Captain Sonar Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
Hey everybody, and welcome to Chairman of the board. Today I'm going to be reviewing Captain Sonar, which is a real-time game for two to eight players, which pits a team of submariners against another team of submariners, and they basically fight until one team is left standing. Now, this game is so unique and unlike anything else. Um, the idea and concept is absolutely uh so original. Um, basically each player on these teams um is has a very unique and individual role, such as being the captain and navigating your submarine, the engineer, whose whose job is to kind of ensure that every person's uh sorry, all the technology is working uh efficiently and is all uh up up for use.
You've got the uh radio operator who's trying to listen to the other captain and try and basically um deduct where they are on a map uh so that the um so you can use your technology against them. And then you've got like a weapons expert who kind of charges up your systems and the like. Now, I have to say uh before I go any further that this game really does kind of um require at least six people to get its full potential. Um, having a team of three against a team of three um really does bring the game to life and any less than that can be a bit of a stretch to um basically get the most out of the game. Uh, the game also comes with a kind of a non-real-time variant of the game, which isn't quite as good in my opinion. It's a bit more methodical, but a bit slower and takes a bit of the excitement out.
Now, this is a really strange game because I've had this in my collection for quite a while now. I've played this uh a hell of a lot, and I found it very, very hard to kind of formulate a solid opinion on it because I do have mixed feelings on the game. Because as I said, for one if in one respect I think it's so cleverly designed. The again, these unique roles in a real-time situation and it's it feels really thematic. It's so tense and you do feel like you're being tracked at any time. You could be attacked and it is super super tense and our communication is so so important in this. But the problem I have with it is kind of in relation to its you know, the nature of the game being a real-time game because it is very chaotic. At least it can be really chaotic.
And very hard to govern as well, which you'll find with a lot of real-time games because there are so many things going on at the same time that the system itself is quite fragile because you just cannot tell if someone else is cheating. I'm not saying they would or anything, but it's just it's a game that kind of relies a lot on trust and that everyone's doing the right thing. The slightest mistake can completely throw the other team off. So again, that system is very very fragile. That being said, if you've got a team of really competent players who are all in on this game, fully invested and I want to play the game to a maximum efficiency, then you're going to get a hell of a good experience out of this. It is really cleverly designed and if everybody everybody plays in an integral way and fully understands the rules, then it is a very very good game.
But as I said, the the fragility of the game is kind of a bit of a hindrance because it's not a game that you kind of bring out regularly on a game night because it has that kind of party-esque kind of a conventiony feel to it. Obviously because the the player count required is quite high as well that you're going to have to kind of teach this game to new players often and because every role is so individual, explaining it can be quite tricky because um again, there's nothing else like it. So you can't really compare it to anything else. Also, if you have one player who isn't really buying into it, isn't really know what's going on, it just throws the game into complete chaos. Um the other team, you know, say I was the radio operator and I was listening to the other team's captain, if they aren't very clear with their commands, then my whole game can just throw be thrown into complete turmoil.
And it really is um you know, the quality of the game is really dictated by the communication between the both the teams and also between the um you know, the individual teams respectively. So, as I said, the the fragility of the game is a bit of a problem for me. It is very chaotic, um very easy to point the finger at other players for ruining the game or you know, for making the game fall flat and stuff like that. And you know, you need to be in the right headspace for this. You need to be um fully engaged and fully on board and invested in the game because if you're not, as I said, the game will fall apart. Um so, very good deduction here. I I think the the radio operator role is extremely clever. The fact that you are tracing someone's movements with a with like a a dry erase marker and trying to fix it on this map so that you can physically work out where your movements can fit on the map because you can't ever backtrack on yourself. So, only a certain uh amount of um spaces on the board will physically be possible for you to be there as the game develops.
And um keeping your uh your weapon systems and technology up to um up obviously up and working is really important too and a real trick to it. So, the communication between the engineer, the radio operator, and the captain is just very clever how each one kind of um synergized with each other and they they do rely on each other to work at maximum efficiency. But not only that, you've got to concentrate on what the other team are doing as well. So, it really is tense. Every kind of uh movement could be your last. Um I love the some of the use of this technology on these um on these uh submarines as well. You can shoot the torpedoes and get indirect and direct hits. Um plant mines. You can kind of go into silence and try to throw the other radio operator off track.
Um you can use sonar which kind of narrows down your um you know, the possibility where the other team could be and stuff like that. So again, thematically this game is wonderful. It does feel like you're in your own little submarine and you're like very you know, you're together and you have to stick together to find the other team before they find you. So thematically I cannot fault this game at all. Really really good implementation of theme. Um now although the game is very very well balanced you know, is very I guess it's abstract in theory because there's no luck that goes into this. But that being said the the the proficiency and the radio operator is so important. So if you have like a really good radio operator on one side and a one who isn't so experienced or good on the other side then the game can just be a complete whitewash. Um you're going to be completely out of your depth no pun intended there. But um yeah, it is a game that fully relies on equal sides to have a kind of competitive game. And while a lot of people will really love that and you know, in a lot of respects I do love that. I love balance is you know, one of the most important thing in games for me full stop.
But you're not going to get a competitive game here very regularly at all. I've personally found that but it might not be the case for everybody. But in all the groups I found one team seems to be significantly better at the game than the other no matter how much you mix the teams. So it's just something I found and it might not be a you know, a widespread issue. Um mechanically so so clever how these different roles integrate with each other. The fact that it is real time is just is so unique and nothing else like it, as I said. Um it's it basically is Battleships on steroids. That That's the best way I can describe it. It's been described as that before, and it is a very, very accurate description. Um the game takes about, you know, half an hour to play, probably. Um give or take, uh depending on how good the players actually are. But, sooner or later, you're going to run out of moves to make, and you have to surface. And when you surface, you have to give your exact grid reference. Um so, that's obviously going to um massively deduce where you're going to be, and basically um funnel towards the end of the game.
So, the time investment is good. Um obviously, the up time is extremely good because it's a real-time game. You've got no chance to lose opportunity here. You have to be on the ball, or you will lose. Um Replayability-wise, there's a lot of different maps in the game. Um you've got some really cool ideas there as well, such as the ice map, where you can only surface a certain areas. You've got ones that have mines already built into the map, so you can detonate those and trying to attack the other players that way. So, you've got lots of different maps here, but ultimately, the game is going to feel basically the same every turn. But, because you can mix your roles and try the different um the different professions, um you're always going to kind of kind of get a different experience um if you mix it up a bit.
But, essentially, you know, the same kind of feeling every time. Um interaction is very, very clever here. As I said, communication is key in this game. Um So, yeah, the interaction between not only both the players, but the the players um on each side between themselves is really, really clever. And um I love the way that the simple roles um correlate in quite a a complex system. Very, very well done, and it does feel like you are in charge of a submarine, which is most important. Not like I know what it's like to be in charge of a submarine. Uh the game is looks all right, I guess. The dividers that come with the game, which is nice that they come with there in the first place, look really good. They're of a good quality. Um the art on them is really nice.
Um the the pens and the dry white boards that the players write on they're a good quality. They don't look the best. Um but again, very functional and good material there. Uh the pens themselves are good as well. And obviously, you can replace them as need to be for dirt cheap. So that's that's a good thing. Um So yeah, this is a bit of a conundrum this game because although I see it I I see its credit like all its pros so so vividly. Um but I think it's one of those things where I don't think I'm going to play it that often because it's a game that is not for everybody. It is as I said, it is just completely controlled chaos and it can it can fall into the um the aspect of being completely chaotic chaotic, not knowing what anything that's going on and just trying to a means to get to the end of the game.
Um the rules completely go out the window at times. Um so you do have to be on the ball and make sure everybody is confident with the game to get the best out of the game. It's not a game that you can just wing and just um hope it goes well because it can fall flat if you do that. I've had games of this that have been really tense and completely uh great exhilarating experiences, but I've also had games that fall completely flat and just aren't weren't fun at all. Um games where um there's a bit of um you know, back and forth between uh one radio operator and the captain where the radio operator kind of disputes what the captain has previously said because uh they might have attacked a spot where they've deduced where they definitely are and the captain says they're not there, and um because you've, you know, they've they've gone west, and actually they've gone east, so it throws the game completely out the window, and it kind of just makes a void game. So, it is a fragile system. That's the only way I got to kind of reiterate this time and time again. The game can quickly fall off the rails.
Um that's that's something I found anyway. I played this at least 10 times now, and I felt that uh it is it's been a regular thing, probably at least half the games that I've played of this, it's gone off the rails. So, overall, um I think it is a very well-designed game. Just uh as I said, unique in almost every aspect. The real-time thing, this is prob- I'm not the biggest fan of it. I've I kind of um worked out the more and more I've played real-time games. There are some out there that I really like, but um I think the the the chaotic and frantic nature of them is starting to turn me off a bit. But, as far as they go, this is probably one of the, you know, it's one of the the benchmarks of real-time games, and some people are going to absolutely love it because it's unlike anything, as I said.
So, um overall, I like the game. Um it's not going to stay in my collection, uh but I'll happily play it at gaming days or kind of convention-y type of events where there's a lot of players to cater for, and um everybody is a gamer, and they understand how the how the game works. Um but, yeah, this one's not going to stay in my collection, but again, it's a good game. Um just not right for my group. So, uh that's my uh that's my thoughts on Captain Sonar. Um if you have enjoyed the video, please hit like and subscribe to my channel, and check out my other videos, too. For everyone else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye.