Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 199: Ian, David, and Liz on the Art of Night Witches

Transcript 1:02:24

It's ad break time. I am proud to announce that the Beyond Solitire podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through Games and Simulations. This summer and going into the fall, CLGs has some seriously exciting projects in the works. On July 8th, they're going to launch a campaign featuring two games. Witch Hunt 1649 by Martha McIll and Making History by Nicholas Proctor. Both of these games are exciting in the classroom and beyond. And actually both have been discussed by the designers on this podcast. So keep an eye out on July 8th and let's get on with the show. Hey gamers, this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitire and I'm here with a very special podcast episode. We are doing a night witches check-in with the designers David and me and very importantly the artist Eno Tulle. How are you gentlemen doing today?

Good. Yeah. Yeah. Good. Slight hesitation. So Dave and I are up at our usual early times and it is the polar opposite is evening for Ian. So we have coordinated across continents to make this happen. Um so uh because people ask this constantly, Ian, how far are we on the art for night? The etern eternal question literally um we are I um what do you want? Do you want to do you want a percentage? Is that what what we're looking at? You know what if I don't even know the percentage. So sure for my clinical interest I would say we are 85% of the way there. Hell yeah. That's a good percentage. That's a B, you know. Yeah.

Oh my goodness. I'm gonna post I'm gonna go and post on all the socials that Liz Davidson said that Ian Oo Tool is a B artist. It gets That's how I'm going to interpret that comment. That'll be like the uh the clickbait that makes people watch this. You got to have uh five reasons why. There you go. You can have a list. Five things we all did this week. Um so um well well the the the good news is that all of like all of the difficult work is done which is figuring out how to present it and figuring out how to represent the mechanisms and all that sort of stuff.

All of that which is really the meat of it. All of that's done. There's a couple of things obviously still need to be updated. Right. Right now it's just thematic stuff really that's that's being finished off. So illustrations and stuff like that. So yeah. Yay. Neither. So you I know you did like a lot of research for for our game in order to illustrate it in a way that seemed good to you. So what kinds of work were you doing while you were off in the wilds before you appeared with with our maps and our cars and all? Um, wow. All all sorts. Um, most of it's obviously visual research for, you know, just trying to find really just trying to find anything, documents, maps, photographs, uh, anything that's relevant. Um, we have 10 missions in the game and they all take place, you know, at different times of year and different locations and all that sort of stuff.

So, it was pretty important to me um to try and do my best to represent them as accurately as possible. Even though some of the missions are literally just over fields or you know there's no real it's not like you're looking for a particular steeple or something like that on on the map. Um, all of the maps, for instance, are still as much as I could figure out. And there's there's some uh uh vagueness about, you know, locations and things like that. Obviously, not everything is as documented as I would love it to be. Um, but all of the all of the maps are real sections of countryside. Um, some of them are based on historical maps. Some of them are based on just literally me kind of looking at where they took off from and kind of where they went and knowing that they crossed a river, a particular river for instance. So, just choosing an interesting part of that river, which is kind of, you know, likely that, you know, they were in in and around this area. Uh, so there's a lot of that sort of stuff.

Um, I also looked at a lot of operational maps and operational documents. Uh, very little is available that actually is relevant to the Night Witches themselves. Um, but there's lots of other stuff around, you know, campaigns that they were a part of or on the periphery of and and stuff like that. Um and also um just just so much stuff also just things things like just you know um Soviet army uh operational documents and things like that. So you know when you see the maps there are like little scrolls of nonspecific things that kind of look like somebody's drawn half a map or you know made a note of something. Um, all of that's real. All of that's actually taken from scans of real sketches that in most cases not night witches made specifically that that we know of, but you know that that were were really used. A lot of the textures are are from actual documents and things like that.

So, there's just a lot of uh it's not world building because it's the real world, but it's kind of trying to create a sense of authenticity, I guess, is kind of what I'm after. And some of that, I think, is is very obvious when you look at it, but also things like, you know, the maps being based on on real parts of the countryside. Um, I guess a player might not realize that, but I still think there's importance, especially with something as histo, you know, with something that's historically based. I still think it's very important to I feel I need to do my best to sort of represent these things as as well as possible. Have you Ian, have you worked on a war game or a war themed game before that you would a game that you would classify in that genre?

Let me think. Um I can't think of anything. Nothing comes to mind. So, did this present like when you were researching this, did this present new challenges that you hadn't you do a lot of historical, you know, games that touch different historical periods. So, I guess how is this different or or similar from some of that research that you typically do? Um, that is a really good question. Um, I think so. I haven't done a lot um war games before, but I have actually done quite a lot of military research before because in a previous life uh I used to design uh part of what I did was design museum displays. Um and I did design um entire galleries of of um military museums here in Western Australia. uh which involved a massive amount of research. And I I find that um military research in particular uh um is is very much uh a case of comparing uh different sources and often conflicting sources. uh and often very often most of the time incomplete sources and trying to get as clear a picture as you can. It's a little different here because I'm trying we're trying to kind of tell a story.

There's like a narrative part to it and there's an uh you're trying we're trying to kind of immerse the player and get them emotionally involved which is something that a museum does sort of but in a very different way. it it's it you know um it's it's a very different thing. Um uh but as regards how it's different from other thing other like other historical games um there tends to be more more stuff to go through right there there's a lot of declassified documents. There's a lot of of just things to look through uh to try and find like little bits of relevant information and stuff like that. Um, and I guess also there's kind of a feeling of responsibility as well in in trying to um represent things as well as we can, but for the most part not be flippant with details. Like there's a lot of stuff that we could kind of get away with yada yada a little a little bit. You could, you know, and not many people would notice or maybe not anybody would notice to be honest. There's a lot of details we could kind of brush over, but um I kind of feel reticent to to do to do that in in in this particular case because we are talking about real people

and we're asking the player to imagine themselves in that position and stuff like that. So yeah, so there's definitely a sense of of uh of wanting to to do the story justice. I think makes sense. Uh so one thing that's also been kind of fun is that uh you know you're doing art for a game that I can also tell that you've played because you've made like little adjustments to gameplay that fit kind of like in a way you're kind of like our third designer now. Um I don't know. I don't know about that. Oh, a little a little dev a little dev on your end. Um, so how of how much of games you know that you're that you're illustrating do you play? Um, and at what point do you make decisions about little things that need to change? Um, I play all of them at some stage in in the development. Um, sometimes at multiple stages. It it kind of depends on the game and how complex it is and how long that development cycle is. Um, but as much as possible, you know, in before I start to do anything, I I kind of need to play the game because it's the quickest way to understand everything, which is something uh I need to do. Uh, it is worth mentioning that on my first play test of Night Witches, I got all the pages mixed up and I tried to do the last mission first.

Part of my feedback part of my feedback was, "Guys, this game's really hard." Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It gets easier and simpler as you go. As you go. Yeah. It's like the Benjamin Button game. Like, yeah. Anyway, once I got that figured out, um, yeah, it's super important to play it because in any prototype or any any any game, there's always there's two things that are uh linked but also distinct. So, there's the rules and then there's the expression of those rules. Uh, and there's a lot of variabilities.

But there's oh usually most of the time there's a lot of different ways that you could approach expressing the same rules, right? So you could have, you know, an easy example is um if there's currency in the game, you can have tokens, you can have a dial that tracks your money, you can have tracks, you can there's all sorts of different things you can do, none of which actually change the rules. They're all just different ways of expressing those rules. So that's really the first thing that um that's what the first play testing is about. Uh it's it's about trying to uh think about not necessarily alternate ways to do it. Although often that's the case. It's just kind of looking at assessing it and saying is the way that we're doing it the best way to bring across everything that we want to bring across. So what I like to try and do as much as possible is make these things multitask. So if we can um if we can come up with a way um of handling a certain rule that reduces setup that makes it more intuitive uh that makes it maybe more thematic or maybe just more fun or introduces like a cool component that has table presence. All these things try and fold into, you know, whatever we do to to um uh to represent the rules without usually without changing the rules themselves. So, inadvertently, you actually solved one of the things that

was bugging me the most about our game, uh which was going to the stopwatch. I didn't like representing recovery time in specific time numbers because we need to represent that that was happening, but also the actual time intervals that the night witches were using were so tight that it was hard to do numerically in a game. So, you came up with a stopwatch. So, how did you end up there? Um I I'm really glad that we did. Um, yeah. So, the stopwatch is is a physical component that looks like a looks like a pocket watch um that has a little dial on it that works like a clock. Basically, it just points the different values and as you move through each mission, you treat it like a stopwatch, right?

You you you tick the watch down until your time runs out. Um, it's pretty much what I was talking about. you know, we're trying as much as possible to put people in the cockpit as much as we can do that. It's a very difficult thing to do and get, you know, it's impossible, but um as much as possible to try and evoke some of those emotions. Um so the tightness of time, um you know, fuel is another thing that that we ended up changing. um as it just seemed that I mean to me just having I mean it's it's it's in some ways it's a very obvious thing because it's well it's a it's a stopwatch it's you know an era specific stopwatch um that that many pilots would have actually used. Um uh yeah so it's it's it's one of those things that kind of does double duty. It it it evokes some uh emotion that we're looking for. It's intuitive because it just we know how a stopwatch works. Uh and it also adds a cool um component.

Yeah. I don't I think the the similar thing you mentioned it was the way the fuel works. So Liz and I had, you know, we had used in our prototype this track that it was fine, it was functional, but every single time at the end of the track there was there was um confusion by players whether the last space counted as a fuel, didn't count as a fuel. And um you just I don't know that you you even knew that, but you you switched it to uh where each each, you know, fuel or each bomb is its own little token. And so it becomes immediately clear to the player. you either do or don't have something to spend, right? So, that was another really nice of of course it's much more physically satisfying to handle little wooden bits that look like bombs than it is, you know, move a token down a track.

But, but uh that was another amazing sort of like very minor like nobody ever going to know. The players won't know any difference, but for us it was immediately impactful seeing that change. Yeah. Um, player boards are often uh where I do most of my meddling with with prototypes. Um, because prototypes and this is great actually for me if a prototype is just a bunch of tracks and places to hold things because that just gives me a whole bunch of freedom with, okay, well, what could this be? How could I represent this? Um uh and the playerboard for Night Witches gave us a really nice opportunity to kind of zoom in on what we see what we're representing in the map so that you're actually seeing the plane. You're seeing a bit more of the countryside and the drama of of the moment. Um but it also allows us to do that really satisfying thing that we like to do in games, which is put little pieces in their place. and you know for them to make make sense, right? You know, you you you you put your wood in your woods shed and you put your bricks in your you know, in your whatever you do with bricks. I don't know. But um so yeah, once we I kind of thought about that, then it seemed obvious that you know, well, fuel where does fuel goes in the engine. Um, and again, because fuel is thematically

running out, it made sense to have a supply and then just each round take away from that supply. So, you've really got a sense of like the time ticking down, you've got a sense of urgency, right? Uh, the bombs are the same. So, the bombs are are physical like little wooden pieces that you put on the wings where they would actually go and then when you use them, you know, you remove them. So, it's it's again it's a very um just looking for intuitive ways to do these things. You know, when you put fuel on an engine and you take it away every turn, people like people internalize that really really quick. Same with bombs. You know, if you put bombs on the wing, they they immediately at least know the general idea of what's going on. You don't really have to explain much to them. I also thought it was very interesting the way that you wrapped in damage and taking damage into that scene because, you know, in our original prototype board, David, it was beautiful work. You did great. Um, we had like just like little spots that you would block off with damage tokens to indicate that something had been had been messed up. But of course, you couldn't see where the damage spots are if those slots were full. So, you like having to move stuff around all the time. um you know is representing damage I feel like that must be a common part of your job. Um but you you would know how to solve these problems better than I. Uh but like what what made you arrive at just having like red pieces as removable pieces for? Um yeah well it it just kind of be

so once I arrived at the idea which I I felt was def very early I felt well this is definitely the way to go which is the the player board represents your plane and as I talk about you put the pieces on. Um, so there's again also, you know, there's a there's a um a refreshing refitting phase in the game. Um, so it also feelsatic to put the things onto your plane, right, as as it does to take them off your plane. Uh, so that seemed undeniably the way to go. But then obviously because of the way the game work, there was a problem. So it really just becomes a problem solving exercise at that stage. So it's like we I think we need to do it this way. So how do we make the rules understandable um to do that? Yeah. So so um what I arrived at is instead of blocking off spaces on a track which is essentially removing the opportunity to do something uh we just have um one of the uh bombs and some of the fuel is a different color. It's it's it's red. And the idea is that in a normal um course of things, they're the last ones you spend. So you spend all the regular colored ones first. Um but if you take damage, you have to discard a red thing from your board. So it's it's it's again, it's very intuitive because it's just pick a red thing.

Um and mechanically does the same thing. Actually, this kind of leads to maybe what'll be the rest of this conversation. So, one thing that David and I really needed you for is to fully evoke the fact that this is a game about women specifically doing night raids. So, as a deliberate choice on our end, you know, we wanted to keep the gameplay pretty straightforward. Like, I was joking with somebody the other day that, oh yeah, it's my first game. It's a uh it's a World War II hex encounter game. Yeah. And so, you know, one of the comments that I've gotten over time are things like, "Oh, well, um, I want to feel like a female pilot, or why isn't there more sexism in here, or, you know, but the gameplay itself, we wanted to sort of emphasize the professionalism and skill of the women, but that means that the fact that they are women and like the historical context has to come out a lot through the art. So, what are some choices that you're making to kind of help bring out who these people are in the midst also of all the things that they're doing?

Yeah, th for me this this is actually a very challenging part of probably the most challenging part like all all of the stuff that we've been talking about the UI stuff, the graph, that's kind of bread and butter for me, you know. Um, but representing real people. I mean, we're not representing real people directly in Right. This is not like in Night Witches. Exactly. Exactly. But they're representative of real people. Um, I've done a little bit of that in games, but not in not in any way in uh like like Night Witches. Um uh it's very tricky because uh for me there's a very fine line to uh and you know we we went back and forth on the cover art a little bit for instance and it was really trying as trying to thread the needle between um making the women seem like real people who had, you know, lives and And you know we because we looked at photographs a lot, right? We looked at photographs of of of the real people a lot.

Um and we were struck by um uh the the liveless of the photographs, right? There's lots of personality that comes across in the photographs. And it's not just the case that like everyone's smiling and looks happy because that's not the the truth, right? There's there's times when they look exhausted and they look tired. Um, but there are also time lots of photographs where they're joking around and kind of, you know, messing around. And I I I think it's easy for war games to be very um austere. Yeah. Uh to to kind of shy away from showing and it's not even a lighter side of people. It's just it's just trying to represent them as full people as as much as possible. Um, and I think also from a from a player point of view, it's important, I think, to the experience of the game. Um, especially since this is a campaign. Would you do you describe it as a campaign game? I guess we would, right? Yeah, I think so. Well, it's a it's a game of multiple missions that you work through. Yeah. I I think our our expectation is that most people are going to play it that way. I mean, you don't have to, but that's the expectation. Yeah. Yeah. Let's go with wastefully short campaign game. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, so there is a a a real sense if you do play it like that um that uh you know there's a you have a mechanically speaking that you have a finite number of crew, right? And when your plane if when if when your a plane gets downed, you lose that crew and they're gone. They're gone forever. So that's really a sort of thematic point that we you need to sort of emphasize because mechanically it's very simple and it could I mean that's something that could be represented in an infinite number of ways um from a from a UI um or or art standpoint.

Uh but I think for all of us it's very important that we we kind of put try and put some weight into that because it could be it it could be a very slight thing mechanically because it's you know it's just a thing that happens if something happens. Um so yeah uh this is a very long- winded way of saying that um it's it's kind of a balancing act uh which is very tricky of um seriousness is is the wrong word but seriousness and um it's not being flippant I think is is really the the key of it. So trying to show them as real people. Uh we also are taking the opportunity to show them not during missions right. So h having um you know the these were uh uh twoerson crews who would have worked together a lot would have gone through a lot together. So trying to show that bond a little bit, trying to suggest that, you know, that's a very uh strong bond and it's it's uh but also just not not trying to show them um uh in a state of of of misery the whole time, right? Because Yeah. Um but also not trying to show them laughing and joking the whole time because obviously neither of those two things is is is the

truth. Um, so yeah, as much as possible, just trying to get across the idea that there were actual characters and actual people. Um, so one of the ways that we're doing that is is the the crew cards, which mechanically represent each card is is a crew. So two two women. Um, there's two sides to each of those cards. One of them represents uh them kind of having a a a a moment uh off mission, right? So, so between missions whether they're and this is something I'm still working on cuz I'm actually finding it very difficult. Um, uh, you know, playing cards and just hanging out and and looking at charts and and you know, that that sort of stuff and and and having a smoke and and you know, kind of casual uh moments. Uh but then the flip side of that card is is those two same women actually in the cockpit. And uh when you uh start the mission, you take one of those cards and you you flip it over and you you put them into the cockpit. So there is a kind of a uh again ritual is the wrong word, but you do kind of have this sense of okay, we're we're getting ready. We're we're we're leaving this more casual. It's

it's this we're getting serious now. This is okay. We're we're going on the mission. We're going to work, I guess, right? Um yeah, so that's that's one of the ways, you know, the the cover art is is is another way. Um the women are very um prominent on the cover art. We've we've talked a lot about, you know, the player the player board showcasing the plane and putting things onto the plane and all that sort of stuff. But this is not a game about planes, right? It's it's not that's not the point of it. I I don't think I don't know, but I don't think you guys decided to make it cuz you love planes so much. Um so while right while we do represent that it was really important to have that aspect of this is I it's not just a generic crew on the plane. It's the crew that you're taking and it's the crew that is at risk that's on this plane.

Yeah. One thing I wanted to just kind of pull that string. One one other comment is, you know, it's super common in in games to have character cards and those character C cards have all kind of abilities or special powers or whatever, blah blah blah. Just to be clear, these these cards have nothing on them but the crew. Like they don't actually have a game mechanic purpose other than to represent your your sort of like quote unquote lives for the campaign. And I think I think that's a really um powerful message, right, that the game is conveying is that like this is this is their their singular function, right? Right. Yeah. And and that's something that that came from you guys. So you you did originally have I mean the the fact that the crew were represented by cards and not, you know, uh a track or something, you know, again, all these other ways that it could be represented. Um, you know, that's something that I I didn't come up come up with, but again, you know, okay, well, we have these, which is very rare. You're you're right, David, that we have these cards that are just there to represent something thematically, and again, there is a mechanical aspect to it, but there's no UI on the cards. Um, there's no icons, there's no anything like that.

Um, so it's definitely an opportunity to use what we have there to to pull as much theme out of it as possible. So, so that's again sort of looking at what we have. Okay, we're going to use cards for these. That works great. What else can we do to maximize the effect of that component? The other that's been kind of fun is it's beyond just components. Like it's also in like I guess fonts and layout. So, you know, I wrote flavor text for each of the missions. Sorry, everyone. Um, and one thing that ended up being kind of fun is that in your version of the layout, there's like the mission text, which is in like a more professional typewritery font, and then you changed the flavor text to first person, picked a more handwriting style font, and then turned it into like a kind of diary.

Yes. I forgot that I did change it to first person. Yes. Yeah. Because it was in a in a look second person. It was in second. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Um Yes. Yeah. That just you know the the map the map um board or certainly the left hand side of it is very much like an operations planning uh that's where your all your UI is basically um and all of your mission information. And so it's like a briefing station kind of, right? And and we see scraps of paper and maps and photographs and reconnaissance and all that sort of stuff in the in the background. Uh but the main meat of it is um the mission specific rules. uh which which are kind of almost on um a flash flash cards I guess to um and then in in sort of behind that and around that in the form of like a letter a handwritten letter is is kind of the the or or a diary I guess. Yeah.

Is is the uh is the flavor text. Yeah. That that little change just made the most sense to me to again to try and put you in that position. I've also been enjoying seeing a couple different drafts of the maps where you're you're trying to find the most legible handwriting font. Oh my god, it's the worst. And I can tell that this is a challenge. It's the worst. Oh my god. I can just handwrite it and you can scan it and then no one can read it. I did I I actually at one point I did I mean I've got terrible handwriting too, but I I was I was thinking who do I know that has like consistent legible handwriting? The answer is nobody these days. Um but uh yes uh uh a hand a a a type face that looks convincing but also legible is a tricky thing to find.

Yeah. Have you have you all ever heard people say that like the best anti-car theft device is a manual manual transmission? Right. I feel like I feel like in the cur in the in the future cursive is going to be the way that like you can keep all your documents secret because if you write in cursive nobody can read it now there one day there will be classes about learning to read modern handwriting. So when I was in grad school I took paparology class which was literally trying to figure out how to read ancient people's bad Latin and Greek handwriting. Wow. on documents that we have like they literally train you to do it and there are people whose entire specialty is reading ugly handwriting from the ancient world.

So just so y'all know uh fair warning it's probably going to happen to those of us whose documents survive beyond our lifetimes. Wow. Those people are going to be busy. They're gonna have a lot a lot of stuff to translate. Um yeah, but I mean type faces especially especially in a historical game uh choices of type faces very important and also just a very useful tool for again evoking uh certain ideas because we're all used I mean a lot of pe you know a lot of people have a lot of reference points for if not war games you know war movies or or books or comics or or or whatever you kind of know the paraphernalia true osmosis. Yeah. Um so you can you can do a lot of uh you can do a lot of work with very little in some cases. Um just a couple of choices.

So I just want to flag this because I don't think we've talked about this in public. Um but one of the art requests that David and I had for you was that we didn't want anything that looked like kind of faux Russian propaganda. Like if you look at a lot of covers of like the Night Witches graphic novel and stuff like that, it's like red. There's like kind of faux cerillic lettering. Um, you know, lots of Motherland kind of stuff. Um, did you find that request liberating or did it make it like there were things that you couldn't use? I actually don't know. Um, it it it certainly wasn't a problem at all. I I I I I don't think there's any chance I would have myself gone down that road anyway. Um in in fact I mean the best thing about it was we were on the same page. It would have been more awkward I think if you were like we love this you know and sending me a thousand things from Pinterest which is just all people looking at you know pointing and you know the the typical sort of Soviet poster thing. um it it doesn't ring true to me in this context at all because you know when I when I look at um the the documentation and stuff and obviously there's you know the lettering and stuff is is there but it's very matter of fact you know military stuff is it's pretty straight down the line you know they're they're not for the most part you know you do have propaganda posters obviously but that's not what these women would have been looking at before their missions you

know they're already there you you know, the job is done. Um, so I I yeah, it would have felt very um it just wouldn't have felt authentic at all to me. and and and also for the cover. I I think um I think there's a danger of um uh especially with with representing real conflicts. I think there's a danger of falling back on iconography, visual iconography. And and I think often that iconography is based in in things like propaganda and it's not based in truth because propaganda is often by nature not based in truth. Um so yeah, I I don't think I would ever really use something like that unless it was literally a game about propaganda, in which case it would it would be appropriate to to use. But if we're talking about, you know, real people in real situations and and trying to kind of uh talk about what, you know, what that was like in some way, um, an approach like that just doesn't wouldn't make any sense to me. So, yeah, that was a very good early like we're on the same wavelength.

Actually, we have to go back and change it all. No, I'm kidding. Oh, no. Um, so did you feel that Okay, so here's a question. You did a lot of research. Where did you take liberties if you did? Um, with historicity, with accuracy, and under what circumstances do you do you do that? Um, so a lot a lot of liberties. um just cuz we have to. I mean there's only a certain amount of research that you can realistically do. You know, you guys do want the game to be finished at some point. Um and also it is a game so it needs to function as a game. It needs to actually work as a game. So, you know, I I um uh areas where I took uh license, I mean, the the maps to an extent, you know, I I I did I think probably more than a standard due diligence of trying to make sure it was right. But at the end of the day, some of it was like, you know, this is as close as I can get and I think it's close enough and and you know, um uh uh you know, it's it's not all obviously it's not all 100% accurate. It can't ever be. uh certainly in in in certain

aspects of the UI itself. I mean there there are parts where uh so especially in the in the mapbook um on the left hand page uh there's kind of a a a breakdown of the phases of the game that kind of brings you through how to play essentially. Um, and that's very obviously that's just modern board game UI, you know, it's not there's not a lot of thematic stuff going on there um at all because it's just not the place for it. Um, so there's a lot of there's a lot of stuff like that. Um, but as much as possible where the information was available and where I could get it. Um you know for instance the the plane model is is is accurate the uniforms are accurate you know stuff where we have a lot of visual reference um I think Raina um it is rain it is rain uh sorry want to use uh sent me the actual um uh uh user manual uh for the plane which was incredible. I I I never thought to look for the user manual for the plane. And she's like, "Oh." Because I was looking at one point I was looking at what the inside of the cockpit looks like and it's very difficult to figure out what models they would have used and there's lots of variation. And she was just like, "Oh, I have the user manual here." I was like, "What?

You can always trust me to have just the right thing." Yeah. So on on on on mission one in in the background under some of the paper there's actually a section of the user manual uh which is which shows the cockpit because I kind of thought, you know, it's their first mission. Maybe they're still brushing up on how to use these planes. Oh man, that's good. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Uh so yeah, I mean the answer is lot lots of liberties there. There's there's lots of um this kind of fits visually. Um, a lot of the times it's it's making making sure stuff isn't blatantly inaccurate, right? You can go so far with accuracy and and sometimes is reference available and sometimes there isn't, but it's really for the most part just making sure that stuff isn't like wildly inaccurate. So, here's a question for you now that we can actually talk about this with a common game between us. Um, what kinds of attachments do you develop to games that you do the art for? because I feel like you do so many um but you know when you like do you like to play games where you've done the artwork um you know do you develop an attachment to each game that you do or is it just kind of like I did it and it's out the door.

Um, uh, no, I I do I I don't mind playing stuff that I've worked on because usually by the time it actually arrives and is manufactured, I've kind of let go of the trauma of making of making that game. It's all forgotten and it's all roses and it's it's all fine. Um, I don't I don't mind doing that. It is actually the first play of a game I worked on tends to be quite stressful because I'm always expecting to find a mistake. Um, anyone who's played their own game, I think will will recognize that feeling. Every time I pull Night Wish, which is out for a demo and it's been a while. Every time I'm like, "What if it's actually terrible and I didn't know?" Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Um, but yeah, I mean, I'm lucky enough to for the most part work on the types of games that I like to play. I'm I'm a fairly broad game player anyway.

Um uh and I'm I'm lucky enough to have, you know, to to be able to choose to some extent the stuff that I work on. Um uh so yeah, I mean in some way the attachment kind of starts before I start to work on it because uh often it's um thematic or or it's based on the the people who are making it. both of which was the case here. Um, or you know, so yeah, I there's definitely some level of attachment. I I would find it really hard if I didn't care about the game at all. Honestly, I I would find it so hard um because I do um I don't want to spend so long making something that I don't think matters, you know, that would just be very sad for me.

Um, and more and more actually in the current climate, let's just say, of being an artist in the world, uh, I don't want to spend time flippantly making things that don't don't don't matter. So, yeah, very much so. Um, I I I try to work on things that have some sort of pull for me. Can I want to ask a follow-up question related to that then? um you reached out to us about this. I think you actually reached out just to say, "Hey, I'd be interested in play testing." You didn't even you know, right? And and so why what was it about this that interested you and prompted you to reach out? Well, I knew the story of of the Night Witches. Like I knew what it was about.

I have an interest in in military history. I'm not like a military history buff or anything, but I do, you know, I do have an interest in it. I also have an interest in in in aviation. Um, so it was just lots of different things. I hadn't come across a a a game cuz there wasn't one to my knowledge uh that was that is based uh on on that particular story. Um I have a there was just a lot of things that it it it kind of piqued my my my interest, you know, solo game. I'm not a hu I'm not a huge solo gamer, but I love the idea of solo. No, I know. I know. I'm I'm so sorry. Um, but I love the idea. I love the notion of playing solo games. I I just tend not to find the time to play any games uh these days. Um, but uh, you know, like so Nemo's War was was a similar thing.

Nemo's War I actually had the original edition, but as soon as I heard that they were making that, I I did the same thing. thing I wrote to them and I was like, can I be a part of this somehow? You know, um because that's that's a good example of just another game that hit a lot of different interest points for me and and Night Witchers was another one of those. And I I think so there are so many games being developed these days and and often um the thing that pulls me towards a project is the people. Sometimes it's the theme, but often it's the people. Um, and I'm not saying it wasn't the people in this case, but terrible. It's fine. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Um, but it's not that often that a theme really jumps out that that you, you know, it's hard to make a game because there's so many now with a very distinctive theme that's very interesting and and kind of captures your attention, your imagination. Um, so yeah. I'm very glad tonight which is was one of those for you. Um so here's kind of like a more technical a worky question. Um so you know this is my first design. So, you know, this has been like an interesting ride for me just overall. But, um, you know, when Dave and I turned all of our materials over to you, I spent a lot of time thinking about like, you know, I mean, obviously because I'm working with David, I know we did it right, but for people who are working with um with board game artists, what can we do on our end to make your part of the job as easy as possible?

Oh, wow. Um, that's a good question. Um, Night Witch was was very smooth except again that I played the the wrong mission. That's on me. Maybe make the mission numbers bigger. I don't know. You can do that. Yeah. Yeah. Um, no, Night Witches was very smooth. The rules were in a good, that's really the big thing that the rules were in a good state. I was able to read it and understand how to play. And you know we went there was a couple of questions here and there but really not very much at all. Um having the rules at a state it's often the case where the uh um the rule book writing comes later in in the process.

You know, the game is the game is designed and rules are uh rules are there and people know the rules, but they might not be written in a way that somebody who doesn't know the rules can understand. Uh that makes things difficult because it slows everything down. Um, so especially when I'm in like UI development brain mode, uh, it's a very specific mindset for me to to get into and I I kind of need to hold all the rules in my head at one point, like at one stage because you need to understand the relationships and if you make a change here, does it mess up something else somewhere else? And Night Witches isn't a a a hugely complicated game, but some of the games I work on are. And that can be a very heady thing that you need to do.

It's a real focus. Uh it's a real focus task. And if you run into roadblocks with, you know, oh hang on, I don't understand how this works or I need to check this. It's not in the rules. So I need to go back to designer. All this stuff really breaks that flow up. So it it just protracts the the process. Uh so yeah, definitely definitely a rule book is the big one. Um, that's really it, honestly. I mean, I it's better for me if it's not covered in images already. Um, doesn't really matter, but it it just kind of I don't need to worry about like as clean a prototype as possible is is is better for me. Um, that's really interesting. I feel like a lot of people feel pressure to dress up their prototypes. Yeah. Just they're like, "Oh, it needs placeholder art. Oh, let's So, um, what about a blink makes it better?"

Um well for I mean it's just a it's a it's a um it can be like a haze to get through like a fog that I need to get through because what I need to do is is strip everything away and just understand what are the component parts of this game that because the the first thing thing that I usually do is is I just remake the game with boxes and circles and you know a very very basic rudimentary this is where this goes, this is where that goes and there's no icons or anything. It's just like text and it it doesn't look like anything at all but essentially like a mind map for for the game almost mechanical mind map.

Um, and that's the most useful state that a game can be in for me because then I can see the relationships of how everything works together. Uh, and I can move things around and take things out and strip it apart and understand without any other paraphernalia on top, which is just a distraction. Um, so if it's there, I'm going to have to take it out. So, you know, save everybody the time. Just leave it out. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I I understand the impulse because, you know, it's probably easier to get play testers, maybe. I don't know. Um, some publishers, you know, maybe we'll be more excited if something has a a picture on it or something. Maybe, you know, that's not my end of it. But certainly for me, uh, it's always nice to see just a flat colors is all I need.

This is encouraging because all the stuff I make is ugly. Just plain zero. That's that's absolutely perfect. Yeah. Uh so you alluded to this earlier in the conversation and you know what I'm just going to go there. So we are in economically weird times but we're also in a time when you know AI everything. I am a noted AI hater and I'm not changing that position, but I want to emphasize at the end of this conversation because it's my soap box and we can um that I don't think that we could have come to anything that looks remotely as good or is as well thought out graphically without a human expert to do it because you made sometimes mechanical decisions about our game and how it should work in order to express it well.

Uh there are player aids, there are symbols that really communicate how things work. I just don't see a world where that is replaceable with something that's not a person. Yeah. Yeah. This is this is my favorite subject. Uh yeah, I I so the yeah certainly like when talking about UI and graphic design um you know it's it's it's very it's different for a lot not really for me but for a lot of people it's different than talking about illustration right as two distinct things. I think certainly that, you know, the process that we went through for for Night Witches, for instance, with all the things we've been talking about with trying to emphasize thematic and emotional elements, you know, they're human decisions and they've come from us being human and understand that we're talking about humans and humans are going to play this.

Um, and that's not something you can simulate. You just have that's an an empathetic emotional process that you need to go through. Um so certainly from that point of view uh definitely not I I I it kind of comes back to what I was saying about work that matters as well and you know I'm not trying to prop myself up and saying you know everything I do is is filled with profound meaning or anything like that but when it comes to work that I respond to and that means something to me. Um the process that is undertaken to create that work is probably 90% of the reason why I respond to it. you know, the work itself is is the work itself and we can all enjoy that and you know, that's great.

But the the process that somebody went through to create it, whether or not it's apparent in the work itself, often it's not. We've kind of talked about that a little bit with some of the aspects of Nightw Witches. Some people may never notice, right? Uh but I still think it matters. I I still think it's there's a um there is a oh god what's his name? There's a famous character actor and he's in um Groundhog Day and I cannot remember his name. Oh my god. Anyway, he's a fantastic his name will come to me in a second. Uh he's a fantastic storyteller and one of the phrases that he used that has always stuck with me is there's blood in the work.

you know when there's blood in the work, which basically means that you know when somebody has put something of themselves in into the work and you know when they haven't, right? It's usually pretty obvious when people are phoning stuff in. Um so I don't think that can be replaced. I I think the danger with any sort of um I think it's apparent from from all of the discourse that's going on that not many people understand how generative AI works. I think that's very apparent that that a lot of people don't or don't care to understand or whatever but fundamentally don't understand how it works. So I I think there's really an aspect of us surrendering our um intent to something that we don't understand and just accepting what comes out because we couldn't do it. Right.

Yeah. Whereas the the the what we can and can't do for me is far less important than the the the why. And a lot of people I think just don't understand the why because they don't understand how the thing works. And even if you do understand how the thing works, the why is still a mystery because you you know what you get is whatever. Um so yeah, I I I I think you know um sorry I'm rambling a lot. Uh this is a big I invited this it's a big subject. I from my point of view like if somebody can't have been bothered to go through a process to make something and give it the thought and the time and it is really time that that people that that it deserves and that it requires and why should I give a crap about it you know if you can't be bothered to one of my most common like latestage teacherisms that I was saying before I left the classroom is why would I be bothered to read something you couldn't be bothered to write. Yes, that's a much more succinct way of saying yes. Yes, I Yeah, 100%. Yeah. What's it what's it worth? You know, if if it's just worth it because we needed to make something and now here's a thing and it there's another thing, you know, who cares about that thing? Nobody cares about it. So, you know, why are we making it? Yeah. Um well, one thing I'm very glad that I can say then is that uh fortunately it's not a biohazard, but however people receive

night witches, there's a lot of blood in the work on all ends. And I'm really glad that we all have been through this process together. Yeah, me too. So, I'm going to cut it because it's been about an hour. David, I know you need to go to work, but gentlemen, I want to thank both of you so much for coming on and actually like for kind of like having this whole process. I feel like, you know, over the course of years, like we've been kind of documenting and looking at stuff about night wishes and at 85%, you know, I guess we're getting close. Hopefully. So, we are. We are. Uh, all right. So, u just some light questions. The end. Have So, Ian, I know you've been busy. Have you played anything that was fun recently? I haven't played a game that's new to me that I haven't been working on in in months, honestly. So my my diet is like little short games like Nova Luna or a Castles of Burgundy or something like that which is fun. I played Bonfire recently. I love Bonfire. Um but I'm not in a new new games place at the moment.

David, you played anything fun? Um I think well yeah I I would say that the standout for me is not a new game. It's it's I've been uh playing Maria again. So, you know, 15y old game. Can we please play this the next time we're together? I really need to play more. Yeah, it's also on Rally It's also on Rally the Troops, which I'm not a big online gamer, but that's maybe what we should schedule. Yeah, one of my alltime favorites. So, that's that's what I've been playing lately again. Always. Amazing. I have been in two big online games. A Virgin Queen and Here I Stand. I'm like doing the Ed Beach thing right now. So, I'm the Protestants and here I stand. And then they because they wanted me to learn as much as possible immediately in my very first game of Virgin Queen, I'm trying to figure out how to make it work as Spain and I think I'm going to die.

But, but I'm having a great time doing it. So, uh, and then if people want to find y'all online, uh, where do you like to be found, David? So, so for me, for me, probably Blue Sky, it's uh DJ Jack Thompson or Board Game Geek, and you can just find me by going to to one of my games and finding my my geek mail that way. Uh I am also on Blue Sky and Instagram. Uh and I have a website which is just enotool.com. And I'm also on boardamegeek sometimes. Excellent. Uh I am beyond solitire everywhere for those of you who did not know that. Um and once again uh guys we really appreciate you being here. Um it's it's been really good to have this chat. Yeah. Thanks for having us and congratulations on the Golden Geek. That's right. Oh yeah. So a few a few episodes ago this was certified as the best podcast. No longer.

Um, so yes, also super like both of y'all contributed to that because you've both guested in previous episodes. So I mean it's really our golden geek. We'll take credit. It's actually Yes, it's ours, right? We'll let you we'll let you share it with us. That's fine. Fantastic. All right, everybody. Uh, please like, subscribe, comment, ask questions, and most of all, happy giving.

Oh, hey.

Progress saved