Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Pet Peeves in Board Games - #10-6

Transcript 50:15

Hey, what's up? This is Ryan from How I Roll, and I am joined by my good friend David from Neon Gorilla. How you doing, David?

I'm awesome. Thanks for having me.

Oh, yeah. Well, thanks for joining in. Uh, today we're doing our top 10 pet peeves in board games countdown. Are you ready to be a little cynical, David?

I am ready to be a little cynical, and I can't wait to hear what cynical sounds like in a Canadian accent.

Oh, yeah. Well, anyways, for those of you watching, we're doing this top 10 list and we're doing it uh split between How I Roll and Neon Gorilla. So, right now you are watching 10 through six on Neon Gorilla. Uh and then if you want to watch, hopefully you do want to watch five through one. Uh that'll be over on my channel, How I Roll. So, uh it is funny you say cynical in a Canadian accent because I'll probably be saying sorry the whole time anytime I say anything, but

I'll try to do the same

for people.

Yeah. Yeah, for people who watch my channel, uh they'll know that I'm not um I'm a pretty positive like not not that's better or worse. Some people love to trample on board games. I'm a pretty like hey uh I love this game. This game's great. This is what I love about this game. So, this is a bit of a different vibe, but I think we all have things that drive us crazy in board games. And uh today you and I get to count down our top 10. And hopefully people can resonate with those. So,

beautiful.

Um I will say just a couple uh quick disclaimers. One is that this is pet peeves mostly about unless you did your list differently. Hopefully we're all kind of on the same page. These are top 10 uh pet peeves about mostly about board game designs, publishing kind of the the game itself. Not I don't want to know the top 10 people you don't like playing board games with or like you had to get rid of Ryan. I'm just kidding.

Um that also this list is interestingly like all top 10 lists are very subjective. This one is like wildly subjective because different people like different things in board games and design and stuff like that. I also two more quick disclaimers is one I'm probably not going to like mention which games some of these relate to for the most part. Some some I might, some I may not. Um, largely that's because some of these things are a huge pet peeve of mine. Um, I don't know. It was like when you're making your list, David, but I was like this is a huge pet peeve of mine, but it's like happens in games that I really love. So, it's not, oh, this writes off the game. It's just a thing that I would slightly tweak in some games um and stuff like that. And uh I had one more disclaimer, but um I forget what it is. So, if I think of it later, I will uh I'll bring it up. So, anyways, are you ready to count down our or do you have any disclaimers? Anything you need to say off the top end? Are you ready to just dive into this?

No, I'm ready. I'm ready to roll. No disclaimers on my end. I'm not trying to be Canadian nice.

Yeah, that's true. I got to like I got to like couch it with

Stop apologizing for it.

I'm sorry everybody. Um anyways, our top 10 t pet peeves in board games are countdown. I'm going to roll. I have this fancy uh custom die from the Game Boy Geek that he had sent me, which is pretty sweet. I don't know if you can see his logo.

Oh, that is cool.

Um so anyways, I'm going to roll this. Uh David, do you want lows or highs?

Uh let's go highs.

Highs. Four through six. You're first on the list. It is a four. So, you're going to be first every single time. So, why don't you hit us number 10?

All right. I will set the stage here at number 10. This one's It's number 10 for a reason. It I I almost feel bad like complaining about this, but it's not enough bags in the box. This has nothing to do with design and this is probably the least of my worries, but I just don't understand when we don't get enough bags to to at least like if you're not going to give me an insert, at least give me the right number of bags to put the components in the proper storage so I can try to get this thing um you know, on the table as easy as possible. My wife always blames me because I don't keep the bags because there's plenty of other games that give you too many bags. I just always throw them away and I should probably keep them. So, this is actually kind of a problem with me, you know. I don't know.

Do you have that problem?

Oh, yeah. Uh, and some some of this list is I I think there are a few times where storage or inserts or types of things are going to come up on this list. Maybe a foreshadow, but I I actually go to the dollar store and I buy like a pile of smaller bags cuz not only not enough bags, but when it's like, and again, I'm a board game content creator. I'm not a publisher, so I don't know how it all goes. So, some publishers or manufacturing people will watch this top 10 list and be like, "You morons, you have no idea how the real world looks." But

all that aside, not only like two not enough bags, but like sometimes when it's like bags this big for like small like weird shaped bags like just a random they're like ah we got like eight of these bags throw them in. You're like this isn't enough or it's like a weird amount or Yeah. So I definitely feel your pain on that one.

No, that is that's actually a really good point because it's not just the number of bags. It's the right configuration because yes I you know some of them are really thoughtful. You're like, "Oh my gosh, this just happened to work out perfectly. I have all my player pieces in a bag that fits everything." And then there's others just like, "You gave me a freezer ziplockc bag and you want me to throw it all together." Like, relax. I know. Like whenever I get a bag that's like this big in a game, I'm like, "Oh, what?" like that's obviously going to be for my kids lunches and not like actually usually when I get a game and it has they've just done the one size of bag like 10 of them in a bag.

I usually take that I put it with my stock of bags and then I pull up my own bags and bag the stuff because you know you often want like you got a few things that go in a small bag, some things in a medium bag, you know, stuff like that. Um I like I like my games to be packed up nicely when I'm done playing. I care about them.

Do you like bags? Do I like bags? Oh, yeah.

Just in general.

In general, I don't know. I I do think like you mean for storing games or do I just like have like a

Yeah,

I I do like them. Actually, a a while ago, years ago, I got into the habit of I had a friend who like made printed labels and put a label on each bag, like yellow components and stuff. I started doing that, but it was it was too much

too much time. I would I would rather have those like bits trays and stuff like that, but I just can't afford to upgrade all my games like that. So,

yeah, I hear you.

Like, if I bought bits trays for all my games, it'd probably be like $5,000. I don't know.

I actually started doing that as well very early on, like just like I started sle it, but it that goes away pretty quickly once you get into a board game collection of the hundreds. So,

yeah. Well, and also like you know, man, we got to get we got to keep moving this list. But as like content creators when you're getting sent games and the question is, am I just reviewing this doing how to play? Am I actually going to keep this game? Like, you know, it's not like every game is a game that you've purchased because you're like, "Oh, I really love this game and I want to like add it to my collection and stuff like that." So, it's the question is like at what point you sleeve it or whatever. So,

that's a whole other episode.

Yeah. Okay. My that was a great that was a great kickoff.

Oh, love it.

Not enough bags. Weird bags.

Um when you asked if I like bags at first I thought maybe I was saying bag like in a weird Canadian accent and so I was like are you making fun of me?

Um okay. So my number 10 is and this is um I often say this is my least favorite mechanism in games and this is wildly subjective but I'm going to say tons of text on cards. So, and what I mean by that now, anybody who's into Magic the Gathering who's watching this is like just about to click away and close the video cuz they're like, "That's what we live for is lots of text on cards." I just feel like personally, you know, when you got this cool game and all the stuff's going on and then every single card you get, you have to. Now, there are some exceptions. if it's like a story driven card or like a story driven game where there are bits of stories and stuff like that. But when each game card has like a paragraph of text you need to read to know how it works and especially so my first real time playing Magic the Gathering was I played five player commander. So if I don't know are you an MTG player? Have you ever been into MTG?

When I was a kid and I didn't know how to play it and I went to the card store and bought 20 fireballs thinking I could just create a fireball and mana deck. But yeah, I I eventually learned the rules. So yeah,

I I don't really play that much, but my first time really playing with five player commander. So not only do I have to read all the text on these like millions of cards I have, but I'm supposed to try to like read the text on everybody else's cards and they're all like, you know, not oriented toward me or whatever. But in general, I just feel like in a lot of games there could be less text on cards and better iconography. So you can just see it, you could know what it is, you don't have to spend all your time like going back and forth and like reading all the nuance on cards and stuff like that. So, that's very subjective, very personal, but uh tons of text on cards to me, not only do I not enjoy it, but also feels like it makes the game a little bit less accessible if there's a way to just make it simpler for everybody. So, yeah,

I So, you and my wife are right there. In fact, if there's a card market that's too far away from her with a lot of text on cards, depending on the game, she can just ignore that those those cards completely like that will turn her off immediately if she has to sit there and read cards. I think it's a double-edged sword. I have something else to say, but now it's it you just like triggered my first honorable mention. So maybe I'll stop there other than to say

I sort of agree with you but there's something else that comes uh that I will foreshadow that comes in lie of a bunch of words that I also dislike. So maybe I'll stop there and we can move to the next.

Yeah for people watching you're like should I keep watching this video now we're going to do honorable mentions right before number one. So finish watching this head over to how I roll and check those out. So that was number 10. Okay so why don't you hit us off with what's your number nine? This is another one where it's like I think you mentioned in your disclaimer so I guess it's sort of a disclaimer with me. This happens in some games that I absolutely love. This also happens in some games and it's a symptom of what I think is a really big problem and it's high point totals. I love when there is a game that has a very specific number of points that you have to hit and the lower the better. doing Imperium. I'm not, you know, comes comes to mind. But when there's a really high point totals, it's like it's trying to throw a ton of dopamine at you, but you just get so much that you're just like desensitized.

And um you know, a lot of people and you know, I I have to mention a game here. Sorry, but Earth, a lot of people love Earth. I felt like everything nothing felt special because everything was special and you got so many points and you got so much stuff and it was just overloading you. Um you know it it just it it cheapens the experience for me. Uh so I don't know what do you think about high point totals?

Well here's my question for you. So actually I have two questions. The first one is so do you prefer watching soccer to basketball?

Um no.

Do you watch sports?

You know I do. Yeah. Yeah. I'm a That's like that's a lot of people's criticism against basketball is they're like, "Oh man, like 130 points, who cares?" You know, whatever. Um, but here's here's my question for you. So, let's take Earth as an example. Uh, cool game, cool system, but I hear what you're saying. It's like a billion points everywhere. Is it more that there are so many points you can get everywhere, or would you Is it that it's so many points? Like, what if those objective cards in the middle were one point? Um, and like, you know what I mean? like if it you could still get the points in all the same places. It was still point salady, but the like the amount was like less. So, do you know what I mean?

Yeah. No, that's a really good push back. And it probably is less about points, but it's more about not feeling smart or special because everything is a combo. Everything is is uh trying to make you feel smart and in the end, I don't feel smart. I don't feel like there was a um you know, a really great hook. People that play Earth all the time will say I'm a complete idiot and I am. I did not play Earth enough to understand the nuances. It's just, you know, a fun pet peeve I'd throw out there.

I love it. That's actually a really cool pet peeve. I'm really interested to see if we have any crossovers on this list. I'm

I'm going to throw a prediction at like three real crossovers, but we'll see.

Okay. Yeah, let's see.

This this kind of Yeah, I think I think what you're saying is really interesting. I think I've I've played a lot of point so I hear you talking about that. Sounds like you probably really like arcs and root and stuff like that because those are like a close

I do for totally different reasons, but yeah, I do. I do.

Yeah. Um, so I played Fortunes of Scoundrel Bay a bit ago. I actually love that game. It was on my top 10 list of 2025, but it was like the score I was just playing with a friend. It was like I think I it the score was like 530 to 275 or something like that. So, not only did someone get destroyed, but it was like insane amount of points or whatever. So the point spread was quite wild. But I kind of like point salad, but I do feel sometimes when so I remember years ago I was in um we were traveling around a couple countries in southern Africa and there was one of them I think it was Zambia where they had hit such bad inflation that they just divided their money by a thousand. So instead of it being 5,000 whatever I forget what the currency was it was now five. Uh because there's like we So I do sometimes wonder if some games need to do that where they could still have as many outlets for points but just be like hey doing this thing is worth one point or three points instead of like oh it's worth 27 points and then you're getting that from a bunch of places. It doesn't this probably doesn't bo this thing probably doesn't bother me as much as you cuz I live for point salads but um

so points are fine. I just played voinage puzzle as an example. Brilliant design. I don't know if you've played voinage puzzle or not. It is. It is kind of point salady comboastic. Lots of kind of interconnected things. I love that. I love that filling out that that puzzle. But, you know, it is

I think the other point that you brought up is the higher the points, the higher possible spread that can happen. And that is another kind of feel bad. you know, you like to have those those games where you're not like, you know, oh, I'm 40 points ahead and there's no way that they're going to win rather than, you know, it might be a similar spread being four points ahead in uh Dune Imperium, but it feels more attainable. So,

yeah, that's cool. Great. Number nine. My number nine is garbage spin-offs. Um, so what I mean is, you know, a game and we could include expansions in this as well. Um, so what I mean is they make a game and all a sudden there's some su success. So like, oh, let's make a dice version. Let's make a this version. Let's make this spin-off. Let's make this expansion or whatever. Um, expansions are often a little bit less problematic, but like let's make the and and they just push it out to get it out and it's like it's terrible. And I find that actually with a lot of dice versions of games where it's just like, okay, you kind of took the art or the skin of the game and you made a game that no one would ever buy, but it just has like the theme or the IP of that game. So, what I'll actually say is um I don't play Seven Wonders a lot, but I think Seven Wonders I'll say I'm doing this as like a positive example, actually did a great job of this. Last year at Origins, I played Seven Wonders Dice, and I went into it expecting like, okay, we're going to roll dice. It's going to have some of the Seven Wonders icons on it. Like, whatever. And Seven Wonders Dice is awesome. Like, it's honestly, if it Seven Wonders came out right now, I might choose Seven Wonders Dice over Seven Wonders. It's impossible to say that objectively, but

Dice is fun. So,

it was awesome. Seven Wonders Duel. So, they made really good spin-offs and I know everybody's making dual versions of games and stuff like that nowadays and they are getting better because I think people are learn but there are some spin-offs or dual versions or dice versions stuff like that that I just think are not real games but they're like we need to put something out with this with this theme or this in this intellectual property and um I just I don't like it when it's especially when it's a an IP that I like and then they make a they make a lame game out of it. So,

well, there's some of them where I'm like, why is there even a duel that plays great at two? I can't think of one off the top of my head, but there's it's I really question like what what what's the duel part? I I played actually White Castle. I played White Castle. Great game. Played it only at two. Why is there a White Castle duel? Someone will say, well, you need to play it. It's great. Whatever. But it's just a question I have. Um

I Yeah, I feel the same way. Like I have Yokohama Duel and Yokohama's fine at two. Yeah. No, Yokohama Duel is a good game, so that's fine. Um, but yeah, I do kind of sometimes wonder about those dual versions. Um, they they just made um Citadel's Duel. Have you heard about this?

No.

You know, do you know what Citadels is?

I know what it is. I have never played Citadels.

Oh, it's like you it can't can't play it too. It's like it really it's good at like five plus. So, um I'm really curious about it. But yeah, I hear what you're saying. I mean, as long as it's a good game, I don't as much mind that they make a dual version. But it is a good question why it's like I guess I guess there are a lot of people out there who just only like playing two players when it's specifically a two-player game, whereas I'm someone who's always appreciated playing any game with a good two-player setup. Like White Castle's a great example. So, I haven't played White Castle Duel, but White Castle at 2 is fantastic already. So,

yeah. Well, I will say uh what do you think about the spin-off that has nothing to do with the base game? I don't know if you've played Flamecraft Duel. Have you played this?

I haven't played that. Um I love it.

When you say it has nothing to do with it, do you just mean like like it has the artwork, but it's just like its own game?

It has the artwork. It's very loosely associated. It's a tile laying game in this particular instance. It is a duel. It very much feels like you're going back and forth. the one common theme. Have you played Flamecraft?

Yep.

Yeah. So, you fire up dragons by placing these tokens. That's like the one common denominator. Other than that, has nothing to do with Flamecraft other than the art.

You know what? I as long as it's a good game and it lives in that world and it kind of makes sense, I'm fine with that. So, at Dice Tower West, um Johnny PAC, who designed Unconscious Mind and Colona and stuff like that, he showed us his new uh upcoming edition of Colosseum, which I think is already crowdfunded.

Yeah.

And then the next day, he brought out this small game called Imprasario, which is just like a side game, but it's not like trying to be Coliseum. It just has similar artwork, similar icons, kind of in that world and stuff like that. I thought it was nice. It was kind of like, well, if you enjoyed Colosseum, this has nothing to do with it, but it's kind of like a nice like collection add-on piece or whatever. So, so I don't mind I don't mind that at all. I just I just often feel like a company is like, "Oh, our game popped. Let's make spin-offs or things like that." And and that can apply to expansions, too. and they do they make something that's not good and it's like well I wish you would have just made a totally different game that was good or something like that. So anyways, garbage spin-offs. My number nine.

Beautiful.

Number eight. Hit us with number eight.

All right, my number eight is no or inferior player aids. This drives me insane. I will say positive Galactic Cruise has one of the absolute best player aids I've ever seen the entire for a relatively complicated game. The entire game is in a couple pages and I don't mind a player aid being in a couple pages. I don't want one rule book that we both have to thumb through, especially when there is like um you know card definitions or like icons. It drives me insane. Even more so, not having the icons on the back page, so we can't just easily pass that back and forth. A good, well thoughtout player aid makes all the difference in the world. And not only does it just help me in the game, it helps me get back to your game. So, a few months down the road, I've forgotten everything. I don't know about you, you teach games, I don't, but I I uh uh I constantly am forgetting games. I can basically keep two or three in my head at one time. And that player aid is such an important part of me being able to get it back off the shelf with confidence and playing again as soon as possible. So, a good player aid is a must. No player aid is inexcusable.

Yeah. Um I mean there are probably some games that don't warrant a player aid because they're like small, but you mean like any kind of real game or whatever.

Yeah. Yeah. I think um Yes. Yeah. I guess that would be there there is a caveat there.

I I thought about putting something like this on my list. I didn't I didn't quite put it. Um I so agree. And it's funny. I actually had Galactic Cruise on this table last night. I was filming something about their two expansions. Um and actually right at the end I realized I had put the agenda cards on the discard pile in the shots. It doesn't probably doesn't matter. I don't think Well, the odd person might notice. And I've had people comment like, "Oh, that was whatever." But

they will now. They're gonna go find that video. Even I love teaching games and I still like you know you can make and so in a complex save like that having a player raid like that is uh so good. So Galactic Cruise I mean they pretty much in my opinion are the antithesis of this pet peeve list for me. like the way they designed the whole game, produced it. Um, like just there's so many things on his pet peeve list that they did the opposite of, you know, that it's just like they nailed it. Their rule book I was looking at last night, I was just be remembering with that index at the back, the way it's laid out, those plays. And especially as someone who teaches board games both on the internet but also in person, I actually love games with player aids like that because usually what I do is I give people the player aid and then I teach them out of the player aid because then I'm like then they're they have an anchor point for that. They're coming back to this and they're saying

point.

Yeah. They they use it like this is the reference point. I'm teaching them how to access that. So a play like that. Lisboa has a fantastic one as well, which Lisboa and Galactic Cruise are like essentially like kind of the same game to me, same artist and stuff like that. But um yeah, bad I I think no play raids doesn't make sense in a game like that. A bad play rate to me is almost worse because it's like

true.

It's like what? Like Yeah. Well, an incomplete one where I still have to go in to the rule book. I'm playing a game right now which I won't mention which I love by the way, but I still have to go in the playbook in the in the uh rule book to get basic definitions on icons. It's like why aren't all the icons here?

Just so you know, you are allowed to name games. Um I just uh I'm just saying that I might not as much but that's okay as but um but yeah, it is it's true. It's just like do a good player and especially nowadays where there are people you can consult with. There's chat GPT. Like there are so many ways to do this, you know, and you can throw it out in groups online and get some feedback and stuff like that. So that is a great uh that was a great number eight. Um

hold on real quick before you go forward.

You said almost everything Galactic Cruise does. I'm going to tease your video right now. Number five is a huge pet peeve I have and it started with Galactic Cruise. So, go watch that video after this.

Oh, man. I can't wait. Okay. Uh, number five, uh, Galactic Cruise. Okay, we'll see.

Yeah.

Uh, okay. My number eight is weird box sizes and shapes. Now,

I could caveat this by saying

that doesn't mean unique. It just to me means weird. So, what I mean is that by that is a box that's like, you know, when you open a bag of chips and it's just like, why is there so much empty space in this? Um, so a box that's way too big, one that's too small for the expansion that's coming up. Now, some some games like Clans of Calonia, um, actually I think Karma Games, uh, is doing so many production things so well. Um, but Karma Clans of Calonia came out like 9 years ago or something. there wasn't an expansion planned or nowadays a lot of games they already have the expansion built created designed like in Galactic Cruise the expansion the first two expansions are in the rule book so Clans of Calonia had this really small box everything fit in but I didn't mind it because it fit in it and it's not like two months later they put an expansion like it can't fit and in fact when they did put out the expansion like eight years later the expansion came in a bigger box so you could move everything from the main box into the expansion box and stuff like that so I thought that was cool but so what I'm talking about. And I'll actually name a game right now. Heroes of Land Air and Sea. I like Heroes of Land Air and Sea.

That's a fun game. I think that the designers that the the people who produced it, and again, whoever manufactured or publisher might end up watching this video and be like, "Ryan, you don't understand how the real world works." And I I agree. I there's a lot I don't know. But what I do know is that my like me, many board game collectors have cal shelves that fit a very specific size of box. And when your box is half an inch too big in every dimension to fit in a calic shelf, like it's one thing like my Dominion big box, sure it's way too big. It can't fit in there. That's fine. It has a reason, but there's no way they couldn't have shrunk that by half an inch so that it could fit in a cal shelf. Um, so it could just be part of my collection. Um, yeah. So basically boxes that are too just like these weird shapes that don't match. Oh, and another thing I'll say about this is um so Garfield, they have those really small boxes and it's cool because it's a style and a system that they like. And in fact, now that they started making some of those big boxes, I'm like, I don't like this. I like there's their thing. And their rule books and their boards fit those boxes perfectly. Some publishers make that same size of board, but with a box this big. And so your board's just kind of like in there and the rule books are weird. So, your box to board to rulebook ratio, the size, what's going to come up. Um, if you've made a small box and you know there's an expansion coming up that won't fit in it. Um, those kinds of things. I just think like you can have a box size that

makes sense for the game that you have can fit stuff. So, actually I will name one more game because I also love this game. Uh, Darwin's Journey. I really like it. I be mostly for space but for a few other reasons. I usually like to combine my expansions into the main game box. And some people might think that's heresy.

Darwin's Journey is this kind of small box is kind of nice, but it's just a slightly too small to fit the expansion with its board. So, I have to keep both boxes out. I just wish they would have given me like this much more space just to put the board in there and I would have been really a little bit happier with that. But, it is a great game and it it's good enough that I have both boxes on my on my shelf. But anyways, that's me. These weird box sizes and shapes. And you would disagree with

No, I agree with you. I wonder how many I wonder if this is just a problem with people that are just so insanely into the hobby because I agree, especially when a publisher changes the size of their boxes like that kind because I want to keep them all together. you know, I want to I want to create a beautiful um you know, arrangement for you, publisher, but if all of a sudden um I'm a big fan of bad comment, all of a sudden my shallow seas box is completely different from my wondrous creatures box is completely different from um oh, what's the one? Life of Amazonia. How do I display that?

First world problems. But I agree with you. And there's a there's a certain box here. Hold on. Not only are we naming names, we're uh showing games.

Sweet lands here. It's long and skinny. And to your point, to get this in a call, I have to back put it through the back. I have to pull the calllex away from my wall to actually fit this in. That's why it's on a chair right behind me. So, perfect. Well, so and some boxes kind of need to be longer like um uh shoot, what was I just thinking of? Like so eclipse like I mean it's just going to be a big box one way or the other. So long as probably makes sense, but that one that one makes me think of a Concordia like what's going on with the Concordia.

Very similar.

Very similar. Yeah,

you could put that in a normal size box that would work well with the rest of my collection uh and stuff like that. And so I actually did talk to a publisher last year where he said he was talking about this and he said they brought this game that they're re-releasing um like it was from some other country and they're going to do it but the box he wanted to shrink the box and the manufacturer and the original no no because we got to redo this. And he's like we are resizing the box so it fits in a Callex shelf. And he said like he was adamant. He's like there's no way we're not doing that. And I was like, "Yeah, like that's obviously your main market sector, right?" And so, um, I Yeah. Anyways, I thought that was really cool. So, weird box sizes and shapes. That's my uh that's my number eight. So, David, we only have two left on this half. And, uh, just a reminder everybody, this half is living here on Neon Gorilla. The other half, which is linked in the description below, uh, five through one will be on my channel, How I Roll. So, hit us with your number seven. This one just came up in an interview I did. Um, and it's I'm passionate about this and sometimes as a creator it's a necessary evil, but it drives me insane. And it's nonnative solo modes or Ottomas are are another um example of this specifically, especially in games that just aren't meant to be play solo. Um, a lot of um a lot of Euros will have this. I don't mind a solo Euro Legacy of You. Absolutely

love. I think it's one of the best uh European uh style games with as a solo experience. And I don't mind solo games. I play play plenty of solo games, but they are native solo or co-op in some cases, but in general, if I have an algorithm to run, I'm not doing it. Unless I absolutely have to, I am just not doing it. I love Nucleium. My wife didn't want to play Nucleium. We played it once, she hated it, and I really wanted to cover it. So, I played had to play it a bunch of times with the Ottoa, and I don't know how I got through that. That was one of the toughest times in my life. Not really, but it was one of my toughest times in my board game life. What do you think about Ottoa? So,

you non-native solo, you mean like here's a game, here's a solo mode?

Yes.

As opposed to like, hey, here's Pillars of Or um not sorry, Pillar uh Hercules and the 12 Labors by Envyorn. That's just a oneplayer game you were talking about.

Yeah,

those are fine. Those are fine. It's becomes fiddly, right? Because you're having to create intelligence in an algorithm. I want to think about my game. I just want to think about what I have to do, not about this laundry list of things that the Ottoa is going to have to do next.

Yeah. You know, to be honest, I just really I' I've often wanted to do more solo gaming. Like I love Descent. I have Descent, the new one, Legends of the Dark, and I love that system and I've just thought I should just play it on my own or whatever. Um, back in the day, I used to tour in a band and we'd play disc golf every day on tour and we love I fell in love.

Yeah, I fell in love with the sport. One time between tours, we're back home and I was like, I'm going to go disc golfing. So, I found a course and I went disc golfing and I didn't have very much fun. Like, it was fine, but I was like, uh, I don't really care. And I realized I mostly, and this isn't to knock on solo gamers, I mostly actually wasn't as quite as invested in disc golf as I thought I was, but I was more invested in disc golfing with Bros. Um, I say bros cuz they're only dudes in our band, but it was not a gender exclusive sport, but um it's kind of like I I just feel like I have a hard time playing solo games. So I Anyways, this is a really long- winded way of saying I don't know if I have as much of an opinion on that. I know I've I've gone on TTS and soloed through Ark Nova, but I just don't find myself doing well with solo games uh regardless of how they are. But I do hear what you're saying like you're taking a it's even the same when you play a two-player game that hasn't managed.

Exactly.

Where it's like one thing if it's like I'm trying to think of a good example. Okay, so in Trachurion, you just fill it, you blank some spaces out. Or Zulkan, you just put some workers in at the start of the game, and that's fine. Good two-player variant. And I actually like in the newer Trachurion expansion where those players move from like all you have to do is flip a card, move a couple guys, you're good to go. But I played um I played a game a bit ago uh by from a publisher I love, and it was just like the two-player maintenance was like clunky, non-intuitive, and just like work. And I think that's what I would imagine playing a lot of solo modes would feel like for me where I have to like manage this like you said algorithm like manage this system. It's like hey quickly go solve a Rubik's cube and do a back flip between turns and then come back kind of thing. It's like yeah not much appeal to me. So I haven't done a lot of solo gaming but I do think that I agree I probably agree with you from that perspective that it's like I'd rather just play a game that's built for the player count rather than like have to jimmy rig it to make it work. So

all right easy. Yeah, great. That's a that's a good one. Non-native. Yeah, if I was more of a solo gamer, that would probably be on my list. So, um, mine is insane imbalancing. Now, the word insane needs to be there because people always, you can always find someone complain about it's not balanced enough and stuff like that. And you know what? Like, I think so on an extreme, I agree with that. I I think like expecting a designer to get every single thing totally balanced between every little thing is like kind of insane, especially nowadays with how many games there are and stuff like that. Some companies do a great job of getting tons of play tests. That's just not really all that realistic. So, I totally live with the fact that things aren't perfectly balanced and that is what it is and it's all good and that's life. Um, but when it's just totally like, hey, did you guys even play this game with this faction against this faction? So, I think about um, Eclipse in their new expansion. They actually fixed some of this and they did it.

Stonem, he's like always updating stuff, which is cool. And I would say his stuff probably starts out more balanced in a lot of games anyways. But like Eclipse is a game that I love so much, but the first set of factions like alien races that came out with it, it was like I could give the one alien race to a complete noob and the other alien race to like a seasoned veteran and I would be like, the noob might win, you know, cuz it's like that's how out of whack it is. So when it's just like absurd to the point of like did you guys even really play test this or think this through? Um I just find that frustrating. And again, I think that's because when it hits close to home, it matters more. So, I love variable player powers. I love asymmetric powers and stuff like that. Um, we just played Root the other night, the new expansion, and it was like, it was a tight race through it. That felt good. But if it was like one player hit 30 and someone was at two points because there was no chance, I would be like, well, that's not fun whether I won or lost. So, yeah. What What are your thoughts on that?

I haven't come across too many balancing issues. I typically think that I'm the problem when I come when I when that happens, like I'm playing it wrong or or I did something wrong. The one thing that comes to mind is Gaia Project and there's just some factions that I would I just can't get to work. I just I just I just can't figure it out. I love Gaia Project, but then when I look up the faction and some like strategy guides, people love them. So that's kind of like makes me wonder, is it just an experience problem? Am I just not pulling the levers enough? Sometimes it can be is the game just not forgiving. So if you not aren't pulling the levers, it's not holding your hand through and just awarding some points to kind of keep you going. Um I just uh I don't know. Um so

yeah,

I don't have a ton of

projects. Kai project's an interesting one because I mean there's so many factions it'd be hard to know like how it'd be hard to play test it all. But I think the interesting guy project is it's almost impossible to speak on balance. I haven't noticed anything I found wildly imbalance. The thing is is that sometime so so many of the factions are situational. So in that starting placement if you're a faction that really needs to be close to people and no one builds by you or vice versa or people are making certain choices in the game, it can like tank or elevate your faction. And so that one's a really interesting one because it really is less like oh this one's like so strong and so OP

um you know so actually my um I had a friend we used to play the DC deck building game a lot together and that's I mean fundamentally a variable player powers deck builder game and and you know you have some things that are situational kind of like in guy project but some that were just kind of like okay if they have that hero and I have this hero I'm cooked like it's just

there's no coming back from this and that's more what I mean where it's just kind of like you can't win if you're this. I haven't I don't know if I've played every single Gaia Project faction including the expansion, but I played quite a few of them.

But I do know what you mean. There are some where it's like

I don't know if I'm as good at this or oh man, this setup is bad for this race or like whatever. Um but yeah, I just find there have been a few games where it's just so wildly out of whack that it's like uh I don't know. I I just find it frustrating. I just wish they had tweaked it a little bit better. So, if Jamie Stagmire can tweak his factions that aren't already like wildly out of whack to streamline a little bit more, I just feel like other companies could be like, "Okay enough to be like, okay, this one's way too OP or whatever." So,

that's great. All right, this is the last one for segment one, number six. This better be a good one because this is your grand finale on this one. If this one's not good, then uh

do you feel do you feel a little bit of insecurity talking about these pet peeves and being like

yeah,

I feel a little bit like what if people are like these are crazy or are there you're missing like ones? I don't know.

Especially this one. Um and it might be tainted by the game I noticed this with which wasn't a game I particularly enjoyed, but thin cardboard player boards drive me insane. I just can't understand, especially when I'm paying so much for a game. The I get you're trying to cut costs and I get shipping and all of that, but it's just not going to hold up. One wrong move, you bend that thing and it's it's done for good. And I am going to name a game since you gave me license and it's the most deluxified, beautiful experience. And it just drives me insane why there's such thin player boards. Can you think about this? Do you know what this is by any chance? I think I think you're gonna say terraforming Mars.

No, Andromeda's Edge.

I have the full deluxified. They they they like spared no expense. I have the minis, everything.

The thin terraforming Mars mats aren't with the delu, right? They're they're not with the deluxe version, right? Anyway, so that was a bad guess.

And this was maddening. And it and it and it just highlighted to me like who would ever do this? I mean, this is the most extreme example where I don't know, the the deluxe was like 150 bucks or something stupid, and you gave me the one thing that I'm messing around with the most that could just be creased and destroyed in it just one one accident. It just drives me insane. Um, why on earth? And it if it's super small box, you know, I paid less than 20 bucks for it, that's fine. But come on. If if I'm if I'm forking over some money, make sure the thing that I'm interacting with the most is at least sturdy. I'm not asking for dual layers, as much as I like them, just give me a normal, you know, with cardboard.

I agree so much. I This isn't on my list, but I kind of wish it was. Um I so I love player boards like which sounds like such a weird thing to say be when you're not in the hobby

like when I when we have company over I bring them into studio they're just like what is going on in here this is insane but um before you're in the hobby you know if someone's talking about oh these nice components are that like I I was telling people my deluxe food chain magnet that he's got from Lucky Duck some non- gamers and I'm like it's got like these really nice like components and they're just like you're insane,

right?

But once you start games as a hobby, you realize, oh, this matters. And I love player boards. I don't know what it is, but like anytime I open a game and it's like, oh, I've got a player board. Um, it's it's like it's cool. Like, I love it. And so then, yeah, I feel that disappoint when I open a game and it's like this flimsy piece of paper. Now, I don't want to pay $1,000 for every game.

No. But I ju I I agree that if you're already making a cardboard board uh and you're already making some other stuff and even if you need to skimp on something a little bit which I don't think you need but like it it'd probably only add a few bucks the MSRP um I mean if it's a $20 MSRP game like yeah any real game Andromeda's Edge like come on that's insane like you got all this cool stuff on it and then you come to your home base where you're doing everything you're working with everything and you got is like a piece of paper.

It feels closer to paper than it does cardboard and drives me insane. We

I'm going to show you something fun on that. Yeah.

No, you keep talking. I'll show you something fun.

What Ryan mentioned about loving player boards is so close to home and and actually gives me the idea that we need to do the top 10 things we love because have you played coming of age Danny Garcia by any chance?

No, I haven't. So, the player board, the whole idea is that you're kind of like growing up and, you know, expanding your your emotions and and and manipulating all kinds of fun stuff. I think it's a wonderful game, but it's a kid's head

and it's dual layered with the tracks in the head for the emotions. It's just this beautiful art piece to me that just gives me so much joy to play with it. So,

I'm uh just about to film a Kickstarter preview for um I don't know if you've heard of Roomies Games. They made the Children of Morta game.

They're actually Vancouver based, but it came that one came out with Lucky Duck. But

anyways, um I opened it and there are these like awesome dual layered player boards um with all these like square spots that you you can put cards into and stuff like that. And I'm just like, this is so satisfying.

Dual air gets me so excited.

Uh, yeah. Actually, I had thought about a follow-up to this being like top 10.

Um, and I was trying to think I I even talked to chat GPT about like what's what's a like pet peeves is such a nice alliteration and stuff like that.

Um, and I I can't remember came up with one that sounded perverted. Um, and then it came up with like one or two that were like

sex.

Uh, it it made one or two that were like it kind of makes sense, but it was like, you know, when you're kind of just like pushing it to a little bit too much or whatever. So,

um, I I can't remember who said, but like I I thought about even just like top 10 secret joys, like something where you open a game, you're like, "Oh, yes." Like that. Anyways,

well, if you can't come up with a good title, we shouldn't do the video, so we'll just scrap that.

That's true. So, um, it's funny you mentioned this because this is not actually what it is, but uh, so anyways, um, I'll show you the lid because this game isn't out yet, but this is Towers of SNOS from Garfield. Um, I'm a pretty big Garfield fan. I'll talk about them a fair amount. I got to do the how to play for this, but they're this I think they're only six copies on the planet. So, uh, the one they sent me to do the how to play video, it had this nice player board. Very nice. It's not dual layered or anything, but this is a nice player board where you get to put dice and stuff like that. But they're like, "It only came with one." So then they they literally printed uh just for my purposes. Like they just sent this with me, which obviously is not like there's actually like tape seam in the middle or whatever.

That's the Andromeda's Edge player board. That's two of them taped together.

They're like, "Please don't use this in the video." Which I'm like, I would never put that in my video. But um it's funny though because this is like obviously not great. It's kind of a cool unique copy because it's like early production. But um but some games actually give you this and it's like

this is uh yeah it's not good. So

and charge you good money. It's not like you know they're they're discount games.

Although that's not on my list. There's not a crossover coming up. That was a great one and I totally agree. My number six, the final one of this first half of the segment is what I call nuance overload. Um, now people love nowadays streamline simple games. I like complex games. I love complicated games. I love long difficult games. I als I also like short streamlined games. That's fine, too. But when when every single turn in order to do the chain of events, in order to do the thing, you have to reference the rule book to be like, okay, but in this situation,

it's like this factor comes in. if it's not like at least somewhat understandable or memorizable or like makes enough sense that a person could that you could condense it onto a nice play, which you should have um or something like that, then I'm not like, "Oh, this game's too complicated." I would just say your rule or your order of operations is too convoluted. Um it's too much nuance. It's too much that going on. And I think the complexity should come from the strategic thought and the game play, not from the mechanics of actually making sure that you followed this the correct steps and stuff like that. So I don't know how you feel about that.

I I totally agree. I think some of the best games that I've played are complex, but they don't have a lot of rules overhead. Like the complexity is in the midst of the dynamic design. it's not in an order of operations that I have to remember. And specifically, if I can't remember that order of operations for a step by the end of the game, the likeliness of me getting it back to the table is so incredibly low. And you do wonder, was there a better way to design this so all of this upkeep or steps didn't have to happen in the exact um order. So, yeah, I'm I'm all in on that one. Yeah, like rules that you can't teach and like so it's actually um I have Venos Deluxe which they have the old version and then the new version. I've only ever played the newer version, but from what I understand like the old version they just had this like pretty complex market system that people were just like this is the So I think what I'd say is I like playing games that are like complex but not complicated, right?

Like it's like if it's just an unnecessary hurdle in order to take an action. Um, like it's one thing to be like, hey, you need enough resources to do this. You need to take these steps. But if it's kind of like, well, you got to move this here, but if like the if it's like between 3 and 5:00, then you know, it's like if you had a burger in the last week, you can't like it's just kind of like, guys, like we I I don't mind games are so heavy that you're looking at player and rule books for certain things like the appendix, like here's what that is and stuff like that. Um, but if you're like constantly having to be like, I don't even know how to take the action because the action is so convoluted and nuanced. Uh, that's what that

frust said something important there which was like if there's a bunch of ifs, right? So, I think I if if there's a bunch of if statements, uh, a lot of conditional rules, that is the tough part because I'm not going to be thinking about all those conditions the whole time. If the decision space is broad, complex, interwoven, beautifully, you know, constructed, I love it. I break my brain all day long about my decisions, just not about how to run the game.

Totally 100%. Couldn't agree more. Well, we have done it. We've done 10 through six of our pet peeves. And uh I'm feeling riled up. I want to go burn some. No, I'm just kidding. I honestly actually this has like just made me like think about some games I really do love and appreciate and it's also actually made me think about some games that have some of these pet peeves where I'm like oh I do still really love that game even though it has one of my pet peeves in it. So um anyways thanks for counting this down people watching. This is Ryan from How I Roll. This is David from Neon Gorilla. The other video is live. You can click the link in the description to see number one through five to find out what's coming up. And David already foreshadowed that he's going to throw some

Yeah, there's a couple good ones coming. There's a a couple good ones coming. So, definitely go check that out.

I'm excited. Well, thanks so much, David. I'll see you in number five through one.

All right.

Progress saved