Skip to main content
Loading video...

Isle of Skye Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 10:19

hello welcome back to the channel when this is the channel where we give you reviews play throughs unboxings we generally like to talk a lot of bollocks about tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're going to be talking about a toll lane game that may or may not replace another time alone game that's celebrating its 20th anniversary this year we're going to be talking about oil of sky and in this game you'll be purchasing tiles from your opponents you'll be laying them in front of yourself to create a landscape that will if linked together correctly provide you with a certain amount of points that will allow you to win the game so in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules we tell you what we do like what we don't like then we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not all the sky is worth your time and bother was it five six years after it was first released in 2016 15 16. so remember if you knew it and please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below and we'll see you after this bollocks so oh of sky how to play this game so either sky is a relatively simple tile loading game everyone's going to get a player screen everyone's going to get a landscape tile with a castle on it you can put it in front of you everyone gets a score token and a discard marker that you're going to put

behind your screen right you'll stick all the remaining landscape tiles into a bag and then off you go so all the sky is divided into six rounds and each round is divided into six phases the first phase is your income phase gonna get five coins for just having a castle so everyone's gonna get one of them right unless you decide to blow your cars up which you can't do in this game by the way i'm just making that and you'll get one gold for each barrel of whiskey that is linked back to your castle by a road that isn't broken up right the next thing you'll do is you will internal of course you will draw three tiles from the bag and you'll put them in front of your player screen and what you'll do behind your player screen you'll set your discard marker your little axe thing to one of the tiles and this is a title you're going to discard and then you'll place a minimum of one coin behind each tile behind the screen right so your opponents can't see the amount of gold that you'll put behind each tile once you've done that you will then reveal your tiles and your money and you'll discard the tile that you place the axe token on right then beginning with the start player each player will have an opportunity to buy one of their opponent's tiles what you do you look at the amount of gold they put behind it and you'll pay that amount of gold to them and that player will then be able to retrieve the amount of gold that they put on that tile right if you don't want to or can't buy a tile because you ain't gonna money or you're just a boring bastard then you will pass and you won't be able to take part in any other further purchases this round so once all the players have bought tile or passed then you will gain

any tiles that you have left over in front of you are the ones that you put out but you'll lose all the money that you put behind them right so if you decided to go cheap and you just put a one there it's not gonna cost you very much but if you decided to maybe push the players off we'll try and gain some money by making it expensive you're gonna end up paying through the nose for that one yeah next thing you're going to do you're going to build you're going to use the tiles and place them into your little landscape kingdom thing you've got to make sure that each tile is placed adjacent to another tile that doesn't mean you can do it diagonally i know some of you want to do it diagonally but you can't do that you've got to make sure that the landscapes match the water sky against water pasture pasture mountains mountains all that sort crap right so once everyone's done that then you will do a bit of final round scoring at the beginning of the game you will have put out different tokens onto the main board and these will tell you how you will score each round you'll see you've got a b c or d or maybe multiple types of scoring on the main board and you will then go through each of these in alphabetical order right so you might have the good old sheep you'll get one victory point for each sheep that you got in your clan territory you might get one victory point for each completed area in the clan territory and this is a little bit unclear but right i know there's a little section referring to it but a complete territory is a type of terrain is enclosed so you might have maybe two sea tiles that connect together and create a little enclave of sea stuff you might get three victory points for each water area in the clan territory with at least one ship and one adjacent lighthouse or you might get two victory points for each cattle that is connected to the castle via road so it might be

the case you're gonna be scoring maybe one of these in the early stages as you get further into the game you're gonna be scoring maybe three of these right so keep doing this you'll keep working your way through all the rounds you end up with six rounds and then when you come to the sixth round at the end of six round then you'll do a bit of end game scoring you'll look at any scrolls that you have and you'll get victory points dependent on each scroll so you might get one with your point for every two sheep you might get one butcher point for each cattle you might get one victory point for every two ships or you might get one feature point for each lighthouse if the scroll that you're looking at is in a completed area like we talked about earlier then you'll double the victory points that it's going to give you you'll then top up any gold that you've got left over you'll get one feature point for every five gold and then the player with the most points after that will be the winner of isle of skye so what do we like about isle of skye thing that we really like about this one is the artwork it's made by lookout games and it's got this sort of continuation of the style of artwork that we've come to love so much from lookout games you know that sort of lahav agricola sort of style thing is prevalent here and we do really like that about this game there's loads of detail on the tiles they're colorful and generally speaking it is a good looking game right so the second thing that we really like about our sky is the concealed not bidding is it but we're going to say bidding anyway because i can't be bothered to think of an alternative word right you're left with quite a good choice in you it's one of do i try and tempt the other players

to take the tolls that i don't want by offering them cheap or do i try and put them off from buying the tiles that i want by making them expensive but the thing is if you do the latter then you're going to end up making it more expensive for yourself and you're not going to have as much money in the next round to buy the tiles that your opponents are going to be trying to tempt you with by either making them cheap or making expensive essentially having the same type of dilemma yet that is a really really good choice when you're talking about the mechanics that make this game so tasty so the next thing that we like about of sky is the mixed end around scoring makes this game really quite exciting because such is the case with some of these types of games that you're going to score maybe the sheep at the beginning and then you won't score the sheep for the rest of the game right in this game those pesky sheep come back to haunt you or not they might give you better victory points if you're going to concentrate on because you know they're going to be coming back so the fact that you start off with one scoring criteria and then you end up scoring more and more not in every round but more and more different types of scoring means that not only can you double down on maybe sheep or cattle but you can also change your strategy halfway through the game if those tiles that you want don't come your way and that is super duper so what don't we like about isle of skye so the first thing that we don't like about the sky is that some of the scoring tiles are a little bit

too ambiguous i mean we had trouble figuring out what they meant by completed areas there is a little section in the rulebook a little diagram that mentions completed areas but that is on a separate page to the actual portion of the rules that mentioned completely there as well so it's a little bit confusing there's other ambiguous terms in this game like when you talk about ships and adjacent lighthouses is that lighthouses are adjacent on other tiles or is that lighthouses that are actually within that completed area it's a little bit unclear you have to go onto the internet and consult the oracle to get a definitive answer that is a little bit frustrating but obviously once you know what the game is actually on about then it doesn't become a problem does it well maybe it does maybe you're just being a difficult bastard so the second thing that we don't like about this one is it's very very difficult to see what's on your opponent's tiles if you're sitting on the opposite side of the table you're gonna have to sort of maybe get up and peer over and maybe it's difficult if you've got a poor eyesight like me to see if that is actually a sheep or a cow because i don't know what the difference is between the two things you know so yeah it is a bit of a pain in the neck especially if there's a bit of a distance between you and the people you hate so to summarize is all the sky still worth your time and bother today and in the future so we're going to say yes absolutely this is without doubt one of the best toll lane games that we have played in a very long time it is aesthetically charming and it does offer a good variety of scoring opportunities

and strategic options at the end of the day it doesn't have the same sprawling impact of games like carcassonne because you are constructing your own little microcosm and maybe a variant or something where you're going to be building like a communal town or a communal landscape in the centre of ball or something like that may have made this game just a little bit more expansive i haven't said that if you are looking for a tile lane game that does offer a little bit more strategic depth than games like carcassonne and it sort of feels a little bit like a big box game in a medium-sized box then all the sky may be the game for you so that's all the sky remember if you're new here then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below and we'll see you next tuesday

you

Progress saved