Top 5 Board Games BETTER than The Crew
Transcript
what i have here is a wonderful game if you've never played the crew and you're looking for a recommendation on whether or not this is something that you would enjoy i will definitely be talking about that throughout this video as i make comparisons to five other games that are very similar to but perhaps better than the crew if i was to rate the crew i might give it a theme rating of 3 a mechanics rating of 9 a luck rating of 8 strategy 8 and complexity about 2. so those are really great scores it's not a very high theme rating but it's a stellar mechanics rating the question is what is the game lacking exactly see mechanics is really a measure of the ingenuity of a game's rules how intuitive they are how clever it is and whether or not the mechanics really click with players but whenever you recognize a game has ingenious mechanics that might not mean the game is for you because it really depends on what those mechanics are in the case of the crew the mechanic is trick taking which is the same mechanic in a game of spades or hearts or bridge or pinnacle or euchre or any number of games that you can play with a standard deck of cards and it may be the case that that mechanic is not really for you and there are a lot of reasons why you might not like a game that involves trick taking
for example cards are really just an abstract mechanic a lot of people don't really enjoy card games period another reason is in the crew and probably one of the biggest faults in the crew is the element of luck it's actually possible to be dealt a hand of cards where there is no path to victory and for some people that might be frustrating and then lastly playing a trick-taking game involves partnerships and sometimes partnering up with other players or even just playing a cooperative game isn't the kind of mood that a person is into or the kind of game the person likes so we're going to be looking at a number of games that offer variations on the same mechanic different mechanics altogether and even games that are competitive and not cooperative so with that said let's take a look at the very first game like the crew it has mechanics that rely heavily on being able to figure out what other players are holding and that's something that i find very engaging about the crew it's almost like a puzzle however the gameplay is entirely different the game is called cryptid encrypted the objective is to race your opponents to find the habitat of a monster by using your limited information and deducing the rest of the information from how other players play what i really like about it and what i find strikingly different from the crew is that whereas in the crew you can be dealt a hand that has no path to victory
encrypted there is always a solution and if you play long enough eventually somebody will find it how long it's going to take to find the solution can vary based on how your opponents are playing and this one is a competitive game so unlike the crew people don't want to reveal information but at the end of the game there will always be a winner and then finally while the crew is really just a card game cryptid is a lot more tactile with its beautiful modular board and its satisfying wooden components when i rate cryptid even though it has very different gameplay i would actually give it very similar scores to the crew except i would have a much lower luck score because the solution is always possible and it can always be deduced through the gameplay of other players but i would give it an even higher mechanic score with a perfect 10 because the way players use components as evidence of what their hints are is nothing but entirely elegant the next game i want to share with you is actually two games and the reason it's two games is because really the two games are the same game but they are a competitive way to play the crew in the sense that they're both trick-taking games just played competitively the games are either wizard or skull king both games are trick ticking games where players bet for the exact number of tricks that they can
take during the round and they lose points by taking either too many tricks or taking too few tricks the thing that makes it really fun is it's actually a riot to force somebody to take a trick that they don't want to take or to steal a trick from somebody using a special card that they weren't expecting and watching them squirm i mean that's that's that's why it's fun you you you watch your opponent squirm it's not a lot of fun if you're playing with people who are extremely competitive and might take things personally however because uh you can would i would call it a game that involves an element of backstabbing so why am i recommending both games well honestly i've been playing wizard for years and it stands the test of time for me it's always a really big hit at the table the only problem is it looks like a standard deck of cards and i don't really think a standard deck of cards qualifies as a board game whereas skull king is the same game but it has a theme on it so i guess that makes it a little bit more um board game-ish there's also a few extra like cards whereas the wizard has a wizard and a jester the skull king has pirates and mermaids and a skull king and like a few different card effects to make it a little bit more complicated i guess aside from the theme the big difference is really the way
that the bidding takes place in wizard you bid in turn so hearing how the previous player bid can influence how you bid and i find that really interesting which is why i actually like that game better uh in skull king you yo ho ho and then you hold up fingers for how many tricks you bid um i guess i don't like the idea as much but i guess it kind of depends on the group but really they're the same game and there's no reason why you can't bid simultaneously in wizard or you can't bid in turn when you play skull king and once again both games have very similar ratings to the crew again the only difference really being that these games are competitive whereas the crew is cooperative the next game feels more like the crew than any other game on this list even though the gameplay is once again all together different the game is the mind now in the mind the rules are very simple the cards are numbered one to a hundred they're shuffled and dealt out to players without communicating the players must play the cards one after the other in increasing order with practice you can really get in tune with how other people are thinking and playing and in so doing become one mind right the reason it feels so similar to the crew though is in the crew you have to work
pretty much in silence to achieve mission objectives by taking tricks and so as you're playing cards you're thinking oh my goodness you know play this play this place or don't play that don't play that don't play that you can't communicate any of those things so i really like how both games create a dynamic between you and the other players that is wordless the mind is actually much simpler though and the theme is non-existent really i mean it might as well be wizard there's bunny rabbits on the card but i don't know what they have to do with anything ninja stars as power up and thing i would say for the mind theme one mechanics another perfect ten luck i don't even know what to call it sometimes based on how it's dealt it can be harder or it can be easier but it's never impossible it's just how good you are as working at working as a group so for luck maybe maybe of one or two or a zero for strategy i don't even know what to call psychic connection strategy is that even strategy i suppose so maybe it's boy this is a hard one to rate strategy is a high number i don't know how to call wordless communication and then uh for complexity like a one seriously a one you can't play this game wrong that's the mind while i am comparing
games like this i want to tell you about theperfectboardgame.com because when i'm not making youtube videos my day job is a software developer and i have a personal project where i have created a rating system for all of these games where you not only can review and rate the games but compare them in charts along different axes in whatever floats your boat there are so many different ways to explore and learn more about board games so if you like board games and you like comparing them definitely go and check that out at theperfectboardgame.com the next game is very similar to the crew even in mechanics it's cooperative it involves trick taking the only thing it does better is that whereas when you play the crew if you play with two players you must play a variant and the variant adds a great deal of more luck and it actually makes many of the missions just unplayable but the fox in the forest duet is a incredible two-player trick-taking cooperative game it fixes the two-player variant in the crew there is no other reason to recommend this game though then you like the crew so much and you wish you could play it to player better but of course as you can tell by the cover of the box it's not exactly the same as the crew it's not about outer space for example
um in the crew you are achieving missions by giving tricks to specific players in the fox in the forest you're trying to move a pawn through the forest and the distance and direction that the pawn moves depend on which player won the trick and what the value of the cards is nevertheless it has very similar ratings to the crew it's just a better two-player game okay every game in this list so far has addressed the mechanics of the crew and replaced it with something else but the very last one is the only game on this list that addresses the other problem which is the theme in the crew aside from the communication limits which i do think is appropriate for astronauts i don't think there's any thematic meaning in trick taking nothing about that says space exploration to me but the last game which is a space exploration game says a lot about that theme and it's cooperative the game is apollo apollo is an asymmetric game for ground control and one to four astronauts there's a screen
set up between them and limitations on what they communicate while the astronauts are taking actions those actions are affecting the integrity of the ship which only ground control knows so using what limited communication they have ground control has to provide guidance for the astronauts so that they can successfully complete either the gemini or the apollo space missions now all of the actions by the way are executed using dice dice are rolled dice are placed the dice element certainly doesn't have anything to do with exploring outer space but the communication limitations are phenomenal i think it's a very thoughtful game and i really enjoyed playing it my only criticism is it feels a little bit like ground control is like a dungeon master so to speak it kind of feels like the astronauts are the ones playing the game and ground control is more just guiding it's just not as active as a role and that might be a turn off to some people if you are looking for a game however that embodies uh what it would feel like to be on a space mission apollo does it far better than the crew or even any other space exploration game that i've
played um not to mention the cards and the detail that go into the components make the game beautiful so those are the games that are like the crew and possibly even better if you'd like me to compare another game if you have a recommendation go ahead and tell me about it in the comments and i will take a look don't forget to check out theperfectboardgame.com and thank you so much for watching bye