Beyond Solitaire Podcast 78: Scout Blum on Rising Waters
Transcript
hey gamers this is liz davidson for beyond solitaire and i'm here with a very special guest professor scout bloom who teaches at troy university in alabama how you doing scott i'm doing good liz how are you i'm delighted to have you on uh before we get going we should disclose something which is that we have something in common uh you are having a game published through cmu's academic press is that correct that's right uh it's a game called rising waters and i'm really excited about that it's going to be one of the first board games that they put out and they're an academic press so i think it's just a really good fit for the game fantastic and i will be talking with you some more about this later but i felt we should disclose this because i am sponsored by cmu's center for learning through games and simulations so scout and i wanted to talk to each other of our own free will but we have a mutual connection
so um scout uh what is your what subject do you teach let's start there so i am a history professor by trade at troy um and i've been teaching for about 21 years there um i my areas are gender history african-american history and environmental history for my research what i center on really now has been the history of childhood in its connections with environmental history so i'm working on a book about um really looking at the precursors of climate change activism by young people um particularly in the 60s and 70s so that's sort of academically where i am i guess fantastic what you mean uh greta dunberg wasn't the first well one of the things i'm looking at is how how unique the modern day movement is but also you know sort of where it it comes from and and you know sort of how kids have been active in uh environmental issues for a really long time um there are some very very unique aspects to what is going on now but then there are also some things that they've kind of carried through so it's a really interesting area to to get into because you know not a lot of people have have talked about kids in activism or kids in the environmental movement really that is fascinating actually but aside
from your book you also bring a lot of gaming into your classroom so what are some of the ways that you have chosen to do that recently so yeah i really enjoy using games in the classroom and i found them very rewarding i found that they engage students um you know that they really can particularly sometimes for students who are struggling in other areas that it can be a way for them to kind of come into the subject in a bit more accessible way so i mean i do a lot of different things in my freshman level history classes we do reacting to the past games which are historical role-playing games so we do those frequently we have a class called history through games and what we do in that class is we will look at a topic so i'll give them some background in lecture and then we'll play a game uh to sort of see how the game is similar or different from um the history that we've talked about and we'll play all kinds of games in that class i mean we've played pandemic we've played settlers of catan dominion you know we do all kinds of a big range of things and they really enjoy those kind of connections and then i also teach a history of game design class which is one of my favorites it kind of begins with um you know very very early cultures the sumerians and the egyptians and kind of walks through the different
games that different cultures have had and how they're connected to their culture and we go up through video games so you know that's that's much more of a history class really but we do play a lot of games in there as well so that's a lot of fun but i really enjoy incorporating games in a lot of different ways i think it really enhances learning that's amazing how do you balance between what you want your students to learn academically and making sure that they're up on the rules of the games that you teach for their actual enjoyment yeah that could be kind of a challenge because sometimes what you get are students who think history through games is all we're doing is playing games and i don't have to learn anything so there there is a balance there and you sort of have to be up front with them about you know this is a learning class too we are going to be learning content um one of the things you know we have um lectures that i do over certain topics like when we play katan i will do a building blocks of civilization uh lecture so we talk about sort of what makes a civilization um and we'll have maybe a notes quiz over that to make sure that they're focused and staying on topic with you know taking notes at the lecture we might do something that sort of has them do worksheets where we're kind of filling out different criteria for different civilizations like egypt and china and those kinds of things for the games in particular one thing i
found really helpful i always post the rules for the kids but i also post videos so how to play videos or reviews they're required to watch those and then i also have them take just a little quiz which is a really straightforward you know simple quiz but it's just to sort of verify that they've done that work um and you know are ready to come to class and play the game and the reason that i find that really effective is one year i i didn't do it and um because i said well i'll just trust them to you know do the find the rules for themselves and you know go over the video for themselves and we were playing axis and allies which you might imagine what's going to happen um they get into class and of course none of them have watched the video none of them have looked at the rule book and you know axis and allies is a fairly i mean it's a it's a very light war game but it's a war game and it you know has a lot to it so they spent the entire class period setting the game up because they had no idea what was going on and there were a couple of kids who had actually you know done their work and so that was incredibly frustrating so you know one of the things that i found is that they do need to be sort of pushed into making sure that they're preparing for those games i think that's a real balancing act um you want them to have fun and you want them to be engaged but if you're playing some of these board games that they have no experience with they have to have some preparation for it
um you know so i found that really low stakes small quick little quizzes or a good way to kind of get them to to do that i guess interesting okay so you're teaching katan as part of a history through games class and one of the things that i always hear about katan like when we're talking about things like games about colonization right and taking over land is that catan represents sort of a fictional black slate place where uh no one's getting hurt there's no one there to displace you just have this open territory where anybody can go and how does that come through uh in your class or does it do students pick up it on your on their own is there something that you want them to get out of katan how do you lead them there well i mean so katan when we're looking at that we're looking at sort of the elements of building a civilization so one of the things that it shows is the importance of things like urban centers the importance of things like trade the importance of things like using resources from your hinterlands but we definitely get into what the games don't do as well you know we we talk about well what are the games missing what do the games not include and certainly this idea of you know not only that there's no you know native settlers there that there these people are displacing um but there's no war there's no conflict between the players and we talk a lot about how
um you know how how euro games developed and how that was in germany a very specific response to uh world war ii and to you know sort of wanting to stay away from this idea of conflict and warfare so i i think yeah absolutely you know we get into those kind of concepts of what the game does not include and what it doesn't have because that tells us a lot about the culture that the game comes from as well so we can get not only these ideas about how the game is portraying and remembering history but also ideas about what does it say as a primary source about you know early 2000s germany or you know 1990s germany or whatever so absolutely and you know those kind of issues of representation um are a key component of the class absolutely you ever offered your students a game that they felt uncomfortable playing um we talk about games like that but we really haven't particularly played one like we talk about brendo romero's train um which if you're familiar with that game is a game and really her games are almost as much art as they are game design i mean these are very very powerful sort of messages and train in particular is about the holocaust where you're playing the game but it's not until the end that you realize that you're sending people off
to concentration camps really so we talk about games like that and about how games can deal with uncomfortable topics how games can teach about different things i always tell my students it's like movies you know you might one day want to go see a comedy you might one day want to go see something really serious that makes you start crying and games can be like that you know they're they're board games role-playing games they can elicit different emotions and that's fine and you know that's a good thing um we haven't really i'm trying to think if we've played any games that make people uncomfortable particularly i've been wanting to incorporate freedom which is a game about the underground railroad but but have not yet done that um we kind of ran out of time this semester but yeah i mean we kind of talk about those concepts but we haven't really played games like that yet i guess interesting i always wonder about these things you know myself which is why i ask uh and then the other thing that's really interesting is i find so i've also uh spoken to patrick rail recently so yes you know i've talked to multiple professors who are using commercial board games in their classrooms and it's fine he's amazing absolutely so i find this interesting though because you know do you find that commercial games are good to use in a classroom or are you using them because they are what's
available and you would like to see board games that are more specifically targeted for classroom use um both um you know i think my game was rising waters was a game that i developed to fill a gap that i felt was needed but i think that there are a lot of historical games out there that can be extremely useful in the classroom and by that i don't mean necessarily that they are good or accurate historically even if they are bad or even if they are you know have a lot of holes in them from a historical standpoint i think that can be really really useful in the classroom to be able to point out to them that hey you know look at what this game is missing and let's talk about why it's missing that or you know let's look at why puerto rico has quote unquote colonists and not you know people who were slaves who were really laboring so i think that there are a lot of games out there that if teachers use them and think about them you know that they can really get a lot out of and again they don't necessarily have to be quote unquote accurate historically to be able to get a lot out of them and i think one thing that kids kind of seem to enjoy is to sort of figure out when games go wrong i guess you know just sort of like if they're catching
them in the act or something i don't know they like doing that with film too because i've used film quite a bit in classroom in the classroom oh the movie's not right about this um but uh yeah i mean i think that there are a whole bunch of really really useful games to use in the classroom but the other i mean sure there are a lot of gaps um i think um you know i was involved with the zenobia award um contest this past year and that really showed in just a million cool ways how how many gaps there are and how amazing games can be when you diversify designers you know when you start bringing in people who are not considered typical you know white male designers the topics and the kinds of things that you'll get games on are just phenomenal and i am so looking forward to a lot of those games to be able to use them in the classroom i mean it's just very very exciting to see some of those topics come out that's awesome uh so let's turn to your game then tell us about rising waters so rising waters is a game that is set during the 1927 mississippi flood and this is one of the worst environmental disasters in our nation's history the players take on the roles of african-american sharecroppers
and basically the game is a way to help players understand how african-americans dealt with the twin problems of nature you know this massive huge flood but also the completely embedded racism of the white landowners in the area so as you play the game you know you're faced with both of these threats and you're trying to deal with them and to to stay alive using um ways that african americans had to assert some power and agency and control over those lives in a in really difficult situations so i know absolutely nothing about this flight so can you use that can you give us the background of what happened what went down sure so um in the fall of 1926 um there was a lot of heavy rains so the mississippi started to get kind of uh filled and and ready to flood basically um but it didn't actually have like massive amounts of flooding in the fall um the engineers of the time period of the 1920s were very sort of full of themselves and quite convinced that humans were able to master and control the environment
and flooding of the mississippi had been a problem for some time it tends to flood on a regular basis because that's what the mississippi does um and but you know that can jeopardize a lot of those really big money-making crops particularly cotton um you know in the in the area and that needed to be controlled so engineers felt they needed to control the river in order to make sure that those crops got protected the solution that they landed upon were levees which are basically sort of built up areas of land on the edges of the river to sort of keep the river contained and this was really the only thing that they had to control the flooding the spillage of the river all up and down the mississippi um it got to the point where the mississippi river you know you have these levees the river is actually flowing above the level of the ground basically you know the ground is about 10 feet below where the river is flowing you would have to look up and you could see boats going by um and this creates a huge problem in the spring of 1927 when there are just massive amounts of rain um and the rain inundates some of the tributaries that run into the mississippi and then the mississippi just i mean levees are just breaking all over the
place because they're not really built to to deal with these things things like that at that level um there are points the mississippi gets so flooded that it's you know 60 70 miles wide in places the river is uh you have hundreds of thousands of people who are displaced by the flooding in the spring um you know it's it's just a tremendous human catastrophe as well as a natural one and the main people who suffer um you know there were obviously white people there but they got very much preferential treatment the african americans who are in the area suffered at far far greater levels uh than than whites and just had to go through really completely devastating kinds of conditions uh during the course of this this flood so so how in the game so you you've explained why uh african americans are the primary actors in this game uh how did you ensure that you were telling their story correctly and reflecting it in ways that were sensitive yeah so um you know this is one of my research areas so i've spent the past 30 years studying african american history and you know i also study
environmental disasters that's another one of my my areas my first book was on an environmental disaster called love canal which um was more man-made than natural one of the things that i really figured into the game was and that i really wanted to come out was a sense of african americans as having a sense of agency and power and control over their lives um and we see these kind of elements you know with slavery and then throughout that that that black people had ways of resisting and had ways of being empowered so in the game one of the things that you do is um there are worker cards and these worker cards represent different levels of power or agency for african americans so there are family cards there are garden cards farm animals church the blues which was really developing at the time and there were hundreds hundreds but there are many many many blue songs written about the mississippi flood of 27.
so you have these cards that you collect and using those cards which were traditional avenues of power for african americans you can increase your powers so you can increase the abilities that you have in the game like you could move more or you can it's it's um you have more workers to help out or or these kinds of things um in addition the worker cards also have what's called resistance cards and these were sort of ways that black people were able to resist some of the oppressions so we have media outlets things like newspaper and radio we also have um you know different kinds of things like um outside activism there was a lot of activism by the naacp people like w ebd boys and ida wells barnett were really publicizing what was going on uh so you have outside activism uh people were raising money through vaudeville shows to send down to the victims of the flood that's another resistance card so in the game i think this is a long answer to your question in the game there are cards that represent um traditional avenues of power for african americans and you use those to build up your power to be able to ease more easily survive the flood i guess that's an answer yeah no makes sense uh so how do you win
the game is this cooperative is it somehow competitive i'm just curious the game is a cooperative game so the players are working together um what they are trying to do is to survive the game with as few losses as possible over the 14 rounds of the game the flood was about 14 weeks long it lasted pretty much through the summer and so if the players can last through those 14 rounds without getting going over the number of losses then they win the game and losses are you can lose have losses through different things if uh land gets flooded uh if you if a town gets flooded or if a worker gets flooded out so there are different kinds of things that can cause losses to add up but basically you're trying to minimize your losses and stay around until the 14th round to win got it so by loss that's an somewhat all-encompassing tournament can mean loss of property it can mean loss of a human life yes yes yes um you know it also includes there were the landowners who were white uh you know had the opportunity to leave a lot easier than the the african-americans who were there so sometimes they leave as well and and that's a loss if the levies get blown out that's a loss there you know different kinds of ways that the game encounters that yeah that's fascinating so how are you
planning to incorporate this game into your classes or have you already as part of play testing um i've incorporated into the games classes and they sort of help me play test um but i do want to incorporate it into either my freshman level surveys um and certainly the the games classes as the game becomes more developed um for me what i want this one to do this game to do is to sort of fill a gap in time but to also fill a gap with representation you know we don't have a lot of games about african americans and about playing from the african-american perspective mario kill has an amazing rap gods the the um uh kind of on the base on the music industry game which is just fantastic um but this game you know i want it to fill a gap in in sort of where people teach and centering the african-american experience but also thinking about the game as representative of the 1920s um you know certainly we think of the 20s as the jazz age and you know people dancing the charleston but there were a lot of other things going on and one of the key things too is is you can see this event as a precursor to the great depression which of course starts two years later the president of the united states at the time in
congress refused to help at a federal level with aid all of the aid for the flood was done privately through the red cross um and the red cross refused to um sort of put any sort of limitations on the states they the states were in charge of how you know that aid got distributed which as you can imagine in mississippi was done in a very racist way jim crow system kind of way um but one of the things that i think it shows is this reluctance of the federal government to intervene in a national disaster which of course is the exact same thing that happens during the great depression early on with hoover and that you know it was a disaster both times basically you know it didn't work both times um so i see this game as a as a way to show african-american lives during the 1920s and how different they were from the preconceived notions we have of the 20s but also to sort of think about well and to think about ideas of racism and how those manifest and and what can happen as a result of racism but also to think about the role of government in society um and how having blinders on about what our responses are to problems can can be very very problematic for the people who are involved in some of these crises
that's fascinating and so emotionally i mean you know they think about games right is they can teach but they also make you act and they make you feel uh what emotional responses have you gotten from your students so far and are you hoping to elicit from future players of your game you know i think one of the things that the game does communicate pretty well is this is a sense of urgency to try to deal with the flood and because the game is round based at the end of each round more weather comes and that generates higher levels of water and flooding um so there is this sense of sort of dread and and worry about oh my gosh you know what's going to be next and um you know what's going to be flooded how can we fix that how you know so there's there's this sense of tension as the water levels rise and build up as you go through the game and that's something you know i'm kind of excited about that that you know people kind of get into it that way um what i really want people to get out of it though too is the arbitrariness of racism and the injustice of it as well you know there are cards that come up randomly that indicate different things the land that the white land owners are doing um and you know i i want people to get a sense of the unfairness of
that kind of a system where you don't really know what's coming or when it's coming and you know you are um having to deal with those kinds of threats and um you know racism on a daily kind of basis and then it it requires some kind of sacrifice on your part to deal with those kind of arbitrary um you know enforcements of racism and stuff so yeah i guess that those are really the the key things that i want players to get out of it and i have been seeing them um you know um seeing players sort of being able to understand that in in different ways so that's very cool that is i actually would really like to play this myself now uh so you also you also have a lot of experience in two kinds of classroom gaming which is something i'd like to ask you about since you know we've talked about student response and what you want people to get out of things you are both a regular reacting to the past teacher which means that you're playing seminar historical role playing games with some of your classes and you're bringing board games into the classroom do you have a preference for which type of game and i guess my question is what sort of game can do what thing for you in terms of classroom utility um that's a really good question i the reacting to the past games are phenomenal um
i am dealing with almost entirely first generation college kids who are coming out of an alabama school system that is just really really not preparing them for college um and i think for some of the reacting to the past games they assume a level of preparation you know they were developed at barnard which is the sister school to columbia and new york um or they started there so some of the games tend to be at a much higher student level than what i have so reacting to the past games are amazing and i love them but they often require a lot of scaffolding and adaptations to be able to make sure that students don't come in and they're super overwhelmed by having to read a primary document i mean you have to prepare them and and get them ready for those kind of of encounters and sometimes you have to scale the game down a little bit to be able to make it so that it's comfortable for them because you know you want to push them and you want to have them gain new skills but you also don't want them to be so overwhelmed that it just completely goes over their head and and they just get scared and don't want to do anything at all so i think reacting to the past games are amazing sometimes they do need the instructor to really think about who their students are and what their students need to prepare for these for the role playing games and
reacting to the past games are also very long generally you know you spend three weeks on them or you know two weeks at a bare minimum so it takes a lot of classroom time commitment that's quite different from when you're playing board games because what you can do then is you can just use one class period to play a board game and so it's a lot less of a time investment especially if i can have you know a freshman survey level class where you've got a whole bunch of stuff to cover maybe you don't want to spend three weeks on the american revolution you know maybe you just want to play a game over that so i think that the the two types of games have different sort of applications and different sorts of you know ways of using them in ways of getting things out of them i think the the reacting to the past games can really generate and this is what's fantastic about them a lot of empathy and a lot of understanding of in a very deep sort of sense you know what's going on during the time period of whatever game they're playing whereas with the board games they're a much quicker exercise but you can also get sort of um an understanding of hey the game has this in it but not this in it and you know let's talk about that you can get sort of this more engagement as well so they're they're really different kinds of games i suppose really different sorts of of encounters i guess with game but both real real valuable this is really interesting and it also so i as a language teacher right think
about what i want my students to do in terms of reading so um typically my my latin classes are structured around i've written a story i've used vocabulary i want my students to pick up and i want them to read the story so i will do preparation work to make sure the vocabulary is good um i might you know activate a few things that will make them think about the kinds of feelings and situations they might encounter the story then we read the story then we play a game to review so in your game classes i guess where in the structure of understanding something does the game go so you have to prep kids to play is the gaming is the game the culminating activity where you're leading up to that you play and then you debrief or is the game going somewhere else in the the structure of teaching students about things so i mean normally i do background lecture we play the game we discuss debrief so i yeah i mean i would i would describe it sort of as the culminating activity and it's really what we center of course the debrief around right to sort of bring in um you know whatever kind of historical memory the game has with you know whatever we learned uh in the background about the the history so yeah i would i would describe the board games especially as the sort of culminating activity now reacting games are a little different because you're you're playing a role for a couple of weeks and you're doing different assignments like speeches and um you know you're voting on different things and you're maybe producing a
newspaper or you know a different sorts of topics so there's different sort of activities without throughout that game but in a board game situation yeah that to me is sort of the the apex of what we're doing and where the debrief comes from yeah absolutely and you know we've talked about the usefulness of commercial board games in these scenarios what are the criteria that you're looking for when you are choosing a game to become the culminating activity for your class yeah um so for my students a lot of them have had video game experience in fact some of them come up with nothing but video game experience um and what basically i'm looking for is a game that's pretty accessible to learn especially early on like in the first third to the first half of the class so we're playing gateway games we're playing catan we're playing dominion we're playing games where you know maybe they've never seen those kind of rules before or that kind of game before but it's pretty quick and easy to get into so those are the kind of qualities i'm looking for as we get farther into the semester and they start getting a little more familiar with mechanics and that kind of stuff then i can kind of up the complexity level and the weight of the games so you know we've played games like like i said axis and allies we play that toward the end of the semester um we play pandemic which you know is not really that much more of a complicated game but i
think the idea of cooperation is something new to them when they're playing games often um so i yeah i mean i think complexity level to me is one of the big things that i look at for when i can introduce it like i wouldn't want to introduce i have some there's a really good game called wendaki which is about uh native americans it's from their perspective about the seven years war and it's it's kind of interesting because it is sort of um built around their their cultural sort of ideas but i would never do that right at the beginning of the semester because it's just it's very very heavy um and i think that that would be too much to sort of throw the students into so honestly one of the first things i look at is complexity level and sort of where it's going to fit within my um structure of the the chronology of the class excellent that makes sense and i'm assuming that you also sometimes at least choose for fun level i mean i'm assuming the students are having fun with these games as well yeah absolutely um you know and one of the one of the games that the kids love that we do play early on in the semester or at least in the first half is ticket to ride i mean they have the most fun with that and what was interesting during the pandemic when we weren't really meeting in person every day a lot of the games have apps that the kids can use some of them are free or some of them are very low cost gatan does dominion does
a ticket to ride does and they really loved playing especially the ticket to ride um app so yeah i mean they you know i and i think the gateway sort of mid-level games are the ones that they have the most fun with the the really really heavy games they tend to get a little i don't wanna say brain dead but i mean it's it's kind of it's a lot of work to play and you know to to keep juggling all those balls in the air i suppose um but yeah absolutely fun i certainly want them to have fun and you know this is one class where it's neat because the kids really get to know each other um i i sort of change the groups around of who they're playing with each time and so they really get to know each other um they have a lot of fun laughing you know i've had like groups classes of kids where at the end of the semester they're still laughing about what happened in catan and someone hoarding sheep or something you know they're it's it's it really enhances the relationships that the kids have too so that's cool that is great and yeah i also find that if i'm gonna talk about a challenging topic i really like to do with people that i know and trust do you find that games also sort of prime the prompt for your students to get real with each other because they know how to play together yeah and i think it it certainly makes students who might not have been comfortable talking
able to communicate in class better and feel like they can say something you know a lot of my students are always very concerned about saying something wrong or being laughed at for some reason you know and i i try to create a comfortable environment but once i've been playing games with each other and laughing and having fun i think that that makes it a lot easier i had one student this past semester who was he was very quiet very reserved um but you know he really started to once he got comfortable with the other kids in the classroom to contribute to class discussions a lot more and he really really was you know having some fantastic points that he was bringing up um you know when early in the semester he was you know not saying anything and sort of very hesitant to talk but yeah absolutely that's fantastic so a softball question for you uh what games are you having fun with right now because you gotta be gamer to enjoy to enjoy games oh i know i i always tell my students you know if you're gonna one of the projects we often do is that they design a historical game and i always tell them you know you have to play a lot of games to design games um you know you have to sort of know the the vocabulary of games to be able to do that um honestly my favorite game period is uh pandemic i mean i think i i think i draw a lot from that game in my own design and sort of thinking about game design and how
you know that one's just been very very influential for me um and i really like cooperative sort of the aspect of cooperation in games rather than competition um i'm looking around at my games and trying to figure out which ones we've been playing recently um one of my sort of side research areas has been with um environmental games so i've been playing some of those recently and i've been enjoying some of those so things like um uh trekking the national parks um endangered um i guess games like that i've been i've been having a lot of fun playing fantastic and uh so if people have questions for you about your work which is definitely fascinating uh where can you be reached online so through email um my email is just scout bloom s-c-o-u-t-b-l-u-m gmail.com uh reach me there is amazing or i'm on twitter as well just at scout bloom so either way is fine and i would love to hear from people if they have questions or comments or want to learn more about rising waters i am happy to talk to everybody about that fantastic and uh everyone who listens you probably know you can find me anywhere as beyond solitaire thank you so much for listening scout thank you so
much for coming on this has been great oh thank you liz i appreciate it i'm so glad i got to do this leave us some comments leave us some likes and happy gaming everybody
you