Skip to main content
Loading video...

Stonesaga Review: Craft Services

Transcript 17:54

Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vasel and today we're taking a look at Stone Saga. Now, I've had Stone Saga for quite a while. It's taking a while for this review to come out because there's a lot going on in Stone Saga. Stone Saga is from Open Owl Studios. It says on the side of the box that it's 60 to 120 minutes. That's not true. It's 60 to 120 minutes per game play, maybe. And [snorts] but you play through multiple scenarios. What you're doing in Stone Saga is you are taking a little civilization of people in some ancient times, but with also some fantasy kind of thrown in there. Not a ton of fantasy, but a a bit of fantasy mostly revolving around these giant creatures that are walking around.

When I first got Stone Saga, I got the rule book and I went and I said, "Wait a minute. There is a hundred and four pages to this rule book and the pages look like this." And the publisher assured me it's not that complicated. Well, sort of it is. To the point where I'm about to show you parts of the game, but realize I'm showing you maybe 2% of how this game works. Here, take a look. Here's a bit of what you're going to find in this box. I'm going to do my best as I show you bits and pieces of this game not to spoil too much, but frankly, there's just so much in the game and I want to show you a little bit of it. Each player is going to have a character and you will actually get these character cards that you can write on and they'll change and you will upgrade, but you have different stats, might, dexterity, conviction, and awareness.

And you might have some traits and an age, you're young, old, or a legend. And these things are going to come into play over the course of this game. You also get a miniature that matches your character. And some of the interesting things about it, energy is one of the main features of this game. You'll be spending energy to take actions. But you also have a backpack, and I kind of like the way this backpack works. It's because essentially you could put anything in your backpack as long [snorts] as it fits. So as long as you can kind of shove it in there somehow. So it's a kind of a spatial issue. I don't know exactly what fits in the backpack. I just know that as time goes by you're going to run out of room, but you have to try to figure out the best way to fit things in. So I don't know, maybe it goes like that. This is a story game of your civilization. So each time that you play a game you will have a campaign start.

So there's like the very first one you start with seeds in the wind. And it tells you how to set things up, and you flip this card. And when certain ticks are gotten to there is some trackers. And I by the way, I really don't love these trackers. I like the components of this game. But these trackers are placed in your thing, and they just fall out so easily. But as you move along this track various events will happen, and it will tell you what happens. Some of them are in the codex. And so this is a good time to mention that you have this giant codex that comes with the game that's full of paragraphs and all sorts of things that are going to happen to you as you go through the game. And then when you finish this, that's kind of like a whole game. But your characters and everything progress and you will go through multiple of these scenarios. And sometimes the scenario will come your way based on different things that you happen to the point where and again, not trying to spoil stuff but the game starts with these giant titans that are kind of out there.

You know they exist. You dream about them. But you will eventually interact with them. You'll be building a board that is made up of these 3D pieces, with which there is quite a few of them in the game to make up a bigger and bigger board. And you're going to be moving your character around on these boards taking different actions. First of all, when you first start the game, you're just trying to basically survive. Maybe to hunt or to fish or things like that. And these involve mini games. So, I'll show you the fishing mini game here for example. You have a deck of fishing cards and this deck can have more cards added to it as the game goes by. But, you'll first draw the card and it shows you the possible stock that's in the game. You'll then draw a fishing card and attach it to this stock here.

Oops, I have it upside down. There we go. Now, once you have this attached here, you're going to roll four dice and you're going to put these dice You'll see that these things follow lines. So, like there's one line, there's another line. So, I might go, "Hmm, I'm going to put one here and I'm going to put one here and I'm going to put two here." And I'm [snorts] kind of going over this quickly uh because there are some other modifiers. Then, you'll turn this over. So, this one here, this four-line, goes up and around and over to here. So, it has a plus one. So, I need five on that line. Hey, everything I have in this line is a five or higher. So, I'm just going to succeed and I'm going to get the reward here, which is water and fish for each of those I put down. If I'd gone up to this one up here, a two plus a three, that's a five.

I get some stuff for going to that one also. But, this nine-one is much more difficult. But, if I do get this nine-one here, I'll get three fish or I can read paragraph 194 in the book. And so, you're never sure what these three combinations of cards are. It might be plus zero, it might be times two. But, you put out these dice after you roll them and as you get more things, fishing poles and things like that, you will be able to modify these dice and put them out. So, this kind of a kind of push your luck and placing dice. Forging is kind of a push your luck style game. You're going to be drawing cards from this deck. So, you'll have a couple cards, you're going to pick one and put it out. And these decks have three sections, these cards. There's a foreground, a middle ground and something in the background. And you can keep adding cards to these. However, once a predator shows up, there's a predator there. When each turn when you draw cards, if there's a predator on one of them, you have to pick it. And if you ever draw the one where the predator's in the front, then the predator has got you. You'll take some damage. Otherwise, you can stop when you want. And then you're going to pick an area and you're going to forage or you might even try to hunt one of the predators if you think you're strong enough to take them or get some of these resources that you see in the background. Another way to get resources is by mining and that's where you're going to be pulling tokens from a bag trying to uh kind of like a push-your-luck style game. Crafting is a big part of this game. You're going to find different types of materials.

Sometimes you need to refine these materials, but what will happen is you if you have materials and they have the same type of symbol on the side, you can try to connect them. So, I can put these together and this then I look at this. If I put there's blue next to blue, that's fine. I then make a four-digit number here counting the number symbols. 2 2 2 2. So, I would look that up in the section of the book that is starting with the yellow triangle cuz that's the first thing here and that just says uh two pieces of wood and then don't create anything useful. Okay, well, I kind of figured that. But perhaps if I had maybe done this and this, I can put a piece of wood with a stone, I might be able to make an arrow or maybe a shovel or a tool. And as this happens then, you will go through and find that card and then you have that way to make that item for the rest of all your games. And really, that's a big chunk of this game is this codex here. We have different outcomes where you have these different things that are going to happen based on different numbers that you find in the book. But as you go farther back in the book, there's whole sections on different items that you can put together. There's a whole section called grinding.

Uh here's mysteries based on different things that will happen based on the sky. You can grind different things. You will once you make a grinder and see what happens when you grind them. There's different effects and this talks about all the different land and again, I'm trying to go through this quickly so I don't spoil it, but this This big chunk of the game. You're also going to be moving when you move across these different spots on the board into different areas, you will be drawing journey cards and more more these will show up and you'll have to choose them. Here you're getting hungry. So you have to move it and then at the end of every round, you're going to be seeing how much energy you get for next round. Do you have enough water? Do you have enough food to eat from game to game? And so the game comes with all these little cards. I have my journey card, something that happens at night, a fishing deck. But there is a lot of extra cards that can be added to these decks as the game goes by and just as a heads up, there is two of these including an item card deck where maybe I will eventually find a way to make a tent or find a way to get the necklace of coral or other things. And eventually you'll run into those giant behemoths and goals and there's all sorts of things going on in the game and I'm trying not to spoil, but that is generally how the game works. You're going to be taking actions on a turn going until the game comes to an end. You can die. You can't have all the people in your camp go away, but your camp can get bigger and happier.

You could even have a rebellion. You're keeping track of how many people come into your camp. You're keeping track of this and there's art. Big part of this game is about cave art and I'm showing you one here that doesn't have much drawn on at all. There's some stuff that's drawn here, but you will draw on the wall of your cave and there's a lot of different symbols that you'll draw and these symbols are kind of a story of what you've done and sometimes cause things to happen or not happen as the game goes by.

So I have a lot of mixed reaction to this. First of all, love the art in this game. Don't love the components. I especially dislike the storage units. I don't think they like I said they they don't hold the pieces quite well. Finding things and sorting things out. This is one of those times where I don't need this clever way of I I like there's those three plastic pieces to put the different tiles out. Just give me the tiles. You're wasting time giving me all this extra plastic to put out in the board and that would have saved space in a box. And there's also two expansion boxes of more stuff that you can add to this. The rule book is, well, frankly, not great. You play through your first game and it is a tutorial. And I'll tell you, if you were confused by my explanation of the fish thing, then you're in good company because everyone I've ever taught the fish thing has been confused by it. But you're basically putting out two cards, rolling some dice, putting those dice in spots, hoping your numbers are high enough, then you add a third modifier.

But that's pretty random. Um it's interesting. I find that fishing game very interesting, but the mining is a lot easier cuz there's kind of just a push-your-luck aspect and so is the the forging as you go out there. But there's luck all over the place in this game. You cross a mountain and you break your leg. You go over here and a lion gets you. And And or some fierce predator gets you. Keep in mind, and I think this is the way the game is meant to be played. The first game uh from one of the first games from Open Now I Play was a game called Mythwind. And in Mythwind it was a very similar thing where you were building up these you had this village and everything. It had some interesting mini games in it, but at the end of the day, I never felt like the there was progression. Stone Saga is the opposite of that. Stone Saga has progression, but they're going to make you crawl and eke your way for everything.

The first game is a tutorial game. Like, here's how you fish. Here is how you mine. Here's how you craft items. But I'll tell you there's a couple things that will hook you. I think the fishing game is pretty fun. But the crafting, I'm like, oh, if I put a stick and a stone together, I now have a spear. But what if I put the stick sideways next to it? Oh, now it's an axe. Now that's interesting. And each time you find these things, you're trying to figure out how can I put these together? And you learn more and more. You'll eventually learn how to cook. You'll eventually get that grinding machine. You You get these things and you're like, well, what can I do with this? Now, this is sometimes muddied by this game and you're like, "Ooh, I'm going to find some interesting things." The game is now over. Progress to the next scenario. And this game is not without its faults.

Like I said, this rulebook is messy, but upkeep in this game is messy. I don't like the drawing thing. I'm not an artist. I don't want to have to sit and draw all these different things over this thing. I get this is like what Whoever made this game, this is like this love thing that they have like, "Oh, people are going to love drawing over this wall." And I think some people are, but not everyone. And in fact, I just got another piece of paper and I we drew on a piece of paper. But you're keeping track of all these different things and you take this card and this card goes over here and you upkeep there and woe betide you so trying to reset it. I played through this game when I was first going through it. I played through it on my own for a long time. And then I wanted to teach some of the people here at Dice Tower. So, I brought it and I'm like, "I'll reset it."

Oh. And it was so much work to reset. And then I played with them and it was so much work to teach all these things and remember which cards where. Once you get stuff, you get these knowledge cards and they explain the mini games. They explain things and it's a it's a decent tutorial system, but it's not great. And there's a lot of problems within this game. I think overall, the story is fascinating, but it is a slow one. They're trying to make this game epic. I think this game could have been amazing if they had taken a lot of this and just shoved it into three games or four games where you went through at a bigger clip, but you go through and at the beginning and I get it, lots of these games like starvation. And I don't know that I necessarily want to have to have water and food for all my people every round and keep track of energy and this and that.

But it is interesting. There's tests that you make. Those four stats matter. You roll dice. There are ways to mitigate that. Interesting things happen. It does one of my favorite things in fantasy where it's like basically everything's normal, but there's this woo You might have a dream at night. Uh you might see a giant, you know, one of these creatures walking in the path. And then eventually you learn more about these creatures. But the journey to get there is a long arduous one. So, who is this game for? This is 100% a lifestyle game. You need to play through this like 20 times, I think, and that's 20 times 2 hours. And that's that's no that's no mean feat here. That that's a long epic game. And I think the game kind of Normally these type of games, I think, lend themselves to lots of players, but this one really feels more solo-esque in nature. At least I was able to go through it. But then there's that trouble of all that upkeep, keeping track of this and that. Or even the fact that you get the terrain and I'm like, wait, what exactly is this? What can I do at this spot? Is that Is that plains or is this Is this a place I can fish in?

And I feel like I'm fighting against the game to get to that stuff. But I still like it. So, my rating on this one I really waffled on this one for a while. My rating for this game is a seven because there's a lot of good in this game and it's a lot of fun. But there are other games that do this better. Open Al has grandiose fantastic ideas for their games. But they don't know how to develop them into a streamlined mean machine and this isn't there. And yet, this offers such a compelling experience. This offers this idea of you take these people that you might grow to care about them and it takes some of the most fun things in the world, which is I put these two together and I have a new item. I take that item and add this to it. I have a better item. And that sort of thing is fascinatingly fun.

What happens when I take this ingredient and this ingredient and throw them in the cooking pot? I mean, that's a big chunk of Breath of the Wild video game where everyone likes cooking. And that's in this game. And maybe Stone Saga should have been a video game, right? I I think that there's there's some of that there because of the upkeep and everything. But if you're willing to fight your way through the rulebook, if you're willing to push back the somewhat glacial pace of the game, I think you'll find yourself in for this epic story. Is it great? No, it's good, but it has hints of greatness to it. And I think a lot of people will find enjoyment out of this, as long as you can find some other people that can play this or you want to play through it solo, you're going to have a lot of fun. So, this is a grand experiment and cool things and open out.

I'm glad that they put this game together here. I mean, there's a lot of neat things Max Brook and Luke Eddie did a good job on on their concept for this. Just next time you do this, streamline it, and then you are going to make that amazing game that everyone's going to want to play. But as for now, cool universe, cool concepts, lots of fun. You battle a lot of spots that aren't fun to get to those fun spots. And I was willing to do that. I didn't play through the complete campaign, but I played through a lot of stuff and went through a lot of different things and saw stuff and was very amused by that. I just don't have time to play it forever, which is what the game's asking, but if you do have time, I think you'll like it. That's Stone Saga. I'm Tom Vasel. We'll see you next time.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you liked this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved