Skip to main content
Loading video...

Grimcoven Review — Roguelite Bloodborne Boss Battler!

Transcript 1:06:01

We played the prototype. Now we're here for the real deal. This is Bloodborne, the board game. I mean, basically, it's like a boss battler set in the Bloodborne universe. Grim Coven has you playing as hunters of the Grim Coven. A pact you signed in blood to kill big bad bosses, aka called grief bounds, cuz they look really sad and are angry. While you fight them, fight smaller enemies, and walk around the board, you will gather lament, which are like their souls, and you will get stronger, but that also means you're getting more corrupted. So, you're playing a rog light inspired progression of expanding your build of which you can assign your rounds dice to differently. There is a huge game here with six bosses without unlocking anything and six hunters. And so, all my plays on screen are here over there. It's it's not that many, but this game is long. Game is for one to five players and I played it mostly solo while doing some research on multiplayer. And yeah, sure, the game is about 2 hours, but with these games, you got to know that sometimes it can run a little shorter or way longer, just depending on what scope of scenario you have. But this is not a campaign game, rather a bunch of independent boss fights. So, there's no campaign to talk about. So, there are some slight unlockables. And this video will be spoiling this secret deck a decent amount. I mean, I won't go into detail about how to unlock things, but yeah, we're going to be uncovering some of these cards. So, I don't think it really matters, people, but you have been warned. Also, full disclosure, we received this boss pledge from Awakened Realms a long time ago, just cuz they didn't tell us what to do with it. So, you guys have been asking me constantly for a review, as this box has shown up in the background in other videos. So, here's the video. I end up using about

half of the stuff we were given. So, besides the core game, we're using some of the acrylic and terrain pack, talking about personal stories a bit, but not talking about the additional bosses or hunters. As always, we never compromise scoring here at Shelfside. And man, this one was a big one. So, thank you to our patrons over here for making videos like this possible. Yeah, man. These these these ones are a doozy. Um, yeah, also our Mad Lad scoreboard. Thank you guys so much. Just really help us just keep going forward and making more stuff for you. Okay, so if you're ready, I I think I'm ready. So, let's go into some edgy dark lord big boss hunting. How to play. Goal is to kill the big bad you've chosen for your session, aka a hunt. Again, these bosses are called the griefbound. And I'll use boss and griefbound interchangeably throughout this video. So, got it. Boss equal griefbound. Griefbound equal boss. To kill this thing, you want to kill its attack card, which will each have a certain amount of HP. And when you've killed all but two of them, the final attack will come out. Once you kill that, you win. That'll be its own finale, which we'll explain later, though. And generally, you lose when a single hunter dies, generally from their HP dropping to zero. On your turn, all you have is two actions. You have a bunch of dice that you've rolled at the beginning of the round, and you just assign them to one action, which is typically one or two slots of dice. Then you do that thing. Examples would be moving, where you move up to your dude's move value. If you sprint, you can even go through portals across the map, or getting armor, or preparing your character's ability, or attacking. Oh, yeah, attacking. That's super important.

So, let's explain that. So, you generally attack something within your range and line of sight, which just means a certain number of spaces away. Generally, according to your weapon or attack, and you can see that unit in a straight line. So, for the gunslinger, he has a gun that says we have to attack two spaces away. So, we do one damage to this minion, it dies. Oh, by the way, when you kill something, you'll generally get a reward called lament. One minion is one lament. You can also pick up lament by walking into these spaces. If we do damage to the boss, damage goes on the card. This card's HP is on the bottom row here. And when it's taken enough damage, the card is destroyed and the team can get some lament. You get rewarded to do this thing called an opportunity. Like maybe you'll get to heal some HP and generally reset the attack area so you can attack more cards cuz that's how you win. Anyways, once you've done two actions, it's time for the next hunter. After your whole team is out of dice, generally because they've all been assigned, it goes to the enemy phase, which is actually a bunch of little phases. We'll go through them relatively quickly right now. You draw an event card that does something. Then minions go according to their card, generally moving and attacking the closest hunter.

Elites are stronger and may have some special ability, but usually just want to hurt you. Now, it's time for the big bad monster. They'll do their attack card if there's one there. This will generally involve it moving and doing a big attack against your whole team if they can. It's big ouchies. Then the attack row refreshes so there'll be a new attack for next round. The boss will do some final stuff like moving around this marker that can trigger its own special things like maybe it'll do another attack. Finally, now we get to the end of round stuff. You draw a corruption card to see what happens to your hunter. Then spend your lament to get corruption, which is kind of like leveling up your character as when you hit these locked marks, you get more dice or an evolution upgrade card. Okay, that is finally it. Now you take your dice off any slots. Then reroll all of them. You're ready for the next round. Note that usually the only way to defeat the final boss is to destroy the final attack card, which is its own phase.

We'll explain later. So, make sure you're attacking those attack cards. Pros: man, this game really has that Awake Realms grim dark aesthetic down. It's just big, it's wide, and it just really sucks you into it. Namely, the minis are straight up phenomenal and feel really durable. In fact, the hunters look fairly different, especially since some of them have wings, so you don't have to always mark them with included squishy color markers. Looking at the mini and then this corrupted mini side by side is always fun to see this progression. Every hunter has a slightly different way of getting completely jacked up, and it's a very close one to one with the splash art. Bosses are giant and dense, have a really nice clunk when you move them around. And trust me, you'll be moving these guys quite a bit. It's typically at least once around. And then there is a lot of detailed art in this game from the weapons on hunters to elites to minions to unlockables. And while I think it looks good, we can't ignore that Awake Realms is using some degree of AI for these. So just like Lana Everchade, they still have a full art team and are definitely appearing to be using AI to leverage these artist skills and keep cost down for us. In any case, it's hard to pinpoint how much AI they're using. And yes, they have gotten a lot of flak for it, but I don't really see a problem at all while playing. So yeah, it still looks pretty darn good, but understand if you just really don't like AI in the game. Back to physical.

Everything on your recess playerboard is awesome. Your specific hunter slots in and out and is locked in so won't accidentally come out while playing. Useful cuz you tend to store stuff on top of your hunter, so you don't want that to be moving around. The health dial is really firm and easy to use. Corruption is this tendril that oozes up to make you feel more corrupt as you move it right. And dice all slot into the areas accordingly. Speaking of dice, these premium ones we're using here are probably the best feeling dice I've personally ever rolled. They're not too heavy, which is good when you're rolling a bunch, and they have so much texture, they're delight to hold with your fingertips. Okay, they're not that easy to view in multiplayer, especially this double sun symbol. So, at least you have the standard ones, which really pop, but I didn't use them. No matter what you do, you have a ton of dice to use, so no need to worry about shortages. For other cool 3D pieces, we got the terrain box.

And sure, while it's a bit extra and unnecessary to have 3D wells and plumes of red smoke coming out of your pile of skulls, I've noticed that these mountain terrain pieces add a lot to gameplay. See, they go over these mountain hexes where you're not supposed to be able to see or walk through them. So, if you have a giant textured lump here, well, yeah, you can't see or walk through it. And it just makes positioning in general just so much easier to identify. Oh, look, there's a guy dying on it. Oops. The system to level up enemies is also quite clean as it doesn't involve getting a whole new card when leveling up. You simply just get a better cardboard piece and then it slots in. So, it's super quick to switch in and out for either boss or elite. And if you're extra meticulous about planning, you can easily look ahead at the next level help. For enemy attacks, it's also streamlined component-wise. Either they attack you for a flat amount or you roll a dieice that has one of three outcomes.

The most common claw is just damage, the other is a specialty, and the last symbol is like rolling a nat 20. Generally, something favorable happens for your team. It's easy to calculate what type of damage you'd expect to make these rolls properly climactic. And from what we've seen, you never roll more than four, so it's clean to roll, look at, and calculate. Now, Grim Coven has a lot of different steps and phases. But you don't mix them up because of how you get two great double-sided player aids that correspond to your current part of the game. Hunter's phase, one side, enemy phase, backside. For the enemy phase, you get these standes, so you can instantly tell where you need to go. one, two, three, just do the steps. So, you can easily sweep the board and it's all within your ey line to resolve an exact order so you don't accidentally cheat there. And it makes planning so much easier. Oh, of course, the minions always go before the elites. Oh, by the way, minions all have one health with an armor possibility. So, that's easier for bookkeeping on the board and make them feel like proper weak minion throwaways.

The very last component pro is that there are some included storage trays and mini trays. And let me tell you, there is a lot of little pieces in this game, so very much appreciated they give you storage trays. I think this game would be such a pain in the butt to play without these. But we'll get back to this later. Okay, gameplay pros. So, there's a lot of really cool stuff happening in this game. But before I go further, I want to talk about that for how big this game is and how complex it seems and it can be at times, it's actually really easy to teach and learn, relatively speaking, because really at its core, you have a cool hunter dude. It has dice. You roll the dice and then you put the you put the dice in the slots with actions. I mean, that's that's basically it. Then you look at, okay, the enemies will always go minion, elite, then griefbound. So, this is all public knowledge, so you can start planning out your turn. This really includes the next turn attack because it's face up or how the time track will rotate clockwise so you know what it will do. Or you plan around the opportunity card which triggers after you finish killing this turn's attack.

If you're a little bit more serious, you plan around the final attack that is a griefbound's final card. Like maybe you notice that is more HP than usual. So right when you roll the dice for every round, there's a huge sense of planning in okay, well, how much am I moving this round? or maybe I should kill things so I don't have to move. Or should I get some armor this round or not with my specific abilities? And then you also have to sequence your turn with your allies because you can only ever take two actions a turn. And if you can't perform an action, you can't freely stall. You have to permanently pass. So, it's really important to communicate with your teammates all the time in that, oh, maybe I should do an extra attack against the boss or maybe I should just prepare my character a little bit more. But wait, actions are all determined by dice. Isn't that just way too random? Well, in my experience, it was never unforgiving because you could just plan everything from the start of a round. So, it's not like you're suddenly struck by bad randomness mid round. It's very clear what to expect from each color of dye. And then that dye will also have a double symbol.

And you can choose what dice you want from the start with your equipment. And you can get more of any dye as you progress. So, if you want more swords, go black. And you can use this tactic token to reroll any dice, which really isn't that amazing, but at least it's here. Like look at how moving is about just expensive as attacking because it's one die for both of them. But you can't spam anything because every action is once per round. You use it, you're done with it, unless you can find some big brain way to refresh it and then still pay for it. The big mechanic for dice fixing is the assist action though, which pulls together everything good about the dice and spreads it to your team. It's a generic slot that you can fill with any symbol. Then you give your player token to an ally, then that player token is that symbol or symbols. It's really simple, but does so much as it helps mitigate weird roles because now every hunter can use one die from everyone else's pool, but you have to plan for it because you're taking a die away from them and are gaining one. So, that throws off the traditional action flow. Okay, maybe this is a little abstract cuz I talked a lot about symbols and actions. So, let's see how it really is on the board. There's a hunter called the gunslinger who does range attacks, but they're not the strongest until they load up on ammo on other areas. So, let's say you want him to be the one to do the killing blow because he gets benefits for on kill.

But then this more meleecentric hunter called the keeper is already in position to do a big attack, but shouldn't attack because that wouldn't be as efficient. Or would it? Because then they could resolve the opportunity to refresh a keeper card so that he can attack again. So that gets around that one round restriction and he could probably restore one discarded die after all. Well, then the gunslinger can use his range attacks to kill the minions, maybe on another side of the map. Or he could kill like half of the minions and then stock up on ammo for next turn. Or give one of his dice to the keeper through an assist action so the keeper can do more attacks. Or dedicate movement to run towards treasure. Treasure is good. Now to go back to this opportunity card, which again gets uncovered when you kill this turn's attack card. So you may look at this list and say, "Wo, that's so much RNG, right? Three options off of a die roll." Well, it's actually pretty well accounted for because you roll a d12 and the best option is only 1 out of 12. So, the common slash is 7 out of 12, meaning you should always plan for the worst. Everything else is just a lucky benefit. The crescent is really like this nat 12 where you just lucked out.

Anyways, yes, Grim Coven is always this song and dance balance where you're always managing your dice and then you have to factor in all your teammates and then you make sure you're minimizing damage on your team, whether it's through killing minions on the board, again, one HP, or playing around the specific opportunity card. And then, of course, not getting hit by the boss attack at all. Because when these hit you, they feel like proper boss attacks. They can usually like three or four shot you and they'll generally give you negative status effects, but we'll get into those soon. Oh, good thing that there's fog so you can hide in that. It blocks line of sight which is just a straight line. So with these movement is a lot more nuanced as you can be standing right next to an enemy and they can't see you. Makes your life easier. And here's another thing for careful dice management. The focus on griefbound cards where if they haven't taken any damage on some cards, they'll get an additional one or two lines. Usually meaning they'll move again or attack again which are both pretty terrible for your hunter's HPs. Ideally, you want to move out of the boss's attack range so it just never attacks you this round. Or if that's not possible, maybe you stay a little closer and deal one and just one damage to him. See, if you ever do more than one damage, it doesn't matter unless you kill the card because after the round, the attack card will get totally discarded. So yeah, all your hard work will go down the drain and that attack card will come back later.

Remember how I said Grim Coven loves good planning? You can even damage the next turn's card to get a head start on that. that will carry over to the next round. So, you can deny focus there. But, you can't just tunnel in exclusively on the boss because minions can get armor if ignored and they hit decently hard. So, you want to wipe some of those early. Oh, the elites can also hit really hard. So, yeah, priorities can vary depending on your scenario as you tackle these small guys and then the boss attack and then if you want to deny focus, etc., etc. And yes, I only played solo, but I watched your old review and I was thinking about the game and yeah, you need a lot of teamwork to really play this through. So, yes, there's a lot of public information with players, so it may seem like it's prone to quarterbacking, but the game is so complex with so many parts, and also your characters will get more advanced over time as they progress. And then if you're playing more tricky characters like the death gesture with the hand of cards, yeah, there's no way someone's going to be able to quarterback you. And you just can't really solo carry early to midame and kill a boss card by yourself, at least consistently. And if you're not on the same page and someone doesn't take care of the minions and the elite rocking around, that's going to be really bad for your team. And if that is still not enough, again, the assist action is almost mandatory to play well because it's just so good. Okay, now let's take a bit of a detour and talk about the status tokens. They're actually all cool in this game, and the overall system is quite well- handled.

Stun starts occupying your actions, so either you take the action to cleanse it or you don't use that action for a while. So, that's more dice management. Burn is just okay, burning you one damage. It's actually not that interesting, but the damage happens at the end of the round. So, you can decide to save the dice and not heal it off if you think you could win the game quickly. Curse feels like an actual random curse as you draw a secret card that tells you it does something. Like maybe you lose double symbols you roll or if you have five curses, you die. Hunger is okay. Well, technically it's not a status token, but gets lumped in as such because it's a token that goes on your player board. It just doesn't get healed via cleanse. But this is a type of ticking time bomb for your hunters because you hunger for things as you spend more time in this world, this hell area. You're generally getting hunger from corruption or event cards.

At the top of every corruption card is something involving hunger. You're typically moving towards fellow hunters and trying to eat them. Yes, literally eat them to do damage to satiate your hunger. Hey, if you're lucky, you might even get an enemy one, the really rare ones. So then you can attack them and heal. So, hunker is a reason to always be wary about hunters being too close to each other mid to late game in case they start eating one another. Hooray for less static game states and it feels pretty thematic, like you're going crazy and you hunger for anything. Okay, let's talk about progression pros overall for those feels good dopamine hits. So, as I mentioned, yes, you are getting weaker through status tokens. So, that doesn't feel good, but at least you're changing. But you get stronger by getting more corrupted. Now, it sounds bad to get corrupted, right? And here is the idea that you're balancing the line between power and insanity. The stronger you get with more corruption is more cards, which means more actions or passives, or you get more dice, which always feels good. But then the more corruption you get, the harder corruption cards hit you. At 15 corruption, you will go full beast mode and transform to your corrupted self, which is a really cool spike of getting an immediate benefit.

Like as a gunslinger, you can just reload every single card with tactic tokens or ammo. So yes, you can plan around that. However, once you're in the 15 plus corruption area, the corruption cards punish harder and can even drain the event deck, which if it empties, you lose the game. But actually, if you die, it's not over. The game slightly changes as you're now critically wounded, going back to one HP, and you have a mandatory side quest to kill all minions or kill the elites. It's nothing super out of the way, as you'd probably want to do these anyways. But, it does add some nice tension as you're not really sure what critical injury you'll get, and if your team can't do it soon, you lose the game. It's a great way to push the players to push themselves to try new things to complete the new objective and trying not to be in compromising positions when they're desperate to not insta lose. Also nice that the person who is critically wounded doesn't get targeted by the griefbound, so it targets someone new instead of having a downward spiral for that one wounded hunter. In fact, when you complete the side mission, you heal up a bit. The griefbound also has their finale of when there's just two attack cards left. When the attack deck empties off of refilling, you enter a new phase, the final act, where stuff gets real. You discard all critical injuries. So yeah, you can't get those anymore. And if you have any, well, hopefully you're you finished it, so you're not at one HP.

And the griefbound levels up themselves and the elite. And again, it's less man standing, so more tension. Also, also, if this happens during the hunter's turn, the griefbound goes right away. Okay, so he probably just attacks, right? So, there's a huge sense of carefully playing around the final act card, at least the beginning of it, because you don't want to get interrupted mid round, so all your dice go to waste. That really sucks. I lost to that twice. Also, quick shout out to the points of interest on the map. Sometimes when you search landmarks, you can get some sort of upgrade, which would be more cards to put dice in. And man, these are strong. And if they involve a quest for you to do, the stronger they are. I really enjoyed this one that can deal extra damage if the enemy can't be moved. and it can move the enemy. So, you can push the griefbound to a corner or you can lure him to a specific location and then you can abuse this card. Yeah, this hunt felt way different with just this completely new way to attack. I wanted to refresh this card all the time. And of course, you can find a companion which is giving you another space to use an action to stall and just generally gives you more map presence. This rat was great to teleport to as long as the boss or any enemy couldn't see him. So, I just scured him into the fog and then bam, teleport instant treasure. Or you could just get a nice wholesome shelfside cute as hell guard dog. Yeah, never played with this companion actually. And while this isn't progression pro strictly, I do want to point out here that even when you're failing and you're flailing, your team is messing up, there's still a chance of hope because of these enemy dice rolls.

They might go your way. You can roll a critical success off of the opportunity or final attack kill. So that gives you a crazy advantage. So, the game really isn't truly ever over usually. Like, not refreshing the attack row is crazy advantage. It gives you so much more time to do other things on the map. A huge part of the satisfying progression of this game though is the hunters. And I didn't want to get into these yet cuz they're pretty intricate. So, now we can go. There's six in the base game and I played five, which were all cool. And the progression here really does take a page out of something like Slay the Aspire where you draw cards. Here you draw two cards and you pick one to use to upgrade your character. Man, these really, really start changing your character and just open up all these possibilities for cool builds. In most decks, I counted between 26 to 28 cards with little repeats. And so, yeah, with six characters, it's pretty insane the amount of content and dedication that went into these. We'll start with the gunslinger, who is a medium static guy with a range. You can pick your range based off what weapon you bring to the fight. The long rifle is two range.

Problem is, his attacks aren't that great, so you want to take another action to prepare to get extra ammo. And you use all ammo when shooting. So, plus one damage at the start. Okay, that doesn't seem that sexy. Until you get more types of ammo, like, oh, okay, I can have an ammo to teleport myself or ammo that lets me refresh an action. Or if you have a griefbound that seems to have a lot of head text on its attacks, you can spec into head shot, so you don't need as much ammo. Then you can go for something like tactic tokens, which can maybe now help you roll the enemy's dice. Then we have my not so sister's keeper, a slow bruiser who has a ton of health and wants to slowly charge up his sword. So you see him often moving and charging it. He can get rewarded by killing things to keep it charged. Or spending his bar to do more attacks without spending die. This guy starts getting huge ways to use his bar, like spending his entire bar to do seven damage. Holy cow. Or you can do damage for how much hunger he has. Well, heck, if you have seven hunger, you're hungry.

So you can do seven extra damage and heal you. Yes, this is one of the best attacks in the freaking game. So, this guy may seem hella good, but he's super slow at one movement, but when he corrupts, it changes. Not only can he bring his sword to full, he can move three spaces. The best I've seen so far in a character. And his character action is still the move and attack. And his character action is not a move or attack, but is now a move three and attack well. So, it turns out that when you can do all that for the cost of one die, that's insanely efficient. Keeper was my favorite until I was surprised by the personality shift from the death gesture who's playing a gambling game with a set of cards. Yeah, actually, you see, if you're feeling lucky, when you do actions, you can gamble for a little more, pulling the top three cards of the deck and seeing if you match the criteria, like getting a pair. There's so many fun things that can happen with this, as you can spec into holding more cards into your hand so you have more freedom to switch, helped with lucky armor, and eventually flipping over your player board. Combine favorable gambling with passives to gain additional boons when you gamble successfully. We love gambling, kids. Or this card that ramps up so that every time you succeed a gamble, you can spend three tokens to do a six damage attack. Heck yeah, gambling paid off, kids. The gambling mechanic in general is far from pure random because as you do gamles, you discard cards from the deck. So now you know what cards aren't in the deck. So yes, even if you discard the best wild jester, if you really want to do another gamble, you can go ahead and top deck for it as you know what's not in the deck. But the price of punishment is steep of having no action and it's great source of

tension if your team needs to go a little bit harder and really push the limits. Like heck, I got to talk about the impossible stare which completely changed the pace of one game for me. That is if you get one king and one queen, you kill any card. Yes, even the griefbound card. Yes, like 10 health at the finale with final health. Bam, dead. But you have to gamble for it. And if you mess up, you can easily just die. That's so much damage to you. So, it's high risk, high reward, but that becomes less risky the more you gamble beforehand because you can set up your hand with previous gamles and fail those intentionally. Okay, I'm not going to keep going in such deaf otherwise this video is going to take forever. So, I'll just share that the technommancer is like a support battle mage who can supercharge her weapons with her unique die. And she can deal damage equal to how many status conditions she has, absorbing some of the penalties with these passives. Duality is all about gaining these black or white wings to later spend to do certain actions. They get black wings from black dice and white wings from shield dice or blue dice. So, they can just choose a spec accordingly when they progress to another die. Duality felt vanilla, but still required careful counting of each color of wing. I only played them once.

The last one, the mannequin, I just thought was too complex for now, so I didn't bother trying, but essentially they have four arm starting cards, then deal two of the remaining cards flipped over as strings to other people, which they can use if they see the mannequin. The mannequin also chooses a personality to guide its body every round. But again, I didn't play this one, guys. It just seems wo super complex. Needless to say, there are six different hunters with a solid list of upgrades. The amount of builds you can do is going to be immense. And since you reset at the beginning of each fight, you can just try a totally new build. The replay-ability goes to insane levels, eventually figuring out your favorite build with your hunter, then seeing how it mixes with other hunter's favorite builds, and against certain bosses. I mean, the options just are pretty much unlimited. And finally, we get to the bosses. The griefbound, the big bad monster. Yes, I've been just interchangeably using these words the whole time, but yes, there's six of them and I played four and they all definitely felt different. They all have a chunky deck of their unique attacks and then they all have their final attacks. Wow, this is like five final attacks. Five final attacks, five opportunities for the graveyard dragon.

It's a lot to choose from. Okay, these are the facts, but I want to get into how they really mess with one to two core elements of gameplay. So, let's go. The devourer is a hungry boy as he loves to eat, eat, eat. He has a stomach tile you set up on the side and he frequently wants to put you inside of him as you end up in his stomach which leaves you more susceptible to attacks, but you can also attack him quite easily. Then you can escape before he retaliates. This hungry man messes with the hunger mechanic. You know, it's like when your hungry bud gets pizza and now you're hungry. Yeah, he gives you hunger, which means you'll start eating each other more. He can also start eating up stuff on the board. The swarm queen is a really nasty one as she puts down these swarms on the board. These are basically just like bases she attacks from. So, she ends up occupying effectively more of the board than you'd think. So, there's not a lot of safe spaces as time goes on. The last one to meaningfully discuss is the graveyard dragon, who is all about status effect manipulation.

Like, he first has disease cards, which removes some status tokens from the game, which is impactful because in general, when you have to get more status tokens, and there's none left, you take damage for each you can't take. That's a big deal. Does these cards also make curses hit harder? Like hunters with curses gain stuns for each double they roll. Or how curses slow you down by one move. But then you can discard that many curse tokens. So there's a lot of turns of sprinting but not actually doing it to move just to get rid of curses. Oh, the dragon is also two hexes and he can attack from the front or back depending on the attack card, which is cool. Okay, for the ones I haven't tried that much, the undead general was the tutorial and he's all about playing banners to command his minions around. Then I haven't tried the convergence who has tornadoes that will move around and damage you. Then the tormentor is your friendly neighborhood serial killer who loves to set up torture devices. He can teleport between them to give you a little love tap. But wait, that's not even the end of the bosses because when you're in your corrupted form, you can unlock the pretender griefbound version of your hunter to fight against if you draw the correct secret card. So this means that the griefbound used to be us.

But yeah, there's actually six more bosses in this game, but they don't have a hunt book. And I imagine you play them all each once because they don't have that many cards. but it's still cool as an option. Okay, as we wrap up this huge list of pros, yes, we're we're getting to cons finally, I want to say that there's some nice little elements to the game which really help add more story elements to the game and also help flesh out replay-ability. And yes, there's no shortage of replay-ability in this game, but it just it just goes up all the time if you really want to sink in the time in this game. Like most types of tiles have an associated card with it, so you can go to the forest to heal or even teleport, of course, by spending an action. So that requires more dice management. Or you can just go through all the landmarks. Like you can use a wagon to actually do a quest to escort a noble woman. I'm not even kidding. Yes, she shows up randomly. And then you can get rewarded. Or you stay away from the ball and chain, an unkillable device that literally just randomly attacks around it. Hunters and enemies. It's put me in critical damage before, but I also had it do some extra damage to kill a griefbound card when I messed up. So yeah, as it was swinging around, I couldn't help but laugh. I wasn't expecting the river to play such a big role, too. It's not in every map, but yeah, it really changes things. So, there's all these different types of river I haven't tried, but when I played against a graveyard dragon, the water would relieve our birds, which was great. But promptly replaced them with curses. Okay, not as good, but not strict damage. Problem with curses against a graveyard dragon is that he fatigued us, so we actually couldn't move as moving would subtract our fatigue. Luckily, if we were just able to sprint at least one space, the water would do the rest. So, we got to land on the dragon space for the killing blow.

This video is brought to you by Aldara, a giant 4X game that doesn't actually take that long. Yeah, this game has phenomenal ships for asymmetric factions. You complete secondary objectives and build up victory points as you leave your stronghold and get more territories, but of course, you can exterminate your opponents. Like seriously, this game is so streamlined. The box is mostly four boxes that have a faction in them. Then you set up the hex's on the board and you're ready to play. But man, look at those ships again. Every ship has a certain die it rolls. And when you roll the highest number, they'll explode, so you can roll again, leading to some fun combat. I had fun using upgraded frig to move around the map quickly and terrorize my opponent's fleets. Right now, there's not only a reprint of the base game at a lower price than before, but a brand new expansion, Aldara, New Empire. This expansion has five new modules you can mix and match with the base game for insane replay-ability. If you follow the Kickstarter now, you'll get a free mini back at any pledge level, and there's a stretch goal pre-launch follower bonus.

So, check out the description below for all things Al Dara, this area control. Now, back to the video. Cons. Oh, boy. Okay. So, I Well, if you go and uh to your YouTube and look at the timestamps at the con section, this is going to be a doozy. So, let's start with component cons. For a game that seemingly looks so cool on the table, there's a shockingly high amount of component cons. Like, right off the bat, the game doesn't have a pleasant unboxing experience because for having so many different trays, it still doesn't organize well. Nor does it give you any clues about what is a good way to organize. I mean, Awaken Realms, I know you can deal with Atlanta Evershade and Nemesis Retaliation, so no idea why they dropped the ball here. Oh, actually, maybe it's because there's no good way to organize it with the included tray insert. I ended up combining multiple tokens into a single tray. Then, it is just absolutely baffling for a game that provides you with sleeves. You're actually not supposed to sleeve that many of the cards if you want to use the included insert. I was repeatedly desleaving cards when I realized that, oh snap.

Yeah, after sleeving two hunters and some of one of the griefbound cards, you just can't fit things in. So, actually, you can't really sleeve that many cards, even though there's a lot of decks in this game, which feels super counterintuitive. My advice is that if you want to use the included insert is you just leave the generic cards in the game like the event deck and corruption deck and maybe your favorite hunter cards or you can just say screw it like people online and just come up with your own storage system which I kind of did as I have this acrylic tray that has my unused acrylic tokens and normal tokens from the game. And then also I put some of the sleeve cards in here that I don't use like the pretender cards and dice. And then while we're on the overall organization, it's also baffling that for a game with such high production value has no organizer for all these griefbound sheets, which should be the heart of the game, right? The enemy you're playing against. And the sheets don't have their levels on the front, rather on the back. So, it's a pain if they get mixed up, which for us, they came partially mixed up, so you have to just keep flipping them over. But yeah, pretty much all the miscellaneous components like level tokens and hex terrain is just expected to be dumped in this clear plastic tray, which not only feels bad, but is a ripe recipe for total mixups, which starts hurting setup. And I'll talk about that soon.

But before that, just keep in mind that this game doesn't really come with many plastic bags. And I'd highly recommend bagged, and I'd highly recommend getting some to bag the separately sized hex tiles, especially the onex ones. Okay, so now for the big component con. Grim Coven is by far the most punishing or inefficient board game I've ever had to set up. Ever. I don't know if punishing makes sense, but I want to say it's the most consistently lengthy game I've ever had to set up. Even when I got the system down, it still didn't get that much faster. So, this isn't really a skill thing or getting used to it. So, let me just explain each step and maybe you can understand here. Number one, first get everything generic out, like the corruption deck, secret decks, playmats, player aids, etc. Not a big deal. Number two, set up the board of differing terrain pieces. So, while they're marked, they're double-sided, so there's slightly more friction there.

Number three, then you have to set up landmarks from drawing cards from the deck than getting the terrain piece. Number four, then you have to populate the board with everything else like lament, portals, minions, elites with all their cards, too. Number five, okay, great. You're kind of there. Now you just have to do everything boss related. It has five different cards to set up. The event deck, the final attack, the opportunity, their attacks, and lastly, their stage card. Oh, also they will have a special thing to worry about. So like maybe extra tiles, but that's not that complicated. Number six. Okay, it looks like the game is set up, but you have one more thing to do because your character. Yes. Yes. Okay, so now you take your characters out of the box, make sure you have all their correct cards, then pick a weapon, armor. So, you're kind of playing the game at this point, but not exactly. And then you just get the dice according to that and then any extra components they might need. The first time I did this, this took 2 hours. Yes, 2 hours, which was excusable because I was learning the game and I didn't know how to set up the game yet. But later on, even when everything was custom organized by me and I had some of the components already in this room or on this table, it took 45 minutes. Yes, this was crazy. I even filmed and timed myself. It's true. 45 minutes. Third time I did this was about 25 minutes. Okay, much better. The fourth time when I was upgrading a single boss, it still took 20 minutes cuz you still need to switch out the terrain. You still need to alter some of the boss cards. And then I wanted to switch out some hunters. Yep. If you're playing the same boss, but on the higher difficulty, the setup doesn't get that much better because the map totally

resets and the boss stuff resets. So, if you have the game out, sure, setup is less, but it's no quick upgrade. For my final fifth game, Against the Dragon, I decided to keep the same characters and have an entirely new boss. And that took 27 minutes. So, there's not really any question that if a game is completely in the box and needs to be playable, it's at least 30 minutes at least. There's just a lot of different phases. There's all these specifically named components in this hunt booklet. And there's just a lot of pieces overall. Like with really anything in life where if there's more components or parts of something, the more things you start adding, the exponentially easier it is to make mistakes or conversely the harder it is to find things. This is because I didn't have a good given space to store all the hex tiles. So they ended up getting mixed with the griefbound sheets and level markers and so I just kept misplacing the small hex's. However, it actually doesn't matter about what number you use because they're all functionally the same if they're the same type, except for this river one.

This is the only exception I found. This felt like such a scam a setup because as most board gamers know, when the game tells you you need a very specific piece, you better find that piece. But in this game, it doesn't matter. Just find whatever similar looking thing. Yeah, quite frankly, I just can't ever see this game being easy to set up a take down. Yeah, that's just it. It is what it is. And I'll get back to this in scoring. Okay, the next component cons are when you're actually playing the game and are comfortable with all the pieces. And that is well, this game actually doesn't use its table space well. Like, namely, where do you put the boss, which is partially out of frame for you guys, and the central map? For reference, we're playing on a standard gaming table with the topper. So, this is a little bigger than 3x5 ft. When using the tutorial setup, the problem is that the enemy information is so far away from you. And that's kind of the goal of the game. This thing, you need to know whether to attack or reposition around the boss and also right next to it, how minions are going to act, if they're worth killing, the lead, etc., etc. The text on these is not big. So, I actually found after using the nice neoprene mads that ideally you sacrifice a bit of the map clarity. And good thing the board is already pretty simple cuz it's mostly just big minis standing apart from each other. And then the boss area goes in the front middle where you can see it very clearly. But this makes the playing space really wide for single player. See how the player boards have to be super wide because of the corruption track. So I was constantly moving my chair to see all the dice or frequently standing up and hunching over. Bad for posture. But this is the most readable way to play the game. Even

though stuff in the back terrain area may be hard to see, especially if blocked by 3D terrain or portals. But it's a fine sacrifice. This really made me suspect. Was this game just like completely play tested on tabletop simulator? And once I got this morsel of an idea in my head, I couldn't let it go. Like, there's four minis restricted to a hex, which is fine for all miniatures except for the boss, which takes up the entire freaking hex. Like, it's not surprising to have two hunters attacking the boss at zero range. So, they're just standing on the boss, and you're just sharing the best you can with the stinky boss. or when the boss steps on a lament token while you can't see it anymore. Or how the map will actually get displaced because there's nothing holding it together and when you have the big boss mini moving around that makes it easier to displace said hex's or the griefbound sheets which we talked about. It's annoying to flip them over. Why not just put the number on the front? Then there's some miscellaneous jank like some spelling typos or some of the smaller cards. And there's a subtle but clear wording mistake on the player aid which just feels so unprofessional.

Like how did they not catch this? Speaking of player aid, they should really have included minion spawn and final act steps because I was frequently going back to the rule book for these or these could be on the griefbound board. Then the last component con is for the booklets. Like it's neat that they're trying to have a tutorial so you don't have to read the rule book and I tried it and it's not really doing the trick. Like for one, the setup is literally different in the different photos. Then why the heck does it not tell me what the wind condition is early on? And there should be an example of your hunters discarding a boss attack because that's literally your goal. Like that's the fundamental of the game. Or why didn't they fast forward to at some point to do the final act, which is the most important thing at the end. Oh, actually, you know how to win? It's on the back. It's on the very back of the tutorial and under final rules. What the heck? This just feels so sloppily put together and does not get you comfortable with playing the game nor that excited cuz it doesn't explain that many mechanics. Like they even encourage you to keep playing after the tutorial turns. And from what I've seen online, people were just like me and that they just miserably got wrecked after doing the steps here because yeah, you don't really know what's going on. It just starts this experience with just a sour taste in your mouth. The rule book is mostly okay, but I can't go into too much detail because again, I'm reading this after I went through the tutorial.

So my interpretation stuff is not exactly linear. And then when I was searching stuff, yeah, it's missing some terms. So, I just end up googling a lot or using, you know, our good old friend AI to find some rules. I mean, a fact with this game would have been really appreciated, but I guess that just doesn't really come with early versions of Kickstarters. Oh, also the rule book being a giant square. Again, I don't like giant squares. I'm not going to end my crusade against the giant squares. They're just annoying to flip through. It's just all floppy and oh my gosh, gameplay concept. So, just like the prototype, the real Grim Cubin frontloads attention pretty heavily. So, end games shouldn't be as exciting as they should be when you're fighting against a big boss, right? Shouldn't that be exciting at the end? But from what I've seen, this feeling is not as bad as the prototype. So, let's do a little review. Originally, when you kill the elite, you're doing well because that not only eliminates a huge threat on the board that almost attacks just as harshly as the boss, and it has pretty low HP in comparison, but also in killing it, you are going around the board doing other things. Well, now he usually gives more of the lament payout to the killer and then usually a little bit less to every single other hunter, so it's not quite as lucrative. And when you kill him, there's a high chance he'll just come back. There's also just a lot of different elites now. So, you're not hard set on just killing the prototype guy that was very straightforward. But, uh, even with all this, yeah, killing the elite is the thing to do because he always does something every round. And from what I've seen, he sometimes has a bigger hit area than the boss and rolls almost just as hard. So why wouldn't you kill him?

And when he comes back, like two rounds later, you'll be so strong that you can kill him fairly easily, even if he's leveled up. So he disappears again. Sometimes he won't even come back again cuz the game ends. You, as a hunter, will be the weakest you ever are at the beginning. And I always envision round one to be, okay, let's get that first upgrade ASAP. So then I can draw my evolution cards and pick one. So I have an idea of what I want to start strategizing around. So, even more reason to kill the elite if you can early cuz if you kill him, everyone will get one lament guaranteed. That's enough to level up. If not kill him, at least partially damage him and then walk around and get your laments and kill minions on the board. Actually, yeah, let's talk about your overall hunter progression. You can just get way too strong and the boss doesn't really compensate. So, once you get your engine figured out, as in you have two to three extra cards, so generally after halfway through your corruption track, there's little reason to get more cards. So, you just end up getting dice. The thing is that once you have enough dice, the dice rolls don't really matter that much because they didn't have a lot of variance to begin with and you pick the symbols you wanted. And some actions will even give you a choice on what's needed to fill them. So, you can kind of just start freely assigning to fill slots. Also, don't forget that your team can always assist each other, which gets even easier to just freely do as time goes on. So, you're getting more stronger, right? You have more action possibility and literally more actions.

Well, the boss just kind of stays the same. Like sure they have a stage card that happens within their cycle at some point. So every four rounds or kind of three rounds for some of them. And so this happens what maybe twice. Also stage cards don't really influence their behavior. It more like levels them up and the elite and then does something more map or minion related at least from what I've seen. So you can be flipped to corrupted side. Maybe you have eight to nine dice and then you're able to consistently oneshot attacks by yourself. Especially from what I've seen in two-player, while he just sits around and does one attack a turn, this lazy bum. And what do you know? As you kill his attack cards, you get lament so you can level up even more. So, you're kind of just snowballing forward. From what I've seen is that if you're able to get past the first thirdish hump without doing too badly, you're probably going to win the game. Just like in the prototype, I was able to consistently destroy both of his attack cards, then position away from him before he does a final attack against us. It seems like it was the intention that you getting too strong puts you at this big risk, right? You don't want to draw the corruption cards, but actually you draw corruption cards right before you level up. And both of these happen at the end of a round. So, you have a whole entire round to use the insane benefits of being flipped, suffer one badish corruption card, then have another whole round. So, if you haven't won or lost the game by now, which is generally the case, then you'll draw a corruption card for some minor bad. What could be the fix? Well, just like we

said in the prototype review, maybe he could react to you. Like, it's really easy to have a static game state where you've just memorized the opportunity card cuz you've seen it like four times. And so, planning around it just feels like standard procedure. It's not really this epic boss thing that you're scared he'll do against you or you have at least somewhat of a ghost and idea of what he'll do. No, it's it's standard procedure. Maybe some attacks could be double-sided so that you would flip it and then he might retaliate against you. Like it could be really thematic. Let's just spitball. I'll say, "Hey, if I shoot the boss's head, then he gets angry, but I still blinded him, so he charges kind of wildly." Let's talk about the elites and minions, too. So, although there's a lot of different cards, there's 14 elites and 12 minions. Seems like a lot of enemies, and some elites are even named, so they're stronger, the way you deal with them is all kind of the same. Yes, the bullfrog jumps to you and attacks you or pulls you to a space. Or the alchemist throws a bomb at you and gives burn. Okay, these are just both bad things, so just get out of the line of sight and range.

Same with the minions, which are more like vanilla minions. And then the undead, which do something generally when you kill them or move into them. But this doesn't change that you should just get away from their attacks and kill them if possible. Grim Coven has a really rigid round structure, which kind of makes the enemies feel rigid in their procedure, right? It's always minions, then elite, then griefbound every single time. Contrast that to enemies in most dungeon crawler E games that have different initiatives that you have to plan around or come from specific areas on the board like rooms so you can run away from them or close doors on them. Or they'll give you a really influential status effect like Nemesis where you can get infected. These serve as a new puzzle to work around and give characterization mixed in with different payouts for killing them. Or maybe there's ways guys manipulate spaces, like they can destroy terrain or they can move faster on certain terrain. But nah, in Grim Coven, most elites and minions just serve to damage you more or spawn more minions. Simple. They move attack. Okay, they can steal your lament or there's the rogue gunslinger that can kill minions before attacking you. But these aren't that different for all the cards here. Just more like varying levels of difficulty. There's a named Elite, right? Alicia the Twisted, but this doesn't do an extra action or retaliate when you attack her, and she doesn't even have a different back. But if you made these smaller non-boss enemies have more character, that might start messing with the rigid round structure the game likes so much. Or add in more bookkeeping, and Lord knows this game already has so much of that. So, this is in a tough spot, but I'd like to see less elites and minions and more specialty with each of the cards. Or

maybe they can interact with the boss in a specific way. Like once you hit a certain amount of minions, they do something with the boss. Maybe this is in the game, but I haven't seen it yet. The next gameplay con has a little bit to do with balance. That is this gunslinger character is just not really as consistently good as other hunters. That is at least in two players. I've just had some games with him where he just feels way too weak. He just doesn't have that much base attacking power because he wants to load up on ammo. Well, to do that, he needs a ton of upgrades to create slots to store ammo. So he first needs to have a decent start where you just farm minions. So this is consistently doable, but his early game sucks. But even when you level up, you'll look at his requirements in general. It requires so much to do the same amount of damage as others. Like he needs dice to get the ammo, then he needs to spend all of it when he attacks. So that's pretty particular.

And one range away isn't a benefit like it might sound like. The boss is probably still going to attack you if you're standing there. Here, let's look at his best starting attack. Long rifle to do one damage, but he can do it from far away, which again doesn't really matter too much with all the fog and terrain on most maps also drawing a straight line. Then, if it's the head, it does two damage. Okay, so it's only good against certain boss cards and only for the boss. Let's look at the battle mage support, Technommancer, who has an arcane staff that costs a similar amount to do two damage to each enemy on her space. Once you start adding in all these cards around, the technommancer can use a die to teleport a portal she's onto her space doing a damage and later she can move away. So, it's a bit of damage. It sets up the map for others and it puts her in a position to easily run away. Okay, so I don't want to go too deep into this cuz we'll be here forever. And there is a tactic token stacking idea, but the problem is that tactic tokens aren't even that good by themselves. And the payouts still aren't that good unless you get like a perfect build with all tactic tokens and can abuse sharpened senses to just keep dealing like four damage. Just four. I mean, that's not even that good as an endgame attack. To be safe, it's best to air on the side of ammo areas. Then when you flip to get corrupted, you just fill in four of them. So then when you shoot, you have somewhat good damage and then just get a bunch of goodies like refreshing actions or even shooting through obstacles. Anyways, the gunslinger is the most conceptually straightforward pick and even the tutorial has you playing as him. So it seems like the obvious starter pick, but

I don't actually think starters should play him. His upgrades are so slow and if you're not good at building an engine, you'll just be so weak endgame, you're not really even doing that much. So to avoid looking accidentally weak and pathetic, I'd recommend playing as the keeper for your first character. Yes, he is slow, but very straightforward. Okay, next is a con, which only really feels like the case in a game as big as this with all the component cons. And also, since it's not a video game, it's going to get punished a bit harder. But this point is that Grim Coven is just not stitched together very well. So, a big part of the prototype review was, okay, well, this is going to be a campaign cuz that would be really cool to see your hunters level up and face off against certain stages of bosses. And now, nope. Nope. It's not a campaign. It's not. And progressing through these hunt booklets is so thematically irrelevant that you might as well call them levels of difficulty rather than scenarios you're doing. When you find a griefbound, you open up the hunt book, which seems like it should have everything related to the griefbound, but it doesn't even give you a summary of the griefbound. All it does is actually explain setup. Then it gives a bit of a prologue that is just some monologue, some edgy monologue from the griefbound, and then you start. If you want to see rules, uh, where? Oh, it's on the back. Okay. Okay, again, there's no summary for it. This is just everything. Why is the back not a summary? I stopped while writing this and went back to look through some of the hunt booklets epilog text and I quickly saw that all the failure text for one griefbound is exactly the same.

I mean, the victory text isn't that interesting either. Like, it just gives you some slight flavor of who they were like as humans before they were transformed, but it's pretty minimal. for the map. It'll also ask you to set up some mystery terrain with text on it, which is actually cool in the vacuum, like interacting with a witch NPC or the hanged man. The problem is is that this has no setup at all in the hunt booklet, it just has to pick one randomly. And because the text is so small, and that there's so many other things to do and keep track of in this game, this is easy to forget. Also, I'd imagine that once you interact with these guys twice, it stops getting as interesting because they just lead you to secret cards, which will always be the same. Oh, right. It's because Grim Coven is leaning towards a rogue light. Like, it's not explicitly a rog light, but it has roglike elements like your character getting these evolution cards. But then, if this really wanted to embrace the rog light, well, wouldn't you have something that unlocks permanently in your run to influence other runs so you have more motivation to keep playing? Like here, you just 100% clean up once you're done.

Okay. Okay. Sure, there is the pretender you can unlocked, which is just like another side level to do. It doesn't do anything to any existing character or boss. This also just never happened for us. Yeah, because it can only happen once your hunter is corrupted. And once your hunter is corrupted, the game is going to end soon. This is where the personal stories mini expansion comes in, which is a whole bunch of cards and booklets that will tell you how to get unlockables for each character. And these are just Xbox achievements to do for your hunter, and when you complete them, you permanently unlock a card. So, that's neat. Although, thematically, I can't say how cool they are. I think these really should have been in the base game and emphasize unlockables for the character. And while we're on this train of thought, it probably wouldn't even hurt having some of the existing evolution cards be unlockables because some of them are really cool and you don't need to see all 20 25 of them at the beginning. Let the player experience the game in a structured unfolding way so you can have like presents at Christmas. A very violent presents actually. Okay, so now we're kind of into the replayability when we talk about how this game's not stitched together that well. And let's talk about the hunters. So, each hunter, it may seem like there's a lot of replay-ability with six cards, right?

You have three pieces of armor and three weapons. However, these are really straightforward and in such clear categories that I reckon that you probably just pick one from each category and stick with them. And also, there's only three for each category. So, yeah, there's not that much variety here. Okay, let's zoom in on the gunslinger. He has three different guns, but they're all super specific. If you want to do a bunch of AOE damage and wants to shoot through the fog, pick Blunderbus. But this probably is weak if not really situational because multi-hits don't really help against the boss. So now you're already down to two weapons, a short medium range and a medium long range. That's it. There's no way to upgrade these. There's no nuance here. Instead of focusing on these mini expansions with more hunters and more unlockables again, why not just have the base game have the hunters be the best they can be? I'm sure people wouldn't complain if there were, say, four hunters instead of six in this game. And that there's a lot of very enjoyable unlockables. And while we're on this idea, why not just change the drawing evolution cards to draw three, pick one instead of draw two, pick one, maybe spend lament to draw more. Why have this rule? Just make it draw three, pick one. Super simple. You want people to have the best engines. You want people to see the best cards, they're have motivation to keep playing more.

But yeah, without the personal stories expansion that changes some things, you just write down your win loss on a piece of paper, then factory reset. It's not that if you kill a boss in a certain way, your whole team gets upgrades. So, let's start wrapping up cons with player count. As I said in previous cons, playing solo is rough because of how wide this game is. And I'd actually reckon that the game is best at two or three players just because of visibility issues because the more people you get, well, the harder it is to see the boss text, which is the most important thing. And there is a lot of room for analysis paralysis because dice sequencing is the name of the game. So, I'd imagine that in four players, there could be a lot of waiting. Or you just ask your teammate a question about like, well, what dice do you need? There's another conversation that comes up. Also, there's probably a lot of procedural waiting in multiplayer as one to two people resolve the enemy phase while everyone else just sits there and does nothing because the players don't react at all during the enemy phase. There's nothing to do. I've heard the game does get easier the more hunters you have. And I could totally see this because the boss has what? More health and there's more enemies on the map, but you'll have more friends, more hunters to assist each other, to have line of sight to use certain benefits, and also more ways to use the assist action. So yeah, if you want to do two players, two-headed for four hunters, and just set up some side tables to make it work, maybe that is the best way to play this game. So you want to make the difficulty easier while giving you more options. Just don't play true solo because I tried that deputy mode and no good. It's not only poorly explained, it just feels like an immense afterthought in design, especially for how many components there are for it.

This is a shame because it's a lot of new rules which seem like a baby mode that could be ported to have a non board gamer friend like a little brother control and still enjoy the game at like a one and a half players. But nah, it's just a bunch of new rules with basically no benefit at all. The deputy has their own hunter board and still doesn't make it clear that it doesn't start with armor or weapons, which is annoying, and there's no deputy aid. How it works is that the deputy gets three tokens that are effectively just blank dice with three new generic actions. And then you have this new player board here. So, yay, three actions instead of two actions that was in the prototype. But these are unsexy actions because they're always blank. And with only blank dice, they don't interact with the board as much. Like they can't discard symbols and once they literally got trapped in the devourer stomach because they couldn't discard swords. And the tactic token is literally useless on the deputy and feels bad to accidentally get.

scoring. Now it is time for a recommener score on Grim Coven where we try to critically evaluate the affforementioned pros and cons of this Bloodborne inspired boss battler, more specifically probably the Chalice Dungeons of Bloodborne. And then we're also comparing it to our initial prototype notes. And so after my 10 plus hours of playing and countless more hours of setting up and cleaning up and unboxing this game, this is going to get a recommendder score of a 6 out of 10. It is above average. Pretty much everything about this game screams that is not for the faint of heart. Huge box, gritty art, tons of components, huge setup, decent play time. And so, the audience for this game already isn't as big as other big box Awake realms or boss battlers. Of course, Grim Coven gets brownie points cuz it just seems like literally Bloodborne the board game. I mean, I haven't played it, but I do suspect that if your fingers weren't good enough to do all those inputs in the chalice dungeons, then you can have a home here. But I've had a lot of time to think about the component wos as I've set up this game again and again and even the most hardcore of board gamers will get turned off by it. Okay, let's do some math here. All right, let's bring up my mathing. Uh, okay. So, let's say the setup time is like 30 to 45 minutes and then cleanup is just as long. So, by being generous, let's just say it's an hour for setup and takeown.

Then each game is one and a half to two and a half, three hours. Let's just say it's about 2 hours for each game. So, uh, yeah. I mean, this is like 50% of your time with this game is just setting up and taking down. Even when you get really fast at this game and play it for the long term, I can't really see any session getting much faster than 2 hours game time, not setup, game time, because even when you know all the rules through and through, dice rocking and worrying about the boss doesn't get any shorter. But yeah, a lot of this core is definitely solid enough to hold up to many, many games. If you just want to jump in and don't really care about the box cohesiveness, rather the highs of dancing around the boss, then evolving and getting that spike of correcting your hunter and that's just so worth it for you. You could stay with this game for a long, long time. And the early mid games will always be quite crunchy with how there's so many threats to manage for a limited amount of dice. And we didn't really get much in the balance besides talking about the gunslinger for a bit because yeah, being slightly weaker or stronger doesn't really matter in a game like this when you can go on side quests to unlock crazy items and there's just so many variables, right?

Winning all the time is not the point at all. There's no waiting to fight another boss. You can just skip ahead to it. There's no unlockable you're grinding for. You could just probably get it in your next game. And then if you lose, well, yeah, you can just instantly just switch out and just get a whole new combination of hunters and try them out. So, this is probably what some people really want out of this non- campaign nature of it. It's just easy plug-and-play. Well, not easy, but it's just plug-and-play. Yeah, we talked about in pros how things are quite well controlled, but sometimes you just get lucky and it helps you substantially, specifically if you roll two nat 12s in a game. Yeah, you avoid a boss attack and kill the elite permanently. So, you're doing great. Or maybe you're even asked to do a critical injury task that you've already completed. That happened to me before. It probably happens to many people out there. or again the complete wild card ball and chain just swinging around. Screw it. There's so many secrets in the secret deck we haven't seen. So there's plenty of more to experience even for me. Grim Coven is a euro at its core mechanic, right?

You're allocating dice to slot tier and then you have perfect information of the enemy. You can look through all the cards. You can look Yeah, you're you actually have to plan ahead. So then you allocate enough of a resource called damage to these cards to move them from there away. And then the non-dice hunter rolls are again one of three outcomes and you just plan for the worst all the time. So really actually for every round there is a way to perfectly plan it out. Like you could find the expected outcomes of pretty much every play. But then this also has so much air trash thrown on top, right? Like there's side quests. You can find the companions. Your characters get unexpectedly more punished from a event card that happens to match the griefbound. It does happen. Or maybe you're just hungry and you eat the boss to win with that small chance you draw that corruption card. If you back something like the Grim Coven boss pledge, there's so much more permutations of stuff with the two new hunters and four new bosses. And honestly, for about $300, it's not that bad given how many minis and sheer play time you can get. And if you don't get that, you have this game for about $200, which is plenty of content. I mean, that's what I was playing here and I wasn't even close to seeing everything.

Anyways, I'm going to end my lukewarm recommendations with a observation on Awaken Realms. So, yes, there's critique that they use AI art. Okay, totally valid. There's critique that, yeah, their games have way too many rules for what they are. Okay, also valid. Or people just say, "Oh, it's just mini schlop." Okay, well, actually, after playing so many of their games, both non- campaign and campaign games, I think the principal problem is actually they're giving you too much content. Like it's so much content that you're ultimately paying and organizing for. And I'd argue that for a lot of the secret cards in these games, most owners in their life will never even see it or they will see it and never get to use it or see it and then use it like once.

Some cards are even meant to only be used once. So then you have a box full of cards you spent all this time organizing that you're not really using most of. As I file and sort the cards in their giant row again and again here, this feeling really gets hammered home. In Grim Coven, pretty much everything's unlocked, and you're just sifting through all the components to use, like only a fraction of it all. I'm like, when the heck am I going to get around to playing all these pretender bosses? I'd imagine that even playing through all the bosses once doesn't even guarantee you going through the secret deck, which we can't really test. There's more penalties for a non-c campaign game like this cuz in at least a campaign game, there's the promise that you will be able to see the secret card once you get to a certain point in the campaign. And then on our end, we could review the secrets when they arrive at certain parts of the story, like a turning point here. It's just Yeah, it's just all kind of Yeah, it's it's it's hard to review. And because in Waker Realms games have so much content and hype around them, it's this positive feedback loop of more hype equals more content. But is it going to get played?

Was it really necessary for this game to actually have 12 bosses where most people with a healthy rotation of games probably won't play more than three or four bosses just once? That's already over a dozen hours. Like why not put the effort into more rogike feelings or an organizer or mini campaigns? But still, Big and Grand has its commercial perks and that has an allure just like when the new Awaken Realms game shows up on your doorstep with its huge white box and gravitas behind it. Huh. Maybe it's kind of similar to how it feels good to click on a YouTube video that is long when it's a topic that you are already interested in. And even if you don't watch the whole thing, it just feels like, wow, this has a lot of weight behind it. Oh man. Okay. Well, what the heck is my personal score after doing all this talking and all this playing and component setup and takedown? Okay. Uh, well, I've actually felt a lot of different ranges of emotions here. Like at first I was like it's pretty meh mechanically but I was really frustrated about the components. And as time went on my setup experience did not improve at all, but it was about after the third game where this game really clicked for me. Like I was able to properly kill griefbound cards. So that felt really good. And then in my fourth game I discovered the death gesture which is a huge new spark of joy. Man, the gambling in this game is just really well handled. Never thought I'd say that about a boss game. Okay, so I'm going to say this is a five out of 10. And then the setup and component woes. Well, h bring it down to like a four out of 10.

It's just too crazy for me. I've never played Bloodborne the video game, but I thought it was always respectable from a distance. So, I'm really happy I got to experience this world with the boss battling through board gaming. Still, Grim Coven's world itself is not that compelling besides some art. Like, the terrain literally just feels like the most generic hex thing ever, which would be fine if I didn't spend like 20 minutes setting it up every time. And the game is just too wide on the table. It doesn't help that the boss attacks are just a bunch of rows of attacks, which ends up making the game feel pretty mechanical to me. Luckily, the core of this game is consistently fun, if not very fun, come midame. Getting evolution cards is always this huge rush. What am I going to get? And combining them with new dice is always fun. There's a really good crunch as I two-headed two hunters and decide how to big brain sequence all their actions. It actually made me kind of feel smart.

There's something visceral about clearing cards after placing a bunch of dice you planned, or even just clearing minions at elites to harvest their souls. I mean, I guess that's what lament is. However, it does end up circling back to, "Okay, we need to kill the griefbound cards. Oh, wait. They're just texts. Okay, am I in range to get attacked? How much dice is it rolling?" These are all crunchy feelings, but it doesn't make me feel like this is a specific boss doing a specific attack, which makes it ultimately dry. And for the finale, it's even worse because, oh no, the boss is doing its mega final form. Then you just like twoot it if you've been playing right. So the best outcome mechanically is the most dull story as the ending is a breeze because I played well earlier. So I had more fun midame instead of panicking over endame. So endame was boring. So yeah, the hunter phase aside from reading the text there which you have to do is it's fun stuff. But then the whole enemy phase is immensely procedural. Do this step now.

Do this step. Follow the red signs. Go here. Go there. 1 2 3 4 5. Like none of these are that bad by themselves, but they just they just add up again and again. And then at the end of the round, okay, cool. I'm actually getting to do my thing now. I can spend lament and get the upgrade. That feels fun. But I got to do so much to get there. For me, Grim Coven climaxes at about 45 minutes in, just at about right before or when you're getting about halfway through your corruption track, then the game just kind of keeps going as I have to kill more attack cards again and again. And while it's fun to operate my hunters, having so much dice and having a guarantee to kill things at my current difficulty feels well also procedural. So, I think there's actually like a fun seven to eight out of 10 game in here for me, but it just needs to be massively condensed. Just like any good art, like a good movie, a good book. I find the mark of a good game is how much I think about it when I'm not playing it, especially for a game as big as this, as long as this. And I found myself thinking about Grim Coven a lot.

So, hence, this is probably one of the most favorable four out of 10 I could ever give on this channel. Yeah, I think so. Yeah. And heck, if it's already set up and I don't have to take it down either, I could definitely be talked into playing it again. Especially if it's with a hunter, I think it's cool. And uh you know, when I was writing the script, I was actually thinking, "Huh, oh, these cards are really cool. Maybe I could uh give this game another go. It'd be really fun." But no, no, no, no, no. The setup is too long. No, no, no. It's fun. And then it just becomes kind of a slo. No, no, no. Keep it together, Ashton. But man, look at all the new cards. Like, there's so many cool cards in this game. Oh, yeah. Lastly, I don't really like cooperative games that much, and so I do not want to play this game with two plus players. I just find it's easier to telepathically communicate to one hunter to another on my own. No talking needed, cuz like there's no hidden information between players, and there's not a lot of creativity to do.

It's just kind of puzzling it out. No need for a teammate. Grim Coven, that's it. It's finally out there. Oh my gosh. Oh my god. has been governed.

Progress saved