Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Red Burnoose | Review

Transcript 13:09

hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson and today I'm going to be reviewing the red Bernice by Roberta Taylor and Matt Shoemaker alright so here is the red Bernice all set up in this game we are playing the algerians and we are trying to Stave off the French so this is a game for one to four players it is cooperative so however many players there are you're all working together to outlast this French deck right here and the French army is going to reinforce itself it's going to activate there are three armies that are going to march from these locations on the board at the edges and they're going to try to come in and take over your Villages so during setup I drew three of these cards that are going to tell me what units to add here and then this Army is actually ready to deploy because when it gets to six units or more then it's going to deploy and we have six so we would flip it we know that they're coming to the two root of pass and we'll put an army here to indicate that that's what they're doing and we'll also be putting our own pieces in our villages to defend ourselves so we can put out Sharpshooters mujahideen and muja had that and the way that we're going to do that is through deck building and playing our cards as well as possible every starting deck is going to be a little bit different because it's going to depend on which leader that you end up with so um in a standard game you're going to deal out two leaders in a person will pick one of the two and then make adjustments as needed and all these leaders are going to have different powers so they're going to contribute icons to you and then some of them can actually be placed as fighters on the board some of them allow certain kinds of cards to be added to your hand system once you start the game with an extra Market in fig Orchard and you're just

gonna have to try out a bunch of different leaders and see for yourself you've also got this deck of just sort of standard cards everybody has the same starting deck except for the modifications that you make based on the leader that you have and on your turn you're going to draw five cards if you're playing solo you're managing all these villages with a hand of five cards um if you are playing at a different player count then different players are going to take responsibility for these different village groupings by color but what you're going to do is you're going to draw your cards and then you have a few options on your turns you can take three actions total and those actions can consist of playing a card and then using the ability written on the card reserving a card and basically what you can do is you can place Cards into these Villages so you tuck the cards underneath and then a lot of times something good will happen from that and you can also take all of your cards back out of a village and there can be effects from doing that and also it makes those cards available to play again so you can use the villages to get special card Powers activated you can use them to kind of thin your deck by stashing cards that you don't think are really that good and you can also store cards that you think you'll need for the future and then pull them out from under a village and then bam you can play um you know a big move that you were saving up for and you wanted to make sure that you have access to those cars from your deck you can also mobilize so if you have majority in Sharpshooters in villages mobilizing them let you move them from one Village to another and so depending on where the French are going you might want to shore up certain Villages before others you can Ambush so if you have a weapon card an image of hygiene or Sharpshooter card instead of

placing cubes on the board you can discard them from your hand and use them as an ambush action against the French so you can do three things on your turn that are actions after that you can purchase up to two cards so you have a static Market over here this doesn't change you can just run out of different cards but basically the cost in different resources is down at the bottom and then the value for purchasing other stuff later is up in the top right so all the really good cards are over here and you're going to have to figure out how to budget for them because you absolutely need them stuff like food especially is super scarce so you're going to want to make sure that you're getting a fig Orchard because you can't recruit more people if you don't have food to feed them Etc et cetera Etc there's also enough Toma that's going to take turns and on its turn all you have to do is flip a card and so basically this card is going to tell you what units to add to armies so basically if an army is already deployed you're going to keep filling up the next Army which will then deploy and the next Army that'll then deploy and then if they're all out there you can add reinforcements and there are also symbols on the card they're going to tell you basically if there's a choice about which direction to go so if we come to a fork in the road you'll see there are different symbols on the board so the symbol on the card is going to help you direct where that French army is going to go when it moves combat is resolved through die rolls as you can see there are a whole bunch of different dice over here that you're going to roll depending on who is in the fight there are a bunch of reroll tokens that you're going to want to earn because trust me you're going to want to re-roll some stuff throughout this game and then routinely throughout the game you're gonna have to check for retreat or loss so you can make the French Retreat if you reduce their army to a certain value so if two or fewer units

remain in Army number one it will Retreat and leave you alone for a little while of course it'll be back you the berbers might have to retreat depending on how a battle went so you might have to take your forces and Retreat to a further back Village in order to hopefully regroup and go back at the French and then if all of your Berber units are removed from a village during combat the player controlling that they've had a multiplayer game has been conquered and then is eliminated from the game so basically this game ends with a Berber win if the French deck is depleted and you're all still there but the French will win if you have both used The Retreat token and you still get conquered so you can only Retreat one time before you end up in trouble or if any two Berber players have been conquered in a multiplayer game so you do not have a lot of leeway to get your butt kicked in this particular game you have to manage your resources very well or else the French are going to overrun you and it's not so hot and that is a very basic overview of the red Bernice let's get to some final thoughts all right so now for some final thoughts um I'm just gonna be a friend this is a game that I really really wanted to like but I think it fell short in some crucial ways um so we're gonna cover all of that but I want to start with the good because there is a lot of good here first of all the subject matter is great I was really excited to see a game that is about Algeria and that is about this period in history and that is about fighting the French instead of an invasion game so thematically the red bird noose is like really hitting a lot of notes that I really like and so I really really wanted to love this game and it's not

just the theme that makes it attractive there are a lot of really interesting mechanical elements that are going on in this game as well so I loved that this was an attempt to do like a deck build Builder combined with a war game so both types of game elements were there and I really liked that I enjoy Cooperative games with an automa so I really thought that you know attempting to have players cooperate in that particular way was really good and some of the ideas in the deck building I thought were great so the idea that you can thin your deck by placing cards in various Villages and then pull them all out into your hand to potentially play again was really smart and I would I've actually never seen that in a game before so I thought that was a super cool element that got added to this game mechanically I would like to see more games try it out and I liked that it was a bit of a double-edged sword because you know you use it to thin out your deck but also a village that has young people in it gets attacked you can't just Retreat you have to stay and fight for them so you have to be careful like where you put those cards and so you know there's a lot of interesting thought that's going in how this game is played you know I like the different leaders I liked conceptually that different types of people and Elements of Life were represented in the cards and aesthetically the game is really beautiful as well and it's very much in keeping with the theme so there's a lot going on here that's right and unfortunately it just doesn't hit a home run for me despite all the things that are good about it mainly because it's just not

fun enough to play and like I know that I don't talk about fun in a traditional sense with a lot of games on this channel you know I'm really interested in historical theme and in the theme coming through and you know I don't necessarily need a game to be beautiful to be happy with this you know there's a lot I'm willing to tolerate in terms of gameplay in pursuit of an interesting historical point but unfortunately what I think has happened here is that there's actually sort of an issue with the economy of the game and so I'm sure it was thought into why things are the way they are in this game but it impacts my engagement when I'm playing so a lot of this really my biggest beef with this game has to do with the icons on the cards so not only are these icons difficult to see like they're all kind of black and white they all look just close enough that I spent a lot of time kind of squinting and making sure I understood costs and um you know what cards had to contribute like is it food is that a missile what is that and so I really found that part of the game irritating because I had to keep checking and I kept misreading things but not only that but some of the more expensive cards in this game are just so tough to get and you need them in order to deploy say a sharpshooter to deal with the French army so like if you are having a food shortage then you can't get more Firepower and there's also a lot that goes into getting things like tools or getting weapons and you know it makes sense right of course it would be difficult to be a Berber dealing with a French invasion in Algeria in 1857 like I get

it however I felt that because I was trying to build my deck in a way that would give me access to this stuff um I kept having these turns that felt dead turns where I was really working towards a card I absolutely needed in order to make progress but it just wasn't in my hand that turn and so then I just kept feeling like I was wasting time especially when I was desperate to be able to get more military to put out there to combat the French and like could I get things working eventually yes but it really felt like trying to turn the keys of a car and the engine just won't turn over and realistically it probably felt like that sometimes during this conflict but that's not how I want to feel when I'm playing a game and so I found it just dissatisfying to play because it was like I could just never get a really nice Snappy turn and you know if I can't get that like I really just can't stay engaged with the game for very long I need to feel like I'm actually doing something instead of just spinning my wheels and this game did not accommodate that need enough not for me other issue that I have with this game is oh my gosh it's a beautiful game there's so much to recommend for it but it's got a huge Errata page already on board game geek and a lot of the issues that had to get resolved have to do with the solo mode so the other thing is if you purchase this game you have to know to go to boardging geek to find little rules Corrections and stuff um and you have to be the sort of person who would already know that so if you didn't know that and you're thinking

about playing this game go to BGG and look at the Errata page because you absolutely need it but I just felt really disappointed that that would happen I know that a lot of work went into this game and you know seeing that kind of sloppiness at the gate it's just like oh darn it like I just really find that frustrating when it happens and normally I'd be willing to forgive it but I'm not enjoying the game enough on its face and so it's just another theme that I find vexing about it and I kind of feel like games should be approachable this should be easy for you to get into and they should hook you when you're there and the red bird news just isn't doing that for me ultimately this is one of those games that was just a Miss for me but I really really wanted to be a hit I love the theme I like the aesthetic I really like a lot of the ideas that went into this game in terms of design and it just came off short for me and so you know if you still want to give it a chance I would not say like oh don't try it because first of all I would just never say that and also there is a lot of stuff that's of Interest going on here but if you're really looking for like a Snappy super engaging experience uh if you and I share similar tasty cross reviews I would give this one a pass this is one that if I were to revisit in the future I would only be doing it for the historical interest and not because I'm excited to play it again as a game and that sucks because I really like Matt Shoemaker I really want to see Roberta Taylor make it as a designer um you know so much that went into this game is so so good but sometimes you know things just don't click and this is one of those times so that's where I'm at on the red Bernice thank you so much

for watching please like subscribe comment uh give to my patreon if you're feeling generous and most of all happy gaming oh

Progress saved