Skip to main content
Loading video...

What are Stella Clark's Strengths and Weaknesses? (Arkham Horror: The Card Game)

Transcript 16:08

Hello everybody and welcome to another investigator strength and weakness video. We have done the Suzy episode, so now in theory every episode after this should be super easy until we roll Lola Hayes in this one. It's going to be absolutely notch nuts, sorry. Anyways, I'm here on my third favorite website arkham.build. I think we roll an investigator and see you which investigator we can we'll come up with two strengths and two weaknesses for today. Stella Clark, okay. Okay, the survivors are on the menu here. Stella Clark is a 3234 survivor investigator. As a reaction, after you fail a skill test, you may take an additional action during your turn this round to limit once per round. Elder sign effect plus one, you may instead choose to automatically fail this skill test to heal one damage and one horror. Soaks for eight on the health and eight on the sanity.

Her deck size is 30. Her She has survivor cards zero to five, neutral cards zero to five. She has three copies of neither rain nor snow, which is a skill card she can commit to basically nullify the downsides of the test if it fails. And then the the sorry, the called by the mist, which I believe deals her like some damage or horror when she when she takes a test with a difficulty four or higher, I believe. I'm not going to check that out too much because it's not it's not too much of a thing. Now, in Arkham strength and weaknesses here, I'd like to try to find some stuff that is kind of like uniquely related to that investigator in mind. Um Stella uh is a very interesting investigator because I think that she um

Fatality.

She [clears throat] is something that was very powerful for a very long time. And then I think as it went on, she just kind of started to get less and less support. Mostly because the fail stuff uh is hard to balance. This is something that I actually briefly was talking about yesterday with Daniel for a video on his channel, and I think it's very apt to kind of see it here, but this idea of winning while failing is a very risky line to walk when it comes to card design because failing should be scary, right? Like failing should be the thing that you don't want to do. And too many effects that say, "Hey, I'll give you this little cookie if you fail." Suddenly, you've gorged yourself on cookies and now nothing for the game really matters too much, right? So, I think that I'm going to actually just like I think this is a weakness that Stella Clark kind of shares with Mandy Thompson, right? We're we're going to just be like design space too dangerous, limits potential future growth. I sound like a [ __ ] capitalist pig right now.

Like I'm in a boardroom and I'm like, "Our design space here with Stella Clark is way too dangerous. I'm expecting we're going to see negative growth in the future because there's just not enough advanced investment for her in the long term." And I think that is actually kind of a big weakness for Stella Clark where I think that she was the best that she was ever going to be when her pack came out. And I think that she still is good and inherently playable and very easy to win a campaign with as most investigators are. Like I still think she's a solid A-tier investigator, right? But over time as legacy grows, there's going to be less of a reason to dig out Stella Clark because this fail stuff is going to be less impactful in the long term, right? Like the fail by space is just too risky to actually explore. By the way, Skellamunker, thank you so much for the sub. I appreciate it and I appreciate you.

I think that this is kind of the first big thing that I always think of for Stella Clark when it comes to her space in Arkham, right? Where if I look at her and I think about what is her biggest weakness, for me it's the fact that I see no room for future growth, right? I just think that she is the best that she was ever going to be. She got the best card that she could have got in the form of quick learner, and then after that it's kind of just not great. I'm going to go for the strength here. A perfect investigator for new players to learn the game. I think that this is a very obvious strength for Stella Clark. This was Eric's first investigator for the campaign that we played when Eric and I played Dunwich Legacy years and years and years ago at this point, which is kind of crazy to think about. That's kind of nuts, man. That's kind of nuts.

But uh Eric chose Stella, and Eric had a great time playing Stella. I think Stella is a perfect flexible investigator, and Stella's weakness does a really good job of mitigating some of the downside that new players are able to kind of really put into action in this. Like players don't like failing, and I say this in a lot of videos where new players don't necessarily enjoy the idea of um impacting the game in a negative way, right? Like they want to be able to sit down with someone who's play like especially when they play with someone who's played a lot of Arkham, they like to sit down and feel as if they are helping that person um get ahead of the game, right? Like they don't want to feel like dead weight. And I think Stella Clark does a really good job of mitigating that feeling for new players. Because yeah, I failed one of my actions, but I was hoping to fail. Or alternatively, I just failed during the mythos phase, and now I get to take four actions during my next turn, right? And I think that this is something that new players can really like latch onto and be like, I really want to work with this. Uh however, I I don't know if I'm going to put this as one of her weaknesses, but I'm going to consider it. It's the fact that she uh can sometimes teach bad habits for new players, right? Where you can rely too much on the fact that you can fail these tests. Um but I think that there is um there's not too many like This is going to sound a little maybe a little bit

absolute with a little bit too big of a period on this, but I do think that Stella Clark is um I actually lost what I was going to say. I'm just trying to think it's I'm trying to think about this. I don't think she necessarily teaches you anything about Arkham. Like I think she's a good flex, but I think that like she is she's good for new players to learn the game, but I actually don't know if she teaches you any like long-term applicable skills um for mastering Arkham. So, I think that I would love to start with Stella, but I would like then be like, okay, now you're going to try to play like an actual like I think like other survivors. Like I think like Wendy Adams does a better job in a similar space as just improving.

But I do think that Stella is a perfect investigator for like someone's first campaign. Survivors are harder to play because of their approach to playing Arkham. Like how they handle the problems that are put ahead of them, but four foot is a good number and the three fist and the two and then also the security of the being able to fail and still get ahead, I think is very relevant. Another strength for Stella Clark. I mean, it's just got to be her signatures, right? Sorry. Uh her signatures are bonkers. Just incredibly powerful signatures, right? Just absolutely nuts that they are just like and I you know what, let's even add like and she gets three of them.

Sorry. Let's Let's do some proper grammar in this video, right? Um but that's like I think one of the big things that people always point to as a reason why Stella is so powerful. I know it's something that Brin talks about a lot on the channel that it's just that ability to have three copies of her Neither Rain nor Snow, which is kind of just a ward of protection two in a lot of ways. I think that that's just That's just really good, right? Like that's just like a very powerful card to have three copies of. And also this was one of the first times where um uh it's It was It was the first time we saw the class specific signatures. Now this is something they're just doing like every investigator gets their uh signatures in the class, which I think is really nice to see.

Um but Stella was the only one and I mean obviously Nat Cho, Harvey Walters, Winifred, and Jacqueline also had theirs in their class, but they never did this before after until chapter two. So it was kind of more egregious with Stella where she got three copies of a survivor skill. And if there's one thing survivors love doing, it's recurring their skills, right? Like they have resourceful to dig it out. They have the um the three the three cost card where she is cooking over the fire. True is What's that card called? I know the art. Can't think of the name right now though. My brain's too loaded up with other garbage, but someone in chat will say it eventually. But like there were a lot of ways to recur her skills, which are just kind of True Survivor. Yes, thank you.

Um, was was just like uh too dangerous, right? And it was one of those things where it kind of felt like it was a little bit unfair that she was able to do this with her already powerful signatures. It was already a powerful investigator. She was at like her peak. Like she was at like the strongest point that she could have been and then um they just made this like extra little button where, oh my god, I can recur my if neither rain nor snow and then also do like two tests a turn at zero difficulty is kind of crazy. I do think that Stella was attempted attempted to kind of have some um a new archetype in the tested zero. I think that that was kind of intended to also be for Stella. Uh, I was no shadow light and exploit weakness, I think is the the kick the guy in the nuts card. Um, I think that those cards are very I mean, obviously shadow light is incredibly powerful card. But I think that was kind of the hope to give her a little bit more there um to kind of give her a new area. But again, I think that she's just hasn't seen much growth. So, I think she feels less egregious right now, but when she came out, her signatures were a big reason for why she just felt so so overpowered.

What's her other weakness? Hm. What is Stella Clark's other weakness? So, if I had to look at Stella, I think we're just going to kind of um I think we're going to we're going to go a little bit kind of like meta with this one. We're going to go like a little bit like big picture and I'm going to be like realistically Stella only has one deck. And this is where we're talking about like how it kind of relates to the design space being too dangerous, right? Where I want everybody to picture a Stella deck in your head.

And I want you to not lie and tell me if it has quick learner in it, two copies. Cuz I'm going to wager that 95% of people are playing Stella with quick learner. It's just too pivotal to her game plan, right? It's just like too free, right? And it's just like one of those things where Yeah, quick learner drawing thin rabbit's foot three. Yeah, you know. Um Yeah, just two permanent Daniels. Yes.

It's like one of those things where I I think that there should be a knock on this for Stella. I think that it's okay if some investigators have cards that are kind of like foundational to them, right? I'm thinking like Daisy Walker with Grim Memoir or Old Book of Lore. Like these are cards that are just really good. But I think that ultimately quick learner is too warping of a card for there to be um uh a healthy area to explore everything around it. I think a similar card is well connected three. I think well connected is also realistically limiting the amount of build around it. And it's actually just like I'm going to hold a bunch of money and just pass tests, right? And I think quick learner is a big reason why people don't They'll play Stella once or twice, but I never you never really bring her out after that.

I I'm also okay that yeah, I I think that most of this the starter deck investigators are kind of limited in scope in terms of what they can do. Like Nat Cho, I think Nat Cho also realistically only has one deck. Like I think Harvey doesn't because card that like if you have a card if your ability just says draw a card, you can get out of it. I think Winifred is probably one of the most open investigators in the game. And I think Jacqueline is also open, but because she has that mystic baggage, she's also pretty closed. And I think it's okay for the starter deck investigators to have a smaller scope for how they go. But I do think that I do think that there is an issue with Stella because of that. If we had to look at one of her weaknesses, right? And I don't think like weaknesses generally they don't necessarily mean bad. Like it's not like a negative thing in the long run. I just like if you look at it in the in the broad picture on all of my patron game days, in every patron game day I've played, I don't think anyone has ever played Stella Clark. The times that I've seen Quick Learner, people try to build interesting decks around it, but they're not bringing Stella Clark to the picture.

Um I think that Stella is a fun investigator to play the first time you play her because it feels very powerful to kind of like just turn the game on its head. I think she's a perfect investigator for new players to play the game, but I think in the long terms and in terms of the exciting build around decks, I feel like Stella Clark kind of is lacking a little bit of spice there. Um So I think it's just one of those things where it's she's a cool investigator. I think that she was uh I think she's in a better place power level now than she was when she first came out. Um but with all that said, um I think that ultimately her weaknesses are making it very hard for her to grow as an investigator in the long term. And I think that that's unfortunate for Stella Clark because I think she does have a lot of cool stuff going for her. Also survivor investigators, I'm going to just say this.

Um Uh stop giving survivor investigators 8/8. Don't give survivor investigators eight health and eight sanity. They do not need it. Stop giving it to them.

Do not give survivors eight health and eight horror. They do not need it. Miguel has the exact same stat line, too. Yes, it's crazy. It It should not happen. It's too high for survivors. Make them 9/9. Yeah, that's fine. Let's just run it like that. Thanks for watching, everybody. I hope you enjoyed this investigator strengths and weaknesses. Who are we going to roll next week? I don't know, but I'm excited to see. Thanks for watching, everybody. Have a good one. And as always, all GG's.

Progress saved