Merchants Of The Dark Road Overview & Review | Is it a game for you?
Transcript
the lanterns may fade but the coins still shine the coin the singular coin still shines
hey friends it is jenna what is up and welcome back to the board game garden we are trying out a new mic today so let me know down in the comments if it sounds better if it doesn't sound better i just do not want to sound like i am in a tin can which a few people have commented on past videos that i sound like i'm in a tin can so does it sound like that anymore let me know but today we are going to be doing another review i've only done one other and this is going to be my second one and we are doing it on merchants of the dark road this is published by elf creek games designed by brian sewer and illustrated by andrew bosley andrew bosley has done some amazing amazing art in some other games such as everdell and a new game coming out is flow which i'm very excited about um but merchants of the dark road is one that we have just gotten pretty recently i would say within the last one to two months and we've played it quite a few times and i really want to talk about merchants of the dark road because i find that it has a lot of back and forth with if people like it or they don't like it and i really wanted to give my opinion on it chat about it a little bit so we are going to be reviewing merchants of the dark road today um we are going to do a little bit of an overview as well so i'm going to put that video clip in here of just me explaining how the game plays and just all of those things it's not a full how
to play just an overview of the gameplay so you can kind of get a feel of how it plays what it looks like and all of that so without further ado let's head to the table we're already at the table but let's look at the table from a different angle and see how merchants of the dark road place after half a year of daylight we must now prepare for the dark season the roads will be treacherous but they will still need to be braved by a select few in order to keep our cities thriving you are one of these brave few merchants that travel the dangerous paths between cities while the job is perilous fame and fortune await in merchants of the dark road you'll be traveling around a rondelle purchasing and selling goods accepting queen's commissions picking up heroes traveling to cities and much much more the goal of the game is to be the player with the most victory points at the end of the game the challenge is is that the victory points are made up of either your total money or prestige whichever of these two you have the least of creates the base of your victory points so it's important throughout the game to keep your money and prestige balance the main way to get money in the game is by selling goods to heroes each hero will have three goods that they are wanting to purchase and you can sell one to three of those goods to that hero to get as much money as you can what the hero will pay is always based off of the current market price from the market wheel so it's always good to try and sell the more lucrative goods and on the opposite side of the
coin the main way to get prestige is by accepting queen's commissions and dropping those commissions off with the goods needed to the corresponding city additionally you will receive a deed at the beginning of the game and have other chances to get more deeds throughout the game and these are personal objectives that will allow you to add more to your final victory points now that you know the main way of getting money and prestige and the goal of the game let's take a trip around the rondelle to take a look at all the locations the first location is the great bazaar this is the market and the main way of purchasing goods that you sell to heroes as well as used to complete queen's commissions players will have a chance to turn the market wheel once move a die to another good and purchase as many goods as they would like at the current market price next up is the queen's commission players will be able to accept a queen's commission from one of the six cities and in order to finish that commission players will need to collect one to three of the goods needed for that commission and drop it off at the correct city depending on how many goods were dropped off the player will gain three six or nine prestige moving on to the third location that is yerg's excursion this is compiled of both the ruins of yin and travel which we're not going to get too much into travel but this is where players will have the opportunity to travel to different cities whether that is traveling themselves or with another player and being able to drop off heroes and drop off queens commissions players can also choose to
go to the ruins of yin and this is a great place to get upgraded goods upgraded goods will get you more points and helpful items when selling them to heroes next up is the dark market this is another great way to get goods to use for heroes and queens commissions and you can also get additional deeds and additional commissions here as well and lastly we have the ringway inn this is where players can sell goods to heroes based on the current market price once the player sells to a hero the hero will join them give them a reward and need to be dropped off at their stated city for additional money or prestige depending on the city that they are dropped off in so that is everything for the main board aside from the four additional buildings that are added at the beginning of the game but now that we are finished with that let's talk quickly about the player boards these are the players wagons which has room for the player's steed which is a card that you get at the beginning of the game that gives you a unique power it also has room for the player's goods which must fit in the space given their lanterns for travel the horseshoes that allow the player to move forward one additional time or backwards blazing courts which allow players to use companion's abilities which companions are acquired while traveling as well as the player's dice the dice will determine the amount of steps taken on the rondelle as well as determining which action or actions can be done on the player's turn on a player's turn they will choose to move one of the three die up that number will
then determine how many steps that player can take and represent the one action that they can take on one of the adjacent locations and the space that they end up in for example this player could either take the queen's commission or jurg's excursion the die moved also activates a bonus depending on the space the die was in left gets the player a good right gets the player two coins or allows them to move the market wheel once and the middle gets the player a lantern or allows them to use their illuminated die an illuminated die will allow the player to do a second action either in the adjacent location or at the building adjacent to them the building placed on the board will be changed to game to game and can only be activated with an illuminated die and that's it that is everything for the overview of merchants of the dark road so that is a little overview or actually a pretty big overview of how merchants of the dark road plays i didn't want to do a full on how to play but i did want to do a pretty good overview just so you guys can see how the gameplay is what it looks like and all of that um like i said i did leave out some of like the smaller stuff which i'm sure you could find in other videos here on youtube if with this review you end up wanting to pick up merchants of the dark road um you know there are a ton of how to plays out there so you can go check those out but let's get into my review of merchants of the dark road if this is your first review on my channel that you're watching i've only done one other one but i really want to start doing more reviews here and i really love a
good structured review so i have five categories that we're going to be going through first one is theme second one is gameplay third is what's third replayability or art fourth is replayability or art and then fifth is difficulties so what the difficulty is who should be playing this all of those things so without further ado if you guys want to hear all five of those categories then just keep on watching and let's get into my review of merchants of the dark road so the first category that we're chatting about is a theme and typically i just talk about how the theme is integrated into the gameplay and just how much i like the theme if it's a unique theme if it's been done before that sort of thing so merchants of the dark road is overall a merchant's theme you are purchasing goods you are selling goods and i'm not gonna lie that theme is pretty done already in a lot of other games it's not some sort of mind-blowing theme that i've never heard of before it is something that you might already have in your collection but we personally don't have a lot of like merchants buying and selling goods type of games so i really enjoy that um but i'm sure that other people do and i think what makes this game more unique is the mechanics within the gameplay which we will get to in a second but
for the theme it's not anything mind-blowing it's not anything super unique it's been done before but like i said the mechanics of the merchant's theme is kind of what i see as more unique in this game now as for the theme being integrated into the gameplay i feel like it's pretty good it's not like spectacular you are just going around a rondelle and doing actions but i feel like the market constantly changing all of the goods prices are constantly changing that's pretty thematic and the fact that you have to really focus on the timing in the game in order to get as much money as you possibly can with the constantly changing market i feel like that's a really good thematic aspect of the game also when you're hitching a ride with someone to go to a city there's that little risk of something bad happening on your travels i find that that's very thematic so overall the theme is pretty good it's not like absolutely amazing there's like not a ton of thematic um integrations in the game it's overall just like a move and do actions but there are a few different aspects within the game that i find very thematic so that is everything for theme let me know what you think about the theme of this game if you enjoy it but that is everything for theme next up we are moving into gameplay so moving into gameplay i would say that the gameplay in merchants of the dark road i overall really enjoy i am a huge lover of really
cool dice mechanisms so in this one you are moving dice in order to do different actions as well as determining how many moves around the rondelle you take and speaking of rondelle i really do enjoy rondelle's as well um the rondelle in merchants of the dark road is not the hugest rondelle i'm pretty sure there's only five spots so i feel like the rondelle could get a little bit repetitive but when you are moving to spaces you then have two different options the two different adjacent locations sometimes even a third if you have your illuminated dies so you know there's always different actions that you're taking on each of those five different rondelles so it doesn't get too repetitive but i can see someone you know starting to think that it would be a little bit repetitive now the one main negative part of merchants of the dark road which i don't really know if this is a huge negative it's not really a huge negative in my personal opinion but i can see people um thinking that this is a pretty big negative for them and something that makes them not want to purchase merchants of the dark road and that is that i find that some things within the game you don't get to experience um there are a lot of different things that you can do there's a lot of different locations but i find that you end up not having enough time to do all of the things like the ruins of yin i think we've played this upwards of four or five times and i have never
done the ruins of yin and the ruins of vietnam is a great way to get upgraded goods which then gets you more money which then gets you the blazing quartz so i feel like it'd be a good thing to try and do but i just find myself never having enough moves i always find myself you know finding different things that are more important like picking up uh heroes and doing queens commissions and purchasing from the great bazaar and there's just other things that i find i'm doing over the other things if that makes sense so um that is one thing and i really wish that i could experience those because i think it'd be a lot of fun and much like that i find that the illuminated die are very difficult to acquire which then you can't really experience the four random locations that you add to the board you start with one eliminated die at the beginning of the game and i've found when i've played merchants at the dark road that is usually the only illuminated die that i use throughout the entire game um the ways that you get illuminated die after the first one because with illuminated dies i don't know if i mentioned this in the overview but when you use an illuminated die that gets taken out of the game and the only way to get one back is you either take one as a reward for traveling yourself which if you travel alongside someone else if you like hit a ride with another player you don't get rewarded it's only the player that initiates the travel
gets rewarded um so you can get one from there and then you can also get one from using a blazing quartz on some certain companions so it's a little bit difficult i find when i'm wanting to get a reward from traveling myself which honestly throughout the game you don't really travel yourself as much as you want to i find myself trying to hitch rides with other players more than i'm traveling myself obviously you could try to travel more yourself if you wanted to but i find when i do that the rewards that i want to take are the wagon upgrades which granted you can only have one wagon upgrade unless you have a particular steed um and then i also enjoy getting like the extra coins if i happen to have a little bit less coins than my prestige so there's always like another thing that i want to get before the illuminated die and those ones can be really really helpful because those allow you to access all of those buildings um so i just don't find it happening as much as i want it to and i really want to get use of those buildings because there's so many great abilities on them so i just wish that the illuminated dies were just a little bit easier to acquire um but yeah that's just like one negative it's just i wish i could experience more on the board when playing the game but we'll get a little bit more to that with replayability and stuff in a second so overall i really really enjoy the
gameplay of merchants of the dark road i am a huge fan of playing games that you can get better at and try to beat your last score and just try to strategize more there's a lot of different strategy kind of routes that you can take within merchants of the dark road you can try different things so overall i really enjoy the gameplay so does francis he really enjoys this one we've played it a few times at two player and then we've played it only once at four player and i do think i really enjoyed it at four player i think it gives you more of an opportunity to travel with other people um usually with the two-player game like if francis is traveling i'm most of the time gonna want to travel with him because you don't get as many opportunities to deliver the heroes and deliver the commission so it's nice with a four-player game to have more opportunities to go to different places again with that comes you know a little bit of risk when it comes to the bad things happening with the travel die but overall the travel die bad things aren't horrible most of the time you just lose a few coins or you lose one good or whatever so they're not horrible but i really enjoyed the four player game but at the same time really enjoyed the two-player game as well and there is a solo variant which i really do want to try so i might do that in the future and i will let you guys know how that is i've heard a lot of good things about the solo variant so
overall good gameplay a few negatives that i can see some people finding some larger issues with than me personally but overall the gameplay is really good now moving on to replayability so the replayability in merchants of the dark road is good i would say it's like you know it's decent it's not absolutely fantastic but it's good i feel like the the mixture of what steed you get at the beginning of the game what deeds you get um you get one at the beginning of the game but you can get more as the game goes on which ones you like have to choose from as well as like what commissions are out which heroes are out what companions you end up picking out when you go traveling a mixture of all of those things can make the game feel pretty different it allows you to be going for different things throughout the game but i will say that overall generally the gameplay is always going to be the same from game to game i personally am okay with that i have enough variation with all of those different smaller things that i find that when playing merchants of the dark road every game feels pretty different you're going for different things but i do know that typically when the gameplay is the same some people find that too repetitive and they don't really like that so i just wanted to say that within the replayability section i
will say though like i mentioned in the gameplay there has been a few things in the game that i haven't really experienced like i haven't gone to the ruins of yin which can be pretty important because that is your main way of getting upgraded goods and upgraded goods can then get you more money as well as blazing quartz which blazing quartz is a great way to get more things more illuminated dye which then gets you more actions so there's a lot of good things when it comes to going to the ruins of yin and i haven't even like explored that part of the game so there's that when it comes to replayability is just trying different strategies um there's also you know a possibility of kind of screwing over your opponents a little bit by you know working on changing the market a little bit more i haven't even thought of doing that so there's a lot of different strategies that you can kind of go into in order to make the replayability a little bit better and make the game a little bit different from game to game so there's that going for it as well so overall the replayability to me personally is pretty good but i can see some people saying that it is a little bit repetitive um when it comes to the core gameplay so that is replayability let's move on to art and components so in my last review for this section i only talked about art because that game that i was talking about was bark avenue and that was a
prototype so i didn't want to talk about components because obviously it wasn't the final product and if i talked about the components it'd be completely unfair so because merchants oh my god punching it off the table because merchants is a fully finished game i wanted to chat about the components also the one thing that i really really really love about merchants of the dark road is the components and the art so i really wanted to talk about that i feel like the art and the components in merchants of the dark road is one of the number one things that it has going for it and i'm okay saying that because me personally art and components in a game is up there with gameplay like if a game is like the game place you know pretty good but the art is fantastic the gameplay for me is going to go up as well because personally for me having the game look good on the table and just feel good like with the tactile elements if it has that going for it then i'm going to enjoy the gameplay even more and merchants of the dark road is absolutely fantastic the dice and the components i only have the retail version as well which is crazy because you have so many options for upgrading the components they have upgraded um like lanterns and blazing quartz and they also have upgraded coins they have the like coin
bags as well dual layer boards um there's also an expansion that i haven't even um dived into dovan open into is that the right word i don't know english was never my strong student in high school just saying but it's crazy to me that this game sitting in front of me is just the retail version and some people have an even more deluxified edition i think frances and i enjoy this game enough that we are thinking about maybe um trying to get some of the deluxified components because it's just oh it's just so good all of the components and stuff that you can add to this game just will make it even better um so overall art and components for merchants of the dark road is absolutely fantastic if you are a big art person andrew bosley has done an amazing job with the style of this game and the art i just love the the vibes of this game um and then also the components again are just absolutely fantastic and makes this game so good in in my opinion personally so that is everything for art and components lastly we are moving into difficulty so lastly we are moving on to difficulty in the bark avenue review i referred to this section as weight but i kind of changed it to difficulty just to make it a little bit easier for newer gamers in the hobby to understand because some people might not know that weight is not like the weight of the game but the weight of how difficult the
gameplay is so this section will be called difficulty and i also want to chat about like what types not what types but what skill level of a gamer this game would be good for so when it comes to difficulty i believe this game is on board game geek um they have a range from one to five of difficulty five being the most difficult one being the easiest i guess it's from zero to five but zero being the easiest this is a 3.14 on board game geek so i would say it's pretty much in the middle a slight bit more towards the most difficult so i would say that this is a what i refer to as a next step game um this is a good game for people that have recently got into the hobby they have played quite a bit of games but they're looking for that next game to just add a little bit more challenge and a little bit more difficulty a few more things to think about throughout gameplay this is a great one for you i feel like it would be a little bit difficult for new gamers for sure just because there are so many small little rules that you really have to pay attention to as well as the iconography in this game is pretty insane they have a whole page of a bunch of different icons um i would say that we still to this day after playing this like four or five times we still have to go back and read those small little rules or look at the iconography page
just to make sure we know what a certain card is saying or what one part of the board is saying so i would say that this is a good one for those gamers that have already played some games that are looking for a game that's just a little bit more difficult with a little bit more to think about so that is the difficulty of merchants of the dark road but at the same time if you are a seasoned gamer you've been in the hobby for a while this is still a really really good game with like i said in the gameplay still a lot of like different strategic routes you can take so yes that is difficulty and that is everything for my review so that is everything that i wanted to chat about about merchants of the dark road overall i really personally enjoy merchants of the dark road i did mention some of the negative aspects and i feel like the longer that we do own merchants of the dark road some of those negative things might eventually be a little bit worse um especially the replayability maybe if we end up playing this quite a bit throughout the next like three years it might be a game that you know we're kind of sick of playing but for now i feel like it is such a fantastic game again like i said i really want to look into maybe getting some of the upgraded components because that's such a big part of gaming for me um as well as looking into the expansion i would love to maybe show you guys some of the expansion in the future and see if that brings more to the table when it comes to merchants of the dark road but
like i said overall this is a big thumbs up for me i love merchants of the dark road um it's great two-player it's great for player like i mentioned i still want to try the solo gameplay which we will see if i end up doing that on a solo sunday over on my twitch which if you guys do not know francis and i stream board games over on twitch it's just the board game garden same name is here and we do two player games on tuesdays two some tuesdays and then i also try to do um solo games on sunday for solo sunday so if you guys want to go check that out i definitely recommend we also have a discord which i don't know why i'm like now just saying all these things but i would really love to have an awesome little community over there on discord chat about board games more we also have a little bit of like video games over there as well because i used to stream video games on twitch as well but if you want to join the discord you're welcome to i'd love to chat about board games more over there with you guys um but yes that is everything for the review hopefully you guys enjoyed and hopefully you got a little bit of help when it comes to choosing if this is a game for you i'm really trying to make my reviews very unbiased personally i really enjoy this game but i did want to make people aware of the slight negatives might be more negative to you than it is to me but i really want to talk about games as unbiased not biased as unbiased as possible and just really make it so that you guys are able to
make a decision um when it comes to your taste and if you would feel like you'd like the game so hopefully i did a good job with that let me know your feedback down below i love you guys so much remember you are somebody's reason to smile and i will see you guys in the next board game video bye friends you