Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Fog : Escape from Paradise Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 19:24

hey everybody today i'll be taking a look at the fog escape from paradise so this is a board game due to be launched on kickstarter on march the 8th 2022 and i was asked to review and preview this by zollox games and to be honest full disclosure i was offered payment to do so however i did refuse that payment on the condition that i could give my genuine thoughts because integrity is very important to me and i wanted you as a viewer to trust my opinion so these are my genuine thoughts on the game so this one accommodates one to four players and takes around 45 to 80 minutes to play now this is going to be the retail-esque version of the game however there will be a deluxe version of the game which will have a wider player count accommodating one to six players and of course the time of the game being altered because of that so the setup is going to look like this where you've got the main board here consisting of this sea area with three boats on these docks in three different colors you've got the main beach area which is where most of the gameplay takes place with these islanders and obstacles scattered semi-randomly throughout and they're going to come in three different colors you've got blue islanders you've got red islanders and you've got green islanders however those don't associate to a particular player because you can control any of those particular colors i'm depending on a draft which we'll discuss a little bit later you've got the turn order board here that looks like this and this is going to change depending on the player count so this is for three players where it's gonna go yellow players gonna take their turn then the blue player then the pink player then the pink player again and then the

yellow player and then the blue player the blue player again and as you can see in certain points in this track you're going to trigger the fog moving which is one of the main mechanisms in the game um each player is going to have their own little kind of action tracker here which shows how many actions you have left on your turn because each turn consists of seven action points and you can spend them as you see fit and also each player is going to have their own little player reference here to show all the different moves you can make along the track along the edge of the board here you've got the fog marker which is going to keep encroaching on the island as it goes through potentially engulfing people as you go and losing the controlling player victory points which we'll discuss a bit later and also you've got this score marker along this side of the board so i think the best way to understand this game is to start with the scoring to understand how that works so there's going to be four different things that score in the game and to decide who the winner is going to be the first of which is getting the correct colored people onto the correct boats in their particular slot so you can see here this blue trap here has a spot reserved for him on the blue boat right here like so and if he's on that correct boat then you get an additional four points for each person you know doing that um however it doesn't mean that you can't put people on the other boat it just means that you're going to get those bonus four points if you get them on the correct boat and you're additionally going to get points based on the different areas they're in because you can see each of these boats consist of different rows here so you've got the top row and anybody of yours in the particular row at the end of the game is going to get seven points or this is going to change depending on how

they are flipped during the setup this section is going to get six points of each of your people there this person's gonna get four well this row is going to get four points and the bottom bit here at the stern of the ship is gonna get two points for each person on there um usually you can only have one person on each spot however there are a few exceptions and the stern at the back of the boat here you could have three two or three people on those particular spots scoring negative points is also a big factor in the game and kind of links to the main theme of the game because as the game develops this fog is going to start engulfing people on the board and anybody who's captured by that fog as in being overlapped are going to potentially lose points for you depending on how far the up on how far they are up on the beach so if they got caught right at the back here you're gonna score negative nine points for each of those but if you make it quite far but still get engulfed then you can lose you know minus three or minus two points you are really incentivized to push your people as far up as you can so before any gameplay actually takes place you're going to partake in a draft to claim these different villagers and put your particular colored disc around that tile so you can see here that in turn we've you know the yellow pair's chosen one then the black's chosen one and then the pink players chosen one and so on until all the different villages are claimed with a particular color now you might say oh why don't i pick all the ones at the front well yeah generally you might do because they haven't got much distance to travel to the boats but inevitably they're going to get gobbled up by the other players and additionally you might want to get these particular

villagers um like with these um with these icons here with the old man here and also the uh the queen lady which looks like this and because the best spots on the boat are reserved for those particular characters and these characters here are a lot more common but they are able to score fewer points so that's probably why you might want to take some other characters instead and kind of sit further back on the beach you can also see that each of these characters has a symbol at the bottom which basically dictates the strengths these characters have when executing a particular maneuver so there's a bunch of different maneuvers you can make throughout the game and each of them takes a different amount of action points or some take the same but so whenever you execute a move you're going to move this track down depending the amount of action points you use and your 10 is going to end when you use all seven of them so let's talk about all the different action points so the first one is going to be a simple maneuver where you just move one spot to the next like so and that's going to take one action point to do so and that is the only move you can use to move back along the beach or the other ones you have to move either sideways or towards the ocean the second action is to push and when you push someone you are basically can move up to two people with an action so let's just say um this character wants to push these two you can go like this and shift them along and create new opportunities and just even push your own people towards the boats which is a good maneuver to make the other one is going to be squeeze which is going to take four action points um where you can squeeze between two characters or between an obstacle and a character for

example this this lady here might want to get into this spot and she can squeeze between this rock and this person to go onto this side here and that's going to take four action points another one is to flip or switch your spot with somebody else which costs three action points so for example i could just go like this very simple maneuver another one is to jump over another character so i could go like this there to there and that is going to cost three action points another one is to jump over one of the obstacles which is going to cost four action points so for example this guy might want to jump over that over that rock like so and that's pretty much all the actions you can take but the relevance of these symbols is because if the particular particular action is on that character like this one's got the climb over obstacle one that action is only going to cost two action points for that particular character meaning that it's a lot more efficient and they have that strength to navigate the map in a particular way some other characters also have a three on them that look like this which means that any action that would cost more than three only costs that character three and some of them also have this plus one on them which means that once you use or move that character then they're going to get an extra movement point also when you get to the water area you can only ever execute the move action or the switch action um however when you do get to this um water area there are different ways you can venture for example you can go straight into the stern of the ship like so or you can start moving down these piers and um

moving like this to get to their particular spots and that is essentially how the game plays out you're just going to keep taking seven actions in turn order you know sometimes getting back-to-back moves and whenever you cross this section here the fog is going to move to the next next spot and potentially just engulf the next row of characters and hopefully with the intention of moving your characters out the way getting onto the ships to get the most victory points however there are some big twists on this game which i'll talk about now so you might have noticed from the little explanation there there is zero luck in this game everything is on the board it's completely transparent you know the action points you can take and again there's no luck factor no dice no randomness no anything like that so it can be a very meticulous and even analysis paralysis prone game if you want to min max and optimize every single move however a variant on the game which i highly recommend and i would never ever try even to play this without this is to use sand timers to take your turn so you have this amount of time in order to perform your seven actions which adds to the franticness of the nature and the nature of the game because you know this is supposed to be a game where we're in a frantic rush to get away from the fog and you know taking a more methodical approach by not using the sound timers just kind of eliminates that tension but adding these sound timers just wraps up the excitement by you know tenfold and it really does add to the feel and you know that that chaos of the game which is it really works and it also leaves you that leeway to make mistakes and i think making

mistakes in this kind of situation is what makes the game more exciting because if you can very carefully map things out again like just very methodically move things optimally as you can um it just brings the game to a bit of a standstill but by using those timers that is completely eliminated and it's not necessarily a real-time game it just acts more like a like a chess timer really just to stop you from getting that ap prone and to stop people from getting completely min-maxing each movement so that being said let's go into my thoughts on the game so first off meaningful decisions does this game have meaningful decisions absolutely it does there are so many things you need to consider so number one you've always got that threat of the fog coming on of course and these can really lose you a lot of points if you do not move the people at the back forward and sometimes these horrible bottlenecks will happen where your people at the back just cannot move you cannot you can't budge from where you are because there's so much congestion in the middle of the board and normally some stuff like that will be a bit frustrating for me because you are essentially powerless to do anything about it but it really does come through in an exciting way this one when you've got that horrible pressure coming from behind you where everybody wants to move really but bottlenecks create and start backing things up and you can't really do much but additionally you really want to move your people at the front forward because you're going to get these bonus points by getting one of those boats quicker and getting the right people into the right spot because only one person could go on each spot so everything is very um you know it's it's tight here you need to get into those spots before the other people do because the opportunities are going to quickly dwindle away so there is that really

cool tension of getting the right people on the right boat people in the boats quicker but are still avoiding the fog and also utilizing the abilities of all the different characters because you know seven action points isn't a lot and you know getting those extra point or two leeway by using the um characters abilities can go a long way if you're utilizing them correctly so there is a lot to mull over here and once you're put under that pressure of the sam timer i get that excitement comes through but still you know mixed with a good abstract style game so a very weird balance because you know normally abstract games are not entirely for me i find them a bit too i get a bit too rigid but that extra element of the time pressure and all the variation of the movement and that the way that merges with the theme of the game in the setting just works so well now something i was in two minds about when reading the rules was the drafting system i thought it doesn't really feel right for the game it doesn't really you know add much and surely there's another way that you can set up the game in a balanced fashion and get it done nice and quickly um however i will completely transparently say that i was wrong i think the draft is really exciting and is a quite a cool part of the game and it only takes a couple of minutes so literally you're going to get into the fun part and into the crux of the game quite rapidly um but i do like some of the decisions you have to make when drafting because of course the front row character is going to be great because they haven't got very far to move to their boats um but sometimes the more powerful characters you know the queen characters and the old elder character here they have the best seats reserved for them so therefore they can potentially offer

more points if you can pull off that move and get them to their right ship additionally because some of the moves work with each other in terms of like the switch rooney or the pushing ability then lining up characters next to each other can be quite a cool decision to make because you could just push people along and move several of your characters with with a one maneuver so yeah the actual drafting part i actually enjoyed which i didn't think i would now something you don't see regularly in board games nowadays is the action point system so a lot of my favorite games actually use this system you know games such as mexico and torres great kramer and kiesling classics um i haven't seen this mechanism used in many many years now i'd like to see a resurgence of it and this game actually uses it really well you know merged with an abstract kind of maneuvering game now the time investment of this game is really good providing that you play with the sound timers which again i want to stress i will always always play with those sand timers i think without it there's too much scope for analysis paralysis and it will completely detach you from the excitement of the game of that fog encroaching so i think you know if you're always playing with slam timers you cannot just sit down and mull over your turns and you're easily going to get this played in that 45 minute mark which is a spot on for me and that kind of goes into the scalability of the game as well i i always would play this with probably no more than four players i know the base game here only goes up to one to four but with the deluxe version i think there is the option to go up to six i can't really imagine playing it that way

and even in the two-player game you actually take control of two nations um and i think only your lowest of the two scores and that for me feels a bit too a bit too much for the simplicity of the game so for me the sweet spot is really three or four players particularly the three i think it works exceptionally well there is a good degree of player interaction here because of the you know the scarcity of the spots on the boat there is that frantic rush to get to them and that tense you know uh angst to get to those seats but additionally i like the kind of passive fallout of your positioning of your people because when we played this last night i had all my people kind of sat in the neck of the beach here and i i kind of drafted consciously that way where all the people behind me were just kind of stuck and couldn't move through me and i just thought you know what i'm quite safe i'll just sit here for a while while the well the fog keeps on encroaching so that's quite cool you can actually maneuver yourself that way and um you know yeah it's a bit cutthroat but you know that's part of the fun really um but yeah i do like the way that you can constantly just push people passively you know sometimes you might get a bonus move because someone wants to move you out the way or switching you around and getting that that race to get to those spots really does come through and that is all embedded in the player interaction it's quite difficult for me to comment on the production of the game because this is a retail copy sorry a review copy and i don't know how that's going to compare to the retail copy or the deluxe copy but the graphic design and stuff is absolutely fine one big issue is the colorblind issue because the red and the green tiles i can barely differentiate

them i'm color blind myself so hopefully they'll put a symbol or something on them just to help the people play that and i'm well aware that the design team are aware of that so hopefully that will be fixed relatively soon by the time the campaign launches but yeah everything else is fine though it's nice and clear i will say that the player aides are a little bit busy and could probably do with a little bit of cleaning up but generally i think once you've got those um moves memorized is not going to be too much of an issue there is also some effort being made in terms of the replayability um yeah generally the setup is going to change each time because these are again semi-rounded we put out which is going to change the drafting order and change how you approach the game um however it is going to feel quite a similar game every time because these boats are rated on the board you know these aren't modular and i think one of the stretch goals is going to be to create modular boats to change that setup just slightly to add a bit more life into the game so i think that's a welcome addition there are also some variations of the games that you can choose to play if you want to and for example sometimes you can if you want to choose these options you can like have require a certain amount of workers on these boats before they can ship off and get those points so adds a bit more attention that way and you have to kind of communally work with each other another one is to have to get the leaders off the island for that to score or so there's different kind of options you can choose to play with however for me i think that'll start to take away from the simplicity of the game and i quite like it as it is because you know this isn't a terribly complex game it does walk that kind of gateway plus level and when you start adding stuff like that to add out of the

bloat and things it starts to kind of deter me personally a bit now i know a lot of people do like that variation and just have like having that option to pull out and add an extra module or two or add an extra rule or two but i can't personally see myself ever using that um with the exception of the sound timers um additionally there are some movers you can maneuvers you can change by using these enhanced ones which add even more complexity to the maneuvers and again i don't think that's necessary i think there's enough you could do enough enough to play with with the simple actions so final thoughts on the fog escape from paradise now i have to say straight up i really enjoyed this game even way more than i was expecting to be honest now normally i'm not a huge fan of abstract games um but for me this one just works you know merged with the action selection system here or the action point allowance um really nice to see a resurgence of this and a lot of my favorite games use it and um yeah it's really good to see again now i will say again i want to stress i'll always always play with the sand timers i think it's a completely essential part of the game and again i would never even consider playing without without it weirdly enough this game managed to really execute that fear and that tension of wanting to move things along you have contrasting kind of incentives you know i want to get my people into because i want to get them in the right place and i also want to get these bonus tokens but at the same time if i losing the people at the back then i'm going to lose a lot of points if i neglect them and advancing the two is where it really lies and utilizing those maneuvers as much as possible under the time pressure is just a really exciting

merge of mechanisms and a really kind of a motive game really because i'm not a thematic gamer i generally i'm not interested in theme i purely mechanical this one the theme actually hooked me i thought it really worked well and um yeah it pulled off what it was intending to so i really think this is a niche i haven't got any game like this in my collection and i'm i'm i'm all in basically i'm a happy player and i i enjoyed the game a lot and the other people i played it with enjoyed it even more than i did so it's been a unanimous hit um and that's normally not the case so yeah it's a really cool game very unique and one that i recommend checking out um once it hits kickstarter and even beyond that so again the kickstarter does launch on the 8th of march or around that time you know if it's changed and check it out because i think everybody can get something out of this one again i want to stress i was not paid to make this review okay these are my genuine thoughts and i did refuse payments so please don't think i've had my pockets lined because it's not the case um so yeah that's already this one's going to get my shield of quality i'm more than happy to do that because it is a really enjoyable experience that is the fog escape from paradise

Progress saved