Skip to main content
Loading video...

I Finally Played Twilight Imperium 4th Edition!

Transcript 33:24

Hey, hey, you. So, you want to try Twilight Imperium, but you're intimidated, unsure, scared, even? I mean, how where do you start? Oh, God. You're not alone in those feelings. I very recently played Twilight Imperium fourth edition for the very first time, and I was so intimidated, but I survived. And I've got thoughts to share about my experience. I'm going to tell you how I prepared, what I was nervous about, what went well, what didn't go well, and was it worth it? Did it live up to the hype? All while hopefully helping you feel like you can dive in so you can make up your own mind. And yes, I am talking into a microphone that I'm holding because this is what you do on YouTube now, apparently.

Ready? Let's go. I'm not fully out of frame. It didn't really work. So, I've just parked and I'm about to go in and play my first ever game of Twilight Imperium. And I am nervous. I am intimidated. I am nervous. I have prepped more for this than any game I have ever played other than like a TTRPG. I spent so long reading rules and watching videos and looking up like strategy and what to do on your first turn and like how does the game work and I'm about to go experience it for the first time and I'm nervous. Here are the things that I am nervous and worried about. Here's why I'm intimidated. What if um I'm the person who slows the game down? What if like I go in there and everyone's like she didn't do her homework. She didn't do her due diligence. She's come in. It's disrespectful because she doesn't actually know how the game works and it's slowing all of us down. I'm worried about that. I don't think that's what's going to happen, but it's my first time playing, so even if you have learned a game and you've read the rules and you think you understand it, then actually playing it, there's always going to be questions, right? Two, what if everyone's like super competitive and mean and play really mean and I do a really bad job and I have a bad time because I'm losing so badly or it's embarrassing because I'm losing so badly. Everyone else gets to the end of the game with between eight and 10 points and I have like three So, I'm a little worried about that. I'm worried that it's just going to be like

overwhelming and I'm not going to be able to keep up with it and every turn I'm going to be like, I don't know what to do. I don't know. And that that's not going to be very fun. I'm worried that I'm not going to have fun, that I'm going to I don't need to win. I don't need to win. I don't need to win almost any game I play. But if I'm doing really badly or things are really not going my way, that can start to like deplete your level of fun. And this is like a I'm expecting this game is going to go anywhere between 6 and 10 hours. And that's a long time to be miserable. I don't know. Hopefully none of these things will happen. I know four, I think, of the six people playing already. They're all nice people. I'm sure it'll be fine. I'm sure I'll have a great time. I think I've done, look, I've done all the prep one can reasonably do before playing their first game, I think. And I am intimidated and I am nervous and I'm going to see what happens. Wish me luck. But the future is feline because I'm playing some cats. Not the Hecon.

I'm playing the Nasoku Rocka Alliance. I'll know the name of my team before the end of the game. So, there's work happening uh right outside my window right now. They were very quiet while I was setting up to film. They're less quiet now. So, um we might hear them. That was me right before I went inside to play TI4 for the first time. I think you can see I was nervous. I was honestly really nervous. I don't know how much it comes across in that video. I was really, really nervous. It's like my stomach hurt. Even though I was playing with friends and the couple of people at the table who I didn't really know, I at least knew they were friends with my friend who organized the game.

Like, I trust him and I trust his judgment and putting together a good group of players. And even with all that trust, I was worried people might end up being jerks or like pushy. If that's a fear you also have, then I would say try to make it so your first experience with this game is with a wellcurated gaming group. Like don't play this with just anyone. Preferably, you'll be playing with friends or at least people who you know are going to bring good vibes to the table. If you know people like in your gaming group who are aggressive or pushy or take things too personally during games, maybe leave them out of this one, right? Set yourself up for success. This game is an investment. And if you think it might be tough to be around someone in a competitive setting for more than six hours, it might not be right for your first experience with this game. So, in that video, you also heard me talk about all the prep I did for the game. Legit, I've never spent more time getting ready to play a game that wasn't a TTRPG. And I play a lot of like Dn D and Pathfinder and Call of Cthulhu. And honestly, I've done a lot of prep for those kinds of games. And I might have done more to get ready for this one. And even when I'm been like prepping for a D and D game that I'm going to DM, I might have put more hours into prepping for Twilight Imperium. And I did that to try to help ease those nerves I was feeling.

And, you know, to be a good fellow player. When you've got a game that's going to take literally all day to play, the last thing you want to do is unnecessarily slow it down for everyone else. Like, it's rude. Of course, it's one thing if you're taking a moment to think over all your options and weigh up the right strategy, but if you're slowing things down because you didn't care enough to learn how the game works, yo, that's disrespectful to everyone else's time and effort. Oh gosh. And I didn't want to be that person. I had such a fear of being perceived as being that person. So, I prepped. But how how did I prep? I'm so glad you asked. First, we agreed ahead of time, everyone in plain, that we would choose our factions before we got there. And I specifically picked mine from this list of factions, which is sorted by complexity. You can find this on the Twilight Imperium wiki list of factions by play complexity. And then my friend who is organizing the game provided me these very handy short descriptions to give me a little taste of what each faction is kind of like.

And then from there, I glanced over each of their wiki pages. So, I'll be honest, I didn't understand most of what I was looking at at this point. It talked a lot about like promisory notes and things. I was like, I don't know what that means. But I was just trying to get a bit of flavor and then choose from that. And I ended up going with the Nasra Rocka Nazoka. I don't know how you say it. And here's what I'm going to argue is that it doesn't matter. I can say it however I want because they're not real. None of these factions like actually exist. So, you can kind of say them however you want. So, the Nause Rocka, that's what I chose because I like cats and I like the idea of focusing on exploring. And I also liked that they were from the expansion Prophecy of Kings, which we were going to be playing with. So, I knew this faction was designed to directly interact with whatever the expansion added to the game, and I liked that idea. So, that's who I chose. Y'all, I did just find this resource on Boardgame Geek that would have been useful while I was picking a faction. I think it lists all of them with like a short little strategy guide and like a ranking and like how to play them and what kind of scenario they're good in. And I think I would have enjoyed using this to help me choose a faction if I had found it sooner. So once I chose the nosraa roa, whatever.

Uh I didn't question I didn't question the pronunciation. I did I did question the pronunciation, but I didn't question the choice or second guess or to go maybe I should have picked the space turtles instead. You know, I just went all in on figuring out how they work and the way to use them in the game because I didn't have time. I didn't have time to mess around with trying to decide if there was a different faction I actually wanted to play instead. No, just commit to this and learn it so that you can play it the best you can. But before I could do that, I kind of needed to know how the game itself worked. So, I started with reading the learn to play document that you can find from Fantasy Flight. This is 25 pages long, and it's not the full rules. There's an actual rule book in addition to this, but you should read all of this. Fantasy Flight actually recommends you just read this before your first play and then use the actual rule book as a reference book when questions come up during the game.

Even the game itself is like look, you won't be able to know every detail about this game. That's what the main rule book is for. Just look it up when you need it, but make sure you understand at least these core concepts. Good luck. And actually, that really took the pressure off of feeling like I needed to have some encyclopedic knowledge of the game before going in. But again, I really wanted to be sure I understood the basics in that learn to play booklet. So, I read all of it. I even read the flavor text. It was two pages of the 25 pages of rules. I really feel like with a game like this, you got to go all in on theme. I read the flavor text for the Prophecy of Kings expansion rules, too. And that's four of those 16 pages. That's like a quarter of that rule book is just flavor. But I actually I really think understanding the story of a game like this is going to help you understand the mechanisms and how they all work together. I truly truly believe that because the point of a game of this nature is like the decisions you're making on what you're doing in the game have everything to do with what the story of the game is. So, if you understand the motivations that your character is supposed to have, you're going to understand the rules a lot better and why you're going to choose certain actions over other actions in all the different contexts of the game.

Yes, the learn to play booklets total 41 pages. I just wanted to acknowledge that 41 pages of rules that I'm telling you to read, but a good chunk of those are like they're like map layouts. You don't really need to look at those. So, you're only going to be reading like 30 something pages. It's fine. It's like it's not that bad. It's not that bad. Also, I'm a visual learner. I don't learn games just from reading the rules. I really don't. So, from here, I took to YouTube. Of course, I have watched the highly recommended videos that RTFM, my friend Shay, who incidentally was also hosting this game. I watched the videos he made for fourth edition and for Prophecy of Kings because like I said before we were playing with that expansion and then I settled in for a longer more comprehensive series on how to play a three-parter on the channel Harsh Rules by Ben Harsh. Ben, thank you so much. Thank you, Ben Harsh. I really found this so helpful. So, it's about an hour 20 minutes for all three videos.

It's detailed. It's so helpful. I really got a lot out of these videos. If you've got the time, I really recommend you take the time and you watch these. But even after all of that, I was still nervous about understanding things in context. So then I watched a round one play example because I really wanted to understand the flow of how the game actually works and what you should be doing on your first turn. And I didn't want to be getting that context and that understanding on my actual first turn of the game. I wanted to feel like I could go into this game with a little bit of confidence and like at least on my first turn I wouldn't have to like turn to people and be like what should I do? I don't know what I don't understand. Like I wanted to understand enough to be able to make my first turn without a ton of help. And I've just really learned over the last few years, you know, I learn a lot of games for my job. And I've really learned that watching other people play a round or two helps me helps me learn a game. So, a big thank you to Jeffrey Zeicer for this video that I watched.

All the videos I'm mentioning, of course, everything I'm talking about is going to be linked in the description below as well, so you can easily find them for yourself if you'd like. And I highly recommend you check out everything that I'm recommending in this video. So, at this point, I honestly was feeling like I understood the basic rules of the game pretty well. So, then it was time to tackle my next fear, sucking really bad at the game, just scoring no points, being a total pushover for my competitors, which meant it was time to dig into strategy guides. This um this had its pros and cons because uh I was feeling confident that I understood the game and then adding even just this additional layer of information, this thinnest veneer just gossamer really made me go, "Oh no, I I don't understand this game at all."

You should definitely look up recommended play styles and opening moves for your faction. I do recommend that. Just be aware of when you might be overloading yourself. It's like, you know, it's like taking a vitamin that has way more milligrams than your body can actually process. So, you just end up peeing most of it out. You don't want your brain to just start peeing strategy. You want to be able to absorb tips and tricks and I have it pass right through you. And I'm not going to apologize for that analogy at all. There you go. Stop peeing strategy. You're going to get dehydrated. 115 Gamer has a great general beginner strategy guide that I recommend. You should all watch it. And then for strategy guides specific to my own faction, I watched videos from Cardboard Crash Course and Esser's Gaming Cave. And then I had to stop. At some point, you just have to trust that you've done all you can. and I'd already watched like three and a half to four hours of tutorial videos, not to mention the time I'd spent reading Board Game Geek threads and the actual rules themselves. One of the most gratifying moments was we were we were setting up for the game. It was right before we actually started playing, you know, so okay, the map set up. We had all agreed our host would set up a randomly generated map beforehand to save time.

And then we were all randomly assigned a slice of that map for our home world. And he did share an image with us. He's like, "Hey, I've seen the map. That would technically give me an advantage. You should all see what the map looks like. Here it is." And I was like, "This means nothing to me. It does not matter to me what this map looks like. This means I don't even know how I would begin to analyze this, but that's a side tangent." So, we're set up and someone asks just some small off-handed question about something. I don't even remember what it was, but I knew the answer. Like, I'm the one who answered the question. And suddenly I was like, "Oh, I do understand this." It felt really good. I was like, "Oh, also I found this player aid reference card and I put the image of it on my phone and I used it throughout the game. Absolute lifesavers." So, let's talk about how it felt to actually play the game. To start, we went around the table and everyone said a little bit about their faction and their special abilities, which I think you should probably always do, even if you've played the game a lot. Twilight Imperium has a million factions, especially if you're including the expansion. And it is not reasonable to expect players to know the details of all the factions they aren't playing. So, a quick briefing so no one is surprised by something that really should be knowable information is just good practice, I think.

Look, I don't know how typical the flow of our game was compared to most games of Twilight Imperium. This whole video is about how this was my first game. I have nothing to compare it to. I don't think there was anything wildly anomalous based on the reactions of the more experienced players at the table. But, you know, keep in mind that what I'm going to say about our game is just takeaways from my one experience. I think they could apply to your first game, or else why would I be talking about them? I mean, they certainly aren't going to be hard and fast rules, right? So, disclaimer done. So, it seems to me that whoever is sat to your left and your right, the factions with slices of the map closest to yours, are the most important in the early game. I think we were like halfway through our game before I felt like I really needed to start interacting more closely with the players across the map from me. I focused on understanding the goals of the players I was sat between, and that's who I made early deals and alliances with. You can't trade items in game with factions who don't have pieces adjacent to yours. And the people you're going to be adjacent to most quickly are the ones sat next to you. And I feel like this approach served me like pretty well. I think I think that makes sense.

Like focus on that to start. This is a game where you have to work together to make progress. So, it's important to feel out those vibes about when to be a team and you know when it's time to do something that screws over your former alliance because you got to do it to score a point and you need that point. You won't win without it. So, early game I made deals and I tried to sew some goodwill around the table. I didn't want to be a pushover, but I didn't want to look like too much of a threat. I'm just some gnomes riding on cats who want to explore space and find some relics, you know. Don't mind me. Don't pay any attention to me. I'm just going to go around. I'm gonna find a few relics. That's all. If you're nice to me, maybe I'll give you one. I think the first real deal I made was with the player on my left. We both wanted to move into the same system tile in the second round of the game, but neither of us wanted to be perceived as being aggressive toward the other one. It was way too early for that. So, we made a deal. We were just very open with each other. We're like, "Hey, I want to go there. I want to go there, too. Okay, how do we make this so it works for both of us?" So, I was going to move in first, get the card I needed, and then as soon as I had the actions to do it, I was going to move out so they could move in and take the planet for themselves. I ended up having to delay my exit slightly, which I think might have messed them up a little bit, but I did get out as soon as I could.

and I felt like I held up my end of the bargain and we both got what we wanted without needing to get into combat with each other or, you know, make an enemy with someone right next to us so early in the game. I really liked this style of negotiation in the game. It made me feel clever to be able to be so diplomatic and trustworthy, and it meant that later it might be easier for me to pull the rug out from under someone at the table if I needed to because, you know, they trusted me. I didn't ever really need to do that myself in this particular game. Maybe in future games when I'm being a bit smarter about things. It did happen to me. It did kind of happen to me. I did have the rug pulled out from under me just a little. And I acted pretty indignant when it happened. We'd made a deal. I'll do this for you now and then later you'll do XYZ for me. And when it came time for him to fulfill his end of the bargain, this is different. This is not the person sat to my left. They were across the table from me. When it came time to fulfill his end of the bargain, he said no, he wasn't going to. I was so shocked. I legit thought he was joking at first, but he was not. He was not joking. I mean, as much as it sucks, there is something fun about being betrayed in a game where you know that sort of thing is possible. And I'm not going to sit here and try and pretend like I didn't have a lot of fun being dramatic and playing up how offended I was at being betrayed. Like, it's one of my favorite moments from the game. Like how dare he? I will never forgive him.

Do you all know this concept of the magic circle? So the idea is when we play a game, we create a magic circle around the table where whatever we do here stays here. It's like Vegas. What happens at the gaming table stays at the gaming table. Well, I don't believe in that nonsense. You betray me in this game, I will never trust you in any other game we play together. It's not fair. But there are consequences to actions. Okay, but it was all in good fun. Obviously, I'm not actually mad at this person. It's part of the game. So, just remember that if the deal you're making with someone isn't immediately fulfilled, there is nothing guaranteeing that it will be when the time comes. Be prepared for that and be prepared to ultimately let it roll off your back, just like I've done. You know who you are, and I'm coming for you. While preparing for this video, I asked my patrons. You can support me on Patreon.

I asked my patrons if there was anything specific they'd be interested in knowing about my Twilight Imperium experience. And one thing that got brought up was being curious about how the negotiation feels compared to other games with negotiation. I think obviously the group you're playing with is going to have an effect on how trading and negotiating feels in any game. I mean, like some people are going to play Katan where you might as well not even bother trying to trade with them, right? like that's their choice and their style and they don't want to help anyone even if it could help them. And some people are super free and will trade with anyone. And that sort of vibe is going to apply to Twilight Imperium just like it does to any game. But something to keep in mind specifically with Twilight Imperium and this is true in some other games as well is that there are two kinds of negotiations happening. There are transactions and deals. I got to can't I can't I can't sit on this spot. Why sit on the floor during the video? She said it'll be so comfortable. She said, "Transactions involve an actual exchange of items and like I mentioned earlier, can only be done between players who are neighbors, which means you either both have units on the same system tile or adjacent tiles.

Transactions have to be done on your turn unless unless it's the agenda phase. While resolving each agenda, you can have a transaction with any other player, even if they're not your neighbor. Deals are just agreements like between two pals and may or may not involve an actual transaction. So a deal could be I won't attack you this round and you won't attack me and you can make that deal with anyone neighbor or not. But this isn't a lawless place where deals can be made and broken with no regard to rules or consequences. Officially some deals are binding and some deals as we saw earlier are not. If the deal can be resolved immediately, it is binding and you cannot back out of it. I can't like be like, "Cool, I'll give you two credits and you give me that relic card that you have," for example, and then I give over the credits. And then the person goes, "No, I'm not going to give you, haha, I fooled you. I'm not going to give you the relic." Like, you can't do that. If it can be resolved immediately, you must do what you agree to. If it isn't something that is resolved immediately like my deal with then it is officially nonbinding and you don't have to do it. So played the game exactly right when he stabbed me in the back in front of God and everyone. I like that the game makes this distinction and I like that there are really cut and dry negotiations as well as more like amorphous ones. It feels like politics and that's a big part of what this game is simulating and I think it does this really well.

So, all of this to say, be prepared to possibly have your negotiations and deals fall through or, you know, to be the person who does the falling them through, you know, just being being the bad guy. But also, be really prepared for shifting alliances. At the start of the game, you might be working with your neighbor, but like in the last round especially, all bets are off. People need to get to 10 points and if it means suddenly screwing you over, they're gonna do it. For example, we were a fairly low combat game. I think it ramped up toward the end of the game. It kind of has to because at some point everyone has moved into every system tile. So for you to make your way where you need to be to meet an objective, you're going to have to move through someone else's space.

And that automatically triggers a combat round whether the players involved want to or not. And you know, maybe part of your intrigue as a player is saying, "Oh my gosh, I really don't want to fight you, but I do have to move through here and we've got to roll dice because the rules say we have to." Oh no. When maybe actually you do kind of want to take out some of the units, but you don't want to seem like you're gunning for them. And I had this very funny experience of watching two different players kind of trading off coming to my defense in situations like this. Like when one was attacking me and then the other one would be like, "I'll help you in this fight." And then it swapped and the other one was attacking me and the other one was like, "I'll help you with this fight." And I was like, "Oh, it's so nice. They they want to be helping me in the situation where I'm being attacked.

They don't have to do that. They they must be sewing some goodwill or, you know, they know I'm not a threat to them and it behooves them to go after the other player who is more of a threat. Good. Yes. underestimate me, you know. But then, like I said, the next time combat happened, then the roles switched and the person who was defending me was now attacking me. And I was like, what? And truly, they weren't just being a jerk, right? They were just trying to fulfill a specific goal of one of their secret objectives, which involved removing a certain kind of unit from the board. in the first combat where they were coming to my defense was a shot at them fulfilling that goal, removing the other players, the attackers unit of that type. And when that didn't work, they switched and they tried to fulfill it by attacking me and removing my version of that unit from the board. It wasn't personal, but it did take me off guard. I will say that combat in general was part of the game I felt the least clear on when I finally was involved in a battle. It's the part of the game I needed the most handholding through by the other players and that to play again I would need to do the most studying up on, I think. And I think that's just because it has kind of a lot of steps.

They're not hard steps, but there's kind of a lot to go through. And until you've gone through those steps a few times yourself, they're just harder to remember and understand. So that's the only part of the game where I was like, "Oh, I really need help to make sure I'm like doing this right." As we got closer to someone hitting 10 points, the game got more confrontational just in general and teaming up and king making or king denying conversations seriously ramped up. Everyone started scheming because it looked like one player could hit 10 points one round sooner than the rest of us and we needed to figure out how to work together to extend the game and then immediately bail on everyone else so we could get the final winning points. Right. This is an interesting facet of the game for me. I mean, it's fun to scheme and have your heart pound because you know you're holding a secret objective that could get you that point you need to be in the running for the win. But three very specific things need to happen. And how do you make them happen? And is that player going to do the thing that's going to keep you from making one of the three things happen, right? Very stressful, but in that fun way. Like how horror movies are scary in a fun way because you're actually safe.

I imagine it's like that. I don't like horror movies, but I do like games that stress me out. The thing I kind of have mixed feelings about is the we all need to work together to stop this person from winning so that the game goes longer. Even if I'm losing, I'm not usually a fan of something that delays a win and makes a game go even longer. I get it in this case because you want your own chance to make that win happen for you, especially if you like feel it in reach. If you think it's actually possible that you could win, you just need one more round. And you know, you've already been here 9 hours. What's what's one more hour? But I always wonder like what if we're just delaying the inevitable for no reason? Like was that a waste? Was it a worthy endeavor? I don't know. I don't know.

I'd love to know. Let me know what you think. What do you think about that just in general? Not just in TI, you know? I'm cool. I call it TI now. Not just in Twilight Imperium, but in any game. Like, how do you feel about that? What I don't have mixed feelings about is that I held my own in this game. There was a world where it was possible for me to score the two points I needed in the last round to hit 10. It could have happened. It didn't. I did not win, but I was not out of the running. And that felt so cool for my very first game. Um, like 10 hours later, just got done. Honestly, I had a great time. All of my fears were unfounded. It was so fun. The light in my car is going out. I understand why people love this game. And I got to say, I got everything out of my first experience playing it that I hoped I would. It felt epic. And I stayed engaged pretty much the whole time. Like legit, I can't believe how quickly the time passed. I checked the clock in between each round and I was always shocked to see that like 2 hours had just gone by. That's a whole game of some other game. A few things that helped with it not feeling long, even when another player was spending enough time thinking that someone would suddenly like look up and go, "Wait, whose turn is it?" You know what I mean?

You know, you know what I'm talking about. Here are the things that helped. one, the snack table. We had a ton of snacks and drinks and in my downtime, I could get up and just like get a little something or, you know, go to the bathroom and not feel like I was holding people up. So, I used some of that downtime to like take care of my other needs. Two, I used the downtime to think about my turn and my plans and figure out how to try to set up what I was hoping to achieve. Three, it matters what other people do on their turns, where they're going, what they're exploring, who they're attacking, what actions they're taking. It matters. It matters. It affects you. I wanted to pay attention to what everyone else was doing because it ultimately was going to affect me and what I was going to be able to do. And when someone takes their strategy action, you get to do a secondary version of that action. So, that keeps you pretty busy, too. I don't know. I was just engaged the whole time.

Some of that's the game, some of that's me, and some of that is the group I was playing with keeping things moving and being just really fun. So yeah, for me it was worth it. All the work, all the prep, all the effort, and all the nerves were worth it. I would do this again. Maybe not more than once or twice a year, but as a sometimes like event. Yeah. Yeah. Give me more. But I wouldn't say yes to just any game of this that comes up. Context is important. It needs to be with a group who I know is going to be friendly while being competitive. They're going to be chill and not have too much analysis paralysis. People are going to get into it and have fun with the negotiations and politics of the game. It's an experience that for me requires trust in the group I'm playing with because ending up stuck in a game like this with other players you don't vibe with, that's a long 10 hours. So, if you've been wanting to try your first game of Twilight Imperium and you've got a group you feel good about spending 10 competitive hours with, do it. Dive in.

Have so much fun and let me know how it goes. I hope you found this video helpful or at least interesting, I guess. And I got to say thank you so so so much to Shay, John, Nick, AJ, and Joey for being so much fun to play with and being so nice to me for my first game. Thank you for watching. I hope you guys enjoyed it. Bye. Oh, also thank you so much to the sponsor of this video, the World Series of Board Gaming. They are all about friendly, competitive gaming. You can use my code on screen for a discount for your ticket. Watch this ad, find out more about the event, and check the details in the description below. Thanks, Realers of War Gaming.

Think you've got what it takes to compete for the ring and your share of $250,000? Well, get ready because signups for 2025 start now. Come for the friendly competition or open gaming community at WSBG. We've got it all. Are you the next big name in board gaming? Get your tickets now at wsgvgus.com and use the code I am in to save up to 35 bucks. So, what are you waiting for? It's time to get in the game.

Progress saved