The Trial of the Forest - Board Game Review - I Am Evil Robin! I Am Evil Robin!
Transcript
All the fish in the bucket now. Hi everyone, I'm the Broken Meeple, win or lose, I'm going to be honest with you and we're finally back to reviewing some games. I've had to deal with Essen, I've had HandyCon, I've obviously been exhausted in between both. Hell, I'm probably still quite exhausted now, but you know, we got to get on with reviewing some of these games. You know, there's plenty enough to cover before Christmas and some will be covered after Christmas, but you know, the best way to do it is just to make a crack at it. So this is the Trials of the Forest, sorry, the Trial of the Forest. There's only one trial. And this is from Rebel Studio, who I've got a bit of a soft spot for. They've made some very charming light games in the past. Two of note being Dream Home, a very you know, nice little just zen-like game about building up your well, your home full of rooms and decor and stuff. But most notably, Meadow. Meadow is essentially their magnum opus game. It is beautiful, it is gorgeous, and it's just a nice light card game. So naturally, anything I see from them is I'm hoping supposed to be looking pretty good, but also I'm just hoping it gives me that kind of charming light feel for a game. You know, they don't tend to go heavy, they don't tend to go overly complex or anything. They just tend to be, you know, kind of ah, you know, almost like a palate cleanser type game. Actually got invited to the demo by the designer, which doesn't happen very often, but thanks for the review copy. I've given it the
beans and it's time to report.
Wingus, dingus, listen up.
So in this game, you are trying to be the next guardian of the Green Valley. By this measure, you are going off on side quests conducting in the Trial of the Forest. This basically has you kind of making a name for yourself. You can be a great explorer, a great fighter, a great merchant, but then there's also the question of are you going to be a good person or a less than stellar person? I don't know. I'm not I'm not sure you're truly evil in this game, but you can certainly be a bit more mean than the average little animal folk. You're given a character board, and this will have a selection of places. It will have backpack slots where you can put your items, a morality track. We'll get onto that a bit later. And also, it will have a place for your port tokens. These are basically your actions in a round. You have four actions in a round, followed by a tent action, which is kind of like a Think of it as four day actions and one nighttime action. And then you will go through the process another three times before the game ends. So essentially four separate rounds of the port tokens, including three of the tent actions. What you actually doing? Well, as you can see on this somewhat mighty big board, you are moving your character across the board, going to different locations. There's a few on offer, lookout towers to draw more cards, groves to find more resources, shops to buy more items, and ruins to find Well, any manner of things. So what are these cards? Well, these cards represent the side quest and missions that you do. They have all sorts of different requirements and costs. You know, sometimes you need to pay resources, sometimes you need to have specific items, sometimes you need to be at a specific location. On rare occasions, you might even need to be on the same space as another player. But
when you complete these, you slot them underneath your board in one of the respective columns depending on what type it is. And this gives you more icons for that particular action. So in this case, commerce. I could do this one called Berserker, have two axes in my possession and spend the resource, and I get to slot it underneath my combat section. And now I've got more dice and swords to use in a combat section. And this is how you build your character up throughout the game. The more of these little side quest and missions you do, the more cards you slot, the more points you get, but also the more icons you have to make other actions better. If you get a lot of explorer icons, you move quicker around the board. If you get more merchant acts um icons, then when you go to the shop, you can convert those into getting more resources and stuff for your trouble. And that's how you customize your character. On the side, you also have a morality track where cards can slot to shift you from essentially good to alignment, and you'll get victory points based on the extreme of whichever one you do. Yes, I'm not kidding. This is one of the first games where you are rewarded as much for being a goody as you are for being a baddy. Yeah, you can happily be a bad case Robin in this case and still get a decent amount of points for it.
Not often you see that in games.
I am evil Homer.
So you will move your Robin around to the different locations, getting items and cards as such, but there are two other aspects. You have encounter cards, which are at the top end of this board, where they're essentially kind of like public missions, you know. They're basically the public equivalent of these D cards. They usually require more combat, though. But what you're also hoping to do is go on these expeditions. There are three in total, each one represented by a different deck of cards. You move to the respective location, and then your actions kind of change. You don't move anywhere, you don't do anything else. What you do is you flip a card off the top of the deck, which is effectively like one of the encounter cards, and you try to resolve it as best as you can in order to move through and land on one of the spots that has the most points on it. Well, how do you know how to prepare? Well, they've got icons that tell you what items you ideally should have in your possession before you set off on the expedition. It's not a guarantee you'll do well, but it means you got a greater chance you're doing well. And hopefully you're intending to do at least one of these during the game because they are worth a decent amount of points as you go through. And that's kind of the gist of how the game goes. You've got, as I said, four separate rounds of the day actions and three separate nighttime tent actions in order to just basically complete as many of these as you can, go on as many expeditions as you can, and create your character in the way you see fit. Once you get to the end, total up the victory points, and of course, the one with the most
Of course.
So we'll start off with the aesthetics. I mean, it's Rebel Studios, so you expect this game to look gorgeous. It does look pretty good. I 'm not going to say it's gorgeous, but it is pretty good. I mean, I mean, perhaps I'm a bit spoiled by the benchmark that is Meadow. We're not talking that level of gorgeousness, but it's still pretty good. You do you'll to put up with the fact that this board is a bit of a table holder. I mean, this thing is huge. I can't even barely get it on the camera. It is so huge. At least there's no trouble in seeing where everything is because, well, it's all there in very large scale like imagery. But you've also got some pretty decent components, you know, thick tiles, good card stock, you know, thick wooden tokens, uh wooden resource pieces. Yeah, you've got like a very sort of basic style insert, you know, these like old almost like egg box cardboard basically, but it does the job. You get an insert with the game. It does what you need it to do. It doesn't need to be complex or made out of like, you know, special laser etched wood like an E Raptor insert for example. It does the job nicely and you can take the trays out and use it for the resources.
It's functional at its best. But at least on that note, you've also got good artwork. The artwork is very colorful, very cutesy. Gave me a kind of um maybe a similar vibe to something like maybe uh Wild Gardens that I've shown off before, but these cards have got unique artwork and they're very nice. I mean, they look good. It's just full of these little animal critters doing anything from having tea with friends, scouting, delving, recon, dueling, you know, becoming weapon experts, kidnapping.
Wait, what?
Yeah, no joking. There is a card in here called kidnapping. In fact, they actually had to sort of consult as to how far you could take the image on the picture for a game that's meant to be played with families. It has a basically has like a um animal dragon behind like a little fox or something that's tied up behind it or whatever. It's like, okay, this is uh you know, woodland critters as if it was done by a Don Bluth, you know, because it basically is trying to say, look, you know what, you can be evil if you want to be. Here's another one which is basically pyromaniac. You have a little rat with a torch, you know, cackling as he's setting a lookout tower on fire. You know, it's it looks cutesy, but then it's got the total shift of something like Root. You know, I wouldn't be surprised if there was like you know you know a picture in here with the rabbits from Root ship down or something. It certainly does like to shift tone every now and again. But rest assured, it's still family friendly, it's tongue in cheek, it's light, it's not meant to be taken seriously, but it's just I like the fact that it's not all just like, oh, everybody's cute and lovely. It's like, no, actually, if you want to be a dick and go around and basically burn down locations, kidnap people, and fight other adventurers because you find it great and funny, then by all means go ahead and do it.
This game will let you do that. And that's one of the strengths of it. It is a very charming game, but it's got a good amount of theme with it as well. You know, you will laugh at how other people have decided to like take their characters. Are they a goody two shoes? Are they a mean robber? Are they just merchants? Are they fighters? Are they explorers? That kind of thing. But you know, the lighthearted theme is here. You are building up your character. You're customizing it every game and you can try a different means of customizing it, whether you're going to hyper specialize or you're going to diversify a little bit. Both of those methods work. And it's you know, even the items that you pick up will have an effect. You know, the common items are specific to certain cards and expeditions, but then you've got the big items like a you know, a potential auto kill bow, something that a compass that lets you get through the expeditions quicker, and a glider that lets you you know, fly across the map pretty easily.
Not sure why a Robin needs that. I feel like a Robin with the power of flight should be able to move faster than everybody else, but like I said, don't take this game too seriously. Um, but they haven't skimped out on some of the important bits that you need. You do get a player reference card to explain how fighting works, how your turn works, and the important iconography. So again, very useful. The graphic design is pretty easy to understand. You know, a lot of the icons in this game are easy enough. They're intuitive. You know, it's not that hard to figure out what's going on. The rule book is for the most part good. Um, it could have been maybe written a little bit better. The layout is a little iffy, and some of the rules take a couple of reads through just to kind of fully get it, particularly with regards to the expeditions. You need to maybe give this one a twice run through to kind of go, oh right, so that's what you're meant to do with the expeditions.
Because it's very easy to miss key rules like that you slot the cards that you get on the expeditions, you know. Some people think you don't, but it's like, no, you actually do. You slot them under your board. It says they're in here. And, you know, there's occasions where you might just miss a rule or two or you might need to reference this. But it's not a bad rule book. It's got a lot of pictorial examples. It does what it needs to do. And, you know, after a read through and a couple of little checks here and there, I found it pretty easy to play the game and teach it to others. This isn't a heavy game in any way, shape or form. In fact, I would struggle to even call this a medium weight game. This is, you know, not quite medium. It's not super light or gateway level. But yeah, you've got a lot that you can do with these cards and how you're going to customize your character. But you know, if you've played a lot of Euro games before, this is not anything that's going to blow your brains in terms of, well, how do I do this? Or how do I do this? Or what should I do now?
You've got a few options on your turn, so AP players might, you know, shudder a little bit at like, oh great, and I could go to there or I could go to there. Maybe I should go to there. Should I use my strong token? Should I use my weak token? Basically, one of them lets you do more stuff when you go to a location. And obviously when you've got a hand of cards, anywhere up to seven, you're looking at them thinking, well, I could play that. Well, how do I play that one? Or all right, well, I could play that one followed by this one. You know, that would give me this one. I could slot down to do that. So there is an element of thinkingness to this game to stop it being like, you know, float away light. But again, because of the cutesy theme that's on it, it's not one of those games that gives you a cutesy theme and then tricks you and gives you like some really heavy game on top. It's like, ah, it's light and in its own weird way pretty charming.
Admire its purity.
The game does falter in a couple of areas though. Firstly, it would have been nice if maybe this did have a solo mode. I don't think every game needs one, but this feels like a game where a solo mode wouldn't be that difficult to incorporate. You could literally just have, you know, a character where you roll a die for the locations and it pops up there. So any cards where they interact with other players, you know, you just make sure you go to that specific location and you have a beat your own score system. There you go. There's a basic way to play the game solo and it'll do the job just fine. But you know, at the moment it is two to four players. There's no dedicated solo mode and certainly no AI mode in here. But be interesting to see if later down the line somebody could design an unofficial one maybe. But what I said there about the interaction is also another potential issue with this game is that there's not a lot of it.
You know, you have some cards that say you know, give something to an adventurer. And there's not a ton of them. There's only a you know, I don't want to say how many exactly, but there's not that many and most of them result revolve around fighting somebody on your space or giving them resources. Now giving them resources is all nice, great. But it's nice that the game doesn't like hinder people for being fought. It's not one of those games where somebody can keep hounding you constantly, fighting you and stealing all your stuff. No, that's not how it works. The duel is basically I'm going to have a fight with you. We're going to compare attack rolls and if I win I get to slot this card. That's it. And if you win, I don't. So you might scupper me if you win, but at the end of the day if you lose you've lost nothing. You don't lose any resources. I don't take your card or anything. So this isn't mean direct interaction, but that's kind of all the interaction there is. You've got your own card. You're not blocked off going to spaces or anything apart from oh, you took the item from the store I wanted or or you got to this space on the expedition before me.
There's not a lot of interaction apart from just those few cards. Which does beg the question of is there a point to playing this with more players? Hmm, hit and miss because when you play with a lot of players you have a bit more scarcity in the item market, which is a good thing. When you play with two players you can pretty much have whatever items you want. It's not that difficult. I think you actually need to remove some of the items from the board, you know, in setup you know, to make it a little bit harder. But the game says 60 to 120 minutes on here and frankly as much as the game has some strong points to it, I wouldn't want to play this game for more than 90. 90 minutes is the absolute tops, I think, a games like this should be played. It really, ideally, wants to be done and dusted in 60 minutes. You can do that in a two-player game. You'll be hard pressed to do that in a three-player game, but you should at least be able to keep it under 90. But four players with 120 minutes, that's too long. You know, the the downtime is not huge, but it's there. And because you're taking relatively simple turns, you know, you you plan ahead, you kind of know what you want to do, and you're waiting for somebody else to get you're waiting for the turn sequence to get back round to you. And if if an AP player is slowing it down as well, it gets even worse. It just drags the game out to a point where I don't think it warrants its length. So I don't recommend this game that much for, you know, four-player experiences. I think you should cap it at three. You know, you can have it as a very nice two-player game. And if you want to try my rules for an unofficial beat your own
score solo mode, then by all means. But yeah, I think this is two to three players max. I don't think four, you know, gives you anything to justify it. You want to keep the length of this game to 90 minutes. Anything longer than that and you're going to feel that length. It just outstays its welcome a bit at that point.
How long is THIS GOING TO TAKE?
THE REPLAY VALUE OF THIS game is again a little bit hit and miss as well because you've only got so many of these D cards. I mean, this is all of them, okay? This deck is all your cards. It's not a huge deck, and you start off with, you know, five of them at the beginning. You can draw a decent amount during the game, and you you know, other players are going to have them as well. There's a few that are similar to each other or not that much different to each other. So they're kind of like, oh, if this one's a berry delivery and wants berries, there's a mushroom delivery that wants mushrooms. There's an acorn delivery that wants acorns. You know, it's there's some like repeated themes across some of these cards. So you kind of see a lot of these in your first game, and you certainly after a couple of games going to see all of them. And it's you'd be hard pressed to find like, oh, I don't remember this card on the previous game or anything at, you know, after a couple of games. I feel like there either needed to be more or maybe you just didn't see as many during the game. I don't know.
Well, it's Groundhog Day. Again.
The expedition card decks are also not that particularly big. There's only a few cards in them. They shuffle back in once you've done like an expedition successfully or run away. But somebody who knows what's in these decks is going to have a bit of an advantage over someone who doesn't because they know what to expect. Somebody who's new to the game won't. They'll be going in pretty much blind. Yes, there's the recommendation of what you should have on you, but I'm going to have a bit of an advantage knowing what's in these after a bunch of games than you are coming in brand new. There probably needed to be a decent amount more of these. Perhaps maybe not have three separate little expeditions. Why not have one big expedition with a big deck of cards that's a lot more varied. And then you have like a whole quarter of the board devoted to this one area, like a big swamp area. And you could make that the expedition. Having three little ones with just slight little tweaks in their rules, I mean, it's variety in terms of the type of expedition, but it's mainly just what paths you go on, what reward you get at the end. You kind of like need a few more cards in each deck. That's not to say you shouldn't go on these expeditions though because they're kind of important. Um yeah, the victory points in this game are quite low. You don't score usually more than 50 points in this game. And most people will score in the region of somewhere between 25 and 40. You know, if you won the game, chances are you've got about early 40s.
So you don't score a lot of points in this. Each point is, you know, sacred in this case. But the means of the expeditions are kind of essential because if you go for an expedition successfully, not only are you logging all the cards that you find, which are victory points in themselves, but when you get to the end and presumably you're going to do it successfully, that's another four or five points on top. I have won this game once not doing any expeditions, but my god, was I lucky. That was a tight finish and I was playing cards like crazy trying to keep up. It was a fluky win. In fact, I'm not even sure how I managed it. But every other time, if somebody doesn't go for expeditions, you will lose. You just won't be able to make up enough points elsewhere. And you really want to do at least one of them during the game. You don't need to do all three. I mean, I've never seen anybody do all three, but you know, you won't you just simply won't get enough time in terms of actions. But yeah, ignoring them entirely, that's a very risky move to take. You really need to know what you're doing with those cards. It's kind of right, okay, you need to customize your character and go on one expedition is what you're telling new players. And I wish you weren't constrained like that. I wish you could basically do maybe there's a you need to have a couple more things in this game to allow you to score points. It's not a huge issue. You just need to make it clear to people when you're teaching it.
So you have chosen death.
So Trial of the Forest is, as I said, a relatively light, charming game. It looks the business. It looks great on the table and it's got very nice cutesy artwork. I like the way you customize your character. I like these multi-use cards. They are easily a highlight because you're discarding them for icons to boost certain actions. You're playing them for their abilities when you, you know, use them and log them under your board. But then when you do log them under your board, some of them will give you icons, some even give you ways to boost other actions. Yes, I get an extra power token for this one, but then I also get to get get another card when I go to a lookout. There's a decent amount of ways that you can customize your character and all in that all of that is good. And it's definitely a pleasant experience. It's just hindered a bit by perhaps the lack of a little replay value in there.
You're probably going to want to play this game once every now and again, not play it tons of times in a row because you're probably going to see all the cards. It's going to start getting a little bit repetitive at that stage. But you're also probably not going to want to play it with four players because the downtime is not huge. But it kind of outstays its welcome after about 90 minutes. It really just needed to cap the length a little bit or give more ways to interact with other players besides just a few cards that occasionally say give a resource or let's roll a die together. I know it's trying to be light, but it probably just needed a few more interactive elements. It is still a solid game known. I do recommend it, but it's probably about as high as I would say I'd say it's as high as a seven. It's a good high seven out of 10. It's a good game, one that I can recommend definitely if you've got families or you got kids who want to have like the cutesy animal cards. I'm not sure a lot of heavy gamers or Euro gamers are really going to get into this, but I like the cutesy theme. I like how it works and I, you know, joke around when I'm playing this and bantering with other people about what characters they've got and how evil I am, you know, the evil rats. You know, there's a lot of good little nostalgic beats that you've got here. Looks the part. It's easy to play and it's a nice solid game. It just needs a few little tweaks here and there or could have had some extra content here and there. An expansion could fix a lot of these. It could put in a solo mode, you could put in more cards, maybe more ways to interact with other players, and maybe, you know, speed up the game for four players, introduce a way to speed that bit up or give you more to do in between
turns like a simultaneous thing. I don't know. These are just ideas I'm running off, you know, running off here, but suffice to say I think an expansion to this game, a small one, could do the game wonders, but at its core right now it's still a solid seven. It's not great, but it's still pretty good and I've had an enjoyable time with it.
I'm going to allow this.
So that's it for me on this episode of the Broken Meeple. If you like what you see, then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on Board Game Geek when it goes live on the respective review page. Of course, check out the rest of my content. These Essen reviews are going to drip feed throughout the rest of the next few months. Are all of them going to be as good as this one or is there going to be some bad ones? I'd be surprised if there weren't some bad ones, but we'll see. Maybe I can be proven wrong in my own weird, crazy, ranty way. Of course, this channel is only kept possible by the support of the Patreons. You know, a lot of copies of games were found at Essen and most of them were not review copies, but it's because of the Patreons that this channel is able to support itself, get those games to report on. And as I say, you've been asking me a lot to report on certain games. I'll get to them. Give me time. You're helping me out. I'm going to do the content that you want to see.
So until next time, remember it's only a game, and I'll see you on the next Broken People video. So take care everyone.