Skip to main content
Loading video...

First look at Re;Match - TCbH Review

Transcript 7:45

Look, I'm a simple guy. I see marbles and I sit at the table. Be it Gizmos, potion explosion, 12 rivers, you get the idea. Which is why at PAX Unplugged this last year, we met up with Mingyang of Brotherman Games to talk about his upcoming game, Rematch. And to tell the truth, I didn't actually know much about the game going in. Eric made the appointment and he was like, "It's got marbles." I was like, "Sweet." that got me in the door. What I wasn't expecting is that it would tap straight into my nostalgia neurons, bringing me back to being 12 years old, burning my summer days playing Puzzle Fighter 2 Turbo. So, let's let's talk about Rematch. Thematically, this is exactly what you think. a two-player dueler modeled after old school Japanese style fighting games like Rival Schools and Tekken with match three elements that evoke the likes of Bubble Bobble and Puzzle Fighter. On your turn, you pull one, two, or four connected marbles of the same color from the two columns closest to you. Think of them as your personal in the shared column in the middle to activate a single power on your character corresponding to those marbles. usually healing, grabbing fans to your corner who will amplify powers of their color, or most often dealing damage to one or more of your opponent's three colored dials, cutely modeled after arcade buttons. Play goes back and forth, but when a player's dial drops to zero, they flip it to its

damage side and lose an arcade token for each currently damaged button. Furthermore, they lose access to moves of that color. But in a great little catch-up mechanism, they can now shortcircuit marbles of the damage color, using those as connectors for the remaining colors and healing the damage button. At the start of a turn, a player can flip their dial back over to its healthy side. But you have to be careful doing that too early or you leave yourself open to quick destruction again. When any player runs out of arcade tokens, they lose the game. Okay, so this is such a simple system, but it feels so energetic and smart. There are a ton of little levers that you can pull that make it a a real brilliant tugofwar. And one of my favorite things about it is that it's not so much concerned with trying to actually be in a performative sense one of these types of games, but it beautifully evokes the the feeling and tone. It doesn't have the complicated overhead or incredible dolification that often comes from video to board game adaptations and the marbles instead of being just a gimmick give a great tangible functional puzzle that makes the whole system come together which a system alone would be kind of meaningless without a wide array of characters to pull from. So, in traditional fighting game fashion, you have all of these different fighters that you can choose, each with their own

style, flavor, and mechanical gimmicks to put on display. From a trickster who sets up boons and banees on different colors of attacks, baiting the opponent to act how you want them to, to a firefighter who builds up rage as she takes damage and goes full-on berserker. to my personal favorite, a chef elementalist who evokes and dismisses fire and ice to hinder the marble shoots and amplify attacks to a DJ who whips up their records to a blissful fervor. Overall, they seem relatively balanced. Like there are definitely aspects of each character that as you pull their materials out of their boxes and you start looking at their pieces and their boards that make them each feel uniquely powerful such that you see the potential in each one as far as how exactly fine-tuned the balancing is like any given fighting game. It feels like there's going to be a lot of micro adjustments that need to happen just to get them into the state where it feels relatively tuned. I've seen success and failure out of all of them, but I'll admit there were definitely some games where it felt like I was on the back foot from the very get-go, including my son absolutely crushing me with the psychic without losing a single token.

on a 20 minute play time. It just made us want to dive straight in again. And on the rematch, I did manage to make it a much more even-handed game, just, you know, uh not quite the domination in the reverse direction that he was handing to me. So, I think this game is one that you're going to know if this is going to be up your alley just by looking at the game itself. And it's something that even though I don't do a lot of 1v one combative games these days, it's been a hit in my household. And I'm looking forward to the final version. But I say looking forward to the final version because there needs to be a couple fixes which I think are on the horizon, but if they aren't done is really going to tank my excitement for this game. First and foremost, as you might expect, this game is going to live or die by the function of this marble tray. And while it sometimes works as intended, over and over and over again, marbles got jammed, and you'd have to noodle your finger up there to try to get them unstuck. So much so that my son, an aspiring 11-year-old engineer, was trying to come up with plans of how he would make it function better.

Likewise, I got this game in a big old shipping box. I have no clue how this will be stored in a final version. And with each character having their own beautifully nostalgic game cartridge-like case, it's hard to imagine how it's going to fit reasonably in a way that makes sense, especially if additional content inevitably comes down the road, as you'd hope from a game like this. I do really like this as a short, sweet, snappy, and clever game, but I need the storage to reflect that being the type of game that this is, and I can't dedicate the kind of space that I would to this as I would to Gloom Haven or something. The marbles are really great, and I love the size and feel of them as designed. I just hope that the final storage solution is going to be able to pair this down in such a way so that the box is also a reasonable size.

In both cases, Brotherman Games has been very upfront, saying they're aware of the issues and have stated that the final versions will be updated for better storage and in the case of the tray itself, much better marble flow. As far as what the final box is going to look like for this game to store it all together and how to easily get it in and out and on your table, well, I have no idea what that's going to look like. But if all those things do get addressed, this is easily one of the best, most energetic, and most clever adaptations of a fighting video game that I've ever played and one that I'll gladly add to my shelf. And that's our review. But let me know what is your favorite classic fighting game and who was your main in that game. Put it in the comments. And as always, thanks for watching. Thanks for supporting. Thanks for doing all this stuff that helps this channel grow. We are entirely audience supported. So we rely on you for those likes, subscribes, the shares, the comments, and of course checking out our Patreon. But above all, thanks for being such a great community.

You know that I've been Jack for the Cardboard Herald.

Progress saved