Skip to main content
Loading video...

Forage Review: Digging in the Dirt

Transcript 13:28

Hey folks, I'm Tom Vassal.

And I'm Wendy Liu.

Today we're taking a look at Forage, which is a game from Flatout Games and AEG. Molly Johnson, Robert Melvin, Stone Stankovich, the the trio from Flatout Games. Um I have to say Flatout Games cuz AEG games this year have not been particularly good. Well, Flatout Games um people know them for Cascadia, Point Salad, things like that.

The point game is what I think of.

This is a roll well, a flip and write game. No, it's a roll and write game.

roll and write.

them all.

You're rolling like eight dice.

I'm I'm so used to having to say to change it. Anyway, you're right. You're rolling dice and you're writing on cards that happily have already been laminated for you.

Mhm.

Here's how it plays. In this game there are three types of foraging cards, pantry, gift giving, and exploration. Each player is going to start with one of these cards from a starting section while there is regular cards that you'll use over the course of the game. And you'll place those face up in front of you. Uh the exploration ones will need to be set apart because as you get more exploration cards, they will connect with either side of the one that you play face down or face up at the beginning of the game. So, each round of the game you're going to turn over one of these tiles. This is something that players can do. Sometimes it's a positive event. This is going to give everybody something positive and sometimes it is a way for players to spend time to get a bonus. And we'll talk a little bit more about that in a second.

After that, you're going to roll these dice here in the middle of the table. There's a bonus die, which is black, and each of these dice has six different symbols on them. So, you roll them. This one's always placed in the middle. Then on this side, you put any dice that match. So, you can see I rolled two berries, but the other dice are all different, so they go on this side. Sometimes you'll have more on one side than the other. Sometimes they're all on one side, but this is how this works out. And then simultaneously, players are going to use these dice. They're always going to get to use the die in the middle, but they can use one group of dice that are the same. If they do that, they can use their pantry, and you'll cross off a jar for each. So, I have these two and one brown, so I could cross off these two red and one brown here. If you finish rows and or columns, you will get bonuses. Sometimes you'll be able to do things on other cards.

Sometimes it's just victory points. And with this card and with all other cards, players have two time, and you'll get more time as the game goes by. You can always spend time to cross off an extra symbol. So, that's how pantry works. Then the passageways is a little bit different. In the passageways, you'll use all the different dice here plus this one in the middle. So, maybe let's see, I'll do that die. I have two of those. I have this one here, which connects that line between those. I also have a mushroom, which connects those lines between those. And a leaf up here and that one, which connects those lines and those lines. Now, not a lot has been done here, but when you connect the lines around something, you will get that bonus in the middle. And some of these will require lines connected on another card as you place more cards out there.

So, that's how the passageways card works. It uses the different side of dice. And then the gift card, you can use either section, and you need to be able to check off one of these. Four dice, doesn't matter what color. Two dice that are that very specific symbol. Three dice, doesn't matter what the symbol is as long as they are brown. And you check these off. And when all these are finished, you will get whatever it shows at the bottom here, which is a free check on another gift card. And at the end of the game, these are going to give you points. This one, for example, gives you one point for every complete travel card. So, players are going to do that and remember like I said, you can always use time to check off an extra thing on whichever card that you use. Players can also spend time to do one of these tiles that's over here. Like I can spend three time to get a footprint. But if you're wondering what that symbol is, it's at the top of your scorecard and for every matching pairs of these footprints and books, you'll get five points at the end of the game. Players will also get points if they reach a goal.

The first person to get seven prestige points only bonuses from cards will get five points, circle that and they'll write them here and there's three of these cards put out randomly. And then you also score points from finishing cards. When you finish a card, you'll get an extra time in the corner. At the end of every round, you'll you'll say you're done with your action by drawing the top card from any of the three decks, your choice. Once everyone's done that, you reveal your card and you may keep that card, an extra card that you can do or you can discard it at the and you just get one time for doing so. Otherwise, you put it in front of you and try to complete it. This will keep going until the final round tiles have been revealed. Everyone will finish that round and then you'll just add up your points. Your points are already mostly on your scorecard. Whoever has the most is the winner.

Forage is a game that it has a lot going on. I mean, it's not particularly complicated at all. Right? You're Each card is different. I mean, on how you do it. I'm like, oh, I got different symbols. I connect paths. Over here, the same in the pantry. The gift, I need a bunch of the same dice, same kind of dice. Um so, that one's it's pretty easy.

I feel like you need to know three actions.

But there's a lot going on. Oh, what that symbol do? What am I doing over here? And it honestly feels like a more complicated version of Silver & Gold and I I a much more complicated version.

Okay.

Because you're filling out cards as fast as you can, then you get another card and you try to fill that one out.

it felt like a Phil Walker Harding game, kind of. But, like a which is Heat's over gold, right? Yeah, it feels like that kind of roll and write or super mega lucky box. I kind of got those vibes to it. Yeah.

I I thought it was more straightforward. So, a lot of times with roll and write gets very complicated. Um like the ones from Garphill Games and there's like a ton going on in those. And then there's games that are really, really simple. This kind of I think fits in the in between spot.

And this game also is a game that seems like you're doing nothing until you finish. The first time I played it, my score was very low.

Okay.

Uh and they gave an example score in the book and I was like, "No one can score that high." I got like 11 points or whatever. Then when I played through again, I was like, "Oh."

Now I see.

Because you really do This is one of those games you you probably should pick at most two of the cards to focus on, two of the types.

Maybe, maybe. Um I think the thing is this game you do a lot of spinning of your wheels, which I think is so much fun. I really enjoy the spinning of the wheels part, but that spinning of the wheels doesn't always convert to points. And I think that with that kind of what you're saying of like you're doing stuff, um like for me, I remember getting to the end of the game and being like, "Am I going to get more points by doing a bunch of cool stuff and having a really big turn that does a whole lot of things? Or am I going to get more points by just buying one of those journey tokens and spending the rest of my timers on that and being like, 'Hey, that's 12 points.'"

Well, honestly, those journey tokens are really important. At first, because they look more boring than the rest of the game. I'm like, "I don't want to waste more time on that when I can use time to fill in extra spots on my cards." Yeah, but if you skip those journey cards, the a card might give you one or two points. That time might give you three or four. That's a huge difference.

It is, but it isn't necessarily a more fun difference.

I agree. Um, and some of the cards, like the the gift cards, are good if you compound them. If you get the thing that they're saying, "Oh, this gift card gives one for every journey card." Well, then I better start doing one as many journey cards as I can get and try to make them worthwhile. So, it's a game that you feel like, "Wow, there's all this stuff going on." But, you also feel the pressure of, "I can't do everything." Or a lot of stuff.

And I also feel like you feel the pressure of, "I have to make a decision now, but I don't know what the future's going to hold. And I might have just made the wrong decision." Um

like keeping a card or taking a time? Cuz that always bugs me. Should I keep that card? One time feels like a pathetic thing, but I need that time so badly.

the time, and you can't fill in all the cards, so why would you take all the cards? But, I kind of like looking at, you know, the gifts or the the pantry and being like, "Okay, I'm out of brown bottles. I'm going to flip it over, and I'm going to see, do I get more brown bottles? Do I like that card because of that? No, I'll give it away for a time." So, I mean I actually like that part of the game, but I also feel like sometimes you get that free free mark off something, right? You're like, "Okay, I can mark off two bottles. This is great." Do I mark them off in brown or green? I don't know, it's kind of equal. Then we roll the dice, and then like no green shows up for forever. And, you know, I marked off the browns, and there's tons of browns. So, I feel like there's just a little bit of that weird like make a decision, then luck determines whether or not it happens, but it's not a big deal.

Right. This is not a I would not consider this to be a filler. It says 15 to 30 minutes on here. I have no idea who's playing this in 15 minutes. That is It's 30 minutes minimum, I think. And I'm not it's not a I'm not saying this is a bad thing.

No, but there's 13 rounds.

Right. No one's like, "Quick, roll." Quick, roll, right. Maybe even with one player, which I have soloed this, you're not playing that fast because you were thinking about where you're going to mark like ooh this is a this is a good die roll to mark off a bunch of my pantry. But I also can finish a loop in the traveling. So you're trying to gauge which one of those is better. And if you should spend time or save it for something better.

Well, and I think when you spend time for those extra actions, that's huge. I loved that. That was one of my favorite parts of the games, right? Um but then you're taking essentially two full turns in that moment. And then if you finish cards and you get those bonuses, like that takes a lot longer.

Yeah, so it feels it feels like a meaty game in there. My only complaint about the game per se is I wish the points were were more. I wish all the points have been raised a little bit because it feels like you're doing a lot of work for smaller amounts of points. It's not a huge thing.

Interesting.

But like if sometimes a card is worth a point and I'm like maybe three or four points it just would have felt better cuz I just checked off a whole lot of stuff on this card and spent a few turns getting to it. And the scores are going to be lower although if you play correctly and you go for the bonus cards, which you should, and get the tiles, which you should, this is not one of those games where you you can say well, you can ignore a lot of parts of game focus on one. You should focus I think on one or two of the sets of cards, but you can't ignore the bonuses or the tiles.

Yeah, I don't think

lose.

And I really appreciate that you do have those three goal cards that are in the middle cuz they kind of point everybody in a direction and that adds interaction, that adds a level of race. But I also appreciate that with kind of everything, if you do it in the same round as someone else you get it just as much as they do. It's not like you have to split it, it's not a you know what I mean, none of that. It's just if you've done it this round that someone else triggered it, cool. You got it 100% and I appreciate that because that makes the real time very clean.

Sure. What would you give it?

Um I'm going to come in at a seven for this. I I thought it was a good fun. It had a lot of those really interesting fun like combo-y moments for me. Um but I also feel like there is that high sense of luck of like did I make the right decisions? I don't know for the future round. Should I have taken the time? Should I have not? Should I have marked off this or not? Um, I also found the rules to be a little confusing. I had to read the rule book like three times for how short it is, just because the way they explained the equal dice versus the not equal dice versus the forge dice. I was like, which one is included in which action? So, I just had to keep going through. But I think the symbols and stuff, it's all pretty clear. Um, and I think that yeah, it's a it's a good roll and write game.

I can definitely teach it faster than the rule book does and easier, but I don't know that I could have written it better. I'm giving it a I'm giving it a 7.5. I find it to be very enjoyable and I find that there's very I think there's very few games that are in this weight class of the roll and write genre. They're either usually very very light or they're pretty complex. This one comes down the middle and it's also very satisfying to finish a card. There are other games that do it, like I said, there's Silver & Gold or they the money one. There's other ones where you can finish cards and it feels good. In this one, finishing a card is more work, so I think that feeling of yes, I did it is even more so. It's going to take a game or two to get how it works under your belt, but I think this one will will will do pretty good in that regard. Will we remember in a four or five years? I don't know. But for now, I'm enjoying it. So, that's Forage. I'm Tom.

I'm Wendy.

We'll see you next time.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you liked this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved