Lord of the Rings: Adventure to Mount Doom (Review)
Transcript
hey everybody welcome back to the dungeon dive Daniel here I hope you're doing well and if you're not I hope you are soon okay today in the channel we are taking a look at the Lord of the Rings adventure to Mount Doom a Cooperative game from Michael renick with illustrations by Alexander cars and I really want to call out the art in this game because I think it's pretty fantastic and it's the thing that actually got me to buy the game because I'm not a huge fan of Lord of the Rings I love The Hobbit but uh the Lord of the Rings I think is just okay I love the movies but I'm not a big fan of the books but let's read a little bit about the Lord of the Rings adventure to Mount Doom froto quest to destroy the one ring in the fires of Mount Doom is fraught with Peril luckily his loyal companions are ready to protect him on his journey with smart dice selection players work together to move the fellowship figures across the game board a beautifully Illustrated map of Middle Earth yes I agree and let's see will Frodo reach Mount Doom before he loses his confidence in this Cooperative fantasy board game all players will win or lose together so while this game says it's a Cooperative game in all actuality it really is just a solo game there isn't much for each individual player to do while another player is uh taking their turn there are no different characteristics to the different members of the fellowship so in all actuality this really is just a solo game and in this solo game you are trying to get the
fellowship standy so that is Sam and Frodo you are trying to get them from Rivendell down here all the way up to Mount Doom up in the upper right hand corner of the map and to do that you will be rolling Dice and moving the fellowship together individually but you want to keep them as grouped together as possible and so in the fellowship we have Galos he is represented by the green Dy and then we have Aragorn with the blue Dy we have gimy with the red die and then Mary and Pippen with the purple die and then the fellowship is the orange D and then we also have these two encounter die and a DI to use for combat so the game board is basically just a track and once I noticed that I felt a little disappointed because I I was so in love with the art on this board I thought it looked amazing and it's one of the main reasons why I bought this game to begin with and I was expecting more of an adventure game but really this is a dice rolling somewhat uh puzzle game a little bit of hand management some resource management but the track is divided into stages so the first stage here is rivendale to lth lauran and then we have lth lauran to Rohan and then Rohan to Helms Deep Helms Deep to Gondor Gondor to Menace morgal and menace morgal to Mount Doom and you want to try to move the fellowship as
evenly as possible and you don't want Sam and Frodo the fellowship standy to get too far out ahead of the rest of the fellowship because the fellowship who is ahead of the Ring bearers but not yet past the next stage end they can help in battle so they're kind of like Scouts they're going out ahead of Sam and froto and fighting things on their behalf if Sam and froo get too far ahead of the rest of the fellowship then they are In Harm's Way they are in danger as you are traveling from one location to the next you will have a certain number of Random Encounters and each of the stages has uh some certain cards associated with it so we have our L lauran cards here and the loran cards each stage will have a number of good cards and bad cards the good cards when you encounter them you can take them into your hand and these become ways to mitigate bad luck at the beginning of the game you will have a randomly drawn Gandalf card and then Gandalf can help you out uh you will start with the Boromir card and then as you gain more friend cards you can pull those into your hand and those can be used one time during the game to help mitigate some bad luck the rest of the encounter cards will be various bad cards you might come across the ball Rock in which you'll have to take certain damage uh you can fight a cave troll in which you'll have to roll the combat die or take two damage you can
have an orc fight uh you might have to place some NS ghoul on the nsgl track so here we have the witch King he's hanging out at menis morgal and then we have eight different places for nzou if this ever fills up then it is game over so this is kind of a threat track that you have to keep uh the manage and then we also might have a sarmon here who is going to be making his urai over in Eisen guard and Eisen guard is up here in the left-and corner and certain irai will be placed on this track and that will dictate the damage and certain combat things that happen when you fight the irai so you want to try to keep this down as as well as uh the the uh the men morgal track here we also have two tokens here that will represent Gandalf and tree beard tree beard when you get him as a friend he can come over over here and he can help you in Eisen guard and then Gandalf can maybe help somehow over in Helms Deep but those will be only triggered by certain cards that you might have in your hand certain friend cards or powerful cards okay so my fellowship figure has reached lth lauran so now I'm ready to set up the next stage of the adventure and that is lth lauran to Rohan so I'm going to take the Rohan cards and give those a sh there are seven cards and in each game you only use six so we will take those and we have a track down here and this track corresponds to the role of a black d here the event die and then you will
have to do what it says and so you will take a face down card at one a face down card at six and then you will put two three four and five face up so we have uh we have S sarmon so he will be uh continuing to create yurai up in Eisen guard we have a king Theoden so King in is a good card so we can take him into our hand if we roll three and we have the urai which is a bad card and then we have one more and we have the wars which is a bad card now we don't know what this card is so this card goes back into the box and we don't know what these cards are these are will be blind draws playing this game is really simple it is a family weight game and so it uh each turn will have a couple of different uh rolls of dice so you will take both of your encounter dice here and then you can choose which of the fellowship you want to roll for and so I want to try to bring Mary and Pippen they're down here they're below lothorian I want to try to bring them up so I'll roll the purple die and then you also choose another die uh let's go with um Aragorn and so we will roll all of these okay a four a five a three and a four so we have the four and the five on our two encounter cards and those represent the irai at four and the wars are at five and so um we can choose which one we want to encounter I want to encounter the wars because that card gets discarded after it's encountered and then space five becomes a space that I can possibly move Aragorn if I ever
roll five so that's really good okay so I will uh place so that's at Five I'll place the five here on the book locking that in so we actually have a choice here between which encounter and then I will go ahead and move Mary and Pippen up three we lock that into the lighter spot in the book and now we continue to roll this blue Dy and we roll This die and now we can choose another fellowship die to add to the pool so I will take the gim's die and I'll roll those okay so now my choices are somewhat limited because I only have one encounter die so I have to do the one I think this game would be a lot better if it came with three encounter D6 and that way each of the times you roll on on your turn you get a choice the second time you roll there is no choice with that encounter die and so it kind of I don't know it's weird you might as well just choose which one you're doing first on the first roll and then lock that second die in because the second roll of the black d really doesn't matter but now we can move Aragorn 5 or we can move uh gimly 4 let's go ahead and move let's move Aragorn 5 Okay so so now that part of the turn is done now we do the action we commit to these actions so we have to have uh encounter number five which is against the wars a nasty surprise with teeth and Claws the fellowship loses to courage and so there's a fellowship track over
here if that ever falls off the track then that's another way that the game can be lost but I lose two courage so I go down to two there are ways to gain courage as well and as well and most of those will happen if you ever roll the exact number of spaces you need to move into one of the stage endings so let's see now we can also move Mary and Pippen up three so they're right here so one 2 three so they have moved and they have joined a legol l just outside of lothlorian okay so now we have uh this diet here number one so we will blind draw card one what is it oh cool it's gadriel all right so before rolling in battle move one move the one ring to the galadrial space on the courage track so she's right here and she's pretty low on the board let me move this camera over a little bit so gadriel is right here so you don't want to play this card until the courage track gets pretty far down and then you can play gadriel and that's kind of will be kind of like a second chance to get a second win towards the end of the game and this is one of the main decisions you are going to be making while you're playing this game is when to play these cards because these friendship cards these are one use and so once you use them they are out of the game so I think a good game will be seeing that these are played as late as possible to help mitigate your bad luck as the bad things start snowballing but let's go back to lth lauran and check in
with the fellowship and so we did our encounter one and now we can move Aragorn five spaces so 1 2 3 4 5 so there are a couple spaces on the board or a couple spaces will have icons if a character ever lands directly on or ends their movement on a heart space then the fellowship loses a courage if a fellow if a member of the fellowship ever lands lands on one of these ring wrath spots then you will add a ring wraith to the uh to the track there and that will be one step closer to the end of the game Okay so we've had encounter one we've had encounter five both are both of those are removed from that track towards the bottom there and now it would be the next player's turn or because this is basically a solo game it's your turn again and you can do the same thing so Mary and Pippen and legol Los we really want to move them forward before we move uh Sam and froto forward so let's roll legol loss let's roll both of their Dice and maybe we can uh we can move one of them fast okay a six perfect okay so we have a one a six and a six and a two if we go to the one down here on the track we can see because we've removed that gadal card from one that one is now a a a a wild space not a wild space but one is now a permanent space where if we choose one we can choose to uh to move same and froto zero one or
two spaces hey that's pretty good I think we will do that okay so I'll lock in my one I will lock in a six for legol Los let's see 1 2 3 4 5 six o that put him right here that's fine we can add one of the which uh one of the the ring race that's fine and then we will reroll that other uh encounter die we will re we will keep Mary and Pippen's die in our pool and I think we will go ahead and add gimle to the mix here okay hey another one nice and then a four and a two uh let's go ahead and move gimly 4 and then yeah that hey I think that I think that's pretty cool all right so we have a one so we can choose to move the uh Fellowship uh here the the ring bearers from 0 to two spaces I think I'm going to move them too um I'll move them one so that way I don't hit on that courage space and then I will also move legol lost 6 which brings him up here brings him up here to this ring wraith space and I will add one ring wraith to my track so I have two ring wraiths on the track now and then and now I will uh initiate my other one so I will move the fellowship or the ring I keep calling these the fellowship I will move salmon froto 2 one two and then I will move gimly 4 1 2 3 4 and so on so that's kind of how the
game is played when you have a battle so this battle here against the irai you roll the battle dime and then any of the fellowship members who are ahead of sammon froto or on the same space of them not yet past the next stage ending space they have a corresponding icon and if you roll that icon you win the combat if you don't roll one of those icons you lose the combat and if you ever roll the eye of Sauron you immediately lose the combat or if you roll a Gand off you can uh discard a Gandalf card to win the combat so in this case here if I was fighting these orai we have in the battle we would have legol Los we would have Aragorn and gimle and so I would roll my D6 here and I rolled hey I rolled the I of sarmon or I I of Sauron I should say sorry about that uh fans the ey of Sauron that was one of those things right that people who aren't into L of the Rings are like okay tolken Sauron and soron you could have chosen any two names why did did those have to be so so similar I know here come here come the Lord of the Rings fans to tell me exactly why those names are so similar and why they couldn't just take the Eagles to Mount Doom one of those questions right I know it's dumb but but so we lost the battle because we uh we rolled the eye and now for each urai in Eisen guard you lose that much courage
there are three urai so I go down one two three and so that's basically how that would work if I had rolled a green symbol a blue symbol or a red symbol then I would have won that combat and you don't get any rewards for winning combat and that's basically how the rest of the game is played each of the stages will have a certain number of encounter cards as the stages progress the number of friendships will get less will become fewer you will have fewer opportunities to gain those friendships but you might be able to hire the army of the Dead to help you on one of those Final on that final kind of state from Gondor to Menace morgal and then here we have our final cards here where Gollum comes into the mix there's Shob the one Rings power the the def file of of gadriel and the Eagles hey the Eagles a small sign of Hope gain of Courage but I think the illustrations in this game are great and that's really about the only thing I really like about this game uh this is a hard game to recommend and you guys know that I love simple games I have a whole playlist dedicated to games that I call effortlessly fun and that's kind of the sweet spot for me I like games that are effortlessly fun I enjoy games where I don't have to think about the rules a lot where I can just
lose myself in the adventure that is happening on the board at my table and the rules for this game are relatively simple so it gets that right what it doesn't get right is the sense of adventure I really don't feel like I am on an adventure on in this game and another simple game that is based off of a token work is the hobbit adventure board game from I and we have taken a look at this one on the channel before and this one to me feels like a really cool adventure I like this game and as a matter of fact I would recommend if you're looking for an adventure game based in a token world I would look toward WS the hobbit adventure board game before the Lord of the Rings adventure to Mount Doom I also think that calling this a four player game is a a real stretch it really is a solo game there is almost nothing for the other players to do you know maybe if you could take control or if you were able to take ownership of one of the members of the fellowship and then they had certain things that they could do throughout the game to to give the other players something to do to give the other players a decision you know maybe and maybe each one had a different Power depending on the stage that you were in depending on the area that you were in I think that would be pretty cool but as it stands you really don't have anything else to do there there's really isn't much to cooperate on because there
really isn't much of a choice in what you are doing with the dice the only thing you need to think about is you don't want Sam and froto to get too far ahead or ahead at all you want them to be towards the back but you want to keep them moving so that keeps the chance of a bunch of bad things from happening and on your first roll of the encounter dice you do have a choice to choose which one but on your second roll you don't so I'm not even quite sure why you roll it twice you should just roll it and then lock in the one you want to have first and then lock in that second one because the second one you're only rolling one D6 so there isn't really a choice when it comes to combat you only roll this die you don't really have a lot of ways to mitigate that as the different players start collecting these friendship cards every player has access to every card that every player has and so this becomes basically just a communal pool of cards that you can choose when to use or when to not use and again you do want to try to hold on to these as long as possible so maybe if the players owned these cards and kept them secret then they could play them on somebody else's turn I don't know there are probably some ways to make the game feel more Cooperative to to to not have it feel more like a solo game but I'm not sure if the game even warrants that effort
and a lot of these games that are really difficult to win that are hard to win they're not difficult games but they're hard to win games when I do lose I feel like oh okay I want to play this game again I want to try to do better uh what can I adjust what can I what changes can I make to my to my strategy to to possibly eek out a win maybe just a lucky win I'll take a lucky win in a lot of games because I'm not very good at games uh but with this game when I lose I just don't feel like playing it again and uh it's been I've had this game since it came out and I've been meaning to do a video on it I just haven't been able to muster up the enthusiasm so it's a really hard game to to recommend maybe if it was in a box half the size if it was a much smaller game then I might think about keeping it because it could fit in a smaller space on the Shelf might take up less table space and a smaller box is just easier to play and I don't expect as much out of a smaller game as I do a larger game like this but yeah so that was a pretty quick look at the Lord of the Rings adventure to Mountain Doom a game with some great art it looks great I love the look but the game play for me just isn't there and so it's just not one that I can recommend to anyone not even I think there are even better family games you know a lot of times people um will say that a game well it's a kids game or well it's a family game but yeah that doesn't uh that that doesn't lessen the responsibility for the game to be good
you know there are good family games there are good kids games and I just don't think that this is one of them unless your family just really really loves Lord of the Rings and hey if they do you might get into this you might get something out of this game so all right guys well hope you enjoyed this look at the Lord of the Rings adventure to Mount Doom we will talk to you later byebye