Galenus | Review
Transcript
thank you hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and today I'm going to be reviewing galanus medical Showmanship and bitter rivalry in ancient Rome so let's have a look at that place and then we'll get some final thoughts so here's galena's all set up for solo play I'm gonna give you like a general description of what happens in the multiplayer game and then talk about how that changes for solo this game does have a lot of intricacies and I'm going to keep my summary short so you definitely don't want to check the rulebook this is not a comprehensive teach but essentially in the multiplayer game you're trying to score the most impact points on this scoring track in the solo game what you're trying to do is reach the four goals on these perga mon cards before the end of year five and there are two sets of these cards that are double-sided so you can have different goals so these are going to push you to try different things in the game and push different mechanisms the structure of the game in both multiplayer and solo is relatively similar in that you have a work phase where you're taking actions both in your home and out here in the city and then at the end of each year after you've taken all of your actions you have a little contest where you see who is the best doctor around at least in terms of presentation in a given year meanwhile you're also trying to publish notable Works which you know here they are they've magically appeared in my setup haha and you gain points by doing this and also various rewards like your skill at
treating patience goes up there's several different actions you can take the most common is going to be that you're treating patients and you can treat patients in any of these regions in a multiplayer game only three of these regions are filled and it has to be Patrician plebeian and peregrini but in the solo game you just mix them all together and lay out four and the patients that are going to be available to treat each round are decided by these cards so they're very small but they're symbols over here on the left side that tell you what to put on a given card and then whether to add or take away Gladiators from the arena where you can also treat patients and the types of treatments that you can do are based on Ancient medicine so I'll move our dignitaries out of the way for the moment you have sanguine phlematic melancholic and choleric patients these cards also offer you the option of doing little special projects and you get rewards for being the ones who treat the final patient on one of these cards you're also able to solicit patients to your house which is considered less respectable but it's a good way to snatch some patients that you need to treat of various types as you treat patients you're going to gain focus in the areas where you've been working essentially and then you can use that Focus to publish works so if I treat a whole bunch of flomatic patients I have some focus in the phlematic area and then I want to publish on my findings then I could do that there are also Journeys you can take to pick up herbs and books which are also going to help you with treatment and with gaining philosophy which you also need to
perform other parts of the game for example you lose philosophy when you publish because you're spending that intellectual capital or when you bid in the contest the other place that you can go is the bath house which is up here on the left the bass of trajan here you can recuperate because if you start doing too well you start to lose health because people are poisoning you haha and then you can also join various sects so I put the sex down here but we'll put them up here by the baths but essentially you can become an empiricist a methodic or a dogmatist you can join multiple sex and solo but in multiplayer you can only Join one and they're used as a tiebreaker you're also constantly managing your stats over here and that's actually one of the things that makes the game very very interesting so you gain focus by treating patients and taking their little treatment meeples to your player board if your focus track is full but you want to like gain Focus you can actually increase your philosophy so these arrows are actually about interconnected aspects of your player of your doctor character you can gain Philosophy by getting books or by getting extra Focus but you lose philosophy when you publish or when you bid in the contest at the end of the year choleric patients cause you to gain reputation when you treat them you lose reputation when you solicit patients into your house again I mentioned that was disreputable or when you go into the arena to treat Gladiators and then if your reputation track is full but you would gain reputation you actually drop health and the reason for that is that
your reputation is getting too big and people trying to sabotage your work if you need to regain your health again you recuperate at the baths treating phlematic patients does actually cause you to lose health so be careful with that but you can't actually die so don't worry if you lose all of your health first it will cost you focus and if you have no Focus to lose then it'll cause you to lose points so basically you have these little interconnected traits that you are playing with throughout the game you're spending in various categories and gaining in various categories to get your actions done so I want to talk about the big key aspect of multiplayer and then how that differs in Solo because I think that does impact how this game really works I think solo feels fundamentally different from multiplayer for a very specific reason so one thing that makes the multiplayer game very interesting is that the the catch to work replacement so you're placing workers either in your home or out here in the world to perform actions for you however the real thing is however the trick is that each player gets to make their own decision about when they start to perform actions so once you start performing actions you can't place any more workers out so you are essentially trying to balance between doing the most things and also having the first dibs on any of the spaces on which you've placed a meeple or you know according to the game book a medical so in the multiplayer version of the game that is a lot of the drama there's a lot of tension of like looking at other people and thinking oh my God I'm going to start taking their action
next are they going to get first dibs on those books are they going to be the one who gets to complete the project oh no and so you know you have to really think that out in Solo it's fundamentally different essentially in Solo what's going to happen is these contest markers are going to move throughout the game so glennis is going to move up the track as he gains abilities and these dignitaries will either just kind of end up below you or they'll end up knocked out of the game altogether as you complete your goals and when it gets to gallanus's meeple then you can do all of your actions just right there at one time so in the solo game the trick isn't to start taking action soonest it's to get going this to a point where he's taking actions earlier and then each of the solo opponent like dignitary meeples only does one thing per turn but they do what's on their card so Saturn's The Physician for example will treat all patients of the region he's in the asiarc will clear out the arena so you better get ahead of him if you want to treat a gladiator needs the cynic will discard herbs or books on the journey card so if you want to shop you better do it quick and then pilops the physician will try to treat one patient of every type and then we'll gain skill for doing so so basically the dignitary metapoles exist in the game too get in your way clear off stuff that you might have wanted and kind of force you to force your way up the contest track in order to get things done and that has a really different feel from oh if I like kind of cut my action short I
can take some of them first it's just a different decision making process so I think I've pretty much boiled this down in Solo you're working to complete these four goals in multiplayer you're just working to get IP and you're balancing your resources in both modes between what you're using to take actions and then how much effort you're putting into the contest each year so those are the very basics of galanis let's go ahead and have some final thoughts all right so final thoughts time gleanness is a tough one to talk about because I really really wanted it to be as amazing as it promises to be you know medical Showmanship and bitter rivalry sounds super thrilling and like kind of cutthroat in a way that I'm not convinced this game actually was for a number of reasons that said I do want to start with the good and I think the good here is that there are a lot of very interesting ideas in this game I really thought that some of the mechanisms that it wanted to put forward were cool and I also really liked the attempt to communicate information about ancient medicine in game form like was it super deep no maybe not but um you know looking at the different types of patients there being some sort of reference to publication was really good I thought you know Galen himself had a many many Publications and in fact there's a a story about him where he was in the markets and uh somebody was selling a book by him that he had not written so you know that's that part is very true to life the rivalries among doctors are
quite true to life and I just thought that you know trying to weave all that together as a game was really interesting and mechanically a lot of the design here I think is really cool I liked that Focus feeds into philosophy philosophy feeds into reputation reputation feeds into health and there's like a loop of stats for your your doctor that you have to worry about um I liked that certain kinds of treatments had social consequences because you know well Galen was actually famous for his work with Gladiators there were also you know sort of social stigmas around working with different types of patients in the ancient world and I like this game tried to reflect that um I liked that the books that you can get at the shop are you know like little medical tomes they're real titles by real authors which I thought was really cool and then of course the big mechanical Twist of the game which as I mentioned is not reflected in Solo so I'm going to talk about that in a second but the in the in the multiplayer version of the game I absolutely love the catch where you are kind of fighting with yourself about whether to keep putting meeples out or whether to start getting results and taking action sooner than other people to make sure that you get what you want on the spaces you've already used I think it's a really cool touch I think that it is a very nice little twist on worker placement and I thought that was really cool that said it doesn't show up in the solo version of the game and I'm honestly really disappointed by that because I think that mechanically that's probably the best aspect of the game so let's pull around to some of the issues with this one and unfortunately there are a lot so the general issues
whether you're playing solar or multiplayer are very much to do with the graphic design of this game this game was clearly play tested on tabletop simulator and not enough in person and also not enough blind test of this game were done um it is very clear that most playtests of this game happen online with enlargeable components and probably being taught by the designer or by somebody else who knew the game because there were parts of the rulebook that had me scratching my head pretty bad but let's start with the components just as a starting place so the print on these cards is really small so I'm holding up one of the cards right now and as you can see like these are the Little Numbers you need to read in order to populate the card and this is Tiny this is so tiny the text is really really small um there's so much space given to Art but it's actually sort of distracting from the information that you actually need and I just think this is kind of a wild graphic design choice and that's actually not the most egregious Choice like in that vein so I almost threw one of the pieces of this game away and the only reason I thought it might be a piece was because it was in the punch board and like it was dyed and you could see like the surrounding color around the piece so it was clear supposed to punch it out for something but the piece was this year marker this is the year marker for this game it is like a tiny little piece of cardboard it is so small and it fills up the year space on the year track on the board when you're doing the competitions and so you know meanwhile the publication board is like
huge but the border with like the little uh influence points is small like I don't I don't know I don't know what went into these choices and um you know there are also other indications of sloppiness throughout the production of the game I personally thought the rule book was messy um there are typos that you can find throughout um but most importantly to me is that there's not a lot of great clarity of explanation so like there are certain parts that you really need to know about the game like how to learn from other doctors for example that show up in parts of the rulebook where the information is there but you want to look it up again it's not totally clear how to find it and like I first noticed it in the part about the arena with the Gladiators and it took me a second to realize that it also applied to other spaces and I don't necessarily think that that is great rule book writing and so I find that a problem in the rule book and unfortunately it gets worse for solo to me the solo mode you know I love it when you guys have a solid mode but I really want the solo mode to be good and this Solomon was dissatisfying for me in part because it took away the best part of the multiplayer game which was choosing when to reverse course and start taking your actions instead of planning them and so that's just not even in the solo and I felt like that in some ways that's the heart of the game um you know you don't really feel like there's a true bitter rivalry going on in Solo the goals for solo you know they're okay but I don't necessarily think that they're all very exciting to achieve
um you know it didn't give me the same sense of progress or like fighting that I got even in the multiplayer version of this game and there were also aspects of the solo rules that I thought were sloppy just kind of undercooked so again it's kind of hard to figure out like how you can learn from other Physicians you know I figured out how to play it I'm pretty sure but I had to find I found myself rereading I found myself checking I found myself finding things kind of ambiguous and having to read between the lines on stuff and you just shouldn't have to do that in a game rule book a game rule book exists to be really clear so that you can play it with confidence and I did not feel confident especially in my very first solo plays of this game and you know the reality is that most people don't play games five plus times and take all that time to learn how to play and so so you know the fact that you're several first games are going to be kind of learning games is a major problem for this one in my opinion so to sum up I really wanted to like Elena's better than I did I think it's got a lot of really interesting ideas in it I love seeing people try to bring ancient history out in a game and there's a lot about that that's cool but the execution on this game was just sloppy and I don't like that partially because I felt like this game had a lot of potential that didn't make it onto the table uh partially because I is a solo player especially felt kind of like under attended with this one and also you know I really see ion as a publisher like
trying to position itself as kind of a historical company a company that produces these really legit games on really serious topics and I think that if you're going to do that marketing wise then you also owe it to yourself and to your audience to have really beautiful Productions that kind of underscore the gravitas of the subject matter that you're trying to cover and I'm not getting that impression from this game so would I look at maybe a reprint of this game and clean up rules actually yeah like I really wanted this to be wildly special and um you know I think that it had the potential but as it is um you know playing if you're really interested in as a historical curiosity but I don't think you realize its full potential as a game so thank you so much for watching please like subscribe comment donate to me on patreon if you're feeling generous and most of all happy giving foreign