Are Too Many Wargames FRACTURING Wargaming?
Transcript
in this video I'll respond to some YouTube comments about how there are too many games fracturing the war games Market I was surprised to learn recently that some folks want fewer War Games to me this is an odd concept but it was undeniable in the comments from a few of my recent videos mainly about the future of wargaming from like last week and the video about the huge success of the trench Crusade Kickstarter last month there were some interesting comments from viewers saying they believe there are too many games out right now and yes many of the comments seem to imply that we should all just play Warhammer from one comment the problem with democratizing games and leaving them outside of a central Authority uh is that it could lead to more disperate and insular communities now frankly I find the concept of a central Authority in war gaming I guess it's like a group who says what war games are legal I don't know I I find that pretty silly I've met many many War Gamers over the years and as you might have as well and one thing that we all have in common is that we can disagree on a lot of wargaming related things pretty easily
from another comment my only concern with the rise of these Indie War Games is that I think many of them will suffer from the fragmentary market they're creating seems like every week I learn about a new war game that sounds like a blast but that many cool options means it's a long shot to find someone to play it with unless you print off more than one faction and invite a friend to play as it turns out that is exactly the point of these types of kind of complete package war games that I was talking about last week pachow and it's something that they're really good at and another comment so many games so many minis the way things are going everyone will be publishing their own rules and designing their own minis so every company will just have one customer I mean I think that this is factious right but the commenter seems to potentially believe that making games and making Minis is a lot easier than it actually is now it's true that it is easier than ever before to get your games and minis sold worldwide you know due to digital distribution and all that but good ideas and execution are still pretty difficult also in the trench Crusade video there were plenty of folks who commented that trench Crusade would never beat Warhammer and stuff like that which I'm pretty sure the creators of trench Crusade hadn't set out to actually do you know beat Warhammer I
see comments like that whenever I post videos about indie games so I'm not really paying attention to those comments here those comments are a symptom of disliking other people's wargaming choices I made a video about that a long time ago pachow and you know it's all basically related to fear as to the first comment I can concede that if we all played the exact same game not even just like games from a single company but just a single game made by that company then it might be easier to find people to play with except that it really wouldn't because the wargaming industry would be dead even if that one single game decreed by the central Authority was Warhammer 40,000 arguably the most popular war game to date the wargaming industry including 40K would have crumbled some time ago markets require Choice the wargaming industry is healthy and you can easily see this besides just you know increasing revenues across the board every war gaming convention I go to every year like the Las Vegas open adepticon Nova open and others all of them are growing in attendance year after year and while many of the people attending these conventions are there to play Games Workshop properties there's also a lot of people there to play other games from other companies and if those companies and those games didn't exist many of those people probably wouldn't attend
it's anecdotal but here you go if Warhammer 40K was the only game out there available you know so that we were all on the same page or whatever I wouldn't be in this hobby today I started War gaming with BattleTech back in middle school which I've mentioned in the past so without that I wouldn't have had that first experience at that time cuz BattleTech wouldn't exist later on in college I was introduced to spacehulk which is where I first heard about Warhammer and such now space Hulk is technically not 40K so again that might not exist either right but if it did let's say then that would have been my first wargaming experience in the early 90s then I would have finally been able to afford Warhammer 40K actual 40K not something like space Hulk in like the mid 2000s which is when I started and if Warhammer 40K was my only choice for wargaming then I would have gotten out of the hobby if it was just 40K in the mid 2010s right about the time of sth Edition I really hated sth Edition and completely stopped playing 40K at that time now instead I got into all kinds of other games like malao and Star Wars X-Wing and Flames of war and even the first edition of age of Sigmar because I was able to stay in the hobby without playing Warhammer 40K I was still around to start playing again when eighth edition 40K launched lat later on having Choice makes the overall wargaming industry stronger the pool of overall
War Gamers would be considerably smaller if they all had to play just one game because if you don't like that game you'd leave right and if that pool was smaller then all the secondary Hobby companies like paint companies brush companies uh other hobby supplies dice companies terrain makers Etc would also have fewer people to sell to and they wouldn't make as many new cool products and all that kind of stuff it's kind of the point of a market economy as to the second comment about so many Indie War Games fragmenting the market which I kind of answered some of that in the in the first response and how many of them require you to produce like two sets of figures so you can teach others as they say in Tech that's not a bug it's a feature one of the great things about smaller skirmish games that I've been telling people about for years is that they're way easier to teach other people not because the rules are intrinsically easier but because it's easier to build and paint and carry around two Skirmish forces so that you can use them to teach people army scale games by their nature require a lot of models for each player it's hard to teach a person how to play 40K if you have to supply both forces so you can teach God forbid they're 2,000 Point forces right like this is mainly why Games Workshop made combat Patrol for 40K smaller forces that are allinclusive in the Box and make it easier to kind of learn the big game that said you're still going to spend around $340 retail if you want to buy
two combat patrols for teaching not to mention the building and the painting usually of 20 to 30 models for each side it's a really big ask however smaller skirmish games can not only be cheaper here's seven different two-player starters under a 100 bucks each pachow but also quicker to build and paint due to low model count also a newer player can find an easier time understanding a smaller Skirmish game in comparison to a big army scale game do not to the rules but just to fewer units to control and all that kind of stuff which will help them to learn and also hopefully enjoy the game more early on so if you have a person to teach then these complete package indie games are doing exactly what they're supposed to and for the the last comment that I mentioned at the beginning of the video about uh everyone making games and sculpting Minis and eventually all these companies will only have like one customer each well again that's not how market economy Works look at the music industry Taylor Swift is huge right but other folks still keep making music why do they do that will they eventually beat Tay Tay signs point to know but some of them will still make great money right to spend on like gold jewelry and face tattoos and whatnot and others will make enough like to pay off their house and their car and that's also pretty cool to them and others yet will just enjoy the act of creating music because they enjoy the ACT if they
make a little bit of money then that's just icing on the cake but the main goal was to make the music and hope someone likes it War gaming is the same way most folks make their Indie war games and minis with no expectation of making it into the next Warhammer they just hope that some people like you know play it and enjoy it and stuff like that I'm proud to say that some people have enjoyed the Indie War gamings that Vince and I have made and we've even made it a bit worth our while too but we're not beating GW that said weirder things have happened I mean like it's not going not me and Vince but you know I've been going to Gen Con right the biggest tabletop gaming convention in the United States since 1992 I have a distinct memory of walking by a tiny 10t X 10ft Booth one year in the early '90s '92 93 94 somewhere in there and thinking that the company in that Booth had the dumbest company name that I had ever heard of Wizards of the Coast within that same decade uh Wizards of the Coast bought TSR the company that owned the massive Dungeons and Dragons game and also bought Gen Con because it was owned by TSR and it came in the deal at buying TSR all of that just because of Magic the Gathering so hopefully you'll understand that more war games and more Miniatures are better for the wargaming hobby not worse right like and it's the same with board games and role playing games and collectible card games
right and outside of tabletop games is there just one video game company no there's not uh just one computer company or smartphone company also no most people like having Choice even if they don't actually act on that choice sometimes and just keep playing the same thing if your main concern is finding a random person to play with at your local shop or Club when you walk in with your army then your choice might be made for you but that's not everybody's choice if Warhammer 40,000 was the only war game Allowed by the central Authority would you have already stopped wargaming do you think that any wargaming company that can't immediately overtake A Game's Workshop should just give up and shut her down does the amount of choice that wargaming provides in this day and age keep you in the hobby or drive you away let us all know what you think down in the comments below and while you're down there you can engage depress mation of the like button and or the Subscribe button your choice do them both or you know whatever both are pretty great they both help the channel and uh as always thanks for watching hey