Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is Every Game REALLY Political?

Transcript 23:01

So, I'm in Germany hanging out in a hotel lobby with some friends. It's early October 2024 and in one month's time, Donald Trump will once again be elected as president of the United States. And then, well, let's put a pin in that, shall we? Anyway, so we're playing games of amongst this posi is Ian O2 and he says, "Do you all want to play the stupidest game ever?" but in an Irish accent. With a pitch like that, how can you say no? So, he takes out Sausage Sizzle, which is sort of the subject of today's video. Sausage Sizzle is a game by Inca and Marcus Brand, illustrated by the affforementioned Ian Oul, and the central idea is that you roll dice, hoping not to bust, to score various Australian animals. The theme is that these animals are stealing food from a garden barbecue party, which is very relatable. My garden is full of hungry crocodiles as soon as I power up the pellet grill. Each player has six animal tokens and on your turn you will roll a dice. Four of the dice have all the animals on their faces. However, the other four have either numbers anywhere between two to five or sausages. There's some variation in how many fives and how many sausages, but that nitty-gritty is not important here. Once you rolled the dice, you can choose any of them to lock in. You can even lock in all of them, but you must lock in at least one. And

then you can roll again any of your unlocked dice, locking in at least another one, rolling again, and so on until you end up with a result. The gist is that you want as many icons of the same animal and values that are numerically high across all the dice. Let's say I have three quarkas, a kangaroo, a five, a five, a five, and a three. This is almost good. If it wasn't for the free, my score for each quarker would be five. Thus, I would score 15 points. But I only count my lowest die value. Thus, it's free quacas times my lowest die value, which is free. My score is nine. Importantly, I can never score quacas again. Since I rolled one kangaroo as well, I could have chosen it instead of the guacas. But then my score would only be free because one times three, unless sausages. If you roll any sausages, they count as a one, which means my score is bad. But if, and only if all the numbers are sausages, they each count as seven. So, in this quawker example, let's pretend that these fives and threes are sausages, which means three * 7. I scored 21 points, and that's the entire thing. Is it the world's stupidest game? I mean, that's subjective, but it's definitely in the running. I'm not going to lie, Ian read the table well. The game pushed the exact kind of buttons, flipped

everyone's mood upside down. I feel like stupid was what everyone needed in the moment. You've heard the argument that every game is political before. It's the same argument as all art is political. Games are art stuff at Ebert. Therefore, all games are political. Instinctually, this makes sense. But I bet some of you at the back of your heads are like, "Okay, but is it all games?" Because some games are sausage sizzle. Is sausage sizzle political? Is it a statement on Australian animals? Are the animals like the working class and they're stealing from the grill master bourgeoa Z? There's nothing here. It's purposefully stupid. And the answer to that, believe it or not, is yes. All games are political, including sausage chisel. First of all, I want to say that a lot of what I talk about today works in tandem with an essay by Amabel Holland called mechanisms as metaphors. that is so good it made me livid with jealousy. I started writing this video before that essay came out, but a lot of what I'm talking about works in parallel with hers. So, if you want a great companion piece, I cannot recommend it enough.

Mechanisms and metaphors establishes very successfully that mechanisms aren't just flat rules. They mean something. They provoke thoughts and arguments and ideas. sometimes in terms of what they represent and sometimes outside of that too. I think um I think I'm going to have to go a step further if I want to convince you with this one. Let's get back to that evening in Germany 2024. I want to paint a broader picture of my emotional state. I'm obviously not American, but things that happen in America politically tend to have reverberations across the world. was following the election pretty close and by that point things were leaning uncomfortably towards a complete disaster. If Donald Trump won knowing his close ties and admiration towards Putin, what would he do in relation to Ukraine? Again, I'm not talking about what we now know he has done, which is nothing. put yourself in the torn up shoes of my emotional state. Because if Putin succeeds in Ukraine, then the Baltic states are next. Which is why the Baltic states are spending enormous amounts of money on military defense right now. And as some of you know, I am from a Baltic state. And this is just one of the many examples of those global reverberations, some of which affect me personally. So, I'm watching this future potential car crash with no way to

influence it. I can only observe I can't vote on this despite this colossal effect it might have on me. But then I get on a plane, fly to Germany, meet some friends, order a drink, and these days I almost never drink and play this stupid game. And for a while, the world just melts away. Okay, you might say, Ekka, your emotions are valid, but what has that got to do with sausage sizzle? Your environment and your friends and definitely that glass of Kari are more responsible for this brief escapism. All true, but whilst we're on the subject of emotions, I think this is maybe one of the most underdised topics in board games. We nitpick, analyze, value mechanisms in so many ways. But mechanisms are tools of expression. They are how the authors speak to you. That expression is then distilled in you, processed by your being, and the result is emotion. We commonly attribute fun to be a desirable outcome of playing a board game. I have just played a new board game. Oh, how was it? stressful, mean, unpredictable. I hated it. Sounds um sounds pretty good, actually. I think I'm going to have to try that myself.

Fun isn't an emotion. It is an umbrella term that encapsulates many different emotions. Let's take movies for example. Groundhog Day, I'm laughing. Fun. Midsamar, I'm tense. I'm creeped out. I'm uncomfortable. Fun. Perfect days. I'm introspective. I'm melancholic. I'm relaxed. lots of fun. We can easily identify when we play a board game whether we are or we are not having fun. But we don't always analyze what kind of fun, what kind of emotions it evokes. And more importantly, what do those emotions mean to us? What do they correlate to in our lives? Because taking that next step might make it a little uncomfortable. Why do I enjoy the feeling in a gricola of praying that the spot I want is still available when the turn comes back to me? What emotions are those? Tension, uncertainty, anxiety, fear. None of those emotions sound like fun. Why am I turned on by this? What is going on in my life? In early October 2024, I felt isolation, helplessness, a sense that all is lost, defeat. I felt tired and the littlest things would set me off. And so, here's this game that says you rolled a five, a five, a five, and a three. And instead of locking in the fives, you're going to pick them all up and go for broke because the only thing that's worth it is all sausages.

You throw away the good enough because it's not good enough. There is an asteroid falling down on you and all you've got to protect yourself is soap bubbles. So, you're going to blow as hard as you can. Now, that is an emotion. Absurd luck in defiance of fate. And then you come out the other side and you're fine. Okay, you're still not sold. So this game that I played just happened to be in sync with me and my landscape, my political climate, my views. That's just happen stance. Inca and Marcus Brand didn't intend any of this. They just designed a silly dice game. It itself isn't political. It's just my experience of it. I'm reading into it. I mean, of course I am, but also I'm not. And this game, it does not exist in a vacuum. It's not somehow virginal. It has influences and inspiration. Have you ever heard of the game of freeze? No, not the one on the phone. The dice game. Basically, all you need is five dice. You roll all of them.

Select one to lock in. And then you keep rolling and locking in dice until you can't roll anymore. The lower the total value across all of the dice at the end, the better. except for threes which count as zero and is therefore the best result. One catch in some versions if and only if you roll all sixes on your very first roll that is an instant win. Sound familiar? I think it's obvious that there's a Fred running through Freeze into Sausage Sizzle. I'd be surprised if Inca and Marcus Brand were not familiar with it. And I'd bet good money that this game was designed as a modernization of Freeze. There's very little I could find on the origins of Freeze. Games of chance are not documented well historically because it was seen as a CD thing to do. High society would not be caught talking about dice games, much less playing them. Uh, so don't expect anything verifiable, much less academic. It's just handme-down hearsay oral history.

But multiple sources refer to an alternate title, trips. Linguistically, you could say that trips refers to triples. It's close to threes, right? So, this is it. This is the prestige. Now, I also found one source highly dubious that states that this game was played by, how do I say this? People in alleyways when they ate candy and when the sugar in that candy made them really mellow out, they would play trips in those alleyways. If I have to work around the YouTube censorship algorithm, I feel like it's getting a little bit more political now. Even if this source is based in fiction, likely many sources cite it as a street gambling game often found in the company of alcohol.

Although the term tripping in relation to candy dates back to 1920, so it's not impossible. Games just don't exist in a vacuum despite our blinker beliefs that they do. Even silly games trace their roots and history to something more contentious. They evoke personal emotional connections. And I bet you if you work real hard for it, you could make entire works of art based on an emotion that a simple game like Freeze manifests. Don't believe me? Well, sucks to be you because here's an album by popular folk band Bride Eyes called Five Dice All Freeze. Guess what it's about. The first single, Bells and Whistles, opens with I was cruel like a president.

It was wrong, but I ordered it. And when Connor Ober spews out that last line, he almost vomits it into the mic. There's a real performative anger. The vocals almost sound like they're clipping. There's a manufactured outrage all for an impression of Donald Trump. This is under a whistly xylophone melody reminiscent of those clawingly incipid royalty-free tracks so often used by content mills. It is not subtle. Good concept albums don't hammer the same point over and over. There's a lot of variety in how they approach their central theme. But I think what Bride Eyes is doing here is trying to capture a mood, a moment in the Zeitgeist. They've done this a lot in the past, too. I think their most interesting album is the people's key that is about charlatans, religion, mysticism, cults, and political zeal. It doesn't have a single verdict on any of it. In fact, the album's ending monologue, if anything, is a reaffirmation that even within the weirdest ideas coming from the kookiest mouths, there can be a rejection of cruelty and fascism. There is a certain hope within that. Five dice or freeze operates in a similar fashion.

In an interview with PBS's American Masters Creative Spark podcast, Connor Obus describes the through line as this. if we want to go big with like a with a metaphor, you know, kind of everything on this earth is like a game of chance in a way and we're all we're all forced to play it and we're like we're we're hoping for that perfect role but you know doesn't doesn't happen that often. I guess it's refracted in a myriad of moods, perspectives, and scenarios. One song's chorus just rhythmically repeats all freeze. All freeze. all freeze in a tone that carries desperation with a faint sense of hope. As if just by repeating it, you can manifest an impossible outcome. By the way, that song also includes the line Elon Musk in Virgin Whites I unal alive him in an alley over five dice. It doesn't actually say unal alive. That's just for YouTube. It is impossible to divorce politics from this feeling because politics is the root of this desperation. When people claw everything out of you, you claw back sometimes for very little. Other songs celebrate this feeling. Whether it's the fateful journey of Bosian Otter, used as an allegory for a carefree approach to life, or even the final song, Tin Soldier Boy, presenting vignettes of criminals, grifters, and thieves embracing the end to the tune of Let It

Be, it goes, "Soldier on, soldier on through the heartbreak and the joy accompanied by a cacophony of brass at the end of time." All of this and much more from just Five Dice. I could go on about this album endlessly, but one last thing, there's a line in Bells and Whistles, the chorus, expensive jokes, and fancy cheap frills cost a lot. And it could be about any number of things, but I just feel like I don't know. It's hard to accept that this is what we get. this clearly absurd situation of a man who's simultaneously megalomaniacal and also probably in the latter stages of dementia becoming the leader so preposterous so stupid it beggars reality swaying like Jesus with crowds of people in tears how can he fool so many so blindly I wonder if he does I I wonder if the reason he got elected again is because for many this is just a joke. Politics takes as much or as little thought as you want. And if you don't think about it, if you don't consider the cost, then on some level, it is pretty funny to see this absurd man be the president of the United States. But there is a cost. So Donald

Trump raised the tariffs on imports from China to 145%. I'm sure you've heard of this. Please don't argue this in the comments or spread misinformation, you will lose your commenting privileges. And if you're anything like me and you lurk in places where tabletop industry professionals and enthusiasts talk or you backed a crowdfunding project recently, you've heard of the devastating impacts this has on our hobby. More and more people I know in this industry are becoming unemployed. Companies are sending out updates telling people they're going to have to raise prices maybe. But actually, who knows? because the current state of things is such that making board games is simply not profitable. And even if this changes tomorrow or before I publish this video, it doesn't matter because the damage has already been done. Greater Than Games, publisher of Spirit Island, one of the most popular board games out there, has been shut down by their owner, Flat River Group.

Sean, a company we all know and love, has ceased all development and fired a bunch of its employees. The future of our hobby looks bleak. There will be some of you who will look at this pragmatically. Sure, some companies will shut down, but others will survive. Find a way through. I'm sure many of them are hoping they survive, too. Even though the odds of it are I wonder if there's a good analogy I can fish out about what the odds of it are. Something about DICE, maybe. I'll work on it. I'll be very candid with you. NPI is not a publisher, but I don't even know what the odds of us pulling through are. Let's say hypothetically a publisher does make it through to the other end. Costs of making things will still be increased because costs never go down.

Increased costs means less space for risk. Less space for risk means less room for creativity. Innovation designs become more predictable, wrote, tried and true. Less innovation means less sustained interest in our hobby, less sales overall. What I'm getting at is that if there's less people making board games, then there's less people buying board games. And if there's less people buying board games, who's going to watch board game reviews? On CNN, Price Johnson, COO of Sephilopair Games, has stated that their Chinese manufacturer told them to suspend all manufacturing for products to US. No one is printing games right now. If there are no games to buy, gonna repeat myself, who's gonna watch board game reviews? Is Sausage Sizzle commentary on the current state of US politics and its impact on our niche hobby? No. Not overtly, not intentionally, but emotionally, discounting weirdo outliers. I would bet good money on every single professional of the tabletop industry, praying for all sausages, because what else have we got? I hosted a seminar in Mannheim last year. The audience was composed of German board game reviewers and other tabletop media people. Some of that seminar was built to encourage people to do media analysis as part of their work reviewing board games that we owe our audiences more than just a regurgitation of mechanisms. One question I got in

that seminar really struck me. I don't remember it verbatim, but the idea is this. How do we apply media analysis to games that are more mechanical? If the game was designed by, say, Cole Wley, well, we know there's a thesis there, but what if it's Splendor? It's a great question, and I guess in part this video is my answer to it. It is fundamentally absurd to ascribe political meaning to a game called Sausage Sizzle. I don't want anyone watching to think that I don't recognize that. But at the same time, it is equally absurd not to because guess what? Overanalyzing things is fun. Unpicking interextuality is fun. Finding poetics is fun. Fun, as I mentioned before, is many different things and people experience it in different ways. It is no great cost to anyone. If I or any of the people watching this want to find more meaning than is visible on the surface, I don't expect you to go out and media analyze the heck out of everything to find a political through line. It's not necessary for enjoying games, but I want you to recognize that there is fun in that, just as there is fun in figuring out how to leverage a mechanism towards your own advantage in a game. I need to believe that people can see this, that despite sincere

protest that politics is too real and too raw and they just don't want to engage with it, that there is joy beyond the heartbreak of it all. I know it hurts and it's easier to just brush it aside. I'm not asking you to stew in the mire. Just do it once in a while, like brushing your teeth or having a shower. Self-care. I know there'll be a bunch of people in the comments going, "This is rubbish. You just built a bunch of straw men. This video is nonsense. Games aren't political." And I don't mean people who are just not sold on what I'm talking about. That's fine. I mean people who are angered by this. And to you, I say I don't care. I literally could not care less if you didn't manage to take a single thing away from this.

That's your lot in life. If all you want to do is engage with the obvious, I mean, go ahead. Just don't be rude in the comments. Nobody likes that. Some of us are curious, however. We know there's something more underneath. We're not satisfied with just mechanisms. And if that makes you upset, that's a reflection of you, not us.

Progress saved