Skip to main content
Loading video...

Libertalia: Winds of Galecrest Review

Transcript 12:48

i really want to tell you about libitalia winds of gale crest and why it's my favorite game of the year so far it's the new version of libitalia a game that was released 10 years ago but has been out of print for what feels like 20 years and it's designed by paulo mori one of the most consistent designers out there behind blitzkrieg pandemic fall of rome and well libertaria the original was one of the few good pirate games out there and rare because you don't just play as pirates you play like pirates you're trying to collect the most gold and you do it by stealing and killing and being a selfish bastard and libertarian wins of gale crest is the same except you play as sky pirates but please just go with it it's worth it each round is a voyage across the open seas sorry skies and every day there is loot to be divided up it's like dating there's enough for everyone to get booty but some you want a lot more than others and if you're picking last after all your friends have already taken the good ones you could end up with a cursed relic a man in his 40s who's never had therapy true to life that relic will lose you money so how do you get first dibs on the best loot you have to play the highest ranked pirate sorry sky pirate you each have a hand of sky characters and every day you will pick one of them and reveal at the same time they get laid out on the board in order of rank first the characters take daytime

actions for example the beggar takes two gold from the highest ranked character so where you are in the lineup is really important and not just for the loot after day comes dusk and it's time to take your treasure you go back through the characters in reverse order so the highest ranked character gets first picked then second highest and so on but what should you take well the chest for five gold is a no-brainer but they're rare i love the gamble of taking a map because you need at least two of them for it to be worth anything and there's no guarantee you'll get another one but you do know your chances i love that you can look ahead and see what loot you'll be fighting over for the rest of the voyage it's so important for planning what cards you're gonna play and when you can see which days the curse relics are out and if you can save your higher cards for those days then you should be able to avoid them but that never fits your plan you see these six cards you have are huge or at least their potential is huge if you play them in the right order the bosun gains two gold for each character currently in your ship with a rank lower than 21. okay so you need to play that one late on after you've already played some lower characters but the freed prisoner gains a gold every night for every character higher than 20 and the boson is higher than 20. so now you want to play the bosun early then the freed prisoner the way the cards in this game play off of each other is genius no card is an

island they're all part of a delicate ecosystem influencing each other and timing is everything imagine you're a stand-up comedian these six cards are all bits of your act they're all really funny in their own right but some are better played early to warm the audience up whereas others have callbacks in they won't be as funny if you haven't already set up the joke earlier but you're not performing in a bubble you are being constantly heckled by your opponents who are trying to throw you off if you play your infantry hoping to get five gold as the right most character but someone else plays the brute that will activate first and kill the rightmost character so your infantry dies and not only do you not get the five gold but you won't get any loot today either it's brutal but the genius of this game is that you knew it could happen because everyone has exactly the same cards everyone started with an infantry and a brute so the brutes will be played and characters will die but they don't have to be yours it's all about timing if you play a high card because you really want that map you do it knowing that someone could play a brute and ruin your day there's something brilliant about that you're the kid in class daring to put their hand up hoping for glory but risking humiliation it's a cutthroat game but it feels fairer than most cutthroat games because the knives are all signposted you wouldn't mind as much being killed

if you just moved in next to charles manson and at the start of the voyage you can see how many of chekov's sabres there are in the loot so you know exactly how many murders will happen and exactly when to be scared it's like a horror film for control freaks so rather than death being a take that surprise it's an expectation and the fun is in trying to cheat it every day that you keep your bar keep alive feels like a victory and i love the gamble of playing the gambler or the carpenter which cost you money when you play them and will only pay out if they're still alive at the end of the voyage so they're prime targets for your rivals to kill having the same hand as each other means you will often pick the same card as someone else you turned up to the party in the same outfit embarrassing when that happens your rank is determined by your order on the reputation track so once again you can look at the open information and plan around it if you get the sense that brad pitt is going to wear the same outfit as you you wear something else no one can withstand that kind of direct comparison you can change your position on the reputation track with certain characters and by taking barrels sorry sky barrels the new tiebreaker system is elegant it fits the game perfectly and is a big improvement on the original game's flawed system by the end of the first voyage you won't have played all your cards the characters you have left stay in your hand for the second voyage and that's where the game gets even more

interesting because now you all get a new identical set of six characters but your hands won't be exactly the same anymore because you will have carried over different cards from the first voyage and which six characters get added will give a completely different dynamic part of the puzzle is reading that dynamic and knowing which cards will be important if you save your win nymph until the final voyage when no one else has one you will get two gold every day and the smugness of the kid who saved their snickers until the end of the hike instead of eating it in the first 10 minutes like everyone else from the outside you might think that libitalia with only 30 unique cards could get boring but it's precisely because it's a small set that it works every one of them a strong character pushing each other's buttons like a dysfunctional family christmas if you tried to invite more guests it would just dilute the intensity except winds of gale crest does add some cards but only 10 and it has changed others even removed some i don't want to go into every change it's mostly small tweaks to rebalance things and ways to manipulate your reputation there's a lot to like in the new characters like the necromancer who will bring a dead character back to life in exchange for a cursed relic so it gives you a reason to actually want one which is a nice twist it's nice to get even more variety from the game and on that front i really like what they've done with the loot powers by giving you two ways to play them there's the calm

abilities which are a bit softer i mean the saber still kills someone so not that soft and stormy abilities which are more brutal on the stormy side a relic will lose you one gold every night and what's really nice is that you can use the tiles to mix and match which powers you like again making each game feel different i really like the new hook power which you can use to carry over a character you've played this voyage so it goes back into your hand for the next one all the changes they've made to libertalia feel seamless like they've always been there it didn't need transforming it was already a brilliant game now it's a tad more brilliant and crucially you still feel like a paranoid pirate sorry paranoid sky pirate surrounded by people you don't trust the gameplay remains like the original unashamedly cutthroat so why does it feel like the rest of the game is ashamed libertalia is a game about pirates fighting over treasure that's not just the theme it's what you do in the game it's all you do in the game so on the box are some pirates the characters you'll be playing in the game surrounded by treasure and on the winds of gale crest box there is none of that there's no treasure and there's one character with their back to us this cover makes it seem like it's a game of sailing and exploration which it just isn't the bright colors and font choice are calming and hopeful the exact opposite of the gameplay i'd call it the disney vacation of libitalia but disney

made a pirate film and it would make for a better cover than this it's like it's been given a rebrand by an advertising agency that doesn't understand the product it's marketing starting with the name winds of gale crest okay i've got three words we have to use do they describe the game no but they give a feel of the game no of weather are we embarrassed of the game i haven't played it but yes wind gale crest why use one word that is related to sailing when you can sneak two more in by combining them to create a fictional place that doesn't feature in the game winds of gale crest is the name equivalent of lift music it has all the flavor and substance of courgetti spaghetti it sounds like words taken from a 90s advert for tampons you know what the name does have perfect search engine optimization it turns out that if you create a sentence that means nothing no one else in the world will have ever used it and then we have the sky pirates i don't know why they went with sky pirates but in my head the decision went something like this so the original game was about pirates but we want to distance ourselves from real pirates because they did some pretty bad things okay let me think sky pirates right you've just added a word in front of it yeah exactly distance what even is a sky pirate i don't know no one does there's no frame of reference no baggage but surely sky

pirates also kill people and steal their treasure do they we can be vague about that maybe they find their treasure lying around yeah piracy is the act of robbery or criminal violence okay we'll make them animals sky pirate animals that'll soften it up yes like in evidence like cute little creatures no not at all i want them and this is very important to look like they have sex like a human look i'm no fan of the original artwork and neither is the actress alicia cuthbert but it's gone from a game that knew what it was to a game with an identity crisis what is the point to trick people into buying a mean game by making it look like a pleasant day at the beach i would say it's targeted at families but the age rating is 14 plus the only thing i like about libitalia cringe of gale crest is the gameplay and the truth is that's all that matters you know when you eat leftovers and it looks a bit funny but you know it's still good so you close your eyes and focus on the taste that's what it's like playing this game the presentation's a little off but it still tastes incredible after years of wanting it one of my lovely patrons called derek sent me his copy of the original libertaria but winds of gale crest is the one going into my collection i'd rather play the better game with more variety no matter what it looks like just like i'd rather

play a game with my friend ben moss than with kate moss no matter how good looking she is that's it if you want to buy a copy of the game there are links in the description below and if you'd like to support the channel and get my monthly newsletter where i talk about games that i don't talk about on the channel please go to patreon.com forward slash actual lol i'm john perkis thanks for watching

you

Progress saved