Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 10:16

my name is Marty kaan ale these are my musings let's get rolling negative reviews are more honest than positive reviews that's the statement I want to look at today the reason why is because over the past couple years I've noticed in places like Reddit bgg and other social media when a negative review comes out for a game that might have a lot of positive views are a lot of hype a lot of the comments will say something like thank you for your honest review thank you for finally being honest and like some of those other reviews kind of insinuating that because it's negative it's more honest than one that's positive and where people start discussing why they may believe it's more honest it comes down usually to a couple things one is people only make positive reviews or constantly make positive views because money's involved because they're paid so if a negative view comes out that must mean that they weren't paid and they can be honest about it I can honestly say in the six and a half years that we've been doing this podcast we have never ever been offered money for review and over those past six and a half years we've made some incredible relationships with publishers and not once if they said hey if you want to add this a game over here you know slippy a few bucks if you give us a positive review it's never happened and in fact I've reached out to some my other friends who do reviews on board games and they're like no nobody's ever offered us any money nor have we ever taken any money from doing something like that now that doesn't mean some

money might be changing hands but typically when money changes hands it's for previews and there's a difference between reviews and previews previews you typically see for something like a Kickstarter that's getting ready to come out where somebody may look at a prototype or early type of game and just give a lot of facts based on it how it plays how it looks just some general gameplay mechanics and usually they keep their opinions kind of to a minimum this is because lots of times it is a paid preview it's more like a commercial for the product that's getting ready to come out but once a product comes out somebody gives their honest opinion about a game at that point it becomes a review and there may be some sort of compensation in like you know you get a free copy of a game which I'll come back to in just a second like I said I've never seen money offered for something like that so let's just put that one aside for a second and say okay well if money's not involved what's another reason for a positive review possibly being influenced such that you won't be as honest with it and that goes back to what I mentioned before working with the publisher and possibly getting free games yes there are a lot of publishers out there that will offer hey wizards game this coming out would you be interested in reviewing it in many times the game reviewer says yes I would like to do that but there's typically an understanding that once that game gets in the reviewers hands it's totally up to them to what they do with it it could be a good review it could be a negative review most publishers are very cool about that but I do get where people may think well yeah well if they trash a game that free

game review thing with that publisher that gravy train may be over and they may not get any more copies well again I can only speak for us but it is way more important to be honest to the people that are listening you to your audience then to a publisher see we do this for the people to listen to about gaming and hear about games and not necessarily is just a mouthpiece for a publisher and if a publisher doesn't want to work with this anymore fine we can just go out and buy a game and review it ourselves I mean I can't go out and buy listeners can i buy listeners whoa whoa whoa delete delete delete delete in fact there are publishers that don't work with this anymore because of some things we've said about games in the past that's a-ok and we've actually covered some of their games since that time because well it's a game we thought we might be interested in and one to check out but I will say for us we rarely ever just totally trash and that's because we know that there are people behind this game that it made it into what it is there's designers and artists who put a lot of time and effort into making this creation and you just don't want to come out there and just blast it it doesn't mean you can't be tactfully honest with you know there's just certain aspects of this game I didn't care for their certain mechanics and like it was too long there was too much downtime we're not gonna be one of those and just totally just dumps on and say oh man how can anybody ever make this game this is the worst game ever again

because there are people that make this and you don't want to be a jerk about it and for those games that we think are just really not that good you know what we don't talk about them we've gotten games in the past Tony and I my co-host will say you know this this just doesn't really interest either one of us and I you know it's just something we don't talk about typically we want to have a very positive content and and be kind of up and upbeat and everything we just don't want to just trash something just for the sake of trash so we'll let them know you know what it's a game that wasn't for us we're not gonna talk about it and also over the years we've kind of learned what games we've liked so when games come out we may go hmm well that game that comes a little bit like that one like the mechanics of that would that looks pretty good too we'd probably like those let's go check those out so just after over the years you end up with more games that you're gonna play that you like just because you kind of know what your own tastes are so yes I can totally see where positive reviews might be influenced such the way that you might not want to be as harsh with them so I guess we can jump straight to the conclusion that negative reviews are more honest will hold up a minute is there any advantage to having negative reviews hmm just look at the internet today it's all about getting some clicks and views and everything and what's the quickest way to do that is to sensationalize something or put up something negative I mean let's face it if I had two video clips and one of those video clips was a man helps up an

elderly woman who fell down the other video clip is elderly woman roundhouse kicks a man which one are you probably going to click elderly woman roundhouse kicks a man save save save we're in a click bait era thumbnails titles anything that you can get somebody to come in and click on you're going to do it content creators are gonna do it websites are gonna do it that's just that's just how it works so if you come out with something a negative review and kind of maybe go over the top with her just talk about how it's just really not that great especially when a lot of other people may like that thing and I'll talk about anything at this point board games video games movies etc if you can have a contrary point to what everybody else is saying people are going to be drawn to that because it's like oh well if all these people are kind of saying the same thing over here let's see what this person has to say and I'm not saying that people purposely make negative reviews just for that reason but if they look at the history and they've done a negative review they might be tempted to maybe lay it on a little more thick than they otherwise would knowing it's like ooh you know what we got a lot of comments and a lot of clicks and a lot of views on this one particular video over here maybe it won't hurt yeah I know that sounds very accusatory saying oh great so you're now saying every negative review does that no I'm not what I'm trying to say is is

that there are situations we're given a negative view it does have a venom benefit there are situations where positive reviews does have a benefit so where does that leave us as a consumer well we have to do a lot more research you may find a particular reviewer that you are just in sync with and you know that you know what they like you know what they dislike and they have a very consistent message so even if that person gives a lot of negative reviews it may be very consistent based on a certain thing there's one particular mechanic or one thing they don't like and they keep saying the same thing over and over well they're being very honest and they're being very consistent likewise if there's somebody who you hear a lot of positive things about but it's consistently the same thing over and over well that just happens to be what they like so you kind of have to get in in tune with people and and the reviews that you're reading and watching and listening to and in fact for me personally as a consumer of anything whether I'm going to Amazon and buying a product getting ready to watch a movie or TV show I will find some of the most positive reviews and some of the most negative and read both and what happens is if I see negative reviews then they I'll say a lot of the same thing I thought wow if they're all saying this there must be something to it but if there's a negative review that Hoadley 180 from everything else everybody else is saying it's not saying it's wrong it's just that whatever they're saying is something didn't click something wasn't right but if there's one person out of 50 that just had this one little thing they didn't care for what other people did again it could be a personal preference or it could be maybe it is they just

miss something so you're probably thinking Marty you just wasted my entire time you're supposed to tell me that negative views are more honest or less honest they may be they may not be well this has all been one big tease it's just the fact you just can't make a blanket statement saying that there are benefits to both and the onus is on you to be able to be able to weed through all these things that you read and watch and listen to to make that decision for yourself but that's just my faults let me ask you a question do you feel that negative reviews are more honest do you put more credence in a review that's more negative towards something thinking there's probably something to it and these people aren't trying to gain the system or anything like that or you pretty much know I think you can have very positive reviews that are just as honest is very negative reviews why don't you let me know in the comments and while you're down that way making some comments why don't you punch that subscribe button and click that like button I would very much appreciate it and as always I've been marty these have been my musings and I am

Progress saved