We're Sinking (A Pirates Dilemma) Review!
Transcript
I'm Ryan.
I'm Bethany.
And we are Ryan and Bethany board game reviews.
And today we're sinking. No, we're not actually sinking. We're just going to be talking about We're sinking a pirates dilemma. But before we talk about that, we just want to remind you to subscribe so you can see all our videos as they come out. Okay. We're sinking is designed by Joseph Frederick and it is published by Ludimus Games and Lucky Duck Games.
All right. So, this is We're sinking again. Ryan and Bethany are not sinking to be clear.
Yeah, we're not sinking.
I think Florida might be sinking.
I'm sure lots of places are sinking. We were sinking about a month ago. Our local creek went like it was crazy. We had a flood order. We had an area in our neighborhood that flooded out. People still are in their homes. True story. This is a true story. They actually did sink. That's never happened.
You're bringing down the review, man.
But it's cuz we're sinking.
All right. So in we are sinking they call this a pirates dilemma. It's a play on words of the prisoners dilemma that famous social experiment and I you know idea. So uh what's happening is we are sinking. We're all pirates on the same boat. We are collaboratively not cooperatively collaboratively trying to stay afloat uh get as much treasure as possible and fight off some kind of sea monster that's attacking us. All right. So, uh, there's two ways the game can end. Either the monster can die or the boat can sink. You are going to be the winner if the boat sinks if you have the least amount of treasure. Okay. The least amount of cards in your hand because you have less things that are weighing you down.
Yeah. You get to swim away to victory.
You win if the monster dies if you have the most amount of treasure. But those actions kind of operate differently. Uh there's four actions you can do. You can either uh bail out water, try to get water out. You can try to repair uh the ship, repair cannons, things like that. You can fight the Kraken or you can get loot. And those things are all kind of linked in a way that makes them opposite of what they are, you know, conducive to for the end game scenario. If you are fighting the sea monster, then you're not getting treasure. But if you are bailing out the water and saving the ship, uh you're getting treasure. Yeah. So it's like this very weird dichotomy. You can take your actions on your turn, but what's going to happen is you have this little dial that has what your action options are. You turn it to whatever action you're actually going to do, but you're going to flip it upside down so we can see what it is and put it in the column telegraphing to the people what you want to do, but you don't have to tell the truth. So, it becomes this thing where um you're going to tell people you're going to bail out water, but then really you're going to go get treasure or one of those kinds of things. Uh so, once the game ends, you figure out who's the winner, and all of you uh probably sunk.
Okay. So, what I one of the things that I really liked about this is that everybody's very suspect the entire time you're playing. Like Ryan said, you can go defeat like the monster, but then in order to win, like you don't have any cards, you don't have any treasure, so you actually need to not defeat the monster, but you actually have to. But also, you just like want to bail water out, but you kind of also want to sink. So, you don't want to defeat the monster. But then if you're not doing that, you're also getting a lot of treasure. And so everything everybody does is very suspect. Even if you like lie, even if you tell the truth, everything everything is suspicious. You don't trust anybody. Sometimes you're like doubting your own motivations while playing this game because that's how suspect everybody is.
What's going on in your mind? Uh the production quality from this game is out of control. The boat itself is absolutely this gorgeous 3D thing and as you're sinking, you know, a literal section of it disappears. So it looks like it's lower down into the table and it has this little spot for these treasures. So as you know, as you sinking further and further, these little loots are coming out which is really really cool. All right. And furthermore, uh the insert is out of this world. Very helpful for setup and tear down as well as just or keeping things organized. Um all the bits are are really nice cardboard. The cards are nice. Um, there's a tray that you take out that has all the things you need during the game. It's all built into the comp, you know, into the insert. The production quality is topnotch.
I want to emphasize that this next point is for me and me alone. I understood like in this game there's only one winner. You either win because you have the most treasure and you don't sink. You either win because you have the least amount of treasure and you do sink. And I thought it worked really well. Like I understood going into this that we're all competitors in this even though we're all trying to make similar things happen at the same time. And for me that worked really well. Like I I got that we're all against each other while we're working together at the same point because I hate I hate those like hidden trader games unless it's a social deduction because it's social deduction first and then hidden trader. But like hidden trader games where you're all trying to work together but then there could be one person who ruins the whole thing. And so instead of everybody winning, only one person wins. Like, but you don't know who that I don't like stuff like that. That's just not that's not a good time for me. But this, even though I I can't win because, you know, like I said, I'm lying to myself. So, I have no idea what my motivations are.
Even though I can't win this game, I thought that that worked really well for me.
This next point is for me and those who are are similar. All right. So, in cooperative board games, I like to have the role that gives other people extra actions that helps them out so their characters can really shine. In a role playing game, I'm going to choose the healer type roles that are going around healing everybody else and making everybody else shine. In um engine building games, I like to build this really fun engine to kind of build this thing up. This is not a cooperative game. That's They're not lying about that. They they're very upfront about that, you know, but nevertheless, there are things that need to happen cooperatively in order to get to the end. You need to fight the monster. You need to bail out water. You need to do these things.
I knew how to win. I knew what needed to happen. I needed to do one or the other thing and then make the other thing happen. You know, either get the most money but then kill a monster or get no money but then sink the ship. So, you know, you wanted I know how to do that. I couldn't help myself. I just had to help get rid of water and I had to fight the dragon. Every time I play this, I was playing a support role. I
a support role in a competitive game.
I just if you weren't like me, if you like those kinds of roles, you gravitate towards those those helper roles, this is going to be a frustrating experience for you because again, it's based off the prisoners dilemma. The prisoners dilemma basically states that um the best scenario for any one individual is to do what's best for that one individual but collaboratively if you all decide to help out each other then it's best for everyone and this is kind of playing on that you know and you're pirates so it kind of even leans even further to do what's best for you. I don't want to do what's best for me. I want to do what's best for the for the all of our my friends, all my friend pirates. And so, uh, it was it was frustrating for me to just to just be like, "Okay, I'm gonna go fight this guy." And everyone else was like, "Yeah, we're going to help you." And then they didn't or I'm going to go bail out water. Oh, yeah. We're sinking. We need to help do that. They all went and got treasure.
Well, I saved the ship so that they could win.
I found it to be a frustrating experience. It's not the game's fault. It was very clear about what it was. It's just my particular play style did not match up with what this game wanted me to do.
This is a strange twist of fate where Ryan is harsher in a game than I am.
I feel like when it comes to games, I have so many more complaints than Ryan ever does. And here I am like saying that this game was so much fun. I had so much fun playing it. I loved it. It was hilarious to me the entire time I was playing it. and and for once we don't agree with me being the more positive one. I don't I can't remember the last time that's happened in a game. So, we're sinking did something very unique for Ryan and Bethany.
Yeah, it was at the very least a very unique game and I really appreciated that. Just don't if you're going to play it, go into it with a mentality of make a win condition happen and do the opposite of that action to do to make it happen.
What?
You have you know what you're talking about.
Yeah. Sure. Sure. But they don't know what you're talking about.
I already explained it.
Everybody, thank you so much for watching. Don't forget to subscribe so you can see our videos as they come out. Until then, you can find us in all of these places.
You guys, thanks for watching. We will see you next time.
Bye.
You guys, thanks so much for watching. Uh, this game was provided to us by a publisher for in exchange for a fair and honest review.
And if you want to see more stuff, check out over here to see something we think you might like. And over here, we think uh that YouTube has picked out a great video for you. You're going to love. Thanks, guys. See you next time.
Bye.