Are BAD Reviews GOOD for Board Gaming?
Transcript
hi everybody Danny here I just want to be honest with everyone for a sec I think I'm a pretty bad board game reviewer
g'day everybody it's Danny from board game sanctuary and welcome to another talking Sanctuary video where we talk about board games and life itself in this video I'm going to be chatting about bad board game reviews I'm going to be looking at from two different perspectives one as a board game reviewer and one as person who's looking for board games to buy and looking at those two lenses is going to really shine a light on what I sort of look for when it comes to reviewing games but also purchasing games into my collection now just to put a little bit of a disclaimer out there a lot of these views are my own experiences so I'm only representing myself in this video and just sharing a really honest and open intimate look into my brain and how I review and look at games to start us off I want to come from the angle of a board game reviewer now I started this Channel about six years ago and the one thing that really captured me and really drew me into YouTube was the fact that I really loved filmmaking but I also loved board gaming as well and I also love green things as you can see now I feel like as a board game reviewer I'm not a really good reviewer because a lot of the times my own personal opinions and judgments are from the direct experiences that I have with the game and I feel like I'm only representing my point of view so what I think is a really good board
game experience may not necessarily be a good board gaming experience for you and this is where I feel like I'm quite insecure about this and how I feel like when my reviewing process is a little bit flawed I feel like all I can do is be my true and honest self and if I really enjoy a game and then I hear later on that other people didn't enjoy it I feel like oh you know did I do a disservice to that game did I make people you know lose money because I recommended a game but they didn't like it and then it really started a sense a process of self-reflection on you know what does it mean to review a game there is no regulatory criteria that board game reviewers use anyone can kind of turn on a camera and play a game and review it and say how much they like it or dislike it and I think what it comes down to for me is that it comes down to the experiences that we all have have as a reviewer I can only really share my experiences of a game I might prefer to only play a two-player game or a four-player game and that's what I enjoy but for other people they may prefer to play games in big groups or they may prefer you know really crunchy Euros where there's a lot of decisions it does really come down to for my own experiences uh your own personal preference and play stuff I love games with a plant theme that are nature based a beautiful art but also really good strategic decisions that are simple yet big on in terms of scale which other
people might not like that and I feel like over time I haven't really conveyed those elements about myself as a reviewer to you guys um as clearly as I would like and I think uh here moving forward I'd like to share a lot more of those opinions with you all of the games I do review on this channel are games that I have purchased out of my own pocket um I've bought them I've researched them I've looked you know at what style of games they are and just thought that's a really great fit in my collection but that doesn't mean that that game is a perfect fit for your collection and this is where the huge conundrum and thought process in my brain has kindly just shot off games that you know I say are good should be always taken with a grain of salt like if I have a really bad experience with the game I will mention those things and I will always speak honestly about those things and as hard as it is to do I may have spent you know a hundred dollars or eighty dollars if I can say a game is truly one that I really didn't enjoy I will say it and this really brings me to the title of the video our bad reviews good reviews and I think the answer is a resounding yes and the reason being is that bad reviews accentuate the flaws in a game but not only does it do that it actually helps uh for you to hear really honest opinion about people's experiences it's always really hard to say something
negative about something where someone has put a lot of heart and a lot of effort into creating and Publishing out into the wider world so when it comes to negative reviews I feel like they are the actually the best reviews to read because they shed a lot on some elements of the game that you may or may not like and you know sometimes when I read a review or when I give a review that's overwhelmingly positive I often reflect afterwards and think you know what I probably should have mentioned a few more flaws in the game that people might not be aware of and I think by having balanced positive and negative reviews we can be more informed about our game choices and where our money is spent I will often look on Board Game Geek for all the negative reviews for a game so I'll often have a threshold of about a average Board Game Geek rating of about 7.1 7.2 for a game if I'm thinking about getting it or if I'm in the store and I'm looking it up but I'll often really gravitate towards the lower end reviews where people have given an A4 or given a game of three and really want to see their honest opinions on it and I think looking at those honest opinions really gives you a sense of whether that game is suitable for you or not obviously you look at the positive opinions as well you know if someone has said you know they played it 20 times and they're really enjoying the thinking decisions there's so much to explore then those are really valuable too but I feel like looking at a negative review really checks in with me whether this is a game that's right for
me and sometimes I'll see a negative review and go oh yeah that's something actually I think is a positive not a negative and this is where the complexity of doing board game reviews um is so open-ended and I don't want to open the floodgates but basically all reviews are incredibly biased because of your own experiences our own personalities and desires and tastes and I can only speak for myself that you know when I look at reviews or read reviews you know I have to kind of get in the mind of that person and what sort of experience they may have had before deciding for game is really right for me I mean for me I often look at the rules digitally online I watch videos to get a bit of sense of a game before I purchase it into my collection but it just really has kind of hit me this train of thought of you know what makes games good in general and what do we Define as good games I think ultimately what this comes down to is honesty being fully transparent about how reviewers acquire games also uh how much time they've spent playing the actual games and investing their personal time into exploring all of what that game has to offer as well as uh delving into the different play accounts and the strategies that you can explore I have received reviewer copies of games in the past never have I ever received any money for it but Publishers have often reached out to me and said you know here
are a couple of games are you interested in reviewing some of them and if you are interested we'll send a copy or to your way uh that is just me being absolutely transparent with you guys I've never ever received any money for board game reviews but I often feel like when you do receive a review copy of a game from a publisher that does already inherently come with some sort of bias it's almost like you owe the company uh your valued opinions and I think when you do receive a review copy it is so important to be transparent that that copy is uh one that was sent to you that you didn't pay money for and that the comments that you provide should be taken with a grain of soul and that you should be as honest as you can with the reviews and I think that transparency really helps to build context around how much someone has enjoyed a game and for me I found it really really difficult uh to often find that distinguishing line between bias and authenticity and I always review games where I feel that at the time these were my authentic feelings about the game and this is what I experienced directly and often those feelings and thoughts will change after I've even made a review so these days I often review games that I am passionate about games that I've purchased games that I've really had a good level of experience with where I feel comfortable about being honest and transparent and
open with them now when it comes to looking for board games that I want to get into my collection I honestly try and avoid the hype in fact I'm someone who probably browsers kickstarters just to see what's of games are coming up and coming along in the future but I'm someone who likes to explore games that are readily available to everyone I feel like accessibility to a board game is so important before I even review a game I often think is this game something that everyone can access right now and when someone looks at a review video for a game they want that game pretty much as soon as possible and I know that if I watch a video for a game and I think oh this game's not available for another year or so I'm probably gonna lose a lot of interest in that game so a lot of the reviews that do come out on my channel are ones that are readily available now the other thing I like to suggest to people before um buying a game is to find a way to try the games if you do see a couple of negative reviews and sometimes I see a negative review I try and see if there's a digital version of that game online and play it online first before actually investing in the physical copy and I always ask myself is there another game in my board game collection that does the same thing and if it does I tend to hold off a little bit a little bit more research and then if I think oh that game would be an enhancement to my game collection I then go out and get it if you really found this topic super helpful please
consider heading over to my patreon page and joining up with board game Sanctuary otherwise don't forget to hit the like or subscribe button for more interesting board game topics and cool content this is Danny signing up I'll see you guys soon goodbye