Skip to main content
Loading video...

Heretical Buddhist Social Upheaval (w/ Joe Dewhurst) | Board & Book

Transcript 53:58

Hey, gamers. This is Liz Davidson, from This Game is Solitaire, and I have a very special guest for this segment of Board and Book. I have Jeff Duhrst. He is the designer of The Pure Land, forthcoming from GMT. How you doing today, Joe?

Uh yeah, I'm great. Uh thanks for having me back on the show again. It's always great to be here and chat.

We got to hang sometime. The internet offers so many possibilities, even though you're a Luddite. So.

Yeah, exactly. I was just just before we went on a me and Liz were bemoaning technology, and I was saying I wish computers were never invented, and we'd have to do this interview for a scrying pool or something.

I mean, monitor, scrying pool, what's the difference, really?

Exactly.

Uh so, for people who have not heard about The Pure Land yet, also I will link our podcast interview about that below. Um tell us about the game.

Uh good question. Um good request. It's been a long time since I started working on the game, so it's it's a little hard sometimes to remember what it's even about, but it will be it will be coming out soon. We're just finishing up art and layout right now. Um it is um a it'll be volume 14 in the Coin series. Also hard to keep track at this point. And it it looks at a very unusual topic for Coin, so it's a 15th century war in Japan. Um the 15th century in Japan is less well known, so this is before the better known 16th century of the Warring States period. And it concerns the time in and around what's known as the Ōnin War. Um and the Ōnin War was on the surface, at least, a civil war between two rival factions within the kind of shogunate government. Um they were kind of fighting for control of the of the shogunate, essentially. But not to install themselves as the shogun, and this is what's kind of curious about it.

They wanted to install a kind of puppet shogun, who would then govern on behalf of the more or less puppet emperor. So, there's a whole kind of line of puppets here. So, there's this civil war going on between them, between the Hosokawa family and the Yamana family, and they kind of amass broad coalitions, and fight mostly in Kyoto, although also elsewhere in the country. Um So, that that on the surface of it isn't isn't really such a typical coin topic, you know, it's just this conventional war between two warring samurai clans. But, what I found fascinating about the period and why I eventually did it as a coin game is that you also have this this um kind of underlying uh atmosphere of of unrest, so both social and and religious unrest. Um So, there's a lot of peasant revolts both during before and after the Ōnin War. And there's also the rise of the um Ikkō-ikki who are a kind of militant uh sect of Buddhist monks from uh the uh then relatively small Jōdo Shinshū sect of Buddhism uh which is now in fact the the majority Buddhist sect in Japan.

Um So, this is the kind of origin story of the Ikkō-ikki, this period of social turmoil and unrest. Um And alongside that, basically the the rise of of what were then relatively minor samurai families, but then would go on to become the dominant ones in the 16th century. So, there's this kind of um broad social upheaval on on many different levels which which I find really fascinating and um I I think made it a good candidate for the coin series. So, you have you have peasant revolts, you have uh religious revolts, and you also have the civil war going on.

That's wild. Yeah, this is a period I know very very little about, which is of course why I've invited you on here to teach me how to learn about it by giving us some good reading recommendations. Uh so, let's get down to business. What do I read to know something about the Pure Land?

Uh great great question. Uh good place to start. And this is where, as I said to you in advance, I'm going to cheat slightly. Um So, the first recommendation is this book by Paul Varley uh called The Ōnin War, quite simply. Um it's it's an old book, so it doesn't have an interesting cover. Um Um, Ōnin War uh history of its origins and background with a with a selective translation of the Chronicle of Onin. So, I'm assuming, um, a lot of the audience, uh, and and myself, unfortunately, aren't fluent in in Japanese. So, really what you should read is the Chronicle of Onin itself, which is a um more or less first-hand report by a courtier who was in Kyoto during the war. Um, that that, you know, that's a good kind of really back to the the the first uh words on it. Um, but there's a a selective translation of that in this book as well as a history of the period of of the century and a half or so leading up to the Onin War. And then a summary of the Onin War by Paul Varley.

And um then this this selective translation which which gives you a really good feeling for for what it must have felt like. So, there's this really more or less apocalyptic situation in Kyoto for about 10 years where the whole city is more or less burnt to the ground as people are fighting. There are There's very vivid descriptions of um bodies floating in the water. Um, bodies floating in the water uh while the um the shogun uh in his Silver Pavilion is sponsoring uh the arts. So, fascinatingly, this is also a real high point of of Japanese culture. And and lots of what we think of as kind of modern um or kind of uh you know, significant Japanese culture uh comes from this period as well. So, there's this really nice contrast you get of the whole city burning while while they're just doing doing poetry uh in in the capital. Um, this book also has a very nice map at the at the front. I don't know if that will show up at all, actually. It's very glarey in here.

Actually, no. No, it doesn't matter. That's uh the map I used as the kind of first basis for the map of the game cuz it gives a nice representation of the provinces as they were then. Um, so this book by H. Paul Varley I would I would recommend if you can find a copy, and that's the big if, because it's um very much out of print. It's from the 60s, maybe? Um, yeah, '67. Uh and it's it's it's hard to find. I when I started working on the game couldn't find a copy for ages and had to actually buy one of the US and get a friend who was visiting to bring it back. Got delivered to my friend's dad and he had to bring it over. I was I was living in Germany at the time. And I think one of the University of Munich libraries might have had a copy, but um, as anyone who's dealt with German university bureaucracies will know it can be very difficult to get access to these things. Um, and there aren't um, I couldn't find a digital copy. There there probably is one somewhere. So that if you can find it, that book's very good. And there are probably transcripts of the Chronicle of Onin online because it's, you know, it's several hundred years old now.

Um, but the other book I would recommend to accompany this or kind of alongside this which came out a few years ago is a book by Stephen Turnbull who's a fairly well-known military historian called The Onin War 1467 to 77, those being the years of the Onin War, A Turning Point in Samurai History. And I was really pleased to see this book come out. I actually emailed Turnbull and got an advanced PDF of it to have a look at. He was very helpful. Um, and this this book is it's published by uh, Helion and Company who do these kinds of um, uh, historical guides that you know, particularly aimed actually at wargamers and kind of kind of miniature wargamers and other wargamers to give you an overview of conflict. And and this book very more than some of these other I've read gives a really a really good detailed overview from a military perspective but still touching on some of these social aspects. And I was a little worried that those might get left out cuz they do sometimes.

But he he does mention the the the the unrest and so on as well, writing by farmers, that kind of stuff that's going on. So if you're just looking for um, you know, a clear, you know, introductory history of the period of the war itself, I would highly recommend Stephen Turnbull's book on the Onin War.

So, how did you come across this topic in the first place? It feels like it wouldn't be like a thing that somebody just in the UK or Europe or the US would just naturally run into.

Yeah, it's a good question. Um I and that's the third time I said it's a good question, so I'm going to stop saying it now. We'll assume all your questions are good. Um I just have these these kind of verbal tics, you know how it goes. Um it's the it's to buy myself some thinking time. Uh the um so I guess there there's two strands to it. One is back in 2019 or so, whenever it was. Um I was I just got into um historical board games, war games, and become fascinated by the the Coin series, as one does, and went down the rabbit hole that many coin fans do of thinking, "Oh, what different topics could I make a coin game on?" You know, not even necessarily intending to get into design, but just kind of idly thinking about it, uh thinking about different topics. Um I I also So, I was working on a few different ideas then and and still have some of those kind of in my back pocket.

But, I I also was familiar with um the the Sengoku Jidai, uh the 16th century period of Japan, for a number of different games, um including Sekigahara by GMT, but also um the Shogun Total War series, of course. Um I'm of of the of the age of people who kind of grew up playing those games. Um and when playing Shogun Total War, I was always very fascinated by the the Ikkō-ikki, who, unlike all the other factions, are this faction of of monks. Uh you know, they they they don't have the same kind of structure or hierarchy as the others, and they they're monks, but also uh rebel peasants, and I'm I'm very interested in peasant unrest and peasant revolts. So, I began kind of alongside this reading about the history of the Ikkō-ikki, and and got back to this Ōnin War period, and thought, "Oh, during the Ōnin War or around the Ōnin War period, the Ikkō-ikki are essentially um a group of insurgents leading peasant revolts." Um and started reading more about that, and got more into it, and naturally began thinking, well, we've got an insurgency going on now, so maybe we can make a coin game like this. Um And but but then I started on it. Um but but one of the coin games I've been playing a lot of around that time was was Pendragon, so I actually initially took more inspiration from Pendragon. Um And I had things, you know, I was thinking about different kind of ways you could have clan revolts going on, drawing on a Sekigahara as well, so this idea of people switching sides, which which happened as well in this period.

Uh and I had lots of fiddly little chits to show who was loyal to whom. Eventually got rid of all that cuz it was too too complex, but uh that that's how I how I started getting into it, really. Thinking about um what I found interesting about the period, and how you could depict that in a game, uh jumping to my at the time favorite game series, uh doing it in in the coin system. Um And and I was away away to the races, so working on it.

That's awesome. Uh and then before we move on to another set of books, so you are talking about an account from a courtier at the time. Um I guess what I'm wondering is like is the account gossipy? Is it serious? Like I I'm always really interested in primary sources and their vibe.

That's a good question. It's um So there's an interesting I just said it again. Oh my god. Um there's an interesting translator's note at the start, which is always good, and uh it's a selective translation because there's a lot of very florid accounts of battles, which he uh cut down and summarized a lot. Um and a lot of kind of recounting in slightly tedious detail different place names and so on, which which are very obscure and don't really mean anything to us. So it's it's one of those quite quite detailed accounts that kind of list all the different places and stuff. I would say uh more than being gossipy, it's kind of melodramatic, if that makes sense. So it's um it's really uh emphasizing the big um uh kind of dramatic occurrences, um betrayals, and this kind of thing that's going on. Um so it's it's it's it's that kind of that kind of account. I think it was written after the war but by somebody who had been there or at least who was in communication with people who'd been there. So, it's not it's not like a personal diary, it's not that kind of gossipy account, but it's uh it's a very uh very much in the recent aftermath kind of account.

That's super interesting. I I love a good primary source and trying to figure out like what that person knew about how to write history and who to consult and how close to the events it is. That's cool.

And and who's who who, you know, who who they're biased towards as well, right? Because it's great having primary sources, but um you need really need to take them with a big pinch of salt because they're going to they they have so much involvement in the events that um they're going to have a particular angle on things, right? Um and and they might know and they might know less than us in many ways, you know, a primary source from somebody in the 15th century um really probably only has a very local perspective on things. So, there's there's a lot you can get from it, but there's a lot that they probably don't know or don't want to tell you as well, uh which is which is uh yeah, tricky. Um I should um I should give a little shout-out now actually talking about courtiers. Um I've had a lot of help on the game by a uh historian called Radik Pazdorka, who while I was working on the game contacted me because he was writing his uh PhD thesis on um basically courtiers in Kyoto during the Onin War. Uh and he's been a really really fascinating person to get like assistance with and there's going to be a short essay from him on the on the role of of nobility. Um and this importantly to explain something in the Japanese context, but nobility here that he's working on and I think the author of the Chronicle of Onin is are the kind of imperial nobility. So, they're the ones um either related to or kind of associated with the imperial court, and that's the old nobility which comes before what's called the Bakufu nobility who are the kind of regional warlords who but who become the shoguns and so on. Some of the Bakufu have have a lineage relating to the emperor as well, but lots of them don't.

Lots of them are more like kind of jumped up commoners. So, there's this there's this kind of unlike unlike feudal Europe for instance where everyone's a knight, there's this contrast really between what you might think of as the knights who are the actually the rulers essentially but are really just regional warlords and the imperial nobility who just live in Kyoto in the palaces and have a nice time but are almost captive there because they don't have they don't really have any land, any territory, and they don't really have any clout. They're just there doing arts and being in the court of the emperor and so on. So, it's a really interesting contrast that I don't think you get at least in kind of Western Europe in the same way. Possibly some Eastern Roman Empire kind of dynamics are closer to that. Um Yeah. It's interesting anyway. Yeah.

Yeah. Oh, that's cool. Okay, so we've got the books to establish a baseline if you want to know general period stuff. But, I saw that pile of things you want to talk about. So, what is next?

Yeah. So, next I'm doing these I'm doing these in pairs to to to cheat the system. Um the other the next thing I wanted to talk about a bit I suppose was um as I mentioned I got very interested in the Ikkō-ikki and their origins in Shin Buddhism. Um or or Jōdo Shinshū Buddhism. Um so, I want to mention a couple of books about that. So, this is uh Jōdo Shinshū Shin Buddhism in Medieval Japan by James Dobbins. Um and this is a really great um overview kind of history but also um analysis and description of both the evolution of the Jōdo Shinshū Buddhist sect and um some of their beliefs uh which which I find really fascinating. So, uh I guess more more than anything else there are two things I find fascinating in this world and both are in this game. One is um peasant uprisings, you know, peasant culture and unrest, and the other is uh weird theological beliefs. And I know you're into those too, Lewis, so we can talk about this for hours.

So so Jodo Shinshu is a particular subset of Shin Buddhism. Shin Buddhism is Pure Land Buddhism and the basic tenet here is that there is this this place or this kind of state of mind or state of being, the Pure Land, which allows you to become enlightened and escape the the kind of Buddhist cycle of cycle of rebirth and everything. So that that's still the basic aim that there's this particular way of doing it which is by accessing the Pure Land. Um but the the way in which you do that and this is where it really differs for particularly Jodo Shinshu Buddhism which is True Pure Land Buddhism, you know, just just saying that they're real Pure Land Buddhists unlike all these other bad Pure Land Buddhists.

True Pure Land Buddhism has this I mean it's in it's in broader Shin Buddhism as well but particularly in True Pure Land Buddhism there's this idea that you you cannot because we're we we live in this fallen age. It's it's it's a basic teaching of it. We're in a kind of evil age, a fallen age, which means that humans by their own efforts cannot achieve enlightenment. You need to be and I'm going to use some Western theological terms here which is hard to although I try not to emphasize parallels too much but they're hard to avoid. You need to be you can only achieve enlightenment by the grace of Amitabha Buddha. That should sound very familiar to you and I think it's hard to avoid. There's this sense that you you you cannot do it for your own efforts. You need to be granted grace. True Pure Land Buddhism so it goes back to the founder of Shin Buddhism is Shinran a few centuries earlier. In the 15th century you have this um religious leader Rennyo who appears in the game and is the kind of um the main kind of charismatic builder and spreader of True Pure Lambertism, and his innovation in a sense is to make the teaching extremely extremely simple. So, the only the only kind of practice they have essentially uh in the simplest terms is the recitation of the the Nembutsu, uh which is Namu Amida Buddha, and it basically means something like um uh you know, I submit myself to Amida Buddha uh to be, you know, if granted grace. And it's just it's just

the recitation of this extremely simple chant. Um and that uh this again is going to sound familiar. Um the Nembutsu chant uh doesn't, you know, by reciting the Nembutsu chant, that isn't going to bring you grace itself. Rather, the fact that you are reciting it is evidence that you have been granted grace. Um and it's just fascinatingly similar to uh uh reformed theology in in Europe in a in a in a broadly similar period as well. It's it's it's just a really fascinating comparison, I think. Um you know, it's it's so similar to Calvinism that theologically it's kind of hard to avoid that that comparison. Although there there are of course differences, and I think it'd be a mistake to see it as the exact same thing. Um but this this teaching becomes especially popular among poor peasants.

So, the the dominant Buddhist sects of the time emphasize, you know, big big temples, huge expensive ceremonies, you know, learning all the words of the of the of the sutras and the teachings and so on. But Shin Shin Buddhism or uh Jodo Shinshu Buddhism, by contrast, has this has this extremely simple teaching that you just need to recite this thing. And if you're a poor peasant working, you know, huge amount in the field, you can't read, you're too busy, um you're you're living in a time of turmoil and strife, it's just a really simple appealing teaching that you can you can land on. Um So, that but yeah, I I think that's a kind of a fascinating thing you have you have growing there. Um The other aspect of it which becomes really interesting and there's a chapter in this book on it is this concept of licensed evil um which Shinran Shinran and then Rennyo both argue against. So, this is seen as heresy, but it's a very logical consequence of of the teaching. And again, you get this in Calvinism. So, if if our actions on Earth make no difference to the you know, the fate of our souls, um then it doesn't matter what we do.

You You You can do whatever you want. And this isn't to say that you should do evil, but uh it doesn't matter if you do do evil. So, some some Jodo Shinshu monks do do teach this uh this kind of doctrine of licensed evil, which is that you you can you can do what you want. So, at at the kind of extreme end of a Jodo Shinshu sect sect, just as you get at the extreme end of of a reformation in Europe, you get very debauched parties, you know, there's no morality anymore. You can sleep with who you want, you can get drunk, you can kill the lords who uh they all are right from you. You know, so it it it kind of justifies peasant resistance because the the the regular laws of man and of God even have been overturned, you know. There isn't There isn't any any uh law anymore. So, there's this what what you would call antinomian, you know, anti-law edge of the of the Jodo Shinshu movement at the time.

Um and that's where the where the Ikkō-ikki come in essentially. They're this They're this militant sect who uh are formed basically for self-defense in the first in the first place um but then also to kind of liberate the people. Um and uh and ikki here being um an any It's It's just just a league. An ikki means any kind of league and there are other kinds of ikkis, but the the Ikkō-ikki is the um I can't remember the exact translation, but something like the the true mind league. Uh and they're they're going to they they they form for that purpose. But again, what's kind of fascinating is the the mainstream Jodo Shinshu um temple or or kind of uh church, as you might call it, at this time is is arguing against this this behavior. So, while the Ikkō-ikki are aligned with Rennyo and the Jodo Shinshu order, uh he's trying to tell them to chill out with that and stop killing people. Um so, there's this real tension between licensed evil on the one hand and good deeds. So, so the the kind of countervailing and more uh correct doctrine is that your your good deeds uh are also evidence that you've been granted grace, you know. It isn't that you, by doing good deeds, you can you can receive grace. It's just that the kind of person who has been granted grace would also do good deeds.

Uh and it's a very odd It's a very odd theology. It's a very odd theological doctrine, but you get the exact same thing in the in the Calvinist church as well. And it's it's just very interesting to see these parallel debates going on, I think.

Yeah. I mean, you know, human action and the desire to know that you're going to get a good spiritual result, I feel like that's a nearly universal trait.

Yeah. Yeah, exactly.

So, um since it's around the same age, is there a chance of cross-pollination in these ideas going back and forth?

No. Not not really at all. And that that again is why I think these You need to be careful with these parallels. And I think I'm not sure if anyone's written Well, there are a few a few papers I've read on it. I'm not sure if it's been a close study as such of of why it happens, but I think it would need to be more of an anthropological study. I think it's almost just that once you start doing theology of any kind, these are the kinds of things you you end up at because, as you say, they're quite they're quite understandable and natural kind of conclusions to draw. Um but, there's not really This is before the arrival of the Dutch or the Portuguese or the British in Japan. So, there's no there's no direct contact at all with Europe. Um there's no knowledge of of Well, there probably is knowledge of Christianity, but only through the Nestorian Church in India. Uh who are in India and a little bit in China at the time, but there's not, you know, there's some trade with China and with Korea, but there wouldn't be it would just be another small Chinese sect, you know, if if if anything. There would be no substantial uh connection and certainly no kind of theological cross-pollination that I'm aware of.

That is that just makes it even more interesting, actually.

Yeah. Yeah, no, absolutely, it does. Yeah. It does So, you know, Shin Buddhism does have some origins in in Chinese Buddhism as well. So, you know, Buddhism comes from China and there's there's an influence there, but I don't think there's any Christian cross-pollination at all. Um except except in so far as I'm there's some evidence of cross-pollination between early Buddhism and Christianity in India, of course, but that's uh many centuries earlier.

Fascinating. Okay, so what what's the book that you paired with this?

Oh, yeah, that's just uh so that that's So, the first one's about Jodo Shinshu Buddhism more broadly. Um there's a book called uh War and Faith uh Ikkō-ikki in Muromachi Japan. Um Muromachi is just the the particular era of the Ashikaga Shogunate because they were based on Muromachi Street in in Kyoto. So, that's just what what that means if you're curious. Uh so, that's a particular book about the Ikkō-ikki in in late Muromachi Japan. So, that covers more than just the Ōnin War period, but um does does cover the Ōnin War and talks more broadly about the formation of the Ikkō-ikki and uh what they what they did, why they did it, and so on. So, if you want to learn more about that, that's that's a good one on that topic.

That's fascinating. So, kind of back to this idea about I guess theological disputes, what constitutes evil. You know, I think that because of the way Buddhism is presented in Western pop culture, um it doesn't really feel like I don't know, like as as as somebody who is a Westerner, like approaching these topics of samurai and Buddhists and fighting but it's not ninjas or whatever because like of what we get over here, what are some things that you I guess as a person who's making game on this topic want normal people in the United States and UK and Europe to understand about this period knowing what we could be going in with in terms of assumptions.

I think so both in terms of Buddhism and I guess kind of samurai culture it would be a kind of uh de- demystifying of it. So um um in terms of Buddhism I think you know I I I I was vaguely aware of this before but learned so much more about it going into this. People have in mind I think a kind of monolithic uh belief system when they think about Buddhism and depending what they've been exposed to that's quite likely to be some version of Zen Buddhism. This this kind of quite simple teaching or it might be the more uh opulent kind of kind of Theravada Buddhism you get in Southeast Asia possibly. But there's just so much diversity and I think um you you can see this as a period of Buddhist reformation in Japan but uh there's other Buddhist stuff going on in India and in and in China at the same time of course. Um so I would just yeah there's such a wide diversity of different sects and different beliefs. So there's other sects alongside the the Jodo Shinshu uh who have similar teachings but different. Um so things like the the Hokke-ikki and the the Lotus Sutra. So there's all these other groups who have come up in the game. So just for just for this this is wide diversity of beliefs and also that they're just as messy and complicated as Christianity in in Europe is. So people are sometimes shocked when they hear there were these very violent warrior monks fighting in the name of the Buddha which you see as a very kind of almost pacifist belief system. But if you read the Bible there shouldn't be Christian knights doing stuff in the name of Jesus either, right? So it's really it's really just as messy and complicated as that and people have the same kind of justifications maybe ad hoc maybe more principled for why they take up arms and

and why they fight and so on. Uh Um, so it's just yeah, it's just such a it it it's much richer than you'd think if you just think of it as this kind of simple foreign belief system or whatever. Um, and then but the same basically with Japanese politics and culture and and samurai and so on. People when they make uh, I think I won't name any particular examples, but some I would say kind of cruder or more simplistic games about Japan of this period will have special cards for like honor and bushido and blah blah blah. But you know, that would be like making a game about 15th century European feudal conflicts and having a special one for uh, like for for the nobility of the knights and so on. But they're just they're just pillaging towns and stealing rice and betraying each other and all the normal stuff.

Um, so while there are obviously cultural differences and these are interesting and and relevant and there's some there's some stuff that happens with them. Um, there's these are still just people and they're still making the same kinds of messy compromises and and mistakes and and so on. Uh, so that that's what I I would try to give people with the game uh, beyond just an insight into this relatively obscure period of history is I think presenting it as just as just as kind of messy and complicated as any other uh, conflict.

Yeah. Yeah, and you've mentioned uh, previously in this conversation that you've been working with serious historians of this period. Um, you know, uh, how I guess have you checked your own work to make sure that you are giving as accurate as possible a representation of a time period that we are temporally and culturally separated from?

Yeah, I mean, as I said, some of it is um, I've been discussing it or playing it with with some of these historians. Um, just just reading lots of different sources. Um, they're they're relatively few in English, but you know, you know, right I was able to help me with some of the more more primary sources and making sure with that kind of goes with his feeling for things. What What I've tried to Um so, I've had some feedback from people in in Japan as well of various kind of mixed types. What I've tried to do though and try to be acknowledged is that this is a relatively obscure conflict even in Japan, and I think people have a particular idea of it. So, for instance, there's this idea that it was really just this very localized conflict in Kyoto. That there was a lot of fighting in Kyoto. But, there were there were revolts and skirmishes and conflicts across the whole of the central part of the country anyway. Um so, things like that I've tried to not try to avoid, I guess, falling into a trap of presenting it just as people expect it to be uh even in in in in Japan where it's slightly better known.

Um but beyond that, just the normal work of a historian um I you know, I wouldn't I'm not an academic historian, but anyone making games uh seriously in this space need to learn how to do history. And I you know, I have some training in that. Um and and just checking lots of different sources, and at some point following your gut instinct to what you think is right, cuz you have to you have to make some calls at some point.

That is the truth. All right. So, you have another pair of books to show us.

Mhm.

What do we got?

Um the final Well, I yeah, just one book actually, but another book not on Japan I can mention or will mention. Um so, the three the three kind of main threads of the game for me there's a civil war uh between the two clans, which came up in the first pair of books. There's the religious reformation and unrest. And then there's the peasants. Um so, the final book and this is probably my favorite book on the period, although it only touches on the Onin War briefly, is a book called The World Turned Upside Down, Medieval Japanese Society by uh Pierre François Souyri. So, it's in French originally. Um and this This is a book uh as the title suggests about the social upheaval basically in the in the Muromachi period or in the in the medieval period. And it's the change from the you know, from the 14th, 13th century up to the end of the 16th century when you have the Tokugawa shogunate coming into place and then they're in place for 300 years with a very stable society. Um, but in between that, there's this huge huge period of upheaval and social change uh and it's just such a such a fascinating period um, in terms of the social dynamics that I yeah, I would urge anyone with uh I guess a slightly deeper interest once I've learned about the Onin War itself to read this book um, which you can get relatively cheaply. It's not that long. It's really like nicely written um, and it's just it's just really interesting. It just makes you think about um, what it must have felt like to live through this kind of time, I guess. This this time of uh really radical change um, and where you think uh the world might even be ending, you

know, uh if you're if you if you're a true believer in this kind of Buddhist sect, you might think we're in this this almost end times of the world and uh the whole social structure's going to fall apart. Um, So that yeah, I I think it's a really interesting insight into that kind of period.

That's fascinating. So, just out of curiosity, uh what is it about peasant revolts in particular that interests you and how do you find that out about yourself?

Um, I mean it's you know, more more than more than peasant revolts, it's any any revolt of of the low against the high. There's this phrase in the Onin War period uh gekokujo which um, kind of means something like like the world turned upside down or or the low against the high and it's just this idea of um, uh the the weak of the dispossessed um, somehow fighting often quite uh desperate or kind of uh you know, unlikely to succeed struggles against their superiors, uh their social superiors. Um, you know, for various of my own political reasons, I'm interested in that, but I find the um, from a peasant perspective in particular, I think what I find interesting is uh compared to later industrial revolts and uprisings. Um peasants often come from quite a different perspective where they a lot of the time peasant revolts still during during feudal regimes still have some faith both in the church of whatever kind it is and the and the king or the emperor or the or whoever. So they still they often still appeal to the the established social order and in that sense they're often still quite conservative. Um what they're fighting against is often the these kind of middle middle ranks of kind of upper middle ranks of um local nobility or sometimes merchants. Um although in in Japan you actually get merchants and peasants together revolting. Um but yeah there's this very it's a very uh curious almost contradictory uh belief system they have where they where they believe in the established social order. But what they often believe in is a kind of almost mythological uh

stability that existed before things got bad. You know there's often this sense that oh things are a bit rubbish nowadays but 100 years ago the king was great and true and we could believe in him. So they often have this appeal to that and I think it's just that that's a really fascinating kind of dynamic and that comes up in this this case because nobody So in the game I have support and opposition like in other coin games. Um but this is support for the the kind of uh structure of the shogunate. It's not support or opposition to the emperor. So nobody's questioning the authority of the emperor. The peasants will often appeal to the emperor uh when they're trying to you know not not that they can talk to him directly but they'll be saying you know surely the emperor wouldn't allow this that kind of thing. So it's support and opposition to the very kind of structure of the shogunate and in the structure of the game there's the civil war between Yamana and Hosokawa but they they both want support. So they're fighting over this this established political system which they don't want to collapse so they want to control it. Whereas the peasants and the and the Ikkikki to some extent are opposed to that. Um but they you know beyond all of that, at least for the peasants, they still believe in there being an emperor because the emperor in Japan is venerated as a god. You know, they're not they're not they're not fighting against that. They just want things to get back to the good old days. Uh there's this kind of sense of there being the good old days when everyone, you know, lays around in the fields and had a great time, which was almost surely never true, but it was maybe better than it was today. Um so yeah, no, I guess that's broadly where that kind of fascination comes from. Um

But also that there's this rich uh culture that we just don't know that much about a lot of the time because it's not really written down. You know, peasants normally aren't writing stuff down, so it's hard to learn about, but really interesting when you get fragments of it from from folk tales or from maybe accounts by nobles who you take with a pinch of salt and so on. Um which does bring me on to to the other book Well, two of the books I'll mention really briefly. Uh one just if we're going to pair another book about Japan with World Turned Upside Down, there's a book called Well, Yoshimasa and the Silver Pavilion, which is about So, he was the shogun during the war or during most of it. Um it's about the the cultural renaissance that that's going on at the same time. So, if you're just interested in that, I I would pair that with other books on the Ōnin War. Um so, about the the cultural developments that he sponsors uh while the city burns uh basically. Um he's a he's a very weak ruler, but very interested in the arts.

Um but the other one I would just just something else I've been reading recently and I think is really interesting in this context is this book about the Well, about revolutionary England, but about the the civil wars in England in the in the 17th century called called The Blazing World, um which is stealing a title from the from the Cavendish book of the same name. Um but this this is really interesting to me because prior to getting interested in this, I was very interested in the English Civil Wars, but particularly the obscure sects and peasant movements of the time. No surprise there. Uh one of which is the Diggers. And the Diggers um there's a song about the Diggers called The World Turned Upside Down. So, this when I saw this book about Japan called The World Turned Upside Down, I thought, you know, I have to read that. Um but this this book, The Blazing World by by Jonathan Healey, for me does something similar to The World Turned Upside Down in giving this account that really uh makes you feel how how insane a time it was, you know, how how how crazy it is to be uh turning things upside down, changing the world in this sense. In the English context, killing the king in the end, which is just completely unheard of, you know. And any defiance of a king like that is just it's just uh a wild thing and it makes you feel, you know, to us now that's old history, but it makes you feel how how revolutionary in a in a really kind of fundamental sense that was. And I think Japan at the time of the Onin War probably felt kind of similar.

That was all super interesting. So, I want to go back to, I guess, being interested in poetry and the arts while the world is on fire. Um

Yeah.

I mean, did people feel that in country at the time? I mean, as you know, I'm sort of fascinated by this because we're all working on a game about the Renaissance as well in Boxes and Lines. So, art in the midst of terror is like fascinating to me.

Yeah, so there's a bit So, just before the start of the Onin War, there's this big uh famine and there, you know, there are famines during the war as well, but there's this big famine and there's a bit, I think it's in the Chronicle of Onin, where the the author is writing about this and he's in the he's in the court of court of Yoshimasa, so they're there doing a poetry recital or something by the side of a river. And there are just dead bodies floating down the river uh from from the famine. Um and and there's this really vivid sense of this contrast which is felt by the author there. So, they're they're aware that there's, you know, severe negligence coming from the from the emperor. Uh not from the emperor, sorry. He's he's a god, we can't question him. From the from the shogun, uh uh who's just failing to do his job really, you know. Um and there's definitely a sense of that from vulnerability, I think, in in Kyoto and certainly from the peasants. Um What What I should caveat peasants as well. Peasants runs a wide a wide spectrum, and there are what we might think of as more upper-class peasants, and often Often the revolts are actually led by them, and I think this is a pattern we see elsewhere in the world.

And that's because they're the ones who have who have some stake in it. So, they're often revolting for things like debt relief and for land to be put back in their control. If you're an incredibly poor peasant, you don't care about any of that. You're just trying to survive. Uh but these these relatively richer peasants then are also angry that, you know, they're they're furious because new taxes are being imposed on them, and the taxes are just being used to build the silver pavilion and then so on instead of instead of feeding people. Um So, yeah, there's definitely the sense. There's a Uh let me just check. There's a comparison or um a Yeah, there's a comparison that's made with this um Chinese this kind of mythical or historical Chinese emperor called uh Ruler or King Jie. Um and the shogun the shogun Yoshimitsu Yoshimasa is compared to to King Jie. Um and that's definitely, you know, to those in the know, that's definitely a kind of critical comparison that invites uh skepticism about about his rule. Um so, that's something uh that kind of that That's one of those things that you you need to, you know, as a historian understand a bit of a broader context to to see, but it's definitely like intended as a as a big criticism of of his rule. Um because this king similarly, and this is where they This is This is a way of drawing these comparisons without getting yourself killed at the at the time, basically. Uh so, King Jie King Jie um similarly, while there were famines and civil war and stuff going on, didn't uh didn't support things at all. So, there are these two phrases associated with with him, which I have on the card in

the game. Uh let the country break asunder, so that's a kind of civil war, and let society perish, uh which is the kind of unrest and so on. So, there's this sense of this ruler who's who's not managing to rule, um uh which again, I think is comparable to somebody like King Charles during the Civil War, perhaps, just just really failing to to uh keep things under control. Um and people at the time were certainly aware of that, I think.

That's really interesting. Um so, if you have a god emperor that everybody has to act happy about, uh regardless of the situation, including the peasants who want to appeal, like what kind of role can that person play in a blow-up that's invoking them from every corner? Um but also, nobody can like the I just feel like that must be a very strange position to be in and to try to influence events from.

It is. And what I I I think what's curious about uh Japan in this period and in in later periods is um the the answer is really they can't do anything, and that's because they don't have any power at all. The the emperor in Japan is is is cloistered and kept in his palace, um uh and isn't really allowed out. And there is a very real sense in which the shogunate are the ones who have control, and they're not letting the emperor out at all. So, people appeal to the emperor, and that does that does bear some weight, and it can it can affect things. But the emperor himself, um until right up until the Meiji Restoration in the 19th century, um is is really just a tool that's being used by these other these other jumped-up warlords, basically, to to govern, um as a as a kind of a tool, and isn't uh so, probably has just as little power as the emperor in Japan still does today. And after World War II, the US did essentially what any good shogun would do, and they kept the emperor around and begin began ruling more or less in the name of the emperor.

Uh and that's still still the situation today in in Japan. There's this very kind of ceremonial role for the emperor who who no one questions and is very much venerated, um that doesn't really doesn't really do anything. And so, I have I have a card um in the game for the emperor uh who was called Go- Go-Shirakawa at the time. Um And I have I have two two options here. One, he makes a rare appearance which just increases support for the shogun in Kyoto, but that very rarely happened. The other, skepticism grows in distant provinces. So there is this this emperor who nobody ever sees, nobody really knows about. Um you know, people that that might make people begin to question their regime. But but really the emperor doesn't doesn't have any power, cannot do anything. Um They they he doesn't have any Well, I was going to say he doesn't have any land. He's got all the land. And that that's kind of the conundrum he finds himself in. The whole of Japan is the possession of the emperor, but all of the all of the different feudal lords essentially granted land to govern on behalf of the emperor. They collect taxes on behalf of the emperor. Um but that's all that's all managed by the shogun who's, you know, doing the nitty-gritty of day-to-day administration for the emperor. The emperor himself doesn't have any say or influence in that at all.

Um It does remind me I don't know. Who knows? We don't even have any We don't even really have any texts about what the emperor was feeling or so on because that would, you know, that would lower yourself to the level of an immortal. So there's really not much to go on about what the emperor in this period was was thinking or experiencing. Um But it does it does This question about the land does remind me of my favorite tax avoidance scheme which happens in this period. And I was very I realized players could do it in a kind of organic way and then remembered or noticed that this this exact thing happened. And what this is is that temple lands are tax exempt. Um so what lords who didn't want to pay their tax would do, who were friends with a local abbot or whatever, they would gift all their land to the temple.

Um but then the temple would pay them a administration fee to manage the land. So functionally nothing would change, but the two the pair together would uh not have to pay taxes or pay less taxes, which is very funny. And the the G Samurai player in the game, who are these kind of mid-ranking nobles and higher-ranking peasants, can can essentially do this. They can give all their money to the temple, to the to the Ikkō-ikki player, to administer, and the Ikkō-ikki can give them money back, and that prevents the other two people taking money from them, taxing them. Um but there has to be a high level of trust between the two for this to work, of course. Or else or else the temple might just run off with all your money. Um but I I just love this this kind of very simple tax avoidance scheme, which uh was happening all the time. Uh it was it was very common. As as things began began to fall apart and people became more autonomous in their kind of local regions, they would they would form these partnerships where they would on paper give all their land to the temple, but then be paid to administer that land for the temple.

That's so evil and smart. I feel like uh there's probably a lot of similar stuff going on today with like nonprofits and charity giving and woo.

Yeah, exactly. Yep.

That's crazy. So, you know, I've noticed that like I've been curious about courtiers and about the emperor because like those are people who are kind of higher up in society, and I feel like you know, when I read historical texts, usually I'm reading from somebody who's higher up. So, I guess my other question about the historical stuff you've been looking at is how much of the like peasant perspective are we getting? And then how much of that is like from peasants themselves?

Um I I yeah, like like I mentioned earlier, you really get none of it from the the very poorest peasants who um are illiterate and uh you know, aren't producing anything that's seen as culturally significant, so it's not it's not recorded at the time. Um you get people writing about them, of course, but what you do get is is from this higher class of what you might think of as almost kind of middle-class peasants who merge a bit with with merchants and kind of lower-class nobles. Um they're they're writing stuff, and you do get you do get writings from them. But, the main thing we get there really is is reports of these uprisings. So, these these revolts, these ikki leagues which are formed, and there's various different kinds of them. There's a It's a do ikki, which is a an earth an earth league. Um, there's a kuni ikki, which is a kind of regional league.

Um, there's another one that name I forget now, which is for for for tax tax relief essentially. And these are So, one of the one of the regional leagues for instance would form in uh say say Yamashiro, which is quite close to Kyoto. And that that happened during the war because they wanted to prevent rampaging armies coming through their land. So, this might even be one of the local nobles, but also the or the the kind of village chief locally. And they would just form together and form a kind of militia to fight people off. Um, the tax relief leagues would often be formed by lower-class lords who are in debt, maybe some merchants who are in debt. Uh, and this would be for debt relief, and they'd essentially go to the local kind of uh government buildings and demand debt relief. If they couldn't get debt relief, they sometimes just burn the building down. So, then all the records of the debt are gone. So, you have you have records of that if they weren't burned, but you have you have records of that happening and and who was involved in those leagues. You know, it's the it's the chiefs of the village who can then round people up from the village, and they're cooperating with these with these kind of lower-ranking nobles essentially in in a kind of self-interest for for for all involved.

So, you have that. Um, I guess the other thing you have is um So, Rennyo, the head of the Jodo Shinshu sect, wrote a lot of letters to uh basically provincial towns and villages uh which are called well, we call them myosho, which I think just means means letters of some kind. But, he's he's writing these, and they're various this kind of correspondence sometimes between people. Um, so you have these kinds of reports, but not nothing direct from the very poorest peasants in the

Interesting. I guess that makes sense. Um, is there any historical fiction about this time period?

Ooh, uh, not not about the Onin War specifically that I've come across in English. I I would be very surprised if there isn't some in Japanese. Um, but yeah, not that I'm aware of. Uh, there's loads about the Warring States period in the next century, of course. Um, one of my favorites actually being, uh, the book Shogun by James Clavell, uh, which again, that's one of the things I read when I was quite young, just a young teenager that got me really interested in the period and that that's about this this British, uh, sailor who gets washed up. Well, it's it's the inspiration for the TV series, uh, which is been

Yeah.

coming out recently, obviously. Um, so it's that that I I read that book, you know, 20 plus years ago and found that really fascinating. Um, and that's that's fascinating, I guess, kind of cuz it uses the vehicle of this foreigner being there as a way to explore the culture, so it helps you learn about it in a sense. You know, it's very glamorized and romanticized and so on, but it's a it's a really interesting book. Um, that's 100 years later than the Onin War, though, so it's not so much use. Um, I I I'll take a quick look and I will I'll I'll put together a list of all these books for you to put, um, on the on the video as well. And if I see any interesting-looking historical fiction, I'll I'll note it and add it to it. But none none that I've come across, no.

This is a very embarrassing, but when I'm learning about a period, I actually really like to read historical fiction about it because putting all of the people into a narrative so I understand how they know each other makes it a lot easier to read the history later.

Yes, I Um, yeah, that makes a lot of sense. Um, it does it does remind me actually, uh, I was cuz you said I can mention one other cultural thing, um, or media. Uh, I've been well, me and my partner Yianni have both been doing quite a lot of work for Combat Commander: Vietnam, um, another GMT game about the Vietnam War, very different. Um, although there's some peasant unrest in Vietnam War, which is interesting. But and some sects, some strange religious sects. But aside from those, we've been doing, uh, Uh, we've been working on that, um, aside from history, I've read about it. We've been watching, well, we've been reading some books, but watching some Vietnam War films. And in a similar way, I think, you need to take those, obviously, with a big pinch of salt, but they they give you some exposure to culture about the period in a really fascinating way. And what I just wanted to mention one of those films, which was a real surprise to us, but uh, our favorite by far. And it's not even really a Vietnam War film, but it's a film with some Vietnam War context. It's a film called Birdy with Nicholas Cage and, uh, another actor, he's the lead actor from, um, Full Metal Jacket, actually, but he's really good in this in Birdy. And it's a film basically about these these two friends. One of them very strange, presumably, you know, maybe autistic. Matthew Modine, that's it. Um, and he he he basically wants to be a bird. Uh, but it's about them as as teenagers and then in the aftermath of having both been in the in the war, uh, and kind of dealing with that and their trauma and so on. Uh, but it's just a really nice, really touching film about their friendship, basically.

Um, and I won't say any more about it, but I would really really recommend anyone who, uh, just wants to watch a a very kind of touching, heartfelt film, um, anyone who's a fan of Nicholas Cage, who's a who's a great actor when he chooses to be. Um,

uh, yeah, I I yeah, so that one I would really, you know, we we got onto that through watching Vietnam War films, but it's not really about Vietnam War, it's about these two friends. Um, and I'd I'd I'd really really recommend watching that. Um, but but, you know, something like that set during Vietnam War would be really fascinating. About two friends caught up in things. Um, I I would love to to read or watch something like that. Oh, there is, um, I haven't seen it cuz I haven't managed to find a good copy of it. There is, um, there's this, I can't remember what it's called now, there's this main state TV channel in Japan who do these historical dramas every year. Um, like like a BBC historical drama or something, like 10-part big kind of feature shows. And they've got one on the Vietnam War. Um, it's not meant to be very good, but I'd be interested to watch it if I can find a version of it ever.

Um, that's from quite a few decades ago now.

That's fantastic. All right, you give me lots of things to watch and think about, which is exactly what I'm doing

this segment now. Um, but uh, for people who are going to potentially dive in after watching, um, what is the the one thing you would start with from the whole list?

Um, I would start with that uh, Steven Turnbull book on the Anarchy War, 1467-77. It's It should be very accessible. You should be able to get it in a library or buy it fairly cheap online. And that gives a really clear presentation just of the facts in so far as the history can do that. Uh, which I think will give you a really good starting point. You'll You'll understand what actually happened in some sense. And then, if you're interested in more about the war itself, you can try and find a copy of that much more obscure book by Vale. Uh, or you can read about, you know, social unrest or about the quickie or whatever. There's other bits you can you can read more about, but that that one book will That's the book I'm going to recommend as a pairing with the game, because it will cover basically all the events covered by the game and and help you understand them in more detail.

Fantastic. Uh, Joe, thank you so much for coming on. This was an absolute delight, a fantastic way to start my day.

Great. I'm glad you enjoyed it. It was lovely talking about it with you.

All right, I'm sure I'll have you back on for something or other as we work together. But, um, for now, everybody look out for the pure land, uh, and do some cool reading.

Mhm.

Progress saved