Shields will matter there are bonuses for filling up rows
and Columns of coins there are bonuses for goods as well there are bonuses for not taking these monk actions so a monk is basically wild in most situations so if you do not turn any of your tokens into a monk throughout the game then um you know you get these points for not doing that but you know maybe sometimes you have a farmer but you really need something else so you cross this off use the farmer token as a monk action and do whatever you need to do so it'll be up to you to decide Shields and then your total Joan scores in a slightly different way that I think is pretty brutal actually so I'm having a hard time even winning the basing mode for this right now um but every time Joan takes a basic you know farmer a sailor a knight or a Craftsman she crosses off one of these circles and automatically starts getting points for some of them as you can see the scholar track gives her little bonuses as well which is pretty brutal a lot of her cards will tell you to fill in Shields which are worth points you go from left to right and then left to right uh and then she has spaces to cross off for any locations that she builds citizens that she gains or progress that she makes so this symbol means that she's reached a new progress level just like you could she just does it in a different way and the way that you decide what Jones doing on a given turn is that you flip the top card of her deck and then this card will tell you whether you're reading from the bottom or the top and then you look at the first available token for her to take so for example there's a Craftsman here she's going Bottom up she would take this Craftsman and build location one if this was her setup so Joan is going
to operate pretty quickly on a little basic card structure but she's super brutal as you can see here if she were going top down and as you can see here if she'd managed to get one of the sailors she just knocks out an entire beneficial deed up here up top so these are other places to put tokens that give you bonuses for each time you do it and then a big bonus if you're the first to complete the deed so this is a game that's full of a bunch of different little choices and that's before you even get to the buildings which again can be built with Merchant tokens you essentially pay the money on the top of the card in order to take special bonus action cards for yourself for the remainder of the game there are five levels of them in a multiplayer game other people are buying up these cards but in Solo you actually have to buy one from each level before you can get one for the next so I basically never get to the fifth level in Solo because I'd only choose my actions that way but maybe that's a mistake so who knows but that is an overview of how this game works you are essentially trying to choose the right tokens when it's your turn to draft to do the most effective things possible in order to get the most points against Joan who is an absolute Point Powerhouse and she's going to just truck up all of these different tracks uh way more quickly than you would feel comfortable with so for now let's just do some final thoughts on the review all right so now for some final thoughts I have mixed feelings about this game I really really wanted to love it because I love a good chunky rolling right so as you all know if you've been watching the channel I've been having quite the love affair with Hadrian's Wall and I still really enjoy
it and it's definitely still King for me in terms of just really enjoyable rolling rights that have some heft and I think that Joan of Arc is trying to enter that space it's definitely a lighter game than Hadrian's wow but it has some of that same kind of okay there's a lot going on we're gonna add some cards you know we're gonna try to capture something that's a little bit heavier in this in this quick setup form is also in a different place though because it's trying to evoke early on which is a fantastic game I actually did not end up keeping in my collection but it's only because I don't think that the solo is strong enough to make it a keeper in a world full of great solo games if somebody brings it out of game night I'm always 100 down to play early on I think it's fantastic and so Joan of Arc I think succeeds in the sense that it does kind of capture some of the same feeling um and it does scratch some of that early on itch but it is a different game and uh the drafting mechanism like if you don't like drafting you will not like Joan of Arc so you know whereas in regular early on you're able to build your bag and it's really about the kind of building that you do so like yes you're fighting for spots on the board but you have a lot of control over the kinds of actions you can take because of the way that you're building your bag in general work that's not true because in gen of R you're beholden to what is actually available in the token pool at the time that it's your turn and you know that's good and bad it's good in the sense it does that's attention to the game it's irritating because sometimes you just never get to take the action you really wanted to take I think
that this game is also probably better multiplayer than it is solo so I've only played it with another person one time but I really liked the game with two people that I played it was really fun to kind of race for things together and you know explore the game together and be like okay well you did that well then I'll do this then and there was a certain excitement to it that I really enjoyed I would absolutely play this game again with another person I don't know about higher player counts I suspect they might get a little bit frustrating frankly um just because having so many tokens come out and then so little say in which one you get even if you go through the bag more times it does seem to me like it would be really frustrating um but I'm not really sure I want to keep playing against Joan and I don't know if this is a skill issue on my part or a balancing issue in Joan like I'm not sure but I've played this game several times I'm really struggling to do well against Joan I've won a couple times but they didn't feel like satisfying victories because those were like the one time that Joan Drew really horribly on her AI so basically what's going on with Joan is that sometimes she just gets everything like for some reason the card that comes up is the card that will you know take the citizen away from you right before you need it or the card that will you know um block the location that you were just intending to go to or that will give her a whole bunch of really quick progress on the scholar track and then multiply all those citizens that she got and you know in addition to that she's moving up Trackers just for having tokens and her Shield Depot gets really really full
really really fast so Joan is a point machine and I get that because you need that in a Solo game where you're a human playing against an automated opponent that has to be a little stronger than you in an unfair way because you're smarter than it like I get that but because of the randomness of Jones card draw combined with the drafting it was like I couldn't strategically draft anything because I really did not understand what Joe was gonna do because she's an automa she can play with any strategy and also because it was so easy for Joan to just take things like the beneficial Deeds you know you can be too who moves into a beneficial deed and like in a normal game nobody else would have even started it but Joan can just take it away from you immediately and I get it but I don't I didn't like it it made me sort of de-prioritize parts of the game that I might have really enjoyed Racing for and getting benefits from in another in another setting so knowing that I couldn't get any of the Deeds made me not want to commit to me tokens to the beneficial deed options and knowing that John was probably gonna get the citizen on the goods track and the citizen the money track before I ever even had a chance really disincentivized me to go for those things and so I instead focused on locations and just trying to get my multiplier up as much as possible to try to offset things I knew she was going to take from me like there was no merry race because I knew I couldn't win and it also kind of forces you at least in my case to play the game the same way a bunch of times in Solo because Joan has really specific advantages and then there are things where she's not as advantaged and so you know you adjust
your game to quit racing your first stuff you know she can get you on and focus on other parts of the game but there's just even though there's a lot to do there's not enough other places to go especially when she's drafting tokens that you also want to really make that feel satisfying so this is a game that I really absolutely wanted to like if somebody at a game night said hey Liz do you want to play this I'd be like yeah absolutely let's do it um I'm I really like the racing aspect with another person I really like the way that you can pick up monk actions or the way that you can still get buildings to make your tokens more powerful like all those things about it are good and as like a heavier rolling right I I did enjoy it and I enjoyed taking the actions that I enjoyed considering my options I just don't necessarily think that Joan is a great and also while I can't speak from experience on this I'm not sure how higher player counts in this game feel I'd actually be really interested to see other people's reviews come out because I don't know this looks like it get pretty tight pretty fast and like it would be really frustrating to watch all the tokens that you really want go by and then have other people draft them and you only get like one so I don't know like this is one of those games where I think it has a lot going for it I think maybe like a low player count might be good but not I think one player is maybe not the best um I'm sure however there are other people who have different experiences of Joan um I will tell you that when I did beat her though it was like she just drew everything wrong and so she would like Miss actions or she'd go for a citizen that I did
already get um stuff like that and so it's possible to beat Joan but I always felt like it happened when she was unlucky rather than because I played well and I would prefer to feel like I had a little bit more agency in that so that is uh Joan of Arc the early on Drawn right uh it is good uh but I would maybe play this with like two or three people so uh that's my review thank you so much for watching please like subscribe comment uh give to my patreon if you're feeling generous and most of all happy gaming oh