Skip to main content
Loading video...

Tier Ranking 60 Board Game Mechanisms

Transcript 1:07:11

Tier list. Boom.

We're tier listing the best mechanisms in all board games. Let's do it.

What's up everybody? I am Mike. I'm Nick.

We are the brothers of Murf and yeah, we're going to talk about 60

board game mechanisms.

Yes, indeed.

Uh there's of course more than that. This will not be an exhaustive list.

This is more or less the 60 we could think of.

60 we could think of. 60 that show up quite a lot.

Yes.

There's probably something we're missing. We're like, I don't have that. be like, "Whoops." Uh, but we're going to tear rank them in tops of like, man, this is always awesome in a game or this is this will ruin a game.

Like, generally, yeah, I guess. Well, yeah, it's it's generally how we how much we enjoy this mechanic. We are assuming that it works in the game that it's in. You know, it's like cuz sometimes you're like, "This mechanic doesn't really work in this situation." We're not judging based off of that. Um, and yeah, so we're basically like in general, how much do we

when this thing shows up, does it lead to a good time or a bad time? generally at least for us right like yeah it's like you know uh abstract strategy we generally like that yeah you know so that kind of stuff also we'll we'll give a very uh very brief description of the mechanic after we say and then we'll kind of rank it so again if you don't know tier listing tier list is this thing that you're seeing with us here and uh tier lists go from S A B C D is the lowest D tier bad S tier is the best

S is super spectacular da da da S tier is the absol absolute best. You hear someone say like, "Oh, that thing is S tier." That's what they're talking about.

They're complimenting that thing.

So, we got 60, Mike. Let's get right into it. And again, these aren't in any particular order. So, um

they're in the order that we wrote them down.

Indeed.

Uh so, first be dexterity. Games have dexterity in it.

See, here's dexterity. Dexterity is interesting because it's also there's a lot of different We could have had flicking games as its own thing, but dexterity.

I'm I love dexterity. I don't know how

I'll go B. I think

I think B is fine for dexterity. Yeah. It's like they're never going to be my favorite things, but I always enjoy dexterity games.

They're they're, you know, they're they're a junk food kind of thing. I want it sometimes. I don't want it all the time.

Yeah. As much as you think you want all the time, you don't.

Yeah.

Um, okay. So, Dexter and the B. I think that's fair. Yeah. I was

the B like

it's like BB plus. Next up is bluffing.

I for me this is like D tier.

D. I I

I hate bluffing in games.

It's not something I ever see. I was going to be nice and put it as a C, but sometimes has to go on the D, right?

I have no I mean, here's the thing. Like social deduction games, games where you're lying about your role, I can sometimes enjoy, but it's really rare.

Yeah, I feel like we've moved on. Let's go D tier.

Yeah, like it's not the bottom of the D tier.

You think you're an S tier at the start of the video, you're crazy.

You're crazy. I don't I'm curious. We got We have to be Let's make this packed. We got to be conservative with our We can't be giving everything S's, which I don't think we would.

50%

50%, but we got to be conservative with our S's. And most things will probably end up in B, right? Most things are the bell curve is

Yeah.

You know, should be

uh What about auction slash bidding? They're technically kind of different, but we're putting one.

I like auctions and bidding more than I think I do.

Same. Yes. Like I feel like I want to put it down low, but then I'm like, but there are a lot of times where it actually is done really well and I'm like I don't think I actually am against I think I think it's going to stress me out and it never actually does.

No.

Like something like maybe like a modern art that's more like a party game auction bidding I get more stressed out about. But like I like when games have bidding or auctions in them. You want to go like B?

Let's go B.

Yeah. I'm that one's interesting because it is like I like it significantly more than I think.

Bridging on A because it always it's a B+

surprises in a good way.

We will also say that in the tier list that we're putting in post, we're not necessarily ranking them within each letter.

So like the B first B is not necessarily the best B. It's we're just putting them in B. So just just also know that. Next one's cooperative.

I think cooperative has got to be an S tier, dude.

You think so? I mean I I feel like because uh this whole thing where we talk we haven't really talked about the mechanisms. I guess we sort of have. I guess we sort of have. Yeah, we have. Okay. Cooperative games where you're cooperating. You're working together.

Yes.

Um

I feel like for the majority of people, a cooperative game is probably something that factors heavily into their early gaming days.

Yeah.

So I'm kind of like I don't know. Would any of us be here if there wasn't for cooperative games? And like I it probably is S tier. We probably should put an S tier because

some of the best games are cooperative.

We play so much less cooperative games because there's just less of them. When we first started board gaming,

90% of what we play was co-op.

Now it's obviously much much it's the opposite way where it's probably only 10% of what we play.

But if I hear something's cooperative, I'm immediately more more interested.

And there's so many I do love co-op. I think I'm like I don't like as much as I used to. It's like no, you just don't play it as much as you used to. But I still if I had to choose if if I had to choose every game ever made was either cooperative or competitive, I would choose cooperative.

Wild choice. Wow. I bang my head. That was so crazy.

You think you don't think so?

I would choose cooperative. If I if it could only be one, I'd choose cooperative.

Maybe. Maybe.

That's me. That's me personally. S tier. Yeah, I think it's S tier. Oo, first S.

Let's go, baby.

Oh, man. Also, by the way, put down the comments, put your put your name. I want to hear where are we dead wrong? Cuz I'll tell you right now, I need a Z tier for the next one. I need the lowest of the low because the next one's negotiation. I will not play a game that has negotiation in it.

Yeah.

Or if it does have it, I won't be negoti.

Yeah. Like trader like

I guess hidden trader we didn't put on this list, but that's also one or social deduction we didn't put on this list.

We're adding one on the bottom here.

Don't worry about it. But the point is while Nick writes that negotiation is the worst.

Yes,

it's a D tier. the easiest D tier we ever made. And

it's the bottom. I know we said we're not ranking them. It's

minus. I'm going to write a minus on mine. I know that doesn't mean anything.

It's how bad it is.

It's the worst thing in all board games. I never want to play Diplomacy ever in my entire life.

Sounds horrible.

God,

sounds awful.

So, why sounds terrible? Here's the thing. If you like it, that's great for you.

Never speak to me.

Do not try to negotiate me into playing negotiation game.

Absolutely not. Will not do it.

Okay.

Next up, though, is deduction.

Deduction. Now, this is interesting because if you if Nick took this survey

three years ago,

yeah,

D tier

D tier.

A tier. Deduction games are A tier at the minimum.

It might be S.

It might be

for me at this point. It might be S.

When we say deduction, we're going to mean like you're trying to get the answer to the riddle. That is the game. This is the search for planet X touring machine.

You are ded it's logical deduction.

Logical deduction rules. Deduction rules. You're trying to deduce things. It can take place in a lot of different ways. Think of Wordle. Wordle is a deduction game, right? It's like you are trying to deduce what this five lever letter word is. That is a deduction game. Uh and it's great. It's at least a it might be S for me.

I like deduction games so much.

I do too, man. I do like them a lot.

You want to do A or S?

We can't be throwing out billion S.

Okay. A. Let's do A.

Now it's the meta of it.

I don't know. I don't know if it's it's so it's the I know we're not ranking. It's the top of the eight. It's the hardest.

This next one is interesting. Deck/bagbu building. This is interesting because like I would say deck/bag building is not necessarily my favorite mechanic, but it's like maybe the most solid mechanic.

It's always

there's a couple on here that I I could maybe make that argument.

Yes. It's like it's always fine. And this is a game where you are getting you have a deck cards or a bag of something and you are constantly adding things to that deck. You will eventually deplete that deck and then you will reshuffle your discard pile and go through it again. There are a ton of games that have this. There are games that have it's nothing but this. There are games where this is a small part of it. We will say that pretty much all the mechanics on this list are on here because they at least sometimes will be like the main mechanic in a game. There's a lot of mechanics that are like very small parts, but they're never like the main part of the game. All of these, I would argue that at some point are the main part of a game. And deck building sometime like Dominion, that's just the whole game. There's nothing else to that game.

I I agree.

I think it's definitely

I think it's very solid. This is another one that I put probably put like an A.

Yeah, A is good. I think

because like it's it's rarely like terrible.

We're talking that and like maybe worker placement or like it's just

they're always good. At least that mechanic is good. Yeah,

a tier in it.

Okay, we got a lot of no C's yet.

What's going to be the C? That's gonna be interesting.

Uh, it might be next, actually.

Say it's probably coming up. Um, all right. So, next up is going to be area majority area control.

Keep talking. I forgot my coffee mic.

Man, where's my coffee?

I don't know. I'll get your coffee, too.

Oh, man. Area majority/control. So this is uh this kind of mechanism does not typically go into the games that we like. This is like you know blood rage. There's these different regions you're trying to fight over them.

I mean just risk you know you want to be the winner risk. Thank you so much. Um things like that. So this is usually tied to more conflict heavy kind of games and therefore for us is not always our favorite. We're not there's not no games that have area majority or combat or you know

um control that we don't like. But I'd say this is like a C. Like

it's got to be pretty

C tier is like

I like more often than not it's not going to be our kind of game.

But I do like at least a couple games like this.

Agree. D tier is like there's almost no games that I would possibly like with this in it. C is like there's some I like some area control games, but it's never going to be the mechanic I I go towards.

Yeah, I think C.

Yeah, C is good.

It's just because it's not our flavor, not because it's bad.

The next one is kind of interesting. I It might kind of be the same thing. This can be like dice chucking. Dice rolling, dice chucking. This could be lots of different kinds of games. There's again a decent amount of games that have dice chucking or droive dice rolling. you know, your kind of lucky dice rolls, but that's always my least favorite part of that game.

Like, is there any kind of dice chucking game where like the dice chucking is your favorite part of it?

Well, you wouldn't say for like something like Elder Scrolls.

No.

Chip theory.

That's probably my least favorite part of it is the dice roll. The fact that you can whiff.

I mean, yeah.

I mean, that's probably the best one for it. Again, similar to, you know, area majority control, dice chucking games will often be in those conflict heavy.

Yeah. Or even if it's like a zombie side or Elder Scrolls where you're fighting against someone, it's like dice chucking is going to be inherently swingy.

Sure.

And swingy stuff, I can like it, but generally I don't like it that much.

Okay.

For me, it's probably C. What do you think? It feels like you're you're more B satisfied.

There's There's some things that I really like with it, especially if we get to get a whole bunch of dice and roll them. Like I don't know. I'd say B or C. We should go with You have a stronger feeling about

I feel like I Yeah, maybe C for me probably. Dice trucking.

Oh man, now the C's are everywhere.

C's are everywhere.

Wow.

I uh I like it. Um but well, I don't necessarily like it. It's It's I will tolerate it, I guess, is a better way of putting it.

Okay.

Which is C.

Now you're including like Yatsi-ish mechanisms there.

I think Yatsi is a different

like save some and roll. That gives you a little more agency, I guess.

I guess. Yeah. But they're not my favorite. Like I'm not a massive massive dice.

Let's add let's add Yatsi. Then how would you give Yatsi style?

Yatsi style game would be probably that would be more like B because I like the concept that I can say. So Yatsi again you roll dice, you can save some and then roll the ones you didn't save. I like that because I feel like I have more agency and I also feel like I have more chances

if I'm chucking dice. You can still, but like I have a a more interesting decision space in Yatsi than just like, man, our two things are fighting. Hope I roll good.

Yeah.

You know what I mean? So Yatsi, I'd probably put B.

All right. Yatsi is a B. Dice chucking is a C.

Yeah.

Dice drafting, Nick.

That's pretty good.

I like drafting games in general.

Sigraas, dice minor,

lots of dice drafting. Oh, yeah.

Dice drafting. Drafting in general. We'll talk about card drafting as well, which will be um at some point in here. Um I think do we not card drafting?

I thought I had drafting somewhere.

Oh, yeah. No, we have card crafting. Let's just put drafting here then.

All right. Drafting, Nick.

So, it's dice/carddrafting cuz it's all the same. So,

that I think it's like an A, dude.

Oh, yeah. I think so, too. Because it's it's again one of those most solid mechanics. This thing where we have a hand of cards. You will keep one card, pass the rest of the cards to the person to your left. They'll pass them to you. You keep one. Pass them. Dice. You might have a big pool of dice. I'm gonna take this dice. Mike's gonna take this dice.

The delicious disc drafting these things

of like, I'm gonna take this, but I hope no one takes other tension where you're like, "Oo, I want to take this thing. I hope no one takes it before me." And then there's lots of different ways you can do it. Again, you have dice drafting. You could draft tiles. You know, Cascadia, you're drafting the tiles and stuff. Drafting is also one of the most

like going varied.

Yeah. It's going shopping, right? It's like you can do drafting in so many different ways.

Agreed. And so when you have something that's so solid and so varied, I don't know how also out of this whole list, what do you think would show up as S tier for the most people? I feel like drafting might be it.

Yeah, there's a lot of really good

people would love drafting. So like I think it's A for me.

Yeah.

But I think it would be maybe the highest mechanic that get the most S's.

Boom. And that's why uh speaking of drafting, we are into fantasy draft. DraftKings, join us. No, don't do it.

Don't do that.

Don't do We are not sponsored by DraftKings.

Don't do it.

And won't be ever, even if they came knocking.

Well, they might send a big enough check. We'll see. Uh,

solves everything, baby.

Uh, okay, Nick. I split, but you choose.

See, this is this is tough. I split, you choose is great. I split, you choose.

Also known as I cut, you choose.

I cut, you choose. Yeah. So, this is basically like there's a a certain things like New York slice is a game that you're split up a pizza. I get to split up the pizza, but then I choose my portion of pizza last. So, I split up a pizza. This person chooses a portion. This person chooses a portion. I'm with what's left. That's I split, you choose. Where you're taking something, splitting them into various groups, but then you usually get to choose last sense. I split you choose. Here's the thing. I split you choose. My my head immediately goes like S tier because I love I split you choose. But it's not so much that I love it. Yes. It's not so much that I love it. I think it's the most underutilized mechanic in board games, but I don't know if it's actually S tier for me. I think it's A tier for me

or maybe B.

It might be B actually.

I think it's a B.

It's also stressful.

It's very stressful

which is kind of like part of the coach just stresses me out.

Yeah.

And I think so much so that I don't enjoy that game

that much.

So good.

It's very good.

Uh but I think ice what you choose is really interesting. It creates very interesting gameplay and especially it's great in like a two-player setting where it's really heads up.

Yeah.

Um I think it could be really cool. Duelaur Island for example. Uh yeah, I split you choose something that if ever if ever someone says, "Hey, there's ice you choose in this." I'm like, "Tell me more."

Yeah,

because it is not super utilized.

Um

I think

you got to be in the head space. I think it's a B.

Yeah, I think it's a B.

Kind of feel like it's a B.

It's one of the things it's tough because I think it's so underutilized, but it's not actually my favorite. It's just underutilized.

Yeah. Next up is hand management. It's a little more amorphous and broad, but like

a lot of times I think of this of like

like this is like every game, right? Like

Yeah. But like hand management, I like things where it's like I'm either trying to assemble like um the best hand like a fantasy realms or there might be a thing where I need to spend cards to play cards. So, you know, a primal or something like that. And so stuff like that where you're directly trying to use and manipulate the cards in your hand. uh you know as sort of the process of playing. I really like hand management.

I like hand management. I think it's definitely a B.

Yeah.

I think it's a solid B.

Solid B.

I don't know if it's A for me.

Also just because it is kind of so generic. It's like that's just part of board games.

Well, that's the next one is just board game.

Yeah, board game. So, what do you think? Do you want A?

Uh, no. Let's go B.

Okay,

we'll go B. I'll save I'll save my

We each get like a veto or two, right?

Yeah.

All right. Easiest S tier of all time. Mancala.

I was going to say the same thing. I was like, I think it might be S for me.

It falls a little bit into the category of I split you choose where it's underutilized. However, I really like all the Mala games that are out there that we have. Like it creates really interesting gameplay. Five Tribes is an alltime game.

Manala I think is super interesting. Um so I don't know. I mean

and this is a game where you're you're manala you're picking up something and then you're dropping dropping dropping. Usually wherever you end up you get to do something there. Um, and I agree. I think it's an easy S for me at this point. Yeah. One, it's insanely underutilized. Like I split you choose, but over I split you choose. I also think it's one of the most fun mechanics in board games. Full stop.

I agree. I think it's S tier, man.

Yeah, I think it's

we have decided.

Memory.

Memory. You're gonna get yourself a D. There's no I mean, okay, let's try and think of a good memory situation, though. I think it's probably a D. Hold on. There's got to be one.

And here's the thing. It's very highly utilized in like kids games and stuff.

And kids are also really good at you know what the good memory is?

What?

That's not a hat.

Yeah,

Nana.

You're selling me on it. Should we see?

Let's go see. Cuz there's a couple that are really good.

I was like, there's got to be some good ones out there.

But if it's not something like that, I can't be bothered. Yeah, there's there's some good ones out there. Let's go C. There's a couple that we like.

Okay,

D has to be like

there's not a single game of this that I want to play.

Yeah, you're right. It's a C. Nana or Trio if you if you must and that's not a hat.

There's probably cuz they're so silly.

Yeah,

but otherwise

Yeah, there like paint the roads. You're trying to remember what someone had or something like that. There's there's certain things.

Change that C to an S, baby.

C is good for that one. Player elimination

D tier worst. Why why would anything in a game be like you you're you don't play the game anymore.

That's insane.

Here's the thing. I'll tell you right now. If you have player elimination, that game better end five minutes later,

three minutes later, right? It needs

or it the player getting eliminated ends the game.

Yes. Exactly. It's like it needs that person cannot be sitting around does it and stuff, but yeah. Like I'm thinking I'm thinking like classic like you're out of the game and then we're going to play it for 40 minutes. For sure. It's like that game needs to end five minutes later maximum.

You know what's so funny about this though, man? For every one of these things, it's like absolutely not. There's games that have it that I'm like, man, pretty good. Thunder Road Vendetta has player elimination.

But that's like But again, the game ends very quickly after that.

So, do we make it D though? That's my question.

I think it's still D.

All right. Still D.

I think it's still

Bloodbath. Awesome. Thunder Vendetta. Awesome. Nowhere else

pretty much. Yeah. And again, there's gonna be an exception here or there, but that's one thing about boarding. I hate this.

Okay, that's there's an exception for that. And it's like, yeah, still D. Don't care.

Programming.

Interesting.

So, this could be card programming like I'm going to make this program. It's going to go

your actions out.

Programming your actions like robo rally or mechs versus minions where you're programming your movement around. I like programming. I feel like it's hard to do programming well when it's done well, i.e. like a mech versus minions or like a quirky circuit. It's a very very a lot of time very robot based.

I really enjoy it a lot, but I feel like it's hard to do well and it's also not that common.

Yeah. And you have to kind of be down for the fact that like a lot of these kinds of games are games such that

your program is going to get messed up. can get really that's the point is that you're trying to not get messed up and so you have to be down with the frustration of like my whole round is jacked up now especially if it's competitive which like Cold Express you know

these kinds of games are

uh I think I like quirky circuits I like a co-op programming too for sure

better than competitive

um it's like a B just kind of like

I think a B is cool like it definitely is cool stuff let's go B

it's pretty middle of the road honestly

how about games that give you action points like a pandemic kind of thing where It's like I can do four things on a turn. How what kinds of things I do with those action points up to me. Sometimes things cost more than one.

Here's this list of actions. You have this many action points.

Do whatever you want.

Yeah.

Within reason.

I always think that's pretty fun, especially if there are things that have variable costs where it's like I'm going to spend more of my turn essentially doing this thing. Uh I like action points.

I think it's probably like an A for me. I I I enjoy it quite a lot. Again, it's one of those things where it's not like a sexy mechanic,

but it's a very solid. Yeah. Right. Hell yeah.

But it's so solid that I feel like it can't really go below a cuz also like in what situation is this a bad thing.

Yeah.

Whereas like you could see like, oh, deck building could be bad in a certain situation. Like when is action points going to be a bad thing?

Let's go. Let's go A. Let's go A. Racing games. Games with a racing element. So I'll say are we Yeah. So racing elements. So this would be like a racing game like a heat where you're trying to finish something first. Are we including games like Arc Nova where you're racing to cross like two scoring markers like Raj is a gun?

I think less so. I'm thinking more of like the point is to win the race.

Then it's probably less for me.

I like the arc.

You think we should open it up to more things?

Not necessarily.

Scythe is a race game in that way. You know what I mean? where it's like you're trying to be the first one to get six out there a lot. It's not the ultimate

and that's the thing

victory condition but like

the distinction I like those more than I like racing games like

Thunder Road, not Thunder Road, like um Heat or something like that. I like them both, but I like the kind of race games. It's probably a B for me either way if I'm being completely honest.

I think I agree with that. I think it's B.

Just a straightup racing game like Flam Rouge is probably closer to a C for me. I think there's uh I need racing games is one of those things where it's like I need like one or two good racing games in my life and I don't need more than that.

I think I'm pretty with you on that.

Whereas I'm like I'll take as many worker placement games as I can get. Racing I need one or two I'm done.

Sure.

All right.

So B then we're kind of encompassing everything.

I think so.

Okay. Next we see real time.

This one's tough cuz man I Here's the thing. I feel like this is going to be

this is an interesting I don't Yeah, I don't quite know what to do with this one.

I feel like it's a C plus because I don't I have to be so in the mood for a real time game, but there are

there are real time games we like.

And that's the thing is but there but there are a number that I do enjoy a lot. So it's like I don't know if it's a B though. I feel like it's at like the top of the C because like how often am I reaching for a real time game? I have to be so in the right mood. And the thing is that's also tricky is that for some people, I would even say a small portion of people, it's an absolutely not because it's too stressful.

So, it's also very kind of group dependent and mood dependent. I think it's a C, man.

Yeah.

I just think because of that, it's not that we have time with it. But yeah,

but yeah, that's a tough one.

How about rolling and moving, man?

Pretty D tier, right? There's been people who have like a couple there's been some cheeky things recently like it's roll and move, but I put a bunch of stuff in here. I mean, Magical Athletes back and better than ever. Uh, but like it's sort of the joke of like what

you should still do. You still could do the roll and move part differently. Everyone could have a hand of movement cards. Yeah.

That have different values. So then you get to choose, but you can do this exact thing differently and it'll be better every single time.

Yeah. I think that's the problem is like so many of those games of our past that that are reasons why we like stop playing board games when we grow up a little bit is you're like, I spun the spinner, I moved to the thing, I did the thing it told me to do. I made zero choices there.

Yes,

I spun. I guess I chose how hard to spin the spin.

Like at least with like something like Talisman, when you roll, you can go either this direction or this direction. At least you have a

All you need is just a choice.

But like Yeah, I would say D cuz I'm like, man,

cuz not only is it not very fun,

choose a different way to move around.

And it's also the meme for like bad game of the past is roll move.

Totally.

It's like that's what you will site.

Yeah.

Next is set collection. Set collection's interesting because it's kind of like an action point thing where I'm like the floor is so high.

It's the epitome of like an A where you're like it's always really good.

It's in a billion games.

And yeah, as a result I feel like the ceiling on it a little lower. Like

it's it's one of those things where it's like it's never anyone's favorite mechanic, but so few people dislike this mechanic.

And so many great games have an element of set collection in them.

Um you know,

it's a it's a solid A, right?

I think it's a solid A. Solid A, right?

I couldn't put it in S, but it's like it's really good.

This is one of those kind of ones like cooperative

wrote as I said that, but a stay in your lane collection.

Uh, next one is solo. This is again one of those things where it's like this is kind of like a type of game. Co-op game is one of those ones that is technically a mechanic. I mean, a b a I like playing games solo. I would never necessarily like choose if I had someone to play with for the most part, but I like maybe it's B then because I like how how more often people get to play board games because of solo modes.

Exactly.

You know what I mean? Hell, we get to play more games because of solo modes because we don't get as much recreational game tonight solo. Yeah.

Um,

and I do enjoy playing solo, but I definitely enjoy playing solo much less than playing with

I'd rather play with some of my best friends. Like

it's like a B.

Yeah, I think a B and stuff. But I'm I'm with you in terms of like I think the fact that so many games now have solo modes.

Would you say it's it's over 50%.

I think so.

Yeah. Right.

I think so.

At least the Euro games, modern board games.

Yes. Exactly. Right. Uh we're very every every Just know this if you're new to us. Everything that we put our thing through is through a very Euro lens.

Yeah. Very very specific lens.

Yeah. So maybe it's not quite 50, but it's it's a lot of them. Yeah. A lot of the premier games of each year.

I would say hobby games. Yes.

Um and I think that's like a good

good reason for the hobby growing like

it used to be pretty rare now again like it feels like everything does which is great.

Yeah.

Um so solo game is B. Semicoop

D.

I think it's D for me too. I hate semi-op.

I don't think it works.

I don't think it works either. I don't think it works.

Let's kind of work together because it comes into like even if it doesn't have like a trader mechanic, which is a mechanic we didn't put on here. I guess we could. Trader is like a D minus for me. Semi co-op just doesn't work. Like cuz here's there's another mechanic that is kind of semi co-op that I think is legitimately different that I do love.

I love that semi-op is just like always going to be like someone could be a traitor but maybe they're not.

Or it's like we're all kind of working together but only one person will win. I'm like just make someone will get killed or something. I'm like stop. Just make it co-op. Semi-op is terrible.

Yeah. I I don't know. I don't think there's any semi- co-op game that I'm like, "Yes, I love that this is semi co-op."

Yeah. I just genuinely like I don't think

I just play them all as co-op games.

Yeah.

I'm like, "Oh, you want to play Nemesis? You want to play Legendary? Cool. I'm just going to play this as a co-op game."

Yeah. Yeah. It's just not our style

mechanic doesn't exist for me. It's a D.

Yeah.

Multi-use cards.

S tier. Moving on.

The best. The best.

Can we put four S's on it?

SS S.

Multi-use cards. S tier. easiest S of my life.

As the name implies, these are cards that you can use in multiple ways.

Wow.

I love multi-use cards so much.

One thing you can you can understand from like what we're talking about is like both Mike and I really appreciate and enjoy

interesting decision spaces, tough decisions, interesting decision.

Go, I want both of them.

You're like, this card can be multi-use cards means it can be used in multiple ways, right? Like the top half of the card does one thing, the bottom half of the card does another thing. You have to choose are you doing the top half or the bottom half. Um that means every single time you pick up a card, you have to play it. You have an interesting decision to make. And that is beautiful.

There's so many ways you can do this. There's so many games that do this in different ways. You have games like the GRA where every card has literally four different uses it could have. Multi-use cards is maybe the number one game to get me number one way to get me interested in your game. I don't know if it's my favorite mechanic, but if you're talking about like give us multi-use cards,

that and another one we're gonna talk about later are ones that I'm like, cool. I'm I'm interested.

Yeah, I totally agree. I think it's like a board game cheat code like just for creating interesting stuff.

There's so many ways you can use it where it's like you can use it for ability or it's just this resource. I'm like, "Oh man, I really need this resource right now."

It's always awesome. Yeah. For I'm just like, "Yes, this is so cool."

Multi cards rip hoorde.

Yeah.

Role playing for me. It's like a D. Maybe a C. I don't like ro I don't like as much as it seems like I would like something like D and D. I really don't. I do not like role playing games at all. I don't want to play the concept of them. I know with the right, you know, our brother Chaz is big into D and D. Our our buddy David like I know if I was playing in a group with them, the right people and stuff, I have a good time. I get weirdly in my head about it. Like and I know that's like a common thing for a lot of people that try it, but it's just like

I just don't enjoy it. Yeah. Even if I'm in a we've been in very comfortable situations the way I always expect and hope to

with like Matthew and Shay and Paula and something a very comfortable situation and I still just like I just I don't

enjoy roleplay on edge about it.

For me it's like a D. I just don't enjoy it.

Yeah, let's go D.

Okay.

It's not for us.

It's just not for me. I just don't enjoy it.

Order/contract fulfillment.

This is one of those things that's like this is in like

I don't know 80% of games at least Euro games. I wouldn't say it's S. It's A. Maybe B.

That's what you like about having goals that you need to achieve.

I like having goals.

Some objectives, man.

Give yourself some contracts. Give yourself an S. A is fine.

Nick doesn't like clcity. You heard it here, folks.

All right, we'll go A.

I like contract fulfillment.

We'll go A just cuz we're being stingy with our S's. or being sit with their S's

should be an S.

This next one might be an S for me.

Rondell games.

Rondell's. So, this is a game like

there's so many great there's so many

it's such a great games have rondell's.

Yeah. So, a rondell's usually some kind of circle, but not always a circle, but think of something like Great Western Trail where you're going along a thing and then you go back to the beginning. You go

some point you reset and you go back through.

Yes. Usually along rondell's you can move as far as you want, but you can't ever move backwards along the rondelle. Things like Heaven and Ale, there's a lot of games that have rondell's. Rondell's it's kind of a I don't know how to why what it relates to. I was going to say it's kind of like Mala that's not true. I don't know. Rondell's more and more and more. I just I love Rondell's. I love a lot of times when you get to the edit of the Rondell like you're like round is over. So it's that really interesting tense decision space where you're like

you know

do I go farther because a lot of times like you multiple people can't be on the same spot. So, you're like, do I go farther ahead to get this thing? Or maybe there's a lot of like resources or whatever on the spot, so I want to get there first, but I'm skipping over all this crap to get there. They're just so good, man.

I agree, man. I think if nothing else, because we have Great Western Trail and Teayot Wakan, I'm like, dude, those games are all timers. I think it's an S tier.

Yeah, it might be.

I think it's really interesting.

Yeah, I think it's an S tier for me. I love Rondell's so much. So much are great. Next up is resource management. This is kind of like hand management is in like a lot of game if you're a Euro gamer. This is like again I'll say like B because it's like it's not really like the main.

It's so prevalent you're kind of like yeah I mean yeah it's it's in there. It's no no need to rank it because it's a given there

kind of. Yeah. Maybe shouldn't even be on this list because it's so generic but it's like one of those things where like resource management particularly if resources are very tight in a game is a an active part of the game.

Yeah. But it's sort of like the byproduct of you trying to get done what you need to get done.

So yeah, it's like a B. It's great. It's it's never going to be like the shining part of the game for the most part, but like it's obviously very good.

We put this next one in here because there's sort of a a a resurgence of this mechanism is things that use poker hands.

Yes.

Poker style.

Poker in general. Yeah.

Hands and games.

It's interesting. I think it's a I think it's a smart thing to have in games because a lot of people know poker hands uh just from playing around, you know, with your family and stuff like that. So, I think it's a cool thing to add.

Um I probably don't I don't like need to put it super high cuz for me it's like a top of C or B, but it's not any higher than that for me.

Yeah. I kind of think C. Yeah. Like there's a lot of times where it's enjoyable, but like just go play Pokemon.

To me, it's like it's like a for the most part, very often, not always. It's kind of like a more restrictive set collection.

Kind of more specific

because it's just kind of set collection to some degree. Um, I'll probably put it like C. It's like near the top of C, but I don't think it's like great.

All right, we'll go C. Next up, this is one that appears in some things is games that have an element of rock paper scissors to them.

What is that? this game like Ninjan for example has it where there's this suit beats this suit this suit this suit but this suit beats this suit and stuff and there's a few uh uh things uh there's another big one that I'm not thinking of right now but there's like a

Would you think of like a off of their heads

kind of

okay interesting I don't know then yeah I guess it's true yeah there's certain things where it's just like oh this is stronger you know against this thing it loops back around

yeah yeah you're not wrong Um, you know, I just think it's cool. It's It's a one that I would definitely put in the category of like underutilized where I'm like, I want to see this thing used more because it's an interesting concept of like even the thing that you would assume is like the alpha, it's the best, but there's also the one card, the low card that can can trump that card. Yeah. And stuff. And I'm like, that's always interesting.

Yeah, I guess that's true. There's that that game. Oh gosh, I think it's Canitzia game. It's a game where like you're putting out animals and the animals are getting bigger and bigger and bigger, but then the biggest one is an elephant which you can be scared by the mouse. I guess that would be kind of that. Yeah, I guess that's true. I never thought about it that way.

I think it's interesting when it gets used.

Okay, B.

Let's go B, man.

Sure.

I think there's more potential underutilized.

I think there's more potential with that mechanism when we see it used in a bigger

situation. Next up is a whole genre of games and this is trick taking. Although trick Taking I feel like is showing up more often in like as a part of the game. I think a lot of times it doesn't work that way. Hello Arcs. Um but my least favorite game ever. Um

we heard it here folks.

Uh

I think taking is pretty awesome, man.

Yeah, it's definitely a Would you want to go higher than that?

I think this is a movie. We're gonna go S tier with it.

You're gonna do S tier with it? S tier with it.

Okay, we're going S tier for Mikey.

I would probably put it a very high A. I would say of card games, I probably don't like them quite as much as I like other ones we're going to talk about.

Okay, I dig.

But sure, I'm down with I'm down with an S.

Too bad I got vetoed right now.

Yeah, that's fair.

Too bad it's an S, dude.

What about take that?

D is it is it C though?

I feel like there might be enough take that games. You don't think so? What would be a take that game that that that that is the exception to the rule for us? Because in my mind, I'm not talking about a conflict game here. I'm talking games where it's like I'm going to be a little goblin to you for no reason.

Yeah, that's a good point.

I can get in that head space. I do know Jeff.

Uh, and so I have to live that.

Uh, if you're watching, Jeff, I love you, buddy. Um,

that's fair.

I don't I don't like I'm building this thing. You're like, "Oh, oh, cool. Here's a missile for it." I'm like, "Why? I'M JUST BUILDING."

YEAH, THAT'S FAIR. That's fair. It's Dtier.

Dtier trash.

Get out of here.

Um, next one was simultaneous selection. So, simultaneous action selection. This one's a pretty solid A for me. There's basically like there's a set amount of actions, maybe labeled one through five, and everyone has cards one through five. Everyone chooses and then flips.

Everyone's trying to be the the the cleverest little boy at the table. You're like, "No one's doing what I'm thinking." Yeah, there's usually a drawback for choosing something that someone else chose.

So, an example that be like Col, which is a game you're choosing these actions and if you go to a spot alone, you get to do like the main action and then the second action. Whereas, if you go with someone else, you only get to do I think it's called the boom action or the bust action. Um, I think it's a pretty solid A. I really like simultaneous selection.

It always is. It's got so many like godamn

the meta narrative, the above table game that starts getting played is really awesome.

Yes. And I feel like it can happen sometimes where it can be frustrating, but I feel like the frustration that comes with this is almost always a fun frustration as opposed to like a truly frustrating frustration.

I agree. I think it's an A, man.

Yeah, I think it's an A, too.

Uh, how about Tug of War?

Tug of War is

really good for two-player games.

Yes. And tugof-war is interesting. There's something like Zenith right now is a tug of war. You have like Caper Europe is a big tugof-war game. It really mostly works for two-player games.

Yeah, it it it's the most sensible because it's like me verse you. I'm trying to, you know,

for I feel like I like it.

There's a couple This is one of those games. It This is probably like a C for me cuz there's a couple games that I like that have this, but in general, I don't like it that much

because it has that thing where cuz I remember you talking about Zenith where it's just like my progress keeps getting undone. I feel like I need to do this. just don't do it to you.

And just like one v one super head-to-head games are not really my style.

Again, I think I'm out of you and Jimmy the most inclined to like those kinds of games.

Put where would you want to put it? Like B

uh at the highest. We can go C.

I'll go see.

We go see.

That's not my veto by the way.

That's not my veto. That's just powers of persuasion right there.

Variable player powers.

This is the thing other than what was the thing I said? Um, Monala where I'm like, if you have this in your game, I'm immediately incredibly interested in it.

It's right on the line of of multi-use cards and stuff.

Oh, that's what I was saying. Multi-use cards. Yes. There's nothing you can make me more interested in your game than having variable player powers. Yeah. So, this is like that you don't get to do

and then you get this cool thing. I'm also jealous of what you have.

Yes.

It's awesome, man.

And sometimes they're just like straight up that. Sometimes it's something like a teoton where um there's an upside but also a downside to your power.

War I think it's so interesting.

Super interesting. Uh variable player powers is an easy S.

S baby

is an easy S. I love it so much. Put it in everything. A lot of times expansions for games just give people powers. It's a very common expansion. It's great.

Uh next up is gonna be worker placement.

Put that Superman S right on my chest.

Bam. Plastered.

Boom. I think I think I'm trying to think I have a real talk. I think worker placement might be like the greatest mechanism.

I think it's still my favorite. Again, it's not there's a lot of worker placement games out there, so it's not like a multi-use cards where I'm immediately like, "Oo, it's a worker placement because there's a lot on out there, but I still think to this day it is the most solid mechanic out there. It always creates interesting decision spaces. It usually includes that really interesting tension of, god, I hope they don't go to the place I want to go to. Oh, I love prioritization in games where it's like, what order do I want to do? Well, you know what? I need to do this first because I need to make sure I get this. It just has everything that I like in board games happens in worker placement and I I still think it's my favorite mechanic. It's been my favorite mechanic for a long time and I still think it is.

I mean, I think for each of us, if we were to do our top games of all time, we had our top 10. I think for each of us at least 50% of those games are worker placement games that are our top 10 of all time.

Uh probably

I'm talking Viticulture, uh Feast for Odin, Conbon, like

Yeah.

Wayfairers of the South Tigris, you know, like literally like so many of our previous number ones.

Um

you know what I mean? So it's like I Yeah,

Progress Club. I mean, it's the easiest S tier

we could possibly give. Next one's tile placements. Baby, you you're higher than this on me. You want to go a

I It's not an S.

Take a moment for myself.

It's not an S. It's not an S.

We have downgraded to an A.

I'm not used my Hold on. Let me see. Is there any other thing I think Mike is going to choose as an S that I'm going to have to downgrade him on? Um,

why don't you like tile place?

I like tile place a lot. It's a easy A. Fine.

No, give it an S. It's fine.

No, we've had two We can't go with three S's in a row. You're crazy.

That's insane. We That's my That's also my thing is like we have to be somewhat conserved with our S's. Although, we're putting so many on here. Here's the thing. I like a lot of mechanics. Let's do A for tile placement. It's tiles. You place them. That can happen.

We only have seven A's so far.

How many S's do we have?

Or sorry, S's.

Okay, that's not bad.

Yeah, something.

Well, that's we have more S's than C's. That's kind of crazy. Hey, a lot of good mechanics out there.

Uh, next up is be polyominals. This is another case of tile placement, but there are these tiles that you can fit together.

I like this I think less than general tile placement.

Really?

Yeah. Okay.

Not a lot less.

It might still be a h I think it's probably B for me. I just think it's kind of gotten oversaturated, but that shouldn't really that shouldn't honestly really affect my opinion now that I think about it because this is just based off how much I enjoy it. I still think it's a high B for me. You're higher A.

I'd put it in A. I'd put the same as tile placement. Okay. But I'm more of a tile placing guy.

Yeah,

clearly we go B.

Let's go A. Let's go. No, you you you went down for me on tile place. We'll go up for you. We'll do the A.

Okay. Uh, next one is be recall. So, this is going to be you put out your act your workers, you put out something, you do the thing, you put out your cards. When you bring them back, stuff happens. A lot of times you get to activate all these things. You get to do all this stuff. I really like recall ads.

I do too. I think it's really cool in games. Like there's not many

the Luke glory special.

Yeah. Where you have a recall turn and I'm not into what's happening.

Yeah. because it can be small like something like Galactic Cruz or um uh Unconscious Mind where it's like when you bring back your workers you get little bonuses. Sometimes it's like a a Luke Lori game where it's like you bring back your stuff and then you're activating tons of crap like Driver's Edge you're doing like a billion things

and that's uh so whether it's a big big big thing or just a small little bonus thing it's always very interesting.

I agree. Are we go another A? It might be another A. We might have a lot of A's in this. We probably should have more.

Here's the thing. We like board games.

We like board games. Here's the thing, y'all. I don't care. That's our list. A

A. Boom. Our list.

Next up is Stocks. So, stocks. Stock market.

Some sort of economic stock element.

Yes. See, probably for me, there are definitely games of this that I enjoy, but it's never going to be my favorite mechanic. Personally,

I think I agree with that. I'm definitely getting more into games with stocks, but I don't think

X Gamers, man or 18XX Gamers.

I'm the only one we got. But I have like Acquire. I have um uh other games. What other games have stocks and like City of the Big Shoulders and stuff that I don't mind and stuff? So like

18x maybe

think about it. All right. So we'll go C B

C probably for me.

C for now.

There's a couple in here that I like, but it's never

become 18x players. Abstract strategy. These are your chesses. These are your uh uh mythic misstic mythic mischiefs. Yinch the gift.

Santorini. There's a lot of them.

Santorini. I This one's hard because there's a couple abstract strategy games that I freaking love. But as a whole, I'm not a big abstract strategy person.

Same. So, is that like a C then

or is it there's enough of them where it's a B?

I think it's a B because there were there are enough times where my general, you know, apathy toward uh abstract strategy games is overcome with like something being really awesome. And there's some games that we really truly love in this category. So, I think it's a B.

All right. B is fine.

B shall be fine. B is fine. Yeah, I I it's there's probably enough there. Yeah. What about Push Your Luck? Push Your Luck's kind of a similar situation where I think it's a low B because like Push Your Luck is not my favorite, but there's enough Push Your Luck games that I love that I feel like it has to be.

I like games that have some push your luck.

But I also love Can't Stop.

Yeah. I either needed to have some pusher luck or the whole thing is just push your luck.

Fair. It's probably a B for me.

I think it's a B.

Yeah, I think it's a B.

I don't think it's higher than that. It's never my favorite mechanic, but there's enough of push your luck games that I like a lot that it's definitely a B.

How about games that have an element of a tech tree, which is more common in the last days? Yes.

Where there sort of like I'm going to get up into this skill thing. You could say something like an Elder Scrolls is sort of uh Yeah.

Uh, you know, a branching path of abilities and things. I think it's really cool. Um,

you say like brass is like a tech tree

kind of. I mean, you have your your your player board and and you're developing these industries and getting up into higher stuff. So, yeah, I'd say that's something akin to that.

I think in a B as well.

Yeah, it's like it's not going to super excite me, but I'm always interested in it.

Let's do it. B

B. Pretty middle of the road for me.

How about games where you get to bump them tracks, baby?

Is this S?

We have two shirts. get some merch today that are based on bump and track. So, it's definitely not a We have Don't We have two styles of it.

We have one.

We Well, we we're

one in production. Yes. Yeah. That's my We literally have an entire merch

based by By the way, get some merch.

Get some merch today, folks.

Based off of bumping tracks. It probably is. I love bumping tracks.

It's definitely an A. I honestly don't know if it's S as much as I love bumping tracks. The only reason I don't want to go S is because I'm like I don't know if it's really a mechanism.

Yeah, it's true.

It's just something that we love doing.

Well, and the one game that kind of did nothing but bumping tracks, which is Rise, I think was a very okay game.

All right. So, I think we got to go A.

A. We'll go A because I think you could absolutely make an argument. It's not like an active thing you're doing.

I mean, it kind of is in games like Planet Unknown where you're like comboing and stuff like that. I do love that.

So, I think I think it's a mechanism. Let's go. A. My heart says S, but my true self says A. Card crafting games where you can upgrade the cards themselves.

I'm like a C. I don't think card crafting works nearly as well as it seems like it should.

You like Unstoppable anymore?

I like some of them. There's a couple.

You don't like Unstoppable?

That's the whole thing about C though. It's like I can't have one game push it up an entire rank for me.

All right.

There's a couple. It's mostly John Declair. A couple that I think are fine.

Emailing John Declare directly. I think it does not this mechanic does not work as well as it I want it to.

All right. Car crafting C.

Car crafting C. Again, there's a couple there that I like. No, it's the whole point of C. Any game, Nick,

where you can cause someone to lose a turn.

I don't know if that's a mechanic.

It's listed as one on board game. So, it's

D tier easiest.

Or skip a turn. Lose a turn. Skip a turn.

Skip a turn. Lose a turn. It is very of the past. It is something that uh appeals to children like you get to take a turn. Again, a part of the game should never be that like, hey, now you don't get to play the game. Yeah, that's insane.

Yeah, that's fair.

So, it's just an easy D.

Fair. Fair. Drawing is next. I think this is a good C because like there's a couple drawing games out there that I love.

Picked all time. Teleustrations maybe the best party game ever made.

Yes.

You know, I mean it can be great. Obviously, uh uh uh you know, Pictionary, come on. It's a classic.

Yeah.

Um I'm not going to seek out a ton of them,

but there's like one or two that we love, and I think that's a good C, right?

I think it's a good C.

Like C is like, hey, there's a couple of these we really like, but you know, nothing else.

The best drawing games are ones that very much make it that you do not have to be good at art to do it.

Yes.

And so again, it's illustrations, mania, very fun. Um, let's go. Should we combine these next two, do you reckon?

We I think should for this one. We'll put it to the audience. We have engine building and Tableau building.

Now, that we were talking about this before we filmed and we have them separated now, but the thing that's interesting is that Tableau building is sort of the

the visual representation of either set collection or engine building. The tableau you have will either give you abilities and stuff or have things that you've collected. Tableau building will be something that you're setting it a a you know an increased amount of cards on the table. Yeah. That are representative of stuff but they often kind of meld together.

Yeah. Because not all engines are tableau but

Yeah. I feel like I think I think you're right. It's like tableau are more of the

of another mechanism. They are so let's just stick with engine building then. So, we're stick with engine building here.

So, yeah, your table building.

I love games tableau building because they usually are like set collection. Engine building. Engine building's

definitely a high A.

I mean, it's an A at the minute.

It's an A. I don't think it's an S for me personally. I mean, it's a high A, don't get me wrong, but like

and engine building is is at the core of a lot of other mechanisms at deck building. What are you trying to do? Trying to build something where you have a a higher likelihood of getting strong turns. You're building an engine. Yeah.

Um, you're doing these things. So, it's

you're building a set of cards, you know, that then start that activate when this thing happens action that gets stronger.

Arc Nova where you're getting cards that then have tags. So, you're building this engine of T. There's so many various ways you can do engine building. It's also, it's almost one of those ones that's like so broad that it almost kind of doesn't work in this sense because you're like, well, what kind of engine build? There's so many different ways you can do engine building, but it's always almost always very good. So, I'd say it's definitely a for sure, but it's kind of one of those things. It's so broad, it almost kind of works against itself in that way.

Yeah. But it's also maybe the crux of all board games. I don't know.

Uh, next would be route building.

Routing is like a solid B for me.

Solid B.

It's like a ticket to ride. Lots of train games where you're always building out routes, hopefully trying to get to certain places.

It's good. I like a lot of rail games, route building games, you know, a brass, a nucleium or whatever. It's like I like it. I like the mechanic, but it's not my favorite mechanic, I guess. Yeah. But it's a very that's like the most BS be.

Yeah.

I think I've ever seen in my life.

There you go.

Yeah.

Uh, next up is be shared infrastructure gotten more into recently.

Is different than semi co-op.

I agree.

And that's where I said like we'll talk about something. Shared infrastructure is like high A bordering on S for me. This is a game where like you're working on the same thing. You have some kind of shared infrastructure like something like Inventors of the South Tigris where I can invent this thing but Mike can actually build that thing but we're not on the same team. We're not cooperating in any way but there's some kind of shared infrastructure. I really want to do a big video all about shared infrastructure because this is also kind of like engine building where there's this is almost maybe too broad for this list, but it's something where it's like you all are working on it could be like a map. You're all working on the same map and it's like that kind of shared infrastructure is so interesting to me. Yeah.

But it's not semi- co-op. It's not something because again for us we think of semi co-op as something that like

you're mostly you're going to hamper someone else and stuff and these are games that I think like why we like them so much is something we've discovered for ourselves we enjoy quite a lot is something that has positive player interaction where it's like we're both going to get something out of this. I hope to get more out of this than you get,

but like we're gonna have a little gonna benefit from this.

Even if it doesn't, like even it's like you're building out this thing, but I finish it. Like I can even be fine with that. It's like I find shared infrastructure, having to share a space

to some degree uh very very interesting.

Sier,

no, I would say A.

Okay.

I would say A for it. um narrative/stodriven games where you're going to be doing some you're going to be playing popcorn, you're reading paragraphs.

I think this is going to be my veto for you.

Veto because yours is going to be higher than mine.

No.

Oh, I was going to go D.

Oh, great. D C. So, you have to use the veto. C

I don't like story.

I don't mind story. I just

I just don't care. That's here's the thing. That's the thing is when it comes down to a story driven games, get big campaign games that kind of

rather read a book or watch a movie or even I just these

I don't think I care about in video games. I mostly play stuff that's more abstract.

And that's my thing and that's what made me realize that I don't care about story in games is cuz like all of my favorite video games maybe have a story, but I just don't care about the story. I like games like Satisfactory, even like Stardew Valley that has a story. I'm just there building the farm. Like I like games like Mario which I guess have a story but don't. They're just platform. Like I really realize like I just don't and like I'll I'll say one of our best friends Paula loves big narrative games and she'll play this these games on Twitch. Twitch.tv/polyming. Um that I'm like this isn't even a game. You're literally just going through a story. Sure.

And I'm like that sounds terrible to me.

Like I would rather watch a movie. And that's my thing. I'd rather read a book. I'd rather watch a movie. So story driven games, especially game, big games like The Dark Quarter, even like

even games like Chronicles of Crime, which I think are really cool concepts, I don't really like that much.

Yeah, it for me it puts us too much in a passive role for too much of the time. Like I want to be doing a thing and like having my head down and like

and I can like it sometimes there's like a Vantage that I'm like, but even then I've openly said multiple times, I think I could play Vantage like two or three times and then I'd probably be done.

The thing I like most about Vantage is that they're they're quick little story entries. are like a blurb. Yeah.

It's very fast. You get back to doing stuff and I'm like that's my kind of

I thought this was going to be like a for you and that's why I was like I'm going to have to veto this one. This is what my I'll say anyway. So it's a D.

Okay. D

ladder climbing games.

So ladder climbing

scouts, you know.

Yes. So this is a game where if Mike plays a

We'll combine this with card shedding because they often go together. You're trying to get rid of your hand of cards.

Yes. So this is the card shedding and ladder climbing game. So card shedding games are where you have a hand of cards, you're trying to get rid of your cards first, hence card shedding. Ladder climbing, which almost always goes along with card shedding, is if Mike plays a one, I then have to beat that one. I can play something stronger.

I can play that by playing a two or maybe I play two cards or basically a higher card or more cards usually beats it. Those two things go together. I think you put trick taking S. I think as a whole I like card shedding games more than trick taking. They are very close, but I think if I had to choose one to play for the rest of my life, I think I'd choose a card shedding game over a trick- taking game.

It's another S is what you're saying

probably at this point. I've gotten more and more and more into small card games. If you put trick taking S, I want to put card shedding an S.

Okay, I going to fight you on it. Uh, legacy games C. I think.

See, cuz I definitely like them more than like story games, even though a lot of times they're very story driven.

Yeah.

But they also they also have things like My City that like don't have a story.

No.

And I'm like, great.

And if they do have a big story like Pandemic, the game is still very mechanical.

Yeah.

There's just a story going on with it, which I'm fine with that. Yeah.

I'm not big into like super narrative, super story games. Also, one of the reason why I'm not massively like D and D and stuff like that. Like if D and D was only the fights,

I would like it more cuz that's like a tact. You're like doing stuff. The rest of the role playing like whatever. So to me it's like C,

right?

There's some great exceptions. Something like my city is fantastic.

Yeah, legacies. There's a lot of cool ones out there, but we're never really reaching for them often.

How about games where the victory points you are, whatever that means, are also things you can spend in the game.

I like this one a lot. This is probably an A, especially a game like

very interesting choices.

Yes. A game like Speak Easy where the goal is to have the most money.

You're spending it every turn.

Everything you do costs money. To put out a speak easy costs money. To do this costs money. I really really like games where we kind of talked about this earlier where it's like a card playing game like Primal or something like that where it's like to play this card you have to you have to um pay other cards. I really enjoy when the thing you want to do costs the thing you you need or the thing you want. Like I really really enjoy that. So games like Speak Easy again, it usually a lot of times is games where you're trying to make money.

Yeah.

I love games where you have to spend your points because then you're that constant like is this is this going to be worth it? Like am I going to net a profit out of this? Yeah. I think it's really interesting. It's not something that crops up a ton,

but anytime you can spend Yeah. your money if that's your points or you can actually spend victory points to do this thing.

Um yeah, it leads to really interesting things to have to decide on.

Yeah, that one's an A for me. I really like that a lot. Pick up a deliver. Pick up a deliver. I think my heart says like B, but I think my head actually says C.

I want to like pick up a Deliver way more than I ever actually do.

I think for me where this lands is I would rather just do straight up contract fulfillment

of like get the thing and then turn it in. I don't need the part where I have to spend turns puttering around to a spot to do it. It's not that I can't do it or whatever, but I'm like I just give me a thing where it's like the amassing of the resources is the the tricky bit and then I can be rewarded. I'd much rather do a clans of Calonia.

That's a really good way of putting it because I think I'm in the same boat where like I'd rather just do contract fulfillment, which it is contract fulfillment, but it has a movement element to it that I don't necessarily need.

Yeah. So, I don't hate it. I'm just like I don't need it.

Like C. I think it's C.

Yeah. I think it's a C for me, too. It's not bad. I want to like it more than I do. Um, app integration. This one's gonna be spicy because there's a lot of people out there who are like instant D. I think app integration is great.

I do too. I think there's a lot of games that use it really well and I think it's really cool.

It's great. It doesn't make a board game lesser than any other board game. It's just different.

Yeah. I kind of like I'm not

just go play a video game.

Yeah. It's just are a little tired and like you know it's like move on. But like the thing that's interesting though,

I'm not ever going to buy a game because it has happened.

No, not at all.

You know what I mean? So, it's like

it's more of a I don't care if it's there.

Yeah. And there's a lot of games that use it in a really cool way where it's like I can do this thing because now I can be the only one to see this or whatever.

But here's the thing. Like some for me it's it's a B because you have games like Search Planet X which need the app. Yeah. But it's inc because of deduction. It's incredible because of that. But then you also have games like Dark Tower which are more of like a story element part of it. Yeah. But also still really cool. But I don't like quite as much as like a search for Planet X or something like that.

And the thing I like about something like to go to a return Dark Tower. I think I'm with you on a on it being a B. See, what's cool about Dark Tower is like or something of that nature is like you could in theory have expansions that are more stories because you can update the app but that people don't need to physically change their product.

And particularly if like in a situation with uh Restoration Games Return to Dark Tower, they have made a pledge that if they ever decide to stop updating the app, they will then make it open source. Yes. Which I do think is important because some people are like, "Well, if they don't update the app, then the game will eventually be worthless." And I'm like maybe like World of Yoho is kind of that way where they just never updated the app and it was but it's like if they're willing to make it open source so if you really want to you can keep updating it then I think it's fine. But yeah I think it's a B personally.

Nice.

And those those kind of I get those fears I totally understand but like I feel like they're a little overblown.

They're a little overblown

just because like apps aren't going to disappear. They're part of our life now.

Like it's but like yeah it's they're overblown in my opinion.

All right. On a couple more here we have a boss battler. This again is kind of a kind of game as opposed to a mechanic. Is this really a mechanic? I mean, or is it just a kind of game? That might just be a kind of game because what's the mechanics of a boss battler?

The boss is battling, you know. All right, we're going to beat him. We're going to ye it off the list.

Yeah. I was like, is that is that what's the mechanics of that?

I mean, I don't know. This is all arbitrary anyway.

That's true. Boss B off the list.

Off the list. Yeah. out there right there. You saw it here.

Next one will be uh

scenario based games like missions, campaigns you can

which I guess is also kind of a game type of game.

Yeah. But like there'll be you know from game to game your goal might be changing you know what how things are set up and stuff

because like internal decks where it's like oh there's just different like kind of scenarios in it. Like I like them they're probably a solid B for me.

Yeah. Sometimes I feel like they're harder to table because for me it's like a little more work because you what scenario doing? How's this one set up? But there's a lot of variety that can come with that. There's a lot of cool stuff that can come with that. So, I definitely think it's solid. Yeah.

Should we go B?

B is fine. We're gonna go B. We're gonna B.

All right, y'all. So, last one here that I have written down is going to be social deduction. Should we also put Hidden Trader? Because Hidden Trader is kind of a different thing because there's like um something something Camelot. What's the one? Something butt to Camelot. Railway to C. What's it called? Shadows of Camelot.

Yeah.

It's like a hidden trader game. So there's like full G. I guess it's a different thing. So let's do social deduction first.

Social deduction is like C cuz there's a couple there's like two social deduction games I really like and that's freaking it.

They've got to do they've got to do some like pretty specific stuff to get over the like just be a good liar. Uh which is like where we always kind of bounce off it. So I'd say it's C. Social

there's a couple that do that.

Hidden Trader. I'm I'm a D.

Last into I think it's a D.

Yeah. on a low note

which like you argue a lot of social games have that but again there are other ones that don't

you know I mean like uh you know Battlestar Galactic is a massive game and it's like it's got a bunch of hidden traders I hate hidden traders I hate it so I have no I don't like I don't like being the traitor I don't like trying to find the trader I just have no interest in this fair enough fair enough so is social deduction different than hidden traders are you are you do you see them as different But do you would you consider would you consider like Shadows of Camelot? Uh

I don't know that one well enough to know.

Well, there's like a hidden trait or or I guess would you consider like would you consider like Battlestar Galactic a social deduction game?

I don't know.

Maybe. But because there can be multiple people so it's kind of sussing out. That's what I'm saying. Like are they

are they different?

I don't know. Kind of.

I don't know.

I don't know.

Should we just put them both in? Well, the thing is I like some

hint I I don't know. Maybe not.

I don't know. We made a list folks. The point is we're not editing it. Okay. We're doing nothing.

All right. And those are our tier rankings for So, let's just quickly go the S's. Man,

we're not going to go through everything, but the S's. We got cooperative, great pick. Moncala, fantastic. Uh, multi-use cards, rondell's, uh, tricktaking, variable player powers, worker placement, rip, and then jumping down, ladder climbing, card shedding. Uh, those are our Sier.

And what are the D's? The D's we had bluffing, negotiation,

player elimination,

roll and move, semi-cop,

roleplaying, take that, um, lose a turn, narrative and story driven games, and then, um,

I guess hidden trader if we're counting that as its own category.

Yeah.

Yeah, it makes sense for us.

Yeah, that's all kind of what I thought.

Tracks.

So, that's that is our tier list of like 60ish mechanics. Um, let us know the ones what are your S's. What are your S tier mechanics and what are your D tier? At the very least, put that down in the comments below.

Give us the best and the worst.

Yeah, give us that. You got to give us the bees. No one cares about the bees.

Yeah, we want to we want Yeah, we're here for the for the spices.

Good spice.

Uh that is our tier ring. Of course, there's many more mechanisms and stuff. These are just the ones we could think of and everything. If there's mechanisms that you think we missed, put those in the comments as well. I'm sure we'll revisit this someday cuz our tastes are ever changing. Anyway, uh, make sure you like this video, uh, if you are, uh, so inclined, you enjoyed yourself, give this video a thumbs up, help get the video out to more people. Give it a share if you can. Uh, if you like this kind of content and want to see more of it, consider subscribing. Let us know that way. Uh, so we can do more things like this. We're kind of enjoying,

uh, you know, just little casual chatty videos. Hopefully it helps your workday go by a little easier.

Um, and, uh, anything else I'm missing? Get some merch, put it on your body, become a patron if you want more of this goodness. And uh we'll see youall next time. Bye everybody.

Progress saved