Torchlit: My Favorite Mechanism
Transcript
Hey, I'm Jamie from Stonemaier Games and today I'm going to talk about my favorite mechanism in the trick-taking game Torchlit by David Spilinsky. This is a the type of trick-taking game where you have to guess how many tricks that you think you will win. And you'll do that at the beginning of the round by setting aside a card from your hand. Here's what your hand might look like early on. You'll choose one of these cards, you will set it aside face down, and that card has a number on it determining how many tricks that you think to win. And this game does a neat thing where it tries to un-abstract that concept of bidding and winning tricks by saying if you win a trick you move forward on this dungeon track behind you. You can kind of see it on the table behind you in this image. So if I think I'm going to win four tricks I I will put a a number four card face down from my hand and I'm hoping and every time I win a trick my character will move forward one space, hopefully ending up on the fourth space of this track because I won four times.
Um there's some good things that happen if you do that. Basically each of these sections are accumulating monsters below them as selected by the person who lost the trick, the the person with the lowest numbered card in the trick. Um but I like this idea that it's it's trying to give a sense of um it trying to lose the abstractness I of of bidding for winning a trick and it it you're moving along a dungeon to fight some monsters even though all of that is also abstracted in this game. Now my favorite mechanism in this game Torchlit is that not only does the winning player move forward one space. So if we play a a a a trick and the highest suited card in that trick is a seven. So like that maybe the lead suit is a yellow and um I play the seven and that's the highest card and there's no trump card uh in that particular trick I win the trick, I move forward one space.
However, let's say someone else. So, let's say I play the seven and someone else still has a card to play and they don't have any yellow cards, they could play a seven of another suit and because they have matched the winning number played into that suit, they get to move as well. They get to move along with the uh the winner of the trick essentially. I think that's a really clever mechanism in this game. It's essentially saying isn't another way of saying it in a trick-taking game is you win the trick if you have the highest card in that trick, but you also win that trick if you match the highest card in that trick. Which opens up some decisions in this game. Like how much do you pay attention to what numbers other players are playing, when do you try to short suit yourself, when do you play those those high number cards? Do you play them always just to try to win the trick or do you hold on to them to try to just match someone because it's effectively the same as winning the trick. I think that is a really clever way of making more than one person feel like a winner every time there is a trick in this game. Didn't happen in our game, we played a four-player game, it didn't happen in every trick for sure, but it did happen a few times throughout the game. And I think as we got better at the game, we would be doing that more and more often.
So, yeah, I really like that mechanism in Torchlight. I'd love to hear your thoughts on a a games that have shared winners anywhere in the decision space where there is or the design space where there is a little bit of a a sense of shared winners or a trick-taking game that tries to lose the abstraction of what exactly are you doing in this trick-taking game. Let me know about that in the comments below. Thanks.