Ranking Solo Titles by Grey Gnome Games (Jason Glover) - Adventuring / Dungeon Crawlers / RPGs
Transcript
hello everyone welcome I'm Robert and today I want to discuss and rank these games that you see right here these are the very popular Dungeon Crawlers SL adventuring games by gray gnome games and they all have a core mechanic in common and it's the exploration deck where you typically draw two and you have to resolve one or if you don't like it resolve the other card usually to worse effect so they all do some variation of that mechanic and they also bring their own spin like a different theme for example and they all also include some kind of character creation element so I've had a chance to play all of these extensively and I want to help you decide maybe which game is the best for you if you don't want to buy all of them or if you want to buy them in a certain order so I want to give you some ideas as to what I think the priority should be so currently these are all arranged in release date order but I'm going to put them all away and then start uh putting them back in my rankings so my criteria for how I'm going to rank them is basically How likely is that game to hit the table and if I were to start over in which order I would buy them so without further Ado let's get started starting at number five we have tin Helm now this is a great game don't get me wrong uh it was the first Super portable tin version of this system and I've had my great uh fun with it now the thing is the reason why I rank it Fifth is uh one
I think some of the other games that I discuss later uh improve on this formula a lot and also because I don't travel a lot the portable aspect of it is not a big selling point to me and in fact because of the portable limitations it increases the fadlin factor of it the biggest one being that the rule books come in these uh cards okay uh instead of a spine bound uh booklet uh which I honestly just find really annoying every time that I have to read the rule book like this um and as I mentioned in my dust Runner review I think it would just be an easy solution if the publisher just offered a plain text like PDF or word file of the rule book so this is a consistent complaint that I have across the board for all of the tin uh games in this list but still don't get me wrong all of the highlights from what makes this formula great are still uh contained here and it's still a worthy addition to the series of games and I also want to point out that I really love the aesthetic in this title because there's definitely an improvement in Jason's drawing uh from this point and also the fact that it's in all Stark black and white uh the game just looks beautiful love it next we have desolate and this is my uh print and play uh copy and this was my start uh in this series of games and uh I absolutely fell in
love with with this game when I first played it and uh there's a couple reasons why one uh it's so easy to learn right so I put this in my top 20 uh intro solo board games actually it was my number one from that list uh from my top 20 solo uh introductory solo board games list so I'll leave a link to that if you're interested but uh so this is really easy to print and play because you can just uh print in black and white right it's it's uh it doesn't have a high ink requirement uh thanks to the fact that it's in all black and white so it's a great print and play if you want to introduce people to print and play games but also a great intro solo game because uh the rules are so simple it's just uh one page front and back that's it it's just fantastic okay uh and yeah so this honestly for me it's a bit more likely to hit the table than a tin realm and it doesn't have the constraints of a tin game okay but as you'll see later in the list uh you know some of the iterations in this formula really do improve it and make it more interesting okay uh so this has an edge over 10 round uh because of its uh e it's easier to learn because you know it has a this just a front and back rule book page rather than the tiny cards and uh also it's a bit simpler mechanically but the the heart of this um the heart of this formula which is where it all started it's still here it's still fun it has it
still has that satisfying uh gam playay look and when you add the expansions which I added the first couple in my print and play uh copy uh it it improves it a lot and it just adds tons of replayability so this still a great uh quick uh Dungeon Crawler romp in space so to me this holds up really well still a great worthy addition to the formula that's desolate next we have tin realm so this was my most recent acquisition and uh I shot an individual review for this if you want to check it out I'll leave a link uh but uh the reason why I rank it ahead of this is because uh this really improves on the formula uh because of its a matching icon mechanic okay uh so the exploration deck here has these half icons on each card where after you resolve a card you have to put it on either side of a panorama okay and you have your meeple advanced in the map when you match the icons okay and it adds a bit of decision making without adding pretty much any uh rules overhead at all and I just think it works so well and it transcends a tin realm in the sense that not only does it compact the iron Helm formula in portable form really well it also offers a fantastic Overland Adventure experience in this format which really makes it stand out from tin Helm and in my opinion makes it
Superior the only reason why i' probably pick this over tin Helm is if you prefer the dungeon crawling theme rather than the Overland Adventure uh but in my opinion the goal of moving the character forward in the trail in order to win rather than collecting shards in tin Helm uh makes it more interesting but yeah I think it's a great iteration of the formula I honestly think it's still hampered down by the portable format when it comes to the practicality of it again I don't travel a lot so not much of a reason for me uh to play this uh over other titles other than the fact that it's a Overland Adventure the art is still gorgeous and yeah unfortunately the rules are still a bit of a pain to go through because they come in the tiny card forms rather than a booklet but yeah that's thin realm my number three in the list and if you want to hear my extended thoughts go ahead and check out my video review moving on at number two we have dust Runner so I have a full playthrough and review of this if you want to check it out which I'll link uh but one of the reasons why I think this works so well and it's such a great iteration of this formula is because it for go dies for combat in favor of this resolution deck okay uh so this resolution deck is used to determine many things like how much extra Health the enemy gains how much damage they deal how much damage you deal uh how much loot you gain uh so because you're not rolling dice uh it reduces the
fiddlin and it just makes it snappy okay which LS itself really well for for this portable format where usually uh perhaps you're gonna be limited in time okay and I love the Mad Max SL cyberpunk theme that it has going on and while I love the black and white look I think the San and magenta colors here just work so well and this is some of the best art from Json that I have seen and also it is just so much fun as you can see in my playthrough if you want to check it out uh it's just so tense with the chase element uh so the way that it uh reworks the formula into a car chase it's just fantastic and I'm really excited for the upcoming expansion and yeah I'm much more likely to play this over the other titles in this list by a long mile pun intended and that's definitely in big part again thanks to the fact that it uses this resolution deck instead of dice for combat you have no idea how much that speeds up the game so yeah that's th Runner my number two in the list and finally at number one we have iron Helm one of my favorite solo board games of all time period and it has consistently made it to my top 20 so yeah thankfully this game is not restricted by any tin format woes and it is simply addicting okay as I've mentioned in other lists of mine the first time I played it uh it didn't really click I ended up trading it uh but then I uh downloaded the PMP uh and gave it another shot and I absolutely fell in love which made me buy it a third time with all expansions
now there is one flaw with this game and is that the base game by itself is a bit weaker in comparison to this okay for the amount of money that you're paying I feel that you get a bit less money worth than most of the other titles but it does become exponentially better with expansions so if you do decide to get it I suggest that you get as much content as possible if you want the easiest expansions to integrate I suggest the loot and lore pack which I'll put up on screen uh because I don't have the booster pack anymore uh and then you also have the dungeon deck number two that's very easy to implement as well I have not gotten around to trying this just uh yet okay I need to give that a shot but uh there's also these uh dungeon expansions that basically uh expand uh Beyond when you play a game you can then go onto a more difficult dungeon so you have these booster packs that give you level two difficulty Dungeons and then you have level three difficulty dungeons okay uh so you could just buy uh a one uh level two dungeon and a level three dungeon now each of these dungeon expansions also add more characters more loot so there's stuff that you can just integrate into the base game uh but yeah for the dungeon expansions you're not going to be able to experience that uh in the first play you're going to have to play a game and then move on to dungeon number two and then dungeon number three and then you have the more esoteric expansion like the fanny pack but then
you also have the iron chest and that adds a whole lot to just the base game if you want to experience that but I can't personally vouch for the cont from Iron chest yet because I haven't gotten around to trying it but I did see how it works mechanically I read about it and it sounds really fun it is super super random though okay it just adds more Randomness more Randomness but it sounds really fun so I'm looking forward to trying that but yeah this game definitely has a really addicting quality to it once it clicks and do keep in mind that uh there are some people that these series of games they don't do much for them they are very random to keep that in mind okay but I am on the side where I do find them extremely entertaining okay and I have had a ton of fun with iron Helm and its dungeon expansions I've not even touched the howling abyss and the iron chest content yet I do need to give that a spin but yeah folks this is definitely the order in which I would buy all the content okay uh and and one thing I forgot to mention is that these two are almost interchangeable I had a bit of a hard time figuring out how to rank these two tin realm is just such a good uh iteration of the formula that I had to give it the edge but that portable format that's just a detriment to me uh but I really like desol because of its Simplicity okay and it's black and white sci-fi look is just delightful and it's a very easy print and play game to do especially if you use sleeves if you don't want to do the card backs just use black and white sleeves like I did it
it'll save you time and yeah not to mention that all of these have print and play files but honestly folks other than desolate I honestly would not recommend unless you enjoy that activity um I had a face where I did enjoy it but uh not anymore I'd rather just pay the money for the full game print temp plays of this scale take a lot of time and it just drove me nuts at some point but yeah folks that's how I would rank them and what do you think how would you rank them please let me know in the comment section and if you have any other comments questions feedback go ahead and put them in the comment section and if you enjoy this content make sure to like And subscribe and I'll see you in the next one