Skip to main content
Loading video...

Kingdom Rush: Rift in Time - Discussion

Transcript 23:22

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for kingdom rush a rift in time which is lucky duck's newest game uh and is basically a tower defense game a true tower defense game uh in a board game and boy is this game okay yeah i remember the first time we were doing this earlier um we thought wow this feels like an app game yeah and then we looked up and went oh it is oh it literally is it is an app that i made into a board game they even have the logo iron hide game studio on it um and you know what that's not the fault of the game that's a fault on me not knowing it was an app which is again it's fine but the fact that the mechanics of it felt like it really says something about the design of the game true it was not redesigned to be a board game it was simply adapted yeah yeah that's true and that can be appealing to a lot of people some people despise app games um i usually don't play them um if i am playing an app game i am extremely bored i played clash of clans for quite some time but then i was i immediately gave up on that once it was like hey you need money real life money but yeah so this this essentially takes that kingdom rush app and uh like you said uh adapts it into a board game what do you think what do you think of the game um i it was fine yeah

um i think that the game play itself was okay although i i feel like and i think that the viewers might agree that we get a little bogged down in the options and how to optimize everything i think we did pretty pretty okay i think we did well i just it felt like it dragged just a few times oh wait but if i do this yeah and then oh i forgot one little rule right so well see i like those kinds of games that's why i like that's what i like about polyamino games is the fact that you do have the flexibility of being able to puzzle it together and but then we got to remember when we get to rearrange things and when we have to keep it in a certain way and because the the phase of playing the towers is simultaneous that it's just like okay well i i like immediately i see this as a possibility and that could open up to someone being like oh wait no no but if you do then you have to kind of take stuff back and you have to go back which leads me to my thing do not play this game with more than two this game is so goddamn fiddly yeah way more so with more than one or with more than two two people strategizing all our different moves yeah took some time three people would have taken well it was like we played this we played the first scenario with three and it was almost like why is the third person even here they don't get the same amount of towers which i thought was weird so like when cat was playing she only had three towers she could choose from where you and i had four okay um and i thought mine was in such an awkward position yeah i never used it exactly and i was like

oh well only if we get this you know the level three archery tower does that one in the court so it even feels weird setting it up because it's like here as two players everyone got to use their towers right um well this is also a very different board right true coming in from both sides instead of just the one channel right i granted i didn't even really feel that different honestly this one felt easier actually than the first one because it wasn't it was two lanes shorter lanes but two lanes but then the first one was two from the same one so they were pushing right uh and this other unless we were just super efficient on this one and the first one we we weren't um granted we both got three stars on that um but yeah it's like so the simultaneous well if someone's not kind of that headstrong player then they're gonna sit back and then not do anything yeah and that's just gonna happen in a simultaneous action game it's likely especially cooperative yeah uh and it's designed to go up to four right yeah oh my god yeah i've heard reports that it's not it's not worth doing with no it wasn't more than two yeah and it i mean honestly what katz said because cat played the app uh she was like this is a solo game like this this needs to just be played solo um and like i said or two because then at least you have someone to play the game with yeah but i can honestly see this game being hey play this solo it's it's like the feeling this isn't gonna be that much uh and by god this game is fiddly in

more ways than one i feel their attempt at a like a game trades whatever a cheap you know poor man's game trace this just gets in the way because you're trying to grab cards and then you want to grab their attacks from underneath so you have to constantly grab those um the fiddliness of the yummy constantly having to take your take your towers back which is i think kind of a weird mechanic but i don't know if that's pulled from the the app where you constantly cycle new towers uh through because normally in my experience with tower defense is you put them down and they stay there and then you level them up right maybe that was their way so you take them back and then you eventually level them up yeah um or the worst part is when you defeat a horde like oh yeah yeah i haven't picked up all the things yeah move them out pop the pop the thing i know it'd be worse if it didn't if they didn't have these so props to them on at least you just grabbed the tower and then just there was just a card we were sliding around oh man it'd be it'd be a bad time so those are way better than just flat on the [ __ ] board um and honestly that's kind of the downfall of the game this is since it's an app yeah play the app yeah that's that's my thought actually about some board games that were adapted for to be apps i'd rather play the app and not have to fiddle with picking things up calculating scores yeah you know yeah and and that's not that's not the case at least for me with

all games right um like some games i would it's like i play for the social interaction but games like through the ages where the app is phenomenal uh and the game is good we'll all just play the app um but games like uh sentinels of the multiverse for example that game is just bad to play and because that one is just like you have a lot of modifiers for cards and it's just very slow you have a hand of cards you can only ever play one and it's it's horrible um but they have an app for that which all the you know the modifiers are calculated so it's like oh at least the app is cleaner game's still boring but uh so yeah it's like is this game bad no it's just almost like a what's the point yeah you have yeah i think it's a good game that does not really translate well into physical realm yeah i'm actually going to uh i wonder if it's free i think it was free like the the app yeah kingdom rush tower defense game it's free and that's 4.7 stars yeah ironhide games um so in terms of mechanics with the game uh you you have your you have your towers that that are pretty much always going to be the same you look at the scenario you know you stack the the spawn decks in the way that they they tell you to so they're going to come out in a certain way and i do like the flexibility of actually being able to when you do pick

up your towers because then it's not like well [ __ ] we [ __ ] up on place in the archer tower there so it's always going to be there or it was great then yeah but now yeah now waiting for something to come along exactly so i do like that that you're not stuck with the poor decisions or good decisions and along those lines i'm also going to say that i like the strategy behind either playing a card or passing it to upgrade it to another card excuse me then you can't use it that turn right and several times i was going do you want to play this or do you want to make it better later yeah because i know we're going to face bigger problems right right and uh that that type of decision is there and it's way better in a um in a two-player game because it's back and forth instead of with three it's just like who do i give this to exactly oh i passed it to you but your towers are useless you know um i don't know if the the app has a where you pick up like a hero that has like abilities i do like the special powers i think they're really good i like the fact that you're like they do play completely different you were big damage and area of effect damage but you had to basically land on the spot whereas i was the range so all this scenario was was me just going shoot shoot i just kept shooting back and forth um but the game's the game's simple yes it's not complex i think the the rulebook's not bad and the scenario books not bad but their organization of it was a

little weird and for example the biggest example we found was the setup is telling you oh put the number of hearts equal to the difficulty level yeah difficulty level you would think oh that's in the scenario book right and it's not and so you're like well how much how much health do i get then whenever we realized oh you just you as a player determine the difficulty so it's always going to be the same regardless of which scenario it's not like most games we actually just played one the other day dark rituals where each scenario had different rules um so you almost think oh in this scenario i only have three hearts you know uh which is very reminiscent of an app lifestyle where it's like oh i'm gonna you know i'm gonna play this scenario and it's going to tell me how many you know you know angry birds that was the angry birds was the app i was thinking of where it was like the star system how well you did you got a certain number of stars right um this is the opposite you decide the difficulty and by the number of stars yeah and then you play through that win or lose right which is very pleasing that is pleasing in app form i do like this map i think this map is really cool and seeing the progress like an app map shows it and they did that really well but once again the production design is weird because they give you one map one colored map and one i mean not just one but sticker sheets these are enough stickers huh i'm sure enough stickers yeah yeah cause there's like a whole another but only for one only for one campaign

play yeah including now what they did do which is pretty cool is you have the ten scenarios all in this color but then and then down here it tells you oh the geralt verse jt expansion has their own scenarios and that's up here ah so it the whole map does have all the expansions on it got it um which is cool and i guess it's not necessarily because we decided to play it on three but let's say we get our ass kicked in a scenario and then it's like you can willingly choose to not put the stickers on sure you can mark it in you can photocopy this i'm sure if you email luckyduck they probably have something to to compensate for this i would hope that they would have something to compensate yeah um but you could be like let's say we were playing this and we're like oh level you know scenario three is too hard um so we'll do it at level two but we won't put the stickers on because we really want to try and get three yeah or just do it true blue and be like well we could only beat this one on level two we're going to move on um my only thing for that is if i play on level three and we do it so well that it's like oh we actually took note like in this particular run through if you didn't have to respawn i would have been like no we did this on on legendary you know whatever it is because we never had healers heal and we never took damage so i'd be like the only thing was you did die yeah you know what you could do well you i suppose you could you could play it that way yeah um that's not how the

rules are written right but there's nothing stopping you yeah evaluating later exactly but so i am going to say so i was going to comment on the the variable difficulty because we played both of these on medium well we played on oh yeah you're right three stars right in the middle yeah because they do have a five way oh yeah difficulty system true true but it seems to me that the way that we've played it it's been really really simple and easy both of these um and it feels like without actually playing them that the more difficult levels are probably close to impossible sure which is a nice challenge but i don't think it's probably going to be the right payoff for as much as you have to manipulate and think about yeah this time you spend i don't know if it's gonna be worth going through all this and then losing that is true that is true all the fiddliness of it yeah i think i mean they do basically with the difficulty give you the the flexibility to kind of um evaluate later like if let's say we did take one you know we took two hits um or if we were like you know we're going to try it on on the easiest one or on the hardest one and just have one hit point and then we lose we can be like oh well we'll just add more hearts and we'll just put the stars accordingly sure uh you do have that flexibility you'll be cheating but you're right if you were to play very hardcore and just yeah the fiddliness of the game it's just i don't i don't see the point yeah really in in in playing this physical yeah it's

i mean unless there are some people who vehemently hate apps sure and app assisted games so they're just like this thing the government is tracking me like this is god's way of hating me and it's like what uh okay but and then they're like i like this i mean i it's it's not inconceivable that people would enjoy this board game yeah but yeah it's just it feels like a lot of time spent and manipulation for the payoff is fine right because i mean let's see the level three uh so level three adds lilith so she is uh i think kind of a uh boss uh we get level one two and three and four eight towers so new towers come out there are three spawn points um you have a new uh so i guess we're trying to defend these towers these level four towers okay um interesting we still don't get spells uh so it looks like and then yeah special mechanisms lilith comes in okay so i could radically change things right and like i said we we've played the first two maybe that's how it's supposed to be intro to the game mechanics and then you advance on to the real challenge right yeah because then i don't really want to yeah it's i can see this game being

way better at one and then two if you're looking for if you're looking for a light-hearted game uh they because i mean you can't play the app with people true so if you were like looking this would be a great game to play with what's the age ranking on it 14 up that seems a little much yeah he probably plays with a eight eight nine ten year old i don't have kids so i i i don't know however clever eight ten year olds probably would be fine yeah um but then they want to play the app instead that is true that is true so everyone can get their own app and play and play their own game it's it's very hard because this game is not bad i wouldn't even say it's disappointing no like i didn't really there's nothing there's nothing wrong with it yeah there's nothing really great right about it for you the question comes to uh is this game good enough for you to forgo the app and i would say no not maybe yeah and that's kind of that's i mean even cat because she immediately started playing it and she said the filliness of this it all that's gone all the you know the biggest i'm just like okay well now it's okay we flip this and then this goes here and then oh and then we have to place this on here and then this on here and we have to figure it and then we kill it and then now we have to take them all off and potentially organize them in the [ __ ] tray and then rearranging our options because we found a better way but oh i played that one last turn so i can't move it yeah yeah um you just don't have to deal with that um and she and she's and they're and the the game is based in

the app is basing scenarios as well she's still playing no no she's like up there i'm addicted spending all my money my credit cards are maxed out what the [ __ ] uh okay it's yeah i got nothing else i got nothing else um scale one to ten um i do not like i will say the storage solution for this is a half-ass attempt yeah like either put the extra effort in yeah or not at all what what the so they got the plastic molded trays yeah that a lot of places that a lot of games don't but the way that they organize them it's like we put this much thought into it but we didn't go the extra step of designing a really great system right it's because what what should have because the the other thing is like these trays they don't these don't lock so i can easily pull this top in so the way but nor do they they don't stack stuck underneath right or forward right and these things fold in but because they're folded so now if i place this in here well so it's actually in terms of like the cards and the i mean the miniatures are okay yeah like they're not they're not amazing they've got some detail these hearts are gray three out of ten no uh i they do i do know they are fixing that but i couldn't give two shits if the hearts are great yes i can paint them myself if i write spray paint them just

oh look they're done um but it is confusing because they put some thought into it but not enough to show that they really thought about which it seems to be that be to be a like a a status quo for lucky duck because like i mentioned with chronicles of crime they have their base game with their three expansions and it all fit in the base game and you're like great okay well you're doing another it's called the millennium series which does this the detective series is in the 1400s i think i think it's one that's modern day then in the future and initially all those were individual boxes but then they're like oh we'll make a millennium organizer which holds all three and everyone's like well what about the base game oh well we're not gonna do that why the [ __ ] not like just i mean it wouldn't be hard but that's a lot of games i showed you goo gong yesterday uh the the game trays vindication has game trays oh yeah a lot of a lot of them do and they're really well organized yeah and this is so clean here's some trays and they they put some thought into it like this this i can see why somebody would think this is a clever idea doesn't work as well yeah in person yeah exactly and so on top of all of that shoddy organization design i guess i won't say production but a shoddy organization on top of game fiddliness where there is an app that you don't have to deal with any of that yeah and i get it some people very like the minutia of

messing with stuff oh i love that i love that if it's not wow this is kind of annoying yeah because you you do defeat hordes quite a bit or you should you should be defeating them quite a bit so it's not like oh well every once in a while you kind of have to do that weird thing you're constantly just it's just not enough so i did one that i didn't want to bring that because this is this is just bad it's disappointing it's very bad so anyway um i would probably say six six slightly above average i because i mean because it is like it's a weird how you got a schizophrenic vote some things are great and some things are what yeah so that's why i'm gonna average it out into a little bit better than okay the mainstream i would agree with you on on on that regard but i am going to be a little more harsher because uh of the production value now i i i also didn't pay for it i'm actually about to look that up i am going to look at how much i paid for the all-in pledge okay um because whenever i was trying to organize it i even i had no idea how how they even store stuff because like even then all these extra ones don't even really fit like they kind of do and i put them up there because it's like well that must be the level four stuff but all right so kingdom rush ah my pledge uh was that really the 129 so for content all right i'll agree with

you i will give it a 6. um you don't have to agree with me well no i was going to give it a 5 because i think this is an average game with an app that does it better but for the amount of content you get for the 129 that is and that was the all in pledge it wasn't like i did 129 with my base and i had to throw in add-ons that was everything i got so over there there's the the the spider queen expansion which adds right um or the spider goddess expansion which adds how many one two three four five six seven seven scenarios and then the two geralt versus jt and vesnen versus moloch which adds one two three four i think eight more so you have a total of was it 10 18 25 25 scenarios wow uh yeah that's yeah and with with potential replay if you're like well we beat it at three let's try and do it on heroic and then we'll try it on iron yeah if somebody wanted to go through all that then it would be a great value no i don't want to but yeah you're right um so yeah i'll give it a six which is a shame because i want it to be higher but it is what it is yep you got anything else um no i think that covers it thanks cool yeah thank you you're welcome uh that's our thoughts on kingdom rush a rift in time let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time i play this view hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video

if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved