Star Wars: Rebellion - Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for star wars rebellion uh which is uh a re-upload uh for for the channel i did this discussion and run through years ago but here's a brand new play i think i did i think i did it with the base game and then i did a review over the expansion so here's one with everything included uh and i gotta say my opinion on this has not changed in the slightest like i very much do not have a good time playing this game i think that it's for a particular group of people um meta like or mega uh star wars fans i think but i just this this is just not a game for me it's it never it doesn't feel like a cat and mouse game it's just kind of like it's watching the round track tick uh on from both sides because as the imperial player you know keeps taking forever to find him then it's like all right well i'm not getting i don't know where you're at uh and then oh you keep completing objectives or even if you're not it's still you know times ticking for me i don't like that and then as the rebel player i don't like feeling like my back is up against the wall the entire time where you really just man i hope that i can roll dice well enough to stop you from
doing stuff so i can finish some objectives it if if the game is balanced which i don't think it is um i just uh i just don't think it's fun but uh br uh i was gonna say brett brad you were the uh the star wars fan uh what do you think of this game i like it because of the theme yeah that's it just plain and simple especially playing from this side yeah i mean because every time i tried to do something it was either bone by dice or by the battle cards and it just totally yeah every so anytime i started getting excited a little bit then it was just like oh no that's wrong that's not right and it feels anticlimactic too because it's like i it's like i don't ever really feel like to counteract you i do anything clever i'm just like i'm gonna put darth vader in there and i'll roll three dice and oh lucky me or unlucky you like i i happen to roll equal to what you got or one more and that's that so then it just yeah it all still boils down to die rolls to kind of do anything and that's kind of boring in a game that like this like i don't i i can't really get immersed in the theme whenever it whenever that's the case it's like there were some times where i mean i had a cool combo in my hand
and it would have been super sweet thematically but uh it would have been frustrating for you because for example i had a car in my hand called collect bounty which i use boba fett for roll three dice and then he gets an automatic two he captures a rebel leader and then he can move to the nearest system that has an imperial unit uh so if i had if i had played a certain way like for example let's say i i played i had a unit still on tatooine and i capture one of your rebel units i move them to tatooine because i have another cult called called make an example and it's with jabba and you attempt against a captured rebel leader in a remote system like tatooine and that leader's eliminated if you succeed so it's like thematic things like that they're super cool if you can combo them off uh and but it's like i i would have to do that that would be a combo that would be kind of worth it to okay i'm gonna i'm gonna leave one in tatooine just to be in it and then boba fett takes him over there to jabba because he works for jabba and then he they throw him in the sarlacc pit and that and it could it could be luke and this is one of those things where oh hey luke actually did get pushed in he didn't you know like catch an r2 [ __ ] lightsaber out of nowhere but i kind of feel like those examples are few and far between yeah where stuff like that can be fun i think it's just one of those things like every like in in the last couple games it's like i there was i did
nothing exciting yeah at all like the most the coolest thing i did was free yeah a person obi-wan that's it because i tried to take out vader failed yeah i tried to build some cool stuff on there failed i tried to do this failed it was just like there was nothing yeah you know actually i guess the coolest thing is i got a yoda ring around luke yeah that was it um yeah i mean and and you only failed because just dice didn't go your way and there's very very few ways to mitigate dice and why there's all this plastic maybe put three things out after my starting deals yeah well because that's the other thing is you would have had a bunch of units had because you were getting uh yeah i had spread out right and then i just happened to have one card that's just like oh all right yep turn all those neutral and i think that was actually oh that was one of your objectives was to be like have all the populist systems in one region to be uh loyal yeah cause i was gonna do that and when you wiped that out my next one was i was gonna use it because that's gonna do that's because that was what one of these was let's do that oh yeah next turn to do that yeah but then i got the [ __ ] secret station i tried to take out your death star and yep and so it's because i didn't play one of these cards i didn't wasn't able to do that right yeah this is one of those games that's like it's weird it's it's pretty simple like i think to learn um
and it don't get me wrong the theme is very much here it's not like it's an abstract weird game that has a star wars based on theme no it's very much star wars in a box with all the cards all the the different you know aspects from the original trilogy it's all here and rogue one but the gameplay just kind of it heavily this is the biggest criticism i have for it heavily leans towards i've played this more than you therefore i am going to do better than you um even even with dice being a mitigator it's like nope i know what to search for in the projects deck i know what to do for objectives uh because the rebels aren't supposed to fight they're literally just supposed to kind of just constantly move and keep getting loyalty because um that's how you get a lot of your units to be able to potentially do a fight and really they're on the defensive the entire time the only card that and i guess you're opening him the only card that i was surprised you didn't end up doing but then again i had no idea now how that was where you were at i was just kind of guessing um because i was really hoping because i was looking at end my probe cards i knew you didn't have endor and i checked for hoth but i was like is he on the boo uh because then i was thinking oh [ __ ] if it's not al huda i have moved my death star so far over that it's virtually out of the game because it's very slow like to move to
move it but the only thing that i was surprised that didn't come up was your rapid mobilization um like i i thought you would have have moved it um yeah because you choose one establish a new rebel base if two leaders are assigned you draw eight probe guards instead of four which lets you oh [ __ ] he's moving the death star towards now huda i better i better bail yeah um by the time that was coming here though i really didn't care so yeah i was just like let's just get it over with yeah it's yeah and i was i was definitely in the same boat too like uh yeah it's just i i don't know i'm trying to think of things that that i like about it if you're a star wars fan i would imagine that you would be really into this uh by theme alone and by by theme alone but i mean then again a lot of people really ra they raved about it back then i think people still rave about it uh well like i said if i would you know yeah i don't know if it would be different going from the other side or what right from my perspective i don't like either side right even from a game perspective galactic empire is just kind of like a you keep searching and if if someone is rebel you know hopping a lot then you're like oh man they might be there and then even whenever you are drawing probe cards there's a lot of times where the cards that allow you to like oh man are you in kashyyyk no and
then you're like okay well i'll draw some probe cards oh man i got kashyyyk and one that i already have placed people on oh that's funny enough the next card was kashyyyk or rylith well i know that wasn't enough you know because i you already started there um so it's it's just not a fun hidden movement game for me as the empire and then the other thing you do is you just combat the whole time and combat i think is incredibly boring even with the expansion the expansion definitely significantly makes combat better because you actually get to kind of choose and if you have special units in in combat it's like oh man i get this better power and that's my one time use for the combat until this deck runs out but then it comes down to die rolls and and that's that it's just it's just not fun this game says i don't i don't find it fun in any way was there anything that you did like the art the art i guess there was some there was potential and that's what i'm saying i mean it's not it's not the worst game in the world i've played yeah obviously i mean it's not but the dice give me major not just in color but it gives me a major x-wing oh yeah vibe where the dice just there's so much put on the dice and one like you had said earlier one card
can completely ruin everything yeah like i mean when you wipe this out all that production that i had and everything just went away right and a reputation and everything right it's just like there is yeah there is a risk reward aspect that is kind of interesting and it's with your leaders is that if you send all your leaders out on missions yeah you're gonna be able to do quite a bit with missions because mission cards are huge but that also is allowing your opponent to do whatever they want right because you can't then oppose it so it's like trying to keep a few people back to do so uh is a strategy and that's why you take turns doing so because you place it's like if i'm sitting here there were times i would i would wait for missions to be like okay who was he crappy still has a layout [ __ ] and then i try to like uh i would try to like use my missions in a different order trying to stall out so you would send someone who could oppose and probably beat me out and it's like oh okay now i can kind of do what i planned on it so there is that that is interesting i like that dynamic of kind of reading what your opponent might do but other than that yeah if you completely but like new players aren't going to know that they're going to want to be like do the cool missions and get involved in like the story stuff like the what-if of star wars and then it's like okay i'm gonna do this you don't have anyone i captured him okay i'm gonna interrogate him i'm gonna do this and just constantly to steamroll you with my mission cards while i also have i kept people behind
for your crucial i need this to do something cool and it's like alice and boba fett out to oppose and i rolled higher than you and that's that well and then also this entire game that we played what were we in six different systems maybe eight and that's the only ones like none of that got touched oh yeah you're right yeah yeah that's true yeah really it's the entire part of the he of the empire is to just kind of spread out but because i had so many probe cards it was like well i i know it's not anyone near me because i have those cards so it can't be that so my guess was either one of those two toy daria and now huda and then i was like well maybe naboo uh because i i cuz i like i mean i like the fact that it's the empire you can ask like there are ways for you to get information and draw additional probe cards to find it but the fact that you were drawing objective cards that were not beneficial or helpful in any way i don't know because there's like 30 ish give or take spots yeah and you start out with on how many um yeah because you draw five cards um and two of them are subjugated three are loyal and then you have three that are loyal so i started out on five and then you know i mean then there's the three that are but i could be in one of those still yes so
25 tall locations um i think it's a 25 total counting the one that you're at so oh no that's not true i'm sorry no there are 30 because 5 are the imperial ones that get taken out so so yeah i mean you're right it's not even it's this isn't a war game by any means i would definitely call this hidden movement uh but at the same time it's like you're the one that's hidden but you're not moving so you're kind of relying on objectives to shorten the game because i think i have one as the rebels uh because i was able to stall out enough and then just be like oh okay here's some freebie objectives and then that just shortens the time yes i think i had the potential of doing well you got rid of the one that was good that was the one that lay you discard two that was gonna give me yeah so i maybe had and within a couple of rounds i could have gotten four points which is i mean which is huge though and there are ways one that's if i destroyed that yes which place because if i would have played this card that would have been gone right i mean that was yeah and texting display but right and and you were i mean you were kind enough to let me reassign damage for misunderstanding the card but at that point if it was probably closer you would have been like nope nope you misread it which is fair because i did um but that is kind of the another negative of the game is that if that was
destroyed then it's like all right let's keep going another hour and a half down exactly and this game is long and i definitely i do not like star wars enough to want to be involved in it that long and because i've played this a ton especially when it came out on both sides like in fact whenever i was playing okay i think his name was nathan uh we would play like twice in a row as one he oh i'd be the empire then i'd be the rebels and once we saw everything that the game had to offer i was like yeah i'm over it like once you see that obi-wan can do cool stuff that luke become master jedi and you can get cool cards that oh if master jedi's you know if master luke is on this then you get to do this badass thing like the first game we played with the lore of the dark side oh hey yeah if i do this against luke then he's just mine and he's dark side you know you know sith luke and you lose reputation and all that stuff is really really cool thematically and if you can get them to happen and you're super into star wars you go to star wars conventions you only dress up as you know star wars characters you only watch star wars porn then this is going to be the game for you uh for me i only wanted to play because i knew you wanted to give it a shot and i was like oh yeah we can redo for the channel it's been a long time but there's not a lot of interaction i don't think either like you said half the stuff was never touched there was never a reason for me to move the only reason i moved these over here was because i was like maybe he went to hoth because i thought
because i was like oh maybe he thought in the first game he i was like oh you're in hoth and you're like oh i will saw yeah then i got to pick it and i was like okay nope he's not there granted whenever you drew eight you could have drawn hoth and then move your base there which is cool but it's it's kind of a crapshoot i think luck plays a way bigger role in this game than than it should uh bring a long game luck is frustrating in a long game that's true that's true we have the same complaints in x-wing as well yeah a shorter game you know then it's it's uh yeah if this was like an hour like like this game would be a blast i think in an hour if if you could rapid like fire like the cool theme stuff um the cool what if theme stuff i think it'd be awesome but it's just it's very very slow at the same time it was almost about two hours to to do it potentially actually it could be short like if someone's getting cocky and they just go and they're like i'll do alderaan and then you move all in there and land in and kill them it's like okay i found you yeah yeah i i kept finding myself like every turn i was just i needed to spin somebody to move and then i need to play this card every turn that was what i did yeah and i did this every turn the whole checking those things yeah i was playing the same cards every turn practically and oh what's this one do oh i get to i get to uh put up one of my big shifts on this three yeah i mean that was it was just wasn't anything like it wasn't
anything like super cool right yeah because i felt like i had cool combos and cool stuff i hardly ever touched my um like my stuff i almost feel like it'd be better if both sides had objectives yeah and it'd be cool if there was like it wasn't a timer on the rebels thing if it was like a race to a certain amount of points like i mean like twilight struggle for example or both sides i mean it's one deck but it's like both sides have those but i think people would have been more annoyed with the twilight struggle themed star wars game it's neat thematically having a rebel base that you have to go out and find uh but if any hidden movement game letters from white chapel or fury dracula is always long uh mind management all that stuff if it was like always two hours and it's like nope nope i don't want to do this so i don't know the expansion i still think is a must one because it gives the game new new stuff to play with right uh and it's not like a major one that totally throws a wrench in things it allows the uh it allows the empire player to not start with a death star yeah which i think gives a leg up to the rebels um but it can also be destroyed because it does have health so i don't know you got anything else so all right well uh on a scale of one to
ten um oh gosh um i want to eventually do this again using that side but doing what i've played so far and uh taking the theme into account the theme is giving it a couple points for me so it's a two it's a zero but i'm going to give this game gosh because i love the components i love the little deals i love seeing the plastics the the adapts and all that stuff out there and the star destroyers and all that stuff yeah at this point i get a five five i mean so two points for star wars yeah three oh god five because of the yeah the theme uh i i am not a major star wars fan um i will watch most of the movies um and have a pretty good time but i don't freak out over it like i do other other genres uh i have played both sides and don't really enjoy either side and but i think i think the game i mean it it works i guess like but i think i am gonna agree with you though i'm gonna give it a five as well um i do think that
given the right combo of cards and if dice are equal on both sides you can have a pretty good back and forth of constantly sabotaging other people's missions and uh but it definitely favors this is for one of those the the people who oh we've both played it 10 times you know twilight struggles the same way if someone has played that game more than the other they're going to win uh but i have i mean i will say i have played really clutch games on both sides where the it's like i need to get my i know where he's at he cannot go anywhere else i need to get my desktop there to blow it up um and i need to reserve all these special abilities to stop him from like preventing or from him stopping me from blowing up the planet um and i've also played it from rebels where it's like boom boom here's all these objectives that i met and it goes from 14 to eight all of a sudden it's like oh [ __ ] okay yep and we have two rounds left before you have to try and win so those those can happen and those can definitely elevate this game like i definitely see if that happens and you're star wars fans then this is like an eight maybe a nine those experiences are few and far between for me uh so i am going to give this game uh a five so components are really nice though yes all right so that's our thoughts on star wars rebellion let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you
hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you