I Reviewed the BGG Top 100 Board Games
Transcript
hi my name is ben this is board game dad and today i'm going to be reviewing board game geek's 100 top ranked games i'm gonna be pretty hard on all of these games in fact there are only 12 that i'm highly recommending 12 out of 100 that's a lot of material to cover so instead of an introduction i will use the first game as an example of how i'll conduct this review the first game is gloomhaven and with each of these games the first thing i'll do is briefly describe what it's about so in gloomhaven you are basically exploring towns and cities and dungeons and different land you're just fighting monsters and you're using cards to do that and actually has some excellent card mechanics to drive the gameplay now some special notes so i do have a special note about gloomhaven the thing about gloomhaven is i feel much about it being the number one board game as i would feel if somebody told me that golf was the number one sport it's not so much that it's a description of how it is as a board game rather a description of how limited we are in our vocabulary to call it a board game i don't want to say that gloomhaven isn't a board game because like saying that golf isn't a sport it takes away some of the dignity of something that is very popular with a lot of people and a lot of people find enjoyable but it's like a board game with an asterix and the asterix is a
role-playing shared experience i mean this is a shared story that you go through run through with your friends that's my special note and that category if when we encounter more games like that i'm going to call these adventure games that brings me to the next part which is what you'll like i am going to tell you what anybody will like about each game and what they might not like with gloomhaven you're going to love it if you like a game with a strong theme and a game that tells a story but you're not going to like it if you're like me and you don't like as much discovery when you play a game so uh lastly for my personal rating i don't feel very personally i don't feel very strongly about the game i would say like it's a three but objectively the game is really well done so i i mean i guess i would say it's a four but i don't really want to play it so not for me it's my personal rate ranking okay so that's that's the formula for this review moving on to the next game we've got brass brass and lancaster are both on this list and they are both economic games so what's going on is you are building uh canals and you're building railroads in order to establish routes through which you can trade different commodities and there's a whole economy of things that can be traded both sold and purchased during the game so ideally you want to buy low and sell
high but you also need to establish a network in order to get a supply chain this is a very interesting economic game but because of the amount of management that's involved you might not like it if it could be a little bit taxing for me personally the theme doesn't very much appeal and i do think the game is more drawn out with the different ages that it has so i feel a little neutral about it a three out of five the next game is pandemic legacy season one at number three so this is a game where you probably heard pandemic before you are fighting off a world pandemic and uh it's a cooperative game which i'm you know it takes a lot for me to get really excited about a cooperative game i've got to say i they're not they're also not usually my style i enjoy playing them and i enjoy playing with any group but cooperative games aren't really my thing you would like this game if uh you like a strong theme there is a really great tension that builds through the course of the game and if you really like a good cooperative game but you might not like it for the luck aspect i do find that games of pandemic depend less on what the players do and more on what the cards are and then with pandemic you've got alternating strengths and weaknesses with if you win a game you are made weaker if you lose a game you're made stronger you've got that going on as
well i feel better than neutral though i gave this game a four the next game number four is gloomhaven jaws of the lion which i feel is just a more accessible version of gloomhaven in fact i would say if you're watching this video to know whether or not gloomhaven is a game for you it's probably not a game for you because people who like that kind of game are already going to know what it's about and they'll already be into it you're not going to need me to tell you but if you're curious gloomhaven jaws of the lion is where you start but i still feel natural about it so i give it a three next game number five is terraforming mars terraforming mars is a game where you are trying to to uh get points for making the planet mars inhabitable and you're doing this by changing tiles and building oxygen and increasing the temperature there's a lot of really cool things going on here thematically but i have made a lot of noise about not liking this game i don't like it because it is the first game in a category i'm going to introduce it is the luck mismatch what i mean by luck mismatch is that when i play terraforming mars the seriousness of the theme and the seriousness of the gameplay makes me expect a lot more strategy and not so much luck i get really frustrated by the luck in this game because ultimately what you can do or not do is determined
by the cards that you get during the course of the game so it's not that i don't like luck but i don't like luck when it frustrates my efforts to be strategic but thematically this is a very rich game you would love it if you like a space theme uh you might not like it if you don't like a very very long game or or if you think that a game a strategic game that depends on cards would be frustrating to you so i don't like it i gave it a two number six is twilight imperium fourth edition this is not the only time we're going to see twilight imperium this is an epic game of conquering the galaxy each player has a alien race that they're using to spread out and spread influence and fight each other they have technology tracks there's a lot going on when you play this game this can be like a 10 12 hour game it is very very involved so you'd love it if you love a strong theme space you'd love it if you like an epic game or if you want a day-long experience uh mechanically it just has everything going on but the duration is a big drawback for a lot of people i put a three on here i don't feel like a three i feel like a four i mean it is so much fun but it's really hard to play it often because of how long it takes
it also creates another category which i'm going to refer to in this review it's the category of games that have more than what is needed there's a little too much game here involved i mean that's why the game takes so long it could have well i like games that are streamlined where the essence of the game is embodied in a more it doesn't have to be simple but it doesn't have to be overwhelmingly complex by the way there is a little bit of color coordination if you're looking at the csv purple relates to complexity pink relates to theme and teal relates to mechanics you'll learn it as we go along so number seven number seven is arc nova arkanova you're building a zoo and interestingly it is it feels very similar to terraforming mars because you're building your zoo using cards you've got tile placement just like terraforming mars you've got objectives that players are investing in just like terraforming mars they call them conservation projects um but i do think it's a lot more streamlined so you would like this game if you like the card mechanic um where you're cycling through the different actions that you can do and the longer you wait to perform an action the stronger the action becomes it's a really brilliant mechanic you won't like the game because of its luck element if luck is an issue but
because it's more streamlined i like it more than terraforming mars and i gave it a four okay number eight is star wars rebellion and here is where i have to confess that i have not played all of these games and the reason why i haven't played all these games is because i'm a dad with a day job so sometimes when there are games that just aren't very interesting to me i don't prioritize them i haven't prioritized star wars because i'm not into um ip games intellectual property games just doesn't really strike a chord with me uh i haven't even looked into this one so i'm gonna have to skip number eight we're going to number nine which is gaia project guy project is a re-implementation of terra mystica which is later on the list rather than describe gaia project i'm going to wait until tara mystica and describe them both then for number 10.
number 10 is spirit island right now and it is a cooperative game um that is absolutely brilliant it is so complex it is it's one of these games where players have different player powers they are spirits that are trying to protect the island from these invading explorers and these explorers are you know have have predicted moves they know what the explorers are going to do so they need to stop disease from spreading through the island and uh get rid of as many explorers as they can this is a brilliantly designed game it is probably the most complex um cooperative game that i've played and because of its complexity you might really like this game you could really get into this game but because of its complexity you might really not like this game i personally i you know it takes so much time and if i'm going to play something complex or rather if i'm going to play something cooperative it's hard when there's a differential in how experienced people are when the game is so complex so i feel kind of neutral about it and i gave it a 3 but that doesn't mean it's bad it just means my personal opinion is that i don't want to play this game so much number 11 is war of the ring that's an
ib game i'm sorry it's not for me i got to skip it okay number 12 through the ages a new story of civilization so this is a game where you are buying cards that come out in a market your you know as you take cards the market fills up and the ones that are farther on one side are more expensive than the ones on the other side and each of these cards helps you build an economy helps you build your war helps you make your science what you're trying to do is be competitive with uh the other players to have the most successful civilization so i think it is i i think it is very very interesting but it's also very long so you would love this game for its theme there's a lot to focus on as you're trying to competitively draft these cards but a big weakness of the game is that it takes a really long time so for me i mean i like it a lot it's a four but i'm not going to go any higher than that because the duration i think is it is a detract uh detracts from the greatness of the game number 13 is great western trail this is a game where you are making points by collecting cattle cards and then trading them with kansas city and you're making money by selling cattle you're doing this by moving your cowboy cowgirl along a a circuit of different actions those actions change as more and more people create actions during the course of the game i do not like this game at all i do not
like anything about this game for strength it has no strengths for weaknesses it has its theme as a weakness and here's why it is the first game on this list in the category which i'm going to be calling a's and b's here's the thing with a's and b's this is also a special note for the game a's and b's means i can make a board game where the objective is to get the most victory points and you get victory points by trading three ds but in order to get three d's you need to have two c's and a b and then in order to get a b you need to have two a's but you can only trade a's if you have a c but do you see what i'm saying a bunch of variables it's just a bunch of meaningless variables and i could make a game as complex as i wanted to with a's and b's trading a's and b's and you just be like whatever it's going right over your head because all of it is meaningless all of it is meaningless and great western trail with all of the different actions that you can do like okay you go here and you can get some more cattle cards and you can go here you can build something you can trade this you can go along this track it's thematically so weak that i it doesn't catch on with me so i don't like it if i had to say anything was nice about this game at all um i do like the circuit i like that you draw a hand of cards you have to go through this circuit to perform actions to optimize your hand of cards and then you deposit the hand of cards in order to make money and you repeat that over and over again but it's a's and b's we're going to see a lot of a's and b's
on this list okay number 14 is twilight struggle twilight struggle is a cold war game it is two player only us versus the soviet union and thing about this game is it is a very luck heavy game you are drawing cards and you are playing these cards against your opponent to either spread influence or to have events happen that will either you know create battles like little war events to flex your military muscle or um store different regions of the map but like i've complained so much about games that had this luck but here's the thing about twilight struggle that i really really like it is the luck that you can deal with in a very meaningful way how how you handle the luck really really matters to me and what i love about twilight struggle is thematically it is a struggle you're trying to overpower an opponent who is racing to overpower you and both of you are only going to have bad luck like seriously every hand you draw in this game sucks so people who don't like it are going to say hate this game i always have bad bad luck and the thing i like about it is that's the premise of the game the premise of the entire game is you have bad luck how are you going to deal with it and how are you going to spin it to your advantage that really works for me so luck that you can deal with in a
meaningful way thematically i think it's fantastic mechanically with the way that the cards work i think it's fantastic the duration is a big drawback this is a long long game it could take four hours probably um sometimes it can end early though how you when there are certain diff different victory conditions so it doesn't have to take four hours but it could yet i recommend this game i recommend this game with the caveat that one it's it could be too long for you and two you seriously might hate the luck but thematically i think it works and i think it's meaningful number 15 is dune imperium this is an ip game that i have played and it is a well-rounded game all of the things work what you're what you're doing is it's basically a deck builder you're using the cards in your hand to perform actions but the cards that you don't use for actions are the cards you get to use to buy your next card and grow your hand so you got to decide okay well this is a really valuable card if i spend it but if i use it i can do this action instead i love that i think it was doing very very well done um i would recommend the game but i just i'm so not interested in ip games i played with friends and i think it's a great game i why i have such a bias i don't i read dune i don't like the book dune movie was okay anyway number 16 is scythe
scythe is probably the the first game on this list that is perfect um if if you like what it's about i mean this is an alternate history game where you have a little bit of economy you're getting workers you're getting resources using the workers to uh spread out and harvest from different regions of the map and then you have these little warriors and mechs and things that are going out to defend your area so if somebody invades you there can be a battle and you use cards to resolve the battle but um an in each player has a unique ability that you're trying to capitalize on plus rather than being a victory point game there is a you know victory condition that you're racing to fulfill um the game i haven't i have no criticisms of this game at all it is perfect um but here's the thing i'm not always in the mood to play it or i'm rarely in the mood to play it actually because i don't like so much i don't like the risk of combat in the game somebody called it a threat of war game it's not a war game it's a threat of war game and i don't like the tension that the threat of war adds i think that's my problem with it but if you can handle that the game is mechanically it's perfect number 17 is castles of burgundy
castles of burgundy is an old old classic it's a dice game by the way as we go through this list i'll get faster and faster but castles of burgundy is a dice game we're using the dice to place different actions you'll like it for the dice it seems fun but there's a lot of luck involved i gave it a 4 but man it's it's a's and b's it's done well but it's a's and b's nemesis is kind of like another adventure game all right it is an adventure game but it's a it's a horrifying adventure game you're trying to escape a spaceship from an alien that's going to attack and could possibly kill you um thematically it's very very interesting it has an element of luck that completely makes it uninteresting to me i don't want to play it it's very very hard i actually i don't like it at all so i gave it a one but if again those of you who like an adventure story driven type game nemesis might be for you 19 is seven wonders duel this is a military uh and economic uh head-to-head kind of game where you're competing to draft cards that will make your um kingdom stronger than your opponent's kingdom there's a excellent tension about this game i can't think of any reason why you wouldn't want to play it and that's why i recommend it okay number 20 is brass lancashire it is
now i've now i've confessed to you that i haven't played all these games so i haven't played birmingham i have played lancashire the same thing applies but i mean i would guess birmingham birmingham could be different i'm not going to say much more about brass concordia 21. this is a absolutely dry thematic game it it's you're settling italy could not be more boring but the way that you're doing it is kind of it's kind of like a deck builder you are always holding all of your cards and when you play a card it performs an action and then you can't play that card again until you play the card that lets you pick up all of your cards again so but when you pick up all your cards you get points for how many or you get money for how many cards you're picking up and that is your turn so you want to play as many cards as you can because before you pick up because picking up is not a very effective turn you get basically more efficient if you can draw it out so mechanically i love it i love this game but it is a's and b's it's my it's my favorite a's and b's game so you will like it if you like the card mechanic it's worth looking at thematically it's so dry yet i recommend it it's one of my favorite games ever it's been on my top 10 list for several years 22 is feast for odin this is the same category of more than i
need in a game it is by juve rosenberg evade rosenberg is an excellent designer here's how he would summarize a feast for odin he took all of the games he ever made put it in one box called it feast for odin it's vikings settling exploring getting islands getting sheep and mating them and putting tiles on a table and just every it's oh gosh it's everything it's so complex it's there's so much to do it is just too much game it doesn't it doesn't need to be that complicated that's how i feel so you would love this game if you like complexity and you just want to do everything you just love having lots and lots and lots and lots of options it's work replacement too you will hate this game if you don't like games that are very complex i hate this i like games that are complex but i hate this game because it's a's and b's and it's too much game it doesn't it doesn't feel eloquent so i get but i give it a two i didn't give it a one number 23 is tara mystica it's a game that's an area control game and players get income when they take the buildings from their player board and put more of them on the map the more buildings they put out there the more income they expose now points and victory is driven by objectives that you can satisfy during the game but at the end of the game it's all done by competitions there's a competition for the longest unbroken strand of settlements and there's competition for advancing on these cult
tracks the thing that i didn't like and i haven't liked this the last time i played either i used to love this game by the way but in the end it felt like i was just filling time i had already secured my position on several cult tracks but i needed to keep playing just so that nobody could overcome me now i knew that there was nothing else i could do for any other additional value it was only cult tracks and i felt like i was just drawing the game out just to make sure that my position was secure i didn't like that i really didn't like feeling the time so it drew the game out too much and for the first time i thought huh i think that kind of like i don't like it as much as i used to anyway you will like it because of the area control mechanic the complexity is there is a lot of things to consider it's it's very intuitive as you play but the complexity might uh be negative for you or you might feel like i feel and in the end it's just filling time so i kind of went from a a five i used to really like this game but it's old and maybe it's just been displaced by um newer games i don't know now concerning gaia project gaia project is a re-implementation of tay mystica it makes the cult tracks a little bit more interesting it takes place in space it's different it has some improvements but i don't think the improvements are
substantial enough to make the game significantly better if you don't like tara mystica so both of them are pretty much the same ranking in my book the next game is wingspan number 24 wingspan is a game that is a card driven game where you are collecting bird cards and the bird cards modify the actions that you can take so you can get eggs you can get food you can draw more cards these are the different things you do but when you have more birds it allows you to trigger different events it's a beautiful game and you'll like it for that mechanic it is very nice to play but you also might not like it for the same mechanic which is that it is played very isolated so that's one of the biggest criticisms of wingspan it's talked about a lot especially here i feel like it's not the worst game ever though i am going to give it a 2.
arkham horror is a cooperative horror game oh wait this is the card game oops this is the card game i've never played the card game i have played the original arkham horror but it's not really my game and i haven't played the card game anyway so i didn't rank it number 26 is eclipse second dawn of the galaxy i'm gonna wait until i get to the old eclipse since i haven't played the new one yet now clank number 27 is clank this is the legacy game i'm going to talk about it even though i've only looked at the original clank but that's later on the list so basically this is a deck builder game where you are using your cards to get treasure and you're kind of trying to screw over everybody else by making some noise and then getting out so that the monsters will eat your opponents and not you and then that way you can get the most treasure that's what's going on the thing is the way that the monsters come about is by drawing out of a bag so there's two elements of luck stacked upon each other one is the deck building element cards that you draw in order to perform actions and the other is you're pressing your luck because how deep can you go before the monster attacks you is the question you're always asking to me it's too much luck stacked on luck but the mechanics make the game very interesting so you would like that game for the the card mechanic you might dislike it because of the luck and uh i i would i would call it a luck mismatch
because i'm okay with one level of luck but not not two 28 is root root is one of my favorite games so i recommend it here's the thing though it's an asymmetrical game you can play four players in this game where every player has a different set of rules and even a different set of victory conditions so the complexity to understand going oh i didn't see what the game is about the game is about dominance in the woodlands and so the different characters are different animal types and they have different abilities but you're using dice and to modify your warriors as you move them into different contested regions and fight each other and you also have certain things that you can build in order to get victory points or in order to create goods and make more victory points there's there's a few things going on here the the problem with the game i can't very easily explain it because it's asymmetrical so much going on everyone's playing by a different set of rules that is why the game is so interesting and why you would love this game it is also why you might not like this game because it takes a long time to explain yet i have played this with a lot of different groups and people like it even even though it is complex so i recommend the game that means it's a five out of five okay 29 is viticulture and viticulture you are making points by growing grapes and making wine and aging
the wine it's a great worker placement game and it's very well done like scythe so that's why you would love the game i can't think of any reason to not like the game except for one thing that i didn't write down on my cheat sheet here and that is in viticulture it's really a boring theme i don't like making wine as a board game and you may not like that either but if you don't mind that theme it's a really great work replacement there's a little element of luck but it's not so much that i can't handle it i would say i recommend it a lot of people really love it um yeah viticulture so number 30 is everedell i can't believe i should really put a two well i don't know i'm trying to be objective i'm gonna put a two for every doll listen here's the thing with everdel it is a card game that's all it really is you're it's a card game where you can get really good combos to make more interesting moves and most importantly get more actions the winner in everdel is basically the person who can have the most actions and they do this by getting great combos drawing cards identifying combos drafting them off the table um and then there are some objectives that they're trying to satisfy you'd like it for the cards you won't like it because it doesn't it has nothing to do with animals and woodlands and forests and stuff got some beautiful components though so i i don't like it i think it's it could it could be so much more thematic and it's just not so i i call
it a two it's oh and i talked about terra mystica everdell really feels like you're feeling time because you are enticed to keep going and people just keep playing more and more turns and other people can stop like the game can be over for three players and a fourth player is still playing i don't like how long that game drags on thirty one is orleans is a bag management game you're using pieces from a bag but what you're doing with these pieces is you're drawing tokens basically and the arrangement of tokens is what allows you to complete certain actions so they have little pictures on them but let's just say they're colors so maybe it's like a yellow and a red and a blue can go on this and do that action but a yellow red and a black can go here and do that action so you're so you're pulling your tokens out you're like hmm well maybe i can put my yellow one right here but then how am i going to spend my my my black well i could do there's a lot of things you can decide i think that's a really fascinating mechanic thematically what you're doing though is you're spreading out across the land and making little towns and you're getting things to augment your player board and make it stronger and your your um you're building things and getting resources and trying to get victory points from resources so thematically it's very uninteresting i i think thematically it's weakness but the bag management this might be the only bag management game in the top 100 and it's a great mechanic i give it a four out of five
number 32 is lost ruins of rn arnac this is an exploration game where you have to perform research in order to get more materials so that you can explore more places and get cards there's a little bit of a card or deck builder too but holy moly it's a's and b's oh it doesn't mean anything i like the card mechanic that's why you might like it thematically it doesn't it's so insignificant i give it a four it plays very well uh kind of reminds me of um the tassels of burgundy almost where it's meaningless but it's fun 33 is mage night board game this is an adventure game it is probably my favorite adventure game because it is the gamiest of adventure games this is not a legacy game you don't have characters that are leveling up and revealing new cards and all these things it's just you are spreading out overboard you got different objectives and it's basically a hand management game as you get hurt you're taking wound cards which block up your your your hand so you're trying to figure out different ways that you can make more efficient moves and grow your hero's abilities i think it's really really well done it's a bit of a you know it's a lot of material it's a big game thematically it's fascinating though so i have a strength i give it no weaknesses but i give it a four because
there there's a lot you know what maybe my weakness is that it there's a lot involved in this game it is a bigger game number 34 is food chain magnate this is one of my favorite games ever it is a card drafting game i suppose you're you're buying employees to build a marketing campaign in a neighborhood and different restaurant locations and make sure you have cooks that can prepare the different kinds of food so you can sell to the clients who are hungry it is thematically one of the best games ever it it feels like you are literally running a business it is so thematically strong it is extremely unforgiving you you you will be destroyed if you mess up even in the beginning so there's that but it's incredible i if this was a longer review i would talk at length about it i'm going to go on though 35 is barrage barrage is a game where you are trying to generate energy by placing dams it's a heavy game it's got a great tightness about it getting resources and and area control as you're placing different dams on the river thematically it makes a lot of sense it's it's a lot gameplay is different but it feels a lot like brass except i think the gameplay is more intuitive and more interesting
so it is one of my favorite like heavy hero games but it is also very hard because of how tight the um economy is the resources you need in order to do things you will always feel like you don't have enough so it can seem very unforgiving too 36 is puerto rico this is a new category game okay puerto rico you're settling puerto rico you've got shipments coming in you're trying to put little workers out there and get uh you're harvesting different things and you've got buildings that can process this and give you difficulty points in different ways but um you know it falls into the category of almost being two euro it's an older game and it is it's just so classic that it's almost like watching a black and white movie right if there's a reason not to like it it's because you don't want to watch black and white movies anymore if that connects i love the action selection one player picks what they want to do and everybody gets to do something um but thematically i think that's the weakness yet i'm still gonna give it a four marvel i'm not a fan you know what not only am i not a fan of ip games i don't like marvel i don't even like the movies so i have not played this but i've heard very good things i've heard very good things it might be worth looking at on somebody else's channel not mine 38 is caverna the cave farmers oh man um i haven't talked about agricola wait
really okay i haven't talked about agricultural yet i'm gonna get there soon basically this is a work replacement game but it's a more complex version of agricola where instead of a farm you're establishing a cave village it has more game than is needed i think agricola is better so i'll get to a curricula soon too many bones it's got a great dice mechanic it's kind of a role player game you're building your character using dice but it's not a game for me so i'm not gonna go into it blood rage okay uh there is a classic game called cosmic encounter which is and blood rage is a lot like it i'm going to describe both of them so basically what you're trying to do is uh have these interactions with other players and you want to beat them by playing cards you're playing different strength cards and then you have reinforcement cards the higher number wins but if you took just that idea which comes from cosmic encounter and you added to it little miniatures like lots of very detailed miniatures and then lots of special abilities that can make your incentive to fight very different maybe you get points just for having fights or maybe you get points for losing fights and everyone's little objectives are being hidden from them during the time you're playing so you don't know what people are doing you reveal those scoring cards later there's a lot more going on cosmic encounter is a more stripped-down version it's it's old it's very it's like the 70s cosmic encounter really gets at the core of what i like about that and blood rage
adds all this extra stuff thematically it looks really cool i mean like or the component-wise i should have said components instead of theme the components are excellent the luck and the chaos you know i shouldn't complain because i like cosmic encounter a lot and it has luck and chaos and you don't know what's going on it can be a lot of fun but there's just too much it's too much game too much going on so i give it i feel neutral about it three out of five pax premiere i'm gonna play pax premiere next week and it looks fantastic but i don't know so much about it yet so i'm skipping it agricola agricola you're building a farm you need to create plots of land that you can plow for for produce for vegetables you have got animals that you have to put fences around in order to create little pastures and you're mating them you got to build your house you got to get family members it is such an intuitive and thematic game it makes so much sense you've got to feed your workers it's uva rosenberg's best work in my opinion and so many others of his games are just elaborations upon agricola agricola is one of my favorite games thematically and mechanically it is wonderful there is nothing wrong with it it has no weakness there i said it and i highly recommend it okay i want to skip a few 99 100. uh you ready i have not played underwater cities i really want to try marika kaibo
i need to look at anachrony pandemic light i mean pandemic legacy season two i've already played season one i don't know if i want to do season two it's a lot of legacy for me mansions of madness this is like a horror cooperative game i think i don't know it's not for me back into the games that i have played ready okay boy we got four we're only halfway done 48 the crew the quest for planet nine this is a trick taking cooperative game with the objective of making sure the right people take the right tricks it has communication limitation you cannot say what cards you have but you have to cooperate mechanically that's amazing so i highly recommend this game the only thing you might not like about the game is uh you know like a lot of cooperative games it's based on luck but also thematically does it has nothing to do with exploring outer space it's so slapped on but it falls in that category of luck that you can deal with it in a meaningful way i like what you have to do with luck you have cards that are dealt you don't know what people's cards are you can't communicate so you have to cooperate by sending signals non-verbally by the cards you play brilliant zulkin mayan calendar this is a worker placement where you put the workers on gears and the gears rotate so as they rotate the actions become stronger and you perform the action once you take the worker off mechanically it's brilliant
that's why i like this game a lot but it has no meaning at all so strategy and mechanics are why you would love it theme is why you wouldn't i give it a four on mars this is a lacera game fataliser number 50 you are settling mars it's a worker placement where you're moving between the orbit of mars where all the science and cool stuff comes from earth imports from earth and you got to bring that stuff down to the planet and you've got actions on the planet for settling the planet exploring it more so thematically it's wonderful lacerda is brilliant at crafting thematic games but it is extremely complex complex enough that you might not like the game i i could have given it a five i think i love it but here's my thing i don't play it enough because it's so complex so if a game is that complex i can't like why whatever 51 mission deep sea as far as i know i i rated this one i haven't played it i've only played the crew i'm assuming they're basically the same it's just like an expansion on it but i don't know maybe i'm wrong uh i should just clear this because i haven't played it power grid is a game that i absolutely hate it's a you know what barrage we talked about generating power in power grid the way you generate power is by bidding on factories and you just keep doing that over and over again it is not interesting it doesn't belong in the top 100. i even put that on my other video but mechanics
if you really like bidding why does it say economy if you really like bidding you would like this um gosh you wouldn't like it because because it's boring as heck um theme i gave it one clans of caledonia this is an action game where you know what this is this is agricultural brass because you've got commodities that are on a market prices are going up and down and you've got different ways you can generate those commodities on your own so you can sell them too you're trying to fulfill contracts but there are so many con you've got you've got uh what is it milk and cheese and bread and wheat and cows and sheep and wool and the beer there's so many things that you can buy and meat and what's the thing lamb lamb parts what do you call lamb meat anyway um it's just so and it's all it all doesn't matter it's all just different things that you're trading for different prices there's a's and b's all the way so you might like it because the economy could be really fun it's agricultural brass so how i'm going to describe it but thematically it's totally dumb i call it a two lahar visit another um juve rosenberg game number 54 here i played it a long time ago i really liked it i feel like i should give it a four instead of a three i really liked it but it has that like two
euro it's you're you know you're basically deciding if you want to buy or rent all of these different things like do you want to buy the ship this building or do you want to use this building and you got to establish different costs and you're kind of bidding things out from other players and stuff i played it a long time ago i really liked it but thematically it's just so not interesting star wars imperial assault i'm not an i'm not into star wars i'm not in taipei or star wars kingdom death monster i'll tell you what i looked at this game and i wanted to see how to play it and i was immediately like nope don't want to play this game it's like you're moving miniature monsters around a grid and trying to fight them and stuff and well you're trying to survive it is just not my thing mechs and minions didn't even look at it um crocodile this is the most interesting category crocodile here you know why this is games that look like beautiful pieces of furniture you can like put this on your table and it just looks pretty but it's a dexterity game you're flicking these discs or you're hitting these different pegs you're trying to get them into the hall and um the components are beautiful and if you like dexterity it's very interesting i would definitely say that like gloomhaven i mentioned earlier it doesn't classify as a board game because it's a it's a flicky wooden game um and it has absolutely no theme so there's that but it's not bad number 59 is pandemic legacy season zero i have not played this one either i'm assuming it has many of the same mechanics as uh
pandemic legacy season one uh although i'm not sure what sets it apart so we'll go to number sixty which is the quacks of quandlenbag crux of coin is another bag management game uh like uh orleans except in this one there's a press your luck element what you're trying to do is make a potion by drawing tokens out of your bag you're trying to draw as many tokens as you can before you draw too many cherry bomb tokens and the uh potion explodes and then after everyone has either stopped or their potion has exploded there's a little bit of scoring and then people buy more tokens throw them in the bag and have a new round uh this is a game that you will like to play with your family if you like games with a lot of luck it is a game that really anybody could win because the only real decision is when to stop drawing and how you want to use the money you earn to buy more tokens so a lot of luck involved but the reason you won't like it is because there's a lot of luck involved i don't like this game at all i feel like it's playing bingo just or everybody simultaneously running their own personal lottery the decision making is not meaningful to me at all i don't like it i do play with my kids but not the best game design number 61 is the gallerist this is also designed by vitala serda who designed on
mars which i mentioned earlier but in the gallerist i think this is his best game and the reason why is because uh thematically there's an excellent art show or you are the curator of an art gallery and you're discovering artists and commissioning their artwork and then you're selling it or you're showing it off in your museum and you're trying to get points from doing this successfully so there's an excellent economy to this and a wonderful worker placement mechanic where if somebody goes in a location where you previously went you get to perform another action so there are some excellent combos that can be done it is a less complicated lacerated game and just really addictive gameplay i think that it is very well rounded although the work replacement mechanic is very interesting so i highly recommend the gallerist although you know what i should put in there if there's anything to not like about it it would be the complexity because it is all the serda games are quite complex lisboa is another lacera game except it's one that i haven't played i've heard good things about it number 63 cascadia this is a tile placing game that people are really excited about it does not interest me at all
uh i have read the rules several times and considered buying it but it's just so um it's like it's recycling a lot of other tile placing mechanics there's not very much that's unique about this game it has a nature theme but the theme is very much slapped on there um the scoring is based on different objectives that can be different every time so there it's i mean it is it is just a run-of-the-mill tile placing game with very little that makes it set apart um so but tile placing games are fun so you know you're these are hex tiles by the way um thematically there's nothing to it so theme is the weakness um what's wrong with the mill like it's not bad it's just not exciting so that's why i give it a three i'm neutral about it um so we'll go on number 64 is uh paladins of the west kingdom paladins of the west kingdom is made by garfield games which makes several games on this list i'm going to talk about this one more when i get to architects 65 is azul azul is another tile placing game mechanically it's very swift and very tactile this has some wonderful components like these really nice tiles that you're picking up and you get to take all of one color and
then the ones that are not the same color get kind of left into a trash pile and i guess what you're trying to not do is be the one who has to take the the leftover tiles that you can't fit into your tableau of tiles um it's very abstract it's you're supposed to be a portuguese top mosaic maker but there is nothing thematic about this game at all it is a very abstract but satisfying tile placing game with very abstract scoring mechanics no theme at all and i i'm kind of over it i used to think it was really swift gameplay but it's very um thematically uninteresting 66 is the seventh continent this is another adventure game this one is card driven so you're you're looking at cards that tell you to read other cards and um everything that you can do is based on a deck of cards and as the deck depletes that's when you die or you expire once the deck is depleted uh i just it's not a game for me it's really not i don't like discovering things i'd rather i'd rather know so 67 is eclipse now i didn't mention eclipse second dawn for the galaxy so i didn't talk about second dawn for the galaxy because i haven't played it i've only played the original eclipse so i'm hoping that my description is essentially you know
they've changed they've made improvements you definitely are going to play second dawn of the galaxy that's the one that's in print right now but this is another epic exploring uh like building an economy as you put your position on different planets gaining resources building a technology track there's a little bit of warfare involved you're invading these other planets there's a lot going on in this game and in my opinion this game is superior to twilight imperium i just feel like it's
more tan tangible i feel like there's a there's a lot more chaos going on in twilight imperium and eclipse is elegant i think elegant is a good way to describe eclipse i love the economy in this game thematically it's excellent it's a very well it can be a very long game that's probably why you wouldn't play it i did put it as a five for me but i didn't put it as a recommend because even though i love it um i'm always wary of recommending really heavy epic games number 68 is android netrunner this is a two-person card game it's also ip but um it has a neat like bluffing mechanic you're building these lines of cards and you're using them to attack your opponent but you don't know which line of cards your opponent is building where their their victory points are so you try different things and the opponent can bluff or they you know were they they're buffering a line of cards that is actually of no value there's some excellent tension um the game is is done the producer lost the license so it won't be printed in new boxes anymore but you can get a second copy i'm kind of neutral about it anymore so i gave it a three i have not played aeon's end
i've heard that i should number 70 through the ages a story of civilization so this is just an older version of the the other game that i've already talked about i i've never played it before it is older i'm assuming it's similar 71 race for the galaxy this is a very popular card game with lots of distinct cards um it is you know it's it's a very swift quick easy to play if you have familiarity with it i don't like it at all because it's another one of these a's and b's it's just it's all symbols every card has symbols on it every card is different so you're looking at your hand of cards you're trying to figure out how you're going to make combinations of cards and how you're going to optimize the utility of some cards so you can get the best effect but it's all just reading different symbols okay this means this and this i i don't like that i i would like a game that has a little bit more intuition about it all right clink so i'd already talked about clink um this is the one i'm more familiar with i don't know the legacy game but um it's certainly a lot of fun just to me a luck mismatch number 73 is five tribes i really enjoy five tribes this is a game where
what you're trying to do is um it's it's a worker boy it's different it's got a monkala mechanic to it so you've got a board with lots of different groups of workers it's actually a square grid you're picking up a group of workers and you're moving them and each movement you're dropping one off just like mancala and then the last worker gets to perform an action based on where they land and the color of that worker and then those get picked off and taken off the board so you play the game until there are no workers left basically i like how tactile that is to pick them up and to move them around um it is extremely abstract it has like kind of a aladdin type theme to it there are lots of genies or gins so there's some nice artwork attached to the game on the cards but this is super a's and b's again that's what i've been calling it i think it's better than azul though because i think there's a lot more going on a lot more to think about but in a meaningful way not not too much number 74 is fields of arl that's another ube rosenberg game and in my opinion i feel much like about this one that i do about um feast for odin uh it's just a game where he goes too far with all of the mechanics and it
very little to return on what gets invested into this game this is a two-player agricultural game so lots of trading of different resources and livestock and you know you're mating them and so on but it's just it's thematically it's not very profound uh to me it's a's and b's again but teotihuan or t o t o t watkin t o t watkin city of gods is not a game i've played i has been recommended to me um and i haven't gotten to it yet 76 robertson crusoe adventures of the cursed island i this is a game where you are it's an adventure game where you're trying to survive or get help to escape a island where you and the rest of your crew have been stranded and it is a very card driven game i owned it for a few years and it never went over well with the people that i introduced it to it it's just uh very much like going on a choose your own adventure so thematically i thought it was excellent i mean the kinds of decisions that you're making are really great but there's a ton of luck and it's very very difficult give it a two agricola revised edition so i've already talked about agricola i don't think i'm going to talk about agricultural revised edition if you buy agricola this will be what you get anymore
78 voyages of marco polo so voyage is a marco polo is a i mean thematically what you're supposed to be doing is exploring parts of asia and you're moving these little explorers from city to city you're buying cities they give you a benefit but the the means of these actions are dice it's it's a worker placement or rather it's a dice worker placement game i this one really strikes me and i don't know i mean i like it but it is it has all of the same attributes as some of these what i keep calling a's and b's i mean everything is so abstract it really is abstract thematically it's not a strong game i really like the dice worker placement and i've really enjoyed it um so i suppose i recommend it i really like it but uh i would put on here the category is you know just this kind of meaningless stuff good but still good grand austria hotel i decided not to to uh rate this one or because i have played it but i played it a long time ago i did not enjoy it when i played it um i i i it was very forgettable to me so i i don't wanna i guess i feel neutral
about it um it's been a long time i've been playing games for like 12 years number 80 is seven wonders seven wonders popularized the card drafting mechanic where all players are dealt a hand of cards pick one and then pass the hand to the player on their left or right uh in this game you are trying to gather cards that will help you get resources to buy stronger cards some cards will get you points others will get you science and even military so that you can go to war with the player on your left and right so it was really exciting when i first learned it i'd never played a game like that before which is why this game is probably still on the top 100 today although that card drafting mechanic is now used by so many other games um you like this game because of that mechanic you might not like it because of its complexity the thing is it is not a game that is easily learned the first time you play it it seems like everyone i've ever taught it to is a little overwhelmed by the game and has no idea what's going on until after the game is finished and then they kind of get a sense and are willing to play again seven wonders 82 is dominant oh 81. uh lords of water deep lords of waterdeep is a game that i've looked into several times it's kind of got this um it's like the back end of d and d your the objective is to send heroes off on quests and the theme is not very interesting to me um it's not a game i've ever tried before
82 is dominant species dominant species is an epic war game with a programming mechanic this is why a type of game where earlier in the round players will choose the actions they want to do but not perform them and then after everyone has chosen their actions then the actions are performed and you can't take back the choices you made earlier so that programming mechanic is is very interesting i love the strategy involved in the game but it does have a little bit of a hectic nature to it because there are event cards that can really turn the game around so you would like it for that programming mechanic you might not like it because of its duration it could be a very long game like four to six hours although it's easy to shorten the game by modifying how many cards you play with and then there is an element of luck that makes it a little chaotic so these days i'm not as excited about it as i used to be i give it a three and maybe maybe a four but um the there is a new oceans edition of dominant species which is supposed to resolve a lot of the issues with luck 83 is kanban ev so to be honest i have not played kanban ev but i have played kanban it is another vitaliser game it was the first lacerda game that i ever tried and i got really excited by its worker placement and it's got an excellent theme he's always good with theme but um given its complexity i don't think the
payoff is as good i am not as excited by this game uh so i feel more neutral about it giving it a 3. 84 is tainted grail i know very little about that game 85 is architects of the west kingdom and i said when we saw paladins of the west kingdom that i would talk about this game company so garfield games has three games on the list when we include voyages voyagers of the north sea which we'll get to they are worker placement type games and i they fall flat for me that all of them are just kind of forgettable they're all kind of forgettable the thing about architects of the west kingdom it's worker placement and and you can place multiple workers in one spot the more workers you have the more powerful the action is but one of the actions is to send all of the workers in one spot to jail but it sounds very interesting i have never been very excited by any of the games that are produced by this company so but yeah it's it's yeah it's admirable it's okay thematically i think they're all of the games are pretty weak except for voyagers to of the north sea which we'll get to and so i have a pretty neutral neutral rating
i have not played el grande but i do know about the game it is a very early work replacement game as i understand it viticulture which has like the big worker um some games there is a large meeple and the large meeple can take a spot even if somebody else um is already blocking that spot and so that idea of the big meeple is i guess was invented for el grande which means the big right so it's a original worker placement game it has that two classic euro um theme about it that makes it a little less interesting and i haven't tried it i called it old school it's very old school 1995.
ah key flower 87 key flower honestly it's a game that i looked into years ago didn't really inspire me so i i never bought it never played it 88 is sleeping gods this is a i believe it's a cooperative game with like kind of a bunch of different scenarios but i haven't tried it yet so not not much to say here 89 k list this is another early worker placement game um it is man i i like i would have been so excited about it in 2005 when it first came out but with the kinds of work replacements and you know how that idea has been like innovate or innovated and developed over time the kinds of stuff that you can play these days is so much more interesting so it's another one of those old school games battlestar galactica number 90 this is the original game for what is now called unfathomable and so i have not played battlestar galactica i guess that's another ip that the license was lost but unfathomable is essentially the same thing it's a traitor game where somebody has a hidden role they're trying to upset all of the other players there are also monsters you're trying to fight off i was not very excited by unfathomable you might like it because of the traitor
but and in the theme um it's hard to say what is wrong with the game necessarily i just don't i'm not really into that kind of game mobasa is a game that i played too many years ago at this point um it has a neat investing mechanic about it and uh it is about settling and um establishing companies in africa to exploit that continent uh so kind of an interesting and a little bit of a kind of dark theme or um but it's been a really long time so i i guess the fact that i haven't been pulled back to it it means i feel a little neutral 92 trois tua is one of my favorite games it's because this is a dice worker placement game um where in this game you have your own dice but you also have the option of buying your opponent's dice so if you have bad luck you can essentially buy somebody else's good luck and they get to have your money but you get to have their workers i think that's really cool it's one of those games where you can do something meaningful with luck which is why i think it's an excellent game for its mechanics thematically it's okay um i highly recommend the game although it is a bit it's a little bit more of a complicated game i think it's not exactly a gateway game 93 dominion intrigue so intrigue is actually an expansion upon dominion i've
i've played intrigue and dominion it's a classic gateway board game or card game really it's it's a deck builder it's a deck builder where you have five cards and you get to perform one action and perform one buy which means buy another card and what you're trying to do is get victory points into your deck but victory points don't give you actions or money so you have to kind of get an appropriate balance i think everyone graduates from dominion eventually 94 is twilight imperium third edition because i've talked about fourth edition i'm going to skip this one 95 is raiders of the north sea again i i think that by um i called it voyages earlier in the video raiders of the north sea um by garfield games again so it's pretty forgettable and i'm not very excited by it although thematically i think this is the most interesting game that they've made lord of the rings 96 lord of the rings journeys in middle earth another game i haven't tried before elder core this is related to the arkham horror and all of these cooperative horror games i haven't tried this one i didn't like arkham horror so that's kind of why i stopped not for me lorenzo magnifico this is something that i definitely need to try i've heard a lot of really good things about it i'm i'm looking forward to trying it one day just haven't gotten around to it yet beyond the sun number 99 this is a tech
tree game this is where players are revealing cards that give abilities and they have to invest in that technology in order to gain that ability and the investment is a tree so you can go off on one branch or another branch and different levels of technology are worth victory points at the end you also have an area of space that you're trying to settle and you're getting cards for building settlements in space it's got a lot going on and one of the things i like about it it's not very combative i i really enjoy that about the game it's a game about space exploration science so i think it's an excellent work replacement game and um there is a little bit of chaos because of the technology that comes out so you won't know the start of the game what the technologies will be it's up to the players to choose the technology i do think that's very interesting but what they have to choose from is very much up to luck and then lastly 100 is tigris and euphrates tigress's in euphrates is a very rich abstract strategy game uh on a square grid actually where you're trying to spread out your influence and gain points by having more tiles of the same color and then you can steal regions of the board from other players by overpowering them the problem though is that there is an element of luck involved because you have to draw these tiles in order to place them and then
it's not it's not a thematic game at all there's there's like military and there's a theme slapped on it but it's not a meaningful theme i liked it initially but as i played it more and more and i've played it many times my enthusiasm dwindled and now i kind of feel neutral about it so that is my review of nearly 100 games there are still some some games left that i need to try out i'd love to hear what your recommendations are