Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Game Sustainability with Sustainability Scientist Derric Pennington

Transcript 1:12:12

i think my mic has been muted um uh so yeah sorry i just realized my my mic was muted here so we're gonna restart uh i was locally muted yeah sorry about that guys um but uh so let me reintroduce uh derek is a lead scientist totally fumbled at the one yard line there uh he's a lead scientist uh at the university of minnesota um and uh used to work at the world wildlife fund derrick reached out to me a couple of about two years ago almost and uh please let me know in the chat if you can hear me now but uh and he is a board game sustainability engineer scientist type of guy and we talked for about an hour and a half a couple months ago on the phone so i'm super excited to have derek on long story short and uh and also marty we've decided is the uh the head squirrel so okay everybody can hear you need some title yeah it needs a title so uh derek has actually been in contact with uh a handful of uh board game publishers some big and some small i believe i we haven't actually talked in in a couple of months about where you're at yeah um but uh i figured the i'll let derek go let you go ahead and kind of introduce yourself and a little bit of the work that you've done in the research and then marty and i will probably interrupt you with questions and i will i'll kind of monitor the chat as well because i'm kind of a science dork so this gets that kind of stuff gets me

excited um and so i'll just let you get started and then we'll jump in we'll have a little falcon and winter soldier chat maybe at the end here but uh uh welcome to the channel derek and thanks for joining no thanks joel it's been you know this is like a dream come true i feel like i'm uh you know in the presence of greatness you know to uh through the titans in the industry in terms of uh i'm trying to lose weight at least you got the longevity that's been doing it for such a long time i've been a part of my uh you know uh education of board games and i think joel when i first reached out to you a couple years ago it was probably around a recommendation honestly around uh war cry and and and me getting ready to jump into warhammer and you've been pushing it so much uh recently then and uh how much you loved it and uh and so i could definitely say that the plastic in this room has increased over the past couple years probably directly related to you but it's been great but it but it definitely uh ties into the sustainability conversation in board gaming my my uh background is uh you know i did uh biology ecology uh graduate school and uh started you know doing uh work with wwf the world wildlife fund here based in washington dc and so i was a scientist there for seven years and i was a scientist working with wwf's private sector engagement team so i was one of the

few scientists working with others at wwf trying to engage big corporations and typically you know fortune 500 companies uh around you know improving the sustainability of the products they sell and and i got to see behind the cover or behind the scenes of how those decisions are made the different concerns that are are raised and so i left wwf a couple years ago uh and came i came back here to st paul minnesota uh with my family we we decided dc was a little too crazy uh to raise a family and uh and started to do that back here in st paul where my wife is from and uh i took on a research sciences position here at the u university of minnesota i'm in the department of applied economics and a fellow what's called the institute on the environment here but my job is kind of similar to what i was at wwf i still engage with similar actors in terms of corporations primarily around agricultural commodities and those supply chains and you know part of my my science thing is is to understand what are the future impacts of different sustainability options or alternatives and think about what are the multiple benefits you know whether it's improvements in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions or

improving the water quality outcomes of producing a particular item or a particular case corn or soybean or other commodity and so you know we do a lot of modeling in my lab and a lot of looking at future scenarios around different solutions how do we design those solutions to be the most effective in terms of the environment and with that economic edge we're also trying to think about how to do it in a cost effective way so it's been a lot of fun but by after engaging with coca-cola and pepsico and and and and you know targets you know i i started to look at this room i'm in which is a 10 by 12 game room it's pretty packed for probably about 300 games and and uh i started to think about that footprint and how i hadn't really looked at you know what's sustainability in this hobby and obviously there's a footprint in terms of the cardboard and the wood and the plastic and what are we doing as a hobby so that's why it kind of you know set me off looking at some of the uh you know reaching out on my own time to some of the board game publishers uh uh and got to talk to some folks at asthma day and europe that are and try to supply uh panda uh and uh let's see uh leader games okay and so i got to see you've got to have a few more conversations uh with what folks are doing but i would say that it's uh

you know sustainability around the environment is coming to our hobby um it's being driven by uh consumers you know and customers like ourselves but i think moreover by um you know our hobby moving into more mainstream uh distribution outlets or big box stores like walmart and target who are requiring uh those companies to do that and i and so anyway that that got me interested what's going on what's happening okay so that's interesting like a target for example might require a ticket to ride or some game that's coming in there to be have uh components and manufacturing processes that are sourced in you know kind of a quote-unquote green manner yeah a walmart and a target they they've you know this is where for the time but an ngo kind of comes over and puts a little bit of pressure on those large you know buyers like you know and and stores like a target that has a very consumer-facing entity and and start to say you know you need to be what are you doing around these issues right and both target and walmart have uh you know taken on a score card basically for uh those products coming you know that they're buying to sell on their store but it's a pretty high high level kind of cursory not necessarily what's the impact of your board game say on carbon or water or those kind of things

but but it's more like what do you have in process are you starting to think about uh assessments what are you doing to mitigate if you if you know you have these particular impacts but it's quite high level um but it is putting some pressure as you go into you know to sell in those markets uh kickstarter also uh just recently uh introduced a new policy that uh every kickstarter has to uh publish a environmental impact statement on their page so okay so that's something that yeah so if you're gonna do a kickstarter you have to do it you know you have to you know on your page uh your landing page have a you know a link to your environmental impact statement uh so panda games is getting a lot of requests from obviously board game publishers that want to have information around okay what elements of my board game in terms of the plastic the cardboard how do we address them one source plus a single source plastic that kind of thing that what they can put in the in the statement so those are two big drivers for our hobby anyway having kickstarter in those big box stores so you mentioned go ahead i was gonna say just just out of curiosity if you talk to the publishers and stuff i'm sure there's a lot of things that they can do uh to reduce their impact but what are some low-hanging fruits that you can suggest pretty much anybody say hey if you want to start somewhere this is probably the easiest thing you can do right off the bat um yeah i mean our hobby probably the the easiest thing would be the you know

reuse which we do a lot and i think um you know reusing our products you a lot of us probably can't remember the time that we threw away a board game uh but we may get tired of it and sell it to someone or give it to a relative so part of it you know reducing the waste uh you know that sort of end use of it and that's something that that gets pretty that's pretty manageable and i think our hobby is is kind of you know our culture kind of works that way our norms are you know we're kind of anti-throwawayers so i think there's a lot of reuse uh reuse um i think the opportunity to to try to repurpose you know some of these i mean i'm looking at i don't know my recent cloud spire and i of course i had to upgrade to these fancy chips so i got like these extra chests so what do i do with those and so uh you know trying to think of you know what a three-year-old can do with those chips or trying to find other uses for them um but i think as far as consumers i mean it is a consumer hobby you know it's the the the challenge between winning a deluxified edition which of course has the bigger footprint but it has all that you know kind of collectibility or what we you know want when we you know because these are things that we're keeping these are games we're keeping and treasuring um i think it's a customer consumer it's a it's a little difficult i think part of what our role might be is getting a little more comfortable uh with how the games are packaged maybe

our expectations uh around uh how a board game is packaged and what we receive um and and part of that is you know one of the biggest uh and it's probably because it's most visible is actually the shrink wrap on game so that's something that you know all of us have you know had that shrink wrap come off we think we threw it away and it shows up somewhere later down the line it's something that can't be recycled um and so there's a lot of you know energy to you know it's kind of like the cosmetics of uh fruit and pesticides you know the pesticides keep the fruit looking pretty keeps the shelf life and in a sense shrink wrap provides all those types of benefits to our board game box uh and the contents in it so there's you know i would say within the publishing community or within uh the manufacturing community single source plastics have been you know a big issue that they want to or single use plastics have been a really big issue in the pack in the components of board games or the packaging of board games that's what they see as a low-hanging fruit to it to address and so they're looking at you know uh what do they call them they're like the little uh wafer seals that you'll see on i know like horrified over here that and rossenberger does this a lot on there right prospero hall uh funkoverse when you buy them at target they'll have to not shrink they have the little so like panda's trying to look at you know these wafer seals and they're getting to the point where you know trying to understand are people

cutters are they coolers and if they're coolers they don't want their boxes there's a lot of uh some you know r d that has to be done um but it's also you know the expectation i guess i come back morty that our expectations in a sense uh with the deluxified and the fact that we're we are you know more and more moving towards you know all the games are sort of a premium product um you know compared to so back in the first days of katan so um there's a trade-off there uh that i think everybody's trying to figure out how to you know how can we have our cake and eat it too but um that's a challenge yeah well i know i know john you i just one last comment i know one thing that could be done hey a fantasy flight games get rid of that valley insert in all your games and you'll but everybody just throws away anyway no kidding no kidding i mean that's that's like half a joke but i mean i know you're serious but yeah i mean it's for sure nobody uses that thing um so before we there's a couple questions actually coming in the chat i want to circle back to one before we talk about materials a little bit more um you mentioned earlier that the ngo was putting pressure on like a target or a walmart can you explain what the ngo is oh sorry okay yeah a non-governmental organization okay so a non-for profit non-profit okay i see so uh yeah okay not profit special interest

groups you know uh okay that makes sense and then kind of a follow-up on that was what's your kind of experience about amazon you know if they do they have any kind of you know processes that they're trying to implement or at least to publicly have they acknowledge this kind of thing because i mean they sell everything as well as like a target or a walmart is that something that they get engaged with yeah i mean uh you know amazon just recently through their foundation gave something like you know 800 million dollars out maybe a billion dollars out and almost on average about two billion uh 200 million dollars went to you know wwf got this the nature conservancy i think environmental defense fund and a couple other ngos and it was amazon you know very similar to a coca-cola target or walmart we mentioned before or several other corporations but you know giving those donations to those big non governmental organizations whose mission is to you know improve uh environmental and i think they even have donated some social outcome groups as well um know that's one way uh a company will engage is through uh philanthropic you know through their foundations uh you know wwf also would work you know directly with an amazon or another company to actually look at internal decision making around

where they source upstream with their commodities in the case of amazon i know there's been a lot of recent engagement by ngos to address their you know moving towards an electrified fleet of delivery vehicles as a way to address um potentially just emissions and in terms of pollution and greenhouse gas emissions um you know that you know amazon though in the board game hobby uh they you know we just talked about plastic shrinking i guess i can mention directly uh you know panda mentioned that amazon requires plastic string really so they're not going to let you you know so that's a big that's going to be a big hurdle if that's you know your entry point right and given like you just said joe amazon's such a big part of our uh distribution uh for a lot of consumers that don't have local game stores or etc to get those games especially that's an interesting uh comment there about the shrink wrap because my suspicion is that amazon wants to shrink wrap because they have such an issue with um you know i don't want to say this but the integrity of their products that come through there i mean there's a decent problem with board games and counterfeiting and so anything that would could be like opened and resealed in a way i mean not that you couldn't do it with shrink wrap but you know any kind of leaning towards that end where you're like well they could just open it up and then re-tape it and you don't know what you're gonna get so they probably have to deal with that

end of as well that's interesting though that they would have that um yeah and there's other there's other i mean has been making some very strong uh stances as well uh around crap i still think shrink wraps is kind of a visible thing but uh you know right now our the the industry um you know they're feeling pressure around sustainability i mean we we saw in our our hobby you know around diversity and inclusion and and and you know major shifts in terms of the the themes that are coming out in board games now as well as just our community in general anybody went over to board game geek uh lately and land on the main page can can tell that we're we're quite different uh as a culture you know as a community than we were a couple years ago um and i think sustainability around environmental these social issues they're feeling it um you know where panda's having webinars now to talk to you know they're talking to you know publishers not consumers so they're getting a lot of you know interest so i think it's coming down the line but it's very nascent it's very new you know when you talk to a panda they're really just you know you know they basically set up a you know a board game publisher comes up and says what can you give me for sustainability you know really all they can say is like well maybe we can do those waffle seals

um maybe we can try to optimize the punch board where we get the most uh out of it um or we can you know instead of shrink wrapping all the cards there's another area where we have a lot of shrink wrapping on packs of cards you know we can use these you know paper buns that go around um or plastic bands you know single plastic bands and that's really all they got to offer um so so it's quite quite nascent now there are litter facts quite different they they've had a history of of of being a little more sustainable and of course flute affects the other another european based uh manufacturer that produces a lot of you know right that doesn't work just to interrupt you for a minute in case somebody doesn't know you know uh panda tends to manufacture most or if not all the kickstarter games and a lot of the newer companies use them as well they don't necessarily have to use kickstarter but ludefact they'll publish a lot of the games you find that it would come out at essen typically uh you know uh hans and look and uh spillworks and i don't know a whole bunch of those you know so yeah so i just didn't mean to interrupt you but i'll make sure people kind of yeah yeah and and loot it could be you know because of the the longevity and they found that primarily on paper components but they've been uh you know kind of ahead of the curve for a long time offering us what we would say for stewardship council certified uh

paper products so that means these are forests uh and paper mills that have been certified under uh fsc or the for stewardship council which makes sure you know they're having third party verification around the environmental practices they're taking in terms of how they're logging and the impact that's having on local communities uh as well as the workers in those mills or on or in those forests uh so so that's that's something that panda's not addressed at all yet is sort of uh around the the idea of different uh you know more sustainable uh materials coming on i mean they they actually mentioned just you know recently their factory and china just got two electric power uh forklifts i can't imagine being a worker in a bunch of gas powered worked inside of a warehouse but um but yeah that's just some of the he said everybody's at a different stage i think it's at its empathy and our in our hobby a little bit right and and you mentioned uh you know the forklifts and there's a couple of comments in in the chat here about the whole kind of i'll just call it the pipeline or the production pipeline is uh you know you have the materials so if you take ticket to ride you've got the the board the cards the plastic trains you know pieces of cardboard and stuff like that uh and then you've also got like the shipping container uh somebody mentioned that uh

gmt uses this was it soybean let me see if i can find it here there's a certain kind of packing peanut that they use um you know and the whole like process of not just the you know the physical components but the actual machinery and the whole you know worker process and the machining process so you mentioned shrink wrap well there's the shrink wrap itself which is plastic but it's also like what is the machine that's wrapping the cards or the box and what's that running on and that whole sort of underlying ecosystem um right and uh yeah there's like a complete life cycle analysis you could right you could definitely keep spinning the i did try to draw up a life cycle assessment or try to drive the draw the life cycle of the board game um and uh you know once it goes from pre-production you know you have play testing and you get some very the sort of you know uh materials you're using then but probably the big footprint is the actual production where your uh you know the materials coming into the system in terms of you know where the wood is sourced where the paper sourced uh you know our plastics are still primarily oil-based plastics they're pvc they have you know they're they're they're tough to work with they're uh in terms of an environmental health issue um they're oil based again um and and then uh and then you have the

issue with micro prosthetics throughout that entire process uh and then you know you have potential water impacts when you're doing cardboard using a lot of water a lot of wastewater going out so there's a lot of you know and you know even though our industry is pretty small um if you zoom into these individual places where they're having to produce these goods at a pretty large scale at least relatively speaking there can be a sizeable local impact and of course then you have in that process on production you still you have the workers in terms of human rights issues labor issues that's part of sustainability and of course once it leaves uh you know the panda factory then there's the logistics of transportation and luckily you know shipping things on big container ships is pretty efficient uh in terms of environmental impacts it's a it's a pretty great way to go and of course once it comes in and all the ups trucks and we talked about that earlier the opportunity to yeah to mitigate those outcomes but of course once it comes into our home we kind of have this embodied environmental impact on our table it's really great in these awesome mini right um and i think that's where and a lot of companies keep saying like well i mean panda says well you know they kept saying it katsa you know our hobbies just different we we keep our stuff we don't it's not disposable we're not just getting rid of it so really our our impact isn't as bad you know because we're we're not throwing it away but i mean eventually these games are gonna you'll probably be thrown away yeah at the end and you and i actually

talked about this a little bit uh a couple of months ago because that was my thing as i i was kind of playing devil's advocate which i don't always like to do but sometimes i got to do it um and my my thing was kind of two-pronged was like if you look at the stuff that we get like you look at a kickstarter game and you print you know 3 000 copies or 10 000 copies and theoretically you're gonna hang on to those for a while or trade or sell them or give them away or something and so that it's not going to go into the garbage so um but you're right eventually everything is going to end up in the garbage to some degree i mean it just is um so that's kind of interesting thing but if you look at we were just talking before the show went up like look at all the old candyland games or the old monopoly knockoffs like those are there's probably thousands and thousands of thousands of copies of those that have ended up in the landfill um so it's an interesting kind of dynamic there if you when you're looking at weighing the impact it's like okay this thing has a huge impact let's say and but we only made 10 of them and the 10 that we made are still around and they're still being used or at least they're sitting on a shelf you know um so that's kind of an interesting sort of juggling act whereas this may be like a copy of monopoly doesn't really have any impact uh component wise but there's a billion of them and nobody plays them um yeah so i i think that you're definitely right i think they're

you know i i've engaged uh with hasbro a little bit and uh and mattel and and these are companies right that you know they make toys they make a lot of uh you know item mainstream games that are often disposable uh definitely have a shorter shelf life at home than than our games but they have a very you know mature it's still you know uh you know there may be a little skepticism of how deeply integrated it is but they have a very mature sustainability uh you know team internally of course they're much larger you know in terms of what they're doing but you know they're you know probably any of our board game manufacturers or publishers could go and look at uh you know as publicly available on hasbro's website but you could you know you can see the writing on the wall what hasbro is having to leap through uh you know in terms of sustainability issues um and these if you're gonna you know especially for asthma day if they're gonna play in the bigger bigger arena um and those those companies you know i think i bought my first hasbro game in a long time the other day i got a uh guess who game from has from uh i think hasbro makes us guess who i think so and i was appalled at the quality of the cardstock i had to put this thing together and it was and it probably was trying to be more sustainable i would say there was probably you know a little more sustainable

elements but almost just you know it was almost made to be thrown away right it felt like it you know it doesn't have that heirloom you know i our fan i remember guess who being so you know pretty solid or candy land having really good you know having it never had great card stock right but now the card stock was literally it was a super thin punch board and these cards are just bending as soon as i punch them out and they're calling them cards but they're in a punch board for for candyland and uh now granted it's being designed for for that you know for a different audience but it does raise your question of like you know you can have a more sustainably produced game you're producing a lot of them and then they're just getting thrown away um i don't know if those games can be recycled uh maybe some of them can i mean that's another um part of where you say consumers or could have a role to play in our hobby would be if we did throw things away could we recycle unfortunately a lot of the components outside of the empty punch boards um there's not a lot that we recycle or can recycle in our hobbies well that was kind of the next question i wanted to talk about is if you look at any of these games um what can be recycled so cards i assume cards cardboard can be recycled whether you're talking about the punch board or eventually if you did throw out the game uh you know the cardboard could be recycled um i know for example we talked about miniatures earlier the miniatures i get from games workshop uh i my local place re

says they recycle plastics but there's so many different kinds of plastic now i take the sprues you know that the miniatures are sort of connected to when i'm done snipping them out i throw them in the recycle uh bin uh but you know i'm not super sure because you know like a milk carton is one kind of plastic shrink wrap is another i i don't know that um we my local you know landfill or whatever is actually recycling everything that i put in there because i've talked to people and they said well we don't recycle plastics here at all it's only like aluminum and glass or some places don't even do glass but um yeah it's not as light so it kind of depends on where you live i guess and what your facility is doing but then didn't we share an article or something like that with one i think i shared with you you shared with me about something and it might have to do with the pandemic was these places are actually stopped recycling plastic because of i guess i can't remember but you might have some more insight there yeah i mean it um yeah there's been some places where recycling is becoming less uh common you know um and uh that there's always the issue of just the access to to recycling i think i did scour a few uh blogs uh for warhammer around recycling their sprues and i got i think the conclusive answer is that they're not recyclable but at least in mainstream but that

they did say and i don't know if it's trying to ever talk to a uh one of their own stores overhammer store but that they will take sprues back and they must have a process where they can recycle it i mean typically the challenge is that it's so much cheaper to just produce to not you know just to produce the new uh plastic than to invest in recycling it this is the case with legos um it's way cheaper to make new legos than for them to collect you know uh you know the old ones and recycle them and use them of course you also lose some of the integrity of that sort of virgin plastic so yeah so recycling um isn't so hot in our pla in our plastic often a lot of the plastic especially like resins even if it's plant-based some of the new resins it still has you know usually another uh you know compound in it like silica or something else that that makes that process difficult i see yeah yeah so our plastics aren't so easy to recycle on our own right well i will say obviously uh half jokingly you can recycle sprues and make terrain out of them but you only do that so much after a while you don't need to do any more um but well there is this there are cardboard constructables uh which is a term in the industry now that are being used instead of plastic uh for terrain and different things i think the new descent that came out uh utilized a lot of these cardboard constructables which

which in a sense is having a game within a game it's a little meta there it's just trying to put those things together but uh yeah i don't think that's actually out here yeah that's another thing yeah yeah but there there is actually some if you're talking about terrain uh there is some great terrain that's come out uh i can think of a metro morph uh which is currently sort of in between print runs and uh what's the other one oh there's another one there that they make cardboard terrain which games workshop used to do and uh yeah it's great stuff especially with like the new screen printing technologies it's it looks super detailed and there's all these cool pieces of art on it you don't have to paint it and you can break it down super easy or super flat and then build it up pretty quickly so as far as terrain go that's pretty cool um now you mentioned the uh resin on a uh miniature what about like three did you know anything about 3d printing and uh in you know like there's the pla printers and then there's the resin printers i mean if you don't that's fine i just kind of popped into my head about no no i know i know a little bit about it and i just hear uh there's been some questions about you you know 3d printing uh i mean you know i mean part of it at any at scale is not very the technology still isn't there and it's it's very uh you know the time time constraint um you know how many how long it takes to produce four miniatures you know that through 3d printing versus you know more conventional means is uh is

pretty far uh pretty big differential still um and uh and the the challenge is they still have you know there's still some pretty wicked chemicals that you're you're using uh if you do 3d printing at home and especially if you're doing resin um you know there's you're pretty you know you're you're pretty decked out um it's like a hazmat sort of setup um and that's another you know aspect with the plastics too is that you know they're always you know off-gassing and resin actually you know part of the challenge is that it has bigger poly you know because basically plastics just are breaking down over time right they break down into the environment and we hear a lot about that in in terms of marine systems and oceans and we often think of you know all the coke plastic bottles washing up on an island or the island of of of bottles plastic bottles but it's really the journey of that plastic before it gets to that island in terms of the ingestion and animals and uh and also the byproducts of making plastic a lot of these micro plastics that are quite small we don't even fully understand how you know they bio accumulate i forgot actually tony uh i was just gonna oh i did just highlight how much how much plastic might be in our bodies right now it could i don't think it's equivalent to this big guy here but um but when i got this big guy this is what i know i had a problem first and then this is when uh it did make me real and i haven't painted joe

but you've given me inspiration um to get one day no no no i've been doing other ones but i haven't got to this one yet but um but when i got this thing and took it out and as the it stuck um you know my room smelled of this really strong plastic like that's probably not healthy um and my wife could smell and i had to like set out the garage to air out but it made me think about this i mean every box in here probably has you know maybe a portion of his arm or something but that's just you know i sometimes wonder like am i silently killing myself by my hobby as i said in this room um but that's another aspect you know with the plastics um and they're getting a lot of you know attention but some of those there is opportunities with plastics to shift to non-oil based i'm not i haven't done the research to know if they have you know less of an off-gassing potential health impact but we call them bioplastics or plant-based plastics um and sugarcane is one of the main proponents for that and like lego made a commitment at least to be i think 100 bioplastics uh in the next 10 or 15 years and they're relying on a global certification platform called bonsucro uh to have sustainable sugarcane plastic so

there is some you know but i don't think i don't think in our hobby we can translate the plastic that goes into uh i don't know how useful the lego plastic is for what we're doing in our hub but that's there is some you know where people are moving that way yeah the lego so i would have a conversation with jane's workshop um or or a female about come on sorry uh more about the majority and plastic yeah the lego plastics are probably too hard the even even though like the gw stuff is relatively hard compared to like a descent or come on it's still pretty soft plastic um but yeah yeah the lego is probably too hard but i was just gonna say i think the reason that thing stinks is for theme because it's uh they might have coated it with something so that it uh it was thematically smelly anyway um yeah it's not like there's something for sure yeah but i know i can i mean i can smell my games i mean i um i mean it yeah and so yeah but it is there is definitely i think resin miniatures are a little more dangerous than what they off gas they're bigger particles that stick in your lung a little bit more but again i don't know the yeah i don't want to freak anybody out because it's not clear right you know yeah i know i know

right i know tony topper i can't remember it was a couple of episodes ago i think where he said i think we consume about two teaspoons annually of microplastics or something in our food uh somebody'd have to go probably listen and get that back like when it he says it it it doesn't sound like a lot but then it says like well if i ate that like all at once i don't think i would keep it down you know it probably uh probably spit it back up or throw it back up or something but uh yeah so it's an interesting thing but i mean yeah it's something that's really tough to think about and quantify it when it gets to that sort of microscopic level um there's a comment in the chat here that talks about sniffing uh the board games and one interesting thing is you know how sometimes and marty can back me up on this you get like an lcg or tcg or something and some of them have just like that that great smell and it must be the ink or something that they use there and i don't i don't know if either of you guys know anything about that but because sometimes you open up a game and just there's a certain smell that some of them have and i wonder if that and i i happily like ingest that i'm like oh it's that one smell and i'll just i'll just like take a deep deep breath of it and i don't know maybe i'm doing the bad thing i shouldn't be doing that yeah i'm starting to get tony's i'm starting to get a little bit of tony's phobia on that where i'm like oh maybe i shouldn't be breathing those that might be my just

cut off five years um we're used to saying that we started our show uh yeah i was always addicted to open like packs of cards and smell it we said it smells like a rainbow and it still does well i can't say that on inks varnishes and glues there's a pretty strong movement towards either soy based or water-based so that's that sounds like a uh part of the hobby that's you know a a better alternative that's been adopted pretty wide spread now so i don't know when they implemented more soy based inks but i imagine there could be a small difference when that happens so between that and bioplastics we can now eat the pieces as we play yeah you know even though it's made out of sugar cane i don't i don't think i call it candy but yeah um they're gonna still be mixed with something that's that's probably not too great right it's not gonna be 100 sugar

uh yeah it's a derivative of that um yeah i mean that it's it's i think what i took from my uh if i can just you know sort of summarize my what i took from speaking to the different publishers and the fact that the game manufacturers and we could take more questions but just uh i i think it it's pretty obvious that it's new to them um the requests that they're getting to uh either you know spell out what the impact of the different gaming components or materials they use have on the environment that those are new questions uh like a panda was pretty upfront that they don't know the answers um they you know they're limited on trying you know they're basically you know have a team that's called the green it's got they have like the green initiative or something like that it's a inside team that's just you know spending you know part of their time you know they're they're project managers but they're spending part of their time uh on the clock trying to research alternatives learn about alternatives and so it's definitely a new space uh i think it's gonna you know it's it's only gonna increase uh but i think they're at a set of you know they're at the journey right now where i think um there's you know they're trying to get a handle on it in terms of how to respond and i think some of these immediate issues that are highly visible

like the plastic wrap um plastic on cards almost everybody was much more focused on these sort of in in you know single-use plastics these sort of uh things that there might be some easy easy things to address with but no one's really uh you know very few folks are sort of addressing what i would say the upstream impacts of uh that occur regardless whether we keep our gains or throw it which is just you know really in the production uh both in the materials that come in in terms of the wood the paper uh the production of the cardboard the production of the the minis and and with the social environmental impacts around that part of the industry um i think that's probably where the biggest footprint is and it's obviously probably where the biggest costs are to try to address it um so it doesn't surprise me you know that they're moving you know kind of cautiously they're seeing the low-hanging fruit they're also seeing things that are quite visible uh they're more they're more obvious perhaps to address um i mean panda just uh and it's great i mean i'm applauding it but they you know their big initiative recently is to plant a tree for every 2 000 games they produce or every thousand game they produce so they they have this making a planetary and they're working with uh you know tree planting organization as a way to i think offset their greenhouse gas emissions so yeah i see elements of

you know what these big fortune 500 companies that have uh you know much more of a history in the space and i just see our hobby uh even though it's small i think it's gonna be uh it's gonna be pressured if it wants to continue to grow and i think asthma day will be a bell weather for that uh but to it you know if there's going to be a different system a couple years out three years out than what we see now in manufacturing i think i predict i i think it's going to get a louder drama as we go on well derek i mean just to take a break from the questions for a second uh i mean i i just want to let you know i really appreciate you like doing this investigation and everything um you know it's it's one of those things where like i don't know i don't speak for marty or anybody else but like as a media person i see a lot of discussion a lot of times on like a social media or certain things like that and i don't really know what to how to assess it or gauge anything and you know because i'm definitely like i said i'm kind of a science nerd but um i'm doing like enough other science in my day job that when i get home from work or so just theoretically uh my brain doesn't really want to try to you know problem solve any more than it really has to and uh so i really appreciate that you you know this is your your your life's work and and you're turning your lens on board gaming and stuff and i'm i'm super happy that you agreed to come on here and talk about this and and share yeah i know and share the

uh you know what the publishers share with you and i'm i'm grateful for them for for you know having at least it you know it's it's definitely one thing that they're doing some steps like you mentioned but they're at least talking to you and allowing you to ask them questions which is a good first step all by itself really um but uh but yeah so i just wanted to say thanks for that

yeah no problem no thank you um yeah i think it's just i think it was interesting i was thinking about this about how the video game market and board game market are doing the inverse of each other so video games remember used to come in plastic cartridges with boxes and manuals and then over the years they went you know the manuals were gone to cds to digital distribution to where the video game industry impact is getting less and less but as board games grow just because the nature of what the hobby is it's going to have a bigger impact than what video games does and there's not really a correlation it's like well they can go the path of what video games did because you can't do like okay you can do digital board games but you know you know what i mean it's like just interesting those those two uh industries have like crossed each other well yeah i mean that's a good point because you have here like cloud gaming kind of around the corner um so there won't be any media you won't even need quote unquote physical disk space locally it'll be in the cloud somewhere um granted there'll probably be millions of servers making some kind of impact but um but the board game industry as i think derek kind of mentioned earlier and i think we'd probably agree is leaning more towards the heirloom uh collector's item pro product that takes up you know the individual game takes up even more of a footprint than it did before so it is really leaning towards the other side with all these kickstarters and everything

yeah i will say on the positive that there i think at least you know a lot of my work is looking at raw materials and commodities and and the opportunities to improve the environmental outcomes of those in social outcomes and and still produce things from those goods um i think there's there's definitely an opportunity for us to still get a deluxified game that has a reduced footprint um it's not zero but we can reduce it i think part of it uh is going to take some you know some courageous actors that can that have both you know the probably the you know is potentially an asthma day or something that has the the financial space to take that jump um and kind of lean into that i mean they do have some micro you know some other publishers under uh use 100 recycled paper i think uh i forget which publish there's like a publisher or like a a game brand under asthma there's so many of them but i think it's called something green games but it has green in the title and all of their products they use 100 recycled uh paper but i think there's a an opportunity for the industry to learn and they can definitely we can definitely minimize our footprint i guess i don't want us to feel like just because we have deluxe side gains and all these components that we should kind of ignore trying to do something um i think we need you know we can keep calling out and and requesting like okay it's great we got plastic it's great we got paper we want we still want those things but how can we start you know

getting them produced smarter how are you going to do that in a way you know what incentives do we need and i think that the challenge will be these are you know we're we're trying to internalize externalities in the marketplace whenever you're addressing sustainability there's always always that issue of cost but um but it's something we'll i'm just saying we you know i think we have an opportunity to have a significant impact on our hobby and i think sustainability is something we hopefully it doesn't get marginalized in our our hobby because i think we could do a lot you know one thing that occurs to me as you mentioned that is uh you know like you mentioned asme has this company that kind of focuses on the recyclable components um is there is there the possibility to hit kind of the economy of scale because right now production and board games and miniature games everything kind of has a habit right so when we do a game we have cubes or we have certain cards or certain types of plastic and certain types of other production processes but over time is it possible um because it's harder and it's probably more expensive to use recyclables but if we sort of collectively as an industry that sort of spun up our wheels and that became more commonplace wouldn't the cost of that sort of style of production and the use of those components everything start to come down as we start to hit like an economy of scale yeah yeah i think that's a great point and and i think

the evergreen titles are where we should put our emphasis you know try to emphasize uh you know those titles that are selling 20 50 you know they're having 65 000 front runs you know a ticket to ride if we could actually you know threw that out one day the first time i was talking to it i said what if you guys took ticket to ride just one of your games this big game and said okay we're gonna see if we can make it so you know gonna call it a sustainable maybe we team up with wwf or someone else do some branding get some benefits there maybe target make an exclusive uh hype the sustainability side but actually really you know focus on one product i mean they already have the cutting edge with ticket to ride it's produced by ludafak all the cardboard they do send in uh you know all the trains come from china but uh you know ludefact currently has two lines of publishing of manufacturing they have sort of conventional uh paper and then they have their certified you know more sustainable paper but i think you know those evergreen titles to your point in the the you know we could learn a lot uh given you know the scale that those are being produced at you know those would be a first idea of a place to start to test again it puts a lot of that in as the day's court which i'm not yeah we can say whether we're uh comfortable having it led by one right yeah so somebody's gonna somebody would probably have to sort of be the guinea pig right to to make that first leap with what you said like a a large-scale production like a ticket

to ride or something yeah yeah and this and and the sweeten the pot would be to have i mean most of these companies uh that engage in sustainability initiatives and uh come to a wwf or or begin to move towards this direction it's really because they're you know it's not so much you know when we think about risk across the company there's you know there is the the nuts and bolts of like buying the the input you know buying the wood and then producing your game and you know looking at your making sure you're in the you know black in terms of that but there's also other factors that come into play and reputational risk is the biggest one around the sustainability it's it's the short you have the license to operate um and and those sort of intangibles around those risks in terms of either future legal risks and where you're sourcing the reputational risk in terms of who's you know going to buy it or not buy it which market you have access to those are real costs too even though they they aren't the same as oh if i get a sustain you know and it becomes the calculations like oh maybe it costs an extra so much to get more sustainable you know to produce sustainable game but you may see this you know other benefit on the other side and in terms of your overall picture so i think companies are looking at it quite sophisticatedly across and i think if a uh if an asmr day did put partner with uh you know this is why you know you come to a a you know a big ngo that has a conservation brand and you got target i could see a match made in heaven though with a lot of players seeing right

you're getting like i mean there's a certain i mean there's definitely a marketing angle there and i mean i feel like i would say well heck i'd buy a copy of ticket to ride if they did something like that just because um uh there's a there's a comment or a question in the chat here from philip and i think i want to kind of bring it in because it ties in with this and he says what percentage of evergreens make up the sales market my understanding is that most of the sales market is the evergreens because you have your ticket to ride your terraforming mars your catans magic the gathering you know all of the big hitters and marty i mean you follow this i think a little bit more than i do but that's my understanding is the vast majority of games sold actually are those evergreens but i don't know for sure i mean i'm kind of hazily picking out a statistic there i sure couldn't i couldn't quantify that at all so i'm not sure i think i've heard bonacore and others state that you know the evergreen allows you to produce your own exactly basically i mean a lot of times it's what capital to do those other games and experiment but if you just look at all the acquisitions that asthma day has made um they're going after an evergreen not the public right and and you can look at even when they peeled off uh when you know kobe dogs peeled off the flathead games he wasn't able to keep those ever you know he's he's rebooting summoner wars but yeah he's awful absolutely yeah

100 right and i think it must have been uh maybe a board game insider podcast or something where i have recently heard that like you you have you sell fifty thousand a hundred thousand copies or whatever of terraforming mars so you can print twenty thousand of your other eight games um so but i don't know holistically if you look at the whole industry because there's got to be you know a thousand board game publishers uh if you add it all up across the board like that how it would look my my suspicion is and maybe somebody watching this later or something might come in and comment um my suspicion is it's it's it's got to be largely evergreens but you know i'm not 100 sure that's a good question well i mean i know that i i keep up with there's a website called icv2 that does their quarterly um uh charts of what sold well in the past quarter and when it comes to board games the the same ones are there six of the six or seven of the tens always ticket to ride in catan now it's terraforming mars wingspan and they're always there in the top ten so i bet if you sum all those up together it's got to be double digit you know market i would think yeah easily yeah and so yeah they almost become like high-paying high-paying rental property that you can just maintain and allow you to go off and do your other stuff too you know your new thing but it keeps your you keep your liquid a little bit

um but yeah i think that's really uh a great point joel i think that's an opportunity to see if we can find some new solutions and like you said with panda um panda seems you know they're doing a lot of the major kickstarters that's where we're starting to see i don't know how we think of kickstarters in the the way of of uh evergreens i guess over time they don't have they don't raise as much money but it's still a pretty big you know i i don't know the number of you what's the largest number of units

exploding kittens was a ton but yeah yeah oh yeah when they were telling me that their prep runs that they put in and they stagger them and why he was saying it was so difficult to you know you're trying to get all these pieces to come together and you have a system that's already up and running and to bring more sustainable principles in it's difficult uh you know it's like trying to jump on a ship that's moving um but yeah he was it was like seventy thousand dollars it was seventy thousand units i think is what he was saying is like a print right our new print run first and exploding kittens in 2015 had 219 000 backers wow that's a kickstarter that still is in production so they they're they're not doing kickstarters but they're still producing that game and it yeah right and it's become an evergreen for other titles i think that's it's you know my suspicion is that the number of evergreens to come out of kickstarter is probably equal to the number of evergreens to come out of not kickstarter um i have no basis in reality of that but i did i did a study of like my my the own games that i've reviewed and stuff coming out of kickstarter versus not over the years and yeah that's scientific jewel you should you should get on that one right yeah that's probably up your alley but that would be interesting that you know how many evergreens since kickstarter

started what's the rash ratio of evergreen going through started from kickstarter that would be tough because kickstarter hasn't been around as long i'd probably have to start around like 2012 or 13 or 14 or something and then go from there you can control it for the same period but the only reason i say that is my little sort of uh guesstimate there is because i a while ago i went back i actually did this twice since i started reviewing games because the people used to say oh so many crap games come out of kickstarter versus the real world and i went through and kind of looked at all the games that i had uh that i've seen that were kickstarters versus others that weren't and it was about the same percentage of games i thought were in my opinion good games versus bad games and i would say it was about like you know 25 percent of them were i would call bad and where 75 percent of them were at least good you know maybe they weren't the greatest thing in the world but um and it seemed to match up to me across the board so to me i was trying to figure out if it was if there was a myth that kickstarter games were were somehow significantly worse than non-kickstarter games and just with my own personal assessment which is completely subjective of course um they seem to be about the same so that one yeah well not especially not now when you're talking about a lot of larger publishers are going to kickstarter with what you feel would would have been a very good game anyway you know prime example uh portal games just took you know robinson crusoe who did amazing they probably didn't have to go

it was game found instead of kickstarter but they probably didn't have to go that route so you got a lot of companies it's like this is probably going to be a big hit and we're really going to you know punch it up by putting it on kickstarter game found so that more eyes can even see it do you guys think we're hitting like a and i feel like uh hollywood and the film industry has kind of hit this you know we're getting reprints you know you know you're seeing you know all titles get remade and you know there's not as much new stuff and i mean like disney's constantly you know now taking all their animated and re you know creating new do we see that in board game now where we're just because it becomes you know we just got to recreate the same game and you know i mean robinson crusoe is one example but um where we're just seeing every year it's going to be you know these new i guess the second edition or the third edition uh but i i feel like that's that's becoming much more lucrative than it was in the past well it's it's a low risk and the episode that we just released we covered three r i didn't realize that time but we covered three re-releases spartacus which came out like 2012 or whatever that was ashes and uh summoner wars so those games we just covered all three have been just re-released and pretty soon it's gonna be uh you know sentinel to the multiverse is uh yeah i think the frequency of new additions is increasing again that's anecdotal um but i i've heard that sentiment sort of fannied about over the last year or two it seems like the you know the second edition the deluxe edition

uh the whatever is is increasing i mean i just reviewed a game after the empire i think i put the review out last week and um they uh they released on game found this week um i actually had the review in the canon i reached out to the publisher i says hey i've got this but you know i'm trying to i try to stagger my you know release schedule and i said i'm doing this show here that we're on right now and they said why don't you put it on friday because we're going on a game found i'm like oh really and so i looked and they're doing this really cool deluxe edition and i was like why i wish i had that one but uh yeah but that game just came out after the empire just like yeah

it's not it's not like um you talked about hollywood hollywood's different where they're not taking the original and touching it up lots of times they're taking better story and redoing it with different people that's different but you know all three that i just talked about maybe were redone and tweaked a little bit but i i don't mind it because there's a lot of games in the past i never got to play uh like last year i never played tammany hall and a new version came out of that last year was like wow man i did miss this good game i you know i've i've experienced a lot of games over the years that i just missed and they were hard to get another one that was just now some gale force knight tyrants of the underdark it's one of those i loved it when it came out then it kind of went away and they're bringing it back so there's a lot of new people in the hobby but i think it is a little bit different than hollywood where it's just taking an idea and an old idea just you know the ghostbusters 2 or you know just you know hey we're going to do ferris bueller's day off except with brand new actors and everything he's like no please don't but that's yeah i agree i agree yeah and i wasn't trying to yeah that was a bad and i mean the reissue part was what i but uh i do think the reissues in the the board game hobby either it's a a title that's not widely available or it's got high scale prices and so it's without a print and and if they do bring it back that that's totally fine that makes a lot of fun and they're often been tweaked and improved i wonder if it is yeah i think there's there's there's a there's a kernel of a point there because like you said anybody can go back and

watch ferris bueller like there's no there's no print run on that because it's a movie um whereas marty wright so if you miss tammy hall or you miss a game and it's not in print well you're not going to be able to get after it so just having a new print run or a new addition isn't necessarily like rehashing an old idea it's just like hey this was a great idea we need to get it to more people uh you know tammy hall is a fantastic example that a game i think when it came out it had less than 500 copies in the initial initial run and then they reprinted it back in 2012 a little bit more now they reprinted again and it's it's definitely a unique game and i was sad to see that z-man as well as um uh grail games have both decided not to reprint a bunch of the reiner caninsia classes classics that they have so i assume that those licenses will lapse and those are a lot of those are in my opinion great games but the reason i'm sort of dovetailing off of this is because i wonder if part of the sustainability issue in the hobby is that whole scatter shot let's print a billion different games i mean stephen bonacore came up earlier he's been pretty vocal about this where if you roll back five years or so the strategy of the evergreen uh well called the evergreen strategy was to print 20 games and hope you one of them wasn't every evergreen that would help cover the cost of the others that didn't do so hot and then that one would go into your pipeline you'd have an evergreen you know in perpetuity and they keep doing that

every year you know 20 games 20 games 20 games so that creates a lot of waste in a lot of different ways if you want to look at it that way although there should be some other good games in there to enjoy but um i wonder if a shift in the hobby to focusing on you know i know i hate even saying this out loud because i hate stifling creativity but if there could be a focus more on like let's just print the really good stuff you know i don't know if that's if that would sort of help the environmental footprint it would help you know reviewers sanity because there wouldn't be a million games coming out every year you know there will be yeah but yeah yeah i think the million games coming out makes it hard too i mean there's there's such good games that come out that i mean it's hard to get that evergreen or be that title and i i think the scatter shot everybody's doing that like you said there's a thousand publishers and so i don't know what is our three thousand four thousand dollars and they can be really decent games i mean how many games have you probably reviewed in your podcast that you know the month later you're like that game was good but i don't want to talk about it um and so i mean the publishers probably feel that as well and it's like i gotta i got this brand set here that you know i can make it better i can you know gussy it up and i know it's got an audience just like like you know like an expansion but now it's as expansions of the base game this i mean these reissues

i don't know if they're more common than they have been but it makes total sense to me if i was running up if i had one of those in my portfolio and i think that's kind of what signals you know kind of you know mentioned like you know this is where we make we wanted to walk away but it's where we're making our our money you know for or if not re-releases obviously ffg is really good at making new additions uh you know arkham hard has been around for decades and now they're what on the what third edition uh so you take something that's very popular has been evergreen tweak it new edition put it out so it's not a total re-release but you have evergreen rule books or evergreen mechanics i think like with the zombie sides or would be all the dungeon crawls in a sense have become uh you know that's been used across platforms but it but but definitely yeah read you know imperial imperial assault mode of the rings i don't know how many dragons i have a bunch of you know ffg uh i live right next to ffg actually but um yeah i got a bunch of their uh you know basically the same mechanics but tweaked but but it's pretty subtle and i don't know if i think that's bad i mean if i really like that game and i want to have a slightly different theme on it or yeah it's still just as fun okay well this has been a great talk uh um you know derek like i said earlier i really appreciate you coming on and marty as well um

it's been definitely educational for me and we're getting a lot of good feedback here in the chat which is nice um i appreciate everybody in the chat as well coming on and giving your questions and your feedback uh it's kind of thank you yeah i know i mean it's kind of uh off the beaten path here for uh you know for the channel and i think in general but uh so anyway i appreciate everybody involved and uh like i said i'm a science dork and this kind of stuff is just interesting to talk about and and uh and just think about and maybe you know you know maybe if somebody gets a hold of this asthma day or days of wonder whoever and they can you know think critically about maybe making a shift like you said or some kind of leap or something something we haven't even covered here or thought about um i i just i'm curious about that and how how feasible it will be yeah yeah it'll be a bottom-up movement you know i mean us as consumers and then you know i think you know those immediate the retailers as well are going to have a pretty big play but right right yeah those ngos and working with target like you mentioned at the very beginning i think could be a big driving force and i think just to kind of maybe try to put a pin in that is like i mean i'm just kind of imagining the sort of messaging and the marketing impact and and just the the the after effects if they came out and said hey guess what ticket to ride starting in 2023 or something is going to be a green game or something i hate that word but you know do you think we could use lego plastic for the trains those trains are pretty hard sure or we could get lego they could get

lego to make the train so they could be little lego uh bricks yeah they can hook together or something there could be some uh i guess right with lego training yeah yeah bring me up so um i really appreciate you guys as well i just think i want to say it's just uh yeah i've listened to you i've been in the hobby for like 15 years but since you guys both came on the scene and you know it's just been you guys put out quality content i don't know how you do it constantly and thanks to marty and tony the humor i mean gosh i mean i almost want to go out and buy a lawn mower it's called i don't eat it it's getting to be spring up there right you got to mow the grass i don't have much of a yard but uh you know he's got me yeah i love it but uh like he makes me think of moon pies every time i uh i grew up with moon pies and rc colas in kentucky and so uh that's where it's at anyway appreciate you guys no thanks sir you guys will not believe what i'm gonna do right after i get done with this i'm gonna go mow my lawn yeah seriously all right have fun yeah thanks um but uh we we did mention that uh we might talk a little bit of uh falcon and winter soul soldier um but uh derek uh derek derek is not caught up so um i want to be careful about spoiling marty and i we caught up to the

last latest episode here just to kind of epilogue this show here with the falcon winter soldier uh maybe what we do is wait till after the finale on friday didn't have a full discussion well there you go we should do that why not okay i would i would be let's do that let's just wait for that and then we can corner out a little bit of time i will say that i have been going back and watching all of the old mcu movies and it the way they put that stuff together like when i watched the first avenger the first captain america movie i mean i had to get i got like slightly verklempt because i was like oh my gosh look at this look at this kernel that they carried all the way through even into falcon and winter soldier across the infinity war and all that stuff and i'm like these guys are just talking about the long haul um yeah anyway it's good stuff i'm into that okay guys enough geeking out so anyway thanks everybody for jumping on and uh thanks everybody for watching and thanks again derek um so have a good day and uh definitely reach out to publishers if you can and just you know express your thoughts there but thanks everybody have a good day

Progress saved