Sandcastles Review: Quick Take with Tom Vasel
Transcript
Sand Castles is a relaxing day at the beach where you build sand castles, something which I've never been able to do. Our sand castles always fall over and collapse, but I digress. In this game, it's a tile drafting game where you build a sand castle and score points in a lot of different ways. Here's how it plays. In Sand Castles, there is a lot of tiles that come with this game, and each round of the game, the starting player is going to change, and that person is going to take tiles equal to the number of players in the game. So, let's say we're playing a five-player game. I then turn over this tile. Do I want to keep it? Nah, I don't want to keep it. So, I give it to the next person. They say, "You know what? I'll keep it." Great, they're out of this round. I draw another tile. I'm like, "I don't want to keep that one." Pass it to the third player. They don't want it. Pass it to the fourth player. They don't want it. Fifth player, they don't got a choice. They have to take it cuz everyone's getting a tile. I look at the next one. I'm like, "I don't want that one." The third player wants it. So, now just me or second the then me and the fourth player. I turn this over and I go, "Nah, I don't want that one either." So, now I have to take the last one. All right, so I take this tile. Players are building a They can build up to a 5 by 5 grid, and when you take a tile, it's kind of like Tetris.
You just drop it and it lands somewhere. You can't rotate them. This is not allowed. The only exception is sky tiles. You put them at the very top of a column. You can have up to five of them, and then they won't fall down until the very end of the game. You're going to score at the end of the game for various things. Seashells are worth a point. Shovels are worth two. Buckets are worth three points. Birds in the sky are going to be worth points equal to the number of birds that you have. You're also going to get points for starfish if they're next to each other. And that's pretty much it. You're going to add up all those points. Oh, wait, I forgot windows. So, you'll notice there's a lot of windows in here, and each row windows, you're going to look and see how many windows are in that row, and then that's how many points you get per row.
And you're going to keep track of everything on this score sheet, which has one slot for windows. Ah, we'll come to that in a minute. So, Sand Castles is a fun game. I like the idea of drafting resources. I'll take the resource and I decide to keep it or pass it to the next person. That's really good. It's not so much fun being last because as soon as a tile gets sent to you, that's the tile you're getting. But you're not always last. You're going to be first at some point. And so, I find there to be some interesting decisions in that regard. It's a fun little way to do drafting. And then the scoring. Do you want to go for points? Do you want to put starfish next to each other? Seagulls in the sky? Have lots of windows? Cool. But I got to dock this game a whole point. So, I'm giving Sand Castles a seven. But it would have been higher except the scoring sheet. I'm not sure who designed the scoring sheet. There's two major problems with the scoring sheet. The first one is at the top of the scoring sheet, it's players one through six.
And then up here, player one is this person and you put their names. Why? You couldn't put their names right up here at the top? It's just a weird thing. That's just a weirdity. But even more important is the windows. I already mentioned that. You are scoring each windows separately. And so, uh I'll have to look at the windows and say, "How many do you have in a row?" And you count. I have 10. I'm like, "Okay, 10 is two points." But there's only one spot for windows. So, I have to count two points. Okay, your next row. How many do you have? 14. That's four points. 1 2 3 4. So, now I have six points. That's such an unelegant way to do it. Why not have a line here for each row of windows or some way to more easily denote that or just taking point tokens or something? So, I like the game a lot, but I find that that score sheet is a pain in the neck and it slows down the ending of the game to the point where some people that I I taught the game to and played it, they really complained about that aspect. But everyone liked everything else about it. Putting the Sand Castle gear is kind of neat and interesting.
So, I still enjoy it. I just wish it had a better score sheet. So, seven out of 10, Sand Castles.
Mhm.