Skip to main content
Loading video...

Reading Bad Reviews of Our Favourite Board Games

Transcript 21:22

no look look at me beans no look up here Dad get Dad oh my God you're such a butthead you know did he just called you a butt head it's not quite nice is it

hello everyone welcome back to Foster the mle a Channel all about and gam things exactly we're here today to do a bit of a silly video CU you know how it do be sometimes I kind of got this idea a little bit from um for some reason what we do in the shadows came into my head and that's definitely not where I got the idea I got it from this game is broken okay they do a segment on their podcast if you haven't checked out the podcast you should where they will read a negative review of a board game and the other person has to guess what the score is but score like the rating oh I got you but we're gon to add another step to see if the other person can also actually it's going to be probably too hard to guess the game we'll try because yeah we'll try we're going to try and pick games that we both love because that makes it even better but we'll see if you can guess the game and the rating of the review that was left you going first I will do one first are we doing five each sure all right are you ready Jeff here's your first one massively overproduced multiplayer Solitaire Point salad crap you've seen a 100 times before Kickstarter obviously what first what do you think the rating of that review is can you read it to me one more time massively overproduced multiplayer solitire Point salad crap you've seen a hundred times

before Kickstarter obviously so my initial my initial reaction oh I got to do the rating first right okay um uh I'll say two it is a two nice and what game do you think it might be so I initially went to uh tapestry but Stone Mar doesn't do Kickstarter right so it's not it's not tapestry but that's immediately what I thought of Point salad overproduced multiplayer multiplayer solitire see then I I'm like is that tend could be tend but do you pull out a recent love I'm gonna say tend no it's distilled what it's a bad review that's what I'm saying I don't know what these people are talking about I know Jeff I know you ain't you ain't got to tell me twice I understand not liking it do you I don't game am well no but like the complaints there are really weird mhm I mean there is limited interaction sure overproduced though Kickstarter obviously see I think a lot of the time that's the actual problem yeah the problem isn't the game people just have an issue with the platform they're crowdfunding on sure and they use the rest as an excuse okay ready ready overproduced table hog with an extended setup plus teach before a long drawn out game with many fiddly Rules theme is imaginative but doesn't interest me and

overall none of the game here would draw me back for another try the idea itself of bag building plus area control could work but it needs to be streamlined and simplified far more than this wouldn't seek to play again can only see myself playing this for the company not the game oh bag building plus area don't forget you got to guess the rating first uh I'm gonna say three no it is a four oh four um man bag building plus area control should be a dead giveaway should when you said about the setup the only thing that could come to my mind was dinosaur world but I don't think that's it if you need me to read it again let me know yeah read it again overproduced table hog with an extended setup and teach before a long game with many I know what this is It's wonderlands or it is wonderlands or four no listen Wonderland's War there's also there's not really any fiddly rules there isn't it's very straightforward it's very straightforward also like the setup's valid it takes a lot to set that game up sure um but that I also don't think the teach is that complicated I think it's one of those things too we don't understand the context of who like that person might not play many games yep 100% the idea of bag building plus push your luck could work no it does work it works it works quite great actually

worth playing to try worth playing to try to not fall asleep at a convention or other long event that's the review first the rating yeah I'm gonna say three to five okay it makes me think it's probably a party game because it's like to not fall asleep right is that what have said mhm so that puts my like head into like Fuji flush or something like like that I and but that's a Mii thing Fuji flush is a mi convention game MH it's definitely a party game I think it might be it could also be so Clover I'm GNA say Fuji flush it's sheepy time which is why then not falling asleep part is funny oh yeah I wonder if they meant to do that I don't know I thought it was funny I never would have guessed that no she becomes a great game she becomes a great game I don't know why people poop on it people poop on it I do I do feel like that that game shockingly MH people are either love or just it's a throwaway totally yeah it's really I feel like we're the only ones yeah me too and maybe that maybe we're we could be the weird ones maybe yeah okay ready expensive box of toys accompanied by a light dice rolling activity instead of any sort of actual strategy game like its predecessor I got bored with it

quickly sold a box guess the rating first two three a box of toys predecessor a box of toys I don't know why I'm looking around here a box of toys what comes with a box of toys read it to me again there's one I'm specifically thinking of but it's not this game oh um in terms of box of toys right expensive box of toys accompanied by a light dice rolling activity instead of any sort of actual strategy game like its predecessor I got bored with it quickly sold oh man I I don't know I don't know return to dark tow is coming to my head but I know that's not it light dice rolling game with toys and no Str strategy and no strategy none and apparently a predecessor that's the same issue is it Mountain Goats nope I knew it wasn't what is it it's funny you were looking around cuz it is in this room it is it's final girl how dare you what toys are even in there also light dice rolling it's not expensive no if you can and also there's a ton of strategy it does come down to dice rolling that's valid you mitigate that with your card play and there's no

toys in there first of all the core box is like $19.99 and each feature film is $19.99 so how is that expensive you don't have to buy everything even though you should because it's amazing that's annoying a box of toys annoying what do you get when you suck all the fun and player interaction out of Magic the Gathering and paste on the most generic TR unimaginative fantasy theme one can muster question mark this turd res I would say one it's a one and it's listen Okay valid complaint about the generic fantasy art that's valid I don't think it's as bad as people pretend it is stripping away all the magic like that's B that just screams me you you suck at res Arana and like that's fine but that doesn't make it a bad game there's so many here like listen to this don't even have the words to describe it abysmal game experience and complete Randomness while chasing my tail what Randomness I don't know see they're probably playing the stupid draft variant yeah you're playing it wrong that did that pissed me off yeah that'll do it all right I imagine the pitch for this game when something like let's take standard deck builder replace cards with dice give them effects that are both complicated and annoying to interpret and top off the whole thing with a pointless map instead of normal scoring is that cubitos it is cubitos well done what's the number uh two four a four you gave it such a bad

review first of all kitos is amazing I don't even care I don't care what anybody say well you said like deck building but it's dice so it's a dice building and then ridiculous maap we love cubitos we just played that too with Ben and Sara yep and I think they like bought it right away this one says the upside dot dot dot oh the downside you lost me at the dot dot dot the downside I found nothing to like on this one I still think I was hypnotized into trying it that could be anything do you want me to give you one with a better well yeah I mean I have nothing to go off that could be literally any game I mean unless the hypnotize is like a key but no it's not all right I hate the fact that this game has no strategy and the most powerful player becomes a Target I find it really annoying maybe it has some fun deep really deep inside bad party game okay one more time I hate the fact that this game has no strategy and the most powerful player becomes Target I find it really annoying maybe it has some fun deep really deep inside bad party game I don't forget about the rating yeah I'm going to say two it's a two okay I'm the ratings you are yeah I'm not what a party game see now I'm wondering like did she pick Fuji flush cuz I mentioned Fuji flush or is it even a party game yeah that's the other thing

people can get Loosey Goosey with those terms the what what what it say about the one what the best player again most powerful player becomes Target well yeah like what geez Louise man I'm going to say zuis no okay dice town of course the most ridiculous complaint okay I just need to say this I could see people uh I love dice town we love dice town we show everyone I don't again I don't think I don't know if Ben and Sarah were big on it and uh I know Max was kind of mid on it so it's it's not like everyone loves this game but I just I have one issue with this complaint and that is the the the leader is targeted the whole point of the game is to race for points yeah so yes and like so you can steal cards and stuff so yes if I have a bunch of points I'm gonna expect people to steal from me yeah I don't I don't understand people sometimes Man People are funny that's a good one that was a good one I don't this might be too generic if it is I'll I'll grab another one this is a really really good production at any price point and it's so good that it almost un it's almost unheard of in this price range however I did not like the game

even a little bit we were maybe half an hour in when every Everything P everyone pivoted to doing the only thing that would eventually trigger the end at that point it ceased to be fun or interesting to me three it is a three um H really good price point for the production I'll just emphasize for the production this will be hard one it there's really not a lot of is it fromage it is not fromage what is it honey Buzz I don't understand that either people poo on honey buzz and I'm not here for it because I love honey Buzz okay you probably played it wrong one of the worst games I've ever played overly complicated rules vague and confusing actions combined with a dumb theme the only good thing about the game is the art so at least it will look nice collecting dust on the Shelf two one is it root no do you want another guess no it's Cosmic

frog again I can understand people not liking frog but all of those things listed irrelevant any such a heads down game that there hardly seems to be any point in playing multiplayer somewhat interesting as a puzzle but prone to frustrating moments uh surprisingly ugly considering it comes in such a beautiful box not for me Obsession guess the number first four three is it Obsession it is not Obsession what is it Calico

what what do you mean what do you mean I don't know what do you mean I don't know apparently the the I don't know what do you mean that doesn't even make sense okay I feel like I need to combine a couple of these because none of they're pretty generic so let me know if these are too generic ready the downtime with four people is excruciating just wait not people WR everybody was telling how fantastic the game is I was let's say very disappointed that's it just wait my favorite one dumb baby

game Dumb baby game say one uh two ah dumb baby games are twoo okay when you find out what game this is you're going to okay dumb baby game and too much downtime yeah that makes that's that seems like an oxymoron I know because like if there's a lot of downtime that makes me think they people are thinking a lot but a dumb baby game thinks makes me think it would be like dumb baby uh dumb baby game with too much downtime I feel like it's something completely obnoxious like koay or something oh dumb baby game dumb baby game what's a game I love that's a dumb baby game um I'm G say Agricola Grand Austria Hotel what first of all there's not a lot of downtime in that game no Dum dumb baby game how Smart's your baby so smart all other babies must be too dumb to play there's no downtime in that game you just draft dice yeah you do the thing you do the thing the next person you don't have to wait really yeah you can just okay last one for me I thought about this more and this game is so mediocre the art is horrible and the gameplay isn't as fun and feels very

convoluted I hate the art the most though and the fact it is such a modern game and it has this level of no care makes me more disappointed but is the art really bad though is it a two I mean it's not a two it's a four I mean I could see people looking at this and hating it I could see that being true I disagree but art is subjective but is this a dumb baby game so I I'll give you a hint I could see dumb baby game being a review on here okay yeah it's not that I saw but I could see someone saying oh just to help you along a little bit can you read this to me again sure can I thought about this more and this game is so mediocre the art is horrible and the gameplay isn't as fun and feels very convoluted I hate the art the most though and the fact it is such a modern game and it has this level of no care makes me more disappointed please tell me it's not forage you've guessed fromage it's not fromage take another guess you've guessed fromage a bunch every game fromage what is it dumb baby game fromage fromage trying to think of a game that I am questioning the art once I tell you I you'll be like oh yeah okay tend no what fast loss I almost did Fast loss for you yeah yeah

the art is a little yeah and it could be a dumb baby it's a bit of a dumb baby game but we love it yeah oh that was fun I like reading negative reviews maybe someday if we get real spicy we'll do reading negative comments on our channel for our patreons that would be really let's throw it out to the community would you be interested I know that you would in US basically roasting ourselves for a video um and reading some of our but the problem is we delete a lot of them we delete a lot of them I do screenshot some of the really bad ones but maybe that's a little bit too spicy that might be a bit too spicy that might be a good patreon video and if we're going to do that we should maybe accumulate some more yeah screenshot them yeah most of them are really mean that's why like mean in a way that's like not just to us but mean to like Humanity or to us or let's be clear or to us you know let's be clear anyways that was really fun if anybody else wants to do this you go right ahead make sure that you start listening to this game is broken podcast because they do stuff like this all the time they they're phenomenal it's a board game game show I don't drive a ton so I don't listen to podcast a lot uh but man they're just so funny if you're looking for if you like board games you're looking for a really good laugh or board gam thanks um you should check them uh check them out give them a listen definitely should that's everything that we have for today we are only going to have probably two videos this week just

so everybody knows I don't know if this one when this is coming out within the week but because we're traveling we're at BGC con we're probably playing a game right now while we're there yep everything that we have if you're interested in board games like any of the amazing ones that we talked about today ignore all of those terrible reviews you should first start by checking your friendly local gaming storm for us that is the boardroom Game Cafe and if you like what you see subbe hope to see you again soon and now we say goodbye goodbye days goodbye two now some of these I'm reading I'm like this will make Jeff mad I should read this one oh my God oops that's a really good one this one has so many good ones Jamie's just trying to go for my soul yeah I love when people write ridiculous comments don't look I'm not I want to pick one that I know is really going to hurt your feelings well that's what you're doing to me yeah oh my God dumb baby um just so you know I was looking at five cucumbers pH skiren and someone wrote I'm not convinced there's any way to make a choice in this game and I wanted to be like is that Max is that Max Max's burner account

Progress saved