Age of Rome - Board Game Review - Roman Swap Meet
Transcript
hi everyone I'm lukor and you're watching the broken meele this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kendra. Kender stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on orders over £30 further discounts on bulk purchases and even 5% of your spending refunded back to you as points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection A F of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so today I'm taking a look at age of Rome I believe this is a deluxe version of a new game released from T totem Studios thank you for the review copy and this one I saw at Essen but never really got a chance to dive into it so this one is a bit of a late arrival in my books this one intrigued me though because of one of the mechan mechanisms that it has essentially each player is responsible to begin with for one of their districts out of four which they can build buildings which allow them to do more powerful actions but the with these districts is that once you finish a round the board rotates and so in the next round you're responsible for a different district and it could be one with less players it could be one that hasn't been built on at all but ideally with four players it's going to be one that someone else has built up and you
know ahead of time which way it's going to turn and you know how much so you're aware that somebody else is going to get a district you're about to work on and you're thinking about well do I want to build this so that they can use that and what am I going to get I'm going to get that piece of rubbish over there and it's it's an interesting little Dynamic but that I had not seen in many games and I figured you know what this is something that I need to try out and see if it is and it's also a new publisher so it's a bit of a sort of Debut game for them so again you know new faces on the Block New Kids on the Block shall we say and I wanted to see if it could like stand the test you know can it do well for a first game from a new publisher with an interesting little concept well let's find out so as I mentioned age of Rome is about controlling these districts so in a round you flip over one event card that will tell you a particular event that you have to follow and what direction this board is going to turn you will be in charge of your specific board so that's just say it's fa this one is facing me for reasons and you have money you have other items that you might be able to use from other cards from Trading but for the most part it's a case of I've got some money do I want to build a building here well you've got a lot of very cool looking acrylic buildings here which if I can get the cover off you can basically decide you know what I want to build a level one military building so in it goes and it's upgraded I get points it can it costs more money to upgrade but it allows you to place one of your workers on said space in order to trigger the action associated with that building military politics trade and so forth each one having a different action like say area control on a military side down here uh putting your vote tiles on
the center column here for like politics which we'll get onto the theme in a bit later but essentially another type of way to score points you can potentially build up your par andon pieces on your sideboard in order to get points that way or or you can simply just draw trade cards which are essentially these green cards here and it's mostly for set collection as well as potential special abilities if you play the card for its effect you've also got a couple of other methods to score points such as Quest cards that you've drawn at the start of the game and might draw more of as the game goes on and in terms of some of the interaction there's an an essence of screwage in that you are able to lay down schemes and on from your player board which if I find a player board example we have one of which there are several and the scheme tokens basically allow you to you know do things to other players like maybe kill off one of their parfenon pieces or get in their way but what you're essentially doing is plugging up their little board here in order that they don't get the special bonuses that might apply to certain actions like Leva here for example is very good at trade and politics sucks a bit of the military well you know I don't want to be schemed against because then I lose my bonus to trade and the rest of it is just that there are pieces on your board and you'll unlock them as the game goes on but as the game carries on these districts are more and more lucrative so you'll gain money at the end of each round based on how many buildings are there and you know where it's going to rotate so next time I'm going to get this one hm what do I do with this one this turn and this carries on for nine rounds and of course once you get to the end total up the victory points and guess what happens to the person who's
got the most of course so certainly from a production standpoint this is insane I mean the retail version of this is still pretty damn good okay this is a Deluxe copy of it which is not cheap you're certainly paying quite a bit for this one especially if you got a essid but you have got this rotating board which essentially you plug it up with this like little disc in the middle and it revolves around nice and easily that's in the normal game you've got little game trays with wooden pieces that are organized for your particular area you've got an insert at the bottom of the box to hold this board and various other components you also have the acrylic buildings which are really cool um I'll have to double check if they are in the retail version but certainly in this deluxe version it is nice to get these things cuz it's like a clear overlay that you put over these and it gives that kind of visual impression of the area is being built up you've even got metal coins in this particular set and you know you get a little pouch for these and metal coins are always a good thing so you are certainly getting a very nice looking game here and it will turn heads and it will really pop on Instagram photos but like I said this is the deluxe version and it does cost a pretty penny the component quality is a bit less in the retail version but not by much it's not a massive drop down and certainly it's still going to look really good it's still got this vibrant artwork and everything so honestly looks wise for a first for a first game that's pretty good going you good looking hot
the game is also quite a simple one to learn the rule book may look big but the first eight pages are literally just you know components and some like background on some of these characters so you know that bit doesn't really count but then you've got the full setup diagram with numbered areas and even though it looks like there's a decent amount of rules in here for the most part it's illustrations there's not a huge amount of text in here which is kind of what a rule book should be not just wall after wall of text give me pictures in fact this one I dare say almost goes to the extreme of being a little bit too illustrative because you'll have a a thing about schemes and how they work and then it will have this whole page devoted to examples about how they work like every potential example having an FAQ for this game I think it's going to be n and impossible because this book goes into so much detail trying to explain how something works with every possible scenario that you shouldn't have an FAQ moment so really learning this game is quite easy it certainly isn't pick up and play and there's definitely an element of complexity to it but the rule book does a damn good job of explaining things and I think very rarely did I have to find myself referencing the book I think once I got it down I got it down so fair play to you and that goes as well for the solo mode which is contained in its own little book not a difficult solo mode to do and as I say this may look like a lot of pages but this is the solo mode rules and all of this is just simply an example game like an example game or example turns played out with a solo
mode in it so you know got to give him credit I would rather take the extreme of explaining things too much than not explaining things enough that's easy if you're looking for interaction in your Euro this one does a pretty good job of portraying it not every action in the game is particularly interactive you want to gain money with the Farms or do trade cards that doesn't really affect other players as much but you do butt heads with the military area control as well as the politics I suppose you could call it area control you're effectively stacking them up and if you can get a set of three you get points but everybody's kind of chipping in and then it wipes out the one at the bottom once you get to a stack of five it's so this thing's constantly changing this thing's probably constantly shifting but those are the two out of the five actions where you're actually caring about the opponent where you really do care about the opponent though is twofold the schemes where depending on where the scheme is on the board after it rotates round is what player it's going to affect but mainly just the whole concept of this rotating board is interaction in itself because I know what board I'm going to have next round I also know who's going to get my board at the end of this round and all those things have to be considered because there's no point to me building a building that's so good good for the person after me and not as good for me it's like well hang on I don't want to give this person loads of extra I don't want to give this person a military action because if he do he's going to block me on this space you know what no military building for you but then you know you're going to get a board where somebody has built it quite highly on the trade side it's like well maybe I can do something with trade then but for now I need to work on this oh he doesn't have any politics
buildings right I need to maybe I should do a politics now knowing that I'm not going to get it in a minute it's there's a few elements like that that you have to think about and but this game does even though it's got a simplistic rule book it's still got quite a few bit areas of complexity with regards to what you're thinking about because you are considering what other players could build what they want to be build oh sorry what they want to be built and what their potential like Scupper actions are doing you know somebody's trying to Scupper you on the politics well maybe you don't want to give them a politics building next round it's little things to consider and it does generate a little bit of AP now and again but for the most part it's still a relatively smooth effect the game also has a solid Arc in which it starts off being like I've only got one worker and I just do one building that's it you know you don't feel that you do very much in the first couple of rounds but it does quickly ramp up and by the time you get to the later rounds particularly sort rounds seven eight and nine you are doing quite a lot to me you may have unlocked most of your followers in which case you've got a good five or six different actions that you can perform in a turn all these places would have been built up with these different buildings that can use multiple workers like you know a level three military building can use three separate workers to do military and at that point you're generating more money to build better buildings and it does feel like as you get to the end of the game the stuff that you have been doing earlier on mattered and you get to play around with more stuff now this will have a knock on effect as I'll get into in a minute but it does mean that the game isn't linear it means that it's also you know not quite a like oh you know this is a
predictable thing that will happen it's like no depending on what other players do this game will lead to some very different styles of games depending on what people build you know if people go really heavy on the politics thing then well the place is going to be Litter with politics buildings but H nobody really built much in the military section well uh that's going to be hard then so where when are we actually going to get to do a military action suddenly that action is a lot more valuable than some of the other ones and cool little twists like that just make this a little bit more interesting but it's not all perfect and there are flaws let's go on to probably my biggest flaw first this is the thing that kind of irks me a bit too much there's something games that I really don't like I tend to roll my eyes when I see this because it usually feels like a a lazy mechanic that's thrown in to add a randomizer when you don't need one well the randomizer in this is the event deck and this one is a little bit of a problem because this event deck you deal out nine of them for a game so you've got nine one for each round you flip it over at the start it has an effect which usually affects everybody possibly and then it tells you what you're going to twist the board so left right anticlockwise clockwise 180° 90° whatever but the problem with these events is that I don't mind the fact that the directions it turns is randomized because you can play a variant where you turn it clockwise you know 90° every single turn so if you want the Strategic element you can do that but I'm actually cool with the fact
that I don't necessarily know if it's going to go back and forth between two players and that but the events are very swingy in how they work because they typically say like players with the most of this or players with the fewest of this but you don't know what's going to happen so it's entirely random as their effects and they can be pretty important things I mean saying like you know players with the fewest money win one money per recruited follower well that can suddenly Propel the person in last place on that front you know to Lord knows when and it's not that these necessarily help who's in last place it's normally who has the least of a particular thing so you know what we got here um yeah players with the fewest victory points on their Parthenon minimum one piece built win one money per recruited follower well my whole strategy might be in something else and I'm doing really well and I'm probably going to win this card just gave me even more money so the rich just got richer I honestly do not like event decks and I don't think this one works either but you can house rule this because there's nothing stopping you from simply ignoring the event and only caring about the direction on the card and honestly I think that's going to be the way I play this game from now on I don't think I ever want to use the event deck for its sness and just the sort of like you know occasionally helps the wrong person but if you want to play the Strategic and just do the 90 degre thing fine I for one I'm just going to ignore the text and refer to the arrow and that usually does me fine you can't do that you can't do that and here's the other big issue the player scaling the
player scaling in this game doesn't quite work you can play this solo two three or four player honestly I think this game has only one player count four and it's not often that I would say play with the most players but here I think you have to play with four I just think it works out better because if you play this with two players you're only looking at one Board of pieace which means as the game goes on a couple of these provinces are going to build up a lot quicker than a couple of the others and one of them might not get touched at all and you know you can play as a co-op against the AI but you know if you're looking for a competitive game two players I just don't think works that well although some people have said differently fre player definitely doesn't work I mean it doesn't make for the the game to be horrible but if You' got one person two person three person building up these and one left over then imagine that you flip those event cards and one person you know ends up with a situation where the board goes one back one back let's say it does that three or four times in a row which it can do pretty easily that means that that person has got one province that isn't being built up by others so they're having noticeably weaker turns than the others who are on provinces that have been built up every single round so free player doesn't work solo feels very much like a two- player now you know I'm I'm I'm in charge of this bit and occasionally other bits get built up again it just feels like a two player and I don't think it works well there but this game shines at its best with four because you want everybody on a
province you want somebody to be working on a province every every round whether they do it optimally or not is down to them but at least every Province gets something every round and so this game is Just tailor made for four players and I don't think I would ever want to play it with less at least not ideally but this leads into another issue because when you have that many players the game length goes a little bit off the scale because this one claims on the box somewhere it's like a 60-minute game yeah good luck with that 60 minutes I guess if you play it solo and even then you need to know what you're doing and not check rules or anything like that yeah so you might be able to do it in 60 but no you're looking at bare minimum a 90 minute game here and this can easily go on 2 hours that's pretty long for a game that's not that complex in terms of its rule set just has a you know only nine rounds I think that's just going a little bit too far particularly if you're teaching this to new players and they kind of AP over the options and they're not entirely certain what they should do on a round you're easily looking at 90 to 120 Minutes for a typical 3 to four player game if you're lucky maybe you could cut it down to 75 but you would have to have some very Speedy players and it's just crossing a line where I think it goes on a bit too long but the problem is if you play with less players you've got less of a game so you've got to kind of decide which do you prefer do you want the four players but you go with the extra length or do you play a lesser game with less players but still but you know curb the length down I'm at that point where I were like
you know okay fine I'll deal with the fact that it's a longer game game I'll play this with four but still I wish it was a little bit quicker the theme is also a little bit on the abstracted side I mean artwork wise looks great for the setting that it's trying to do I mean that is a fantastic looking cover you know it's a great you know these player boards dual recess with a big portrait are really cool the board is an instagrammer wet dream I mean seriously the pictures I put up with Instagram for this looked gorgeous when you put them through so visually looks amazing the theme is kind of very abstracted though and I was kind of hoping that a bit more of the theme would come out of this game but it is a very dry Affair in fact this kind of worried me at first when I was playing it the first impression I got when I read the rules and saw what this kind of all was was of traum Tran is a stepan Feld game which is basically just a bunch of mini gamess all thrown together to see what happens I really don't like tran tran is not a game I like and I was worried I was going to get the same level of hatred here thankfully no the mini games here are a lot more simpler but they are essentially mini games you know the area the military is basically just put a guy on an area and if you've got the most you get 10 if you got the second most you got five I mean that's all it really is you can move them about but that's it there's no other weird combat rules the whole politics thing politics is basically putting these little discs on the central snack and trying to get free in a row so that you score points or trying to end up with your one in the middle and one at the
very bottom and all to score the most points in the stack I don't know why the middle is so important but the other bits aren't and so the politics I mean it's no voting or anything it's just literally a stack of tokens so that's a little bit abstracted and then everything else I mean the Farms is literally just gain income nice and quick the trade is literally just taking cards and trying to collect sets I mean there's no actual trade between players or anything and what's the other one the paron piece you literally just build the paron on a little sideboard next to your thing you build it looks visually interesting but that's it it just scores various points per piece you shov down that's kind of all it is so the theme is neither really here or there if you are hoping for a formatic like roam setting with all the stuff that that comes with it you're not going to get it here this is essentially a bunch of mini games with a cohesive Narrative of like moving the board around and twisting it there but yeah it is essentially mini games so age of does have some interesting quirks to it they tried something new and the concept is cool and I do like this aspect of rotating the board and working on something that other people have done that element is Pretty Sweet It Is Well produced whether it's retail or Deluxe I mean particularly if it's Deluxe couple of little minor niggles with some of the pieces and that but you know nothing major you know other than that everything else looks gorgeous artwise and component wise the main things that do hurt this game and they do hurt it quite badly are those events which I do think kill some of the enjoyment in the
game but they are easily house ruled but for the main part the player scaling is just a bit of an issue because solo is fine but I don't think this is a game I want to play solo two-player again I don't like the idea that you're working on not every Province at the same time and free players can just end up with a lot of major imbalances and it's not fun if you're the third player who gets stuck with the rubbish Province on a regular basis it can happen it's just there with the cards so maybe you have to play with the Strategic variant by you know twisting it clockwise round but then again turn order I mean you know do you want to get that empty Province at the first turn of the game or do you want to get it four turns later it's again it just feels a little bit imbalanced so you're kind of restricted to play age of Rome as a four player game only and then you have the problem the game kind of takes a little bit too long to finish so you know there's a few things that get in the way of what could have been a really fantastic game but it's still decent but I think it's it's hard to say would you pay this much money for this game knowing that you had to pretty much play it with four players and it still wasn't necessarily perfect you know I think this is a pretty solid debut from this company but not quite solid enough that I can recommend it for everybody I think I'm giving this one I'm giving this one a high 6 out of 10 I think it's still above average and it's still something that I have enjoyed playing and would happily play at the 4 player count and
notice my player scaling at the bottom of this video where you will notice that I actually do consider this to be a 7 out of 10 endorsement rating with four players specifically four players at that level it works nicely but I just think it's not quite there with other players you know and I can't as much as I can house rule the event deck you don't get brownie points for me fixing a design floor in the game you know I'm just saying that that is the fix but it's still an issue with the game and that everybody likes the house r things so it's still an above average game you know I can't quite bump it up to a seven unless you are going to play this with four players only and that is your sole reason for having the game but as a four player game I do like it and think it works I just don't think it quite works with less players but you know they've got another one coming out in Kickstarter soon called restart that looks pretty sweet so I'll be interested to check that one out and as I say first game new publisher so this was an interesting concept something a bit different doesn't fully work but it does work in some aspects quite nicely and so I want to see what they come up with next it's about how hard you can get hit and keep moving forward how much you can take and keep moving forward so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on board gamee when it goes live on the page don't forget to check out all the other content I've been doing this month mainly my top 100 which is at least 60 games into the top 100 and I better get on with doing the next 20 in just a second so until next time remember regardless of which way you want this board to twist on your next term it's
still only a game so try not to get too addicted to it and I'll see you next
time