Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond the Sun Review: So Close, Yet So Far - By Board Of It

Transcript 15:03

hello everyone talian farrell here from board of it today we're going to be discussing the much talked about and much praised game beyond the sun beyond the sun appears to have become a critical darling and a fast favorite in many households in beyond the sun you will take on the role of a civilization or a corporation or even a cult and you will attempt to take humanity beyond the sun and you'll be colonizing new systems and hopefully become the biggest new empire in the galaxy in terms of gameplay though you'll be doing some work placement there's a lot of tech tree progression and some heavy resource management however to lay out cars on the table we're not going to be joining the growing list of reviewers that are raving about this game that's not to say we dislike it not at all it's a very solid game and that can't be denied and we always have a lot of fun playing it it also does a lot of cool stuff but for us there are some issues which we'll be discussing later anyway before we get into the discussion we'll give you an overview of how the game works so to begin with you'll have your player board a ship on seoul and your little worker placement stick each turn has three phases in the first

phase you'll move your marker to a worker placement space and take the action in the second phase you'll either produce one resource or you can trade resources into others in the third phase you may claim achievements and place your disk on the achievements if you have met the requirements and when three or four achievement disks are placed depending on the number of players then the end of the game will be triggered your player board will be full of these multi-face dice which when they're on your player board are supplies supplies can be turned into population one of the major resources of the game or ships the other major resource is ore and these disks on your player board are linked to your production of population and all throughout gameplay you will be getting these discs off your player board and onto cards or systems or even just different places on your player board and the more you have out the more population and all you can produce the majority of the game will be spent researching technology on this big technology tree and colonizing planets over here on this space board to research or colonize you will be spending population and or when you research you must have met all prerequisites required for that technology which is usually researching or preceding technology on that arm of the technology tree you must also colour match in that you must research

technology that the previous tech in that arm indicates if you have a choice of multiple you must pick one of them before you start drawing technology cards and these technology cards are going to give you ongoing bonuses immediate bonuses and even open up action spaces on them for the player who has researched that you must also draw event cards if you're the first player to research a space of level 2 or level 3 tech and these event cards they may give you vp at the end game they may give you an immediate bonus or they may even uncover new work placement spaces for everyone colonisation requires you to produce ships move them around the galaxy and remove them from the space board in order to gain that system card in your play area when you first move to a planet you get to remove one of the disks from your player board and put it on that planet when you colonize that planet you can remove a second disk place it there and also the cards are worth vp so let's start with the good beyond the sun is a terrific resource management game we love that the cubes are both population and ships it's very clever design it actively pushes you to research tech which makes you discard population or colonize planets which makes you lose ships just to get them back again to then produce them all over again and all the systems interlink masterfully and beyond the sun

you know you'll want to colonize because it's a great way to get out your resource disks but to be able to colonize you need to research tech but in researching technology you'll then discover that or end up with ships that are stronger and can move further meaning you can colonize better planets quicker which then means you'll end up with more resources because you get more disks out which then means you can research higher level tech that costs more resources and the thing is is that you never see where one system ends and another begins it's just a really well designed cycle it's also cool how diverse this game becomes by how it uses a few simple mechanisms ships resource balancing tech cards and planet cards the way these all mix together makes the game a lot more variable than you'd expect it's also a lovely game to teach and very easy to pick up we were actually both beat by a friend on his first game despite us being quite experienced at it that's always a good sign of intuitive design we think beyond the sun will appeal to a lot of different people with varying levels of board game experience but unfortunately this simple core is the downfall of beyond the sun for us it just got repetitive quick this is a game i played for the first time and i turned around and went that was good i enjoyed that but i don't know how many times i want to play it again and that's not a good sign of a

game that you'd spend this much money on and in a competitive setting we like the tech cards in principle they're interesting diverse and always provide a good dilemma of which one to pick it's really fun to research them and see what you're going to get but absolutely gutting when an opponent researches one that would be perfect for you down a tech tree that you never researched it's also really cool that they have thematic titles which insinuate what technologies and challenges humanity might face in the future however there are limited technology cards and even after a few plays this becomes an issue if you only use new technology cards each time you played you'd still be seeing technology cards you'd seen before in your third game and there are limited systems in beyond the sun which means there's kind of limited actions available to the players so yeah you might have a totally different arm of level 2 level 3 tech but it doesn't really shake up the gameplay game to gain and essentially the bottom line is this repetitiveness is making the game a bit boring to us and this is true as well of the system cards and the event cards and as an example and i know it's a bit more bad luck than the game's fault but the game is still at fault because of a lack of variability three games in a row we have the same event card and this event card has you put a level four tech up here and anyone can research it no

prerequisites so three games in a row we got the same event card three games in a row we drew the same level for tech to put up here and speaking of level four tech they're a bit limp because you spent all game researching and trying to get a level four tech it should be a culmination of your efforts and research is even an achievement you can claim to bring about the end of the game and then it's just disappointing you get a card that tells you get 6vp at game end or gain a vp for each automation you've done and i'm not actually criticizing this mechanistically i understand why it's been done and i think it's fine it's just that it feels anticlimactic because you've done all this work and you feel like you're going to be getting a game breaking power especially because the level 3 technologies are very powerful and then you just get told you're getting 6vp but there is a bigger sin of the tech cards considering they're likely the most important part of the game they're poorly designed the text is so small often there is subtext which is practically microscopic honestly in one game there was a piece of subtext that i thought was a hyphen it's impossible to read and it does severely impact the enjoyment of the game as you'll likely have a players setting upside down and b players on the other side of the board from important information that is pretty much impossible to read and it does impact how you play

the game honestly at the end of one game we played you could clearly see a divide down the middle of the board of both our colors because it was easier and more pleasant to only research tech on your side of the board rather than having to get up every two minutes and take a look at the cards on the other side of the board pick them up read what it says it's it's quite annoying bottom line they should have made the cards and therefore the text bigger and just have them take up more of the board and actually just chime in here because of something that i noticed when we were talking about this if you just take this one example and you look at the size of the card and how much space the text you know why so much white space and this is important up here because it tells you that it's immediate and look how small that is now i'm usually wary when a game ends a game by having players claim achievements but beyond the sun does this well to give credit where it's due and it does this well because the achievements are just not worth a lot of vp and it's probably actually harmful to go out of your way to do them which means that the game ends organically and at a natural point for it to end what's also great is that you basically finish the round and then have one final round which means anyone else caught out by the game ending quicker than they thought has a chance to do a bit more with

endgame scoring we like how any direction you decide to go in is rewarded with vps which means that pretty much anything you do in this game is going to get you vps thus if somebody hasn't done so well they still have a lot of points to count up at the end which can take the sting out of losing perhaps this is not so great for the environment that what this game could really do with is something like a score pad as there's lots of things to count up at the end of the game that you've scored for all over the board and it can be a little bit tiring to do it mentally or on your phone and can perhaps leave room for error if you're counting it up like that and it makes it difficult to go back and check if you've scored a section correctly even a victory points tracker could be better than nothing at all i agree now to change tact the components and general quality of beyond the sun is a bit hit and miss uh just to start with the art direction i'm not a big fan i find it pretty bland but talia suspect she likes yeah i'm not a huge fan of the kind of art direction on the player boards or on the tech cards but i think the background of the board that out there and on the box is pretty cool uh yeah i can agree with that i think one thing i don't like though speaking of the board is the tech lines are pretty busy at their origin points in some cases and it can be hard to discern quickly what's going where yeah but it is also top designed to include divots on the player boards that's

always a plus one happiness point from us always love it love a divot um the dice and the discs feel good they have a good weight and the all resource is unique and pretty cool but speaking of the discs they are actually have a well they have a dark side where essentially at least in our copy i don't know if this is the same for other people but they're very poorly printed uh a lot of the icons on them are not centered at all some of them are even almost coming off the disks and it just looks really bad and it's like distracting and not nice to look at when you play so obviously not happy about that we paid for this but um they have a worse sin which is that the icons are only on one side and i just find this a real ball like during setup because you dump out your bag for your resources and stuff and then lots of them are going to be face down so then you have to spend loads of time flipping them all face up before you can even start setup of the game i know it sounds like a small thing but this is something you have to do every single time you play and it's something that could have been very easily avoided and is avoided in many games and you know the time accumulates if you're going to play this a lot and you could be doing better things without time in summary beyond the sun is a very well designed game that for us is let down by a lack of variety it is a joy to play but its small deck

and the dependence on cards to convey the gameplay means that after a few games you kind of feel like you've seen it all many times before in addition the tiny text in a text-based game is pretty criminal yeah i think beyond the sun is going to be a game that really improves with the big box expansion well that includes more gameplay and just more cards more tech cards more system cards and more event cards i'm glad that i played beyond the sun but i don't know how many more times i want to play it as it is right now but i would also like to say that this i believe is a designer's first board game and it's a great first attempt so i'm very interested to see what he does next and finally just leaving back to something we said at the beginning of the review a lot of people love this game including a lot of prominent reviewers so i think that if you're interested you should definitely check out some other opinions as well maybe we're just really grumpy maybe we are but we'd like to thank you for watching and we hope it was helpful and it would be great if you could like uh comment ask us about it ask us about something else or ideally subscribe because that means a lot to us but thanks for watching most of all and the dogs would like to say goodbye bye bye bye

Progress saved