Skip to main content
Loading video...

A Conversation all about the Game Crafter with JT Smith

Transcript 52:29

Hey folks, welcome back to the dungeon dive. Daniel here. I hope you're doing well and if you're not, I hope you are soon. And hey, today I've got uh JT from Gamecfter uh to do an interview with us. Talk about the Gamecfter, talk about the games. How's it going, JT? Uh it's good. It's uh it's all good. I'm glad to be here, honestly. I've been watching your show for quite a while, I think, since I think you had only maybe 2,000 followers the first time I saw one of your episodes, and you're like more than 10 times that by now. So, yeah, it's it's it's it's grown. So, yeah, it's it's been a while. So, yeah, you've been on the channel for a long a long time. Um, the dungeon dive has had kind of a kind of a relationship I think with the with the game crafter and um I think uh Tavis reached out to me pretty early with uh the support with getting review copies and um it's one of the things I really like to do on the channel is bringing attention to some of the smaller games and I think you guys are producing some of my favorite games. You know, that's always good to hear. It's kind of crazy that I think my sec, you know, my second favorite dungeon crawl of all time, uh, Quest for the Lost Pixel. Yeah, that's a great game. Yeah. Would literally not exist without the Gamecfter. That's what I tell people. Uh, because I know that, uh, Pete the designer, he doesn't want to do Kickstarter. He doesn't want to do any kind of crowdfund because that's so much work. Absolutely. And he can kind of offset a lot of that work to you

guys. Indeed. Yeah. And it doesn't Exactly. Right. And it from what I understand it doesn't cost him anything. Right. Right. Well, actually that's not entirely true. We do require the designer to buy uh at least one copy of their game, you know, as a proof because if you're not willing to make sure that it looks good for your customers, we don't want you to have it on our shop. That's great. Okay. Yeah. So, that's the only kind of upfront cost to a developer to a designer is Yep. They send you the files, they have to buy one copy as a as as a final proof. Yep. And that's it. And then they can publish uh publish it to our shop and uh and start collecting royalties off of sales that they get. Um we we market the website, but we don't market individual games. So the other I guess cost to them is whatever they want to put in as far as marketing effort uh of the individual games. We, like I said, we market the store as a whole, but we don't market uh individual games.

So, do you guys offer any kind of marketing solutions to designers? We offer a number of things uh within the site and external with our social media. So, you can uh for example, you can pay to use our social media to uh and when I say pay, you're using crafter points when you do this. So, crafter points are a thing you earn. It's like frequent flyer miles. when you buy something on the game crafter, you get crafter points, right? Okay. Um, and so, uh, they can use crafter points to buy advertising within the site, you know, promoting their own game. They can use that to, uh, get, uh, get notifica or get, uh, their game shared out onto our social media, that sort of thing. Uh, but we don't provide other marketing tools. Like, like I said, we do not specialize in individual games at all as far as as far as marketing. Uh it's just there's too many games for us to to do that and then we'd have to pick winners and losers and that's not a that's not a fun place to be. Yeah. Yeah. That would be a kind of a an interesting proposition to say, well you guys users should buy this game and not this game when you don't really want that. Yeah. I guess we should back up a little bit.

Maybe I jumped the gun on this conversation. But uh the game crafter uh the game crafter is a tool. It's a resource that designers can use to create very great prototypes and finished games to sell. It's a very it's a print ondemand DIY game creating service. Would you say is that a a good explanation of what the game crafter is? our our um kind of uh mission, I guess, if you will, is to be the one-stop shop for everything a game designer needs. So, we start off by providing a really big community of game designers that you can chat with and get uh get feedback from on early ideas about games. Uh so, we Oh, that's cool. So, do you guys have like a a a designer forum designer? We have a community on Reddit, we have a community on Facebook, and we also have our Discord. Um, okay. So, we provide this community. We and we facilitate this community through all kinds of things. You know, we're we're always supporting the community through uh donations, through through con contests, through uh discussion points, uh you know, whatever way we can do. We pay our community, literally pay our designers to go to conventions and promote their games. Um, okay. So, like all kinds of stuff like that, we do those kinds of things to promote and facilitate that community. Um, and then on top of that, you know, that's the that's the starting point, but then we give you all of the

all the templates you need and videos and and uh documentation. How do you design a game? How do you format the the stuff uh you know, for our website? Um, we, you know, we provide all those kinds of tools. And then we provide the way for you to print a copy of your game so that you can make a prototype like you said. Uh, and then we go further than that cuz we have our shop where you can publish your game and start selling it to other people. Uh plus we have a crowdfunding platform on our site called a crowdsale so that you can uh you know kind of do that aspect of it on a on a very easy basis. Way easier than Kickstarter. So much easier. Yeah. Because you don't have to deal with a pledge manager. You don't have to deal with any of that. Like running the campaign is probably the easiest part of a crowdfunding campaign. It's all the it's all the crap after. I mean I I hate the after crap as a consumer. Yeah.

having to keep track of all your pledge managers and did I pay the shipping? Did I pay for that? Where am I? How long am I going to be waiting? Yeah. So, yeah. So, we we take care of all that. There is no pledge manager you have to deal with after the fact. Uh it literally just goes straight into production and then gets shipped to you uh as a consumer. So, and then as a as a uh game designer who's published through a cloud sale, you you again don't have to collect surveys. You don't have to deal with customer service complaints about something got lost in shipping or whatever. Yeah. You guys handle any kind of uh uh customer service things after the fact. Like if if a card was misprinted or something was missing, they contact you, not the not the designer of the game. Exactly. And and to your point about what you said about what Pete said to you about uh Quest for the Lost Pixel, that's exactly why he likes crowd sales and selling on our site because all he has to do is design and market the game. We literally take care of everything else. Yeah. Um and so, uh beyond that, there's all kinds of other things that we do. Um we we support a lot of conventions. We have a game design software called Component Studio. Um like I said, we put out all kinds of videos and those videos aren't just tutorials about how to use our service, but community oriented videos.

Like we have this whole ongoing series uh called the board game blueprint, which is all about the game designer's life, right? like things they have to topic or they have to talk about like how do you uh go talk to a game store about your game? How do you design the box uh you know for retail experiences? How do you find play testers? And is AI art okay to use in your game and all of those kinds of topics. We cover those kind of lifestyle things uh through the board game blueprint. So we we do all of these different things to kind of be the entire thing that a that a game designer might need to have, you know, the whole ecosystem in one place. That's really interesting. Now there are there there are I want to talk to you about the two um the two kind of elephants in the room that whenever whenever I cover a game crafter game y um there are two things that always come up. Um one is the price of the game. Mhm. And the other is the cost of shipping uh outside of the US.

So those things always always come up even if I like say okay guys yes I know these games can be expensive and unfortunately if you're outside the US that can be another expensive even more expensive. So I try to convey to people the print on demand aspect. Could you talk a little bit about pricing and give your give your expertise on print on demand versus games that benefit from the economy of scale and that kind of thing? Yeah. So, we're always printing one copy at a time. Exactly one. And that's the entire business model is built around for the game crafter uh is short run. So everything about our from our uh the way we train our people to the processes that we use to the equipment that we use, everything is built around being able to make one copy at a price that uh isn't going to pull your hair out. It's more expensive than you're used to, but it's not like a car expensive, which is what you know, like if you go to a long run manufacturer and they make a prototype for you, that one copy could be $1,000 easily. Yes. That's what I I know that even like a $300 prototype copy from the game crafter, that's still much cheaper than it was 10 or 15 years ago to make a prototype, which is super super expensive to and we can make prototypes depending on the depending on the size of the game that you're doing. You know, we can make a single game for less than $10. So that's that's amazing to be able

to have that uh right now because that didn't used to exist that you know before us that wasn't a thing. Yeah. Um and so yes it's expensive. I agree it's expensive. We're always trying to figure out how we can bring those costs down. Uh but the reality is we're working off of one copy at a time, not you know a thousand or 10,000 copies at a time. So um the economies of scale aren't there but we provide tools so that the economies of scale can be there like the crowd sale that we talked about crowd sale. So the crowd sales I'm I'm imagining that you guys schedule those because you have only a certain number of printers that are able to be running. So how do you schedule those? How does a designer approach you say hey I want to do a crowdfund you know what's the leadin time? How long do they have to wait to get their crowdund going? Yeah.

So, they don't have to wait at all. Actually, we don't we don't we don't dictate when they can run their crowd sale. Um, we we we actually have this whole Q management system that we've developed over the 16 years we've been doing this uh to uh to facilitate any of that, you know, uh those fluctuations in orders. Like you said, there, you know, sometimes we already have a full queue of of stuff to work on. It doesn't matter. We just add it to the end of the queue. We'll we'll do that. Which means sometimes when you back a crowd sale, it might take you three months to get the game. Uh, which is still faster than a Kickstarter. Yeah, I know. He thought like three or four years at some I mean I remember I think it was one of Jason Glover's games. I think it might have been like Tinhelm or something that there was a long wait but we uh you know he was telling people and I was telling people well hey you know the crowdfund was very successful so that means there's a lot of games in that queue and those games get added to the end of whatever line is already ahead of them.

So Right. Yep. And so that's what we do. We just uh we have four different cues. So, there's a the regular production queue. If you place an order from our website, just go through the cart and check out, that goes into the normal production queue. If you go into a crowd sale or if you're a company ordering a massive quantity of games, those go into what's called the bulk queue. Uh, which is um, you know, that's where we we start giving you discounts based on quantities. Yeah. Okay. So, so you can offer that. So, if I was a designer and I made a game and I came to you said, "Hey, I want to print 40 50 copies of my game to take it to this convention." You guys do offer a discount if you say upfront that you want a bulk order. Yep. If you order 10 or more copies, it automatically gets put into the bulk queue. So, because at that point, we're starting to give give discounts at 10 plus copies. So, um, so whether it be a crowd sale or you're ordering in bulk, those go into the bulk queue. The bulk queue runs a little slower usually, uh, because it's massive orders that are going in there. Uh, but that's how we keep the normal orders, keep, you know, keep pushing those through because, you know, those are two separate cues and we have two separate teams working on those cues. Um, we also have the urgent queue, which is you basically pay double and you get it uh, you go run to the front of the queue. All right? So, you're the next game we're going to work on when you do urgent. Um, and then the final one is the parts queue. And that's just you ordered something that we don't have to make on demand. Like we, if you're ordering just dice, we didn't make those dice. We ordered those from someplace

else. They're just sitting on a shelf somewhere. So, uh, somebody can just go grab those off the shelf and and give them to you. So, that that queue runs separately just because there's no reason for somebody to wait for something that's already pre-made. Oh, right. Right. Yeah. So, so, uh, your manufacturing of the cardboard and the things that you guys print, that's done in the United States, correct? Yes. Yep. In Madison, Wisconsin. Madison. And do you guys have like are all of your offices and everything at that printing location? Do you guys own Do you own your your own printers and everything? We own almost all of everything. The printers are the one thing we don't actually own. We lease those. Okay. Yeah, you lease them, but but only but only Gamecfter is using them. Oh, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Absolutely. Yeah. It's not like one of the big manufacturers in China like Panda where where all kinds of different uh uh publishers are are using the same printers. Yeah. Yeah. No, everything we do is dedicated 100% to the game crafter and the game crafter only. So, it's not like uh we're it's not like we also own a business card printing company or something like that or wedding invitations or something like that where we're, you know, producing these other things and that's putting the games on hold. Everything we do is about making the games for our customers. Interesting. Um h have you seen an influx in in questions or in from designers or even some publishers coming to you guys to talk about manufacturing games because of what's

going on with with tariffs right now people wanting to make more things in the United States hopefully. Yeah. You know is that have you seen anything like that? We do see an influx of of new stuff. Like when that first big tariff was announced, uh I was at a convention that weekend and my phone just started going crazy because I was getting tagged in hundreds or thousands of posts across social media. Um and uh you know, we're happy to help people out, but they need to understand that we're not going to be as cheap as China. It's just not what we do. And we also don't specialize in long run printing. We're you know, our last discount ends at a,000 copies. we'll give you a,000 copy discount, but if you order 5,000, you're not going to get a better discount, you know, per copy than you get at a,000 print because again, all of our people, our processes, and our machinery are all designed around this shortrun kind of model. Um, right?

So, we do work with we do work with a lot of longerrun publishers uh here in the U or uh printers here in the US uh such as Cart Mundy. Uh, Cardamomi is uh has three different production facilities, although you need to have 5,000 minimums to go to them. We also work with um uh Yeah, a lot of a lot of So, you're right. A lot of printers have a minimum order that a designer or publisher would need to print to make it worthwhile. Yeah. Whereas Gamecfter, you could just you could print you could design a game and only ever print one copy of that game. That's absolutely right. Yeah. So, uh, so yeah, like I said, we were working with we work with Deleno as well. They they are over in Michigan and, uh, and, uh, they have a minimum of 2,000 copies. So, you're still going to have to have those minimums and they'll get better prices than you'll get from us because we stop our discounts at 1,000, right? But there you're not going to you're not going to get better prices than China because the entire industry of making board games is in China currently. Yes. Right. Um, so it's not just it's not just the making of the games, but the paper is made, you know, in China. The ink is made in China. The wood is made in chi, you know, the wood bits, the dice, the everything that you're thinking of, plastic injection molding, all that stuff is done in China, not in the United States. And so there's this whole ecosystem there that, you know, here it's I'm one company, Deleno is one company, Cardamom is one company, but

all that other ecosystem infrastructure doesn't exist here. There's not a single, to my knowledge, a single company in the United States that manufactures dice, for example. Really? Wow. Yeah. As far as I know, there isn't a single one. Now, there might be like some really specialized craft dice on Etsy or something like that. Metal carved metal dice or something like that, right? But not like not like at scale dice like you're expecting to, you know, to get them cheap. Um, so so yeah, that's that sort of thing doesn't exist in the United States to my knowledge and I've been looking for it for 16 years, so I don't think it exists. Yeah, I bet you. Yeah, I mean I bet you would be. I mean, it's not like, you know, I tell people that print on demand, you know, the the copy you are getting was printed for you and and uh that, you know, it's not like the game crafter wants to make things more expensive than they are. I'm sure they are constantly thinking about ways to bring down the cost, but there are things we have to keep in mind. And one of those is shipping. And you know, after man, I mean, CO threw the entire shipping industry on its head, we still haven't really recovered from that. And so we're still paying crazy prices for shipping all over the world. And on top of that, the Gamecfter being based in the United States, shipping over to the UK, not only does it cost money, but they have to pay their tariff when they receive it as what, the VAT tax or something. The value Yeah, the value added tax. And uh so I have oddly the Dungeon Dive does have uh a large number of people

overseas who who watch the channel and we have a large number of customers overseas. So it's something we really care about. 20% of our c of our orders get shipped outside the United States just so people know. Yeah. Yeah. So, it's not it's not a small amount that you know we definitely care about how how much it costs people to get their stuff uh in the EU or in the UK or Canada or Australia or anywhere, right? It doesn't matter where it is, Brazil. We ship stuff to nearly every country in the world. So, I know I know some Dungeon Dive viewers have gone together on uh like a group order. Yes. Yes. And they'll have it shipped to a central, you know, whoever is like the most central person in the in the EU or something and then they'll distribute them when they meet up for some convention or something. Um, right. Have you has the Gamecfter explored ways to bring those costs down? Have you guys talked about having overseas manufacturing or anything? A an EU game crafter? Sure.

Let let's talk about all the different options there. There's quite a few. Uh so let's start with the EU Gamecrafter. Um we would love to do that, but unfortunately it's going to just to set up a basic operation, it would take us about €2 million um that we just don't have the money for. We're a tiny little company here. Um, so having an extra spare €2 million just lying around that we could invest in a, you know, a somewhat risky idea of opening up another franchise in Europe, uh, is a pretty is a pretty tall order for us. So, if if there's somebody out there listening that wants to do that, please get a hold of me. But I I I just don't know how to do that right now. Um, as far as other options, uh, we're we're constantly looking at the shipping options of, of course, we aren't a shipping company ourselves, so we have to rely on what we can get for what we can buy out in the out in the market.

Um, and we are actually about to launch, well, not about to, that's putting it too fast. Uh later this year, we should launch another new international shipping option that should be slightly cheaper than what we have now, which is already one that we went and did a couple years ago, which was uh like half price for what we used to ship for international. So, we're already in a better place there, but we're looking at at more options to get it even better. Um, we also, uh, recommend like if you're doing a crowd sale, we do recommend going in on a group like you said, and having people order together because then you're only paying the tariffs once, you're only paying the shipping once, advertised across as many games as possible. Um, we do also, a lot of people may not know this, but we have retail partners in various countries around the world. I have heard that now from a few uh people that a few Dungeon Dive viewers that hey they they're they're stocking game crafter games now in some stores. And so I would imagine if that happens then the importer the the the uh the retailer is probably paying is paying for the shipping is paying for the VAT. And so they but they're again doing that thing where they can advertise the cost of that shipping over all of these different games. So like right uh a couple of weeks ago we just sent another pallet of games to Woodree Games which is in uh Germany uh and they handle the whole EU.

They'll sell to anybody in the EU and they have a whole bunch of different games that they that they have from the Gamecfter on that pallet. Right. So uh if there is a game that's on the Gamecfter that you want and you're in the EU, reach out to Wooden Tree Games and say hey could you get that into your next order? Right. That's awesome. Okay. Yeah. I know I have a quite a few people in Germany who I talk to on a regular basis, so I'll make sure I mean they'll watch this, but make sure that they know about that. Yeah. Yeah. Uh if you're in Canada, we work with Board Game Board Game Bliss, I should say. Um and so if you're if there's a game you want from the Gamecfter, let them know that that's a game that's interesting to you because we ship them stuff all the time. Uh, and so, uh, they can again amvertise those costs across, uh, across their entire order because we're ship shipping a lot of games to them all at once. It's not just one game at a time. Um, so we don't have partners in like Australia is a fairly large country that we ship to very regularly. uh we don't have a partner like that there, but if somebody's listening to your show and uh wants to partner up with us for that kind of thing, reach out uh and we will work with you on that with just like we have with these other partners that I've just mentioned. So, if it's if there's not something in your area, reach out to us and we'll see what we can do with you. That's super cool. Now, as far as partnership goes, I I've often wondered, you know, I get a you know, I'll do an order with with with uh with Cavis.

He'll set me up with some review copies. Mhm. Um, you know, then I still buy quite a few things as well. Um, when when when Tavis sends me a review copy. Mhm. Is the game crafter buying buying that copy? Yes. From the designer. So, the designer does get their royal or their payment for the review copy that I receive. That's right. Yep. We pay them that the royalty for that and we pay for the manufacturing and shipping costs when we send you a review a free review copy. Okay, that's super cool. Yeah. So, the designer isn't out anything by us sending free review copies when they are requested by uh people such as yourself. So, do you guys send out quite a few review copies? We do. Yeah. Um we have a bunch of different YouTubers, podcasters, um you know, people bloggers, you know, that are doing reviews on stuff. And if if uh somebody has a blog and they're interested in a particular game and they reach out to us, we almost always say yes. Uh unless it's, you know, sometimes it's people that are just trying to get a free copy of one game and that's a fairly obvious attempt. But um but if they have a history of reviews, like they have, you know, they showcase their work out there, we almost always comply with those requests. So yeah, I've really I' I've really enjoyed my like my working relationship with you guys and just because I I do like so many of the games that you guys uh that you guys uh print and uh like I was saying, a lot of these

games just would not I I tell people like Quest for the Lost Pixel is the ultimate example. Just that game would not exist at all without without the without the game crafter. And um you know, I know Pete really likes working with you guys. And what kind of advice do you have for people like Pete who who want to make somewhat of a substantial game, you know, kind of walk me through some of that? I know there are different levels, you know, you have like the mint 10 and people like working with that because I think you have, you know, what n like you have a certain number of sheets of cards and so you have to design your your your game around that, but then you scale up to these really big games with thousands of cards. Um, what's what's a what's a kind of some beginning advice that you would give to a designer who wants to make a game specifically to be made at the game crafter, right? Well, if you are the first thing that pe that designers need to get over is that the price isn't going to be what you want. Uh, and most of the designers aren't business people.

They they don't realize that there are customers out there that will pay the price if they like your game, right? Um, and just like you said, Pete's Game is not a cheap game at all. No, it's very expensive. Very expensive. I'm I'm forget forgetting what the price of it is right off the top of my head, but it's like $150 maybe something like that. I think so. There there's evidence of me I think I think Deborah from Geek Gamers was the first kind of big bigger channel to cover it. And I watched her play it and there's a a post from me on her YouTube channel me going like this game looks really cool. Oh, never mind. I just saw the price. Yeah. And then I broke down and I bought it like, okay, yeah, I get it. But yeah. Yeah. So, so some of these games are pretty expensive when they get big like Pete's. Um, and at $150, he still sold more than a thousand copies of that game. So, it's not like there isn't an audience out there, even if your game is expensive, as long as it's good, as long as it presents itself well. Um, and it obviously doesn't hurt being on the dungeon dive, right? Right. Um, so, uh, you know, I know you he's been on numerous lists on your channel, you know, like obviously you did a a whole episode just on the game itself, but on various lists over over time. I've seen episodes where you're like, uh, my favorite game of 2024 or what, you know, that sort of thing. And, um, you know, I I don't remember exactly what the episodes were, but I've I've definitely seen them because I've seen so many of your episodes, they're sort of blending together at this point. But, um, you've had different, uh, different things like that. And so he's been featured a number

of times and on other channels as well. And I'm sure all of those things have helped him sell those thousand plus copies that he's done. But he had to get out there initially somehow. And it was through his own hard work that that happened. That is an easier thing to do if you're selling a smaller game. It's easier to get somebody to bite if you're smalling selling a smaller game. So I always recommend that people start small. Um, and you know, start with a mint tin or start with an 18 card game or or even a 54 card uh game. Um, start with something small uh because a it's easy for you to design and make sure you're doing a good job of it. When this the if it gets to be sprawling, uh it's much harder to make sure that that game is really really good. Right. That said, uh once you're confident that you can make a game at the size of Quest for the Lost Pixel, which is an enormous game, so many cards that tell like there are almost a thousand cards in this game and even smaller games like uh uh Iron Helm, which again will probably only exist because of the Gamecfter uh has quite a few cards. Uh another one of my favorites was Rogue Dungeon. And yeah, you know, they they have gone off now to do their own uh thing through Kickstarter, but even that had a lot of stuff to it. And yeah. Yeah. So anyway, there's there's um the the point is just, you know, make sure whatever you're putting out there is worth people's time. And that way when when the word will spread when when somebody

gets a hold of your game and and feels uh you know the juicy bits of the game in your mouth in their mouth, they're going to want to share uh and be like, "Hey, this game was amazing. I I you have to check this out. Yeah, it's expensive, but it's worth it." That's the thing you need people to get to. Um and and there is an audience out there for, you know, you've been in business for 16 years, obviously. uh you know there's it's there's a reason that people come to us because we provide quality game materials like we can make your game look good. Uh, so now it's a matter of you making your game good to play, right? And so that's the number one thing, make it good to play, but also I think when you're just new getting started, start small because it's easier for people to make a good game and it's cheaper so that if you're if you do have an audience that's trying to overcome that that price, it's um, you know, you can sell your game for 20 bucks or 30 bucks or whatever and people aren't going to block at that, right?

Yeah. Another game that I really like, uh, uh, Spacers, the space adventure board game. Yeah, that game blew me out of the water. I ab that game is amazing. And that was actually went to the game crafter after it was a failed Kickstarter. Like they they failed to reach their goals. So I'm sure you see that quite often is people who it's almost like the the Gamecfter is kind of like the the next best for some people. Yep. some for some people um like Pete it's the first best because they don't want to run that Kickstarter in the first place and those that do go to Kickstarter and either fail or the more common option isn't even that they fail but it'll be more the Jason Glover model they succeeded but then people are still asking for their game after they sold out. What do I do next? What do I do next? Yeah. Um and that's a huge thing. Yeah. Yeah. That's a huge thing.

And so you end up going uh you know, you could either try to do another Kickstarter and another print run, but then you have to go through all that hassle again. Uh or you go to the game crafter and you just sell them as they are ordered. And so you don't have to maintain inventory. You don't have to do customer service. Uh like in Jason Glover's case, at least in the early days, he was hand assembling every game. He would order the parts from this place and that place and whatever and put them together and then hand mail them out. That's a ton of work that you're not getting paid for because you almost certainly did not charge enough to pay yourself for all that work. So, yeah. And most of these guys have I mean have full-time jobs that they're working, you know, 9 to5, 8 to 5. Yeah. And then having to deal with all the logistics of shipping out and assembling a game on top of that. I mean, that's that's just so much work. Yeah. Exactly. So, it's it's you know, we see we see it from all over the place. um you know the different ways that you can be successful at this. But but the big tip is like I said, just make a good game.

Make it small if you're getting started and and get out there. And if you if you can make a big game and make it uh good, then by all means do that. Uh it's just a little harder in the early days of marketing. Um, but uh, you know, the other option is, uh, if you got a big game and it's something that can be shown on a channel like the Dungeon Dive or others out there that'll that'll show it, that's a way to get your word out that it's a good enough game to be worth whatever price is that you're charging for it. So, so I don't the dungeon dive I have a very a very narrow uh, focus, right, on the kind of games that I cover. So on the game crafter, I'm kind of completely unaware of the other kinds of games that you guys uh uh print. Mhm.

What are some of the other categories that you find that sell really well? Yeah. So the number one category on our site is definitely solo games. Okay. So that's kind of a modern trend that a lot of people are moving towards. So, so you guys do kind of you see a specialization in the people who come to you wanting to make a solo game. Yeah. It's actually more It's not so much that the designers are coming to us wanting to make a solo game. It's that it's that um the solo community knows that the Gamecfter is a good place to pick up solo games. So, they're out there buying. And so, when somebody publishes a solo game to the site, it gets bought up in pretty decent numbers, especially when we run a sale. you know, like we just finished our Cinco deio sale. In that week that it was running, we sold like 5,000 more games, uh, you know, that that week. And those, you know, those, again, these aren't our games. These are are the designers games. So, in that normal week, we would normally sell like 2500 games. So, we doubled the amount of games that designers sold in that one week because of that sale, right? So, um, so yeah, that's a, you know, we do sales and people people in the solo community will be like, "Oh, the game crafter is running their next sale.

Let's what which games should we, you know, what are on your list for this time?" And you can go see them if you're in one of the groups for solo gamers on Board Game Geek or Reddit or on Facebook or wherever they happen to be. Um, you'll you'll see them all planning, oh, what are you getting this time? You know, that because that's a new sale is coming. And so, you'll definitely see that sort of stuff for the solo community, RPG community. uh what RPG board gamers, you know, which is more your your flare. We see a lot of that. Um and that I I attribute that one mostly to Jason Glover actually because he does a lot of that sort of stuff, although there's lots of people like Pete out there that are that are doing that now, too. Um and the other thing that we see um quite quite a lot of is um kind of family weight games there like uh one of my favorite family weight games that's on the site is called Flip.

Um, it's got it looks like Uno if you looked at it, but it's a much better game than Uno as far as I'm concerned. Um, so anyway, there's there's lots of those kinds of uh things that you see on our site as well. And then one that's not even a game category, tarot. Um, there's Oh, really? Okay. So, you guys do a lot of like custom tarot cards. Absolutely. And there's lots of tarot YouTubers that that, you know, reach out to us and are like, "Hey, would you send us this, that, and the other thing?" you know, um, and so tarot is another area where we, you know, we have a strong community, uh, that's always buying game or buying cards. Some of them used them for games, too. Tarot was originally a gaming system, but, you know, evolved into this much broader thing over time. Yeah, I have two or three games that use a tarot deck, and I haven't actually purchased a tarot deck yet. So, now I know uh, where to go to get one. There you go. about to go shopping for a tarot deck on the on the Gamecfter. Uh that said, you know, I've listed some categories that are very popular on the Gamecfter. That said, we sell everything. So, if you're a Eurog gamer, we've got Euros. Um if you are a dice gamer, we've got dice games. You know, whatever it is that you happen to be that is your niche. If you even miniatures games, you know, we have and war games. Um we got pretty much everything is out there to some degree.

Uh, and so it's just a matter of going out and looking through our catalog because there's in the published in the published catalog there's over 15,000 games in that library. So that's a lot of games. Jeez. Now, do you guys ever what what's your method of calling stuff that hasn't sold in five years? Do you do you have a do you have a limit where if something falls off your active your active pages? How do you how do you how do you maintain your database of games? Yeah. So, we do this via uh something we call game rank. Um so, we don't actually we never callull anything. We uh designers uh will, you know, pull stuff off on their own sometimes, but we don't actually pull stuff off unless it becomes incompatible with our site. For example, um sometimes a game will use a part that was made by some third party that we can no longer get that part. No longer get Yeah. Right. So, if they don't uh if they don't fix that problem, because we'll send out an email saying, "Hey, this thing is no longer available." Um, but if they don't fix that, then we'll have to pull them pull them down because it's just not for sale anymore. You know, there's no way to sell that game anymore. Um, but uh but generally speaking, we don't callull games from the library. We just leave them out there. Uh what we do instead is we do game rank. So, in our search engine, everything is sorted by game rank. And gamer rank is based on uh ways that you have done well in our community. You like reviews that you've gotten from reviewers or number of sales that you've gotten from from selling. Um

you know or if you've done an art test. We do these various test systems in our site to make sure that your game is good. So the art test is like does it look good, right? Um and we also have something called the sanity test which means that your rule book is good. Um you know that's that's an important that's an important one. the the rule book is a is an is a science and an art that far too many people don't understand. Exactly. So So yeah, that's a and and that's a good test um in general, too. If you're a buyer on the Gamecfter looking to see if you know you're on the fence about getting this game, if it has passed a sanity test, then you can be pretty sure that at least you'll be able to read the rules and figure out how to play the game. It doesn't mean that it's a good game, but the author has gone through a certain amount of hoops to make sure that their game is of good quality. So, let's talk about that because that's really interesting. Now, first of all, that sanity test, is that a is that a seal?

Is that a stamp that a user can see on the game's landing page? Yes. When you go to the game, you can actually see the list of accolades. Uh, and accolades are these little badges that'll appear on there. And some of those accolades are like sales accolades. it's I I've sold 300 copies of this game or whatever, that sort of thing. Um, and but there are accolades for tests. So, if you have passed a community verified test, uh, then you get this. If you pass the sanity test, you get a different accolade. Uh, and the the sanity test accolades will tell you how well they passed that test. So, did they get a 90 plus? That's the best you can do on a sanity test. You want to get a 90 plus uh on there. And if you did, you've done the best you can do in a sanity test. Uh, and then you can actually click on that accolade and see the results of that test, including all the comments that were left by the sanity tester saying, you know, this is things you should fix in this or whatever. You know, that's So, who's who's doing the sanity testing? We have three sanity testers on staff that have backgrounds in uh writing and they will literally read these uh read the rules, look at the shop page, watch videos, that sort of thing and make sure they can figure out your game based on a rubric that we've come up with. Um and so we do this. We've done thousands of these sanity tests uh for various games.

That's really f I had I had no this is a whole new information for me. This is really cool. So, does the designer do they pay for that with uh with with a game crafter currency? Do they pay for it with cash? What's the process to go through that testing? That one they have to pay for with currency because you know those those people with English degrees are not cheap. All right. They're edit I mean they're professional editors. They're reading English is their main language that they understand. That's right. cuz that's that happens a lot with Kickstarter stuff is so many times things are lost in in translation because they're not paying for professional English translation. Their buddy their buddy who speaks English happened to read the rule book once, you know. Exactly. Okay. Yeah. So yeah, that's the the sanity testers are all people that have backgrounds in technical writing. Uh and then they have been trained uh you know by the other sanity testers how to do it before they even before they even like start doing or you know when they're grading their first test they're trained by the other sanity testers that are already there to make sure that everybody's kind of doing a consistent job at how it's doing. We even have a private forum where the sanity testers talk with each other when there's a question about that sort of thing. Um because the other thing that happens is sometimes people will fail a sanity test and then uh the test will come back in a second time and so then the sanity testers will chat with each other like this time it's a different sanity tester checking it and they might have a question on what the previous sanity tester said about that thing you

know and that's awesome. Now can can somebody who isn't using the game crafter to print or sell their game can they use that sanity testing? Can they just pay for that service? No they cannot. Okay. So, it's part it's kind of a whole package thing, right? Because it's actually it's all built into the the subsystems behind the scenes. So, the sanity testers have uh have access to see things about the game that normal people can't see. Um, got and so your game literally needs to be in our system for them to be able to do their job. But if you're doing a prototype, I mean, I would anybody who's designing a game, I would recommend them use the Gamecfter for their prototype just because they look they look nice, they feel nice to play. And so at that time, that would be a perfect time to have that sanity testing done. Exactly. Yeah. Yep. Yeah.

So, yeah, that's super cool. It's It's definitely worth it. Uh we do like uh we do those art tests. Like I said, that's a good way to check your art. That one does cost crafter points. Uh because what we're doing there is we have uh you pay I don't even remember what you pay, but you say pay some amount of crafter points to put your game up in the art test. We pick a bunch of random images out of your game and show them to uh you know like a couple dozen people and they rate your images based on whatever you know the criteria of the art test. So it's members of a of the community that are all going through looking at this thing and going does this look good to me you know or could it look better? Um and so they can they can just do something as simple as a thumbs up or a thumbs down but they can also leave comments and all that and you get a rating for that and if you pass again you get an accolade for that. Um, community verified test is another one, but it's just like is this person doing disgusting things in their game, you know, or or like do they have a Mickey Mouse logo? That's another thing, you know, like is the rating is is the age rating appropriate? Uh, right. Yeah. Uh, what about uh accessibility testing? Um, accessibility is something that I think is really important in in games. Uh, colorblind uh you know, fonts being too small. I mean, man, I have some games where I literally have to use a a magnifying glass to to to read the the cards. Yeah.

Do you guys offer anything anything like that? That we should do that, but no, we don't do that currently. That's that's that would be a great idea. We do put uh like we have our design software uh called component studio that has colorblind filters built right into it for example but we don't actually offer a test for those that don't use component studio to you know to go hey this this should be colorb blind friendly and it's not you know that sort of thing. Um so we don't we don't have a test for that currently but we probably should add that. That would be great because I think I mean a lot of games do fail at that accessibility of just the there's physical limitations that some people have with games and that could be easily fixed without having to spend more money, right? Yep.

Exactly. I want to go back to the art because I think one of the other big elephants in the room these days is AI art. And you know, I've done a video on my thoughts on AI art and you know, one art assets are very expensive. M people are costconscious things. There's a give and take. There's I I I think there are some maybe more ethical ways to use AI art than others. Um you know, I've told people on the channel that I'm not the AI police and I don't participate in AI witch hunts because I've seen people get accused and it's not AI and so then they have to go and they have to like show their whole portfolio. So, I I think it's a pretty complex situation and I think I mean that cat's out of the bag, right? We're not we're not shoving that genie back into the bottle. So, what do you what does the game crafter have a stance on AI art? Do you recommend things? Do you recommend not using things? What what kind of uh what kind of advice do you give for that? Yeah, that's a hard one. Um because like you said, the technology exists and it's not not going to go away. So, any art is dead on arrival as far as nuance. Um, and so, uh, you know, I I personally use AI art when I'm prototyping. Uh, but that said, I don't actually like the look of AI art from a professionalism point of view. Like, yeah. Um, so I actually when I make a

game, I still hire a real artist to do the real art for it. And I give them the AI art that I use during prototyping as my starting point, you know, like a mood sheet almost. Y um so I find it actually helpful when I talk to my artists, uh you know, when I'm hiring an illustrator, uh I find it helpful to show them this is what I was thinking, but I need these changes and I need it to have more of this mood and you know, that sort of stuff. Stuff that is hard to get across in AI when you're making the stuff, right? an illustrator in a single sentence, I can I can accomplish what would take me an hour in talking to an AI to try to get it right. Uh and and an illustrator will do it, you know, a whole lot better. Um the other thing is that that you get from an illustrator versus uh you know, using AI art. Yes, AI art is cheaper, but an illustrator usually has a following of their own. So when you go to publish your game, you're going to get the benefits of their community coming after, you know, uh backing your game too because they want to help that artist out. They they like their art and want to see more of it, right? Yeah. Exactly. So, uh so saying, you know, you should always use AI art or you should never use AI art, I think is a is a weird stance. Um as far as the game crafter, we don't police that at all. Um we do recommend that you post whether or not you used AI art. Yeah, that's that's that's kind of my bottom line is Yeah. be upfront, then let me as the consumer, as the customer, let me make the the the choice, right? Yeah.

Yep. And I think that's a a great way to go because um there are absolutely people that are adamant. They do not want to support AIR in any form at all. And I think they should be given the opportunity to do that. Don't lie to them. Be honest. Yeah. That's that's that's what's really important. Yeah. And I actually think and hope that there I think there's some interesting things going on in the court. Me personally, this is not a game crafter stance. This is me personally. Uh I think that um that one of the things I that is before the courts right now actually is the idea that AI art should not be copyrightable. Yep. And I actually agree with that statement. I don't think it should be copyrightable and that should be the domain of an illustrator. Their art should be copyrightable. The art that was generated from a computer, no.

Um, yeah. And so I think that's one of the b another one of those benefits that you should get by having a real illustrator working on your game is, you know, all of a sudden your game is more protectable. It's more protectable. Yeah. Though that's I mean, so my day job is in intellectual property. I Well, I used to be an intellectual property parallegal. Uh, okay. And I still work in that law firm. So does the Gamecrafter offer any kind of legal services at all? any kind of uh you know recommendations for for IP protection or is that that's probably completely out of the scope of what you guys do, right? That is way outside the scope. If there are things that we can help people, you know, not make obvious mistakes with law. We we you know have links in our help system. So like uh you know there's the testing that you have to have if you're trying to make a game for children. We you know we tell people about that. That's why we don't allow Oh, like like small components and choking hazards and that choking hazards and the types of paint that could be used in a thing and all that kind of stuff. That's like federal that's like just basic federal law that you guys as a manufacturer have to comply with, right? And so we're very we're very upfront about that we don't make games for children and this is why, you know, for that sort of thing. And so we're like, don't put this on your packaging because that is a violation of federal law and you know that you shouldn't do those kinds of things. But as far as and and we also have videos that we have of not us talking but lawyers talking about um you know trademark law or use of AI

or those kind of things because we run conventions where we'll invite industry experts in to talk about these kinds of subjects and we record them and put them up on our YouTube channel. Um and so that those kinds of things we you know in that way we help with law but we don't we're not lawyers and we're not going to uh we can't advise you in any way on it other than have a lawyer uh on retainer that people can that people can hire to uh to talk about their an IP lawyer. Yeah. And IP lawyers are very expensive. Uh yeah. Yeah. It's very expensive and and and and very problematic for us to be involved in that at all. This is uh it needs to be taken on a case- by case basis. Uh as any lawyer will tell you, the answer is always it depends. It depends. Yep. Nothing is black and white in law.

That's right. So, so therefore we it's not something we can get into. Uh, and so no, we don't help out with that. That's awesome. Uh, I want to touch really really briefly back to the art subject. Uh, does the game crafter provide any kind of art asset libraries for designers to use? We uh actually from our um make menu or I'm sorry, from our shop menu, you'll find the uh game design assets link right in there. And that's a library of assets that other users have uploaded to our site for sale or for free on the game crafter. Um, so artist So artists can make some money by selling their art assets through the game crafter as well. Absolutely. Yep. They do it every single day. Um, and so some people will do art assets for uh for sale or for free. Some people will uh some people do other things like they'll upload uh die lines, you know, they like a a good one um that I know in the community is somebody made a you know, we do custom punchouts where you can make you make a cutout shape, whatever. And so somebody made a really cool one that uh makes a dice tower that you can, you know, customize your own dice tower kind of thing. So they give you all the die lines. I I don't think that one's for free. I think you have to pay for that one, but they give you all the die lines pre-made to make your own custom die. uh dice tower on the game crafter and it um but they give you instructions on like how to modify it so you can make your own custom one. So yeah, that that's super cool, man. This

has been such a fascinating talk. Yeah. I' I feel like I feel like I've learned so much. I feel like maybe, you know, if I didn't know, I'm sure there's other people that didn't know the kind of bigger scope that the Gamecfter isn't just printing your cardboard, right? It's like a full kind of onestop shop for almost everything you would need as far as That's the goal. Yeah. Yeah. Well, that's awesome. Uh, hey everybody, I hope you enjoyed this talk with JT. Uh, maybe maybe we'll do it again because I thought this was really really fascinating. So, thanks for your time, JT. I really appreciate it. Thanks for having me

Progress saved