Shadows of Kilforth Review
Transcript
shadows of kill forth the hotly-anticipated stand alone but totally combine a bowl sequel to 2017 s gloom of kill forth is a game of cards and cards and cards creeping in this petty place day by day until the last syllable of recorded time anyway yes cards for your character class and abilities cards randomly arranged to make up locations cards for encounters that live for different terrain types cards for the four types of rewards cards for villains for nighttime bad stuff happening between rounds this is a pretty dense game of procedural generation all through those cards but for all that it's surprisingly organized I'm not going to say that it's streamlined but overall it's fairly straightforward to start you pick your character and race dictating your starting stats and abilities then you get your saga what's a saga it's five chapters in the ongoing quest you need to complete before you confront the big bad each chapter requires certain keywords to complete either from discarding rumors in hand or just having them on assets in front of you these rumors and assets are achieved by exploring the world revealing encounters at locations with mysterious places curious strangers and vicious enemies when you attempt to complete the encounter you roll dice based on your corresponding stat succeeding on fives and sixes with enough successes you'll complete the test reaping rewards in the form of treasure but also putting either than
counter card itself or a corresponding asset card into your hand as a rumor since rumors are discarded to complete a saga chapter when possible you want to put assets into play by visiting their corresponding location granting new abilities bonuses and other general goodness the more you haven't played the stronger you are and the more keywords you persistently have meaning less work in the journey ahead speaking of getting stronger HP is one of the key factors for your character and kill fourth as every round you get action points equal to your HP and everything from movement to healing to encountering to putting acet to play takes one of your action points but as you complete saga chapters your health increases and you gain abilities corresponding to your class and saga chapter level meaning you both have more actions to burn and are way more badass but it feels meaningless without a sense of urgency after every round night falls and a night card is drawn flipping one of the locations and to gloom and adding a special encounter or resolving an immediate or persistent effect gloomy locations caused damage when you end around there which again limits your actions in the next round furthermore the big bads each correspond to a terrain type and when there's fallen to gloom they reveal a plot card which if unresolved makes their final climactic battle that much more brutal if the last night card is drawn before players beat the ancient one someone for every player in the cooperative game they lose the game yeah there is a ton of stuff going on in this game lots of
little wools and tokens and yeah cards but it can all be boiled down to essentially you get your character you get your quests you move around the board you encounter stuff to get stuff you get more powerful and ultimately fight the big bad boss before time runs out and that path wild straightforward feels really dynamic and cool this is a rare adventure game with a meaningful arc where the whole time it feels like you are progressing through an epic quest and preparing for the final confrontation by the time you complete your saga you feel monumentally more capable than when the game started having raced against time foiling the ancients plots leveling up and developing your skills when you finally confront the Beast it will truly take everything you got as you exchanged blows and round after round of climactic combat yet the fundamental framework of the game hasn't changed at all and there are some other really nice conveniences in here too I mean probably one of my favorite things about the game compared to other games in this vein is that there is an investment in tests when you fail a skill test you leave the successes there for the round and if you attempt again you add your new and previous successes together also the system provides directions through probabilities there are four types of terrains and four types of assets and you better believe that if you need al is the blue asset type you are more likely to get them from counters drawn from the planes the blue encounters it's things like this that make the game feel more fair and reliable and as a consequence more strategic without
sacrificing the inherent fun that comes with rolling dice and drawing cards at the table worth noting though is that I've only played this game Solo and I played with the super nice luxury Edition with play mats actually dice and big old location cards well I could see myself playing without most of these things the play mat did feel like a huge boon to keep myself organized and as for solo play well let's just say that even one player with the whole set of actions abilities progression etc there's a lot to contend with compounding that with more players and the additional actions and agents and everything else they bring seems like a lot I could see playing this with two but honestly I think this game scales beautifully and kind of seems perfect as a one hero adventure the fact that it's not a tactical dungeon crawl where there are deep synergies relying on two heroes working together means like you don't lose much in the solo game and what you gain is clarity time and the ability to hit the table much more flexibly personally I enjoyed the game more than I expected to it sounded great in concept but when it hit the table the rulebook was pretty difficult to follow there were just piles and piles of cards and tokens and it felt like a super dense mass of my neutrals and overly obscured thematic terminology and leading to a growing fear that a would soon turn to overwhelming frustration but by about half way through the first game you start feeling more and more natural and kill forth for all its stuff revealed itself to be a compelling framework for emergent storytelling and
gameplay from the races to classes to skills and assets to the pairings of saga chapters encounters and Ancients there's so many elements through choice and chance that lead to incredibly unique and immersive adventures it is dense and there are a ton of my new rules and overly thematic terms seriously just say exhaust instead of veil but once it clicked it all felt part of a cohesive and thoroughly enjoyable whole so if you're looking for a companion during isolation and you want something that's both strategic and highly thematic with lots of moving parts and a nice balance between random chance and reliable direction and you want that sort of big RPG feeling without all the baggage of a campaign then shadows of kill forth is one of the best thumb at ik adventure games that I have played in a long while and that's our review thank you so much for watching I've been jack for the cardboard Herald if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our Channel and website cardboard herald calm our content is the audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard Herald