TDG: Revolutions: France 1820-1880
Transcript
Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, I've noticed that lately people don't like to hold hands in public. Especially if they don't know who I am. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at Revolutions 1820 to 1880 from Fellowship of Simulations.
In Revolutions 1820 to 1880 from Fellowship of Simulations, one to five players take on the roles of various political factions as they attempt to dominate France. All right, ladies and gentlemen, there is a lot going on in this game. I'm just going to give you an overview of the rules and then tell you what I think. Now, in this game there are five different political factions. There are the Ultras. The Ultras want to turn back the clock, have king and the altar once again, and kind of get rid of everything that came from that pesky revolution. You have the Orleanists. These are constitutional monarchists. They like the idea of a king, but they also want a new liberal tradition. You have the Bonapartists. They are tied to the glory of the French Empire under Napoleon, and they want to resurrect it. You have the Republicans who have no need for a king and want to create a new liberal tradition in France.
And you have those pesky socialists who are all about workers' rights and their own form of liberalism. Now, each player is going to get their own player board. It's going to have various information. It's also going to have various information about how they score in the game. You're also going to have kind of various conditions that may give you certain bonuses at the start of a round. Now, you have a turn round board, and then you have kind of several different boards that are going to be very important to the game. First of all, you're going to kind of have your government board. This is where the various political parties will battle to to claim control of the government. Uh essentially, when people go up, they will have a better standing in the government and hopefully be able to steer the France in the direction that they want. But, you'll also have a social tensions track that if it's not checked, could lead to a revolution.
Now, you've also got a section of the board that has three very important tracks on it. First of all, you kind of have your the nature of your government. Are you a federal state? Are you a republic? Are you a monarchy? And this can only be switched once during a round. You're also going to have your national sovereignty track. Essentially, how people are represented. Do you have kind of direct representation? Do you elect representatives? Do you have plebiscites? That too can only be altered once during a during a round. Finally, you have a section for your rights and freedoms, civil liberties during the game. And this can change in various ways as it goes up and down. This can be modified a few times during the course of a round. So, at the bottom, you actually have kind of six areas of society. You have notables. You have the songs, the popular songs of the day. You have the clergy. You have workers. You have peasants. You have newspapers. And these are places that all of you are going to try to dominate over the course of the game in order to get votes so that you can control the government. Now, the game takes place over a series of rounds. Now, every round has a bunch of phases. Now, the first phase is you're going to collect cards. Now, you had each player has four cards that have a one, a two, a two, or a three on it. These are kind of the ways you're going to try to spread your influence among those different segments of society. But, you will also have three essentially bluff cards, cards that you can place down so people won't know exactly where you're putting cards that actually can do something. But, as I say, on your own player board, you will have various conditions. And if these conditions are being met in certain areas on the board, you will have access to bonus cards. These are other cards that have numbers on them
that you can be that you can also put down during the next phase. But, once you've collected all your cards, that's the first phase, you go to the second phase, which is betting. Essentially, what you're doing here is you are placing cards in the different segments of society. So, you can place them in any of the six areas below to influence those segments of society. Or, you can also put them in the social tensions track if you want to make social tensions worse or you want to make them better. You want a revolution, you want to stifle a revolution. Now, not every section of society is open right at the beginning of the game. Initially, it's just the three on the right side. The others will open up eventually. Next, you're going to resolve the bets. Essentially, you're going to look at all of the cards in a section and you're going to see who has the the most votes there. Whoever has the least votes, they can decide what they want to do. Now, you can move with your votes. You can move any of the any factions marker anyway you want. You don't have to just move your own. You can move any faction marker up or down. Sometimes, you'll want to bring the opposition down.
Sometimes, you may have someone you find yourself in a political alliance with that you want to help out. But, you can make those decisions. But, you start with the person who voted the least amount and then you go all the way to the person who voted the most amount, and then that person can go last and try to maneuver themselves or someone they want into a more advantageous position. After you've resolved all of the orders on the tracks of where people stand, you look at the social tensions track. You see who has the most social tensions there, and then you can make the decision if you want to uh move up or down on that track as well. Now, once you've got all of the uh segments of society done, you actually look at your where you are located in those spaces, and it will give you kind of indications on how that segment of society votes. You then go to kind of the the voting area, and you start to raise your markers to keep track of how many your total votes are. Then, once you see how everyone has voted, you've got everybody's total vote on there, you rearrange kind of the the seats in government to see who is the most powerful to the least powerful. Now, depending on where you are in the government, you're going to get influence discs, these orange influence discs. So, if you got the most votes, you're going to have a lot more, you're going to be a lot more influential politically. So, what you're going to do there is you're going to take political actions, legislative actions. So, beginning with the first player and going around, you are going to uh essentially take these different actions. You're going to spend these discs in order to do the different things that you can take. There's all sorts of things. You can try to get the executive. The executive has a lot of privileges in the game. Uh you can spend
money to try to take the executive. You can try to move the form of government you have, like I say, from a monarchy to a federalism or to a republic or vice versa. Uh you can try to alter national sovereignty, how you vote, and how the the the government functions. And you can try to position the legislative uh or rather the uh rights and liberties of society as well. And all these things are important because again, at the end of the round, you're going to score based on where these things are. So, you want to get them to places where they're more advantageous for you. And what you will find is that you and some of the other players are going to score similarly and you'll be working together in some of those areas and you'll be working against each other in others. Now, at the end of the round, that's what you do. You go to scoring. You essentially see where everything is. You add up all of your scores, you get any bonuses, and you start to move your VP track along. Now, as soon as one player gets their VP marker to 51 victory points, then that person wins Revolution: 1820 1880.
We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, books on history, military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel. And now, back to the review. Okay, ladies and gentlemen, there is a ton more going on in this game. There is a lot going on in this game. That's just the bare bones. Like I say, you can have revolutions happen in which you can kind of significantly alter the composition of those those tracks on the board. You have kind of little civil wars there and stuff like that. So, there's a there's there's there's a lot more going on. This is just the basics of the game. So, this is one of those games that um I was kind of interested in because, you know, I teach Western Civilization. Uh I I I'm I'm I'm not hardly an expert in 19th century French politics, but I'm familiar with it and I do find it interesting. Now, obviously, this is going to be more interesting to people who have a familiarity with this concept. So, we played it the other night with five player game. Uh we had Al, Mike, Ray, and Chris here. Now, Al also um is very interested in history and he was he's kind of interested in this this time period. Uh my other friends, not so much.
And I could kind of tell in the way they played. Uh I really liked this game. They liked it less. Al initially wasn't too fond of it, but he kind of came around and he said, "The more I think about it, the more interesting that game was." But I do. I like this game, and I'll tell you why I like this game. I like the betting system, and that essentially that's that's what the game is is you are political parties, you're canvassing for votes, you're getting elected, and then you're using your political influence to carry out your policies. It's pretty simple, and I really like that. It The game is deceptively simple in a lot of ways here. But I like that, and I as I say, I really like too how on each of your player boards, you can tell what everybody's going to score off of. You can see where everybody scores and how everybody scores. And that is really cool too as well. I really like how that system creates these kind of alliances in some areas and not in others. Now Now, for instance, in this game we're playing, I was the Bonapartists. Now, the Bonapartists don't care if you're a republic or a monarchy. They can do either. They're happy with either. But some people desperately want a monarchy. Some people desperately want a republic. And so, you know, in that sense, I was kind of playing kingmaker in that in that in that battle there. But I could go either way, and if somebody was going to alter the government one way or the other, I didn't have a dog in that fight. I scored either way. But yet in other areas, like with rights and liberties, you know, I wanted a certain kind of rights and liberties, and I I had some
real hard fights there because other people were opposed in some areas, but they agreed they wanted the rights and liberties there. So, I really like how the game pits you against each other in these kind of unconventional ways, and and and where these kind of natural alliances begin to pop up. And And And what I like about that too is it kind of you know, for not knowing a ton about the the the politics of the era, it nevertheless gives you a little sense of role-playing because you're saying, "Oh, I want the republic." "No, no, we shall not to be a monarchy. We want the plebiscite. We want the representatives. I could go on and on in a French accent just because it's so much fun. But I I really like these systems here that this game is set up. Now, like I say, my friends were not as thrilled with it and I really think it came down to theme because even they told me the the systems were pretty good. And I should point out when we started playing it there were a few little things we got wrong. For instance, we didn't we didn't quite grasp that you could only change governments like so many times in a round. That's key, right? That's critical. When we figured that out we're like, oh, yeah, okay, that that really fixes a lot of the problems we had with the game. Uh and and you know, we we did the voting wrong initially, too.
There's a lot of different things here that are just it's kind of a fine-tuned machine and it works very, very well. But, your mileage will vary depending on what you think of the theme. It's it's it's not a theme I think most Americans will will appreciate, which is a shame because it's a very interesting history and it's a very fun game. I really like this game quite a bit. On the Cody scale, I'm going to give Revolutions 1820 to 1880 an eight out of 10. I really got a kick out of it. Thank you once again, ladies and gentlemen, for joining us today on The Discriminating Gamer. As always, we'd ask you to please leave a comment here on YouTube, on Board Game Geek, on our Facebook page, on X. We'd love to hear back from you. I love to hear what you have to say about these games or anything else you want to comment on.
Please like this video and subscribe to our YouTube channel. And if you do really like what we do here on The Discriminating Gamer, I would humbly ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about history, military history, books on history, fun things like that. I even post some of my lectures on that channel. Please check that out and subscribe. It would mean the world to me. And if you do really like what you see here, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. My wife said I'm too old to make tennis puns. I'm only 40, love.
Ugh!