Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 28:39

hi i'm adam porter and this is my top 100 board game mechanisms of all time and we're now down to numbers 10 to number one my top 10 board game mechanisms and at the end we'll also be talking about one mechanism that i really don't like and this is my number one mechanism that i really don't like we've already counted down numbers 10 through to number two before we start i'd just like to say thank you for all those people who have commented as we've gone through this list it's been really nice to see you engaging with it it's kept me going this has been quite a lot of work putting this all together so it's been nice to to to see that people are appreciating it and hopefully i'll come up with another top 100 for next year obviously i wanted this list to be a little bit different to what other channels have been doing where you know those top 100 board games of all time lists are fantastic but they've become so um so sort of commonplace now i wanted to do something a little bit different so with all that said let's get stuck in to number 10. so number 10 on the list is tile laying and as with many of these other mechanisms i've made a whole list of top ten different ways that board game designers use polyaminos how to design a polyamino game so you can go back and watch that video but i really enjoy polyamino tile laying in fact i prefer it over the previous entry on the list monomono tile laying so that's where you just lay a single square and you try and position them up now with monomial tile laying like carcassonne we tend to have to try and connect up roads or different types of terrain and so the orientation of our square piece

um really matters in a lot of these games emporio no tile laying of course the decision space when you're playing your tile is is a lot more complicated because you've got to rotate that tile perhaps flip it over to the alternative side slot it in among all the other pieces and the bits jutting off from your tetra shaped piece are going to get in the way and so because your decision space is already quite large we don't need all that interconnecting terrain and roads and things like that in fact if you try to put all of that onto a polyamide piece i think the decision space would probably be too large i'd like to see someone try and see if they can make it work but generally a polyamino piece is what it is it's a red piece it's a blue piece it's this type of building it's that type of building and and then it's all about rotation and flipping and slotting it in to try and fill spaces in your grid i find it really satisfying for all the same reasons that i've talked about previously in the list in relation to you know positional polyamino use in in in role and write games we've talked about that previously it's just that organizing part of my of my brain it's really satisfying when when pieces just slot together and you manage to you manage to fill that grid and make the most efficient use of your pieces it makes you feel clever number nine on my list probably is no surprise either i really enjoy push your luck games and again i've touched on elements of push your luck throughout this list but push your luck at its absolute purest um where for example in the game diamont

where we turn over a card we turn over another card we turn over another card and at each stage we've got to decide are we staying or are we going are we going to keep on pushing is it's that stick or twist thing that we see in casino games so are we staying or are we going and if we stay too long and a second um disaster or a third disaster comes out of the deck of cards then we lose everything so how long do you stick at it i really really enjoy the game alf toyville comrades it's one of my favorite games and it's my favorite game from zok verlag which is one of my favorite publishers so our toefl comraos is where you're drawing coals out of the devil's cauldron and they each have numbers on them and you want to get as many of the high numbered ones as possible but sometimes you draw in these pathetic little low numbered ones so that just pushes you to want to keep going but the trouble is if you pull a devil out of that cauldron you get nothing you failed okay and i just love that mechanism of shall i keep going shall i keep going and the other players willing you on and partly they're willing you on because they want to see you succeed they want that big moment of success and partly they're willing you on because they want to see you fail and you don't know what it is that well you know actually you know that they're trying to be naughty that they're trying to trying to get you to to push yourself to the point where you fail you know that's what they really want but you can't help getting drawn up in it and just keep on pushing keep on pushing and those big successes are so satisfying so i love push your luck games in all their different forms

number eight on my list is a living board and what i mean by this is a board that kind of grows and develops over time so for example in a game like dominant species we have different areas of terrain and new terrain is added to the board as we play and then we can populate that terrain but we can also change the different sort of resources available on that terrain which might make it easier for a species to thrive in that terrain or it might make it harder for them it might in fact lead them to going extinct you then might bring on these glaciers or vents in the marine version which get placed on top of the tiles and they're going to kill off a lot of the different species but if you can hold on and survive in those spaces then that's really good for point scoring so a living board a board that develops it might be a game like forbidden desert where sand blows across the board and piles up in certain spaces and it makes it harder for you to maneuver through those spaces and find the pieces that you're trying to find to to complete this cooperative game i've talked previously about destruction entire laying games and i think this is almost the sort of opposite the flip side of that it's where we're adding stuff on and and our board and our terrain is just getting better and better i remember it in the game um dungeon quest that i used to play as a kid where you were working your way through a dungeon but at each turn you were placing a new tile into that dungeon a new room for you to explore or it might be in a game like tikal or or cuzco where we're placing tiles to create this terrain and so in tikal

essentially clearing the forest and finding temples and treasures that you then have to claim by by by forming a majority in those spaces in order to claim those treasures so i really like that idea of exploration that comes from having a living board number seven is another one of these very specific game specific mechanisms i'm sure it's been used elsewhere i'm only aware of one game that does it and that's the quarto mechanism so in quarto um we're essentially playing tic-tac-toe or or connect four you know we're trying to we're trying to place pieces in a row or in a column uh in order to score points but on your turn you choose which piece your opponent has to place and you don't choose where it's placed you just choose the playing piece that they've got to position and that's just a totally different way of thinking thinking about what do i want my opponent to do what can i do that you know if i give them this piece it creates all these opportunities for them so what can i do that gives them opportunities that are going to hinder them or or or help them the least and benefit me or potentially set them up for setting me up okay and and so it's just a totally sort of backwards way of thinking you know a reversal of our normal strategizing it's similar to what i've tried to do in my game picoco i mean this is not the same mechanism at all but in picocco we're playing a trick taking game but you play from the hand of the player on your left you play cards from their peacock not from the

peacock in front of yourself and so and you're trying to achieve certain goals by doing that um based on the bets that you've made throughout the throughout the round um i just find uh that slight tweak to what i'm thinking i'm not playing what i want to play i'm i'm choosing what somebody else tells to play but then they've still got some agency over how they play it i i find it a fascinating mechanism i'd like to see it used in more games number six is probably the mechanism that rhinic nitzia is most famous for so this is his mechanism let's call it the nitzia scoring mechanism i don't know what the name for this mechanism is but this is where you collect up a variety of different resources okay and they're all worth points but you're only going to score points for the resource that you have the least of so in tigris and euphrates you're going to be collecting up red cubes and blue cubes and yellow cubes and green cubes all i can't remember what the colors are but you're getting a bunch of different colored cubes and in theory they're all worth points so having loads of cubes is fantastic i might be doing brilliantly in the red cubes but that's not going to score me anything if i'm not doing very well in yellow okay because it's the lowest number that the color that i've got the least of that is going to score and of course essentially this is a different way of thinking about sets isn't it you're going to score a point another way of thinking about it in tigris and euphrates is you're going to score one point for each complete set of every colored cube and every any

leftover cubes score nothing but i i don't know what's more intuitive thinking about it in that way or thinking about it in terms of you know the thing that i've got the least of is the thing that i score it harks back for me it's similar to the mechanism i talked about in haben gute and lords of zidit and high society another one of rhino knitsia's games that mechanism where yeah you might be doing fantastically well maybe you've got more cubes than everybody else maybe you've got double the cubes any other player's got but that doesn't matter if you've done badly in one particular category okay it's okay you're not being eliminated at the end of the game but still you're not going to win just because you've got the most cubes you've got to keep an eye on have i done a little bit of everything have i done enough in that lowest category in order to succeed i think it's a great mechanism i think it's wonderful that konnichi has kind of made it his own and and reused it in multiple games and this became sort of synonymous with with his name i think that's really clever um and really nice to see i love it when there's a mechanism that's kind of known by its designer known by its creator number five on my list of mechanisms is straight up combos combinations okay so this card works so well with this card okay i play this card and then it powers up this other card i've got and then i can play this other card as a result and so i can chain these different effects and have a mega turn and these combos tend to build up through the game so it could be

something like dominion uh dominion's great for this where you know at the start of the game i play a single card i use a single action it's pretty low-key maybe i'll buy another card by the end of the game i'm playing right i'll play this card which allows me to play this card and then i draw this card and then i can play that card which powers up this card which allows me to buy these cards and these effects just chain and layer on top of each other which means you just get that momentum and those exciting later turns in the game and a real sense of of progress as you work your way through i find that really really satisfying it makes up for a lot in terms of you know lack of narrative if you've got a game that's fairly abstract like dominion where there's not much story going on but we're creating our own story here okay maybe not a thematic story but we've got a sense of something's happening you know things are getting bigger my turns are getting better i'm getting more and more excited the adrenaline's flowing okay and and that in itself kind of makes up for that lack of thematic immersion because you're so immersed in the gameplay so i love combinations again it's a mechanism that makes me feel clever makes me feel like i'm achieving something and makes me feel like the game has a real sense of of drive and momentum number four is a really broad category and it is dice rolling just generally dice rolling i've talked previously about the yahtzee mechanism um you know i've talked about push your luck all these things feature in dice rolling games i've talked about roll and write games and all this stuff

but basically i just love having a handful of dice and rolling it the tactile nature of it the the the noise of it and the the familiarity the nostalgia of it and it's just exciting you know that it's randomness i enjoy randomness okay now clearly randomness needs to be mitigated and and you need to take care with it and and you need to you know be sensitive to the player's needs and making sure that the game is fair and making sure that you know you don't have a long game that just feels like it's entirely based on chance there's a whole video about this on my channel one of my most popular videos is a video called dice and not the answer um so if you want to go back and look at that as a few years old now but it's a popular video on the channel um and i stand by that dice aren't the answer and dice need to be used with um with nuance and sophistication you know people need to think about what they're creating when they use dice but i really really love picking up a massive handful of dice and rolling them i used to play warhammer 40k a lot when i was younger and over the last couple of years i've dabbled a little bit in age of sigma these are games where you have i mean a literal handful you know like 30 dice you know just rolling them and then picking out the different results and then you know okay now i'm down to 15 dice i roll them again um just it's just so sort of satisfying um to do that so i i really like finding games that don't use the artsy mechanism i enjoyed the artsy mechanism as we've discussed

previously that idea of roll dice re-roll re-roll here's your final your final result but i like games which find another way of doing it so games like las vegas and the rudiger dawn game where we roll our dice and then we sort of combine them into sets and i have to place all dice of a certain number so all the fives or all the fours or all the threes go on to their their relevant spot and then we're competing over those spots in a sort of area majority type exercise i find that really satisfying i really like the game pick omino another rhino knitzea game that uses dice in a different way to that yahtzee mechanism this was what um was the motivation for me in creating my game thrown should be somewhere behind me on the on the the um on the shelves here so throne is a trick taking game that uses dice but it doesn't use that yahtzee mechanism and we're using those in a different way now whether it's wholly successful or not i don't know but but i find it really satisfying that seeing all the different ways that dice can be used and randomness can be used and to create different game states and different experiences for the players now we're getting high on the list now and number three is a bit of a left field choice okay but i i think this is such a um ingenious mechanism i felt like it needed to be needed to be mentioned even though it's a mechanism that as far as i'm aware only were only features in one game now there probably are more there probably are more that i'm not aware of but in the game fischer flippen

frickadellen from freedom and freeze this is a game uh it's a stockholding game i've mentioned previously i like stockholding so you're moving around aboard and you are stopping on spaces and trading essentially it's a bit like a pick up and deliver you can buy goods from those spaces you can sell goods at those spaces you can swap one good for another and there's a little table which shows the prices of all these individual goods and so prices will go up and prices will go down sounds simple so far right so you're moving around the board you're doing this trying to compete with the other players but the twist here is if you have multiple copies of the game you can have them running concurrently so i can be playing flipper fisher fluff and fricadellen on one table another group's playing it on a second table another group's playing on a third table and that is as far as it goes and so we could play with up to 15 players working on three different tables but the key thing here is you can swap from one table to another so at a certain point in the game i might leave table number one and join table number three or table number two now there's six players or seven players or eight players on table number two but there's only two or three players left on table number one which means their turns are going much quicker they're achieving much more but we're bogged down on table number three so i want to get off table number three and get to table number two but when i take all my fish that i've collected on table number two and i get to table number three the fish aren't worth anything on table number three the

fish stocks have plummeted on table number three i need to get back to table number one where fish are worth an absolute fortune and so players are switching around between the different tables and they don't know what's going on because those tables are far enough apart that you can't see what's happening in those different environments so you're taking a bit of a chance when you take that ferry and you travel to that different environment and then you start exchanging your stocks now clearly it's chaotic it's hard to control what you're doing it's silly it's impossible to get 15 players together for a game virtually impossible i hardly ever have managed to get games of fisher flip and fricadellen it does the game does function as a as a game for two to five players playing on a single board but it's a very different experience and not a particularly exciting one until you start to bring in those additional tables now this is a game that was only ever released in germany it's probably really hard to get hold of right now i don't think it's impossible i do see copies around from time to time but it didn't make an enormous splash you know it didn't stay in print or anything like that's been out of print for a long time now and i suspect that's because you know how marketable is it really how many people hat can afford to buy three copies of the same game and have 15 people who all want to play the same game together and have the space to play on three different tables uh within a relatively small space so you can all cross over into these individual tables

it's just not really workable or manageable and yet as a mechanism i find it inspiring and exciting and i just love these big left field ideas another example of a big idea this is not technically on my list but i thought i'd mention it at the same time as similar sort of big idea it's that idea in the gift series of games um which is yinch and tsar and um punkt and gift itself you know these games where when you complete a game and you win you gain a playing piece which you can then utilize in a totally different game so we play a game of gift i win a playing piece that i can then use when we play our game of yinch and it increases my my um my abilities in yinch and then when we finish that game of yinch of playing pieces awarded to the winner which they can then take and use in their game of devon okay and so there's like six or seven different games in this system and and you can play all of them in this one big meta game now i've never done that okay it's such a big idea and again like fisher flip and fricadellen it's pretty much unworkable and unmanageable and for the majority of people they're just not gonna really do it but that's an idea i find it inspiring and i find it exciting that people still are willing to experiment in these ways with their game design number two on my list of mechanisms is

betting now i really like i as a younger person before i was into the modern board gaming hobby i was always a gamer as a child i was always playing board games but as a young adult i really liked playing poker just with my mates i wasn't going to casinos and i wasn't putting big money down but i always felt that poker only really works when there's real money on the line and you know if it was just a 50p or a pound it never quite felt enough you know it needed to be five pounds ten pounds i was putting on the line so if i won i was getting 50 60 pounds from that evening and if i lost well i've lost five or ten but i've had a really fun evening i i really liked that that level of stakes um that goes into betting and and and it links up with push your luck of course um you know placing a bet and hoping that you're going to manage to pull it off particularly in a game that's relatively random like poker um but the the excitement that you get in just the excitement from gambling essentially is um it's real you know the the dopamine rush the adrenaline involved in all of this there's no wonder people get addicted to this stuff and thankfully um i was going to say i don't have an addictive personality but you've only got to look at themselves and board games behind me to know that uh there's probably some things i'm addicted to but thankfully gambling isn't one of them but in a board game if they can pull off that same um thrill but without the money being at stake then that's fantastic so games that do it really well my favorite is alftoyvil conraus i think

that's a wonderful example of a game where you know you feel like you're gambling you are essentially gambling but you're gambling with fake money but the gameplay is exciting enough that you don't really notice that there's nothing more at stake than who wins or loses the game you know it doesn't really matter it's just you get still get those thrills of the big wins and the big losses and uh you know okay i'm gonna put this ridiculously um ambitious bet down and then can i pull it off you know it's that's so exciting i like bedding games gambling games like um camel up where we're racing those camels around the track and we're betting on which camels are going to win and you know and then seeing your camel running ahead falling behind you know pushing its way through at the last moment and then revealing who's bet on what and who gets the money i mean it's satisfying stuff it's why people enjoy a day out at the races okay just that excitement of having a having an interest a vested interest in some sort of outcome of this particular game and number one on my list of the hundred board game mechanisms that i love is something which doesn't feature in an awful lot of games but when it does i get really excited about it i really enjoy a game that can pull off a trap yeah when i was a kid i played a lot of dover patrol with my dad and dover patrol is a precursor to stratego it's essentially the same game really but

you're moving pieces around the board and the other player doesn't know what your piece is okay because it's facing you and so they've got to choose to attack your pieces but they're attacking them blind and then both pieces are revealed okay and then the player with the highest ranked piece wins that particular battle and the other piece is eliminated and so you gradually whittle your way through the armies you gradually gather information about whose pieces are what and where they are but among these pieces there are bombs or mines and you're trying to get to the player's flag and so there's nothing more satisfying than having a really powerful piece sat there and pretending that it's the flag now you don't have to outright lie i've separated this out from lying because this is more about bluffing it's about the fact that your actions in the game imply to the other players that something is true and then if the other players fall for it well that's on them i never said that that was the flag when you attacked that bomb there and lost your most powerful piece that's not on me i never said that it was the flag okay you deduced that from my actions and maybe i led you down that path a little bit okay but there's something really satisfying about setting a trap and then your opponent falling for it okay as i say doesn't feature in enough games i'd really like to see more opportunities for me to set traps and then other people fall into those traps in a recent game of dungeon bowl i was playing um my

opponent was better than me doing better than me winning the game essentially they'd just grabbed the ball and there was no way i was going to be able to catch them all i had was a tiny little nobler which is like a little goblin character he wasn't going to be able to deal with my my opponents um monsters that they they had control of and they were going to run away with the ball and score a touchdown okay but what they hadn't noticed was that there was a treasure chest sat just near them okay and i had spotted it i knew that there was a treasure chest there sat right near them they hadn't grocked it and those treasure chests tend to explode when you open them and knock the players over that are adjacent to them so all i needed to do was kind of tempt my opponent into staying around that treasure chest area and then i could get in there with my little nobler my little goblin i could open that chest and yes i'm sacrificing my nobler because he's going to be knocked over too but i could knock over my opponent and the ball was going to scatter and i was back in with a chance what a satisfying moment in a game when the player doesn't see it they don't see it coming they've walked into your trap and then you pull it off and you have that big dramatic moment in the game okay i love traps let's have more of those please game designers watching this games with traps right up my street and if you know of any games with good sort of trap mechanisms in them let me know because i want to play them and all that leaves me with is telling you my number one board game mechanism which i

really don't enjoy so we've counted down from 10 down to one this is the final one on the list the mechanism that i really really don't enjoy in games and it might feel minor to you and it might feel petty but i hate it when a game has a card which says play this card search the discard pile and find another card choose a card to play or even search the deck okay play this card you can search through the deck and then there's another card to play can you imagine if this happened in wingspan that deck of cards particularly with the expansions if there was a card which said search the discard pile or search through the deck and find a bird that you want to play oh my god i would absolutely hate it it would be so slow the other players would be spending their time looking through that deck everybody else has just sat there bored oh come on get on with it you know but but they're not doing anything wrong that player because that's what the card allows them to do now by rights it should be an interesting mechanism right in theory it works you know okay you've got a choice of different cards so let's lay but so many cards in those discard piles i love the game abyss the abyss is my second favorite game of all time but i remove those cards the cards and tiles which say search through the discard pile and choose oh i just take them out the game is better without them the game works without them it doesn't ruin anything and those cards just serve to slow the

game down okay it's the i've mentioned previously on my list of ten things the the the ability to use other players powers and it's a very similar feeling that this creates in me except this is worse because you've got so many options available and they're searching through an egg what does this card do oh okay let's get into the rule book and just check just clarify what does this card do here okay right now i've gone through the entire deck but actually that one i saw earlier was was a nice card let's go back through the deck again for a second time see if we can find that card and it just goes on and on and on i hate it it's a mechanism that i would advise you never employ in your games as a designer and if you do employ it in your games i will do my best to throw that card away in fact i probably won't throw it away because i can't bring myself to do so i'll tuck it under the insert and nobody will ever know that that card exists if they're playing the game with me so anyway that's my top 100 board game mechanisms of all time and 10 that i really don't like i hope you enjoyed it if you did please leave me some more comments please subscribe to the channel please share my videos around we could really do with more subscribers on this channel we're still relatively small i hope you enjoyed the journey and i'll see you on a future video all the best

Progress saved