Are Wondrous Creatures’ Gargantuan Beasts and Crew Set worth it? TCbH Expansion Month Review
Transcript
It's TCBH expansion month, and that means it's the perfect time to do a mini review of these two mini expansions simultaneously released alongside the base game of wondrous creatures. Now, first off, let's get this out of the way. I don't like simultaneous release expansions. It fractures the player experience, and they're generally a lose-lose proposition. If they kick ass, then maybe they should have been included in the first place. If they suck, why bother? But, let's examine these specimens. The crew set, contrary to what you might expect, is not just alternate awesome player pieces, which are entirely cosmetic. But, let's be real, the three-eyed schnecke is now objectively the best pawn in the game and maybe all gaming. But, you also get a player power based on the pawn you play, one card for each set. These are just one-time player powers used for a free action, and while practically useful, seems wild to add more setup and rules for a one-time use power.
Even if having some free eggs or restoring energy at a critical moment is sexy. Now, we turn our beaks to the gargantuan beasts, the more immediate of these two minuscule modules. Here, you have a few more creatures to shuffle in, importantly dealing with the new beast mechanic, and a few more captains to choose from. And then, you set out one more slumbering beast than player count on display. During the game, as an action, a player can hatch four eggs to claim one of these cards, and importantly unlocking your captain's ability, even if you haven't already completed an achievement. The beast stays with you on its sleeping side, but whenever you play a creature matching one of the two types the beast is associated with, not to mention a few other levers that primarily come from creatures or rewards from achievements, you advance on the beast's track, ultimately awakening them, flipping over to give you a persistent ability, some fat point scoring, and important species tags.
These are big, interesting, and intersect with a lot of cool systems already in the game. I'm a big fan and intend on playing with them from here on out. Though, I can't help but feel that there's a more cohesive idea being tiptoed around between these beasts, the locked captain power of the base game, and the crew cards from the crew set. All in one way or another represent a personal asymmetric way of intersecting with the game, giving you identity, potential, and perspective. But, because these come in three separate boxes, it feels like none of them are given the chance to be the best they can be. And the fact that the crew now has this weird player-colored power mismatch confusion, since supposedly the powers are tied to the pawns and the pawns are supposedly tied to the colors, it's just kind of annoying.
My advice, skip the crew set unless you love love love wondrous creatures and the cosmetic part is meaningful to you. If you need just another layer, gargantuan beasts are definitely more meaningful, but by no means is there a beast-shaped hole in the base game. I have them, I like them, I'm going to play with them, but it's hard to say it's a better or worse game with them. And that's the nature of simultaneous release expansions. I'm sure there's some business reasons why it exists, but there's no real winning. Even at best, it has to be somewhat inconsequential, or you'll be accused of releasing an incomplete game. And a much more mature substantial expansion released down the road can address criticism and elevate the game in a way that these just can't. And that's our vid. I hope everyone enjoyed this and all of our other expansion month coverage that we have during April 2026, where we're doing reviews, interviews, and general discussion all about the good, bad, and ugly of board game expansions. And speaking of what we're doing here, thank you for all of your support.
It helps the channel continue to grow. No money changes hands between publishers to us, so that means we rely on you for the likes, shares, subscribes, comments, and of course, checking out our Patreon. But, above all else, thanks for being such a great community. You know, I've been Jack for the cardboard herald.