Skip to main content
Loading video...

Mercurial Review: When Magic Goes Wrong

Transcript 13:22

hi everyone I'm tally this is farl and we are bored of it today we're going to review Mercurial and this is in some ways a little bit different than our usual reviews just because spoilers it's not a game that we were wild about but I just think we wanted to talk about it because it's one of these interesting examples of almost there and where things can be missteps and go wrong when this was originally something we were very excited for and at least the what it was supposed to be was very much something that we enjoy generally in other games so what what is it it's a dice manipulation engine building game and it's for two to four players and it has a magical theme you will play as a mage doing heroic deeds and crafting unknown spells

in Mercurial essentially what you're trying to do is to create spells which will generate power and then the amount of power you generate will allow you to select from a kind of if you will Victory point card that will give you a variable number of victory points uh and then kind of repeat until somebody has a set amount of these so what you're generally doing on 95% of your turns is manipulating your dice because at the start of the game and also after you complete a spell you're going to roll your dice and then you're stuck with them essentially then you have alteration cards and these let you alter the dice so you're manipulating the dice most of the time to get what you want and this is because when you come to take a spell card which are these down here you can only take them if you have matching die or resources to spend so you need to manipulate your random rooll into something you can use and often you're trying to chain certain types of spells together because you have different elements of power so you have um have to check ruin and restore and these kind of cancel each other out so you don't want both of them in one chain unless you have exactly the same amount of each in which case they they do something weird and wonderful and create Mists kind of third power um and you'll generally just work

until you have this big chain of spells in front of you that you're happy with or when you run out of dice and can't take anymore and then you'll take a turn to kind of run your spell cast your spell letting you take the victory point card and if you're lucky and meet the right condition uh one of these arcanas which gives you another way to gain and gain points the only other thing to keep in mind is that both your uh kind of semi- asymmetric uh player board or character uh has symbols on them and so do these kind of Victory Point cards heroic cards I believe they're called and if you can kind of get pairs of these symbols or or more uh or even more you will get some extra victory points for that but as I said the game will end once a player has gained a certain amount of these heroic cards and that can change depending on if you want a longer or shorter game the first thing to probably mention and something I assume you notice in the explanation is that it's a game which has a lot of stunning artwork and production but is a bit themeless and that's obviously not a problem usually we don't care too much at all about theme uh it doesn't affect our enjoyment but I think here they've fallen into the Trap of being one of those games where there's a lot of jargon essentially like you know ruin

and restore and arcas and heroic Cs and these alterations and because it's kind of un themematic you know it doesn't really feel like you're creating magic and controlling it and manipulating it it feels like you're turning a die over it it it makes it difficult to get into and kind of remember when you come back to it what all these weird words mean uh and that's just something that you you definitely are going to keep hold of the reference sheet and have to try to remember what type of card is this what type of thing does that refer to and all of those things probably the most egregious mistep though of Mercurial is the amount of Randomness it injects into the game which in many ways is kind of an efficiency puzzle trying to cast these spells as quickly as possible and as powerfully as possible while racing to get the required heroic cards uh to end the game because if you're the one who ends it you're likely the one who's going to have more heroic cards than anyone else which is probably more points but the first problem you'll encounter is you roll all the dice and what you roll is random what's in the marketplace can be random and there's not really much of a way that the marketplace shifts without players taking the cards now for example here I

haven't rolled anything which matches five out of those six cards and I just dealt these randomly by the way they're not I didn't set this up or anything so in this situation I would have to make alterations to my dice to manipulate them which is fine that's the game right but then if one of the other players players roles maybe three water symbols uh which is very common Motif down here at the moment they will then instantly be able to start working on those spells and taking those cards without doing any of the kind of groundw that I would have to do literally kind of cutting the amount of effort required to cast a spell by a significant amount and so I think you can initially see the problem here where it comes into the the different elements of is bouncing off each other then you have to question okay well I have this I need to get an alteration card let me look is there any that I can actually use that matches these that turns it into what I want and maybe there is maybe there isn't and another criticism coming on from the alteration cards is that as you play you'll take them to convert as you need but the problem is they're always situational because it's always this type of die face into that type of die face and that's very dependent on what spells you're trying to go after and this means that when you build up a hand of cards you you don't start getting

more powerful or getting these big bad combos it's just that you have a hand of cards that are situational and you might be able to adapt a little better than you could at the start of the game it's not exciting the bigger issues come where the imbalance meets that randomness because there's a very weird distribution of victory points amongst the arcas and the heroic cards the heroic cards kind of range in points from 4 to 15 but there is really no reason to ever look at the lower Point cards because having these cards and gaining them is bringing you closer to the end of the game these cards are also the main way you'll get points in the game so because a single card here could give you 15 points and you need at least four of these four point cards to equal or surpass it but then you only have one more card before you trigger the end of the game so it's it's just a weird fact that that there's so many of them in this in this heroic card deck and they kind of block out the market place from the the cards that you actually want the high point cards and I've just never seen anyone take a lower value card unless they absolutely couldn't do any better uh and it's not that hard to kind of generate spells that get you up to the these high point cards either it just takes a little bit more

time uh it's just yeah it's just very weird because it ends up blocking players giving players less choice not rewarding players for how well they can do and then you turn to the arcas and these give you a base amount of points and then some points on top base B on what spell cards you have at the end of the game and I have two examples here this one gives you one point for every four cards of any spell card any type this one gives you one point for every two spell cards that have The Ether symbol on him now from that breakdown four and two you would think that 50% of the total deck would be e cards but it's not it's only 1/3 which means that object ly this is much harder to gain points from than this one is and almost kind of uh ironically this one's actually probably arguably harder to gain as well and this is what I mean it's just there seems to not have been so much work on on the balancing of things and it just adds further and further to the frustration when you're playing this game there is a little bit of a lack of player EXC excitement for lack of a better Phrase game to game because you are essentially doing the same thing you know kind of following the same processes to complete the Spells the only real variation that comes in game to game is how frustrated

you might get and that's according to what the cards come out like and how easy or hard it is to achieve what you need to achieve overall there are games out there which do very similar things and are arguably more efficient and more fun resar for example has these Snappy kind of 4 second turns which build into a massive engine whereas here you don't really get that feeling of building anything because once you've completed the spell it's done and you start again so you don't get the satisfaction of having these big explosive turns also it is simply just too long for what it is and what it provides because of this final thoughts well being fairly harsh on Mercurial it's not so much that it's a terrible game with no redeeming qualities you know it's when you're in it and playing it's a fairly nice puzzle to work out yeah it engages you um you you know it's definitely interesting to kind of pig the way through the path to get to where you need to go you're not not having fun when it playing it it's yeah fun in the moment yeah well I I for me I think Fun's a strong word but uh it's it's not fine yeah um but yeah I just think that it's one of these things where it's obviously a more crowded Marketplace

than ever I just think there's so many more games that do it so much better uh and also there's a few things we pointed out that just don't quite sit right like the blend of randomness and kind of the fact that you're trying to be efficient is never a good mix in my opinion no I agree um it's not a game that I'm going to wake up in the middle of the night and think about but exactly like what games do you do that for quacks um but I think it's perfectly fine in the moment like I enjoyed it as we were playing it but it's just not something that's super memorable and like you say rokana probably technically does it better but probably well I can win this one and I can't win rokana so yeah I really like playing rokana I just don't think I've won a single game ever and I think I was able to win this against you so for me that gets a little bonus point in fact yes PR standard yeah yeah so that was our review of Mercurial and yeah like we said at the beginning we just wanted to talk about it a little bit because it's always interesting to see what about a game that you're very what like I was very excited for this why you don't like it what went wrong where you came up against it so hopefully that was interesting if it was please consider subscribing if you have any questions please let us know and thank you for

watching see you bye

Progress saved