Extremes Only Review: More Than Words
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vessel
and I'm Chris Ye.
Today we're taking a look at a party game called Extremes Only. Uh this is a game that is uh you are picking answers to a topic for someone and you want them you want to give them the extremely best answer or the extremely worst answer. Here's how it plays. In this game, you're going to have a pile of cards and each person's going to take turns being the judge. The judge is going to pick a category from the card. If they don't like it, you can pick a new card. My almost obvious tell when I have a crush. Huh? I wouldn't be too sad if this person died today. It's a pretty dark category. Or fictional world I will most want to visit. So I picked that. Everybody will write down an answer. We'll shuffle them so you don't know who gives what. Although handwriting and all. And we'll reveal them. Roshar, Middleear, Tatooine, Candyland. Well, I wouldn't mind going to Candyland, so I'll say it's my number one. Tatooine seems pretty nice. Roshar. And as much as I love Middleear, I don't think I'd want to go there. Too many goblins and dragons for my tastes. Then everyone will write down another set of answers.
And we'll reveal them. So, Hyrule H. That's even more dangerous than Middle Earth. I'll put that there. MCU. I'm too worried that I'll get killed by someone. So, I'm put that one at the bottom. The Mushroom Kingdom. Well, that sounds fun. You can't change the order of the cards. that are already out there, but you can insert ones in between. And Bajala, well, Bajala sounds pretty cool. So, I move that one. I move them around. I'm like, "That's my number two." And this is just kind of a quick running here. Obviously, the top answers for the best and the worst are going to get three points. Then the second will get two points and one point. So, you'll hand out these points to those people.
You will erase the answers. You'll pick another category. Favorite pickme up. My most controversial hottake on food. Most annoying commercial. Favorite non-human fictional character. Field of study I consider most important. Something that never fails to bring a smile to me. My spirit animal. Blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah. After everyone has had the chance to be the judge to go around or the referee, you tot up the points and whoever has the most is the winner.
Yeah. So, there's some good and there's some bad with this party game. I I like the concept of always giving someone the extreme best or worst. I almost wish the extreme worst wasn't in there because you can almost the extreme worst. It's kind of a weird thing. the game rules push and almost they set it up so like everyone's trying to give you the best answer and you're like forget this I can't get the best answer I'll get the worst like favorite pizza topping I'm like well diapers you know at that point
it it gets like almost to the extreme extremes you could pick something that's not really in the category
I thought now I I might be wrong but I thought that you uh I think it explicitly says at least this is how I've played it if someone does that if someone's trying to like really game the worst answer or the best answer if someone says brick of gold. You just don't you don't quantify that. You don't
No, no, no. I get that. Right. And so I'm glad that that's in there. My my concern with this game though is I feel with these games the idea for the party game, which is harder than people think. Everyone's like, "Oh, I could have thought of that." Well, you didn't.
Well, you didn't. Yeah. Exactly.
That's that's half of making a good party game. The other half is a pool of really good questions. And I think there's a lot of questions in here which are not that good.
Like for example, off top of my head, there's one that's like like uh best taco filling or something something I was like, well, there's like seven. You know, you could start really stretching it after a while, but if you're playing with a big group, and the game's made to be played with a big group, it's three to eight.
Some of the topics just don't work that well in those groupings. I think and this this does speak a little bit to your point where this this rule book also does have explicitly said you you draw a card. There's three questions, pick one. If you don't like any of the questions or if they don't work for your group, just draw another card.
I agree cuz the one I showed in the example or I didn't use it as the example, but there was one like someone you would like to see dead. I'm like I I don't know that any group I'd feel comfortable with that question being thrown out because I mean
whereas your group might be like yes, this is awesome. Right? So,
I do like that flexibility. Does it speak to maybe some maybe not this being like a perfectly fine-tuned party game? I do think so. But I I do appreciate those rules clarifications because they just it kind of feels like, hey, play the game more or less how you want to play the game.
This is an icebreaker party game. It's a game that you can play with people. You don't have to know everybody. You can throw answers out and hope that they pick your answer. And a lot of games like this feel like they should be icebreaker games, but you need to know the person, I think, because of the three round structure of the game because you see how they rate stuff and then you do a second, you know, everyone throws one in, then they rate stuff. You you should be able to pick up on a person's tastes as the as you play the round, which I think is a great strength.
If I like, well, you don't know Chris at all. Well, good. I got the worst then,
right? Yeah. Yeah. But but you start figuring out like Chris doesn't like this type of movie. Let me think of the most, you know, uh that type of movie in existence. Oh, he doesn't like horror movies. I'm going to go with Saw. I'm going to go with Texas Chainsaw. You know what I mean? Like it you actually got to you get to figure out the people's tastes over the course of a round, which I think works surprisingly well.
Yeah. So, that's pretty much it. There's not a lot more to say about it than that. Honestly, this is a pretty solid game. I wouldn't. It's not super special. It's not bad. The the little tiered
the little construction things
are a nice way to move everything around. If you don't take the game too seriously, it works well. Solid game. Seven for me.
Okay. Yeah. It's And I think that maybe it sounds like you're a little higher, you know, based on some of your complaints. But I'm I also agree with your complaints and I'm coming in at a seven as well. I think that the game does enough things right. It could have been a higher rated party game, but it it does have a few weird little edges to it. Kind of smoothened out by the rulebook saying you don't like that, don't do it. And that's okay by me. So yeah, if this does sound fun to you, I think it executes on the concept pretty well.
Extremes only. I'm Tom.
And I'm Chris.
See you next time.
Extremely. Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.