Skip to main content
Loading video...

Streets Review - Cute, but any Good?

Transcript 11:18

earlier this week i had the opportunity to play streets a beautiful new tile placing game where players build city streets not only that but i got to play the deluxe kickstarter edition which is even more stunning but is the gameplay as good as the components that is the question that i'll answer in this video hi my name is ben and whenever i rate games i use the perfect board game formula which is based on five attributes theme mechanics luck strategy and complexity so in this review i'll go over each of the attributes that'll also give me a chance to talk about what the game is about theme and how the game plays mechanics and then finally at the end i'll tell you what i think of it so getting started with theme as i mentioned in the introduction the game is all about building city streets and the designer hack and gardner did an excellent job of giving the components lots of character to amplify this theme in the deluxe version extra care is taken so that each type of meeple or citizen for the city is given extra character so you've got the hipsters and the families or the parents the tourists and each one of them is absolutely adorable then every single tile that's placed in the game is a unique building with characteristics on

how it's scored and unique artwork i really really like that a lot and even as the person who brought it to our board game night took it out of the box i was drawn in but whether or not the theme really does well kind of depends on the gameplay at least that's how i score it theme is not just about how the game looks but does the theme and the gameplay work together to really support and give a holistic experience so before i can rate theme i want to talk a little bit more about mechanics as far as mechanics is concerned it would be impossible for me to rate this game without comparing it to carcassonne if you're not familiar with carcassonne the basic concept is each player is taking a turn during which they play a tile and this tile opens up a pattern on the board which eventually they'll score but initially the pattern is not yet closed it's still open so the player puts an ownership token sometimes it's a worker or it could be anything in this case for streets it's a suitcase with a dollar sign on it they put it on there in their player color and as play continues more and more players are placing tiles and this open area grows and grows in value and in size until finally a tile is placed that completes that area and when that completion occurs all players score that's kind of the idea of carcassonne but what's happening in streets is whereas in carcassonne there

are only a few different types of patterns there's cities streets monasteries farms right in streets there's only one pattern a street and the way the street gets points is based on the types of tiles that compose the street so each building has a different scoring mechanism every time a building is placed one of the citizens from the supply is added to the building matching the color of that building space and if there are more than one icon more than one citizen can be added there now a street can be limited to five tiles at five the only option is to close the street you can't go on six seven eight tiles like you can in a game like carcassonne so when a street is completed that's indicated whenever um another street is laid perpendicular to the ends so a perpendicular street to one end and a perpendicular perpendicular street on the other end completes a street of up to five tiles so at the time that the street is closed all of the citizens are going to have an impact on the score too but here's the really big thing the person who closes the street gets to take all of the citizens and place them on new buildings matching their type

so the person closing the street has a lot of power there another thing that makes streets very different is in streets you always have a hand of three tiles so in a game like carcassonne you're drawing from the bag and immediately placing here you've always got three so you have the option of choosing any one of the three placing it anywhere on the map and then after you've placed drawing another tile to replenish your hand that's a really nice way to mitigate luck so that you don't just have a crummy tile but you can choose from among the three now if i were to leave it at that this gameplay of playing a tile putting a citizen on the tile and then drawing a new one to replenish your hand and your turns over it makes the game really quick and easy it's really simple gameplay but the thing that changes the fluidity of how the game is played is the scoring so again carcassonne you've only got a few different uh pattern types in this game every single building has a different scoring mechanism on it every player goes down and they have to score so this takes time the first player is going okay well look i'm scoring for every pink building and so we've got pink buildings here and then they're scoring for the number of meeples on their building and that's theirs and they take that off and then the next building okay i'm scoring all of the blue buildings and so they scored all the blue buildings and then they take theirs back and then the next person and the next person the next person and just when you've taken time scoring five

tiles the next player goes and they complete a street and now suddenly you're doing the scoring again this really acts as a as a speed bump in the in the flow of the game uh and i don't really think it aids the theme at all this is to me very much like carcassonne with citizens and buildings instead of fields and castles but with a much more tedious scoring mechanism so for the theme score of this game as beautiful it is it as it is a beautiful cover does not make a great book i would say 3 out of 10 but for mechanics oh man i'm gonna save my mechanic score until the end let's talk about luck really quick i love the luck mitigation aspect of it i love having a hand of three tiles at all times i think that's excellent i also like that unlike other tile-basing games every single there's only one pattern right the only pattern is a street pattern so there's always the ability to play anywhere on the entire board every tile can be played anywhere

as long as it's not the sixth tile on a street that's already five long that's the only limitation but you're never in a situation where you get something like oh gosh i can't play this like that never happens which is really cool uh so for luck i think there's very little luck um like three three and that's good i i don't like games with a lot of luck for strategy you're playing the best card out of three um we played a five player game now one of the frustrations in five player game is you can start a street and by the time it goes around the table it's your turn again that street could already be maxed out and you will have lost the option to play another building on the same street that you started i think strategy actually depends on the player count if it was a two-player game i think that'd be awesome like you're you're just trying to maximize your score by having dominance on a certain street that's great in our five player game you couldn't count on it going anywhere so there's really a sliding scale here for strategy i'd say for a a two two-player game strategy could be like a six and in a five player game it feels more like a four okay and as for complexity the game isn't very hard uh except there's a lot of scoring involved so scoring isn't even part of the game like i don't i don't think of scoring as as the gameplay but it feels complex because you're always

counting things up if there wasn't for that i would make the complexity like a two um score you know if it was a oh man if it was a app that'd be awesome but it's not an app so i would give a complexity of three so what are my thoughts on the game well to summarize after we had played i said to everybody i would love this game if my chief complaint about carcassonne is there wasn't enough math involved because the scoring really dragged on this game i think there's a lot of creativity in um the artwork i really kind of like the scoring mechanism itself like the way that every building was different but the way that affected gameplay i did not like it all uh and then as far as mechanics are concerned i'm disappointed that it doesn't add anything very new here i'm i i don't think it's very inventive gameplay um i think moving the meeples is an overpowered move i think that the fact that streets are limited to five is a really arbitrary limitation it doesn't seem motivated by the game at all um i mean we played the game and i was having more fun talking with the other players than than playing the game the game did not draw me in so

i think i would warn against this game i would give the mechanic score a 2 and i would say don't let this game draw you in try it before you buy it because i was really disappointed i had my hopes up i wanted to be awesome i wanted to love it and you know it's my thoughts so thanks for watching this video review i will always be honest with you if you'd like to look learn more about what i'm doing go to theperfectboardgame.com and see what's going on over there thanks again for watching take care hope to see you next time bye

Progress saved